從引文分析、期刊排序談人文社會學門的學術表現評量

全文

(1)*. ' JiJr-fHJ~ H"'~~ A. x.;f±, it!¥: r~ If.J !¥: {,itT *- JJUt J: J ' *d'l~ ~ }t --t:tJt~~~x.llH~:It. : x.5¥- '2004) '~347-362 r -Vt i] Ix. 7t- *Jf. 172. 0. 1ft iJI x7}~Jf " $JJfuJJ~~-tlAx~±1r~ a~ ~ #g- JJi ~f-I-. *. r,. The Research Evaluation ofLiberal Arts & Social Sciences Studies through Citation Analysis & Journal Rankings ~~~* Mei-Hwa Yang @~a~*.E. •• ~~.t!¥:~~m~~*mk. Professor & Director, Graduate Institute of Library, Information and Archival Studies,. National Chengchi University. E-mail: mhyang@nccu.edu.tw. #!ta~-i-~Jl-~i!~lt1.:;fpf;ltb~A1. ' !t#t%~X711 ili ~I. m xtt:;fp-t-~:~*f- '. ~~k.~_xM0~ •• ~#.*~'~k#!t~~~~~0M~~~ff ~jJt~ ~I X~*Jf1f-~~4'- ' G~~Jt~m#-1~m ~a~-P7fJt~~.#a~~~ ~ X(t a~ -PJf ~ , jE)f] YA iT1*%~ X a~ • .f,ltt *-JJl, ~ ~~ A.X;f± -t-~ r, a~"ff-X ' ~ 0. 0. 1. EtiG~y1t-PJf~a(;:;ti(~r. A:.1J'--~g ~15t~*Jfa(; ~~. ,. '. ~)Jii!!iG~W1t-PJf1E7j-~t~1~1G~a~!.t*-. ;l:}J ~t~ <TIiit a~~I~. ~~~~~~*.'~a.~ ~~:g~. r,. ~~. ••. 0. *5t~. r,. , ft.;kJ*.-tt ~ ~ A.X;;f±-t-. 1f. "ff-.n~~.~,.~~~.~~.~~. 0. Abstract The evolution of science has sequence and cumulativeness. To give the credit for citations and references are required for scholarly writings. The application of citation analysis has been widely used in many subjects for research assessment. However for the liberal arts & social science studies, qualitative evaluation must be taken into consideration as well as quantitative measures. This paper illustrated the definition and function of citation analysis first, then investigated the controversy among journal ranking in the liberal arts and social sciences studies. Finally the implication of international research assessment indicators were discussed and suggestions were made for future reference. ~~iJti~. : 51 ;t7t-~JT ;. .#g-#~. ; Jl:jJf~JJ~Jf.. Kevwords: citation analvsis: research assessment: iournal rankine.

(2) ~~~B~~~~.tt~.~tt,aw~~~m,~~~~~~~~~~m. ±i:±j3K~. , ilG~fj~~~f4B"J~U*JTWB~. f4~~Jf~IfF13~ 7B* EI aB"J~. 0. ~,~&~~.~,~~,~~~,~~~#~,~~~mR~M~~~'~$. ~±H~'%~.m'~B.~,~®~±~~m.,%~~~~.o~~,~. [±j 51 m~Jl!\fD#~1f*4 ' /f{*~m~~ffil~pJT ~\~JHI1J§B"Jf4~1~~ , -m~ f4~Wf~I flF13 ~\~JHI~B"J1T~tJ:~8 Cli 1) 17ItT~ffil~JU. 0. ~m~~~.OOA~~.fi~'Wf~~~~~~Mm~'Wf~13m~~~ ~,~~~m.MA~.~~~~~~~~~~~~mo~~,~~~~mWf~. B"J mij[t1J -, Jl.ll flF13 B"J rnm ~ flfl ~ ~ , 5Im~ Jl!\ ~ ~ ~1iItJ Wf~ $ /f"6J~ ffifi: B"J ~ J.& ;fi~~~%~JtJt!H1fJTsl m~i\B"J1T~t~~ , M~~WJJKa~w~~f4B"J~D.1~lIWli ~~D~;[J\~fH~ , 1ft1JE~~1ifqB"J~~ lli4* ' 51 X51fJT (citation analysis ' ~f-iiJsl m ~Jl!\51fJT) B"Jf§HWf~~~ 0. 0. ~~rs~~~~~. , 5t¥IJ1Ji¥z:m*~lftsl B*.Wf~. 0. ~~~~. ,. 7J~~JK~*j~I~H~. (Garfield, E.) JK 1963 4F7fJBB"Jf4~sl xWts' 1f*4~ (Science Citation Index, SCI) ,. tJ.& 1~AA~~f4~1f~RWf~~ (Institute of Scientific Information, lSI). JUSI fflxJVWtsI1f*4~. (Citation Index) PJT~. 0. sIX51fJT~~:¥9. ~f~B"J-%. ' B1Ji¥ztfuE!ffl. JK~ffl%~Wf~W~~~&~~~~~~Wf~,lftm~~ffi~~~~m*~o $'}Z~:g~JK~~11+=44+Jj~~51fJT7. Citation Index, *±~f4~sl~WtsI1f*4jiJ). jiJ) '0:tFi. 20024SCI' SSCI (SocialScience. 'EI (Engineering Index, If~WtsI1f*4. 2002 4~P9 154 pJT0fL.ll*~~~~ffil~B*~§t • •. ' ~SI~~P9 ; ~A~~~. , /f"6Jt)J§~lft~ffil *4jiJ:m:l:~~E!tzD1PJrr~ ? 1JtB.~1JjtJ±~:1J1ft~~~~~1ifq~.:1J ' lZ9llt~~F~z OO:¥9ill*~-m~A • • ~~gtt~Rm~o ~~1i:JK~P9fjJKSI~51fJTB"JBmWH!mpJT~±B"J*~ , jfjai:l*~liif~t~~RW ~1ifq:WAA?r!a'Hffil. 0. ~A~;g~ EI 1ft~~sl~~*4jiJ. m-~~Wf~pJTJK11+. 41iJj--tB~¥JJ¥ rsl~51fJTW~1Jjtn~~1i:Wf~1~J. ~1sl~51fJTB"Jf-'~ffilWH!m. -,. + /\ B '. 0. ~epWf. slx~*4~W~1JjtJ~~~1i:&~~~nH~W~1ifq3~~1i:-*~. :1m ' tJ.sl ~~AfjsIX51fJT~~;g~D ' "6J~M"J~rtITW~~1j. 0. l!*.~A~*±~~F~B"J*17fq~~1i:'(~1*~[±j. ®:;('ll~~~+[Z!Htm~1JjtH±[lJl!JK11+ -411Jj =+1i. '=. 1~~*~=m~g~~epJG\W9f;i1±¥JJ¥ r &mD:~~$'}ZA~W*±~*1JjtJ~~1i:Wf.

