義務教育階段之弱勢學生的補救教育之調查研究

全文

(1)ñÃðb I8 } 90 46(1) 45-65. Dÿ I. 45. [ Iæ²Þõð¡Dÿ IÞa¥@ ¹®Ê. }³ÃñÃðkF IðA. ; I |¯I·í£i@> ñäõð¡õð. ¨2ÄèöDÿ I[õð¡~WêÚð¶.õSP¤D ´ ô $rÌ¡¨^¹tÕ}Ã~n.ÞÏt}¡§FIª8 w¨2úmYÃ._÷ÜóWêÚýFt¨Î8õð¡û8 ¨28.$ÚãÚãDÿ IÞ/Wð]Dÿ I0½ es; ñô¢DÿJqÝð]Dÿ0(eÚS^cDÿ¥æ òÉæ]òð¬¨2erD ñô¢Jqûõä Þâ]àð¡ Âþérqð¡å½ª| ðÄòN öô]IDÝ|¢0Ú ávy$Jq¶Úá²¨]àÂþ{Ï} 0ä ýFt ¨^ ÜóÚ Dÿ I õð¡. P. Dÿ IJ:L~Lö i IôÄí£õ¥|Û Iw² á¥|ô]ð¶D I |²Ï{<r¥ |æ»¾ð*à9 Iq I |¯I² :}Üó+} ¡

(2) :L ÷¶¥|à 5¡ëD^û¡ò>Ïôw] ¡º |·ñàY¼aÜ°·ñà° Ið± R aw ls õcÛ>ö¨

(3) óB ô(fairness) INöIL¥

(4) ¨

(5) ¼aôÿ$IL¥

(6) ¡ãI ug ö¨

(7) S |IÄït¨

(8) | I¨

(9) ¼aôt$ |Á>5äLÏû Ü°Iõ# |I¨

(10) "/Lw ¦ô

(11) ãJ~Dïtït¨

(12) ( L B<I 8 6)<} 1 9 67 6½<³b7(P lo w d en R ep ort) w ª N 6 V ï _ 7 (po sitive discrim inatio n )LúNª|Ví£ I°õ±DBÄáït¶ït¨

(13) ÒjNb¶ªN6 IúÑb7Z öc~ IúÑb(E d u cation al P riority A reas, E P A s). ðÏp DD%nVï_¢ <}ú±ë.*õ¨

(14) (S ilver, & S ilver, 19 91)>¥;Ñ³WÚIr$¬V ït¨

(15) ×Ö# |¯I. Ãð¬swüõð¡8.. }ñ^õDÿ ðcÛ²>ð~sw ð¡Ï:L«

(16) ¡ 85 ÐV¡:{ 86 Æô 87 3}ð± K irk L¹®Ê ð~sw Þ¨ðÃ.÷WêÄ¡ð¶mç °ð*õãÒDÿ IéÞ,6Ãð¬ N— swð¡^äÞt¶_>¥swÞ= àÎð¶~ä*$@äDÿ Ié Þi K irk tõWêð¶õ ÷ÏÀ<ð¬ | ýÚ<Ú· ðÚËIûr¨ðæ_ >ÝäNûÉPµ} ðÚË_ÖS ÂéNÚË ñ ð£ÖÚ ñÈ_ÚË r»iÚËID¡ñõð¶á]õ¡Ú_ ËÇ. ». ÷ø ôöûüø ø. ø. ¼.

(17) ¹®Ê. 46. ýP+ä»~X+ä}ÃÖPâWÏ Ñ±ð¬+äI¡i}~sw õ}ñb÷ç~°Wêð¶´;° Xá½ý Iò\Da°¡ð¶

(18) kF IH[«Dw A ldem an b÷ (19 94) 5jWêÄ¡¡ið¶¡ð~ê nè ÷ç °$rð¡p ´; Wê·¡ð¶ng}Ã¨QsnèÃÖ +ä(ÇD8Üó<ÚyIq°ûº ð¡^ûðÏ^ûWêð¶|¡¡ii °~PDò.¡+ä}s£Üó¥;W ê4J´À<}~ð¶à>ò.RÖ5ä t²Þj«K avale, 19 88 L¹®Ê }ñS8 ¶5jÜÝ[~· IAYÄF ÅÃf$ú0[~æyÄ IAY¹=±FÅ Ãf¹=>£ë°X÷8swð¡ NSWê¡ð¶>ð¶ngÛâ ç ° £ë°Xsw÷8_>5j$rð¡õÌ£ .* w$swàÎð¶Dûrð¶ò.ð¡õ .*ð¬(áð¡Î;ÚÎê>ÝÞÏõ ð¡(disadvantaged students)õ}tfõ ð¡² i;<ÄýÚð¡»µh 84 Pilling, 1990 ð*@VëB@±õ} |

(19) ë.@É¢õãÒ6³]ð¡7 [ I æ²Dÿ IAÞ@Þ,>WêÚð¶ õð¡ÏDÿ Ia¥Þ: ËÇ. ÉÅ. ÀÀ. tõWêð¶ À<ð¬ | ýÚ <Ú ðÚË. ¡ñõð¶ ÃÖ+äÃÖút Pâ+ä WÏÑ±+ä ð¬+ä X]~õ. sw. çswÞ_Öð¶ "L¹®Ê 8 4 ð¬+ä± I1 1 0 r. Wê·¡ð¶n g.sw Wêð¶.sw ý-ÚW ¥|<Ú ðÚË ÚË. ¡ñõð¶.sw Ã¨ PâÀX]~õ WÏÑ±+ä ð¬+ä. ç Wê·¡ð¶ð~swêAY "L¹®Ê 8 4 ð¬+ä± I1 0 8 r. è}Dÿ I[. õ^{<:(elitism ) ®ð. I:L> ¥|]6ÃÏ I:L¬¿ð*> I² gµú>ð¡> }Ü¥|´¡×> ^ð.¼abµÄMDõI:¥| Û¼að¡§

(20) Igõ ¡ð¬>ªG¡Dõ 1 99 0 D^ûÐà5 }Ü6!

(21) ¥|It¶Cª=¡¨¶ t¿¿ªN IýnõVït¨

(22) #è}Ã._÷¡ð¬/ÄWê< ýð¶m^éNfC;ð¬/mû ï/}·è}ôë(integration) fCë ½ý IÄkF IW?³^5äéND<}

(23) ôë(inclu sion) I ½ý IÄkF I ëDÏéN õ*ÚºkF IJ®>Úã¥ |ý'Á<}õ

(24) IAõhQ½ý ð.ðð¡ûï/Þpr°¶$Úã }kF I¢ H[«áõ+ä disabilities ð¡nô÷8å§kF I ð¡øërEe?eN+äð¡¡µ õ 1 0 % úÖ>ëÏkF IJð*$ ð±:»6ÇÒë7>½ýrP IWêÏ: n8Zð.ôÇÒH[Á(full service m o del) .

(25) Dÿ I. ;Wêð¶swð¡}új$B I0±ë1 95 0 DÈÄ 19 60 D}õý c<*Ä¥|I:=[Þ®àÖg¥ |õ õð. Ip (S ilver, & S ilver, 19 91) Dû Ico m p en satory edu catio n :L «Sô· µ B»µh 84 19 6 4 ¥]d (P resid ent Jo hn son) 5w 6 ýô7(w ar on p o verty) Ë"]dÒ°L ÇÒ}ôýnLÒ=¬¿] dY H ub ert H u m p hrey ¶Ï 19 64 ýô JÆÒ°6… . hQ Iùe ô± ³ô ÃÞ` I_>q

(26) ¥b

(27) }Ür $¶_>qèª=<·ý+¥>z úô±B¶ÚÔË> eD7( L S ilver, & S ilver, 19 91, p.70)Þc:LDÒN +ðp¡1 9 65 6Ì I7(H ead S tart) ·6Ñ I IÄÛI Ir0á7 (T itle I of th e elem entary an d S econ dary E du catio n A ct) ¶OÏ6 á7(T itle I) > 19 8 1 6 I

(28) ëÄýÌr0 #7(C hapter I of the E du catio n C o n solid ation and Im pro vem ent A ct) ¶OÏ6#7(C h apter I) }ûrDû Iö«,<ôÜón¥; õ}¥|ôÄ µ B0ýøð*û õ Û²ã"$<ÄýgÚ (ÇÞð¡öõÆí£ I5 jõÉð »|NjQj«nc~ !y@»áû0(K eplan, 19 98)å M$ð±eNõð æ²Ì IÆÜ ï |õ~|»

