貿易自由化過程中我國就業安全制度的初探

全文

(1)m. ~ ~ lfl 1t~*£ tf. ~ :rt ~ ~1:1Jl'J & a9 ~JJ~. :millan & CO.,. a. eading Borough. Cemeteries and. .z. !&.. •. *-. i:'1 *. .:f-. t$j. j!. if. **. ;ervice, NO.285,. Begrabniswesen. ~.~~~~'A. ••. ~aMt4.z. ••• *~a.~.o~~'4 ••. •• ~&~MS~~.~~'~~~~'A •• ~At~~~ hW~#~~~'~~~~?~#~#~~ •• ~*~S«'~~#~~&. ~~~«t'-. Jl:. ' JiM f};) *";y,ttl:.• • J-t ~ Att 69 g) ~ • &#r~~IA. art. 0. •• ~~AtM.A~~.·~~~~'~~hW~4A. t~~~~*J~&~ •• '*~~lft~ ••• ~3#~hW~g)&~~~. ~'A 69~k. •• ~4At~8~~~~'~#~8~~~*~ff~ff~t~~~~ '. ~~J-t~Ji.~. i. 0. .:J::. ra"' ..u.. .... ~-!-. F\IJ 0::. f"l. tt!Wfi~~Ji~ (World Trade Organization, WTO) ~:lLI¥J::t~§tI~1E:III~j®~~fi~. ~11j , *~m/Jtl¥Jfltl~mmm;m::lt'8fi~~if ' ~~~~fi~$I¥J~tJH~~ , 1;tiffl.:fJUJ!~1:m 7j<zts: ' 'f*~7t7t$t~. , f*~.~q~A;m:ff~fRf*I¥J#i.j:j* ' flftktt!Wjj~I¥J7t7t;fljffl;m.. * 1't:it&M 1} .:r)#~fJfii4f ** 1t:it &i9U~k~A tf&'.~ £'jii4f:l1-'(.i.1:r 209.

(2) *rmJba'g~llfO~~. 0. !3Illt '. ~*J3..a'gtfffit~PJTImcm;a'g. ~-1I$IDl1JDAt!tW-fi~*J3..a'g~*~:ltBl£ffii~. ~:iIjf:IJ£t. '. 0!ilfE~. *Xa'g:l:lfUi •. _*rmJb. flS : =~!Jtf:l:~~. , tJDAt!tW-fi~*J3..~fJt~~1:f~~&~7iL1:a'g. fii • § a'g.m~~. , ~1f~c15"~~fi~m~~I!;mfjlfjl$'". 1i:@ , l:Jit¥U §Hi3fi~a'gmt$fO§a'g. , Jt(;mt!tw-w. ~f~ll~i*~'". JJ.l: ' lliflW1ll*fi ~.~~[ti]~oo §] Ei3 ft , ~~~~~~ll~&~ttJm$ll~f!3'i'.~a'gfjj. ~1:fft*.f::t~jf:!J£ta'gmi~ ,. fflfjp~~,*~~1:ff:ffi:iJ ~ Ima'gJ3.. fi~a'gfi&l't;. 0. 0. mimM!3IlliD.~Z.~ffii~~*~Jt(;.om.R~m.~\"'~miJt(;*~~~~*.g-[ti] 1t¥U~K-ffi~~m~~a'gll~M~1tfEl'i'~jf:Ua'gJ3W. '. Il*~f@.f~~. • fflH)t~:'ffarfj~1ml't;:t!!;. mlllmfJt~1f. tit* §] ~~a'g5~f.!{ft*ffiiIm~~~J!U1d.a'g1mt1HJ.. 0. f*J3I~~~W1.ffii*a'g.~*l1Jm$. ~ ttJ 11 "~a'gfJB!. a'g~W. 0. ~~bDAt!tW-fi~;l[.~ffii1t¥U~iIDfjj.a'gmi~ffii§. ffii&~'~Ji~~lli*1J:~ttJ1J. 0. !iIfE~. , "aJfj~!3I~~ft*1J~~~~. ttJAD"~a'g~E. • 3jJtl;*ttJADtE~:WJ~ft~fID~~~ , m.tEtf:i ....:Jt§ , !31. Il*z~~~ttJm:t;i. m~~Mm:iI~~I!·.~ • • a'g~~"aJa~~RJtl; • •ll~PJT~llia'g~I1J1Jo. "~a'giWmtE~"~rou~&~I1J1J:fijf!('l§fa'gJt(;6b. laO '. ~K-f~~~~~m~&H)}19i~:iI~ ~ ~. mt~Jjj¥a'gfj~1J. -IN'ffii~. fO~~i*~. 0. llt~. fZSlllt '. *XIEJ:J~~~~lI.iU~fi&m~t~a'g:iI!!.lli. *xPR1*ffl. ~~fOtJD**1E.mf*ffl7~fJ:"(a'g. CGE.~pRm~. ~. 0. 1E.~.tE*.!l!1. ~ft:*. a'gj\i,lE.. 0. ,. . . If'f!roll~n#rmf,fl't; (Job Training Partnership. ~a'g~~tE~1!1·. (Trade Adjustment and Assistance Program) 'ffiitJD*. zp::I1g~fJ7Jd~ &l. (Industrial Adjustment Service) . . ~~i*~iifOtf:i.~~I~l!at. ~&~flrmJb\¥j. ~~7tJJU1*l{)l7~~i*~ii~HI fOfi~~l!t:bUbat.. (Policy Instrum. • § fI.l16'~JU~fJt~fji~~~.Dffia'g.~roll~ . . ~~Ji~~~~.mWJ~JUAWflflS~. M&lliDfmRti~. J:JO~m;tt!3l~fj~1J. ~. !3Illt,. 'i'Imcm;fi~§Ei3. (Program for Older Worker Adjustment, POWA). tt-'- :. f&~~JIDm$PRii. Equilibrium Moc. 0. Ei3fi ~ 1£a'g Jt(;j'[~~ttJm$mi~E*a'gfjj¥ '. a'gifo/C tf:i .ML ~tJD J.;. Ei3 ft~~~1ti. , -1m~*a'g~~~~l!iIJ~f,fEi3=OOxttPJTmJt(; , 7tJJUm.~roll~ . . ~~Ji~. *}'lU1*l{)l7~~~J~l!nIU%. *'. mlllm~K-f!3lbifi ~ §. 0. Act, JTPA). fta'gJjj.~. , m1:f~~J!l!ll~r~'A1JJi~"~a'g. , ffii~~~*mn~~~~~lI.iIJ~t}lmfjJE~l1Jmt~f~fMa'g:iIJ!~mI~ WlJtlo '. mlf~~t~ § ~mT~. '. 0. 0. • •~llt·. 0. (. ). *.~.Et o Ei3 ill ~ "aJ ~I. 0. Hufbauer, Gary Clyde & Schott, Jeffrey J. 19.92. North American Free Trade: Issues and Recommendations. (Washington, pC:lnstitute for International Economics). pp. 113-188.. -210. f,f. 0. ~~a'g~1.

(3) 'j{ ~ 0. iITi~. $J.~. , tit:W W . ~{¥~,.*p;fi~ fI~~&if&rtt.t1¥J. *::XC1¥J1I['li '. til ft~fj !f1:fJt IlH'it3itt;: 3! itlJl.l t¥J fE Ni. -1.nf1l[11j~~m~I¥J~~fi~ffl. ... tt~~A17ll~l¥Jmij~~ft~fJm. M:=~.1I[11j13l.if&.~$I¥J.~o~Jtt·*::XCl¥Jm~~$.1I[11j~~m~l¥Jm~fi.. § 1¥J~1.S~~~JUW ~ EI EB1tflf.8'9~~&:ttA17ll7JH.l¥Jm1f~~ft. fi5 '. 0. ii~rtu~rmElEB1t :t~flJ~I¥J~~. ,. .g' , .J...~ 7fIJ -;.rt. ~\ 1""" :..±.:: 1751. ~E~~~El.-ioJ (}~:t-mij~.$~. ~ft~17~i$i~~ ~tEt:p. J17. 0. , iitWJ • I3l m~tlOJtt. •. IA17 Jl7JH.qf$1¥J. 'I't. 1.S• •a~tE~Atit:WW~M.z.~~~miitma~l¥Jm.~~&t:p' • • I¥J~~M. •. ~1¥J~f1*lfJiP~. -it. ~IfJ17qf$8'9~~'*::xcmlli-OO~~.~m~*ffi.mWJI¥J~~AO~&t:piit.~~M* IfJAO,'f$I¥J~§. 0. tEj:):liloo*.!i!~mm!~fJ1t~mlif (simulation). ~Z.tt~lfJm~I¥J~\V. 8'9m~t:p .iJft::fiJDj:)~Jt. 0. 0. :¥:11j~FlmmW~IllW8'9~jJf.~. BSIJtt '. *::xc pJT ~ ffll¥J •. • fllj~1.SJt1t~::f~ , tE~~~~. *::xcmmJtl8'9m.~*fimtJU~a!i!'jtEiJOA tit:WW~~JHIZ. 1~f1*iJJm~pJT~~:ft1g;mlll¥Jfmj.. El EB1tf111j*1fJ. If;} , .R~~lmm~~~1J. ~ ~ 'iff m ~ 1.S. 0. r m~. 8'9 -. ~:I:$) 1jjm ~ J. (. Computable General. Equilibrium Model' CGE m~) 'E±~~.ffltE!i!'j~W~&fllmrJ:lIi...t ~H~' gt~~~. mI~. 0. f9l1tlO '. i!f/3~mTm~1¥J. ng Partnership ~ram) •. iITiiJO*. !1jti*I~J!~ trm~W~ElEB. J~9U AWF1iSf;J. ade: Issues and pp. 113-188.. CGE. ID. 0. m~mWi~I¥J~~~ ~jl tE~*~ EI. 0. ~*...t. '. § ~:ftf:=g1tl¥J:if!6fjt:p , ~'iffa~Jtl-~:I:$)1jj8'9m. tBgt~tE~~af7'J. m:ft*8'9~JE. 0. ' .;mtEf:E.1:~If;}~*:ft*8'9ffJ1OO • m.~m.m.~m;m&mHf tE:lilmiIXi7lr ' M~ " *~ " ll*&:9}lHim#)J~~~JUf#m:l:$)1jj CGE m 0. ~8'9~tstE11j1!!.--aT~a~OOa~~~l¥JmmiUR ZP::I:$)WfR7,fd~&~gt~AO~. '. ~f1~a~~~O!i!'j~fiJTf~. , j:)&OOa~~~oOOJjU~~~fi". " I~~~lli ". ~m;m&fJi:f§" OOJj~~~gt. ~&~m.&8'9~lliO~':I:$)n~.~1!!.--atEmm!l¥J.mt:poJtt~'if&WI¥J~mif&.I~. (Policy Instruments). tBmj:)~:§:~~tEm~t:p~fJm.. 0. f9l1~O. '. tt:9}W~l¥Jl5mm. " ~Otf!:1. ~&lliOMM~if&.m~q.~~'iff.~iITi~Am~f7'J° *m~~EB1:~OO,m~oo,m*OO&tt~.~~*.~mM~,m~.m~~lM °EB~IDm~~'iffaf7'J~.ffi~~OO.~tE-®I¥J·.~M~ • • • ~lliE~I¥J~iJJlm. f*. 0. mm!I¥J1:~oo~j:)6fJn~'I1*liI~~~. , ~1.SlI~ " .~ " ~lllliotw~~ " ~ll~Otw. ~~"~O.~tw~~"~ll.~twE~". • • tt~~~&~.~tt.~~#AOO~~$. 211.

