國際政治與國內政治

全文

(1)'-. /. ....l'8".fi.. lS. 1. rmI~a~a'-!lI pqjfk~a .]f!W AI1;H~~ .... lil3.... 7lij·.t'la~'. ~litA~fjrlijfi~~*f3"" ~it".Mle". (. e~~,AJa~tmfl. ' tJ.ltjnJl.fJ(.~'¥i!! ! /f\IU!3p;j .. 1t~~Ii~ '7!liIi~afe • ~. JUltmlt ' f{tre*UiiJt.lll\tJEfi--mA:I(*::Pll9.lR~*-a .~~El1Jrr1i($fHt. •. 0. om-~~. •• ffl~.~~~'~~m~~~a~Q. ~rem!biiJ*jU.=M Q Il-.~.~B'ilmlb" .gu;O.pM&~A • •jilJ-1fC~. , .Til. *Mm!il~~-.±3;.~flQftf!fl~B9;f1j~1a'tt:mBiQ~~~Atm.'flJ'I!:J!:Z. ~A~.~;~.~~~~._~~~±i~~Z.MI.~Qg.A"~~~i~~*. ~):5.1h~ 0 .'::;'.:J!~fp~fi!ilb 0 fljaJ~IIII.Jlft1't~*J!~1IIl:@:I:!i.:r..f(~ ; Mm. !P1t...~ iQ* M"~it Jf.I ;·1&:1!:H fllJiE. MfiU II ; 1):1:. t£ mam ~rF' 0. ~fIi(s. ·1Il1l~iI~IVJ$!J,\~.IiIlf~ft.lJ;fU~ , ifiHtb fle'.vitffttf£ Q~jtliiJ flJ~lf.il~ffi.tm o~!It,. itftU-iJUIJ t ~JtU{ft:w: M=:.~I1H'~itfPB::m~it~m!lboflltltliWlIrdtz IIJ ' -iii~~~:nl'Jl• • •*ifj),'1t~ t -iii.~~if*BtJf~ • • 1JB9fd{:)~:b 0 ilff*~ .,.' _*IlU:l:itfli Ji1tjIUl§ml!l.·-lii#E-!ji-Jllfja:ij:.tJ.~ , §J -1Jili5{~:t'.Elll:~ T~MI• • '~~ll:~T• • MlSHom~:I:- • • • ~itfP.W~~.~o 0. (I. t:eJ::~al'BMI~fnla~ml1J ~ ~. o. ~mmMMf{re~MJtgJ .tr9~fnR. .71'* ' IIpgf{reJlI!tlJ lItR 7b~;SP~;fj' ft.'" *I '. ~i!!~ • •#1: . .. itfPM:1ilMitM:=tlmlto •. i'fii.1' ~ IUl rtf• • ~'-'RIiI.~jftJl!ill ~S(7ft ~*.J:rtiJ ~~ {JlJ:QI] ~I! ( F rood ch Schumann ) .~.A:e::IiI~iitl:* ' ~$ft.Jitt7ifjj • •~~JH!~!I9:f.Jit 1i'J~'fI1Z11tf». 0. Q. ~.'I'~IUf(JM(gj5J1M1J.' tt!.ILu:~*~It~Jii!iIt~J!ttfJ!$flj1lm.~ •• lulflJ~ MI~iU: 0 ~r1t,. il!IEijiiJi1iiU".... t-f~ " ~1ii ' 31Hlfiaremlt iiI.~Jtg.~,-,. 1J:I: '~.IiI~'f:J1..R:$ti-ev?H(~m~~ , ::tmJ~~~J~m.~IiI.*arsftll~d~~ . (~l) :tEt!~'3!(" II.ZJ::f4Itu~JMm.' RU~$JijiE.j!j_.mo (1t2 ) :1.j-&.IUlfrr&.:f.t&~( Hans Morgenthau) ~II.AiilP-Jit ..§!tAA,*.i1k. ag "'RHIJ"ag~. tEfRIMA.iiJMM.~-m~l:BSJ_ ' .~ifjj.JltfIJfti1'IUtl!!l 0. (I. Q. ,. ~.~iw.~ft*m~§!tagft*E1J*~.~~~~~.~~~.~~~~QWA Af'1i1·I'Ii.:tEfti1'~iEtB~B~.' 1li$*ilt{~tI. ' • •f!IIHl1J ° ~~ , Mf!{f!. 1t1: Frederick SchUll1a.Wl, Iot8x-natipnal Politics, 4th _ ed. (1948), p. 79. - . , ,. 1£'2: Frederl9k Schuma~,.Ip.ter.Dational Politics. 7th ed. (1969), p.148..

(2) 2. 1I,IIIIIIIm;IJ.U',:::1J:I. JlHIj] • m~Sl:If.Jj]It(tjJ5ai* ,.j]Jt;l)(tjJ1}• •'IIt$/J, ~JItzat • IlIpgfPZJS.i'l"UI ~ fIB~A'*'~fll:il:1!tJt!.faI* :~HtQ1!tW.ftIZJS./FIHI{li: ( I± ~ ) B1if(B9~U!lI~lU~#ltUtbwr C John F. Dulles) $tt;U.IIJ·.~JllIJpgSl:7EtB9~ IIiIIOJIJ flB3ifillJP3Sl:7EtA-mb·\Jj!{IIJIlSl:7Etm/FA;ffB9~. 'E11'l:l: :. Q. t. 0. Q. Q. 0. -"mP3~*A;ff&~~~*~.~.(tjJ~X~ftI/F~X~o. =". 1itm~IHI~. • IIJpg~*;ffSl:rti• • ( ~:il:~IUat). iiJtllnl!~. 0. ==,,!jJJP9futA;ff"~fI.Q. 1m. "Jj~l:i'j~M:.B9.YIM·t 1IJP9~iiJt{{t(~.l'*o. n"~P9n*;ff~~B9j].iiJtl~M.ft~.z~.~,&~JItiiJtl.mfi~z ~.o. ;1\" 1IJP3~*;ff~~ZWijflJti:Mli ' t.tQt.A~~mM • •Jtfiitlf.JtfiJ(tiJjuj] '.ft:A ~~~~W~~'.ft:ffl.j]Q(1±4). ,*it~.I! ,,~m~1i.tI:~~B9;fi~. , flBrJ.fillJ~A;ffJi*ft.iJSl:rB~.·' fI"lIP9. Sl:rti;ff• • t m.~ifi1t~*jd4l-~B9.1J. Q. m1itllAtttt.~lItlJ:B911J1t '.j!. lIm:.B9~II.ffi'~JitT.~*(.gl".ftB.(tjJJit\.·W~.fi;tIl1I1;ff._~mofi!i1. ~'IIJ~iiJ~ • • ~~~~~.~.~.~'fi1it.~.~iiJtlffSl:n~7tl.~t B;ff~~iiJtlm~~~~'IIJ~~"$;ff.m~~.~~(tjJ~1Jom~tlJ:~~ ·flBrJ.AIIJP9a7Ettttt:l:ftIZJS.B9".~B9Q. &~*ft. • tElIJlll*M41 • 1IJ~~.(tjJ • • /f'M. 0. -1IJ.·fi1}J!I!IE.~. , 73-liIiiJ. ~~fi$~~.o~.~*~~~~~'~iiJ~.~.IIJ • • A~• • Sl:Qfi!i1~·M*. ~.B9A~f..Q*:It5fitHMiIlJJt!.B9fct'1\.. ' mre.IIJ~~.~$IPfftE liI.tmfF~ff• • 0. ~tElIJ~~m.ZpgD~JIt'-lI.~Jlftl¥(tjJIiI.~W.~Il:il:o m~Sl:l'hJlIIJP9Sl:l'h.lll~;ffJ:~.~~~IIJj?IiI.itl'h:l::a-~m&W~a7Et.. :I:~~,,*~?~*arJff,MBR.,:arJ*B:mJ:fJt(tjJ.It~'.~:I:~ • •~".1i~· ~(tjJIIJP9Sl:rti~.~.~'. ,. • •~~B9I1J.Sl:7Et*.It~D • • J:'.=~1!tJt!.* • • ~ :::.+ ~1f: J;,{ * t1I1lJ:lZ5l ~.~aJi~ .It *f.*~ ;ff1lQ ~t£ " pi! r.:p :m:.~ ,~ ~f:I] li" EJitJJrJa ) .~, .lIfP.i$.j.~ " 4l~Jlf:l]Lft.'" § ftJ~~~ff(tjJ~.Je52ft1/{.. " lt52~~"~JItM- ·,fft.It.I!{iqJ~flJJl.~A~~lbJt!3 ma9i111J t ~fftttlZ5lta#1t. U~ES~.IfiiJjt1t " ffiolJl ,,± .Jt~.fii"Wirdl.1t1!ti "cJ:I;JtJlH1t1iililt• •. .... ~,. _ _ ,_-.r'........ -~.. '" . .. It 3: H~s Morgentbau, Politics Among Nations, 3rd ed. (1960) pp. 502-509. 1:1: 4: John F .Dulles, "The Institutionalizing 01 Peace, "~ess belore tbe 50th ~ual Meeting 01 tbe American Society 01 Internatio.aal Law, April 25, 1956 (Washi.octon, D. C., Department 01 State,Public Senies Division, Series S-No. 46, 1956 ),P. 3.. \.