(3) ~.Jm~'.~~~ffi.A±&~~~~,-m~».~~~.~~~~~~ ~f!tEfJFp~m. a. .§'X~'~~~~~A~EfJ~~~*'~~AA~~~EfJ~m~~'$ mA~~NEfJr~~~ttJ. 1~~~EfJ1JA5i-. '. ,~~~~~~m~EfJ~.m~o~~'~7reft.. J!~reft~1~~~:;t#~31{~%~8"J~*. ~F~EfJ~.J!~1#A*±J~EfJ~~ EfJ~1~. '. jl;;!t~~.Ax*±.. *X"§7tfriiBij Ix7t*"JTEfJ~m3 ' :r:j]#~.OJ#~ , ;!t*~~j'~ [7gAx*±.~F~~.• WjflJ~Fpf;EfJ~m ' tJ&;!t.~~~~vrq~SfZ a. .m.EfJ~~'*~~~.iliJ!.ftAx.tl.~W~~EfJ~.1JA,~~[7gEfJ ~1Ifq~!tt1E1~rtJ~~~~EfJiJD. a. (-) iJ I X 7)-lJf aq :t ilsI *ltIJ~III.f§~'I'~¥IH~~~~;$. , ij rx7t*"JT~ r -~lm~~fDt.Ot~t~8~1Ji:t ' tJ& Jt~ , !if,fg , :ffB~ , ~:j:i5~JiI,~1Ji:t ' !Jf4~»XZFa~1¥1EEfJij I~.*ij r~8~m ~~fi7t~,~.~~.x • • ft~&.x.~~~.EfJ~ • • ftEfJ~.W.ft ZFa~EfJ~gp~J. a. (ti3)~~Z' ijrX7J-*"JT1*~ijIXEfJ.1~~.&[7g$mf$:~1T7t*"JT. ~~~x.ZOOEfJ.~o;!t~m1Em~x.OO~ffili~mB~W~»xWM~~ ~f4.~M1 Fa~pf;JU. '. '. ~1Tf4~x.f.:S~.f4~f.:S~8"J~~. .~gp. ,. lEJJ!tfjf4~~mkEfJM5E.fd1¥i. ; nEl3xJll($ P!Tij rmEfJ$~fD~. ; tJijrm*~EfJ§7.*~ffi~*fD. A:;t ; ~~ijrmfD*ijrmEfJ~'I:~.~~ , ~~'GEm~f.:S~&;!t~~$lfJ8~~. (ti 4) (=:) iJ I JfJ. xit aq J:}] jj~ W. iJ IX 7)-lJf aq li JfJ. 1E~1ifq~mkEfJ~W$. , ijImxlt±'~EfJ:rj]#~~Ji5 (ti 5):. 1. ~U¥~1R'7t~~~~8~~~ (Paying homage to pioneers) 2. ~ffi .~fF~T~~ (Giving credit for related work). 3. ~~;g~~1J& (Identifying methodology) 4. j1£1~ffilm~~~;f8t (Providing background reading) 5. f~lE §. cEfJ1'tJ1 (Correcting one's own work). 6. f~lEffuAEfJ1'tJ:l~ (Correcting the work of others) 7. ~*UtX~UEfJ1'tJ1 (Criticizing previous work). a.

(4) 8. 1i'itJf~81V~ (Substantiating claims). 9.. fJEMHiJf~~~BJ~JT81fFJ:I~. 10. ~ 1&1'-1. *. ' %' 51 :::f )E:@(; a. (Alerting researchers to forthcoming work) ~ 51 m [Ij ~81 fF J:I~ fJE1:# ~ 51 (Providing leads to. poorly disseminated, poorly indexed, or uncited work). 1L fJE1:#~.~*4811zr-m (Authenticating data and classes of fact). 12. ~i~Bf#r~:@(;~~81)J¥Jil[lj~ (Identifying original publications. in which an. idea or concept was discussed). 13. M tJtt ~ -. fJj{ ~il ~ ~:@(;:5"*. Vlq ~ 81 fJj{ ~IJ ft&::$: (Identifying the original. publication describing an eponymic concept or term). 14. t~t~1fuA81fF @:@(;fIJ~~ (Disclaiming work or ideas of others) 15. ~~1fuA81:7EMW:~J3 (Disputing priority claims of others) ~*JJ&#ft§t ' § M~tt:W#,"}1§ 90%t)J::.81f4~)<':lVllft1§51 m)<.:!l\ ' 3iZ:t»BJ JFi s: IV1§ 15 ~ 8151 m s: IV * ~~:I:fu 1!f£ #,"} 1§ 88%ft i=i 81m ~ f4~ )<.:IV ~rt 1§ 51 m)<.: IV ' 3iZ :t» BJ JFi 9=J s: f4~ gfB s: 1§ 8.9 ~ 815 Im)(IV Cli 6) -~~ffifa ' 51 m)<':lVfD*5Im)(IVZFs51¥1f~r31IJ~~J].~ Cli 7) : 0. 0. 1. pg?G81t§~tt (Relatedness of content). 2.. ~j~. 3.. ~~lt1J. (Field) (Persuasiveness). 4. "6J1~tt (Availability) 5. fFff § 1X51 m (Author self-citation) 6. :jtJHU §1X5Im (Journal self-citation) 7. t±tf51m (Social citation) 8. ~)<.: § 1X51 m (Language self-citation) 9. ~~ § 1X51 m (Nationality self-citation) 10. ~Fs~:7E~ (Time difference) 51)<':7ttJT81JJ!m~j~1.1t. ' *~~"6J&~U[Jg,f.?,; : (1) ~~5E~f481~.Wm~tt ; (2) 1lJf~~f4#,5f# (t§1L~~~' ~~~~~) ; (3) 1*§1~f4~§R~1mt7t:ffi"M*1JL ' TI([fljlj 5Et§~81$f§R*me ; (4) tii1zA~{J\:jtJjflJ ; (5) 1lJf~f4~5UJ1UD$fm~~;t~~ ; (6) 1* ~)<':lK~1~fD$f§RflJmJIW:M ; (7) 1lJf~jj§R1~m~81~**~JI1: ; (8) &tft~17fq;f~!H# ~W~1lJf~*3iZWA~M*R~fi~~om~ ~l[t' 5'X7ttJT81t~~'E2J3Cli9): (1)51)(~m$&5IxJ&.m; (2)5Ix~J[~;.

