台灣外交政策的政治經濟研究法：依賴/世界體系理論觀 - 政大學術集成

全文

(1)~~*~~.~~~. ... ~~*:*ft/~~U~~ ••. a.~~i&~fYgi&¥Et~~~~ifF~1:t. :. ~fi/t!tW.ft*J]!ffifBfi. 1lJS. tf ~ *. {*)c1~rJ> ~~~~~~.~.~~~*~#*~~.,~~~~~*.~~ ~~.~§.m~~~~~~I~M.~~~*~~.~~#o~~M ~m*6/~~B~~»*~~~I~*~~.o~-~~O.~M~'. +*KI~I~~.~~~~l.~~A' . *l.~M_r. ft ~. ~~~J. ,~~a~~~~~~o*fi / ~~U~_. •• ~~~-ffl~. ~~~~B~~~.~~l~~~~ffl~~~~'.~~~.~M.' ~A~~~.~~~~*~.affAo~.~#'~~k+~~~~ff'. ~.~~+~~i~ffl~~~.~a.*~~~~~~~~~ft~~~ .~'~~l~ft~~~~~~~~~~~'~II,a.~~~.M. .1~1~~~~oM~~I£~tR~-fflr~~.~~J ,.*~~ _~*~r~~I~J. 'A±~~~~M~~o~~~~.~~*~~. ff.~ffl~~~hR~~~.~~*'~~~~*~/~~ B ~-»* ~~ftft&~~#o. ruJ~-t~. :. *#t~-t~ (Dependency Theory). ,~~U ~. --MIl (World System. Perspective) '1tiJt ~ ~ (Underdevelopment) '~r ~ fUH.% (. *~~m~~~~~*.*~.~~~o. ~.

(2) Approach to Foreign Policy) Relations). ,~,~. '71' 3t jEt. *- J;ff ~ 7i it;-. Il (Core Nations). ,. (Foreign. '*. -f-:it. ~. (Semiperipheral Nations) ,±t~1l (Peripheral Nations) ,. Jiit; ~~~* (Political Economy). §-n~O~~~~'~¥~~fr~~m~~~ffi~T~~SN'E~~7 ~~:enoo r ~~I~fr,llIJ* ~~*1l~~5t~. J. (tE.~MZ~ r ~~I~1r,~~a J. ). 0. flHJ.~~. , ~fr~{JJ.~~~IlIJ*~rr~U ' .R=1'i&1;~:Blu~~NI~1r,~mgt ,. {~:1~~¥~;J~l.ltite;ttffl!~~~~*. 0. ~ftfr-teI~1r,;J*W~~~m*~tiEfll. ~.w~~~~~a.~WmM~~?~W.~~~mR~8~~? ~~~~affl~~'~~~*5tm~Xa.,mmm~E$~.afflW.~ lH!i]pJTID~~llIJrgfD~~~ff4~.¥ti~~arfHB*tln. 0. fr~1Paffl~~m~$~. ,. *X~~m~~/ttWm~~~*m~RIlIJ~~xa.o. ~~'~~~~~~~~.~'~~EmmWft~~~~.~o~.~~¥. *~fim~Em~MW~N~M~-.~~m~~$ffi~'ffili~~~~.o.. 1lm!Jl(;~~~IlIJ*~f~N~M.§teEfBl~IL<~i3~~1lIJ*59H'JkfiAi(*::t~ttW m~o.~Z'~IlmIlIJ*frllIJ~~~5tI~ffiR~~E~~~~~B~~~*. ~~~MW. ••m~~ottw.*~~~~-~mlliTfr-te~~m~~*oo~*. ~llmiiJ*WG~~I~1r,;J*. 0. m~ttWft~~~'-~=1'~~*::t~~*~~§~~~~~~~,~~~ *lI~lf7t. ' tE.~~~*~U-f~ , ~*~~af,f-~~~§. 0. ~fl~I1j5tEJ:t§i.