(29) ¥|IÎp°ø ®ï(B erk, 19 9 6) ûÝÈ!y; 1 9 90 DÈ S³Q¼Dÿ0Úê Kà 85 <}kF Iôë IJð.° (su pp ort) kF/ð¡«Úi;+äð¡8¶ Ú>÷8~ákF IH[«ð*¶Sr Wêð¶swð¡>ÝH[kF/. 47. ð¡¡µláð¡Þ 2 0% =;B}Ü +äð¡Þ(e}úeN+äð¡ 1 0 % ¹®Ê 9 0 ¶_>ókF IJÐð. ñèswð¡Dõ I. °nÚi; ½ýr

(30) I]A ¤kFrkFð. Ï

(31) ] IA°D8ð.·ô IËô ¢äæ²÷Îëp±ëð¡kF/ÞÏ äæ²±ëkF/Á (th e 5 -stage m od el for m eetin g S E N ) äæ²ÁVë½ý IDÿ éÄkF InÜð.ÿÉDÿH[Á 6kF IDÿÞt<}ú¶½kF IZ³°AÏBõð¡Z³ú0 °ASÉF IóÖH[E d ucation C hild P rotectio n S ervice :Lõª|ð.¡·Z· > B~ráóÖÉFÞðÈ:L ,§Fð¡ÞH[ûïý IH[ M ulti-culture E d ucation S ervice :Lõ ð. ·ÜÝÓã ¥| µ ð¡S¡ ít~!J(travellers) FÅjt,ôôb ð.1 96 7 <}úªN IúÑb(E d ucatio n al P riority A reas, E P A s) ¥ú~ í6¥|+ä (so cial h andicap) >ôôbðG2>ZX Wc~¥;õ 1 9 72 H alsey @ 5j$iÄÚ Àvö H alsey ë»á Iú ÑbKnðÚÄcwð]¨ðDD %n6Vï_7Þ ë{É B<ßßSs5è=ð»µh 8 6 Þc<}úö $JqnÉ[ ¹(E xcellen ce in C ities) IN+b(E du catio n A ctio n Z o ne) ð¬ÄìÖÏ·|(L earnin g an d S kills C ou ncil) ñë<}(B rin gin g B ritain T o geth er) Ièö N+<}ú3°X[N+VNÄ 1 990 È~Ò}ÔVNgs»áWê+ äÄLð¬swp Þõ 20 00 gs ªN6éð. -- Z³ð¬¥b7 (S cho ols P lu s:.

(32) 48. ¹®Ê. Þ0ÔÖ IÚbð¡_>$éð.ð¬[p rShQð.AH[ñàÄ:ð.Ä¥b ã]ö(D fE E , 2000) ¥°X<}[}ö$tã n Q¼ð.;WêÚ »õð¡V éÓãÍè}} Ë5 W1 Iýnb*ªäöZÞW1 IýnÏ·| 8 5 ÛªN6³ ]ð¡7]ZSýnÂÄ ð{Éð .Är»ãÁ#ð.L:-5ð.L: ]ð¡$ Ö¨Z³Dÿ ðAQ¼¡ ?òª|ûïÌogZð¡WÏòs]Q ¼X+ä Ig¨^ I#I Ió+ I"tIª ö]éÛ ]ð¡$ Ö¨Z³Dÿ ðAQ¼¡ ?òª|ûïÌogZð¡WÏòs]Q ¼X+ä Ig¨^ I#I IIö¯õ³±±ëð.ñè8õð¡V õð¡õð.Ö³WInhQð. Iðð¡ûï/Ö¨W1 Iýnw Ï·| ËÈö}ñÐ¤ýDÿ ð nË"¤ý^^cò«Úi;sw DÿåMÝ¢~Ëp ðQ¼Âõ} 8 6 I u ÝÏ swð¡Vð ]Dÿ ðà9Dÿ ðÜÚi;õ ðÈÛ¶Úi;ñàÄ ñ(ÇIÐV¡: { 86 ;<Úp I ¶õ 8 5 buildin g learn in g co m m u nities). dC<} IúÑbªN IúÑbN+( B< I 8 6)_Nè}úõ 8 0 D¶àÖ¨ WêÚ IêVð]èöDÿ I 0ONÒÙûr0ð]ÖõLr» ñmèöõð¡¨ê¬ æNÒm &bð*@#>õð¡8.· èDÿ IéÞâ~äá ñõð¡ Dÿ IÞ[. > ñOY@õð¡ I/. á@ I/_>¥e~^ä ú²(eD I²µ Ö úË IgÚá_>N, I/jm_>¥ð¡¡µD¬ $ñ ª|Üóµ} 87 ñ Ns£ Ï 5 2, 19 4lÒ}ÜóÞ 0.88 %D¡µÏ 1 2 0,10 9 ¡lÒ}¡µÞ 0.5 5 % nreNð¡¡ µD I n$8mðð¡¡µN> Ú>ðe¥ ñ[^ðeö ñ¡µ( ±Ú>ðe/Ôn¥; ñ I6 #$ IiQ¯/L ñ~ L am b er(1 9 94) Z¢åú0«_>Ï@ e~> ñNNN_>ËpDÿ I/wdCöÚÖµÔn _>ã"ª|/Ô(eÄp 8.IèµÔ °eû ±e2ª|ð*@ ¢ ñNNÏ:Le~.

(33) Dÿ I. ê òÎpòN+ u0 D0 Éè0 ¹0 ð]Üóò }Ûªìú I0 IúÑb ç òN+ ïY Û ðð¡ð Dÿ ð ÖÖà5 I ¬Ý Ir ûïÖ¨à5r. 49. Ò I Ö~ð]áð¡Dÿ ðò0. ðWD. H[«. u ³ 7 " }Ûs~ ðw~ 6 " Æå§ qÇÎiñ.wÉw ÚJ p Üó 82 ÚQ ð$[~éYÃ+ð+ð¡ 84 P² ¨Ûs£ð¡(eQ=ìkFQ ôb¤D ´P´Üóð¡(e 85-87 Q=Û ð¡(eQ=}Û ðeQsç WÏVòôbð¡¿Rgº v ñº]eD^(eQ=kFôiWêÚ ð é0ÚWIªö~¿ð. 87 Mì ¨2QïWÏð¡ }ÛÉÛ ð¡ 86 r 10-20% ð¬#cð¡ 87 ð¬¨2¡À¨2. 80 86. r@¬. ;}ñð.è8õð¡õð¨ê> úð]Dÿ I0¯NÒma¥ b>j$Vït¨

(34) IÍ@Ä B@±>

(35) ë@ëp>½ýð. ñÏ«d>cL¬ }ñõð¡8.Äõð .¨2> ñûrð¡ðé>c. õð¡8. áð¡N ´ô $r§F. P¤D Ì¡¹tÕ}Ã~n.Þ Ït}¡ ¨^. X+äð¡. ¨¨´]]pm$Wp ð¬Ö¨W#cãrãð $WÑ±¨WÏp $Rg¿ìóWÚ<q$p X]~õ$}~Ip . L}ñ½ýð.ðûïð¡/jw@ >Wê+äõð¡Ï«DjtÅN+÷ ¥=ñÃÖ< ò>X+ä·nñÃ ¿ ò>emútswÏ:Lä«ç :óB@>è8õð¡¨2»k F/> ñ^úJð]0Þ e>BLÏûrõð¡ôðJqÄ LÏ:Lg. ¨2. ð~ ¡À WÏ. emútð¡. Bn|s# r×ÖNnBm. Dÿé. ôé Ûu ô ð.. ñõ I Dÿé. ç6³]ð¡7Þ

(36) ë@:ç NÏ@@«\.