(3) o.iJii ,jO~:'"Ua.~.tGPi8B.~' "~.f'q~. • rutt& iii. PI ftt& 3. ". IJ~. (ilflf) ~ BJS~m" .r~ . ".1iIiMwr" .BIt" ~.,ltIDi" eft ",~m" Je1mi2:JJl~ tlS1t;till::ktGi1'lSBfIJ.. • iJiim:~IiI. ' _WHM."mgH$II.1tIUI~• •Sc.Jil.lI~i1'lSB.~ ilt~ -pijs:ra.~tG~1I t -&~~M~~tSHI"~iMfj , ~ft~ mJltiJ J! ' .~~~$ 0. 0. 0. "~,, ' ~:if':1f~-WtGlli1'lit* ; gH'Ht!:.~ffii~=Ef(jJii:I:* ' ~$JI~Ff-&~iJ''. . .~. ift:~ f1J #11. 0. JltM- ' ~~.*ilAti:.lIf?U'~1\~IIi1'lScrbU ' IilIJAScra-&iJ':J!JC~i1'JiU' o1f$ti '.~~ff::tEf(jJ , fY.iS-.IiI~~" "1!t!ilHtUi" 1ktf~tt'iJi!~ ."II~l1: _U::kf(jJil. t ffi:J!it&R~~~II.I§~elSlI~l1:~1~BR1J J!lI~~::f!tE-lIt aU~3'EttJ:~II.i1'Bttr II~~ , ~~l!!:~.M-3'E·'8"f(jJ~."tlHB 'iliJ:JI~$ 3'E1if(jJ1Jl.~' J!j!:troJlt ~~ 1iI~*.$B~~IiI~IU.' ~.f'.liJtl!ait.~~f(jJ 0. 0. 0. ,. h~'~ft~~~$1Jl.'.~~~mM-~~"~~~T~U.~~olil~m.$iJ~ .*.tl.E~ • •~1Jl.o~tro~• • ~f(jJ~~ • • ·;ti• •~~l1:$• • '~. ••. ~m"~II=E~~~u.3' .~.~&. ·.,It.lIM '. • •i1':J!~~.~1Jl.~~;ti~~ff'm!!:II~~B". '~;ti~ffl1:$f(jJ~~o.m,.~~ft~.f(jJ~~~~'II.*M~. ~1IIntUJ:. '. ~fIl1lt.II~fijt.' 1I~l1:~i1'~ff~" • • 0. iJ'itlitTII. ~~~'II~.B".~.$A~SB~~~~~~.f'.lfill~.~~~.·tttt;ti~~~. . Ittft~ lUi.' '\ ~f1J«fjHf(jJ.·1IG '. ' @!!:~lIiJtl fIt~1Jft.lI~m.~fj.g:5 m~m.$iJfiM;~~~f(jJIiI.1kit.{~f • •M:f(jJlOO. • • ~.".::kflflMJiiJ,lti§Jeill!m.11ri~~f • • • • ' Jl1!tlilfiIUIJ§Baf(jJA(P1t itJf'J1kiW~f~~II$.11i • • • "1!tIlt.t~~t.1k$~.1kiTtIJ. ' ~1tm.II~~1J • •$:1:" "u~" .1iIii&lIf" i§~~~~jtBz~2Jio ft~, 1iI~*Mf€t.:y~II~M fl ' .~+~;ti1lJl t ffit4J:tEa1lJJijj ~ JltiJ~.jjf(jJ1I ~Sc\Jf'JlHJm.fiI:fBI~ "Ii~ ,. _.,. ~it" m-a~." 3ttt{f'IiiI~*MIi1iUjOIil.~~.D:*1i!I:*f(jJ_~ (il£5) 0. 1iI~*.li!iI~~;tiEl BtG~1J. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. IU.tlJ:f(jJ~fi' $~.*.IIScra*Jt1l.~z.!Cfflfm.~ara*M ' iJii11i1'lara. *MAA;tiaJF.HJi.~Scra*M' M~:fi*.l:B9~. iI:l" ~-aR~.*JtUilAJmft~;ti Mf(jJIi1iI~ara.m."flA·~"f(jJ1i!I i1'lara.m~\:ffi.Lt~~ , £i1'_'I' i mJ~ , IiIP9Scra* ftMPJiI 1111 ~ ara JlIiI i1'la MmAllf(jJtfll, lI.ara*M-&~~fJC~:if'A. ' ra~.*.J:~~J4o. It ,: Raoul Narollt "Soientific Comparative Politics and Inter.aational Politicst" in R. Ba:rry Farrell (ad.), Approaches to Comparativea..od Inter.aational Politios (1966), pp.. 329-337..