(3) 2*-m ¥+~~fI$iflf~mW~ 0 ![~i~M~n$ifW = iliGe*~, ~ifn$fi7JrI\'J'~ ( 9L61 'uosu!qn~ !9L61 'l::l{nq:>sIV) [{~nJr~M~~~IGe~n~IHt~}f~t~¥f. '-. 0 *rI~ifiW:a¥f~ ,. ~¥l;;t. , it.![I~. ~fI$ifGe~:rlz*M-m~i*~\'J'~~nf~~W. ~M~M~~~m'~~~~~~~¥WGe~~¥~~ft'~~~~O~¥-L y~o*~.~Ma~.~.Ge.m~~~W'~M~ML~fi7J.mM~~~.. ,. ~l¥I (OL61 'SOlUl?S sOG). 19~J{/:t~.. '. 0. ~HjgGell~{$3Bt.y9:m\'J'~~m2'(1. ~.¥Wfb~~r;u~Ge~~M?*~\'J'~. ,. '. :w, *t,·r!mM~$. .l.~~~),@~37:. 0 m~. ~+~~4BGe~~~~~¥~.~,g.Ge~m:t~~m~3Bt~.g.~~.. , ~¥lni~¥l~W~m\'J'~~?~$:W~I. 0. n$ifGe~.J!~M~tW~*~M-m~~~~~. )2*~~~ffII*~\'J'~~!mfi-~ M~M.~i;~~m a~W-=-;a:IDDi~~. ,. 0. JHIGebJ}a~l**~$~. ~~i~MEI3~~*~\'J'~Hi~rm~oo*~M-m. /. ~W. 0* .l.~~~~.WGe.E~~~'~.GeroH~MDi~~'.~'~~Ge*~~~ Di*m~~;;tLfi7J*futO~*~\'J'~ , LffEl~*H~tI.~w~Wfml- (IL61 'gunlIllD) o ftlE:~§;~r~¥lIl~sJ~*~~.J]l1tM~\'J'~ (!f) : N~!tftlE:*~g.jI1J}G;J ~~1Il5l!q:~Mm\'J'~ ( ,@1). : 4IE:GeN~!t~J~~gf~~~.jIl1H~5I!q:~-rm. ( -=-) : ftlE:GetlM'M*M~{£mgf~M~\'J'~ (=) : 4IE:GeCt+{£B ~fl~aJ1lTftIHI \'Jr~. ( -) : w&liifJ~Gen~.l.iJI1f11§Ge*~~NW~ 0 ~:rlz*Ge:tf~'lH§p;~,,!3fm. '~~'*~.~~fi7J*.W4IE:~n~¥f~*rI~~'.wGeftlE:~~nB=1 ~~'~~4Ilim~~~ifw-ili.Mo (~:rlz*Ge.~~~'V~Ge~N.~ ~EJ3~1?fl. '. ~~~t~*~\'J'~EJ3!mfi-€5i. '. ~~;;t2\E:it.}f{(~t~~~iH$!IDfi-i!t. ~~).~jI~~~~W~~Ge~~~~~$~~'~~.~~:rlz*jI~~~i. ~nJr5a~.'~*a~Ge~~~:rlz*~iJI~~M-m~~~4IE:m~0.~~~. ~Ulg~~4IE:m~~~W~*~M-m~~~~'~oo*~M-m / ~m~m. o ~.Ge~~bJ}an?ia~~mGe*IIM-m37:*~~-:~tM. '4IiWGe\f/~M?!ttj,. G;J. ~~~.WGe*~M-m~~i;.Ge~.WID~~.~fu~~'~~Ge~~~o ~ Di.~~jI~~~*tj. ,. ~~Ge~iH!i1\'J ' ~~~d!)Jf~*}~GerrJ' *m~~~t;B~f~. ~~~~o~~Ge~*rI~~M*~ • • ;;t.~futM~~mm'. • •m• • ~i.