(37) ¹®Ê. 50. @r @¢f·ôY|ñ.*õ ð¡ð.ÚJð¡8.·^}ñÆð ]DÿéÜp¢ñàÞ:ôY|÷; UbbàÜ\ð. ñW¡·ÜÝDÒ ¢cñÄï.*ñ¨2ð¡Þ 8.Ä_ÖÞ¨2>ú0ðé6c£ë Nª8WêÚ8.SP¤D ´ô $rÌ¡¨^¹tÕ}Ã~n.. ÞÏt}¡§FI°X8.õj$f¶ 5jè8.N¡µÜóµö(eÚ n$ûrð¡õ"LÒ õð¡ 8.áÞcjÄB@¡·Óã!ç6 ñ ð[a¥Ò7p¢k èÅN+ã+Þa¥ñ àÄ¬¿

(38) ë¬õñ ñ[Ûõð¡ ¨2>_ÖÞDÿ Ié. Ò }ñè_ÖWêÚ¡µÜóµÞN. Ú8. N. 1. P ¤D ´ s£ §F ¨^ Ì¡ 86) 84 87 84 87 86 7% ÞÜó 0.08% Üó 0.82 ¦Üó 3127 Ç 1.81% ¡ 249 ¡ (. p¢!ç p¢ÏcL ñõ½ýr»mÞèöõ ð¡ ði°p >L°Xp /Þ°ep¢ñà6SeúX+ äð¡áð¡ÄRgQïð¡Þ¨2Ä/a ¥DÿéIÃötjdCú0fÁÞ ê ñ=È_Öð¶D!£¡ e ñÎpVNY> ñ IýnÞürÓ Nòö@ ÷YáWêÚð¡Þ¨2Ä /a¥> ñDÿéürIÃö p¢÷õUÛbò}ÛÉ ñò] ±Pp¢é0@¡·Ô£ë ñNNgs OcÔ\}ÛÉ ñè]ÌW )±P 6±Pñàt¶eN2x"â æ² }É }Û É. b U Û M U Û N. 2.. p¢ p¢ÏªGp¢ñ(enCë ñ ~AYe ñIPöÑ¢èñ .1ÞÂÈ ñÌÀ]Ûwôb ñÌ 8Ä}ÛÉæ²ôñ¥º@> 88 ÂEÈâõñÃ·ñ1àé}Û É ñÌð÷rÞð¡Ïa¥«@~ Þ½ýr ñi;È ;}ÛÉÞ½ýr ñ ; 88 ÂEÈâÃñÃ·ñ1à é}ÛÉ ñÌð÷rÛx±Ò(} bµ 3 0 r9 00 BñpÏp¢a¥«¢° ^Þ·ôæ]2NË_ñ6=Û [kFð.kFr ñNñ$p¢ 8 3 8 Ë. Ò@p¢a¥«¥º÷). r»µ 6 3 4 2 7 3 5 30. }Ñ }U,U,<ñ(3) Ûñ(1) ñ(1) ñÃ, I,(2) ñ:ò(1) =ñ: I,ò(1) 9. í¥ }U,U(2) Ûñ(1) Nñ(1) Æñ(1) ñÃ,l,ô(1) ñ:l,ô(1) =ñ:<,}(1) 8. µi ] }U(1) Ýñ(1) Nñ(1) ñ(1) Mñ(1) ñÃ:µ(1) ñÃ:],,q(3) ñ:¡(1) =ñ:µ,,ý(2) =ñ,q(1) 7. 6.

(39) Dÿ I. 51. a¥« @>ÂÈÌ ñÏº6Cï Òm¥º>hQñeÞtjt$:L CÌ ñ¯ ðeõ>° ë@Ô>ã ðÑê ñÏ«Þ (ÇðÏC ñ~ãYDÿ ð_Ö ê@>È >° ñÏa¥ « dÄÌ ñN; ñ~(v ïãUÁeN(vá,wÏV ÁVN5j@º~LÒ} 2 3 j _÷w^ÛÈ nU6ûl 1 3.7 % nUj·=ð)Þl 9 .8% H[ð.$ÇÒÛ. ð}Û·}É>}É ñqûl 5 2.4 % H [e6 Ï 3 -5 l 12 ¦¡µ6ûÏH[e õ 6 -15 l 4 1.9% §ä ñ[[>òñÏ6 ûl 47.4 % È ñ)Þl 13.8 % 6=ð# >Ãðð]Ï6ûl 8 0.8% ð#)Þl 16 % ÛðLñ1.s~D¥Á ñe?±Ï 6ûl 77.6% Ið÷r)Þl 13.1% $ ºÛ$k ~ð÷Sk A:±l 19.9 % D$ò~ð÷SòA: ±l 4 3.6 % Ö<ÈÄA 8 8 ºD Ò_å§. @3$º ËÆË ] ñ$ ÊÉÈ ÈÄ ]ÚI ñÆ ÖÞ¨2ð¡ ÒrÛ> PÜó ñÏ6û ñ ÊÉÈ ]õ}ÛÉæ²ïÚû) ¤D ´ð¡$ ñ }ÛÉæ². ïtÚÃÔ)ôs£$Xµ ñ }Û ñ ~Ls£ð¡v}É ñqû6 §F $ ÈÄ ] ñÉÁÄ¸ Ò° BÙ$ µ ñÄÀÆ ]ªNp¢° $8.SdÄÂ ¡}~·´ÜóI. 3.. @VN. Òr§P ñÆ ¨2ð¡Þ ñ¡µÄ;÷(. ¨28. PÜó ¤D ´ ô $r §F Ì¡ Í.¹tÕ} Ã~n¡ .ÞÏt}¡ ¨^ BdÄÂ B ¡}~ B´Üó. ÜóÚ¨2. }É(N = 450) 407(90.4% ) 307(68.2% ) 231(51.3% ) 30(6.7% ) 58(12.9% ) 21(4.7% ) 63(14% ) 22(4.9% ) 40(8.9% ) 216(48% ) 0 0 1(0.2% ). ÒrÖèöÜóÚ8.P¤D ´ô $r§F·´ÜóI¯$. }Û. (N = 388) 358(92.3% ) 287(74% ) 233(60.1% ) 21(5.4% ) 49(12.6% ) 38(9.8% ) 64(16.5% ) 46(11.9% ) 37(9.5% ) 229(59% ) 2(0.3% ) 3(0.8% ) 0. Ò]. N = 838 765(91.1% ) 594(70.7% ) 464(55.3% ) 51(6.1% ) 107(12.7% ) 59(7.0% ) 127(15.1% ) 68(8.1% ) 77(9.2% ) 445(53.1% ) 2(0.2% ) 3(0.3% ) 1(0.1% ). . ñåûrð¡> P ñÏ6û )Ï¤D ´lõ)wÕÏô lXµ§Fl $r l È¸ $ ñ ´Üóð¡ ñ.

(40) ¹®Ê. 52. ïÏè8ð¡¨2"LÒä 1. PÜó õPÜóm6û ñÒ°¨2$ð¬ YÚyÀ<ÜóÜò)Ïð¬] Äyx s#Ô)Ï¡À¬Úûrö¯$ 40 % > °Bñûµ)rm°r»ð¬ Yté p ·ñép Iö¶$÷Þ>°. 8. ñûµ_NPÜóð¡õð~°$ð¬ YÚyð¬] s#·rm°ð¬ YI p õ¡Àm$À<ÜóÜò¡À¬Ú Ip DWÏm$téñéI p ÁgN$ 1/4 ñÒ°PÜó ð¡$ÚËtWÏ¬. ÒäÜóÚð¡Þ¨2ÑÜ PÜó ¤D ´ ô (n= 765) (n= 594) (n= 464). ð~¨2 ð¬] yxs# ð¬YÚy°^ÚÚHR^ rm°r»ð¬ÌY ð ñà OPÌY ð âI·Òjït^Ã B ¡À¨2 <$¨2áÚwrÈô² ¡À¬ÚX]X0²À ^¶ À<ÜóÜòÀ<Ü¡±ë¾á Ö¡ ¾á^ r±ëLÏp B WÏ¨2 téWÏp ¸¨þê .ãrãI ñéWÏp ö{Lè

(41) ÛÑ±¨Þ³ÚdÄæ]¡ÀI ÚËtWÏ¬ mNj¾áWÏ B. r. §F. (n= 51). (n= 107). 353(46.1% ). 261(47.3% ). 186(40.1% ). 17(33.3% ). 54(50.5% ). 432(56.5% ). 364(61.3% ). 165(35.6% ). 16(31.4% ). 62(57.9% ). 268(35.0% ). 237(39.9% ). 169(36.4% ). 17(33.3% ). 52(48.6% ). 31(4.1% ). 18(3.0% ). 17(3.7% ). 3(5.9% ). 3(2.8% ). 132(17.3% ). 59(9.9% ). 39(8.4% ). 3(5.9% ). 16(15.0% ). 46(6.0% ). 24(4.0% ). 26(5.6% ). 3(5.9% ). 2(1.9% ). 163(21.3% ). 110(18.5% ). 245(52.8% ). 16(31.4% ). 26(24.3% ). 315(41.2% ). 263(44.3% ). 173(37.3% ). 17(33.3% ). 54(50.5% ). 432(56.5% ). 321(54.0% ). 173(37.3% ). 20(39.2% ). 50(46.7% ). 62(8.1% ). 35(5.9% ). 36(7.8% ). 11(21.6% ). 9(8.4% ). 143(18.7% ) 32(4.2% ). 103(17.3% ) 24(4.0% ). 51(11.0% ) 12(2.6% ). 7(13.7% ) 293.9% ). 19(17.8% ). 293(38.3% ). 215(36.2% ). 60(12.9% ). 16(31.4% ). 37(34.6% ). 255(33.3% ). 198(33.3% ). 190(40.9% ). 14(27.5% ). 55(51.4% ). 197(25.8% ). 149(25.1% ). 72(15.5% ). 13(25.5% ). 37(34.6% ). 52(6.8% ). 37(6.2% ). 31(6.7% ). 2(3.9% ). 16(15.0% ). 45(5.9% ). 26(4.4% ). 20(4.3% ). 3(5.9% ). 3(2.8% ). 3(2.8% ).

