第六章 結論與建議
6.2 建議
由於要建立一個完整的預測模式必頇有龐大的毒性數據來加以測詴,
因此,未來如果能夠以其他不同物種針對本研究所評估之反應性醛類及急 性麻醉性氯酚類來進行混合毒性詴驗,並且增加評估毒物之種類,已使本 研究所採用之 RA 模式更加完善,並更進一步的運用在環境風險評估上,
相信對未來的環境保護有一定程度的貢獻。
此外在模式選用的部分,由於在分析結果發現並非兩毒性物質互相產 生交互作用,而是單一毒性物質與詴驗 Medium 產生化學反應,因此可以 將所發現的現象納入考慮,以讓我們能夠更詳細的考慮各種會影響混合毒 性效應的現象並能更加準確的預測混合毒性效應。
Reference
1. Okumura Y, Koyama J, Takaku H, Satoh H. 2001. Influence of Organic
Solvents on the Growth of Marine Microalgae. Arch Environ ContamToxicol 41:123–128
2. Kaiser KLE, Esterby SR. 1991. Regression and cluster analysis of the
acute toxicity of 267 chemicals to six species of biota and the octanol/water parition coefficient. Sci Total Environm 109/110, 499-5143. Diane JW, Blum RE. 1991. Speece A database of chemical toxicity to
environmental bacteria and its use in interspecies comparisons and correlations. Research Journal WPCF 6:198-2074. Christensen ER, Chen D, Nyholm N, and Kusk O. 2001. Joint action of
chemicals in algal toxicity tests: influence of response level and dose – response regression model. Environ Toxicol Chem 20:2361-23695. Arensberg P, Hemmingsen VH, Nyholm N. 1995. A miniscale algal
toxicity test. Chemosphere 30:2103-21156. Mayer P, Nyholm N, Verbruggen EMJ, Hermens JLM, Tolls J. 2000.
Algal growth inhibition test in filled, closed bottles for volatile and sorptive materials. Environ Toxicol Chem 19:2551–2556
7. Nyholm N, Kälqvist T. 1989. Methods for growth inhibition toxicity tests
with freshwater algae. Environ Toxicol Chem 8:689-7038. Padrtova RR, Marsalek B, Holoubek I. 1998. Evaluation of alternative
and standard toxicity assays for screening of environmental samples:selection of an optimal test battery. Chemosphere 37:495-507
9. Lin JH, Kao WC, Tsai KP, Chen CY. 2005. Anovel algal toxicity testing
technique for assessing the toxicity of both metallic and organic toxicants.Water Res. 39, 1869-1877.
10. Chen CY, Chao MR. 2000. No-observed-effect concentrations in batch and
continuous algal toxicity tests. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 19, 1589-1596.11. Nyholm N, Damgaard BM. 1990. A comparison of the algal growth
inhibiton toxicity test method with the short term 14C-assimilation test.Chemosphere. 21, 671-679.
12. Hostetter HP. 1976. A rapid bioassay for algal nutrients and toxins. J.
Phycol. 12, 10.
13. United States Environmental Protection Agency(U.S. EPA). 1996.
Ecological Effect Test Guidelines. OPPTS 850.5400. Algal Toxicity, Tiers I and II.
14. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development(OECD).
1984. Guideline for testing chemicals. No. 201.Alga growth inhibition test.
Paris, France.
15. International Organization for Standardization(ISO). 1987. Water
quality- Algal growth inhibition test. Draft International Standard ISO/DIS 8692. Geneva, Switzerland16. American Public Health Association (APHA), American Water Works Association and Water Pollution Control Federation. 1995. Toxicity
testing with phytoplankton, in Standard Methods for Examination of Waterand Wastewater, 19th edn, APHA, Washington, DC.
17. American Society for Testing and Materials(ASTM). 1994. Standard
Guide for Conducting Static 96h Toxicity Tests with Microalgae. Annual Book of ASTM Standards. ASTM E1218-90. Philadelphia, PA.18. Chen CY, Lin KC. 1997. Optimization and performance evaluation of the
continuous algal toxicity test. Environmental Toxicology Chemistry19. Brack W, Rottlern H. 1994. Toxicity testing of highly volatile chemicals
with green algae-A new assay. Environ Sci Pollut Res 1:223-22820. Brack W, Rottlern H. 1994. Toxicity testing of highly volatile chemicals
with green algae. ESPR. 4, 223-228.21. Kuhn R, Pattard M, Pernak K, Winter A. 1989. Results of the Harmful
Effects of Selected Water Pollutants(Anilines, Phenols, Aliphatic Compounds) to Daphnia magna. Water. Res. 23, 495-499.22. Galassi S, Vighi M. 1981. Testing toxicity of volatile substances with algae.