(4) 4 1I.1I~ • • •::.JIj. 11 T3'fi?i OO.IiI.i~Jit. *ICMJ~.. ft.fJ1J:t!ll ~;it'Pf'fi:U ~/lII .~ 7J'fiU ~ffU l'tiInP9ft .re*M1JIl.tl.Jt_ ll1iJliitft t :ftfj1iJ~.IIU~:r&*.~J'JfHH:*itrit~H!f t tl1ttmlltF iI~Bc~~,rc • 1Jn~Jt. ~ ft¥J1iJ~fJeH·~I.f*?HtT.~itW:l~.MSl r&MJftm.J .. M{Mit*tfiJ4tJ.~.~~j; :JlHi*_g I!JM ±Jt3J1§ tEjS(¥eJ: Ji{1t€tjj:* • t. 0. 0. .0. t. t. ~*.~~~.~·m~~~~~Mit*~~.~~~it*om~tEm~.iI~~it .~t~~.~~~A.~~M.*~~~~.a·~W.~zM~o.T~g._.. ilz~* 1iJms;i.ll~'I'* A t9..t=-.~.~MJtI.,R:I:"IJi:Et'9 .. iI~JE;tMJ 0 @..RJ!;jj'jjtf:. *ff:tE ';jj'A• •~fifJ~~ • ftU~.~1JfMJ~~.BIIJI' ~~1iJ$B itr&.~~Wi •. ( David Eaatan ) 1Ii11iJtl-RHtJ9( coutingent ) - -/flitm ( continuous )~. , *~lIfiifCf6~M.~fi:J: flBtl~~tI9II.Jjf .. ~. . . . . ~ ••tV~1Jf .. tt1t 0. 0. ~ff/fIfR'.iJ.fftrngf'fi.lI.fllla9---~Jf.OSJ.~o-lilire*.~.tI9IIlJf ft~~.MJ• • • 1\"~.~.~~fi~a~ ...f'p~@IJf~~~t~a.~-RR~. ~.. !II Uil~'U~it~*Yf~.fI:1fU" ~.It.fl*" ~.~.~MJti/Jt.iI .. ilf'fiMl'@. 0. /JtJl~.' RUiU.i~jflfi~-_. 0. (~6 ). W~1I11m ff.t~1iI P':IR fit ~tEfill ~ - -jfDfiMJilMJ: • .it S MJ III IIU5cW:l* M1tt ~ ii~.gqHMJ-~ fI"':fi.... _M:MJilI7AIUi 'tru.~111 • tJ.lljl:~;fj'lIIf1i~" . . . . 3'e it .. xIU,Z:w:r'M:1it Jltma;a:::t£ ' iii ~1I..mfF~.Z.11t .. It... ~.~.tV~ 0. ~·.f'pMJ~.M:'.~~~~M~fit*fftF~~tJ9~.~.~~o ~~·. • •aW:l*fftfiJ~.~~.tfiJ~mfiH~~~MJ.~o~~iI~.d~~. .11.' ,&:lI*tt?;tf~~f1'UI ~-]ri~*iI.UH.~DjUt* t.RjfJJm~~fII3::E • •i~z~ffil.~ • m~ • • r'._RIIUII¥i1_~tt?;I\*.~ ollltmlllzElfJ9B mx~~2JS.z.Uif ' .1t~;:C1t.~z~~ (H7 ) ~~~IHmlil!ll.~. ,·:mllJ:fH I!~it* ' ;lt~M~fftZ./Jt 'IUI:• •~ltgfilJf J!.~:M'if'lfalJj.:....~ 0. 0. t. 0. ~~~'.~~A~.~MJ~'~.Jt~~ •• a*'fiM.o~IiI!II~.~W ~ , - i\ -i; -t;1f 3!: !U.t 1:1:1 ~~+ 1m fiX .:f-t; -f[;iIl ~7G ~. . . . . JIJlQ-t; ~ fi~lra i\ + =:'fi~. 7ci '3i-JL·tlm~.jj~l\' .:f'::!~:n;-t!QflJLf.~j[; ns ) -JLIDV\$,R:fj-. flQ.:fA~j;1t=.:)'G3!-JL-t;-$II~UliiJilfa~ ,,"'0 (aiL) !iI.A~4tJ_MJjf1Jn t 0. (. 1£6: David Easton, "Political AntbropOl?cy," in Ber.oardJ. Siepi (ed.),Biew:dal Re view or AnthropoloR (1959), Pp. 235-231.. .. ~7:.H •• a~~.ZH.~ti.~~.a.:*~.: 71S -750. ,. •• m~ •• (~~+E)'.. 0.. .. It 8:211; Rio~ W. SterliJig. Macropolltios International R"Iations in aQlobalSociety (1974),pp. 623-624, John 19.77 (1977), pp. 204-205.. W.Se~ll, !!!!...Unit8d Sta~ World D.v~lopment Agend.e .. .. 1t9: K.J.Holsti, mteruational Politios (3rd. ed. 1977),1'. 87..

(5) .. ••••".1'1"*. ~. 5. . Ed~1!Aotl1JnJilf!~*IYiIIa~ !ij-jfjif t 'EfJ-&BC:~TlfIlIa*.rk#{~jl:1Jn t ~ ll-&{J!11(;fiIlIlIa*MrR:tk;£:Jl1Jno 0.. ~1tfiG3<.~SCWs*M~f!5~{f:;tm@Il:*g[~SC~*Mo fIIlmn~f!56t{f:;1!m. : Ha . . , Ws~ {9.!1il,ttflllfd: *~ f!5[IJJIJ tm@1l:. ; t4 ScWs~f!5 fBiJltfl:i1J tm8/l: .; ~Scf&~f!5ajU'r' ... {f:;tm~lIfttiiJ~~tiiJ~1Jf olEJlU1ttNSCWs*Mrp t af&~IHttt'Utflll~8B .... .tL~ .. ,. fi~fjHaf&*.*ilt'. itT m~7.j( Jil;e.;£:iEB~. 9 ;;t1l!!iE.W W!J]tt***aa o § Atl.lit[~tti'/H~::'ti~.1!:Q:t\fiaf&ff_ ' mJtE~1i;U~~' *Ik' li~flU$. "~1!3 'I'~:tE~fiJ:: t [email protected];£:M**1'1JIT;;tM:. stScM~Iif[i1J81Jf it 9 :ft(gJJ!~lIA• •i&MJ(rt:l~f!5 '.~~jH±::e: " ;fttmftU{i].~-g;MHI!lJHjfU'~(tjJ~ 0. ~. 0. :Il±::e: ,'!1!!15e*, ~lE1rA" f6:1i4f 0 .1!• •IYiIScrtt*.~f!5~{l:;t~ 0 ~~ af&A ~.r'ftf{dmllt~:a.1ti£t&fflltmtt.ifiit\l ~:ti8at&*H~;ft1l~·tI± ::e: "1!* "M*~ • ffi:J!jtYJS*J:1!~liiJtm t ~I}.~ 0 :fiB'.i.l·SCt& *.ftU:at&l.1J~BII.M{f:; ,. .Jit1J;£:l!mPJ~.R"1R±::e:;£:"fI ;;t1l!!A±JtlHi ~ ,*m:="~t5~{I:;a9@Jff1!~lIIittiiJ ° ( It 10 ) .~.lIaa~~M~tkB'.i.l.IJfJil• •~~.~a~*~t~~5*M~f!5B~ U.:r-~{I:; ;ftg;"lI1RSc~l.1J@8 t :Il.itlil~~J.!J!y¥* ;ftg;.j!~W.J~:ro. ' :Ilil _~ :fi~RIJit1JOS--IU€~lI'Jitl:*.B t·fIl1!§.tI:s:r'fllJ ° ~~Ii!I.*.~~{I:;(tg 9. ".!lJt.-.... t. 0. 0. Q. 0. @Jfff41~itil. t 1lI.*M~.-IiI~Jnlifi• • t ~11ttl!Psct&.~jnlflli!l.* ~A;;t r ft.Q[J t' ifii.MIR.*.IYiI!I.5fiJ~ ~.m"il?iI.tEilt.rpo .iE'liI Q. IUfiafij.JIlIfFAA ' ~1I5*.:±''';£:A± ° :It#JPJalSJI$!lflIiI5*,,A;;ttt.1iI: ~AAO'alSlh • • ' -tV: ... ~.::rJit.~.UE~rrtlS t :It#J~tbwfl.BllIiI.~II* . • IIlJlJl' WfJ;.{ ~!lII.f;tmA±:fi:tl1Jntm.~ ° Jl311.SC7ft*rt.IUt€tSCt&*.1JnJ;.{Jt.(gJ7j-lJ{ • •;t;@"tm.~ mtt~t&. :1tflllltri± ( Thomes Hobbes ) Max Weber ) - jfIl.A-: tE..:iElI±P'5I .; .fJ!i ftB'.i.l-€t~{i!mJit1J ' 7;~mftlil.B9tftl itt 11) ~ifiitEJjj{Ma~*rtc:p , ~i1'~~'. m... t. 0. .{a (. Q. (. ~A.;ftm.~~Mftfl.'ifii1!~A • •~~~ftfF~ti~.ftB9la.o.1!-m~ :±'i£t&*rtf:f:tEtiiJge~.{tf:. ° ffi:J!.~~tlftfF!~~-~f.lJ.~Mft_ t. ififll.R;ftlE. at&*rt1t;7t~{I:;. 'n.fttmfl.fi{i!~MttMIt. .. tEJI(tdtScffl*MJ:j:I. diiJJ;.{.Rt-flM• •lltflllf1tiiJ~:iE9l\fi!P~gJit1J~M ... .t. gpl!~~. fIlfttW~*~".~. ilt10: f,ijtt 6 pp.240-242. Gabriel A. Almond &: G.Bingham Powll,Comparative Politics : A Developmental apProach (1966), pp. 218-232.. it 11: Max Webir, "Politics as a Vocation," in H. H. Gerth &: C. Wiicht Mill. led.) From Max Weber (1958), p. 78.. ,.