(5) (3) iJ IX~;; ; (4). itf~WTm~ (~:tl§~~:tl§:wJfU?fTiJ ImB"])t~lfllliE.!if.l¥JxiX'pJT. ~l¥Jtt~'~~~~:wJ~~.~I¥J-M~~'ili~&~.*M~~x.~I¥J-M m:~:tl§~). ; (5) §iJlfD§iJl$ ; (6) iJlxlfl}gmI¥JAAflJ7t;;ffi. 0. (=:);;1 X ~*JT:i!Jf] ·tf.z ~tl J:.!~J:.. '. -.xiXz'pJTj;)~iJlm. '. ;£\~~~TJIJ~tE (li 10) : (1) [1g~I¥J8bff. (Quality of content) ; (2) f'F~l¥JtE5jU (Gender of author) ; (3H'F~~ (Number of authors) ; (4r*7JJ (Source) ; (5)~iJ Im*~ (Citedness) ; (6)3:.~ (Subject) ; (7)JJ#i. (8)~:h.!:X. (Approach) ;. (Field) ;. (9)f~1~fF m. (Assimilation). ~mJ~~iJ Im~1IW~f4'W~I¥J~~. 0. , lW~~iJ ImXiX7t:fJTr!l¥JlE~'I1: ' IZ9. Jlt ' iJ Ix7tfffl¥J/fmmttl:iJifg* § TJU~\Ulm~ (li 11) 1. *# r",' iffl a~ ~ M] ,ftj-./±. :. ~~W~~~!if.I¥J~~'MMT~~M~'~~m~'~~fi~ffi~l¥J~ ~'iliMMT~~~~~m/f-l¥Jm~o-MlE~~~I¥J~W~-MB.M~1¥J. ~f4. ' -@1J:.!~tEfD-lllHl}f.H1:I¥J~f4 ' ~iJ ImlJJ~fDiJ I mmiEJ:.#~~1Nj(~· mJj(~f4fO/J\~f4~iJ Im;mNJ:.ili~'pJT/f~. :W ;. 2. J!Jlf11t~. 0. .. tY *#7}-~a~ ~M],liN1.. m~I¥Jj(~iJ IXli;f-j.J!l['pJT~)(:~AAfUI¥J~f4 '~I:±:H~~*. '. teJt&~~]ft/f~t$]1ti. ~ml¥J'IZ9Jlt'*.~®H0lE~&~/f~~*'/f~~W~/f~~X:wJ~l¥Jm ~. -~mJ;;. 0. , iJ IX1T~Z-~. r ~1~'I1:J. 'W\~PfF~~f\iJ Imft~~1!O&B"Jli. ft~~~5Z:I¥J~~~ ,~j;)lW~M*~. f--J.' f~~ x.f~. 0. ~ti~m. : SCI. , IZ9Jlt ' 3.. ,PJT~)(:~I¥JIfl~Mfllm1NY. $~MflJ~iJlml¥JmlW~9r. ,. 0. ;f±it* ~ -!;fp,#tit ~-!. t±~~IZ9~'±'~1~!;@-iJ IXIJJ~ A~. (*±'I1:) B"J~1T~Xft~~iJlmB"J , mJ~j}f4~*~~lflxl¥J~5t;mN .. MfU~J!. X.I¥Jj(/J\ '. '. ~X~;;~. ,. , iJ IxmfH '. ~f4~:W. '. MfU~~. ,. f.VE§tIZ9~~U$~¥UiJrm~F~m~~I¥J~~. f.VE§t*~J!l[B"J~~. ,. .~W*.~I¥J§t~~. Jltj} , iJ Ix7t:fJT~~~Z:lt1T~~TJUl¥Jrn~ 1. ~f~~r~ill~fu.j(z~1ifq~x'M;1"Fl¥JmiE. '. ,. JlJ3flJ~. 0. : ~m'M;~xl¥J~~J:.f~/f~~. ~o. 2. ~5E~~~VJq~x;z'M;f"Fwll~~/f~~Jl. ~x-@rf"F. 0.

(6) 3. ~A~~ §. sl JiH:r ~*JlRX:~ , fj$~~ § z#i~*~gTi{f.iG~ , .aJ'tfFFU ~ffE X t: sl m;f~ j81J;Z~ 7R'*lHm 4. J)jfUZ~1:r::f!f11t~ : ~~~~IF~m* ' *~gJt.lz:[PJffl'~frnJmU'§[ ; ~~~Ij 0. ¥B~:J;~APff~~. , ~FfX~?JtJ[~*~tm~7R'F55'}. 5. ~{*nf1imU'§[fl~~.t~~. 0. : ~@MfU~; , 7j(3f::f- , ~Fs~zti£~Q1PJ. $t}£ ? sl X7tfJT~£~B"J*f~ , ~fj*;B"Jsl X~t'~1:r5E;7tfJT1iJf~ ~:EJ.~3:: ~~£7R'tfj~RJbZ rgf§sfmJ B"J~1* ~~-.xl*~*~~-.xl*slm~~ 7R' r *~ sl mX l* J ~g m1=!t f§ ~ 1t~R ' rm sl X 7tfJT 3:: ~ 1* fU m$ ~ ~ § ~ s ImX ~ , ~t~xl**lf~mB"J'I'~ID ' tX~7R'~f1t~B"J1t~R~t~~ 1'~~slx7tfJTt~A ~1j~fljm~t~*ls '~x~;~#,r!lfD ' P)&B3t ' ~f1tlc~.~1fHx~1t~s"J~~::fJLZ.* :E~ ~rm ' m:flHt~1JD~~S"J~t ~7JA?ffij!f~::f:J;Fp~~ lZ9~ , ~~fF~S ImlfJ 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ~'~W~~'~~~~~::f[PJ~~~~.T,mfl~03f'~~~~ffi~~o lZ91c~. , sIX7tfJT~1iJf~~~?Jj\sl~::f:J;~~ , ~~&~rr¥U~~tlt~f ' fXslm ' slmtj~, slm:J:)]~LZ.=*slm~1~~*~i. ~rp7tJ,A§. 0. ~~$~.~*~~2m.7t+=*~,~rp~~RX:~~-*~rp,~[PJ~ 1*~t~*~x,!(LZ. ~.Mj!fti1tj:~ (~P~fU) ~fwts"J 20 ~J~t~t~z-. rp ti£~ i§j ~. 0. ~fifg~1fHxs"J~*R~~~:g~*~. , ::f~i§)J[~fwtt~t~ti£lTn~ 20% '. 0. f-4~1iJf~I 1t~Jt.lz:1f-M At~#J~flRX:~B"J£~J:. ~tfj1iJf9G~~. ~ § 1W~~JH~t~. ,. t~#'f9:ATiJf~LZ.£~~7JIoJ~'I~%. Fs~ fjJ ~ ffiffl X Jb ~ s".7 -. 0. ' fjfWBxs".7sl m;"6JJ,A. ~7R'§1fHx3f:J:)]sl m$~Ij~~I~~. fl $ ~ Ca 12) ~ f-41g ~ sl m ~ pg ffiffl X W£ ~ 1£f-4 ~ sl x*' sl (SCI) LZ.If~§1fHx*,sl (EI) S".7§1fHX~F~ , fUl£lfi§j~.1*~mfU~§1fHxJ~.e1~Jm:~ , 0. ~~~pgf-41iJf~~~*~*.. 0. *~~~~~1iJf~*m::f1B~~~~ffi~m~*.'ili~~~*.*::fJ~*. .. SCI, SSCI (*±~f-4~§1fHxslm*,sl~if¥4J1J) fDEI~~~0§;eWL~tx':ffmfU B".71t*4J1J ; ~fifg :W-B~§;e~ , ~gfU!tlf~ ~MfljJ:s".7~1fHx ' ~:J;l§ -5EB".7~fifg7j( ~ , lZ91C~"6J1t~~f2*. Ca 13) 20034- 10 jj rpB]~~:g~0;ffi~*~1£SSCI -, SCI LZ. EI MfU~*B".7~1fHX.~ , SI~1±~~:W.1z~1§1fH IE~~~:g~LZ.*~f~ ~. 0. 0. 0.