(4) *'. ~!f.wn~~~. : R fflf1H}~*I¥J*~**~j@:Fa~f§H~~~mHi-.~ , Jt19:W. ~~~ & ffl~/L,~*pfTfi~l¥JmH4&~~~ J;JI~[:~~~I¥J~~{f:~~£~. mID~g~t'iI*~I¥Jfi315. 0. 0. ; =~*~1&?1~I±\*I¥J*'T7f~:a: ' ~. (Dos Santos, 1970) I~{r.~*I¥J~~, 0P]:(£~. 1'Fl%~I~~UITtf!l ~l¥Jff~~. , ~~0P]~~T 5b1H41t. W~*l¥Jjf~. , ~E8' f~~~*1t- ~mi[1:I¥J*5m ' !fff~{J' I~~*1¥J 1~j:f[&1~Jjt~ Jm~*I¥J.~*5-g- , f'@5!~/L' ~I¥J?1~ (Evans, 1979) -JiN:ffiJ s ' ~~0EJPfT {-t ~ I¥J 5i- ~ flj £t -aJ fig. %Hr.~ ® 1& mf=r ~ ~ I¥J ttMlz: ffiJ ffltt;!:t ftt!.A ; 1& mm ~ ~ ffj 0. £ttt#.~a~W~~0P]~£t-~o~.~~*.~ffiJ ~ '5i-*l¥Jm.~a m ~~?1~&~~~~I¥J~~. h'&~.~*~1&ffll¥J~~~tto~sZ'~~ ~.ID~m~~ftOOI¥Jfi315~M~.~ml¥J1&mM.W1&ml¥J~~o 5i-~~~I¥J~~~~/L,l§¥Jffl*MEt~W5${r.1!tWim*$I¥J{t(*~*5.I¥J5B -f~~. mu. 0. )'i-~~~I¥J~~~1&J&rJj~~~~*J!~. (-§M1!tWitH=r '. m~~~£~~~). &~OO~~~.(-§~.~~~I~~*I¥J.ff)l¥Jm~,m • • m~#~~.. W)'i-~~.ffiJ*,~.~{t(.~I¥J.~o)'i-*I¥J~~~WM~~m*.~~~. 1¥J.*'@~~~~ffiJ~.~~.~)'i-~o~sZ,{t(.~~~~~.~I¥J~~ ~Hf~~~t£jf~~mt~~/L'~. e~~~~!\~!lrmmUI¥J~1'FMi. 0. ' wIffi¥f. (Teresa. Ha yter ) ~!e~)'i-m!fff~iI~~1&J&&,jj~)??,~*:!i:f.L.A.*W1JU~fIJ J~, 1¥J~.~lt t±l (Hayter, 1971). Jtt)'i- , )'i-mm• • 3&)'i-~~hfj*~;f§: .I¥J~W '. 0. ¥fJj~~?1~~. N~I¥J.~@~1&mo~~m~~R~Mm~I¥J.#'I~E{f: ~ HE8~M~~ ~~.M~~ .m=1!tWI¥J-fi?1Jm1&mo. ~/L' Wjf~ra~I¥J{t(.rDJ{*~~~~~ ~~*IDlI.If7gl¥J1&1Ei ~~{r.. '. ]l!JjtffiJ~ . ¥u;!t:fj)'i-1&m. 0. '. ~~f[]ffITitMff4~. ~;~, (Bruce Moon ) £~11X*~. /. 1!twmt~U!!!. , Hf;}F7fj ~ $~*9i-X1&mml±\ T :95~:~X?&{-ti[1:I¥J~~ , m~JjIJ~{'*1t~1f~ J!M (Moon, 1985) 'ilfflT (t(*~1W*1t~~stJ8ffij~jj , W}~1,~~{t(*~W-9i-:x1&UHI<.J M~~~-.~MI¥J~.~~;~~.g~$'~~I¥J • • &~~~.mAA~~ 1¥J&, ~tE~~¥H ,H !tI¥J~Nffjlj Jjt- :$ffiJ a ' iI~l§¥J*W~/ L,~*rJj*~~ , 1&m ' ffr±.&Jt{r.I¥J{t(.~EU~~:1J.9H51T~~l¥Jhit ' ~i8~N TF7fj~$~*m:~::g ~. 0. 0. 1¥J .*&~~oJtt)'i-,~e.m&~~ ~{t(.~*0~(~&~.A¥fm~)~.