(6) 6 1I• •_.tI.~R!. ~IIItA;ftUUI.l:t$.J!G ' ~ifii;ftIDJm.l:tflJ!h1til~ 'iIS&.~:1J~lOO.~;ft~1j. •. •. 0. (12H. ) JIS.R ,ti"!h1ttJtI:.lIlB9ft~*Bf~1Ia.fiIU~"!@? tt~it*.~·2tA~UJ~ilH'i . '. :J!• • S:A~ 11.~ :f'ffl' ° 'm g.Tii1t f7TTtf}.~IiU~ 1iirJ @. tl!ril'ii~ft1J11 AfJ1lIlt mJi][ ~ ltJf "'][MJfi1i:IMI"o &~IItIJI!fJ1lJft;;afIJ~Ii~' iJ;Ati~liU~lit2fifitflJ~j~ _"f±f±IJ#{.IIt~.Tii1tffl'TmA;;a~ • • :!tfft.~XfIJlol~.~ ° (It 13 ) Iil!IIH4~M.:fi".Mi~:1J.I.~$U~ , §1tr"~ •• ~3f.~~Jm.**~~;ft ~*:1J~.iI«fifilb' m:li1Ia,~M~*.Ii.;;aIl.Il)J!Mi.I~.J!G ' tE.1lJ: :t1lt1la 0. *. 0. IIto~ifiiiE1IaIiUJI{tftft~~_*~*.-.,.{tIil!l(l.itAft/:'!.IHl.)!iI*~fFTii1t. ;;a!h1t.:1JtN~~ , **it:RJm*fil~~' ,*Wb:!fH'l~~II-ft~l§ '~U~tI!3A:fi"iI a..t~~.:1J ' ifiiAIC.\JI.l:~.tlif' .fi.Ia~MTii1tAJi li15.~=E.z.1t 'JiM 0. ~liIltO~1it.*~I!:1J. ' &:J!l§::Jj~fifllm~JjinIJl{~Z.1lI*MP9!HfiJ7)'. ' .IiUl:ft~,. ~,. . . m..... "1~tfi!~.' ii~ • • ~tflJ:W-. -It .~MIJt .... ~,.~,. . . Ii.... "1~~][1tJ' ~1;{.~A.ll' • •iI:~~XtE ~~j~JtU~:f'.ffi ' ~ifiifIJ~~JiIdiA.~ ~ifii • •IIIl1Il.~il1Jo .. I!aIruLItJ ~Ii. ~X~fl~'nl.~.fft ' ~.HHJi f1l1laEllIJt:J!rHJRrf!IUi~ ,. .~l1H_ 1J11**:1:811._' .:;ft*l§~l.itl§1i.~.1II ' fiRIilJitt~r~II~.m"iiJ1!:fi"~* 0. 0. '. ;. 0. 0. ~.omfiRlil!Ifi~IiI.~Tii1tA 'Ji~gMII~*~-ft~.~om.m~~:!tfft. ~X~fIJ~m~.~fIJ~~tflJ~.@lJto. ;;aa9_._ DII.H$lf(tftS:f6~M• •IUitf6 ~ H*(gJ~IiU":I: • f3JWtflJ:fc ~• •1JI':$lt.fi IE 14 ) fl!!~.AtE.IiI.~lf(tft~., .~iE~Il)JS:J&ffU'Ji)l ~• •" • •~,~IIt~"S:ffl'T.~f3:1J."~::Jj~*~~riE.Jom• • •f3 :1J.~~MA~.'§~"~'.~~'.~fi~~."ffto~ifii • • f3:1J~~~ MAliillJlI!It§liit.flililitA1}iE • ~JlJ*Hril1litzmAil\ll. ' *~Iffl. ~ Jlt. mfl"'"lllmtuJJ.. t mU.ftl'YJ.~ "tt3PRfiB9li~ ~ifii&ft~A1~ue*fi!* .tIl, •• li1Mm*.Bt.ftl .fillifftfiflIlMJXj{Uikf6*l1fftiJff t1fi.&;fjlfni1e~fF 0. (. 0. 0. 0. Jf.)o. ftJftl.tiM1f • 1I1l1S:f6~ • • • IfI~~lf(j$S:f6~M.m1!!l J!J § tfJ 2111: ' 1i!I~~ft Tii1tA~~.1Jllfc.pt. , .,*$R;;aftdll31J.lJIf~~1i .Ii § t1~"~I!I~fn'F~~ti ~ , St,fIII....~fi*=1I!tfft m:fI•• Z.IlI."iiJtI!;I!.~li.t1llfc.~lIJ!~* • 0. 0. 0. 1I.t12t JOII: 8PP. 217-219.. &13': Max qtuckmaollt : rtb - ~~JIII.&III • • IitJY-j it .. ·A/JlllE¥- ~.1:f.iJl . lE §l- ~. 81: ,Ut • it" acJ. M 1.1. til It lE ila ~ Iiill/:. tit JY-j. ~ 1: 0 JGluckmai:l:& ;Jt flIIlII 'l'JY-j. Jl. • a Jl. C~wiok· F .A1ceJ:',. "Comparison ot Int:ranatio.aal &ad International POlitics, "American Political Science R.view, LVII (June 1963),pp. 417- 418. ' &14: ff .. JIt·JU:flIIZjfH~. 2Jl. Roger D. Masters, "WorldPoUtics&S & Primitive Political Sys~," World Politics, XVI ,(July 19M),. pp. 595-619..