(7) r.J~~g,tt~~~~~ • • ~.,m~¥.~~,~®.~~.~~~. r.J~~g'~~~ffi~~.~7M~~~~~~mo~.~.~2001~m. '. ~ Thomson lSI (Institute for Scientific Information) Research Service Group ~ ~B. ~J-'. 22. {~~*/¥].1iiq~~~m. ~F~~~*~DB ,~,. ' f.6~~ml£~ , ~~1£. . ' ~~f~~ijij~1£. i;m 16 ' {8:@~~~.~. , 1£ 21. M~~$~. r .~f4~J 1][~1:E1:!t:W-3f~mzJ:. 0. ,. ' ~~/J\m~m~~. 22 ~$ '~~~ • • ~F 20 {i~~1:E1:!t:W-3f~m~"T ' Q ~ 0. §~1£. (ti 14). ;!t.~)~~HJ1iiq:W-iJft~~JJU~*~~SCI~~Z~~ • • ' ~m~~~~~~~. ~A5Iffl*.~~.. '. ;rj]\~P£.~{g;, ~~~¥U~:m. 0. EE~~IQJ.r~%J.ffiHr>C3f. ~5 [m*.*~~~ ,t&ffi~I1j(¥~mJF~£~iffi#tB;tjt~r5s"J rt§ff~.~ J. (Relative Impact, RI) ~~~1ifq7j(~~-Ei~1~~. WX '. 2002~ • •~~. ,. B~m~WX~{~~. 0. S:~~~~ • •. 1991 ~~p~J&rm. , {8~4pJT~~r~ZRI~~1:EW~WXz~. 0. ~~~~~~x.§fi~~r~*~~J~~'lli~*.~%J~¥~~~~m~. .IDfEx ' 1997-2001 ~I¥JRI~ -40 (l::t~~¥~m9 40 0/0) mmx/¥]~~.¥.JQ ~~~ZJ\mG ' ill. 1997-2001 ~/¥] RI B~~ +19 (l::t~~¥~m~ 19 0/0) X~O ••m~¥~~~~~ r • • J ~~~ 150. ' RI ~ -10 mmxl¥JffiiH~./f:&. ~Z* ' RI W~ +40 ' ~~l::t~~/¥] +28 ~iWJ ' PI ~ r ~ J .tt r IJ ~~ , tifS"J 0. 0. 0. ~X~1f~A~*~. 0. (ti 15). 1:1= ~ ~ ~ Ji 7\:; ~ ~ :fi!t ... m~. Thomson lSI Research Service Group fr,jE ~. 1997-2001 ~ 261il~*/¥]~11fq~j(~ffl. ' ~~~mf1t~1:E 26 M~*$ , [RE~ • • m~.18,m~[REXffiti~.~ill~WM1][~m~~:w-¥~m'R~r • • ~.J~~~:w-~~m'M~~~~x1:Er~JJ:B~,m1:Er.JJ:W~~~ ~oftt!.~. , ~xSJZ~atB~~.~'fJjrQ]~* rm' IJ\ ,. ~. '~.J /¥]1iJf~. 0. (ti 16)lli~*. ••• m. ~~WIQJ.OO~~~M.~~.'• • *~I¥J~~,~.~~~~w. ~'~~.~~.~.'~~.~~1iJf~~~~~~'~*~W&.~I¥J~ft, j:)~.A~;t~fff/¥]. §. I¥J. 0. (ti 17). ~~~x~.~1iJf~~~.~l¥JmG~'~~A.~.~~~;M~~~ff' ft~m~~~_/¥]. •• ~~PI~'~~~./¥]~~.~~~~.~~~I¥J~~'. ~~~~.~w~~.~~mM~-o ~ J.I-L l-!At/,;<!Jf'l/IIJ -:J r-l=IT f'l/JIJ 1-!At7l"= P ~ :r131~. .m.

(8) , MfIJB111FF¥W~f1~ff~WmJ§ , ~T37IJ~~6~1* (*1 18): 1. l5J~m § M~V/lJ Wff@]JjIJJJ3fIJB1IiltJH.¥N ; 2. I5J .!.-)J~ ~ 'JjflJ 81 ~V/lJ :&.~~~71d~ , 1JEJJJG~'J3 flJ FB~ B1 N 11'1~ -$- , ~ ~~*i .lbt91 :sLJJ3fIJB1~vrq0lE'I'1 ; 3. Ht1;tHJf~~:{fs 1m, m~j , t9:f~~B1*t~ ; 4. fFJ,%~V/lH!M~ , [Ij~~,§§TmJ ' t*.JJ3fU~B1~~*i ; 5.1tJ,%~1JjtJ1iJf~-*1iImm*ffmA~ , 9Y:1Ji:5EJ~~A~ft-~ , ~J~ , siTz~ W$*~mJ~. ~;. 6. ~f~t~*pff. -,. ~*~~17/LJ*J~Z*t,~. ,. J;)Ht~~1JjtJ1iJf~QQQj'f. ;. 7. 1t~~f4fl' $!{~:g~~WM~~Jl}]' tffiJl}]W~~' ~~~~]:$~~B1*1J§t~~ ~pg5}~~m*-W~tMflJ~vrq1l1HB17J1t:;J§&"~TC. 0. ' Lancaster ~P~Ht¥1J1}Em. *JJ:%1JT ' *~s Im*~%;fJT ' ~*~f~t1!~1\l~~m*~f~i:~~fIjB1;fJ~ (*1 19)~9J .:sz.J;)S ImXI*%1JT1! ' ~*~f~i:1!:&.JJjfUB1~rt~~ (mHiX1~rt' ~*1t~:&~ f~$~.m1rA!3t~) ~~1Itm &tS ImXI*%1JT1!mJ~ , *~-WWft11NB11JJf~1!3 tJj~~~6~ - (li 20): 1. pff[S,l*B11JJf~ff~ 1Jjj]~Nm- r 1~~1iJf~~ J 'mJ~~~j~~fJifj('§ ~ ; 2. ff~® tH~JE'tj~J,%~rf:[1 B1'JjfU~;glJflJ/f ;ZB1'JjfU~~/f5f1J ; 3. rJJ3flJs Im$J WJJjfIJ~~zFBfJ-:Mz~~1SfjlE;f§~(rzg~~~X*SIm-iliI5J~~ ~£~~OOSlm ' §~Srm ' JfHBe'l'1s lm -, @~ttSlm~5fD6b1f/f;f§~B1 0. 0. ~*). ~. SSCI,. 0. pg A X 1± tr ~m flj B1 ~f It EEl ~ J\. ~ ~ fi B1lt ~ t~ ~ , W1It 1*.!.-) ~ ~ 371J A AHCI 1t~~~1J ' ~l!:t ' .R~g'!'-)*±~~:{f~I~~'JjfUJ::.B1~vrq*JJ2,1tJ,%-gf. ~o~§~~A+~m,~~.~~~t9:AMBmF¥zffi~1JJf~9J'~WflAX ~1~~~J\ +l?B~I*J~~ ~~J\ +-t;~~l1::.. , ~1-1 ~#I~fT~~F~~vrqMfIjB111FF¥ (-gflt) I it ID:;~ ' ~~+1i1~~F~jcfJXl!:tJ~I1t Ilt-JJ3flJ11FF¥I1tzjcJJJG ' 0. 0. ~7~~m~pgAXlitr~~~~MBB1tJj~*j'f'~I5J~~W.:{f1JJf~~~$ ~~W~~z~.m. 0. ~f4.m- ~ ~ J\ + J\ ~ lErt g* r ~~AX~:& 1± ~f4~ ~~ F~JJj flj§flt11F. F¥J ~ ,. ,z~.:sz.~fim=M~.'~JJJG*~*~m-~~ft+=~jcfJX'~M9J~X 5}~X~. ifj(tEi~. ,. ,. tgJm~. ~§~. ,. ,. JIl~~. -,. §.}vrq~. ,. ~~~. ,. J~\~~. ,. 1!1f~. ,. 1±tr~. 1@:tB~1iJf~' [Ij~jf-gT\~~F~' n:M~~~f~t7Jrt%JjIJ~~~IJT*. , 0.