Chemosphere. 10, 1123-1126.
23. Herman DC, Inniss WE, Mayfield CI. 1990. Impact of volatile aromatic
hydrocarbons, alone ane in combination, on growth of the freshwater algaSelenastrum Capricornutum. Aquatic. Toxicology. 18, 87-100.
24. Mayer P, Nyholm N, Verbruggen EMJ, Hermens JLM, Tolls J. 2000.
Algal growth inhibition test in filled, closed bottles for volatile and sorptive materials. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 19, 2551–2556.
25. Huang HJ. 2000. Experimental design of the algal toxicity test based on
photosynthesic response. A Thesis Submitted to Institute of Environmental Engineering of National Chiao Tung University.26. Vasseur P., Pandard P. 1988. Influence of some experimental factors on
metal toxicity to Selenastrum capricornutum. Toxic. Assess. 3:331-34327. Halling-Sψrensen B, Nyholm N, Baun A. 1996. Alagl toxicity tests with
volatile and hazardous compounds in air-tight test flasks with CO2 enriched headspace. Chemosphere 32: 1513 – 1526
28. Arensberg P, Hemmingsen VH, Nyholm N. 1995. A miniscale algal
toxicity test. Chemosphere 30:2103-211529. Kao WC. A comparison of the results of several freshwater aquatic toxicity
testing on synthetic and real wastewaters. A Thesis Submitted to Institute of Environmental Engineering of National Chiai Tung University.2001.
30. Lin JH, 2001. Experimental design of the algal toxicity test based on BOD
bottle. A Thesis Submitted to Institute of Environmental Engineering of National Chiao Tung University.31. Nyholm N, Kälqvist T. 1989. Methods for growth inhibition toxicity tests
with freshwater algae. Environ Toxicol Chem 8:689-70332. United States Environmental Protection Agency(U.S. EPA). 1996.
Ecological Effect Test Guidelines. OPPTS 850.5400. Algal Toxicity, Tiers I and II.
33. Vasseur P, Pandard P, 1988. Influence of some experimental factors on
metal toxicity to Selenastrum capricornutum. Toxic. Assess. 3:331-34334. Lin JH. 2001. Experimental design of the algal toxicity test based on BOD
bottle. A Thesis Submitted to Institute of Environmental Engineering of National Chiao Tung University.
35. Chen CY. 1994. Theoretical evaluation of the inhibitory effects of mercury
on algal growth at various orthophosphate levels. Water Research. 28 : 931-937 .36. Millington LA, Goulding KH, Adams N. 1988. The influence of growth
medium composition on the toxicity of chemicals to algae. Water Research.22 :1593-1597.
37. Newman MC, McIntosh AW. 1991. Metal Ecotoxicology. pp.1-26. Lewis,
Michigan.38. Mazidji CN, Koopman B, Bitton G, Neita D. 1992.Distinction between
heavy metal and organic toxicity using EDTA chelation and microbial39. Sorvari J, Sillanpaa M. 1996. Influence of metal complex formation on
heavy metal and free EDTA and DTPA acute toxicity determined byDaphnia magna. Chemosphere. 33: 1119-1127
40. Hsu CH. Toxicity assessment of non-polar narcotic chemicals using a
close-system algal test. A Thesis Submitted to Institute of Environmental Engineering of National Chiai Tung University.2002.41. Plackett RL, Hewlett PS. 1952 Quantal responses to mixtures of poison, J.
Roy. Stat Soc 14:141-163
42. Christensen ER, Chen CY. 1985. A general noninteractive multiple
toxicity model including probit, logit, and Weibull transformations.Biometrics 41: 711-725.
43. Veith GD, Call DJ, Brooke LT. 1983. Structure-toxicity relationships for
the fathead minnow, Pimephales promelas: Narcotic industrial chemicals.Can J Fish Aquat Sci 40:743-748
44. Franks NB, Lieb WR. 1990. Mechanisms of general anesthesia. Environ.
Health Perspect. 87, 199.