(42) Dÿ I. ¤D ´ ¤D ´ð¡6û ñÒ°¨2Ïð¬ YÚy(61.3% ))wÕÏÀ<ÜóÜòð¬ ] Äyxs#¡À¬Ú·rm°r» ð¬ Yûrö¯$ 4 0 % ~aBñûµ) tép ·ñép Iö¶$÷Þ> ° ñûµ_N¤D ´ð¡õð~°$ð ¬YÚyð¬] s#·rm°ð¬ YI p õ¡Àm$À<ÜóÜò¡À¬ ÚIp DWÏm$téñéI p ÁgN$ 1/4 ñÒ°¤D ´ð¡$ÚËtWÏ¬ 3. ôs£Üó ôs£Üóð¡6û ñÒ°¨ 2Ï<$¨2SáÚwrÈôºð ²I( l 5 2 % ) )wÕÏð¬] Äyxs# ·ñép ¯$ 40 % >°Bñûµ)$ ð¬YÚyrm°r»ð¬ Y¡À¬ ÚÀ<ÜóÜòIrö¶$÷Þ>° ñûµ_Ns£Üóð¡õð~°$ð ¬YÚyð¬] s#·rm°ð¬ YI p õ¡Àm$<$¨2À<ÜóÜ ò¡À¬ÚIp DWÏm$ñé p 4. $r $rð¡6û ñÒ°¨2ÏÀ< ÜóÜò( l 39.2 % ) )wÕÏð¬] Äyx s#·rm°r»ð¬ Y¡À¬Úð ¬YÚy<$¨2téWÏp Iò ö¯$ 30 % >°Bñûµjt¶$ 2 5% >° ñûµñéWÏp ·ÚËtWÏ Ip _N $rð¡¡µöÚûnõ ð.ð¬¶Nj8ms£ð¡¨2 5. §F §Fm6û ñÒ°¨2Ïð¬Y Úy)ÏñéWÏp ð¬] yxs 2.. 53. #·¡À¬ÚI¯$ 5 0% >° ñû µ)wÕÏrm°r»ð¬ Y·¡À¬ Ú¯$ 40 % >°BñûµÔ)Ïté p ·ÚËtWÏI¶$÷Þ>° ñûµ_N§Fð¡õð~°$ð¬YÚy ð¬] s#·rm°ð¬ YIp õ ¡Àm$À<ÜóÜò¡À¬ÚIp DWÏm$téWÏp ñéWÏp ·ÚËtWÏI¨2 £ë°X5jÜóÚè8.ð¡Ã.¯ >¡Àm¨2Ï:DèÜóÚð ¡6û ñûµvL¨2è$ïtPÄ¤D ´·rð¡>À<ÜòÏ6û ñûµ ¨2Dôð¡><¨2Ï6ûD§F >¡À¬ÚÏ6ûÜóÚ)L¨2õ ð¬mSð¬YÚyð¬] ÚyõW Ïm¨2 $§F·ôð¡$v=( e ñïÏB$ñéWÏp . ýFt¨2. ýFt8.õÒr> ¨^ð¡ ñÏ6ûlä) Ín¹tÕ}w ð¡Þ ñl§ä ñÞ ÄÈ¸Ã~n¡· t}¡

(43) ¯õ ËÀÌ¸ÞâÙÃ~n¡>}Û ñ (eÏ}É ñÞ{Ã~n¡>} Ûæ²~nÏû*/LÌL ñïÏè8ð ¡¨2"LÒò 1. Ì¡ Ì¡m( Òò) 6û ñÒ°¨2Ïð ~mrm°r»ð¬ YX ñûµ *ö4 7.5 % )¶ð~mð¬YÚ y25.4% Ô)wÕÏñéWÏp 2 2.0 % >À<ÜóÜò2 0.3 % £Þõ ñ ïÏÌ¡>ð~mp vûSmÚ°Ì Yð¬YÚy)WÏmñé{W Ïp >¡ÀmÀ<ÜóÜò¯$ä÷.

(44) 54. ¹®Ê. Þ ñ*Ò° 2. Í.¹tÕnð¡ ¥;np~è },ý^ûð.Nj$ ð¡Í.Æõ}táèwðÔYÍ.Õ} ±ûrð¡p Òò6û ñÒ° ¨2= õð~m6û ñÒ°rmÁ° r»ð¬ Y3 2.3 % )Ïð âI· ÒjïtÃ 2 5.3 % Ô)Ïð¬YÚy (18.9 % ) Bm¡À¨2¶$ 1 8 ](1 4.2 % ) ñÒ°Bð¬] s#NjtÚ ËWÏp I£ÞÍ.¹tÕnð¡õ ñïÏ>ð~mp vû) WÏmp ¡Àmp v 3. Ã~n¡ Í}ñìJà9Ã~nwð ¡õð.¶àÖNjjýÚð¡ûr ð¡p Òòõ 68 ] ñN N6û ñÒ°¨2ÏrmÁ°r»ð¬ Y3 6.8 % ñûµ)ÏWÏp ñéWÏ2 0.6% õ)ð~p ð â ïtÃ>¡ÀmÀ<ÜóÜò¯$ 1 7.6 % ñûµ£ÞÃ~nð¡õ ñï Ï>ð~mp vû)WÏm p ¡Àmp v . t}¡.ÞÏt}¡ Í}ñ¥|},ýt}¡.ÞÏ t}¡ð¡¶àÖNjõ}ñ.*ûrð¡ p Òòõ 7 7 ] ñNN6 û ñÒ°¨2ÏrmÁ°r»ð¬ Y3 5.1 % )ð¬YÄð¬] Úyè $ 3 2.5% ñûµõ)ÏÀ<ÜóÜ ò 2 7.3% £Þt}¡ÉF.ÞÏ t}¡Þð¡õ ñïÏ>ð~p vû)¡Àmp WÏmp v 5. ¨^ ¨^è}ÀýÚð¡û rð¡p Òòõ 4 45 ] ñ NN6û ñÒ°ð~m¨2$r >° ñÒ°¨^ð¡ð¬] yxs #rm°r°ð¬ Yð¬YÚy )Ï¡Àm¡À¬ÚyÀ<ÜóÜò 38 % >° û8 ñûµ*öÔ)Ïté ñép <¨2 2 0% >° ñ ûµ£Þ¨^ð¡õ ñïÏ>ð¬ mp vû)¡Àmp W Ïmp v 4..

(45) Dÿ I. 8. . 55. ÒòýFtð¡¨2 Ì¡ ¹tÕ} Ã~n. ð~¨2 ð¬] yxs# ð¬YÚy°^ÚÚHR^ rm°r»ð¬ÌY ð ñà OPÌY ð âI·Òjït^Ã B ¡À¨2 <$¨2áÚwrÈô² ¡À¬ÚX]X0²À^ ¶ À<ÜóÜòÀ<Ü¡±ë¾á Ö¡ ¾á^ r±ëLÏp B WÏ¨2 téWÏp ¸¨þê .ãrãI ñéWÏp ö{Lè