(5) ~ ~ 71-. ~~%J&fm[(. 0. x.J1tJR a9 jfL{d'1'-i;'!t~ 1E i!- : **~. /. i!!:- %f..t't ~ J:! ~ftJt. ili~JjU~ffl:tE1R~~*l¥Jfff9H5t-T (~~~m~{5t-T). 27. 'lZS1~:jtjJ&. ~&~~~~W1R~~~~~:tE&ili&~~I¥J~~~~~~m~~o.~'W1R. ~~~.*Wl¥Jm*~m~ff~M~~~*~~oili~~T-&~~:~*m* f5lT~{BW~~Ji**~¥~~flj~. , lli5t¥f$:{J,~*~~wi&YElm*l¥Jflfi!WYi. Mo~~,m~ffi-Tti~~jJ&*I¥JYim~~o. •• ml¥J.~~~'-~~.~~~I¥JYim,m~~:tET ~~m&'~~TjfM!~*-ayijg~l1'X1Il1z: § ~1¥J9i-~i&* ' fJX:J?JttE¥AfrWf$:{J'~*& ~~0~¥@W~~&l¥JjJ&*om- •• ~~'~~~*~$~~ •• 1z:~OO~ m~~~~~~~. ~1¥J~M&ili~m~~~*.~~~ffil¥J~.'~~1Il1z:§~I¥J9i-~jJ&*;m=. ~~ffim.&~AT.~.~~~*fi~ffi~.'~~1Iln@~I¥J*~jJ&*o (Biddle & Stephens, 1989) ilitll¥J7tifJTlli3Zf-fTtttwe~JJ.mlfil¥J~5i ~[)j. , f$:{J'.=:~~roJl¥J~*~~T1JfE~I¥J-ayijgJ~. ' jf~ , *. 0. .'~~m~:~~w~~~~~~~ :tEili.l¥Jtttw.*~.m*~'~.&_~W~. __ JJ.:jtW~T~~~*M. ~*~~~~?-ft.~~~~mlli~.&.:tEtttW.*~~~*~[)j~~,OO r:p~1HI~*§iU~jlM!~{lL. 0. {Eili;f1I¥JH~Im{*T. '. ~.~~.~~ffl~~~YJfE. .~W&.~~~'*~W~~~~*ti.~~~o~. '. •• ~~~ffl~~~~ffl. ~1¥J~*~?*~~U*~ •• ~:tER~A+~~~~~~~ff~ffl~U~Mo *.~~.~~~~R~A+~~ft~~~~$~~B*~'~W~~'. m E~'U&~~~~B~~W~m'.YiTA~I¥J.~&.~'lli~fl+~~ .ftW~@l¥Jm~oW~*lli~mtt.,m*~~~~~ff~ff~ft~'.ffM ~ft~. ,. ~~m~lli.~ '~f'Jf*~~a~lli&l*~~. 0. ~OO. ' ~~~~*f[Ji~~Ji;. ~~~~T~~~~.?~~l¥Jn ~~ ti~~~~~~X~~~~~?~.~~ *~~~@,~~-ayU~-@~roJ~w@*7tm*.~m*lli~:.~~~wm ~~~~nl¥J ~ ~;~~~~ti_~m~~~I¥J.m;Wm~~r~fi~MJI¥J. . )JfD~{". 0.