45. Bradbury SP, Lipnick RL. 1990. Introduction: Structural properties for
determining mechanisms of toxic action. Environ Health Perspect87:181–182.
46. Schultz TW, Sinks GD, Bearden AP. 1998. QSAR in aquatic toxicology:
A mechanism of action approach comparing toxic potency to Pimephales
promelas, Tetrahymena pyriformis, and Vibrio fischeri. In Devillers J, ed, Comparative QSAR. Taylor & Francis, New York, NY, USA, pp 51–109.
47. Cronin MTD, Schultz TW. 1997. Validation of Vibrio fisheri acute toxicity
data: mechanism of action-based QSARs for non-polar narcotics and polar narcotic phenols. The Science of the Total Environment. 204:75-8848. Ren S, Frymier PD. 2002. Modeling the toxicity of polar and nonpolar
narcotic compounds to luminescent bacterial SHK1. EnvironmentalToxicology and Chemistry 21:2649-2653
49. Jawecki GN, Sawicki J. 2002. A comparison of sensitivity of spirotox
biotest with standard toxicity tests. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.42:389-395
50. Liao YY, Wang LS, He YB, Yang H. 1996. Toxicity QSAR of substituted
benzenes to yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Bull. Environ. Contam.Toxicol. 56:460-466
51. Verhaar HJM, Van Leeuwen CJ, Hermens JLM. 1992. Classifying
environmental pollutants. Structure-activity relationships for prediction of aquatic toxicity. Chemosphere 25:471–491.52. Lipnick RL. 1991.〝Outliers:their origin and use in the classification of
molecular mechanisms of toxicity〞. The Science of the Total Enviroment109:131-153
53. Takuo K, Kuino K. 1995 Acute toxicity and structure-activity relationships
of chlorophenols in fish. Water Research. 30, No.2, pp. 387-39254. Tadayoshi S, Yasuo S, Yuko T, Kikuo Y and Fumio Y. 1988. Acute
toxicity of chlorophenols to green algae , Selenastrum Capricornutum andChlorella Vulgaris, and quantitative structure-activity relationships.
Environment Toxicology and Chemistry, Vol. 7,847-7,854.
55. 中華民國環保署環境資料庫
56. Miyazaki A, Amano T, Saito H, Nakano Y. 2002. Acute toxicity of
chlorophenols to earthworms using a simple paper contact method and comparison with toxicities to fresh water organisms. Chemosphere 4757. Clotilde B, Yves P.- 2008. Joint-action ecotoxicity of binary mixtures of
glutaraldehyde and surfactants used in hospitals: Use of the Toxicity Index model and isoblogram representation. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 71 (2008) 252–259.58. Kim KT, Lee YG,Kim SD. 2005. Combined toxicity of copper and phenol
derivatives to Daphnia magna: Effect of complexation reaction.Environment International 32 (2006) 487 – 492.
59.Wang C, Lu G, Tang Z, Guo X. 2008. Quantitative tructure-activity
relationships for joint toxicity of substituted phenols and anilines to Scenedesmus obliquus. Journal of Environmental Sciences 20(2008) 115–119.60. Kim KT, Kim IS, Hwangb SH, Kim SD. 2006. Estimating the combined
effects of copper and phenol to nitrifying bacteria in wastewater treatment plants. Water Research 40 (2006) 561 – 568.61. Kristian S, Anders E, Henrik P, Nina C, Valery E.F. 2008. Mixture
toxicity of three toxicants with similar and dissimilar modes of action to Daphnia magna. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 69 (2008) 428–436.62. Wang L, Zheng Bi, Meng W. 2008. Photo-induced toxicity of four
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, singly and in combination, to the marine diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 71 (2008) 465–472.63. Lu G, Wang C, Tang Z, Guo X. 2007. Joint toxicity of aromatic
compounds to algae and QSAR study. Ecotoxicology (2007) 16:485–490.
64.Elaine M.B, Ken K, Andrew A.M. 2001. Toxicity of mono-, di- and
tri-chlorophenols to lux marked terrestrial bacteria, Burkholderia speciesRasc c2 and Psedomonas fluorescens.Chemosphere 43 (2001) 157-166.
65. Christensen ER, Chen D, Nyholm N and Kusk KO 2001. Joint action of
chemicals in algal toxicity test:influence of response level anddose-response regression model. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry(2001) 2361-2369.