(4) r~. 0. (. ). ~1t~Hmr~~~pfT'1iHI9*'Aj.~/*jJ7S('ii*p:p:j{l!*Mrt~A. 0. f§HW~pfTf~OO§t1Sjf{**. .&.*~.~~M.&m~'~Wm~&."~Mm~{I• • • o~*OO~ • • ~lliOO'. r I . j:::J!§t1S,*Fa'~* *PfTf~. ' *Ntm. '. ~wm.&*,.~*. 0. *HtfBr~m.~±J!*~.~}]&.. , ~wm.±J!*§m~ • ffiJ*,.~.~f:fIjEE.lfpfTjf{*. ~DWlliD. EEtil. '. ~{lPJj£~~D,z'~~~~)~1dm. 8'9m~~~CJ?iO. D~mP'~l&m~Fr:t~1Yl. 0. ~~lliDPJj£~ff1ft B~~~&fij. • ~mm~~'. ~'~~j::~. ,. 1. L.._. tJYi-j!i~§t1S~{lPJjtf'a~. iTIiPJj£~lliDf:fIj§'€3-CJn~8'9lliD~mP.~. • :ft~1JoAtttw.j!i~*JH:~1~pfTOOI:Wi8'9:ii!mmm~flll~. tJ~~jffl~. '. '. 0. I. 0. '~~~Jl&lli. ~~~JllHmp'~l&m~§EEj!i~~~U~~mi:&. llfl~&~t!I~n~jJ. , ffiJJl.lt~I~fljft8'9~~CJ?i!~-~Jt(;~. 0. 0. /fJl~~llfl~.lt~'~fUft~~~. i;t~A.D"~H:€~&fij~~~~lli*. • iTIi~. *~AJt(;~~~~o.EEm~.M~mM8'9.~CJ~':ft~~~Atttw.j!i~m.Z.~~M i;t~A. 0. 8'9.,'t11*. r. I. I. 0. ~. (. :. ~/\@$r~~EI=l19:/\~t!:\*f7'jz~$r~~~~Ht1!ii1](]tt *~ffi~o. .. 212. (Aggregate) ffij;&; ,. 1J(]~l'fJm~~Je./!ft~.

(5) ~. ~~. .p.;~.:f!. :tllii(#. ---. lilWf;!f 2f1!. lilWLBJt:f:1. OO*ili 1(#. ~ti I. 1. I !fllllltO Hi I. 1 1. 1. 1~~OHiI. I~1~0i? i ,. ~m. i?,J :0 ,________. ~~. OO~~. OOY~. IPJ~ta2'~4:'.~~ l. ~Im ' *ftl¥tit~!H ~~f);l~n:t~'Qf+r f;j ~~JmffH:W~~M;ij. /jI. ftlflll¥tMi'2;'il1lli.. ;vI. o. /'. !fif!IlHJ ftl 0.. f);l~ ilHlii"2:gfnHiM. ,--------, :~. I--------~. *:. :r~'---:f{Ii 1________ ..1. ::t. ,. ,________ J. .flC?*t1f~*§fi~ 'oom~t1fwxoo*. *~J~gf~OOiliY~f);l.

(6) *~M.~~CGE.~.- • • • ~a~.~o~~M~mfi*.Hfi~~~mN. ~*i!.z1rdmffl;W1iJ~i&~tt~'jrm~&~Il*~~~1311 1.!tta:&~iI~;yrm~.jC~U~. ; W\JIP '. 0. *.~~~~p).r~.~~~. :. *M\1'i¥ ' tt7t:~1. *~~.i"J~f=r.~&1'Iij~1J1iffi~mf~lIl~1J. .,'j/'''~-f:,~.. 1l.AD'.tJ\:;:.R~u>;. W~~Ji.tt~j§1. *Jlt3l1m~flmo. 2, • •:f<B(.m.-./J\~ffi:ia1f3(~~~.. rllH'Oflm. .~ i"J pJT ~ 1Jfj1:. ; W\fW ' • • &1'Iij~1JJlt3l1mNmf~~~£m. ttlM. 1£llt~Ji~. 0. ~~ttlMr:p. 0. 3.'a:'M:tE.~r:pM!~tfjilij8}jD~filjts. 4.txqi~1j[M!~:tE.~r:p;/]DP),~~. : W\!W '. ; W\~n '. PfT1'I~~tf13~.f!t~ffi:i;jFi:d3~5(~. fi~1£;/]D~mN.~*J:I.z13't. '. 0. ~ii:tx1i*ft. ~~~o. 5, flmfj~5.I¥!'~W1iJ~*iiti*-~~ttlm~1¥:tE. 0. 1£m.ittW ~i&~a)!:~1l;} , ~iI~ &ffiJ.~. ~m.gjC~~~.ffi:i&~ffWIl;}M~~~.o. J!to1£*~r:p,. 1±J~all:3. - ,. ='. pfflf~i. **pff~. :§'Hll:lJm~1j. ~~.1J1£ii:.M~.jC~~.":W\~n'.~~~~~I:tE".~Mm.i~~mHo. , :tit I£1l3rm pJ. (H-=). mU,~' *.~~ $t]~m~ffii. P). ,. § ,1. 1£p).~!ifjm. fD~1m !ifj;fll!'l"Nfl. • • •~~~~."* • •. rN~~+A~~.~.ii:.~ • • J. '. rr:p.N~~.~. .~NMMJ ,rN~~+A~ • • • ~il1J.fi~.J&r~~~.~.iI.$M.*. ~~;m •• J 'fN.lltJ!t."Ii.ffii~~~fi.-ill:lt~ttl.~."Ji. 1£.~*mrm. 0. (H([9). ' &,~7t:U~."J!l!p\JZ."~,AJ!I!~lIi.~r:p , M!flJffl-J!t~~5.I¥!'~*~7E. iE@I5'~*4JpM. mf~PfT~gt(}';J1. &lI~~Nii-il~. ~1ri1m'li ~ '~';t ~m1m'li~1l. ., ••. •• •• ••. ••. H~:~g.~~~.· ·~*&~AOOffi~ffig~~m~'~&~.-.~m~ ~.~M ~~.o~~m~~~m~R.& ~~ ~'~ ~~.~.=o. HI1:9 : Jit4JjUil~~~.~f~~Ii.,~ Li, Ping-Cheng. 1994. Environmental Policy, Coal, and the. m1m~~~ 4,. ~~AD~7.. Macroeconomy: The Impact of Air Quality Regulations on the Pennsylvania Economy. Ph.D. Dissertation: &Vff1fPm. ' ~J\ +11:9 ' ~fj(iIilI.1¥:~JJ.jfl11tiii&m~~tI!z • • ~.Mifi5 0 r~ rr*~fifi±~3t. an. : Calibral.

(7) .a~~Q.m$ft. .. ••• ~~~~~w.. , :u[.15$fflJ1~U~~~M~rx:i¥J13<~ (calibration). r-t~~1J[]A t!t~ji. ~M~Pff:fj15fflj\i¥J~IH~. f~1fM~~:. *M~. f]1iffilflmf~~CijJ. ~AO&:'~~~1b'~1Mpfflil.i¥Jgt~'t,\.Drx:J,;)u(HE~Mi¥JlElit'li. , ~Jlt~WfEJ!f¥i¥JmnftfJt**tfj-~J1~Mi¥J~~:f;!g1tiM ' 0. (HE.). 0. 1E. 1E:U[~~M~pff:fj~~i¥Jgt. Jt* ' ~W~~1E1J[]At!t~. W~*J1.f~~jfmmfJtfJt*i¥J[~~11'fID ' M4~M~i¥JmmfJtfJt*~~~~ , .m~*tfj-m~i¥Jj$) !t ~mf~i¥Jim&lJl~. i¥J:f;!g.Mrp~ • • • ADrx:i¥Jm.'~~.M~.~At!t~W~m.ti~~m.~ • •m. .. f~§i¥J3C~. ::f!t '. .Mo1E:U[m~i¥J:f;!g••• rp'~1M~~~~~~.~i¥Jgt.AOrx:o~.£.j$)• • .&~. ~. 0. ~~1.S{fiHE. ~~ii.&m.ii. pffJ.m~i¥Jmim. 0. 1E*Xrp , M4jifrJ,;Xf~*J1:±~i¥Jfljf :. - ,. ?:£'~~M:iL::§E@]*~~*U~,l~ns+1F~a~ifBr~&,~~~~!mm~ 36. ='. pJf1i~~~ifBr~HIJ~~! 38. %. % ' iffl. 0. **pJf1iil~~mmfjt~ifB1fX5~. 0. ~~m.~ • • i¥Jm~~~a*~~&~M~~i¥J~.®f¥1E¥.m~i¥Jm.o. 0. ••. ~'~~§MPff~fii¥J~rW~~i¥J~~.*~~J ,~-.ft~~~.*.~~.*Mi¥J iJjU~. , *~M5ift~7!~W:u[.'I1'fDl. $1y~~®§ '1E~~rp. 0. ~rt'i'~~i¥J~7t. '. 1E*~~~1~i¥J~~.i¥Jjf*~;t~:aijE. , ~M~Ji*M~~~/G~i¥J'. ~MIJ;;fJi*M~IJ~t)'ff:lf~~. 0. Pff. ~'1E~~~m~.rp'R~7t~~a*~~T~Mm~M~• •IDm~~.*~~T~M rp~~~a.:ItH. 1£~*$P'jf*. '9). flJft~'Ii*~~. 0. m-OO~jfi¥J~~~D~. J~=o. y, Coal, and the vania Economy. 0. 1 &~ 2 pff5F. EI3~rprx::Jrj~~{]. 0. , 1E~MIJ;;f , ,~lli. ~~fta~Pffm~i¥JmmfJt~~g~'~.~1E~~.*~~.~~.*~~T·tia~~~ mf~pff~l&:(t-JfjJ.ffl~*~t§1IlJ. 0. ~.~5F"4Wl~l&:a~1i~A1i::bi¥J~.. ' ITii:!trpJ,;J• •. &• • :U[~OO • • ~A • •~.tt~~i¥JWM~.Pff~i¥J~ • •*o • • 1E~~a*~~T i¥JJiffMti:~.~j;IJ 32,525 i¥JJiffM'Ii~~:fj 33,982. l! :J:\4il! ~ ~ 1\l1'19m. ~~~.Wt5. m~M~fj!11'fID. ~M~~:fj 4,742. A'. fd:i~ •• ~~11l'8 3.24. A ' fd:i ••••AOi¥J 3.38 %. % 0. 0. ®1E~~.*iJjU~T. ' •• $P~. ti.~rm § , 1E~~.*iJjU~Ti¥J. A ' fd:iJt••AOi¥J 8.41 % : ITii~~a*Ti¥J~M~*:fj 4,347 A ' fd:iJt. .*AOi¥J 7.71 %. 0. r~. ali: Calibration ~JE~&1J$~l'l~~Shoven and Whalley. 1994. Applying General Equilibrium 215 . 0.