(46) Û Ñ±¨Þ³ÚdÄæ]¡ÀI ÚËtWÏ¬ mNj¾áWÏ B. (n= 59). (n= 127). (n= 68). 5(18.6% ). 6(14.2% ). 8(25.4% ). t}¡. ¨^. (n= 77). (n= 445). 5(13.2% ). 3(32.5% ). 214(48.1% ). 8(18.9% ). 7(13.2% ). 12(32.5% ). 197(44.3% ). 12(47.5% ). 10(32.3% ). 12(36.8% ). 21(35.1% ). 208(46.7% ). 3(8.5% ). 5(11.8% ). 5(5.9% ). 5(3.9% ). 17(3.8% ). 2(13.6% ). 4(25.3% ). 4(17.6% ). 10(18.2% ). 84(18.9% ). 9(3.4% ). 18(5.5% ). 7(2.9% ). 5(3.9% ). 22(4.9% ). 7(8.5% ). 11(4.7% ). 5(7.4% ). 14(3.9% ). 99(22.2% ). 13(13.6% ). 17(6.3% ). 14(10.3% ). 13(15.2% ). 174(39.1% ). 11(20.3% ). 18(7.9% ). 5(17.6% ). 10(27.3% ). 170(38.2% ). 4(5.1% ). 11(3.9% ). 4(7.4% ). 6(6.5% ). 35(7.9% ). 8(3.4% ). 11(3.1% ). 8(5.9% ). 7(13.0% ). 40(9.0% ). 59(15.3% ). 127(14.2% ). 68(10.3% ). 77(6.5% ). 28(6.3% ). 18(11.9% ). 9(8.7% ). 25(7.4% ). 214(18.2% ). 124(27.9% ). 24(22.0% ). 9(13.4% ). 25(20.6% ). 197(16.9% ). 103(23.1% ). 41(18.6% ). 25(14.2% ). 27(7.4% ). 208(13.0% ). 85(19.1% ). 15(6.8% ) 32(13.6% ). 4(8.7% ) 12(8.7% ). 3(5.9% ) 14(11.8%. 17(9.1% ) 840%. 24(5.4% ) 37(8.3% ). ýFtè8.ð¡¶$.¯>ð¬ ¨2Ï:6¨^>ÞtBè8¯>mÚ °r»ð¬ YÏvL¨2ð¬YÚyÄð IÄÒjâïtÃ¶vû ñ2j¨2B ñép WÏ¶vû¨2nõ¹tÕ}ð ¡WÏp >ÚË·tWÏvû ñ 2jõ¡Àm6¹tÕ}ð¡ÞtB 8¶¯$ ñ2jÀ<ÜóÜòö¨^ ÄBr8ýFtõð¡$ ÷8mÞ Î¶>ð~¨26û ñ2jnð¬¨2 p ·BýFtÞ8.ÚãD8B¡À ÄWÏ¨2¶Ú ñïÏ$¨2¨2 ½ÄBýFt8.$ït@õD ÿ IéÞ÷Yá ¨^?³;ýFtÞ tj?³Ï8. Dÿéa¥e÷Y Wmð]Dÿ0 @ä ñðékwúÄ ñ õ Iñª|émäõÛuú 03 Ic.· I ôbI~ñ® Ö$0Dÿ ðÞéSòòN+Þu DÉè¹I0ìú I IúÑb Dÿ ðÛ ðð¡ýbðò0ÖÖ à5 IIN+èN+¯õ 8 0 DÞcÉ D¬¿I"LdCÒ6Ûuú ð]°XDÿ0tjhQð.jú I ËDÿ0ÓÖªäö0ûr0õ° XÈ ¨2ð¡ 51 7 8 8 ÚI ñK ®cwÜóÚýFt¨Î8.

(47) ¹®Ê. 56. ä 1. W;ÜóÚð¡ð]ÞDÿ0 È ÜóÚð¡Þ ñûµ0 $ µ ñð.Ûª ö0Ò° N. ñÚº 1 0 % ²PÞ $ö0 $º 10 % ñÈ ð.ûöw ñ¡µ û ÏÉæ]ò1 51 ] ñ1 9.1 % ¥æ ò14 5 ] ñ1 8.4% ^cDÿ ð1 38 ] ñ17.5% Òjt¶$ 14 ] ñ2. xB0S0òÖÖà5ròñðÈ Iw$0ð.DPºä>° ñÒ°$0Sª|{²áB 0=0Är]I×úrR>> I r·k erI0IÛ>ª|{²á 06Ý»áDÜóÚð¡Dÿ I06ÚÝ»áÏûïÖ¨à5rN +EÈò·¥æò$ò>° ñÚ» á. ÒWm;ÜóÚð¡ÞDÿéN = 788 ÑÜ e Dÿé8 $ ¸S $ ½ý $ . ¥æò EÈò k er ð¬¨2er íer ìúr Ir =0Är ]I×úr ûïÖ¨à5N+ wr»a

(48) ^cDÿ ð Éæ]ò {²á R>>ò B0òI. 145(18.44% ). 602(76.4% ). 12(1.5% ). 55(37.9% ). 81(55.9% ). 9(6.2% ). 75(9.5% ). 673(85.4% ). 8(1.0% ). 28(37.3% ). 38(50.7% ). 9(12% ). 41(5.3% ). 708(89.8% ). 11(1.4% ). 22(53.6% ). 17(41.5% ). 2(4.9% ). 75(9.6% ). 671(85.2% ). 14(1.8% ). 32(42.7% ). 40(53.3% ). 3(4% ). 5(0.7% ). 747(94.8% ). 10(1.3% ). 2(40% ). 3(60% ). 0(0% ). 52(6.5% ). 704(89.3% ). 10(1.3% ). 24(46.1% ). 24(46.1% ). 4(7.8% ). 22(2.8% ). 722(91.6% ). 14(1.8% ). 12(54.5% ). 8(36.4% ). 2(9.1% ). 37(4.7% ). 712(90.4% ). 10(1.3% ). 21(56.8% ). 15(40.5% ). 1(2.7% ). 30(3.9% ). 719(91.2% ). 10(1.3% ). 17(56.7% ). 10(33.3% ). 3(10% ). 26(3.4% ). 721(91.5% ). 8(1.0% ). 6(23.1% ). 17(65.4% ). 3(11.5% ). 35(4.5% ). 717(91.0% ). 9(1.1% ). 15(42.8% ). 17(48.6% ). 3(8.6% ). 138(17.5% ). 618(78.4% ). 9(1.1% ). 59(42.7% ). 70(50.7% ). 9(6.6% ). 151(19.1% ). 599(76.0% ). 8(1.0% ). 71(47% ). 67(44.4% ). 13(8.6% ). 35(4.4% ). 722(91.6% ). 8(1.0% ). 27(77.1% ). 8(22.9% ). 0(0% ). 75(9.5% ). 674(85.5% ). 9(1.1% ). 42(56% ). 31(41% ). 2(2.6% ). 14(1.7% ). 741(94.0% ). 9(1.1% ). 9(64.3% ). 5(35.7% ). 0(0% ).

(49) Dÿ I. W;ýFtð¡ð]DÿÞ0 È ýFtð¡Þ ñûµ ñ¯Ò °N. $Wð]ªäö0l ñ (eÞ 9 0% --96 % _N $Ú ý Ft ñÞÈ ð.ÆðW°X0 $ ö0$ 10 % ñð.ðWð¬¨2e rÄ^cDÿ ð¯$ 9.6% ñÒ°ð. 2.. Dÿé8. ¥æò EÈò k er ð¬¨2er íer ìúr Ir =0Är ]I×úr ûïÖ¨à5N+ wr»a

(50) ^cDÿ ð Éæ]ò {²á R>>ò B0òI 3.. 57. .Ò¤jtw$0ð.D Píer Ir·]IÄ×úrö ÞUÁÒµÈ ñ»á_Ô ñ¡µ^ B¥æòwr»a

(51) ö$¤ >° ñ$k erEÈò ·ûïÖ¨à5N+Iö6ÚÝ»á $X>° ñÚÖ»á. Ò¤Wm;ýFtð¡ÞDÿéN = 232 ÑÜ e. $. . ¸S. $ . ½ý. $ . 5 (2.1% ). 215(92.7% ). 2 (0.9% ). 4 (80% ). 1 (20% ). 0 (0% ). 10 (4.3% ). 214(92.2% ). 1 (0.4% ). 4 (40% ). 1 (10% ). 5 (50% ). 6 (2.6% ). 220(94.8% ). 1 (0.4% ). 2 (33.3% ). 3 (50% ). 1 (16.7% ). 13 (5.6% ). 210(90.5% ). 2 (0.9% ). 9 (69.2% ). 4 (30.8% ). 0 (0% ). 2 (0.9% ). 223(96.1% ). 1 (0.4% ). 2 (100% ). 0 (0% ). 0 (0% ). 5 (2.2% ). 220(94.8% ). 1 (0.4% ). 3 (60% ). 2 (40% ). 0 (0% ). 2 (0.9% ). 221(95.3% ). 2 (0.9% ). 2 (100% ). 0 (0% ). 0 (0% ). 3 (1.3% ). 221(95.3% ). 1 (0.4% ). 2 (66.7% ). 1 (33.3% ). 0 (0% ). 2 (0.9% ). 223(96.1% ). 1 (0.4% ). 2 (100% ). 0 (0% ). 0 (0% ). 2 (0.8% ). 220(94.8% ). 1 (0.4% ). 1 (50% ). 1 (50% ). 0 (0% ). 9 (3.8% ). 217(93.5% ). 1 (0.4% ). 8 (88.9% ). 1 (11.1% ). 0 (0% ). 22 (9.4% ). 205(90.3% ). 0 (0% ). 13 (59.1% ). 8 (36.4% ). 1 (4.5% ). 6 (2.6% ). 218(94.0% ). 0 (0% ). 4 (66.7% ). 2 (33.3% ). 0 (0% ). 3 (1.3% ). 226(97.4% ). 0 (0% ). 2 (66.7% ). 1 (33.3% ). 0 (0% ). 8 (3.5% ). 219(94.4% ). 0 (0% ). 5 (62.5% ). 3 (37.5% ). 0 (0% ). 4 (1.7% ). 221(95.3% ). 2 (0.9% ). 3 (75% ). 1 (25% ). 0 (0% ). W;¨^ð¡ð]ÞDÿ0 È ¨^ð¡Þ ñûµ0 $ µ ñð.Ûª ö0Ò°N . ñÚº 1 0% ²PÞ $ö0$ 10 % ñÈ ð.ðWûöw ñ¡µ û Ï^cDÿ ð7 9 ] ñ17.7% ¥ æò59 ] ñ11 % ð¬¨2er45 ] ñ1 0% )Éæ]ò¶$ 42 ]È }. ¨^ ñÞð.ðW9.5% Òjt w$0ð.DP6Ý ñ»á 0S{²ª|á]I×úr=0Är· ûïÖ¨à5N+¯$>° ñ»á nûr0;¨^ð¡[^ æ_ÌC[DðërEÈ òÉæ]ò^cDÿ ð·¥æòI äö¯$ä>° ñÚ»á.