(9) ~. m-WlWm1J~. r5. (.§:. 881f). m=WlWmjJ~ (.§:. * ~Il~~ r:p~X~. j}~X~. ~-2;-,@ I:ll:! I=l '-=F. ~5t:~. g. ~. (WltU~~' MBx~~ , ~'-&fF~bt~ffu) 40% *-=tIl~~:~tfW*~J!(-=tIlW 11: ' ~~~g) 30% *§Wl~~.E~m$bt~.1J3~. * * *. BJEHJiMBxt1tslm*~. *~tf-=tIlW1Ji *~tf:JSim~tlf. * WlflJslmtJiJi$ * ~FJ¥;fI$ 50% 1* w*flirr.l~tlf l:t 50% (a: 21) ~~ A~ rr.l~;g~~i!. 1*. WJ fU IiiiiI!llliU Il!' j;'ffi';1*. ~II~~ (~f-l\W;fJ~) 40% -=tll~~ (~tfW*~J!) 30%. ~.1J~~m$. (MBx*slm*. 1£) 20%. *. f.*ii1J[]7tfl~ (WlflJ~tlf:!,l§fI). 10% (a: 20). * -=t~*umj~~rr.l~f§: 2~% 1* W~~1il'qWHUWl:t~FJ¥;rr.l5f§: 2~% * Wl tU ff1!F~ ~;L ~ J! 40% * IT.Ii ~~ [PJ -=t:t=iJ A ~H¥J 1Jo~ 10% * 7f3~~{tf 30% * WHUslm$ 3~% * ~tf-=tIl:W1I: 3~% * ~II:Wl:t ,7t~7f3~f'*{tf (lii~ 20 7t) , .~f'*{tf (lii~ 80 7t) =::k:IJ[o * -=tRW.rt (a: 23). ~tff;fWltU~W1I: ~tff;fWlflJ~:t9:m~tlf. *. * * *. 921f). ~. -§:J3 : (l)&!:jgIJI11 ; (2)-=t~ .~tt;m7t~;L.~WMB~;L • • f¥J}t ; (4)f.;5mW#.i§.t.lf¥~ ; (5)X* ; W1i5~~ §. (6)~~~*4WslfflX~. ~. 0. * -=tRW1i5 * t±~~. A~~. * -=tlltlf1i5 (~{y*~~S 7t.rt) : AAfUrs5;f§B:slm~1.RJ~.J * ~RW1i5: AAfllrs5ffiB:slffl~bt(a: 24) r lliJ\1fsl m~i)]J)(J fF~;!t~R * -=t~RWt!ii¥Jf*iimfl fI~ * -=t~Rf.*iiWt!i;L~FJ¥; * -=t~II:W1i5~ti.6b~;L7ttFT ~RWt!i. * -=t1l~ft~1Ji * AA tV tlf:!.l;L:!,l§fI (a: 24) 17 :IJ[ * AAfUt1tsl m~bt;Ltlf l:t * lli1iAAB:;f§slffl;L*~(a:26) * W*W7t. 1HE .II ". 0. ~W-~. *. .. .r.J~tfW1I T 7tI£X2/3 +slm* ~ T 7t~X 1/3 +~f4~~WJ1J:.& AAflJ1J07t*IT. ' :MLf;fWl:t~7t~ 1T~~7t~ , #~;JJT~AAflJ7t~[gM ~#&. 0. (tt2?).

(10) * ~AIilWjZiJ 20% * ~A19:~~~ 10% * t;~u~~-gfoc 30% * ='iff~*ljoc 30% * *~51 ffl)xlJ 5% (n 28) * f~1tf:*1,®11J'~ 5% * ~lIjJt~1J 60% * ='if~t~1J 20% * ewlJt~1J 15% * ~:a!xoct~1J 5% * 'i§: wH~ ~: r 'JjfU 5,ffl J}lt $ J '. * **l5-t1~JHIJ. (~~t~~ 60% . ff~. ~~40%). * ~F~tt~JHU (ff~~~r:F. 75%. (~~~~ 100%). ' HE$B1IbPJZiJ16. (=#,~,7tZ. ~?l16. 25%. 30%). "JHIJB1'i§:~. (=#J@'7t Z 10%). * mfUB1t.i-'~p~~ * 'JHIJB1~?ljJ(29) * mfIJB1~1JItJ~~ ~o. r ~JjfU#~='ifAAi5t J. * IDt~~: r ~%!fmfUB1I~~:r iJJ ' r ~%!fmfIJB1tSif~~~ J. I. ~. * I~g:r.tt (~%I~g:riJt&~%t9: * ii:~~Jf%A~!f~'JHlJzg:riW * mfUxx*51 (t.rs~§iflx5Iffl* ~~,~) ;)7:) * ~b~:r.tt (:f*ffl5Ifflx!i*7tfJTr:FB1 1.t~5Iffl¥fg*IJ*7tfJT). * ~JjfU~~ 15% * §jffiX~~15% * ~r41r1~~~[J!J< 20% * *~*ljoc 40%. (n30). * mfU~**f'l'1~~ * IDg:r13 : ]), r Fp~~~~1Jit J. ~. j§~~Ps r1&~~Jf%bUfu:E.!~F5 J B1 ~%ft~Ps r1&~1iJf%:&tfu:E.!~. F5J fEl!mWHUB1PJZiJ : I~~J-~g:r13iS~r:FpfT 0. *. ~bg:r13. 1UmfUf§1[Fs5*~51 ffl B1~$fF~H ~~~o ~o. :~;f+*-~. * ~JjflJt-i~ 20 7t * IExt-i~ 40 7t * t.i-'~11=* 20 7t * *51 ~:£~~t# 20 7t. 1.1i".iI.UiE/@ *-#~~~ it' r ~[@Ax.~ai±it#~~~r'$J]f1iftt.#~n- J '~88 ~ 1 jJ 2.1i".iIt~ [@ ~#~~ ~ itA x. At ' r $J] fHJ~n- J .http://www.nsc.gov.twlhurn/range/range index.htm (#X %" E1 $J] : 2004/4/1 > 3. ;'ii!biit, r II :t;i-m.~$J]fHJ~n-.z7fJA1i1'-4~;ffj-J '4- 2003 ~-'i-m.#4tffitll :tit~#cf ,f;}fitit"tiii X. ~ , http://research.di1s.tku.edu.tw/conference/2003/readipaperlD4-;'ii!tiiit. pdf ( #X %" E1 $,fJ : 2004/4/1 > 4. ~:k~' F*iik~' r$J]fHJ~n-:v~%mt. J 'Ax.ffit~:±.1f#~f.jj-m.5: 2 (~93~3jJ) : 33-35 0. 0.