(7) • •itta• • PJitta T ~1It$Ai1i.U.gI!lDFfzf'Fm. o'. . z ' e(iiJlItMit*z:fltE t ~~~ns-;!tt.:l:1lffiJJtz~f'F"tlJ~ ° m.~f'F"@ '. ~~~~~~~~~~t~~~~m~~~ffit~~ns-~1It~.mt~~~~*M~ "t~~ns-~.~.~*~.~o~~.*~.t~~~~* •••~t.~~.. 6'1i1'lt t :)t1l$;ffiTB9~f'F~@1B~~~~~ ~j~trom~"MB9.~!l °. -. *MlIra iiJBft~.~ a~.if~~ ftA.1t @J.!U~'z - ° .:liil'it mz.t.{ BftOO- II. ~~m.t$m.t.{mM~~~~o(nI5). WfIl*a(Sysrlu) J;m-.A:fift-ntB9 ...$B9J[I1Jf1fiB9.{g:itiJ.~ o*a.;t;. m~~.'iI'.iiJ~.~~*ao3~~.~~*M~~~~.~*a~• • *ao~ ~,*aB~Il$;JG.&~~'I'ft ° 'efJ~~.~ .$;JitB9t6'J'l" M... J[." J[ 11J .......$ .. ~~ ... A,.lli,~~,~.~O • • (Gabriel A Almond ) ~_--~~u~~aJ!fft!flmJ!~3\> ftlJlI lI-W ~ ret* a.A i1ill!PJi~ fiDB9~. '~mfiiJ.t.{J[toJt.- , -w~~*a~:fi~~_ t 1!f AiiJ.t.{Jt.tttM•• f~trofiJJt"~~ ° ='-Wa~*~Ato~@a~~~t1!fAm~~~arr@~ ... af1~~tro~ ... ~~arr~.~ ,,1JOJ;{Jt.=- . -Wa~M• •~~~~tro t 1!f AiiJltlC:lt~~.f~@fill ° 1m .. -Waffl*~~3tfl:;~.U~tI~~~ ° 1!fAiiJJt.-;l!tJ! ffl:"~Ma'lJfi1:fi 9. 0. 0. 0. ( I): 16 ). • • ~.*.ltU ~;tJ~~itlfB ° ftIJ·Jta~;tJ~~.?tflt*~1IWflfaN:liWf .~t~W~iiJf'FAJt •• ~~~ft • •a~tro.~o ••• ~~{;lIa~~*;tJ~~: - .. a~i1:flfl:;'Ut~A::t~Him. =. 0. ~ ~J~Z.it°. It 15:"1iVl~aJ!l!.fr-J.Jnffl:iiJY.l.(JHlllr : David Easton, The Political System (1953), A Framework lor Political Analy'ais (1965), and A Systems Analysis 01 Political Lite (1965); Gabriel A. Almond .II: James S. Coleman (ads) ThePolitios 01 the DllIveloping' ~ (1960); Morton A. Kaplan, System and Prooess in Internaticnal Politics (1957);. Gabriael A. Almond .II: G Bingham Powell, Comparative Polid.;s:A Developmental Approaoh (1 966) •. It 16: Gabriel A. Almond .II: James S. Coleman (OOs), ~,. pp. 9-25.. ~olitios 01 the Developing.

(8) 8 • • II~.".;:l!I. =." flJ 1it:zJrU~i. 0. m! .. B:t&JUI Ii .. m.zil~o 0. 1\ . . . .Z~o. 1:: . . . .z.~ o( 1t17 ). l1fJm!~:J!.A~~ 'f&=.~J!.l:fi~~. 0. .l:fiUJ~IHI;tB:iFf~~tf:1z:tLi'Ji. .. fTalk. WJi'Ji ' JIt.UJIH'EIli'9~.lklllJ~~fltZJ41m ' ttt3tB~Ot-1~ , mtE.RstB:t&*Mtf:1(tg .AUJts ' ~n.l;l;tfTo - .. B:~n.ft'UJ(~A:tiJl. Jt~t&A;,tiJl.ifii. '• • IiI.B:~ttiA.:tE:ti1JOo~Jt.MI!I.~ f1fifii~ t "'-JJltf:11il1 ~m ffO(tg.lt 911 tt!;fr:tl1JOttiM" EBm~iEM-3C;E jRJ'U!M-3C ' WB:W~3C;E~n~?f.3C ' 7!71!:~Ii!I?f.3CDtti •. ~jl1WAm:*a' .*.~tfsJ."n'1I07?f.3C$D(tgfT1U 1lr.aIfAA .. tJM ~ ....~ .. A tJ.~ IC.'.'J." I;~.* ~~.fti;J;M-.Ba9~~ 0. "0. ~o. .. "),1-*.. .. 0. ". M ~ ,ftllJlIIl1.".S._ t$JIIA*ftl '::'~*'UEn:R~a9.+.$' J!.MI~~t *ilrilHtimJHt_IliWl EJfi .IIJME~M~. ' mlff~*~ " UBli .. ~j$.HFMlfI _~(tgA~':tE.~lIJlk~~IIIJIII • • tf:1~~~*~m~(tgA~o EB~/1'/iUtfsJA@S ( lIA "1iI~ ) 1JO~ 7111J.~Ma9l1!~ • :....:1.1iiiijt.743-1IJ~3CB: .tfsJlI!trtu~~.1IJ 11111. a9f;fIUIUift:1.1 ~ , -:1.1 iMtt! EB~."II.I1.m 1ba9M!1*ifii .ttfit$B:~_"«IIa9.lI!t 0 .llff*ifii~ , ~FB:t&f£A±Z.ft?f.3C~.~trtfj' . EJ~.*7?f.3Ca.a9i'9~oAd .. ~~ft"M!~H~"IiI.~ft"M!~.~" •• 'fib} .. IIJIII~iii.rJ3JIA ' $;t3~lIJjt/iij*J!lt$~. o:tE~~mml' ' IJHIrA3tfttm.ltm:tt 0. ftMI.T.MB:t&~~MJ~.o. ~FIJ:*IIA±:tE.~IiI:&~~I!I.m.i'9mllMlM:!l '?fJ\,"*fi;k~ • • ~ 1tJ.ltflJ. 1I{;?f.3CtflHit:JeES:fl ( P aul- Hehry Sp8ak ) tt;frl' ~J-~~i!I! : ~-n~A~-nnm!~~:tE~M~' •• m.~Ii.$om.tm~.~N~~.~ lilili ' ItHfi.tfsJJtt7R~~~ • • •········· ~~*~~mJ!jjf~IUi " .~1tJtM 0. af!IDi\m-sllro.~.i'93'f.T.f.!{a9~~~.'U.lbfjt3. B:t&Mz.f!,C., , fZSjifiifB."~~Sl:ret$.JlU ' It 17 : /6J1lr1! • =1\:-1\:0 0 .. It 18: Paul-Henry Spaak; "The ~1910-1960. (1960), 84-85.. ~zperiment. 0. it~fi.IiIUt~~. ~.El.fi~1fi~ ~1iI¥iJ.lt~.fF~ 0. ... (m&. of collective Security, II in perspective on.