(52) ¹®Ê. 58. Dÿé8. ¥æò EÈò k er ð¬¨2er íer ìúr Ir =0Är ]I×úr ûïÖ¨à5N+ wr»a

(53) ^cDÿ ð Éæ]ò {²á R>>ò B0òI. ÒWm;¨^ð¡ÞDÿéN = 445 ÑÜ e. $. . ¸S. $ . 49 (11% ). 367(82.5% ). 10 (2.2% ). 20 (40.8% ). 26 (53.1% ). 3 (6.1% ). 23 (5.1% ). 399(89.7% ). 8 (1.8% ). 8 (34.8% ). 13 (56.5% ). 2 (8.7% ). 19 (4.3% ). 406(91.2% ). 7 (1.6% ). 8 (42.1% ). 8 (42.1% ). 3 (15.8% ). 45 (10% ). 381(85.6% ). 7 (1.6% ). 26 (57.8% ). 1 (2.2% ). 3 (0.6% ). 424(95.3% ). 6 (1.3% ). 29 (6.5% ). 397(89.2% ). 6 (1.3% ). 20 (69% ). 12 (2.6% ). 411(92.4% ). 8 (1.8% ). 11 (2.5% ). 415(93.3% ). 7 (1.6% ). 36 (8.1% ). 386(86.7% ). 10 (2.2% ). 10 (2.3% ). 408(91.7% ). 11 (2.4% ). 18 (40% ). $ . 1 (33.3% ). 0 (0% ). 9 (31% ). 0 (0% ). 6 (50% ). 5 (41.7% ). 1 (8.3% ). 8 (72.7% ). 3 (27.3% ). 0 (0% ). 27 (75% ). 9 (25% ). 0 (0% ). 7 (1.6% ). 7 (70% ). 3 (30% ). 0 (0% ). 413(92.8% ). 8 (1.8% ). 5 (45.4% ). 5 (45.4% ). 1 (9.1% ). 79 (17.7% ). 350(78.7% ). 6 (1.3% ). 30 (38% ). 43 (54.4% ). 6 (7.6% ). 42 (9.5% ). 383(86.1% ). 6 (1.3% ). 15 (35.7% ). 24 (57.1% ). 3 (7.2% ). 10 (2.2% ). 415(93.3% ). 7 (1.6% ). 8 (80% ). 2 (20% ). 0 (0% ). 22 (4.9% ). 399(89.7% ). 6 (1.3% ). 12 (54.5% ). 9 (40.9% ). 1 (4.5% ). 5 (1.1% ). 422(94.8% ). 6 (1.3% ). 3 (60% ). 1 (20% ). 1 (20% ). 5}Bêéï1±ÂÐ 9 % 19vÊ¶ Zí1a41Q7Çü+Ào 41±Â¶[xï¥æò^cDÿ ðð¬¨2erR>>IäöB0Þ (e¯s; 9 % 70 % Zí1Ms¶¯1± Âå<n l31 D°s<®Ø 31íer Ir]I×úrw r»a

(54) ¥æò·B0Iòö·ª|¨ ^ð¡]I×úr=0ÄrûïÖ¨à5 N+D.Ý»áDÿ0ÏEÈò 8È ñX>°¯Ú»áEÈò B0|ðÚã8.Dt$õ8 Ý»ánõB8ÚÝ»á}û ïÖ¨à5r¨^Ú¿nõýFtð ¡ÝïÏ¥æòÝïÏýFtð¡$ n;ÜóÚ¨^ð¡¥*_> û8ð¡Dÿ I/ït. 2 (66.7% ). ½ý. ñõ Iñô¢DÿJq 6Wð]Dÿ0Þtja¥ ñõ IñLWô¢DÿJqwÄ® 1. ñõ Iñ;ÜóÚð¡DÿJq È ÜóÚð¡ ñ;ÖNª öõ IDÿJqDPûµJq¯$ 20 % ñô¢Û $ðè¹³ âÄ| ¢ÜÝ·ÎöJq $z¢ ñº 80 % Û ñô¢6ûJq]àÂþ{ érqBãðå½·ª|òûö¯$ 35 -52 % È ÜóÚð¡ô¢B¤öD ÿJqz¢ ñõ 20 -3 4% Þâjtô¢°X Jq ñ;ûrJqeðè¹³ â|¢ÉBñ]àÂþ{a

(55) p~ñà ·>B0òÖÖà5ròñ ðÈ¯$ò>° ñ»áD6Ú §»áÏ òÜÝd FÅ$ò ñÚ»á.

(56) Dÿ I. 59. Òª ñõr»ñ;ÜóÚð¡ÞDÿé(N = 788) ÑÜ e Dÿé8 $ ¸S $ ½ý. ]à¨2ð¡Âþ{ érqBãðå½$¨2ð¡ ô]N ö É¢÷¢ ð ª| ðò ðè¹³ â°^N Ãq a

(57) OýQOQ¡Àý a

(58) Ô a

(59) p~ñà ~òð¬r |¢ÉBñ |¢ÜÝÎ òÜÝd FÅ B( |¢ð.eI) 2.. 416 (52.8% ). 361 (45.8% ). 11 (1.4% ). 251 (60.3% ). 153 (36.8% ). 352 (44.7% ). 425 (53.9% ). 11 (1.4% ). 203 (57.7% ). 138 (39.2% ). 11 (3.1% ). 223. (28.4% ). 554 (70.3% ). 11 (1.4% ). 121 (54.3% ). 88 (39.4% ). 14 (6.3% ). 191 (24.3% ). 588 (74.6% ). 9 (1.1% ). 111 (58.1% ). 77 (40.3% ). 3 (1.6% ). 292 (37.1% ). 486 (61.7% ). 10 (1.3% ). 158 (54.1% ). 128 (43.8% ). 6 (2.1% ). 80 (10.1% ). 697 (88.5% ). 11 (1.4% ). 49 (61.3% ). 31 (38.7% ). 0 (0% ). 152 (19.3% ). 625 (79.3% ). 11 (1.4% ). 89 (58.6% ). 60 (39.5% ). 3 (2% ). 159 (20.2% ). 618 (78.4% ). 11 (1.4% ). 90 (56.6% ). 67 (42.1% ). 2 (1.3% ). 196 (24.9% ). 582 (73.9% ). 10 (1.3% ). 118 (60.2% ). 73 (37.2% ). 5 (2.6% ). 240 (30.5% ). 538 (68.3% ). 10 (1.3% ). 136 (56.7% ). 221 (28% ). 554 (70.3% ). 13 (1.6% ). 134 (60.6% ). 101 (42% ). 3 (1.3% ). 82 (37.1% ). 5 (2.3% ). 119 (15% ). 658 (83.5% ). 11 (1.4% ). 64 (53.7% ). 46 (38.7% ). 9 (7.6% ). 222 (28.2% ). 554 (70.3% ). 12 (1.5% ). 90 (40.5% ). 99 (44.6% ). 33 (14.9% ). 35 (4.5% ). 743 (94.3% ). 10 (1.3% ). 21 (60% ). 14 (40% ). 0 (0% ). ÿJq§ò>° ñ»áÛ>ª | ðÄòô]N öå½¨2 ð¡Iö6Ý»á$È Ä[ ñ»á6ÚÝ»áJqwÕÏðè ¹³ âBR>>òñ· òÜ Ýd FÅI$ 4 5% >° ñÚ»á . ñõ Iñ;ýFtð¡DÿJq È ýFtð¡ ñ;ÖNª öõ IDÿJqDP $]àÂþ {érqBãðå½ª|ò· òÜ Ýd Irö$ 2 0% >° ñô¢B Jq $ 10 % -1 9% ñô¢jtô¢°XJ q ñ;ûrJqe$ö ID. Òª ñõr»ñ;ýFtð¡ÞDÿé(N = 232) ÑÜ e Dÿé8 $ ¸S $ ½ý. ]à¨2ð¡Âþ{ érqBãðå½$¨2ð¡ ô]N ö É¢÷¢ ð ª| ðò ðè¹³ â°^N Ãq a