(8) ~:lLi&Yfl*~~$ftm1::.;+ f!:9W:!. ~~~.~n~8~~. ~l. !lID JE Ili. *. ••• Ao~~~. i*JiJ. *,J J!i. Jlt)1':(£~W]r. ffltil:A. ~~~jitfJ~~:. *,J J!i. !Ii$ fffU f:itfJ1'~m. ~W:!. ~W:!. ~W:!. ~W:!. ll*B'Br~. -32,525. -29,J65. -33,982. -26,766. !ill *B'Br~. -4,742. -3,751. -4,347. -3,943. ~J!iI±lD~j§*. 0. 52,031. 0. 33,473. D~j§*. 1. 957. -746. 1 , 131. 1,552. ~j§*. 0. 942. 0. 117. m=~J!mm. J!i 'j'{ fj) ~ j§ *. 0. 3, 135. 0. 4,123. -8,606. 0. 3,902. 3i~~':lii~~. 0 -9,890. -11,956. -12,280. -9,355. ~Wijf>. , :;Y::~ifB:(£. -49,114. 0. 51,741. 0. AJ;).J:. 0. ~D 1~. 'j'{fj)m~ fj)m~. ')(. AD~,~. r ' *fi~tfJ\"~j ~A JJj{ JttfJrJtW]. 7;JMf:itfJ ~~ , . n~~~) tfJgt~. {7J~~. ~tfJ~W]~~~. lI~gt~A[Ji¥J. !lID JE Ili ~W:!. fti~i?t~gt~.A. *. i*JiJIli. *,J J!i. ~W:!. ~W:!. ~ff:tlt! '. 1f. ~i1J1Jo. ~B'Br'. - 3. 24%. -2.90%. -3.38%. -2.66%. 204,985 fmJI i'f.i. !ill *B'Br,. -8.41%. -665%. -7.71%. -6.99%. .I~~~tfJ~1~~. ~J!iI±lD~j§~. ~J!i~D~j§* ~Dfm~~ 1~. J!i 'j'{ fj) ~. ~F'j'{ ~m~*. 2.70%. 0 0.86%. *. ~m~*. -0 33%. 1.73%. 0 1.50%. -0,69%. 0. -0,35%. 0. 004%. ~~ Jj\t~~tfJfj. 0. -0.77%. 0. I. 01 %. 0. -0,23%. 0. 0,10%. ~f,1lj~~~o~. 2.16%. ~W]rjj.w~W]fjj.tllJ~lPF~. 0. -2.61 %. -~jffi §. -2.68%. 0. tI&~~tI~~. 2.04%. , ~W]tfJljj.~~W]tfJfjjf$~/J\. ,*~ ~a:(£ RW] tfJ#Km r lt~¥f ~ § ~WUi~~* ~1~pfi5tljj.tfJl~m: *5~fi~tU. *,J J!i. ~W:!. , jl~~~. :liif~tfJJJ!~ OJ J:J EB ~'rrJ tfJ. 011<2 tfJ*5~~jf> , .~~r~&iU~~~r~tfJ~~1~m:(£~W]~!:ti..1iw]fD*i-® - 216. 0. :*~~~. !iJjEH~Ri ~1I~nX:W. ,Jit nX~~~.

(9) .a@~tt.N~ft~. .. I. ~fll. : A. j!J1!t. :fikM. Jlt7f. ' :t£ft:1t§""f '. ~D~,'~OJJ-Y-5G~Jt<;J}jI¥J~'. lHt$fflU~I¥J'I1ft5t. ""f '. '. ~~tI10.B.tI1}j,tI101J~rmtJIjBtI152,031 OO.::Ef"F~1t. *~.1.f\M~i1J1JD. 33,473 OOr,t.~1t. ~A~*l¥Jffl1t§~.®tI1Ao. 3,943. *w~I¥JJt<;ft:. "1,552 J 17. 4,123 3,902 9,355. o. lll!t. 0. 0. rm:t£r¥ifJlii$. ;j~W~·I1~~J9i.tI1}j,~ifJ1J~tI1l¥J}j,~. , {tJ-'¥W. • •~m~tI1m~~I¥J~*·~~~l3lm~~tI1o.B.tI1m7. • j~Hlf~ftml¥J~ifJ1J • ~~.mf~~~fJTjl*.5IJtftB~.. ('E2m;j~w~'1i:. JiJ9i~)I¥Jr,t.AOo. ~=*J1• • I¥J~*~D~. 3 &~ 4 m-;f\. , ~ifJm!lf}m~oo.:t£fj~.L,Wi~l:t~-*J1• •~. ~~~'~~~~EE~~=~• •~~~~m5G~~ml¥J~t5t*~fim~l¥Jo~OO~$I¥J~ .~-;f\. ,. /f~n'ii:t£Wfijlii$fflU~""f. '. ~1t§I¥JOO.~tJH'!~~mM{tJ. 0. :fX~I¥J$*.Ao~~U+gg.. A~.L°m~~ • • &~.~~oow.~.m~~I¥JAOO~W.*o:t£~~Iii$~~""f·. ~1¥J~1t§*~~~u. a-*. ) iE~~~~m~~tI1l¥J~ifJ1JilJ~EE. (. ~• • ml¥J~~5G~~~o:t£• • $'*~~O*$mMEE.~tI1o.B.m.~o:t£~~. :6,766. ,3,473. ••~~MI!t~m.. 96,470 A '. ~.r,t.AOI¥Jl:t19l1~~. 9.60 %. 0. ~.I¥J~1t§*~:f:f. 2,589 A '. f~. 22.33 % :t£f-¥ifJlii$1¥J11ft5t ' • •$r~I¥J~1t§*.~ 98,892 A ' 0. 87 %. f~~~.f,;t.Aol¥J 9.. {~Jt@r,t.Aol¥J. 0. ~.I¥J~1t§*.m. 11,932 A '. {~Jtf,;t.Aol¥J. 21.16 %. 0. ~.~,:t£ft:1t§l¥Jmt5t""f,~~tI1o.B.$M".~Jt~~~~.m~atl1l¥J*$~. M. *ifJ1J. 0. :t£~~Iii$""f. '. ~~tI1o!jWB.~:fX~1JDAt!tW-W~~J1*,H~"tI1}j,.~Jt<;ft:rmtJIJtI1. . 66%. 204,985 OOI1'F~1t ; f-¥ifJlii$""f '. .99%. mJt<;ft:I¥J~~~W~.B.'W~JiJ9i.:t£f-¥ifJlii$~~""f1.f\tI1m~W~ft:°. .73%. .69%. .04%. .01%. . 10% 04%. m'l, , ~~l3lm t!{i:U J-Y- EE :fXfr':Il¥J ~1t§W~-.®o. ~*-g. J-Y-.LI¥J~.fJT ~BJt<;~~IBOO~. 0. ~lJtJIjBtI191,647 OOr,t.~1t. 0. Jlt57} , :t£ft:1t§1ttl1}j,~ •. ' ilJ j;)Jl~M:fX~:t£1JDA t!tW-W~~J1~~~ , m;mIDlll~~m~1t~~ifJm ••. &~.~~~UAOOOO• • *I¥J~OO~.. '. rm~~tI1o.B.~IJ~}j,. ~.I¥J~ft:°.~.~~.fl.~J}jI¥J~*B.~~:fX~:t£.~iliO.E$M~I¥J.~· ~&ffi~~~~~ • .LJjl.~ftft~fl~. , **~-~.mlB~~l¥Jtil~:t£~.®~ • .LOO. .&a••. ••. •. 0. •• •• ~.~~fi§~~-.m.~.o-.~g'~~~ ••••ADBlli•• m~tt •• '~7 ~.*gq •••• ~Z~'~~~~ •• ~.fi~.~&~.~.~ •• ~a~~S~.8 ~ •••• ADrr.M~~3a.fiq.o. :*.~®m:fikM~".~~~~~~omrr ~'".~~fi~~7 #.n~".~. n~~.~.~,afirr~.~Amw.aM ~#.$ • • • m.~~.".. ~. 217.

(10) •• ~~~mtt. rnLEl § rrI ~~ g~ p~ ~5t 1JjH~: f1tOO J).Jfi~'I~UlI ~ tt!H"l:5t m!\ ~ *$. *~ffi.lli~CGE.~~*~.a~~~Alliw.~m.z.'~ ~ ~ifft ~ It!rffJ ~~ ~~. 0. •• ~~M$~~~&.lli*o~~~~m.~~ifM~~fiM6~. ~mM~~&AM~ •• AD".'®~~.5t*m~fi.~~*$M~~~h.~~m IDo~~'~~m~.fi~fi.M~H.~*~~.~~~A~lli~•• ~.n'~.~~ .~~ CGE ~*4,r!ii~~~11 ~~ *~.fi~.~ADfi~*i!1t:i:iJfi~lliJJ!Jtl;l¥f~~ , {t::/. P~'~~ffl.ffi~~. 0. .3. ,. ~.~AD~11::~B5tJ:t.:t~mi:iJf~~*E*. $r~. .*$r~ ~ t±\D~~* f.iljI'lJlD~~* JlD~ ~~*. 1)]; J!t jl{ JIh t\! jl{ JIh JIH~ * iF jl{ JIh JIH~. ~~AD~f{. 96,470 12,589 0 -3,815 0 0 0 28.324 141,198. 0. &~[]ftiJ1J05mtEgf. M.ti~tt!. t!lIJEIIi~ifjlL~. •. ~J~,~f/t{~~. 0. ~m.~~B~.~U~AQ.~E. iIfli:tL:A ~Wl. ~.m.~. ~lff!&J3tilm S". II~ ~ Eli lliMt.l. $~c€i. t¥ lfJ iii ~ itIJ. *Wl. ~Wl. *Wl. -92,801 -9,968 204,985 1,203 -8, 145 6,818 -61,527 -40,565 0. -98,892 -11,932 0 2.274 0 0 0 -32,965 -146,064. -78,067 10,749 91,647 -3,414 592 13,293 13,207 25,324 0. '. ff. 1%Wf.~ ~,~t3. l! '. .rmf~gt~. .~. •• , ft8. ~iW~i.~ OO~W. 0. W. (Specializatior. , EI3~A: f!1JE: ' :tiiE: ~ ~W:l. I'l *Wl. -9.60% -22.33% 0 1.68% 0 0 0 -6. 19%. 9.23% 17.68% 10.62% 0.53% -3.01% I 67% 1.61 % -8.86%. t!lI *a~r~ .*$r~. t±\ 0. *. ~ J!t llllH~ D~ ~J!t JlD~~~ ~. 1)];. jl{JIh~. JIh )IIH~ jl{ JIh )lIH~. **. lii~ifjlJ. J!t. *Wl - 9.84 % 21.16% 0 -1.00% 0 0 0 7.20%. -7.77% -19.06% 4.75% -1.51% 0.22% 3.26% 0.35% -5 53%. 9} , ~mtM~:. ~~~W:ltA~. .. **iI!l.i' ~~. Ah~tjf~*~. tt 1::;. : Thorn, Relation tt 1\ : In] tt 1::; , it : GnJ.hl, British.