(11) ~m*l¥JW3flJ~l:!::pJTt*mB"JhA::k~5(OJMW3J.% (2)::tI~I¥J.~C~~J!~i!i:1.t. :007f3AB"Jii1~~i!i:~hA I¥JjG~/f:t*m. '. : (I)~.l¥Js rmXIX:5tfffr! ' ' (3)W3fIJB"J@BX~A ' ~~%IJ~ , ~'-&~~ff~W3flj)i. :tEs 1m xIX:5tfJTJJ:ifzrr. ' ~1J~fj~J:.zi¥:~ , ~. 0. ~I¥J ~'J~l¥ 60% (~D : !&t&~r~). 0. gmfi~J.%£fim • • :5tR~-.m.WB'.~• • ~~~.'~/f~. jG~~~.R£fi'fflm£fi~-~ffi~.~I¥J~*,~ttl¥J~.~~~~~± ~~tt~~~Z@B~JJ:'{8W~J.%~ttl¥J~~~w~1.tm~J'~J.%~ttl¥J~~~ ~~~+JJ:~z-~.mz~tt.~~~.~~~J.%.fU'W~@~~,:tE§M. ~:tE~*~~zm~W3~~~1.t.±o~~:tE~m~$'~.~±&~~l¥Jm~ *~.£fi ' ~f7':J~'§ffi~ rPJB"J@B~S:5t$ 1~~~1@B. ; (3)JI:~. : (I)j)j~±&~D~~r~~ftr€Sz)i.~AJJ: ; (2)Jlm~ : ~~1fuW3fljs rm*JJ:Jm~~ , ~7]\~JI:~~iWi ' Jmm. ; (4)m~:tft.ir.:yI¥J~{I. 0. (tt 31). :tE~~~J.%~.I¥J~~m~~'::k~l¥Jm~~hW~~~J.%~~o~~~m ~~f7':J-@::k~Rm~ffl • • Jl:W~m~.~Bl¥~~-~*~,{8~W~*&. ~~m::kwm~~.m.,*~m~~$o~~~~~~m~fi~'-~::k~'. & f§ IHJ f7':J ~ ~frf.i?j , 5$. jj~ @A 0 rl=l~mI. '. ~1# ~A~~. ~~{iL~~A~ §i!t~Ji~t.t!H~. 0. (tt 32). ~ & I¥J ~ ~Cff1PJ!f-J •. '. ~~ ft£ /f [PJ B"J ft!j~:gJj fff. ~D1Si1lJ*!f::k~f4t.Xjf)(*m~ $. iL\ (CWTS) .~f*.. , ~p~~~ra5~i~d3"Jf4~m~~~m~~{.ll: ~$iL\/f{8~§l:* , OBCD' W\M ' ~f7':JJt::k~W0'8jB"J~~m~~ , :idli:J!~§l: 0. ft1r~~f4ffl¥J~~m~~#."J. 0. ~f4fff41t$iL\~ j;J 1995-2001 ~-t;1il7'ctt~*R[9f~2t,~~~OI~~l:!::~. ,. m~ft~~&w~~z~~o-t;~7'ctt~*J.%~~'B*'~~'1.t~,~~,. 1Si1lJ ' j;J-ESJU. 0. 2t1~~[~HIm.m$~*~lJt~l¥.i~. ,. $~. ,. ~JT1JD~fD • •. 0. (tt33). m~~~'§ffi:. 1. ~H~f4~fDJJ:~ : JJ:~ , ~H~ 2. I~f4~. ,. ±* '. f.itE~. 0. ,. : ~~ , ITt} , ~~ f~~ , 1?&t}~~~ , tfufi ~ , ~ , AA:~~ , ~~I~~r~ 3. §~f4~ :·1~~' ~3=J. ' 7(~~' tfu~f4~' ~~f4~ 4. • ~R±~f4~ : ~*±$f4~ , ±~ , ft£ ' J1l* ' ±~.~ ,. 1~~I. 0. 0. .~. 0.

(12) '!. 5. ~±1ff4~ , f'J~f4~ : iE!2:/-El ' f'Jif!2:tgfJ. ' $i~f\i$11~ , {J\fJ.~ , ~±~~ , A.~~~. 6.. Hdl '. 0. , A.~~~. ~vrq. : ¥:idl '. ~ga~. , MjE&~~~. 0. 7. ~~~±'!!:Xf4~. : M~1iff~~jffix~*:tEw,f'JB~f4~~~,t~D Nature' Science W~ ~f3 W~g £ c,\~ B~ t~ 1JJ ;;: ~~!tJj J:J * - l [ Me z SA 1ii1iff ~ ~~ @, & f4~1iJf ~ tg fJ.7Jd~ , -@~IE1iiB~1J¥tH!~~1;fUtHjffi::Z~~s Im$ , &§jffixf.tr@,~s Im~£ 0. J. 0. ~~*~~A.D~.~~*$*~~~~~1iJf~~$iW.~'.~~~~~~£ ~JHjffi::Z1iff~B~ Q~~. ,. :ill!:H£~~M¥Rrp~~B~1iJf~. 0. f4~1iff~.:tE~IJ*JT. '. ~t~*'~?~. ~'I~B~~AJ--~£~~7'cB~~* (tt 34) 0. ~tt~~~~.~~~~~~tt~'~~B*~~~*B*~~£~m.o ~Mft~~~~~~~~'IE~.~~~~&,~tg~~~OO~'~-n~~~ n1~'®Htl1f~W.,£~~q~m.~~~~~,~~~~~~£~~.o @~,~~~~:tE£~.~~~,~.£m~~~*,~~~z~~.~1iJf~m ~~?17EB~~~. , M~~it~*~*B*~. 0. (tt 35). S 1::Z7ttJT:tEFf~1J¥tJ=.!Ri~~~.tl&~fr AtEB~iJ:~ , {B~t§~:ttE.1.f\~~ ~N~tIJ EEM'~~~r~t*ms 1::Z7ttJT~~\~J[tlH'~~f4B~~~& w**#5 IJ/ES IX7t 0. ~~m.,~~:tE~~~.m.J=.~.m1.f\~-/E~~~~~o ttJt~T37IJ$JJ[{3tt§~f§~ F~1*~.nffi. 1.. :. -* ... ~1ii. a1 ~.i.. ~~~w$~7'c~~*.mw. • • &,~:~~~r~~~m~J. ,~~~. r~~*~~R~~.J ,~~~r~~~J~&.~~r~~~~~.~m~ g $. ..R 13. J. ~. ~. 0. (tt 36). 2. ~ {AiPJf 1E a1 it i. J.it }f i. jt "t" *~J,§Fi-~~t~tJj. , s IX7ttJTpJT£~B~£1~t~.:ill!:~F~vrq~f~KiB~~tlft ' -87K:ttE.. 1*m~~~1J~*~mM';;:~~~~~~~~ftOO~.'~~.~~~~~~~ 1iff~pj(;*B~f73?G&~~. ,. ®~F{jilli*~£B~jJF~. 0. ~f£t#5IJ~W£*~B~~ R~§jffix. ~~*.~®8'1iJf~*~~r~J~~£~o~~Ff~~M~£~'~£M'~. ~1J~&~~1?g~ijZMA.~pj(;* ~~l*~lJtl. '. '. :ill!:OO~IJ**B~1iff~~i8. ~tg~t~~:§:-87K~lfJ£B~±~1JD. '. 0. ~1iltJW1JB~~~t~~.. ®ZZffifi~B~~*. 0.