(9) ••aift•• PiikIG9 @.U"*e'!JJf~. t • •IiI.IUlf.§.MJA±*j,._.l6fiiti.fWJTtJ9_~. ~. ~-;fLn:;fL$~1I. (ChadwickF·. Alger) U.'Ht.M-~ll~.~tII.~.. ' . ' • •fWiIl"ftJ9l6ta: H • •"1tllat.7'Htll• •iIlfiIilfFtmti~ 0 ~ • •"1t.~.7.1t • • ~fiIilfFtJ9.~0 ,~ • • "1tlilat.7W~a~~MJ.~0 " • • •1t.~7~~~IiI.MJ"0 (Jj) • •"1tIil~.7 • •*.*tmff.o ~1I1fH~ • •~fi"1tIlIfF.t&IiI~~AAIi~_are~.iI~7Jitm.tE1!' il'iiJ~:&.BjlltlitJ9m ... @,.iIlft*ttts 0 ( ~ 19 ) mJ:.i1tIiIJ&' ~AliItl~itr&A:::t~I • • areit.1'ttJ9j1j~, *It• • •arefill ~itreo. =... f1J~Z~• •"J~z.M. 0. _ • • •{f{iJare ~.~;fi""~Z~.fi~Z.M ' :Jtj! ill1E:l::1!i;fiWr'.II* •• mM.~~ ,t(:a.:l::1!im-1WAi1tIlJ.~~• • ilMtI~15 0 ftI!......."j_. , 'MJM_*ilJ;fi1lQ11 : ifII~1'ttfiiilj_1I1 .*M:MJ"j~1II11 ' ~·IJ.M:tfjJ"J_1I ' :& • •JE: ~ tmz"J~1II11 0 Wf1ll1tlHJt1'ttmfl ~1II11J;m• • , .... 3tfr 1t• •iTii 11 ''81l'JiU(.EI.tJ'jj''J~ ,it.itif:.IIJ.tfjJ""~o :Jt.IHJ!:;filE~B9il." .r'~ AAo.*M:~fl~IIJ.J;mI*"Ifi.*mM .. :Jtftl!A~III• • o~1l'JtfjJ~m:l::OO ~tmM:¥ • •IIJ.MJ"j~ , ;fi• •tfjJjtij:Jtfll!itreu*• • • ,jt 0 ~~.*M:MJ""~IIJ .J;m~ ... A8 .. iIk'it .. ~.lUIMIlil'ii-m- t '81l'Jii,*,~1I11A .. ~ii" ••:a.* ••• ' ~~lE:AitiJ t rmltM:tfjJ*~iti"~ 0 ftill-1Ia.If:il±:E~fJ.uIUt~j, , i1t:l::iIk ~1Eft~f.§.~jtij-1Iit~1lA~W.~.0 • •JE:~tmz""~.J;mmit*ElHtm jtijare*.tJ9• • '~iIl• •~~~.o""~z.MJ;R&.fl~M1t~-_M:a~o fl~Z • • • •Mj!M.tIJ~n;fftI:4itiJ 0-_*_ ' frJ~~" , f&*~Ji ,'~ • • , ~tfjJJI?}- t IU~1E .~J:.:l:: IiI .l;lll[ ilJMJ 0 ( it 2 0 ) MlI§'( James S •. Coleman) Itlfmw : 1EH.~ • • fl~U• • •M' tE tE~m~~MJ'ft.M:tMiII.(iIl{l{AtI"~.".1I"M... ~... jJ.f5}• •*~ ~.A ) *urs: 0• •tmMHlIfi1t• • fl~ttttlllifIM'. ' 1iV1fI$~~mllJtB.1'tagitllJ* • •'0 1Jfi!;fi~~.1'tag"J~IIJ.n ' fEit~~_~$Jf't&l;f• •MJjIj~ 1Eat:~1J. *_ ,.. 0. It 19: Chadwick F. Alger, "United Nations P8.rtlcipatioQ As A ~earDi:ng E%perience, II Pliblic Opinion Quarterly, Vol XXVll, No.3 (Fall 1963), 411---426.. It 20: IiU lit 16 33---45 •.

(10) 10 • • • • • • •. =-•. • ' 1IJjfM:lYilflJ~IIII1( .~ , ~~ltlllll ' x'iJ*~) A~~I!M:ft:m :fiJ• • • •1m .~ • • ~~~ • •~~=a~.:~~M:~ftDM:III . . .~• •RM:~~·.*M: fII_• • :tEii~RlI3t ,J;J.1t iMJjfM:fII~1II11 z1~.fJ • :@:to"UftR1t1Yil ~~M: ... it. M:llll1z1.1APl1l7'#JhltlYil fll~ 11111 ZHHM ~ ll.f~lII. Z~ Z:rt it_11ft.J;J. *JOJl'J:tE' ~1!1I1JfM:1II • • {E~1!M:~~ .~Ma· flM(gJ1.1.rsi1l7m*f~tmH AI (It: 21 ) .1I~MJllJnl~III.~.{l;J.Z. tt~:@: : itJ¥M: ... ~~M:1II11 ( JftJlmliliHfii . ) • •mM~E~~~'~SM.~~~.~~fl~.~&m~o~Mm' • • 0'. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. M:1YiI~J~III. 'Jft._.~1f1lJ.zaJR'iJJUfillRllm.,utifjj.. p. 1f~~.Jl.Ua. .1I~MlYilflJ~ 0 m:@::tEIU~~iI. ' 1IJjftE~J~III.~mlil~~.*Jl~.~"~. {E.' $!l• • Ii!I.ifjj~~it.M:fIJ~ :tE1iI1I*M~ 'ibJl.JfM:~J~III. ' mns-A:;t51~Jl it*f~ IYiIfF m ' ~flMS?tIYil~.1.1 SUlm*f~ 'M?t (tt 22 ) &Jt:J!:5 • .~IiISC Jf.f ~.Ii!III• •IYiIAft ' m~}jtt5J:@:IiI.~J~ ( .1lUII.J'gSiH:DIYiI~J~~n iI'D~~IiIII*M 0. 0. 1YiI~~o~~.lIm.IYiI.A.~.II~.AIYiI.ffit~.~.eam.lillYilfII~tifjj. 1h.'UfUallllt ~M(tjJ ~1~ ~~ • ~~Il~M~J~Z~.'UfUa.~~I:1Jiij JHtI~'UtJiij.~IU'.**~ _.lYiIfll~ ~1I:r.*Jt• • gjt*lI~~* ' ~1II.~ • •JH@jJ!f:JtJiij.(Sa. • J;J.~ }jt:JtJiijIYil~J~ .~Il.JH.tii*~III77tlC~*~SC.IY.iIM:J( ( _.'l~~ it* ~~.) 1I'ii~to~lYiIlL. • ~:@:1'nlIJII.Htyft;~1II~16l"-IYiI.j!o~Jft'~j~Z~*iI:' .~:tEMW • • lY.illi.'ifjj:@:9MlIgjt·~JHtljJ!f:JtJiij.~~R1tAzlL.to~*M it· .mWIiiIIl~.lYiIfI{ltiJ :jJJ1lUJlitIilJt~~IIIIIU.t¥nIrAII ' $f{SitfJUIYiI*JtIil 0. 0. ••. ..... 0. 0. 0. fliit·:?'IlI!*.IYiI~~MitR1t.IIIY.i1.j!SitSC.o:tElI~IIIJi\t~~IIIIIIlaq:.fII~z. ~.".M, ' .m• • *~IIIJtli!lllm.z.A*.{E ..*~. ~1~~1!M:i1k&. 0. HtMJ. tmlil.*~III.. Jiij~. mns-4HlflJ~SitiJ(fi.~ , ~*jt..~,ij! , Ii!IIIt~M~~J~. z.M.ltIilJ'g~MJ!~IH~~. 0. ='Bci'Et• • • • •aW.~SCffl~Mftrrm~~~~IlIYiI~~o~-~oo'~ • •R~~m* 1tiIYilai'Et~M~·:;t~?t1ti1Yil • • • • Wm·.~~lLlYilJi\t~.IY.iI~Ao ••z':tE. ~A~fiij.IY.iISCi'Etxf~ • J;J.,1tEJ~IY.iIJt?tf~IY.iI~J~~.Jfl.MI5.lYiIai'Et~M~ ,.11 • •*;fi.*@JjflY.ile~Jfl?t~ ~1R'H~ • •:l::AIlIYiI~T ~1iIY.il' SCi'EtXf~*.t , 1l.?tf~lY.iIn.'I'~J~~.".MtmSCi'Et~M ' IU~ • • •?tf$tt.flJ_."a 0. 0. ... It 21: Q" 548-549.. itt. 22: Chadwick F. Alger, "Comparison of Intra.riationel and Internatio~l Politics, II. American Political Science Review, LVII (June 1963 ), p. 413..