66. Duan Z, Zhu L, Zhu L, Yao K, Zhu X. 2008. Individual and joint toxic
effects of pentachlorophenol and biphenol A on the development of zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryo. Ecotoxicology and Environmental safety 71 (2008) 774-780.67.Juan B. (2008). Prediction and assessment of mixture toxicity of
compounds in antifouling paints using the sea-urchin embryo-larval bioassay. Aquatic Toxicology 88 (2008) 308-315.68. Adam O, Badot P, Degiorgi F, Crini G. (2009). Mixture toxicity
assessment of wood preservative pesticides in the freshwater amphipodGammarus pulex(L.). Ecotoxicology and Environmental safety 72 (2009)
441-449.69.Chen CY and Yeh JT (1996). Toxicity of binary mixtures of reactive
toxicants. Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality (1996) 83-90.附錄一 單一原始數據
實 驗 毒 物 : 4-chlorophenol 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 : 2,3-dichlorophenol
實 驗 毒 物 : 2,4-dichlorophenol
實 驗 毒 物 : 2,4,6-trichlorophenol
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-hydroxybenzaldehyde
實 驗 毒 物 : Propinaldehyde
附錄二 混合毒性數據
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-H + 2-CP
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-H + 2-CP
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 :
3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde+2,4,6-Trichlorophenol (DO) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
MCV (μm3) : 41.53 D (μm) : 4.252 Initial pH : 7.50 EC50 A : 27.377
實 驗 毒 物 :
3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde+2,4,6-Trichlorophenol (Biomass) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
MCV (μm3) : 41.53 D (μm) : 4.252 Initial pH : 7.50 EC50 A : 32.109
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydroxybenzaldehyde+2,4,6-Trichlorophenol
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydrobenzaldehyde +
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydrobenzaldehyde + 4-chlorophenol (Biomass)
初始細胞密度
實 驗 毒 物 : 3-Hydrobenzaldehyde + 4-chlorophenol (Growth rate)
初始細胞密度
實 驗 毒 物:Propinaldehyde(1.615) + 2-CP(2.162) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物:Propinaldehyde(1.425) + 2-CP(2.352) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物:Propinaldehyde(1.534) + 2-CP(2.655) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物:Propinaldehyde(1.343) + 4-CP(1.175) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物:Propinaldehyde(1.425) + 4-CP(1.464)
實 驗 毒 物:Propinaldehyde(1.534) + 4-CP(1.337)
實驗毒物:2,3-DP(2.209)
+
Propinaldehyde(1.343)實 驗 毒 物:2,3-DP(2.123)+Propinaldehyde(1.425) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物:2,3-DP(2.436)+Propinaldehyde(1.534) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實驗毒物:2,4-DP(1.979)
+
Propinaldehyde(1.343) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000實 驗 毒 物:2,4-DP(2.239)+Propinaldehyde(1.425) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物:2,4-DP(2.408)+Propinaldehyde(1.534) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實驗毒物:2,4,6-TCP(3.525)
+
Propinaldehyde(1.343) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000實驗毒物:2,4,6-TCP(1.945)+Propinaldehyde(1.425) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實驗毒物:2,4,6-TCP(2.333)+Propinaldehyde(1.534) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-Chlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-Chlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde
實 驗 毒 物 :2-Chlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :4-Chlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :4-Chlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde
實 驗 毒 物 :4-Chlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,3-Dichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,3-Dichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,3-Dichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,4-Dichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,4-Dichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,4-Dichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,4,6-Trichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,4,6-Trichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2,4,6-Trichlorophenol+Glutaraldehyde 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-CP+3-H (3:1) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-CP+3-H (3:1) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-CP+3-H (3:1) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-CP+3-H (1:3) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-CP+3-H (1:3) 初始細胞密(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :2-CP+3-H(1:3) 初始細胞密(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :Propinaldehyde+2-chlorophenol(1:3) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :Propinaldehyde+2-chlorophenol(1:3)
實 驗 毒 物 :Propinaldehyde+2-chlorophenol(1:3)
實 驗 毒 物 :Propinaldehyde+2-chlorophenol(3:1) 初始細胞密度(cells/mL) : 15000
實 驗 毒 物 :Propinaldehyde+2-chlorophenol(3:1)
實 驗 毒 物 :Propinaldehyde+2-chlorophenol(3:1)
附錄三 HPLC校正曲線
0 100000 200000 300000 400000 500000