(11) .M~~t.@~ft~. •• ~~.iJt~W.. ijm~~F;mm'f1W. !t ' 81 -t ~ ± iJilJ Ji fl!] #t ~t. y~5}~J\1IeI*~ Qrtuu:H~fli~~~. ~*. jJJ 1:7 f$.if] ft;] m. ~~n. ' P)J&~fT. j~.I!ti¥f~~. , ill. EE.~~J~~5}fJTPJ~. ~£'~M:Wil~. 0. , 1ZSI~$~~1JOAtltW.W~mH~ , ~I*JJm~f.li~fI]fl3ftlJ!ft;]A1:7Ji~. IZSIllt ' il&11til&m~:itft;]m!!.'}jZ -~~lJ!tE~tlofitJ~pft*if]m:~ft;]fjj. '. EHlO fitJ1Ja~:~rt£Jm~f.li~Wil~~f~ $ 1mlltll~:ttf!. •. '. *jJJfi~ft;]~!ffjI ?. m:~m;t~~~lUlf*¥~~**Iil&mft;]lfin. tE~1~lltjJ ffl ft;]twl7l~. j..~. 0. ~f911gZ. 'Mm:~m~~~ff. '. , ~1Jil&11tm: ~ £,~ }iS'- ~~ It<;* jJJ1:7 1~ Iltilffl ft;] JEtIZSl ~ fitJ ? ~ EE ~l{ff. !I. :).,. a*ft;]Jmlli1m$IJ!M~~~~ffl~'~~~m:~~~a*~~~~~mm:~m~m~ZM1m. iJt. $~~,~~ft;]JEtIZSl~~~~ft;]m.~~lZSIlJ!o~.ft;]''Moo~~~~~ft;]~~fI]".~'. *m ,067 ,749 ,647 ,414. ~i¥fm:~ £'~f?f1[1'~IWft;].~IDII_. '. m:~~~fI]~~~~~il&m~~ JEP)IZSIIJ!Jm~~~ft;].. jI , ~mH~~~rd1A1:7Ji~1~p)nli'ifIJf$.". ftft;]• •. lZSI!lt '. ~IZSIIJ!Jm~~~~~ftA1:7JiVffif$."pfi~. ,ftm:~~~~Iltft;]~~~~f?f1H~~~~o. tEf?f1Hm:~3(~itlJIltft;]~1J~Zfij. -592. 0. , £,~.w$BJ3ft;]~ , A1:7Jijjwa~Jm~~~~~M!:~FR~. ,293. ,207 ,324. o. ~. 00 J3 VI. 0. m: ~ a *. j}J m ;t~ jffi. g , A 1:7 Ji Vffi ft;] f$. ". P) 2J ft *Jf! ~. (Specialization) "W*i~:t7J~~Jm~*jJJ1:71fIT~ft;]m1:7f1]IJiIt<;!it~1:7. 0. ~. ft;] w~ it. (lit) ft~it~. jffii'EE~A1:7JiVffift;]."'~.Mit~• • ~1:7'~~~$ftW~AA~~.n~~m'. ~. t. ill~'fiit~grtu~~ffl~~~~~W~AA,~~~~*jJJ«~a~.~1:7ft;]~#ollt. 9;" , 1ZSI~~~W~AAft;]~*~9:W '. *jJJ«.ftlrtu~~~IDII_Wf!lW/JJ:t~# § i31t<;~r..'f~. ~m. Jimft;]W~AA. 77%. *~~'*jJJm~~~fftE~m~~~~ft;]~~o (lin)~§Z'~~~~~ft;]~W~~,. )6%. 75%. ' P)flJ §. i3tE~~m;t~Lft;] • •. 0. (liJ\). ili~. ,. EE~Ji~1fIT~fI]Ji~~ ~ It<;. A1:7JiVffimM.m:~m~~*.~fi~ft;]~~ml7lfftE'~ft~mM.~*ZMfftE~~~. il%. :2% 6%. ,5% 3%. -I:: : Thorn, Graham 1992 "The Single European Market and Labour Mobility" Industrial Relations Journal 23(1):14.. : /l'iJli-l:: • pp. 22-23 tin : Grahl, John & Teague, Paul 1992 "Integration Theory and European Labour Markets" 0. British Journal of Indus-trial Relations 30(4):515.. 219.

(12) 1iJm1Wf- 1lt9} , 0. EI3~Ift~ml¥Jfr A~1l::~P'JmH;!U~IJI¥J~NfliU. nH~~i~'~1:li&~. ~. , t!M~1~AjJ~~l¥Jf:tt~~~t)(1iJI¥Jf~~. ' 0. 1l::~P'J~~~ijJnJ*:~W9Hm~iJJ. AI¥J1l::~ 99 .8. (a+). 1l::~1¥J § ¥itfIDII~i. lH!~1lt. '. i&JffJfill:~IDII. W1l:: ~ f9: W~"I ~ t1 ~ zp: 1iJ ~ iJJ m*;§ f:tt mmm f* .gr m i9i ~ fliU J!t tt fr A (Institutional. Intervention) 1¥J~~fDJ}]~~. 0. I¥J~~. 9. , i:P,Q)"j;J1. f!t~i&JffJfill:~IDII~W1l::~f9:WIDII~m~t1~ZP:1iJ~iJJm*;§f:ttm. ~~.grm.~.~~~'~Nm~~M~.m~~~Jfill:~~f9:WIDI.~.~~~.~~~? 7t~~1IDCiW;~~AjJ~~~,'~~. • '. f~1~iW,rl~¥'. , f9:WIDII~I¥J~~~~~.j;Ji&Jfff!P~~1l::~I¥J~jJ~. 0. fN:ff r Jfill:~IDII~¥! J '. Jfill:~IDII~.:llffiI¥JI35:t§ffittglGIDII~. ~IDII~fD~~~Jfill:~IDII~~t&M (Jfill:~IDII~¥!~-=ft*). t1~. , .f:ttIDII~I¥J~fmfD.:llffiI¥JP'J~. ~I¥J~~. 0. WtlD~'. 0. ~1;ij~IDII~. ,. jif~IDII~. ~-M~I¥JIDII~.gr~:jt.:llffiI¥J~5E. El3Jfill:~IDII~~m¥itff!l!.. rJfill:~IDII~¥!J PJT~fH~~~@:~U'I~jJ~5E. mr Jfill:~IDII~¥! J t1~Jfill:~IDII~":llffiPJT11&I¥J~IIJB.+7}Wfm. 0. J. (Jfill:~IDIi. ; 1:t:lz:¥!~5E~ , -EfAQ)"j;J~ 0. ~ffjj. ,. ~~N]I'*~fJt~Jfill:. ~~'II~nlG~Bf~~~~'rj)~c-g-**it~fDgt~m*;§~I.iI¥J~~IVE? f'F~t11ltilft/f:;t~~D. ' f!l!.El3. ~:. ~-. ,. f!t~. $~~m. '. ~f5(~:f±~$A~~mllM~~. ~ffjj. ,. El3~ 5 1¥Jt&:ff~;j4**. ft* ). r Jfill:~IDII~¥! J CP~5E ' '. Jfill:~IDII~~fm§ffi: 0. = , j;J~;f~¥!A~:lz:~ J 0. 0#Jfill:IDII~fmfDiHf~~). Jff~1&. 0. ~flEl3i&Jff:i:~I¥JJfill:~IDII~~~~~~-g-~Jm~~r.!~I¥J~~ftHft. ~~:l'(g. , §i'!i:l'(gl&1l::~~m~j;JCP/J\1l::~~:i: '. %' 100 - 299. A~~ 90.7. (Jfill:~IDII~$~Ei.. *i"l&t§f1I¥J~!. 0. (§ffii&. , ffjj~~~~.fJlf.f~Jfill:~IDII~l¥Jtf5i±~~~~1&~i& '. /f~~r&l. 0. ~Q)". @~1l::~~milft/f~~nlG~/f.f:ttJfill:~IDII~1¥J. j;J B *~f§lJ ' B *-f1J\[9$$~.fJl §¥itfIDII~.btf§lJ :. ~ 78.4. m=,;n. .f:ttJfill:~IDII~ft:i:~I¥J*~~?!'{~i&Jff$r~'. '. 0. ='. r - , i&Jff~mm~:lz:~. lM~mm. ~D. ,". r .nlGIDII~ , f*t1+Ei.~j;J~~~~CP~.. , PJT":llffi~~Ugt:~Jfill:~IDII~ J ' ffjj r .nlGIDII~ ,. ,~¥!~-t;, ~J\ft*). ,. % ' 300 - 999. ffi!IAt&~ 30 - 99 AI¥J1l::~. A~1l::~~ 96.4. %' 1,000 - 4,999. . ' ~f~1JOI. ~~, m§~~~. llt1~~r' ~ '~~:l'(g'. :. ~IDII~Jj6'@iT,. ~t1Jfill:~IDII~. a+-: MuM' a+= : M!ImIf - 220 -.