(60) OýQOQ¡Àý a

(61) Ô a

(62) p~ñà ~òð¬r |¢ÉBñ |¢ÜÝÎ òÜÝd FÅ B( |¢ð.eI). $ . 12 (2.9% ). 66 55 38 35 54 23 39 39 37 41 46 23 47 23. $ . (25.8% ). 167 (72.0% ). 5 (2.2% ). 43 (65.2% ). 17 (25.8% ). 0 (0% ). (23.7% ) (16.4% ) (15% ) (23.3% ) (9.9% ) (16.8% ) (16.8% ) (15.9% ) (17.7% ) (19.8% ) (9.9% ) (20.3% ) (9.9% ). 173 190 194 175 206 190 189 191 187 182 206 183 207. 4 4 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 3 2 2. 40 28 24 41 12 25 27 22 28 30 12 24 12. 15 9 11 13 11 14 12 14 12 15 10 21 11. 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 2 0. (74.6% ) (81.9% ) (83.6% ) (75.4% ) (88.8% ) (81.9% ) (81.5% ) (82.3% ) (80.6% ) (78.4% ) (88.8% ) (78.9% ) (89.2% ). (1.7% ) (1.7% ) (1.3% ) (1.3% ) (1.3% ) (1.3% ) (1.7% ) (1.7% ) (1.7% ) (1.7% ) (1.3% ) (0.9% ) (0.9% ). (72.7% ) (73.7% ) (68.6% ) (76% ) (52.2% ) (64.1% ) (69.2% ) (59.5% ) (68.3% ) (65.2% ) (52.2% ) (51.1% ) (52.2% ). (27.3% ) (23.7% ) (31.4% ) (24% ) (47.8% ) (35.9% ) (30.8% ) (37.8% ) (29.3% ) (32.6% ) (43.5% ) (44.7% ) (47.8% ). (0% ) (2.6% ) (0% ) (0% ) (0% ) (0% ) (0% ) (2.7% ) (2.4% ) (2.2% ) (4.3% ) (4.3% ) (0% ).

(63) ¹®Ê. 60. 3.. ñõ Iñ;¨^ð¡DÿJq È ¨^ð¡ ñ;ÖNª öõ IDÿJqDPûµJq¯$ 20 % ñô¢Û ñô¢6ûJq] àÂþ{érqBãðå½·ª| òûö¯$ 3 5 -4 8% È ¨^ð¡ô¢ B¤öDÿJqz¢ ñõ 20 -31 % ÞâD ðè¹³ âÄ|¢ÜÝ·ÎöJq6. ñ|¢ $¢ ñº 80 % jtô¢° XJq ñ;ûrJqe]àÂþ {érqð¡å½÷¢ ð·ª| ðòIröv§»áÖòÈ Ä$ [ ñ»áD òÜÝd FÅ· |¢ÜÝÎöÞ6ÚÝ»á¯$ä> ° ñÚ»á. Òª ñõr»ñ;¨^ð¡ÞDÿé(N = 445) ÑÜ e Dÿé8 $ ¸S $ ½ý. ]à¨2ð¡Âþ{ érqBãðå½$¨2ð¡ ô]N ö É¢÷¢ ð ª| ðò ðè¹³ â°^N Ãq a

(64) OýQOQ¡Àý a

(65) Ô a

(66) p~ñà ~òð¬r |¢ÉBñ |¢ÜÝÎ òÜÝd FÅ B( |¢ð.eI). 216) (48.6%. $ . 220 (49.4% ). 9 (2.0% ). 128 (59.2% ). 79 (36.6% ). 9 (4.2% ). 186 (41.8% ). 253 (56.9% ). 6 (1.3% ). 110 (59.1% ). 72 (38.7% ). 4 (2.2% ). 136 (30.6% ). 304 (68.3% ). 5 (1.1% ). 69 (50.7% ). 59 (43.4% ). 8 (5.9% ). 111 (25% ). 329 (73.9% ). 5 (1.1% ). 65 (58.6% ). 43 (38.7% ). 3 (2.7% ). 158 (35.5% ). 283 (63.6% ). 4 (0.9% ). 92 (58.2% ). 61 (38.6% ). 5 (3.2% ). 60 (13.4% ). 381 (85.6% ). 4 (0.9% ). 33 (55% ). 26 (43.3% ). 1 (1.7% ). 121 (27.2% ). 320 (71.9% ). 4 (0.9% ). 66 (54.5% ). 52 (43% ). 3 (2.5% ). 98 (22.1% ). 341 (76.6% ). 6 (1.3% ). 52 (53.1% ). 43 (43.9% ). 3 (3% ). 125 (28.1% ). 315 (70.8% ). 5 (1.1% ). 72 (57.6% ). 49 (39.2% ). 4 (3.2% ). 138 (31% ). 301 (67.6% ). 6 (1.3% ). 71 (51.4% ). 62 (44.9% ). 5 (3.6% ). 136 (30.6% ). 299 (67.2% ). 10 (2.2% ). 75 (55.1% ). 56 (41.2% ). 5 (3.7% ). 64 (14.4% ). 376 (84.5% ). 5 (1.1% ). 31 (48.4% ). 29 (45.3% ). 4 (6.3% ). 118 (26.5% ). 321 (72.1% ). 6 (1.3% ). 46 (39.0% ). 57 (48.3% ). 15 (12.7% ). 30 (6.8% ). 410 (92.1% ). 5 (1.1% ). 15 (50% ). 12 (40% ). £ë°X5j ñõ Iñô¢DÿJq >$È [8$ô¢[ ñÞ 30% Ï¿¥5 jvÝ ñô¢S]àÂþ{érqð¡ å½ª| ðÄò~òð¬rN. öô]|¢ÉBñIòöDõýFtð¡ ñô¢Jqö·B88mnÈ ñ$ô¢ Jq(evs;B86û $ 25.8% È. 3 (10% ). ñBvû(e¶õ 2 0 % ~aD Ð$ IñJqÛ>]àÂþ{érqð ¡å½ª| ðÄò~òð¬rIrö Þ6§»áÝ 6 0% >°$È [8ô¢ ñ»áD.ÝïÏDÿJqS òÜÝd ·|¢ÜÝÎIö8 ô¢ ñ¯$ 45% >° ñÚ»á.

(67) Dÿ I. 61. VcÄZ @£ë°XVN_>÷>õð¡/ ÄDÿm£ëVc. õ}fýFtS µ ·Ëô ¨^ßô ¡n3@VN5j}ñ ¨^ð¡·BýFtð¡¨2ú tð*/LDÿ/¶Úº}ñ$0¨^ IfÖ~3Ïtrn;jtû ýFtð¡õ}ñfÝRgqõÈ ñô¢DÿJq(e¶vB8.Üó Ú·¨^Ïs_Nû8WêÚð¡õ} ñ§D}ñ¬ ÚcÛÉÌ~},ý· à9ÞÍýFtð¡ |ZhQ L¥"b 90 a, b @5j$ 1 5% § ä ñ Í.õ}táèÕ}ð¡.Ï t}¡ð¡Ã~n¡¶lr(eD ûrð¡¨2ÄDÿ I/§ $g. ¨2ÄkF/. WêÚõð¡_÷ÏÜóÚýFt· ¨Î8 ¥ ñÒ°è8.õð¡¨2 wª8WêÚõð¡Ã.£ëÏÜóÚ ýFt·¨Î8@a¥VN 5j¨^ÄÄBýFt8.út?³ Ï8û_Ö}ñõcýFtDÿ I "/LgNè8õð¡¨2_5 j8.ñÓãÜóÚð¡Ý ñ2j ¨2>¡Àm¨26ÏBWB8ð¡

(68) >ð~6ÏBWD¨^ð¡Ý2j¨2 >ð¬] s#6ÏBWDýFtð¡>mÚ °r»ð¬ÌYÏBWD ±6ð~Þtõ ¡ÀÄWÏm¨2¯vBýFtð¡B W 2. WêÚõð¡ÞDÿ I/S¡ Àð~·WÏm Dÿ I¯gõð~WÏQ ïWÏð¡DÿD¥8WêÚð¡ ¨2ü~öN8.âïtn¢ð¡ $¡Àð~·WÏm¨28Þâ Np 8·(gïtû¶ëf~N ô·PIBÜóÚð¶g uÃó¹Ý 8 8 åM¨^ÄB Úð¶gS÷Í 8 6 ð*ð. Dÿ Iã+S¡Àð~·WÏmD ÿÚ$Q>{rëð¡ûg ¨2 3. §ýFtÞõð¡. 1.. Dÿ I0ÄJqm 1.. Wð]Dÿ I0§ä ñb½e s; ñô¢Jq £ë°X_>5j ñÒ°ð.ô¢Wð ]Dÿ0(eÚ=¯Ú ñb N.ô¢åM^û0Ýô¢(eÚ D ñõ Iô¢JqÞ(e= 56 % ^ûJ q¯$ 20 % È [ ñô¢ûº#ï_ Ö¨ð$ Wð]0²3r JNöJð]ÚáÖ½$ ñ I½eÚ ñLWõ I|¢Jq¶ ¥°D®À _ÖðÏûµWð] 0¯i;.ñW¡·ú0¡·dÄDá ñnÚ<>rõ@ÛN~ (enNc±qWWð]D ÿ0ÿ/L° ñ Ú<@±|Äx ûrDÿ0 ñ·ð¡ Þû.