(13) 3. AX.;;f±-t-~. r, at;trit# :t~x 1iJ:t .. ~ ~it'" .. -t-~-Mix.zJl. Ax~W;!tftP.~F~/f[Qji¥J:l:fu1J. tl::. ' 7J1EtR';!tiVf~~JJt±~1E r. J r:p MAX ~*~, r. J ~!f.fK~.lt rX¥J ~m:~ ~rrn ' AHCI s: THCI Wt~~te r. J !&AiJ IX~*4$r:p AXlJz.t±ftf4~~;!t r1E:l:fuJ i¥JfJ~ , /fJJ!1i:j;)~~ 0. 0. 0. ~gfJ~~~~-i¥J~.mfJo~R,~~r.~i¥JfJ~J~ft*.AXi¥JR ~. 0. IZ9lft '. AX'*±ft~F~i¥Jgf.?1.J'$~.mIii •. 4. Ax.;f±-t-* r, at;-ttx. .,. iVf~m- •. .,. ft~IDfBxz~1±1. 0. ' ~ ~y ~~ r, at; ~·ti.~~Ai.. Ax~ft~Mi¥J~./f~W~ftW~~~MOO~-~~'IZ9~~~MWa~ ;!t1:.~!f-'tts. ' biT j;)~m: ; il5c1EAXfDt±ftf4~~'@l~F~L ' /fblt*[Qj-fJ3$*. 5. ~ ~.t:H~ at; .tt--tJL §iW~MAXt±ft~F~~.a-j~&. .. '. ~JJri1W;j;]j1ti¥J:m~. i¥Jm:~tElJz./fQJ7&1~tE' ~s!:t~PX~fi:~JE. ; ~s!:t~1J~~SSCI. SSCI i¥J1Jm ~~F.Jg?6~iJrx*iJl WiJ IX7t ifJT QJ .L-~~ ~1iFrJiVf~ ~13t -1W! ~ ffj a-j iL~ , ;!t?JT ~1:.i¥J .m 1t}I~H~U~:~vrqiVf ~IfFi¥J~F~ii$ , MtR'.1r;i¥JJX~~;!tfF~~17/tJ~.z1Jm ' ~1E~pg ffitR'Mlft ~][~~$t~~ffi ' /t~¥)[6J B ~vrq~.?JTiJ I~a-j~MW~L~ ~VltJiVf~&\~3t7tW 1@~5tmE/t#~ B M3t.~* ' IZSIlft ' ~~ SSCI zgf.}~fJ~;!t&,~'~lJz. ~~'~ M1EiI.:W~~F~i¥JiLt~ , fJt1f'~bI'&~. ' SSGI ~~~~'~mfJ~~-JEi¥J~~ 0. 0. 0. 1Jm~D~~#~Ji~. 0. 6. *-'±'1~.}!J]f~-MiX.1f# ,$.zJt~ .tR't±ft~F~i¥J*±'~. , ~&~\~ft~3t • • ~t±ftf4~iJIX~*t~W.~A xiJ rX~*t$i¥J9tj[ , 1E*~W*m:L~-1jZ1iJlfli ~*7'CJl ., ~j}cff ([1 37) ~IT¥ .~j!f.*~[Qj;[J\liI;@~ , 9tli1E:l:fu'~ ., 1ZJGV~l ., fJt*IJ'~i¥JJe;I\f.itW"!!i ' 7t§t1t1~ .X ' ¥}:jt~~~~ , :IJ]~mEtR'~~1IJ*a-j~JGI\ ' '&ft~tf:\ • •~VltJx1r;i¥J±'R 0. '~~D;!t1Jm 0. *. 7. j/:Jl f~ .~ .. 7~-4! at;;};{. JtEjfU~VltJt.I~*1jZi¥J~~ fUi¥J~vrq0lE'~. 0. , QJ j;)1JEpt~.MfUrs~B-j~'~fm* ' ~#~~lft9tiLJtEj MAXt±ft~F~rrn~ , JtEjfUz~~~QJ j;)~t~pg*±tlzJtEjfU~. .~m~~1Jm'~M¥@~.M~~I±1.~,~rrn~~~~~~~w*~m~ ~ • • ~.i¥JJtEj~'~AI@~M~ • • ~.'~U~•••M~i¥J~~~.o.

(14) 1. ,~'['B3i'. xtlt11t'. rift§~~1rltJ§ifBX9JB1iJfxFp~mL. 'lil~'I~¥~~D~2003i:f~. 3 M (2003 i:f 6 ,Fj) : 26 0 2.. r &~, i:l~B1 (AXJJz. *±~) ~~~1rltJ~f~tu3H"1~J ,2004 i:f 9 fj 25-26 B ' *~'±J1:. : http://www.hss.nthu.edu.tw/~apcs/pages/act/kao.htm(;fW:%.B M : 2004110/. 12) 3. J!JX,~' lil~~'§~"~¥~~B~~(~t~: ~§x!l*~1i: *JT.#~~Ji§, 1991) ,5210 4. X*1~' xIVtt £~iJ l§ifB (11# : .jffigffijB::k~t±Jfl&*± ' 1997 i:f). '370-440 0. 5. M. Weninstock, "Citation Index," In Encyclopedia of Library and Information Science (NY: Marcel Dekker, 1971) , vol.5, p19. 6. ,~'['B3i'. xtlt11t'. r iftB~~17ltnifBX9JB1iJlxFp~~J. 'lil~'I~¥~~D~ 2003 i:f~. 3 'Jj (2003 i:f 6 ,Fj) : 26 0 7. Christine L. Borgman. & Jonathan Furner,. "Scholarly communication and. bibliometrics," Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, vol.36 (Medford, New Jersey: Information Today, 2002) , 3-72. 8. 1~'I'Bii'. xtlt11t'. r ift§~~f;itnifBX9JB1iJ[xFp~~J. ,[il~t~¥~J;D~2003 i:f~. 3 M (2003 i:f 6 ,Fj) : 27 0 9. ~JtM~' 59 10.. r'JjfljiJfX7ttJTJJz.~'I~¥~1J1~J. 0. [PJa 7. 0. 11. lt52%!' 'I~¥~I fF. 12. ~~~,. r 1997-2001 i:fJCR (§ ~14~fl&) tt £1~1JB1~1t:W7ttJTJ ,[il~ 48 (2004 i:f I fj) : 56-57 0 r14~Jf~£:W-1JTE::k~J. sccc/article.asp? ser=71 (;fW:%, B M 13.. *;gm,. 14. t1~~ ~~J. ,2000/12/5, http://scc.bookzone.com.tw/. : 2004/3/23). r~*1~f~· /ff§j~m1JD1~*~J. , N7t~'. '2003-10-24/~~~¥~/A4 #&/J!~ 0. r ~17fquJfJi:~Jt7t"@c:W~Jf%~UJL~.f*8"1-t)~14ffuJf%~Jt. '~~~~~~W.*~:=+-ili~::k~~W~~~~~~~~~. 1Wff~tifBx~. 15. ~UjUE' 16.. 'lil~'I~¥~IfF48(2004i:f 1,Fj) :. [PJa 14 0. , ~f;itT~Jf%:w~vrq~IJ~~ , 2 0. r ~17fq~JfJi:h!£~rm~~£~J. '2003-11-21/R~¥~/A2 #&/*JTtifl1W~~ 0.