(11) .IIJIU~t~ • • ~iJI:~ 11. .m~U'~W~M.~*li~'~.~~(~23) ~~~H~.~~~.o~,. f.lEB~.~' $1«, ~tfciilt3t{~il'iiM1I11'~iI9itl:~. t ~;§"~.gt[7e~EI~e~ftftl*.' N EB~m3ti19 ~ il'ii1J1l ~T ft.~.n: Iirtu ~ -:nim ~ gill ~ I'Bftfl **'fiiJ IJHiI(m~ Mft~JilftM~PR. 1fUf~~mIiffi.~:&~.BtTI!WJIf~fflil9*.U'.At1l- ' • :1f~mA*'f~~~Wil:a:AJilAIUJ.~ • •ttlJft• •~ o,[email protected] 0. 0. ~A1I~om.itl:m~itl:.~e,~:&~mJil.#~~~m~'~~M.*.~mfii19. '~fH '~~JH. ' tJlT~JH*~_~Bcfb.ill::ff::a:(tj}M*~e --. .1IH~Mfb" 5ilttlJ~. ftll.R~IiI.HilUOiCI.. 0. (1l:24 ) *$ffift• •"EB* MiI9.,ijltA 0. ,. ~. m~~'~.~A~fl~a~t~R.,ijltAiI9.M'~T.,ijltA~n:lirtu'-ft~ ,. '. .-&~IJln'*liIiI9:fil7UU6' J&.*liIiI9.~,.ftl2I~. 0. ~.,ijlt~~~iI9ftftlIA*~. :a:1Jllsl1HltJltil9*M ' iM~~~~f¢ ~2III~*.~*.ftfl'.II~~IiI~iI9~~ , 'e 0. ~.:a:III.*8l:.m~n:Jil~BttlJn:.o If'~EBM~~.~.1JIlTm.me '~f.I~~~;§"M,ijlt.III::tn.*.iI9f1J~. 0. ~~,oo~¥~~~.ttlJ~.-&*~2I~8~~fl~iI9~5iI'il'ii~III~m.~~~*. tt 1iU1fi:' 0. EB~.~II..ft.AlB9:ff:~' ~.ftHIl_i!.~.n:W~1E' 1f'~-EE{iiJ1II. ~iI9m.Jil~.o~1l'!.~iI9:fil1JiJil3t.ftl:'}lm;§"~n:Jil~.iI9M:.til'ii2l~.IlI.i!. .g:Jil.~. o' • •l:~1F~* t MI~*_~flJffl.IUII. • •A_1Jiil9.l!GM: t fF~.~ 1iI• • iilfiil9~f* EBl:~1iJ~" H •• *MiI9a~.5iI:;'t;.TftMM:' 'e-&!J...T dft{~ iI9~f!t (it 25 ) ~.~l:iI9~iilfit1iJ~.~IiI.Rfb~.~~a~iI9~fb'il'ii~~a~~~~• • iI9afb'§A~~.It.Rfb~~iI9~~~~.It.'~~A;§".~l:ft • •l:iI9• • o 0. 0. :a:R.l:~-&~1iJ~~~~~n.*MB9ftMM:'il'ii*~.mft~o. 111' ?Ji;AH3Ii1.afbJilJl{Mtil:*Rfb'lJFJil~.~afbft-ftlil~Rfb.lt • •. '.RfbJil.~afb.;§"~J4. '. ill$;§"~~~5iI£J&. 0. 'lIm.. ill:M~ *MJilIR~iI:*nlf'liU. .+.'. '~~'IiI.afb"IlI~Rfb.~ftijttlJ~.oilit7~fiiDl':. - , iI~it*iI9.,ijlt~T~~' ~.T ~ • • ,. a. 23: f<iI it 16 45-46.. ~ 24: ~ Iii!.. It' 25: ~ 1£22. 557-558. 414.. .W.', JU.TX ,.fi.