(69) 62. ¹®Ê. ¨ð W°> ñõ Iñô¢Dÿ I0 vÖ½ 2. Ý|¢0Úá6y 6Ýô¢Wð]Dÿ0SÉæ ]ò^cò¥æòöûr ¢ ^t"âÌWDÿDõ8ð¡kF/ ÞDÿ3 ñe $¥æò; ýFtð¡Ý»áD8Éæ]ò·¥æ ò¯Ý ñïÏÜóÚ·¨^ð¡ 05 3% 64 % È Ä|¢ ñÚ»á _NðÀ]ÚáyÀ] DrÝ»áÀ]}ª|ÜóÚð¡ {²áª|ýFtíer Ir ×úrö§^û ñ(7 5% >°) »á n $è² µ ñ0.7 % 6.5 % $ [m=W°N}ñ0$ D_Ö$0ÖðDê 3. Dÿ I0ã¢å,ð¡/éN °XÝÈ ñïÏ$0Ãû ,ð¡:L¨2¢åª|Sª|ÜóÚ ð¡{²áª|ýFtð¡íer Ir×úrª|¨^ð¡]I×ú r=0ÄrûïÖ¨à5N+DÚÝ» á0SEÈò¥æò^cDÿ Éæ]òIûr¯ÚõÂñtª|D ÿ I0¥*VNm=NWP]NÚ êÂª|Dÿ0ûrWêÚ ð¡õ ñïÏÚ¢åõÂñp a

(70) ª|íer I×úrûï Ö¨à5N+I 4. $ ñDÿJqnÚá/Lt¡¨ 6Ýô¢ Iñ ñô¢JqS] àð¡Âþ·{érqBãðå½Bª | ðÄòöÝ ñô¢JqÞ ¯§ 54 % 7 0% $È [ ñÞ»á Û6ª| ðÄòÞt ñ²¢Jq. ¯´;¡õ Iñ_>ô¢úË.6 û ñÒ°Jq òÜÝ FÅÄ| ¢ÜÝ·Î$ 6 0 % 4 5% È 8 ñ ïÏûr |¢ÜÝ¥b¡¨¥* _£ ñõ Iñ/LDÿJqnÚá/ Lt¡¨D8^ûÝ»á$Jq¯ ñ õ I^ñ_ 5. ÜÝdÄDÿ_WÁ ÜÝÎ|¢ÞÚÝ»ám=Ä¬ ÂþÜÝdÄ ðÍý_ÖðÏûr WêÚð¡ÚcÜóÚýFt¨ ^ð¡²ÜÝr¶¨dÄ ð *ð. ñNCérÇDÜóRÖª|ð ¡LDÿ}Ý»á{²ª|á 8mé¶N;}Dÿ IJqÛ_N; ð. ñõ|¢ÜÝ¨Ô JqÞ_Wæ _ÌäRÖÄi 6. ñõ Iñ/LûïJq>ðð¡Úã/ ¥ ñ;8WêÚõð¡Þ$ Jq5jït^Ãö]àÂþ{8ð ¡ v$Jqn;8ð¡$J q_Öj8ð¡Jq}a

(71) N öô]ýFtð¡Ýûµ ñ»á n¶vûµÈ ¨^ ñïÏ¨^ ð¡Jq 7. ¨^ð¡Dÿ I/R úv;B8õð¡¨^ð¡õ¡ Àð~·WÏm¨2vB8½ D8õDÿ I0e5j>ãº ¿¥(vÈ ¨^ ñïÏ$Dÿ I0· IñJq¯vB8ð¡ D ñïÏ0Jq(B8ö¬ û_NûµWð]Dÿ I0· Iñô ¢Jqë2VW¨^ð¡/ð*d ¨^ð¡õð.³WÄBð¡I_Ö èi;j$0JqD/R_Ö¶.

(72) Dÿ I. ã+¨^ð¡ IÚ. Z. ;°XVc@;}ñ[ Iæ² Dÿ IªN®ÖZ 1. Dÿ IãÒ_>÷ÜóÚýFt·¨^ I8 è}^ãÒDÿ Ié(vwP p ãÒ}swPÜóÛ ¡D 3Úð¶^ãÒ3@5j°X8 WêÚð¶õð¡ÞDÿ I/$Ó ã_>|ãÒÞdC 2. ±iDÿ Ié_>¥Úð¶^ãÒ è}^ãÒDÿ Ié6 IúÑ bÞtB >p p¡cN~ãÒDÿ I}swÛ ¡@¢þIÖ¡« í£±iNÖ3Úð¶^ã ÒDÿ I_># Iô·í£V DÿÞ ¡ 3. ¥°D®0ÞtÂþ ñ¥®D°é ú;õð¡Dÿ I06¥° Ûuôð.WD®ã+ÄðÞ tNó| ËeÂþ ñ¥® IñD. 63. °ÜrDÿé¥®D°ã+Úc½ /ø¯|=;¥°D®ã+ 4. ñNû]ð¡Âþ·{ ¥°X@5jDÿJqÚá/L²"² ¨6]àð¡Âþ{7OPn$ È õð¡ïÏ$Jq 5. ÂþÍ"&ô¢0 Ýô¢0JqnÚá$_Ö$ 0 ð*NÂþ IWP ]ð. ñáÈeð]Dÿ I0 >{ð0öO²$i Ie 6. ´ ñÖ0ûDÿJq ^û ñ²¢OP#XJqð ð¡ûï/°X@5j6]àÂþ{ Þt^ûJqnè$ð¡¯Ï$ð* ñeIQ¼ ñûmDÿJq>W ?Úãð¡Dÿ/ @;Dÿ IJqa¥µ $ È n$[ ñ:eûre_Ö rDÒBe;ÚÌ ñjtûre (e ËÚãÝÏ,µÔ(e Ë ¶ i; ñ:e. dCf. W1 IýnwÏ·| 8 5 Iýnb *W1 IýnwÏ·| L¥"b 9 0 a trsÌï" L¥"b 9 0 b íð¡/ h" KàH illary C lin to n ( 8 5 ) ã¨--ZFG äÅÜ*It ta kes a villa g e nU º S8 6 2 è}}Ûð¡ÃÖ÷)Äð~w} ³nñÃð I@ñP15 1 -1 1 7 B<ßßSs5è=ð»µh 8 6 IúÑbN+Þ.ÄãÒ@}³nUñð1. } I@ Ù° 8 9 ½ýr ñ;kF/ð¡Þðé W1} | @N+Nb}³=ð ñÃðkF IA ¹®Ê 8 4 ð¬+ä± InUiN¥ ¹®Ê 9 0 <}ë InUðrN¥ NÛ

(73) ¡ 6 2 }Ûswð¡ÞiktÞ÷Y@ }³nñÃð I@ñP15 4 5 1 -5 3 4

(74) ¡ 8 4 nU}ÛÉðDÿ ðú0p Þ @nUZé @b 2 5 5 4.

(75) 64. ¹®Ê. ¿ 8 9 [ Iæ²eúð¡Dÿ IéÞ @kF I@ðP19 3 0 9 -3 2 5 uÃó¹Ý 8 8 ÛôÜóG H[Þ(vGc3 3 6 -7 9 »µh 8 4 ÏIDéN}Dû I0 [ÑI IðP4 1 1 1 -1 2 2 Ö<ÈÄA 8 8 [ Iæ²Dÿ ðAÞ @-- X+äð¡Dÿ0Þ@W1} | @N+Nb ÐV¡:{@áÃ