(15) 17. ~~~, rfWj~Jrm~~· WiJ$~)L\J ' 2003-10-28/~~¥&/B8 Jt&/~1f 18. Ji~1fi ' ~~;g, rMfU~~J¥;¥&15-lW~ J ' A)(Wt±-t"f4~rmm 5 (~931f. 3 jj) : 33 19. F. Wilfrid Lancaster, If You Want to Evaluate Your Library... (Champaign, IL: University ofIllinois, Graduate School ofLibrary and Information Science, 1988) . 20. *~-8t~j:J~ ; ~f~:flttt[QJ~¥f' r~pg~?f(f~nlJ*MfU~~J¥; J ' ~d~rlJ : 1:rjf!xJJG~*f4~~~-t" ' ~ 851f. ' 2-5 21. ~)<J&ijlm*~?t~ r4iB.~)(ijlm*~J lk r4iBJr:Fijlm*~J 0:tE r*~J~OO'~MW$~)(~ffiH~~~a*_~A~.'~.$~: ra *_=4iJr*_ X t§H~~Jr~J (4iJr*~~~~~~;!iI' Ill*- ' mtt~ ~~~:&*~.) ;:tE r.~J ~OO ' ~UtJ$~~~t§H~~~~ 0*J1Jm ~~~.~A~ : tJ~MfU~ rijlm*~J ~tJt§!tB!~ ra.~J (tJB .~x~.fiL) flJ r~l!t*~J (tJBJt*~.f.fz:) , 1~t±:l r4iB.~~ijlm *~J R r4iEfJt*ijlm*~J 22. ~~J¥;~~~?t~ r~AJ B: r.~ J ft*ft ~Aft*ftfti 20?t ' .~ft*ft1ti 80 ?t (~?tJ1J§'§:fti : A.1J~flfUJt 30?t ; B.i;~~~-t"~m~ 15 ?t ; c.~~ *ij I~ 15 ?t ; D.m~ 10 ?t ; E.~~1~~f4-t"~Jj 10 ?t~) 23. E8'§:!E : (A) fi:'m"~81z+mMfU ' (B) fi:)j]·®J~mB"J+mMfU ' (C) fi:)j]~ :Jt1:fi;~~~~+m~fU ' (D) fi:)j]~:Jtf:f1J~ A~+mWJfU~ 21 @lFp~;!iI~ rW*,lirp~g~~~Fp~;§: J *~1:r?ttJT .~ft*ft?t~ : A.m~ 10?t : B.i; ~~~1f 10?t ; C.1J~1I5UJt 20?t ; D.fBHl10?t ; E.1i1f.pg~fU*&ijlmJI~m 10?t ; F.1i!q:.pg~)(1~~JI~~ 20 ?t 24. tJijlm:sp::J;)]*~1"F~~~.~~ i§1C, tJ 1993:¥20001f.t±:lJt&B"J~X* 1993 :¥ 20011f.t±:lJtRz~Xij Im*~.~~fU~~:1JB"JfWjfi£ Ilt-~m~~. ' '§ :fti 1993-1996 1f.* 1993-1996 1f.fD 1997-2000 !q:.~~ijlm~*~, tJlk 1997-2000 1f.* 1991-20011f.~XijlmB"J*~ #~~MfU~~ fi~mt§:tJO' ~~tJ 1993-2000 1f.~~flJ t±:lJtR~~~~ , tJJ{)(1~l1tWJ Fa'~MflJ~x*ij 1m 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ~:SP::J;)]*~o. 25. ~fUtlf:l:lZ:f~~lW ;:g~: rMflJzW*J[j:JffWj J ' r~1JmflfU~J ' r~ flJ $ J*~UJ[j:~1j[?JT1ti Itfjlj J 26. J~ffi1:r:f~t±:l.~J[j:~PJa?t,§* : (l)~ 74-83 1f.*~f4-t"~WJ~X?JTij ImZ 0.

(16) )jzlj(: : (2)~)7i-'I=AIj(: : (3HliEJtJj;f§HiJlmZ)jzl)(: : (4)llil]JtJj~.~tU#HxZ S)j-$ : (5)lliEJtJj.~t1i1JroJf,i,r&)j- : (6)11~ 86 ~f4~~gj]§#Hx13:&13-~JjflJ3::. ~Z~-r)j-. 0. 27. fN t~ ~ 13 Jj 13- ~Jj flJ ~ VItI 7-K $ ±. ft ~-r 11 B~ :5.fI J>J Ij(: · W13- ~Jj flJ ~~ §?2SriJ 7-K $ B~ S )j lt~ff[Z;1~)j-;fJT · :illU--:JpJTf~¥IJB'j[Z;1*)j-1)(: (Z) · Q~RX: T)j-I)(: (=10XZ+50) · 1-\~~IDJ~13ff13-AAflJ~*-g-~-r1IB~ T )j-I)(: 28. ;!:tJjfU*~ iJ Im)jzlj(:1~.~~ft~5t§m~~JjfU 9=J Z~fXt±\~&g~J[z;!:tJjflJ · - ifPsPJT flj~§#HXz iJ Itt · :ill!:*t~@Jm§#HxiJ Im~17J~JjflJ - if 179 pJTflJ~§#HXZ)jzlj(: · ffiJB*I!z*t~.L-:J§#Hxlj(:~.1.lI · ~IJ~£fliJlm13 29. ~~:1JHi~l!z~m~;!:tJjfIJM i ifpJTt±\~&z§#Hx · :tE T ifN~13-1~;!:tJjflJiJ 1m z:»: Ij(: · 16~AAf1JM i ift±\~&z§#Hx*!&l)(:zlt$ [Z;1.lr~~~JjflJ:tE T ifZ~~:1J1~ I)(: = (T-l, T-2,'" ···T-i ift±\~&x~:tE T if*~iJ IttPjzl)(:f,i,f@fD) / (T-l, T-2, ...T i if~~JjflJ t±\~&Z§#Hx*~,~f)() 30. :tE~JjfUiJ Im ~j$J::. · {~m r f,i,1!tiJ IttPjzlj(: J fF~1~1J · ;!3;§t~1J;rt;~DT : )j-ljlJ §t~ 1999-2000 !cf-t±\~&B~tgJjJtJjflJ~VltJt1§ffijXB~mlj(: 7tljlJ§t~13-MflJ:tE 2001 !cf-~!cf- t±\Jt&B~§#Hx 9=J B~ ~~xl*(l)*~;!3;E 30 fl~JjflJ~VltJt1~xiJ Im B~*I)(: (1~iJr*I9:)' (2)*~§a~JjflJ~1fl:'I:1§ffijX7IJAB~*19: (§iJl*'j(:) B«3)iJlm~Ps Eli' tf±§#HxB~*19: ~1it · #~ rf,i,f@iJ~m*'j(:J ~.L-:J 1999-2000 !cf-t±\~&B~tg J-'-~JjflJ~1Jj'qtU#HxB~ml9: · 1~¥IJ;!:tJjfIJB~~~{~19: 31. ,~1~ff' r ~pg~W;f§~~JjflJ~F~ J · :tEft~Ax~R*±~f4~13-~F~~JjflJ ~-r lt~F~ , .j~m : ffjljz:rm~*f4~~ ~ ~ , ~ 88 !cf- 1 j=j , 81-82 32. fQJtt 12 33. ~~~I' r • • ~VltIxirEG7t;fJTR:tEf4tz1;R5~ZH!mJ · jljz:*~~ , ~ 91 !cf- 12 j=j 5 B 34. fQJtt 12 35. t~~~, r~P.A~~~~VltI3::.1m:· ~M~D~#~~:M . ~7t*~~WQ"1~J ' 2003-05-28/#~~:M B ¥~/l Jt&/*~rmtx:.fU 36. fQJJ::.tt 37. ~-**~, ~7kl¥' rft'rr~~1t~¥Mffi:*1iJHi~: #Jr§ El3I~~J3j(1~TB~~vjtI 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ±~J. ,&~.~~. 2004 if 9j=j 25-26 B. (AxRtl~) 0. ~~~~~~mM~~~~X~'2'.

(17)