(13) •• ~~~.~~.~ •• ~~M~~W. m~W9f-$~1iJ. AI¥Jit::'l99 .8 % '. lit ' il&mtlflill:'lWfl. it::'l1¥J § WRwlI. tBf:m~~.~I¥J~JJ% '. \.. (Institutional. I¥J"R~. ~IAIir:tE 5,000 A,l:Jl::tr~IJ~ 100. m. .5 •.• .•. mt lM tt it }JU. :Flf;).: b. A1xc. 141. 12,892. 508. il& Jf-Jmt~;. b/a. c/a. 275,702. 91. 1955. 8,168. 90,941. 16. 179. 59. 1,264. 33,753. 21. 572. ~~~&. 124. 762. 22,539. 6. 182. rl3jllll. 49. 1,293. 43,514. 26. 888. :/};:i:!< JfIll: WI!. 13. 836. 21,471. 64. 1651. I~it$. " i1Ef~lII/1. " ". f:if1t..ht!iI¥J~)E .t~!iMR$~Jh". (lfIiIl:'lrof/ I. t ' .g: A IlJ,l:Jillt !;~,*~fX!iMlfIiIl. K3®~fi. M~m~W9. l1Iililih. :/}it$.. J. 0. •. 0. ffl;);g: , 4' B:tEIU.1¥J. (fi+-). ~IJiI&mt~IJfj~$1ylt":'llIlll.f[J71Ifl~lfIiIl~IDII.t:;tAji! ~. ~~~. f:if:;it :m:fI1b~Jt ?. !f!. 0. , tBllJ,l:J f~ il&mt:tElfIiIl :'lIDII.iI&~ l::iftJE ~ ~~ziJ.!tEf[JlIH.t I¥J~ Il*. ~~liJrP:t~ffHI. i! it: :'l1¥J~ t.J ~. ro. mtlM. ' ~EE. I. .M*.:fiil&~#I~R.'~A+li'. • • _.#~.M.~·I440o. W~~fiM.o. =". m= " lIft~~~m:tE§EEft3®fj$ffiIUGWt;IDlI~ " ~HI ' f&IDJ ' fX!iMJfi~IDI'.I¥JV'J~~. ~:'lIDf/.$1ifHi. *.ffiltI¥JIDlI~o0~.~~.I¥JV'J~M.IDlI~ • • ~¥:m:Jj)'-.~~Jfi.I¥J~.'~~. 1Er~'. 111 " ~~}JDI " :t!¥~ " ~cft '. Il~. ~f!.H~m~Jj)'iI&. t\l!~. , ti~~m:'l '. ~~~Ib'. Jltl~75rF. 'I!!;;LY-'-.:::bo. ItlJibtJL-a 0. (§ffiil&. 0. ~1lJ. H:!tlflill:'llIll'.1¥J. ..... 99. AI¥Jit:~. 1,000 ..... 4,999. ,. ItH~~~1H"f[J:ttftM~I~. '. ~~tIB. , Ill[ , itT " fI~ , ifij! ,. Jfi:'lroll_~1!H:~,*~ij~$1y!29J1j. ' :{£§ EEftilmtl¥JfJJ.""f '. ~IDII.&:,~Jl7 ,l:J:m:t~. 0. Jlt9f- '. Jj)'ti.~IDII.:R:lmI¥JAt.J. '. ,. ±* ' ~. ' ~~tf!i " EfHiIU '. im~'liU;tIt~f§~m~f3j.~Ij~m~z. iIUlt~~~ml¥J~j1i. , frnrm'lJ~. ~:iftJEf[Jm#!:*j!:~~ADrp,e. tiJj)'~~WJfi~~OOtBm&:'~Jl7 ,l:Jli:t~. "R~&~~fMjl¥Jt:;t"R. '. 0. ¥}:lJOl:iI&mt:{£~l&,Ml1~. '. (. ):{£. 0. &:'J!I¥J"~f[J¥}f,t. f&IDJ ' ,. 0. EEJj)'iI&mt~~R. :tL$f[JITiI&~ITI. ·... ' ••••• '.n. ~+-:.*~'~A+-· r~.~JfIll: • • • ~ffi~.~.~.J ~.,.to ~+=: • • • '~A+=· r • • m~~~.~W.~M~~~B.m.J. 221. o.

(14) ;. f'FJ:OJij~OOcm;8":Jff-¥iajm~' ~$~lI8t~IDII~M!fljWtH~rl§fI&~1lf8":JfD&ff-¥8":J~'~ft~~. $M~N~~ • • • M.8":J~~'.~A• •. .3(~R*. 0. (. J::t'im~5t~[I~. o. ~~J:)J:8":J:7Hfi '~.IDI[~$Uf:!Wnrtu.f'J:Xll~mtllJ. ,. , jEj(1fJ. E8J:)1±iI&mt:±~8":J~.IDII~i:&~Ef:til::.~.. '. '. ffflm"J8":JJjJ'l1.fE~. iIJ~~~:ff. J:Ff8":J1. :. .L-A~.ttc~8":JfD?ir.!~8":J[I~rm~. 1. gt.~~fE1:yj. 0. il&mtffiW.8":J~~ • • • ~".~~ • •Wg• • ~.I.I~o.~~,amtw~.fE~. ~f§li~". .IDII~J:.~f~£,~8":J:7}I. mllJ8":JfI.'fErp. IDII~fllJ. ' itJ1ltIDII*,* ' ".IDfI*'*fDg•• IDII~E8a}r-Ht1lf '. ~1j~W~f~. ~fDf:ya~"1;f:.. 0. m= '. , rp9C. fE~IDII8":J~~J:. 8":J;f§mm~rll~£'1j1f' J:).:r!. '. 11%1Z9.~.M.fD • • ~mJ:. '. ~~fE.&r.uf:!tf:lO~~.~:f1. f'~~-' ~~,~. ~.I%~J\ +[91;f:-t. 0. • • ~lH;ef*,~f,@~[I.I%~.8":J~~fE '. *$t~JJjU'!t:fffffoJ~~JE'11. '. fffl.J:)~;;EH1. ' ~OO. +-1:: ) ~:ram1iffi~i. ~~:ram1iffi8":JJ1lt~ B9.~~m. 0. IZ9llt '. ~iH~J:)n~flJ • •. ~.~IU~~-:f1 r. (mtiEl8":J). specific) 8":J~fj~W*J!~. , ,. '. El8":J.~~tif~~~.:~nilJfp:l-~~M\. @~ , El3~~JE~.8":J~lIJ.lm~Jil:ffg~F~~JE. ht~lIJ~~m~~fj~~!k- • • g~F~1J1~• •fI~ff-¥. .gt£'~lHtt~F~;ttftgg~F~gt. Jj]fj~ , £,~j1W~.IDII~. 0. mfE J. '. lltff-¥flJj:X.1:YOOfj".IDII~r,,:mj!Jj. ~.f*~~ (~.mWJ) ~\PJMft. '. 0. IZ9llt '. '. '. {~~. (Sector. 1i1j8":J:7}~c~~tf. .~~~If1'IJfll¥. 2.mWJ~i*li. gt.~~fEfI. gt.~~fEtlX~f1J;tt. .JilGgt.3(~m~::tf~J:)~;tt. f1'8":J~$. 0. fffl4' '. jJfD~1j8":J*:fi~. :r}jo gt.~~fEgt~11%~lIJjJf~fi!!ntif~~ft. '. f,@~~:J;t!f~~lIJjJjjji'!c8":J-:raIfF. 0. ~~gt. .fP~rp~fi1m7~~ft8":JfI11~. , gt.~fE~~AjJ3(fI (relocation) fD~M\8":Jtif~ , ~¥[[tbb. WJ.&~.8":JEl.o. '~.mfElZ911%.~ff-¥MmEfD~fiW• •m.8":Jm~'fEI. ~11. 0. tf J. M:'l ' gt.ij 8":J~"tirp. 0. 3. gt.~~fE~. gt.~~~~{I~;ijJilG[I*AjJ~~a~. ::tfIJm$~~.~. El.8":J~~~-,£~~~.mJ1lt.Wtl~fDm8":J.~n$o~~~,mW~[lfj~~.~. .~fEfI.*fJ~~. f1'miIJ8":J~fj~B~~'§ft¥U~1!. fE~~*flWti~8":J.:r~. 0. (. ). i!frtlDllt '. , :;1ftff~~.~~fEW~.f*~~fD~.IDII~If1'1JDJ:1Mft '. .JilGfjl~8":J~ ~. + [!9 : f'J iI&!fJC ~. ~-r1i.. t,_ : Johnson,. George E. 1983. "Potentials of Labor Market Policy: A View from the Eighties." Industrial Relations ;l2(2):284~289. .. 222. :. ~+t\:. ~+-I::. [!9. : JfiJl\fli~ ,.

(15) .&~~~.~$a~. .. :ft~~ '~Jff. ~t~~a*. 0. ••~~M~~W.. (iff+[l3). .l:t\m~7t~~*lt1nit~~Ii1~~m~itJljJttr-J;IiJl.lJ'. :tE1n :. ifJBAJ.Jfff~.J;J rtr-J~9(. tr-J~~1m~o. (iffi--li). ~~fJ~Jrit~R~~If'Ftr-Jm. :. 1. it ~RIi1~fT~m~H;*f*5}it'l:lfjU. ' 7ffj $::k:M*&it~~~lHff1~- , $ ::k:~jt!r15;t Frmg. Jff~1f:~tE.. 7f:f§1I~1B. '. tt1fj:~~f~. mlJJtr-J~.. ' tE$::k:M*&gt1:Q.t5fT~~~ I~ ~ fl.~IDII**r.u ' fT~~~lf;j';l~'§':H-.-m~~ f!l. •. fl~rr~~~~.~~~flo(iff+A)~ft;t~tEit~~~If'Ftr-JmIJJL'B~itflID~ •. D~~~.m. fl7f~-. ,. $::k:it~~~~~.:Mz7fmrtfH~11li1~:nTi~:f;tlr15gt~R~~~.. ~jU!~;:ill~ij7jttHttr-JPJ~~~9(. 1n~~J\ +gg~{:;~. iltjij'!1 '. ~OO. +-t). ~lJim1lffi~OO;fifPJ:if~~~~1!iil&m:f§H. ~iti~~m1lffitr-J~~~D1oJ. ;t~ij~. j(7jtr-J5}~c~j:mffB. 1l!~. ~JE (Sector. '. '. '. '. ~n. ••tEtE~-lJigt~Ji~If'F ' 3-J!tl.11tr-JIIiUlIJ. 0. 0. 0. '. (. ~117f. 't7ffjlt1n~Jff. J!lt~F~~~~fl£~J!ltr-J*:t~:·1tlr~~IDI1lG7f0WJl)ttJl 0. f'F. ~~W!f~~fT~~~~.-m~~~fI~JE. 'tAm1!.'tB;li:lB1I;&:it~~1i1~0ZP:'11. ~~Ii1~If'F1HItr-J7f1jl;-JJ!~~:±~J!tl.S3. ,it~~~~. ~j~O. g(.gt~~~ I. E3 ~ , It:i!&~:J)i:A~~~ntf~j:~tr-J~~f'l*~Jff~~P.~fm*l1r. ~f.~r~Yimf;!:!;. ,. 0. 0. 0. 9'C:jtlZSJ ' it. •. 2.t~WJmtk~~~I~it~~~~If'Ftr-J-~f5J' ffii9i-R~Itr-J51~~m~~~~Itr-J15. ~~~ *iX ~11li:jt. 1t;t-. ~:t~.J;);~:jt. f'Ftr-J~$offii~'~9i-R~IWJ!tl.;IiJlJE.1nit~~~• • ~Jt;t~'M~Lit~m.~.A. ~ft, it~~Ii1~If'FWj}R~I51~1'f:jtIMd~' ill.~j}R~I51~7f~it~~Ii1~I. }]~ij~tr-J*:fi:J)i:A~U7}R~ I. If'Fo£1nit. !Ji. '~~Ut~. **. if;!:!;. 0. Y:J~~itJlJ. ' tEI. 0. J. ~*. '. WJ!tl.If'F L '. f~~7i-R~ I"iJ!tl.fPJ:if B*.i!~f.Sgt~RIi1~tr-Jm. gt~~~.If'FfltlJJtr-Jfl7t~Ff,.~UmffB. tr-J1ii~Ji$. ' ~Jfftr-Jit~~Ii1.~m-tBJ@A r J~Aflt7f Jt. 0. 3. it~~Ii1.~.~*7f~. 0. S3~ 6. tr-Jij*4Am5F '. J!l~*7f~iti~1'f~*.it~*~1'f~*. A.}]~1!i~m. ::t~lJffl*mg~7fr.u. ~lt1nit~~. ~~Ii1.~.*fij~fJt~f;£$~fr~ijYimf:Jt~If'Ftr-JmliJ1'fH. '. gt~~Ii1~~.tr-J~n~g1!.'t:Mz*1t:f5J~11li 0. 0. ITfi~~:jt$~lZSJ. 'I'1!.'t '. *.~W*:t~*~tr-J. J\J~~~tr-Jit. m the. iff+[l3:fia~.M.m ••• '~-t+*'. fi+f". : lQJiff-[ill '1':[39-87 : [l3 , 159. •• M.M.$•• m.Z&.'·-D. 0. 0. fi+-t:.fr.'A+[ill.~R+AB' r.fi.*~~ff.afiMM*.J '~+Ao. 223. ' fht:ifWit.