(12) 12 • • iI••".. II.::... (ilt26 ). -1WAfil~-mAfJU~jJ_.1JIim~/f'~' @~fJ~~tA.1J~If!il:tlnffo. Eb~AJUt~~ , 4ij -11 A:tEBJ(~~ Itr:f:1m {l;tfjJ mll:.'I'iSiitJffIlJ. 0 lit lu!'att ~• .Rli 1i~1i~'". t 4ilYl~A:tEitrit~Mr:f:1MlltU MiMl** ofiijfli:4ijfl1;j£AB'iJ. r~itJ. - ftAO , iifi.SR~.fiJif!l.~.*a- -:m~ti*·, ;tt.1JiSft~ti* JHiitk::x (MulJive ~EPlft$J:-.IiiI) Ji~.it~lIu'1JZ~mfaI.:1::T;fitfrf ' m1PjI• •~, 0. _IIP:1it*:tEII:liUh$ t ~:tEafftfli: t B'I'• • ~jJU1f.1IAB'lI~* @:tEII/It;;\f1CM ~~Qlj .. ~:tEit1fU' t 1l/I~§(.1l:ifdt~.1J B'iJIifUkB'iJlIlf . . ~JffIl:t:!!1!m.MljUljj, 14l~/f'tBJ~H'~"' ~Z.fiij , QU~lifJlI~"" Jff.;Qltb1J.Mla:.~. '1ID1l'.H;Q~ .H:Uil~~~ t is/f'*J&Jlj • • (t]~ . . 0. =... IiIP:liitl:*!II~:/Q.T;tf~1:Iil.BlJ:Ml~J4. f. @J!:-'!WIiiI.P:lmut'.iltt".~J£. [,JffIlJlMl ,~aU~liIftJl~~.~ ""@Ji:-tSRMlIiI.~aMl.$;IUi.:tEAfI' :tE~... :tElftf ,:tE3tfbft_ .. :tEf!I.~. t :tEM!~H.R@lft :tEitritM.:&1Jiii ' ItJfifi.:*:Ml ~"t~~~II.~~J~z.M~a~ • • ltIilP:l~_Am.o '='liIP3i1t1::"UI1ltJff-lYIi1!-.J;;{J:aglf3~_ "llA~ t"Ut~ll .. • •~.~rs ~'~~.1ItA*~.$;Am.~ofi~~~'itrit~It~$.~~~~.~~. ...... flJJlttF~tI.jJ1It~fF n,.tEz{I(tiiU. 0. i!Il1ut~Qgll'l\ 0 'B&;tJ~.Ml. .. . tF~U*.fJ~E" • • ~.~MJ~IS o:tE:.-mlilm:~ Ef ;£IIJII lar£ Ml*.I1':¥_ .m~~MlfJ.tt~Il'A~~• • •a~~omJ;;{f!il.~~• •mfFZ~E' • •~ .~'Ajt{t6I1J.mEf • • ffo:tEm.*_If3'-1WIIIP.;ttffi!IIJ.1J~t-1Jiii1t ~ • • • zfl8.mjtlifJfl~ i ;!-1Jiii t &Ji:J!?I'jiMl1J:it ' 71:IiUllm~... gil .. ~!i!DlliflI=Fm:'I!;tt~III.Bi~ . . :tEII.*.If3ft!d_fi1• •~~~Uq$;~T.. ... ~. .. ~~.~o. 1m .. EbJltiiJJi!.1iI.itritWiJ.1JiHtltMl ~ ~~luMl .1JMl~E" artttt.Jl,Jt', ~ BtlttMl,i'.M' .1td1!HI~**~~o • • II~iHI1It~J;U'~}t~MlA1JfilEf~• • ' .1It~Jl~IiI~~ffi!~MI~.'@~~~Jfi~.S.~MI .. J!.~*ft~a.~J;;{Jl,Jt "HtJil.A~ag~. ' iI!~j9:m::&.Mlfflb .P:litritWiJ.1JQU.1It~.1f3 '1iIJ;.{Rm~~ atllMlalll .. !i!ifiAo 1i .. 1i11RftWlifll3tfbliritllaritiH:*fbB@ , tEliIP:I' IiI~Ml~*itltt~ • •" . 0. 0. It !6:1UUU'± (Ray 5. Cline) )ifi"T- ali +1\. • • • ~"A CJl£-'fli Ei _Q1.±=lffi .. =.. ~=.~Ael£-=flia_aT.~a_S'±.5+h.oACJl£lia_B~~+.B'±=lfli. . +5. 0 A elf E+_ST • -'f'B.±=If=+. 0. Ae-=f,err=lf.RfI1t" • • •. Ray 5. Cline, World Power Assessment 1977 (1977) 40-43.. 0. 8111:.

(13) --::. • •3:NfJlfilPutNf13 .. ~oft~Mzfi~*fi·~~~tt~ •• ~.~ofi~-MA~~~~.~~~.~M'. :!l ' ffi~RI!@P;;1tH:iE'It ~ fli~,*,*.~iI~tm.iiS\ 0 N.z ' m~~z.1tJiij.MJ3t{t'" ¥a:&:~;ttniiit*fl:;(fi1~!I! ' ~.*rcftjJ:£*1tIlUi5i Jit.I£A$I1'.11'£f1~ ~ • • ~. ~ . . ~N.:lt ' ~:~?f~ft1il;iflJ• • ~itr€! 'flifJi.TfI8iUIJl;;fifiH'jfjj~Jififi~ 0 fi ~~rm.MiiJ1{rdi. ' ±l},tt~ftI3tc*lt.J:fJIJ1J($ I 7).tE--1L-e~$m~1J~.JIl{ 0. fl.. 0. ·a;*_flJztf!{A.' JUtP~Mtm.Jt ·.fj[llM~~mlb(t;J~li.1ilJ!iM oil'm':IJ§fiBi" JIt... ltill.iIl:1i;:t .iit1JMJ~ m ~~ 1it J3; iMil ii'M' R t-tn.If.IilJi tl'M.!l:lit13 ~9~tIi~fflo fEot'iiIJ~Ili'li$J¥~B9. 13 .Ht~1'i1a9 ~W1fUjm.it~B9~ft • •IJIM o~~"'AJJ;(illla ... Jtfc."ttill. 1\ .. -tliTiiif' 1{nt:J!EtfjlS'~*~Zff:tE. 0. 0. 11( • &lI'{J:II.~z{f:mJ.!t~.1JZJ!tft 0 1iU~' tE~.J: 'iiUl1iffi1i1.l£~T.1i. ~fl'iJlit13t!m. 0. -e .. m.J:~'i.T.Jl!ilbrE!~~li~f:lI.j@".PiBcw..~/iiotE*~.II.*· .13 - fFlt .. Jtfi~: tEJ1I~J:i1~:l:9~i*' tE• • J:~AtIi.fJi1tll.o • •iE'Iaw..m lb(tlllAj\tIll.iI'*'&~5Vfi~ff:B9U 0 IlIIUJ:JtIJ=t.• • •zlllJ • ilD~ , • •~. ftt!: 'JJJJQ"41 m~{(fJJHtt.:fli' RJ!:I:.flJfJf~j{, $ • •IJI'M JiijIfW ' IlIl!1ilf& ::E1ti6J~ff: • ~• • ~itlJ~. 0 ~Jlt '1'I1!I*MB9.i~TJ;J;(,tt5E.1F1~Ut.1\jt@~. o :tt1tl!"l!lfM.~ .. 3t{t~vt; i ftlIIMH'• • ' 81£M:fj:ftjJJft.~ T 0. Q. A .. tE~~~.n~'~~n*ti~• I!o. ~-l!t*s;, ·jkTII~ijfA1i1'i9. '. .1J.mz~.!l:'=t.~*~~.~~.13itlJ~. .~m~.I'tiJ~~§.tm.flj*. t. 41~JUIB'jjzlNJ. tn*"IiI~z~'~~-~zM~~ffl,J;(~.!l:.fl~.moffi • • ~J; • •~ • •. ~tIl.ii1IIICfI13 (tJ;.ttlS. • ~ JltIilIJ1~ .,1i-tl13lim 2!1i .ll:=t. JH~• • 13Zttk~~ E 0 .~tia ' {:t(• •132pJj o mmUI132J11I t m~ilJ;(• • • • t .lL~lIMJjj;t; t *~!l. 1l::-·mlit-If.,JfIc..'~~tl9ii11~ , .~ltiJ ' tiElJHmlil t. .a..I£A~~a9~":i1':tE~fl;~wr~~(I9:1:~~• •. 'JIl{ft1iIHiJlkf£ t. 0. tEm.M~l'. ifjj*EH'I£~TI'UJ~.13~1!. 0. iii .. • J:fJf~ '. iiI ~~J.&~zll:""':fI.'H'$~~d t 1lI1!1.w..".PiBcf&U.~m . ~ ° 'ft:JtJillMMaw.. - ~.41ii11~J.&~ ll-MPia~ag.lt.*~, ~a1i"'~~iI . zll ffilJ.it~lllilpgit~tErf." .13~I!" ~1t ... tt:fj~ .... ~~~.~15 . '. .. im f:lI tfJ~1i+;tOO.itlJIiIBU 0 ~.ttiJrf. {:t(JlkJl~EitlJ.13 .. ltiiitlJ1&*1t.... .It t. .. Q. .. t. @.l!litllJ,l'i9~li. .. t. t. ~.132J!MiTtiI~~l'i9a~". , iiIJUI1,iltT/ill!law..WYt6iJr°.

(14)