(16) ~lIi;m~I~~~IZSI*. 1Rl{*¥Hr,t~iU~ffi~fr!'ttl~:r}JWN. '. ; f.§.~. EE~:rxl@ E. , ~ZP:~:§i@j:llB5}Z::::+. rn!'ttl*~~~IZSI~r~A~~J@~$~~I~~~~,~~mffi~.~~~~~~!'ttl~~. g~:§ ~!'ttl IZSI JJ! ~. ~N~~'~~A~~o~~'ZP:~ili:§~:llmB5}z+li!'ttl*.~~IZSI~r~I~~*J. W. ~ ~~Jl.f&Ej. '. ~f'f~{~Aj. ~&lliB5}z~I'ttl*.~.IZSI~r~~fi.~.~J '@~$~m~r,t~m.~.!'ttl • •. !IJJ '. ~. :r}Jg~Wfilfg. , ~~~litffi~.!'ttl~~~litffi:r}Jf'f~ift~JIAIl~fII. «6. 0. • • ±th 00i ~ ~. (tl+!\). m~UilJ 7i: ~. iM. Hi f1H1!i5~. :;J(_Afx :;J(::tAfx. ~!HG. ~!HG. Y:tifU.t~. Afx. 1i5&:;J(_ 1i5&:;J( i,t~$. 1?. , ~). "~WII~:1l. YltiL:A'%. ,q zm. 0. f1jffl$. J: 'BJ~{:it '. ~~. ~WJ*i1j. fJH. 0. 1981. 197,466. 317,264. 113,666. 57.56. 35.83. 1982. 230,516. 272,366. 1I2,667. 48.88. 41. 37. 1983. 234,038. 370,642. 121,891. 52.08. 32.89. ;mr,t~WII~1:t,. 1984. 241,939 I 389,774. 121,919. 50.39. 31.28. ~~!IJJ~~$~. 1985. 291, 177. 272,068. '111,690. 38.36. 41. 05. 7i@~.J. 1986. 265,604. 452,416. 1I8,949. 47.78. 26.29. .mWJ~$. 1987. 208,508. 560,547. 111,315. 53.39. 19.86. ~, ~f1X$~i. 1988. 202,981. 583,175. 1l2,320. 55.34. 19.26. ~, ~Wti~1. 1989. 167,696. 483,428. 90,119. 53.74. 18.64. 1990. 185,589. 509,393. 91,839. 49.49. 18.03. 1991. 195,337. 563,632. 102,660. 52.56. ~. 173,974. 559,635. ,174. 44.36. 13.. 1993. 144,960. 511,388. 70,390. 48.56. 13.76. 1994. l.Jv,u50. 410,099. 73,099. 53.42. 17.82. 1995. 165,034. 352,227. 682,557. 41. 54. 19.46. !. ~!'ttl~D1I:f';HfH. ~5t"~WII~E. ~f:!i'd~:fEfJi fr ~. §iW:rxl@t t:it1f::f~!'ttl1tX ~. Ji*4*i1lli : 1jj!)(I~H~' I~ ~ lUiaJ' 1996 ' cjJ1iRIIII.itMili ~iI.J~\IT,q ~. , ]if 162-163. I'ttls. §iW!'ttl9HIif¥J,. 0. no J:; :fEnDA t!t w.. r{ff'UJ '. ) ,]if 28- 31. - 224. 0. *. J.

(17) w~ El EB1t5&lf~cp~~&it~~il!I/iIJf:{ty;]f)Jml. JflMi;jj "EHt z'::: +. .. ~~a~§~~.~~ • •M~~m~.~fik#~.k~~.~'. • •Ji.aM~~. ~~WmfJt#HfJ~~. ~5fl~~~JJ!$~"1J[[At!:!:WW~m.tt~.fO • • ~.~fjj~' ffi!Imi~Jd~~ a~1J[[At!:!: ~\. ~. ww~m• •~.~ • •AD.ft'~.~.m~~.~@i'~fl.~ • • • • I~~m. r 1mIf'F~tt J •. ~JIU~~.~Ji~. 0. IJJ '. :tjj5~A1JWi1*~~.rl3'.flJf$". ht~. 0. , ;ltcp , • •~"'~.~~f*~~t!?Aff.)t7J~.m:·J!. ~• • ~@o~@'~mfi• •~~a~~.~~M~T'A1JWi1*~~.~~8q~~.. , ~AJf~. JlRflJ;1G~. 0. .!¥.roJl~~~ • • roll~~.¥lJ$J!fJtf#. , ... %. 0. ~ • • wJl~~.PfTfJtf#~roll~. ,. teJ~~roll~.m. *.83. kPJ:rJiHtl: '. l!t~PJfJtf#5lrollft@~z5lrollt$~6. fml'lJJ*i1*. :fJU=r~3::J!~Ui-~,[fjfJtf#~fml'lJJ1JJ.t. . 37. *~.~tt • • ~$.W."'. .89. f[] • • roll~1:il5fml'lJJiifirf!l. .28. .#IJJ¥~$~+-j'*. . 05. ~@PI~J ~#lJJft~fj~II5~~$W.zii'i1ll (J!~1JJ¥~$~+1\1,*) , tB.~~ft~ •. .29. ~l'lJJ1t$nZJ!~o. .86. ~. .26. If.¥ . . *.'11~MJE'I1I f'Fz ~1JJ~~~.~rl3j , 1m$:f.tH.~.fml'lJJ1t$~ff¥lJ$$:rlHf::\. *1'. '*". .64. 0. ... 0. {§~~¥*1:tl5pMI~iiJE.k. '. ,. ~+ =j,*~~+[qf'*JiJTmJE~ti~.1:. 0. ~.fml'lJJ. '. ' Il?f,~F;lt~5lii~rl3'~. ~f!IJ~. r JE~#IJJ~~~. Jjj{~~~#IJJ¥~$tt~ill@~lJJft~f*~~JE.zi'&. ... lJi '. ',.. .76. fEj1l;ltE~. ,~~,*.tt~MJEttI~Z#lJJft~~~~ii@PI.ft. , .~¥*W.~f!IJ~~ J! '. .79. .~PfT~~~.fml'lJJ1tjfjUgr. tt~~lJJft tJJE~~~.3::~ti75t. l!t~~fljJ5l~JW. ~f*~~mfi• • ~~~grCPtB.~~~• •m• •. . 21. '. • • ~.~~~I'®fml'lJJ~1JJ.tflr~I~.J~~.t$M. fl5lq.wfl~~~~tB[ZSI@5lj!U~". .03. '. ~.:J:. -i:~. 0. ~WPfT&. 0. f!i£~~. ' ill@#lJJftz• •fl. o. mlJr- ~~:. "'p t1""'1 ~, ~ ,:I.. ~. .82 §~a~~zp~~pfT1~BjflH?9. .46. *~U~~.~#*~~t.. J*1t~t Fl. i=~). ' ~0:7C 2000. §~~:9j.IlI:f¥gBJEIHif!l900 f!~:7C. ~.1J. 'Jf 28-31. 0. '. 11,300. ' '. 1,000 f!~:7C '. 7 %fOAo. a~~zp~~~JiJTft~~j!U 17,000~:7C. '. 1JDk**tl'Ugr.~~PJ#~'11. tJ~if:~~.Jf~.$ 6 %~. 0. : @a~. a~§~1tW~~. ~t4lIX~~3::.~.B~~~~a~JIJ.B~.~.. *~~At!:!:w.~m.z.,a~M~OOB~.~.~.J.t'. 225. 0. *. • • -~.*~~m.&.~.

(18) ~lIm. 0. mtimliffijf~lllif' ~~itlIDEJEBftjf~l'Y:Jf'F$. t~.ii1:f§'ilD~zfjJ.. , "~Jj~rg.ii~. 'mla~~W~mtnp. 0. ~~~.lIDOO.Z • •l'Y:J• • ~.nWi,~nEB~• •z. • • ~lIDa~ • • ".~. '~M~l'Y:J • • ~'~.'~'~.z~~~~Mmo~§M~~-B~Z.'~'~~ l'Y:J.~ADct:r. , ffHt5"~I23~.~tfm~n~jpJf~~W~~ili*:I:~n '. mJ!t;~.AD~~Wjff~. Hufbauer, Gary and. Econon. lIDa~~o~~'~~'I23~.ii.~.m~~~'~~~~l'Y:J.ii~~~~~ • • .ii~M~ili 1't:J~_n. 0. m.~"~I't:JM~:ff~.'.&~_nMf!(~I't:J~JJJ. ~~.'l':E~.l'Y:Jfb~~. 0. ~aw~. ,. I23Jft '. '. s~1j. , .ii~~.~~ill~fj~~. I. ~. Grahl, John. Markel Jj~flJl"~I't:J~I. it&J(;J~\~JHff;iH~\Jll'Y:J$iti~. '. , fEIfBlI't:Jf!(~ ,. .~. Johnson,. Geor~. ' {§~Im~M. Eightic. h'~hfD.~m.mfll'Y:J.~'~I"~~~7f' • • • ~Ql'Y:J'M~~~.~~.l'Y:J~. Li, Ping-Chen. fD"~roll~t!z.~m+7tmJl. ~. 0. .~:ttfj~7f'JEl'Y:J~Ini1flj" • • ~~~'Jll'Y:J. , it&J(;J~~!JtlE.$"~l'Y:J~I~Ij~'~~.1iffirmft.s.~~'l':Eit&m. Irnpacl. 0. Jft~'lIDJj• • ~.I't:J~~W~~'~.~M~.~n~~.~~o~Jft,it&J(;J~~~. f'F~~fDI f'F:ttfj~~:tmtJIDlil1t¥U. Penns:. , ~~"~&~=W~roll~I't:J~~ M:ttl'Y:JIDt ' it&JffW~w.l'Y:JliJf~*~1it~ml't:J~~a ' it. Shoven, J .B. ,. ~.tbhWJI .~1j*mml't:J~1t. ~. Unpub. '. ~~~II't:Jf!(~~:ft. 'I. 0. ]'iJT. CarnbJ. tJ ' it&J(;Jffi~itiLWI .l'Y:J~~~jj1f~ , Jj~~*fjJ• .ii~ffi*~7~\Jll'Y:J.~ , ~OJft::tfj~. Thorn, Grahan. lID'l':EI't:JIl~. , Jj~~OO1j. '.~~Ji~I't:J:tkl5t. ~1~Jj.ii~Ah~71jl't:JfjJ.. mlWiz. '. 1IfE~~~I.illt;tfjMOi:A$~fDlllW¥. Relati. 0. 'An~71j~.~1j~rJ1I't:J~"f*,.ZP:1it, m.~'iI~"~~I~~\@;f~II1:m. W1:~tl'Y:J.$*l~. , ~ljmU?~~-f47f'lE1itl'Y:J:m~. o.~. • Jj~mffj~*l'Y:J~~f/;}.~J!CJ!. ~~Rmi:l.j!!rrilitB~.1iffi~~fmWJi1E:itIJ~. 1jit&llJG~ I~ j. fiit&IlJG~I~ J. • ~IJ7f'~fI~ fl1f. 1jit&IlJG*~~it~. • B.1jZ~~ • {§~lID~m~ftW EJ EBftl'Y:JOO. fiit& 1lJG~J!~it ~. ~ , ;!tt~;j';g:fr • m.~Jj~~"~.~.l'Y:J~I*~7&:\JlI't:J~~-.tl'Y:JtbhWJ. • '. 0. ijjU~mmJlJillffift€~~fDMII.Il'Y:Jff3~~~. 0. 0. :;lt~ , ~~f:~J~itIJ~l'Y:J$ijjgftt!zJJ!~~mlfj. WfAfil't:J15~o. Il**tt • RJ\ Il*lI!@1Mi ' RJ\ 6. - 226 --. 0.

(19) w~ EI m1t~~~ r:pfjt~mUt~::?ti!lfJfl(fJf)ll~ ... ~ftI~~~~~If.n=p. ~. ~. X III. .~*~"*rl'l~. fzll' m' tj(~. Hufbauer. Gary Clyde & Schott, Jeffrey J. 1992. North American Free Trade: Issues. 'tlJA [] tE~WJM~. and. :~*T~t~*PJT. tJj. Economics).. J14~lHJYi1Jtfg~. Imle9~~. ,_*. (Washington,. DC:. Institute. for. International. Grahl, John & Teague, Paul. 1992. "Integration Theory and European Labour Markets." British Journal of Industrial Relations. 30(4):515-527. Johnson, George E. 1983. "Potentials of Labor Market Policy: A View from the. e9'ffi~f:flI~M ij!f!~ ~* e9rl'l~. Recommendations.. Eighties." Industrial Relations 22(2):283-297 Li, Ping-Cheng. 1994. Environmental Policy, Coal, and the Macroeconomy:· The. Impact. of. Air. Quality. Regulations. on. the. Pennsylvania. Economy.. JIt ' i&Jffi1J V).~. Unpublished Ph. D. Dissertation, Department of Mineral Economics, The. ffg~1:mV)'~fE9tl. Pennsylvania State University State Colleeg, PA.. me9~~ftI,~. ~tifD~W¥. Mi~. 0. Shoven, J.B. and Whalley J. 1994. Applying General Equilibrium. (New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.). pJT. , tlaJlt::tff~. Thom, Graham. 1992. "The Single European Market and Labour Mobility." Industrial Relations Journal. 23(1):14-25.. ='. 1Ti&~~ I~ ~ fUiEn. :if.';j'1Ii~~t:~. 1Ti&~~I~ jhrtKlEn' 1994 • .p~~~ii.:tt!!TK~tlJ*1t:iIT fH~. l'~tlw€oli1ll. 1Ti&~~~ij!~~~it. '. ~-f::;+1\ ' ~**6~$,~.pm:*n~~Za)(~. !::W § E13fte9fJi. 1Ti&~~~~ij!~~ ~ it. '. ~J\. ttP.~~~mllJ. 1l*7.k11 '. ~J\. Il*lI-H9J '. ~J\. 6 Vf¥~'". '. ~J\. +. iI~'~~Ll5Em. iitJt:l~!rlil~tlJ*1t:iIT!¥1i. 0. 0. 0. +::::::. ' .p~~~IE.:tt!!TKm:*rP~~¥~ ( ~=~). 0. +_,. r :1E:*J7;j.*roll~e9;f§IUd~f1jWiim J 'm:*Wrolj~,. +::::::.'. r 1itwj:lttlJfXffg~5EW~mffilJ,t@:e9iri&mm1i1!i J. 'm:*Wroll~,]t 3. ~~m!:i:~~lWiai&mii.tJtz~~ia.fPf~. , r~¥I::k~~**~~titf. 5-11. 0. 0. ' ~~ 84 !¥ '. - 227.

(20) XD 15~r~IlU. S.I.T.C.~~. K. L (01)11 (02) iii. *-. 232,245,246,247,291,292,941. PYA AP. 271,274,277 ,278,281,286,287,289,322,323,333,667. P. 001,041,042,043,044,045,046,047,054,057,075,222,223. *-. (03) i'i1i ij[ ill 0 ~ ~;$i. 244,248,261,263,264,265,266,267,268,269,288,289,582 583,584,585,611,612,613,633,634,635,651,652,653,654 655,656,657,658,689,677,681,682,683,684,685,686,687 689,691,692,693,694,695,696,697,699,716,722,752,761 762,763,764,771,772,773,77 4, 775, 776, 778,812,821,831 842,843,844,845,846,847,848,851,871,872,873,874 882,883,884,885,893,894,895,896,897,898,899,961,971. IlJi 0 ~. *-. 233,282,335,424,431,511,512,513,514,515,516,522,523 524,531,532,533,541,551,553,554,562,572,591,592 598,621,625,628,671,672,673,674,675,676,678,679. (05)Ji 0. illl. ~~. (06)1~ Il 'fi ~ ~. (07)'fi. *-. *. ttJH~*. (08)~FW ~'t'':EJH~*. 711 ,712,713,714,718,721,722,723,724,725,726,727,728 736,737,741,742,743,744,745,749,751,759,781,782,783 784,785,786,791,792,793,881,951. 'fi~[. X. M. XS PM EXR PXS E. PE PXD il/5;J< Z. 011,012,014,022,023,024,025,034,035,036,037,048,056 058,061,062,071,072,073,074,081,091,098, 111,112,121. CD. 122,211,212,251,334,335,341,411,423,424,592,641,642. GD. 661,662,663,664,665,666,892. GOTI. 911,931. Y. DST FXD. INY. PK OK.

(21) •• 8~~~m$a~ ••~~.~~w• ~= -11. .. 1J'lit$*~IDlt·tr-J~.. 0. fl'i~(indices). ( p;fj ~}JU ). ij. .il.t1.}J~. k. J!~~JdK,. L}. ['31:~~. 1:.il.t1oo XD. 3. .il.t1.}JIJii*J!~m*. L. .il.t1.}JU~IbJ!~iI*. PVA. ~ 11ft 11D fW 1iR. AP. 1:.il.t1J!~~fW#i( K, L}. P. tf,3p;fj~~fJ#i. • • 00. 7. {$r~5}m. ~.il.t1~f#~. K. X. tf,3p;fj~#t~. M. :lito. XS PM EXR PXS. ~.il.t1~~I"l#t~ :litO~Z~l"lfJ#i. I!i$ ~.il.t1~1"l~1I~. E. Iflo. PE PXO. IflO~Z~l"lfJ~ ~1"l1:. m*oo. '. 1Ift~. Z. $ra1m*. CD. ~Mfl1lft. fJ~. Y. ~Mrtf1~. GO. i&Jf,ffl1lft. GDTOT. i&Jf,f~Y:1fl. DST. .il.t1.}JU :a'~ii IiID ~ii. FXDINV INVEST. .~. PK. 1iID:iE~j(fJ#i. OK. ~ § ~$r~*~IiID:iE~ii. 229.

(22) ID. at. J&J...JID YINSTK GTENT. 8 ~. :$:. ENTTA\. iE5U/1 f;j ~103 jJ:: * B"J fjt J&. ENTSA\. jJ::*~1i. DEPREe. ~ ii :$: If''H.f 41 Wi. YINSTL SSTAX HHT. */i'HH'. rt. 3t 1t. a. ~*fJJPfi1~. sd. :t± \t if: fjt l& 1M f;j at fjf) r~ Z tH' 3t it. ht. RE~llT. [@ 7~. gs. GR. l&1MJ&J.... dst. HRIFF. I01fQ. ks. INDTAX HHTAX NETSUB. rfl'~fjt. mt. Pfi 1~fjt. 1&;. ~rPmi. tBOfiUIj. dr. FBOR. ~7H1!i ArPmi. sI. HHSAV GOVSAV FSAV. ~. et r. l&1M~1i. Ix [@ 9~iili. SAVINGS. ~. G"JP\.~. ~§[@~Pfi~. RGN P. [@~IM~. PINDEX 7~. fO~d'~ ~. 4: ad. esr. *fl. Pfi 1~ zp ~ f§ fl. [@. - ,. ~~fl(t'.lf$fJJ*fl ~~UBtfj~fl. rd. XD. .4: jf€ rn fl Z fl!l fl. fds. ~*lJH~WZPi$J. ~~lfrmf~. ~lID. ac rc. pllm 1m. ~iliii:. 1li:m~~BI¥J~. ;i1!O~flZf$fJJ~fl. ;i1!ornflZJ!*iBmi ;i1!ornflZf§fl ;i1! 0 £ Z [@ ~ 11 t1i BmfQfjt$. - 230. fl.

(23) •• e~~~N~fi~ •• ~~M~~W. ~.. teo. e. teDmg~::'~*171m/~~. ~JfJ~~. rt. teDmg~Zflil~. pIle. teo Z~I~H.~ teDfiUs$. te. *00. ,. it. It. at. tef~~. a. f:G:. sd ms. ffjjf171m/ ~1lf* pfTflHilm* il3I:}(;J)t te 171m/ ~ f:G: 'jj WI¥J P3 ~ iI z it f91J e i!ill $ r~ !!1l )E f:G: 'jj Z 171 m/. *. ht. gs ds t. **. ks. *~Jl$J€1\!I!. mt. i&A.IID. - ,. dr. tJT1i$. st. f±@'~~mm$. et r. 1t:.m. tx. ra'~m. esr. 1t:.~1lf*. ~~miJJ,~it. ~~ifl¥J~~IHij~.L-)' CES ~~j?gf(1JOj:J~~ :. XD. _. J. -. -rdJ. ad}ojkj. -I'd} -/ rd}. + (l-o)L j. _. ,k - K,L. ~17g.imf~jlH5'JJ&jf*lltfilYtI~~~~*~~im£ 1Jl~~~~l¥Jjf~~fmI. AP kj. 0. (3.1). ~~~;PI¥J*5*f~1~~~~~1¥J. :. PVA j '. Ok) .. XDj JPI kj ,k == K,L. ~OO:itT:Xl.im~fiflJfl\ji&*ftl¥J*5*. 0. (3.3). 007JU~~JiJTf>jz~~~~l¥Jfl~ APKj W*~~. - 231 .

(24) k. Ids J. AP kJ. .. APk. '. ( 3.3). k = K,L. f~1f( fds ~ ft~!Y:I~EEW-~ItHi~BU1tJj*~l!I!!j!!f'I1~:WpJT5 [j{QZ$r'ra'x{"11fl~L.. ~~¥PJTfl!Y:I~~:tffOm.:tf~~9Hi:il1:rW ~. , ftfr'j~~~~6bfO:il(]6bZra'~~F%~~ft6b '. CES ~If(~.ffij~. X·J. M-~. , IZSIJltW ~ ntj~fI~mW-W ~ 00 0ltW ffij~~:W'I1!Y:1~6b (i~Jm~~ffi. m~L.11~. &:il(J6b Mj m. fi~j;)Ili~. Z~ Armington ~~) IZSIJlt~-g.r:fi6b{tt:*'ft (r:fi6b~m.) ~EE~~6b Xj. : .re]. ac J 6 J M J.. -rei -l/re}. + ( 1-6 J )XS ). 1ZSI~ • •~-lI/J\m!ffijmlDX!Y:I~~a Z~~jJ ,. ~ljmW-l!IJp ~:. !Y:I~:W0. :il(Jffij~. ltW-1:f:. (3.4). ' • •~~flI3W:il(J 6btEi!tWm*~L.1fl~ pwmj. IZSIffij pwmj m9i-~~~ 0 :il(J6btE~J19Z11~~W-:il(J6b!Y:Ii!tW11~1JOL.~mfi~j;). ~$:. (3_5 ). IZSIm.6bm• • • ~W-lt~~6b!Y:Im • •~L.lt:il(]6b!Y:Im • •. 'M~.-g..6b1fl~. ( m.6b!Y:Izp:~11~ ) m : (3.6) Jlt9i-,m.:tf~.~~6b&:il(J6bm.ft~'~~.m• • fi.*~~oftfr'j~~~. iI~~fjl~tlr,zntj~. M ). = XS·. J. : 6. PXS. [ 1-6. PM. ) J. ,I. J. J. 1. -U}. (3.7 ). .. , fI- '".

(25) .a~~tt.m$am. ••~~.~~m. ~. :JtcP , (3.3 ) .$r'ra'~f1f.~L.. (I. 1. . .. - - ,mM. W XS . l+rc.J J .. j. zflR~'1i. 0. '~1M~~~~~*~~~fI~.tt~~':Jt~z-m~tI1O'W~-fI. lt~tI1o ~lJm~~~m.. 0. ~JLt. ~~~~ XDj ~Etll±lo Ej &~~m. XSj. '. ,ffl CET fijIUI.W. /iX: .. XD I· = atO 1 E IrlI +(1-0 I )XS Im. .J. (3.8). I"I}. • m~W~oo°lt~ ~6b (~flfflU~~. Cj l?dl 0. 6b Mj m. ~mD:ilflt~OOi!t~mr~J!-OO/J\~!H¥Jf~t;!fe. M-;j{ifu '. iP~L.{.~ pwei ~~~jJ f&~P)IIi$. iP*lL.fIi~ pwmj. tI106b1£~~Ztl10$~{.~~tI106b~i!t~{.~iJOL.tI10*'tiQ6Z. pwe i (l+te i. ) .. (3.9 ). J::XR. ~m~6b~~fmI~~Em~~~m.~tQJi'iJoL.tI10~f.{mI. '. JiJTP)~~~6b~~~=l"f.. ~m:. r.~iJOL.nm~p). PXC j. (PE j ' E j +PXS i. ::;::. (3.10). XS i )/XD j. '. :6:1& • ~~=l"blCl:E~~~~mfJi6b&tI106b~.l:tf9ljp);~<Jr~:6:*flJfiJ (3.5). Ei. ~ XSi [. (3.6). :ttlfl' 0. 0. ~1MCJP)1~~Umi,@. ~fI:f*i71~jJ~A:. IT P)** tt fJi 6bf.~. E.. E:Md~fl~.tI106b1£i!t~. :. Pi:; i (3.4 ). 0. '. 'i. P'E j PXS,. 'Ii. (3.11). 1. 1 '1I. j. ~1MCJj..~~f3. =,. 1-8 i. l-rt. Ei. WXS. i. z1fl~~tt. 0. i. ~*h~~~. (3.7) 1I*CJii:itmcpra'1I*&:6:~m.. '. cpra'1I*~m*JfJm~ (Leontief) fli]l:E~A~~~. - 233 .

(26) Z ij. (3.12). = a ij XD ij. :iU~~.:X: EJ31t-$"Wl7}~*~t~. f~ftj:*~~. '. i&Jf-J~.&~~~*. , li:N~~cptlemQf~i¥J~'Ii~.ftUJ!t (LES). *~~. 0. *~~.~m~},llft7d~. Y1. : (3.13 ). GD i = gSi . GDTOT. (3.14). ~~~*§ffiff~~liJ&fg]5E~~. 0. fJt1r1W~fil:lIJ1;ij6'bi¥Jff~~liJ~llt~6'b~.ff:(£fg]5E. Y. ttf91Jmmf* : DST i = dst i. .. (3.15). XDi. G 8. FSDINV. PKjDKj. =. =. INVEST - L DST. P. (3.16). ksjFXDINV. (3.17). D. (3.18). S. i. I. I. 8. PK j = L Pimt i. ,. 8. 1Di =,£mt ij DK j. (3.19 ). J. - 234 .

(27) .a~~~~m*a~.~~~. rzg -, plf ~~ (3.12) ~ffl~FIHljdt. ••. ~w.. n ,I it. ~.M~.ji*~A~~aR~~.®.M.*0~m'0~~~&.*~.:. YINSTK. [#APkjKj. + GTENT - ENTTAX. ]. ENTSAV - DEPREC (3.20). (S.13) •. *~M~.~ji~A.*tl.~~~ili: 8. E. RINSTL. (3.21 ). APljLj - SSTAX. j. (3.14) itJ~:It#:(£~7E. *~+Pfi1~.~.Pfir~&*ltJpfT1*tJD~i&R.M~f11ijtJD~9i-~ ••'. :. Y = YINSTK + YINSTL + HHT + REMIT. (3.22). aR~A±~~*~~m~&~9i-m~:. (3.15) GR = TARIFF + INDTAX + ENTTAX + HHTAX - NETSUB. + FOB· (3.16). (3.23 ). EXR. :(£~~ZM1*n~~~®~~~7E.~T:. ~.®.*~1i7E~.: 8. (3.17). t±.~~~ili.. (3.18) ~ji~*. :. (3.19). Ej. DEPREC. (3.24). dr PK. K· J. J. J. :. SSATAX. st [. ~ API) Lj. (3.25). ~.m.:. ENTTAX. =. etr[ ~. APkj Kj + GTENT. - 235. 1. (3.26).

(28) 8. INDTAX ==. l:. (3.27). txjPXDjXD j. j. RGA HHTAX. = ht·. TARIFF. = [. j. J. j. PIN. ] EXR. (3.30 ). :. ~,1HFf~~1J. ENTTSAV. HHSAV ftl~. (3.29). EtmjpwmM. ] EXR. =[ ~ te,pwe/::.;i. NETSUB j£~mrff~. (3.28). Y. =. esr[. = ms . Y. ~APkjKj. + Gtent - ENTTAX -Dt;PREC. th). (1. (3.31). ~~~a'9~. (3.32) X. , JtftBf§IUda'91r~:i'\5E.~D-r :. I. @.filim: SAVINGS. ENTSAV. + DEPREC + HHSAV + GOVSAV. + FSAV • EXR. GR (3.33 ) 8. 8. GNPVA. E ( APkjKj. + APlfl1~IFF + INDTAX - NEATSUB. J. - 236 -. l:j.

(29) •• g~~~N~am ••~~.~~m •. . ,. (3.34) (3.27). .Jt~B!;M14;~: 8. 8. RGNP==L;(CDi+GDi+IDi+DSTj. ). +L:(1-z-e i. ). (3.28). Ej. ). I. 8. L:(1-z-m) M ) ). (3.35). ,. ). •. fJi~:t~~~~~. :. (3.29). PINDEX. ( 3.30). ==. GNPVA/PGNP. (3.36). 11. ' ftlHZftii1.nlit. ••~~nm~~-~~~~~.~m~~~~m~~o~fl~T~OOnm~: ,. ]. ( 3.31). §:'P.I~~~~~: 8. Cj + XDj L: aij Pj + tXjPXDjXD j . PXDjXDj. ( 3.37). J. (3.32). im~m~~~~: 8. "Z L. I) + CD I + GD I + ID I + DST I. XI. (3.38). ). il3<:J&J&x~~~: 8. GR. ==. E. Pi GD i + GTENT + HHT + GOVSAV . (3.33 ). 9}l!!m~~~~. :. 8. L: pwmjMj 4.TSUB. (3.39). ). 8. L: pweiEi +FSAV + REMIT + FBOR. ). ~.ftlt~~~~:. - 237. (3.40 ).

(30) INVEST. SAVINGS. (3.41). 8. E. KJ. =. K. (3.42). =. L. (3.43). J. 8. EJ. L. J. .a~M.~~-~~fi~A.~~~m~'~~.~~~m~~.§. 5o~ft'.~~~U.~~~'~~~.~H~*~.-~~. T (. •••®.§ffi. •• om~MM.~~.~. -): i&JfJ2P:.~. '.i:-:. :. 1Utlll. GDTOT. gdtot. (3.44 ). f,"{i:~. GTENT = glent. (3.45 ). III ' iiE.. HHT. = hht. (3.46 ). &t **!b7i FSAV = fsav REMIT FBOR. = remit. = fbor. (3.47 ). , -1ft. (3.48). l..JtJi.. (3.49). ;fl.t-~ JlE!~Jf.. PINDEX. pindex. (3.50 ). *. JlE! ~{.iJ. f*!b Xl. ary. 0.

(31)