(6) ' f\tirraJ t)~¥IJ~~1±1'Jt~3(fjkt!¥J~i1Jffll¥1J ' J.-jJl;t*~ti ~.1±B*~'~~~M' •• E~'B~~~~@~*!¥J~.B~M~'~~ ftjl:~nm1JOO. .!¥Jm~~~m~~~~'~W$*.*!¥J.~~fifi~o~~~,f\t~.m$ ~1fH~*!¥J.~. , 1m).. r cp~1fH~15eJ. (System of Central American Integration. ; Sistema de la Integracion Centroamericana, SICA) =~!¥J~. 0. rfl~~}H7\~:TG§~-fLfL. ••• rflK~.~m~~~.~.,~m~m.K~~~~~'~§~. ~~~~rfl~~m*~.!¥J~~$A~~°rfl~~~*~~m~~.M!¥JBM' ~@e~~~7B.~~!¥Jrfl~~ffi~!¥J~.(~~'rfl~~$~ ~ rfl~~~W. ~x1~ta~~*IJ) 15Uff~~!¥Jrfl~YtH~f~. (f9lJtzo '. ffrmfft±tr~15 '~7\:;~~f~). 0. ~~m.!¥J~.*~'rfl~~ft§~ ••• ~.~!¥J.~~.'~~ ••ff$~ tr.'~fi~A.'M. •• ,m~~~tr'rfl~~.tr'rfl~~$~'rfl~~~. .e•• o~~~~,m@~15~firfl~~**!¥J.BffiM.~ftm!¥J~~o ~m~~.mrfl~~~*.Mf\tm~)..,~m~m.~~!¥J.~&I.BR. ' fJ~~f\t.1±m~~1illi!¥JW ~ , ~Ji!¥J~{'FMJ 1* ' fi1lR~j:!))(~£H'~ff1N*!¥JWJtIt tEmfl!¥J1wi5GT ' rfl~YfH~~~~tm1±.~0 Wrflfif\t~!¥J~M~~~ffi.rfl~;.M*.~.e •• =M,m~~~.M~ .fi'*~~M.e=W~'ffi~~m.e~=~' •• E~.e •• ~&~m M.~3t**£*~-~j(~~~}i ' .15~B!~tr~lr~~1Ufj'iJ!rJ ' ~rfl~H-~.1~t) !¥J~Mi. 0. :fi1mJllWflj1JO)..m{l~UJl.. 0. m~.~.,~~m$~~~rfl~~~~.&#mrfl~~.~~~ffi~r-.~ ~J~~Z~~o.~rfl~!¥Jm~~.ffi~tE!¥J,m~f\tmm~~WJ'ill~.m ff~!¥J~f;f. , m-~~~{[!1~~~!¥J a. 1±~~~~~~~g~&f\tm~.!¥J.m1JOO,*~. (-). ••e!¥J~~~~~~:. sm!¥JAD ' -5E!¥J~~± ' ff~!¥J~~m&~~~.~~ !¥J~~,~.m-+M~.~*!¥J~~'~~~-M~ •• ~!¥J~*o ( = )~ f\t1r~t1llf~T-. M~~~~§~ill.~*fflMg'rfl~~~!¥J~1±WBB'~~~N~!¥J$.o. (=). " El ~ " ~~!¥Jrfl~~~~W~~ff±1t ' =t~~ (~) rfl~~.-=fffl ' ~IJ~~{i!!.~*~~~?Jf\t{r~~. .r~ra~&\~JrmJ{~~M~~. ~K~WJrfl~~m~-*~ t1f£-JJj{~. 0. 0. (E) rfl~lli1i+~*!¥Jif]HT~ 'f~f\t1±~~fft±1fLZml!J~¥IJ~.

(7) ~~~~. 0ZP:l¥J~llm. ill. 0. •• ~.~ft.~~*:*~/~~.f~ ••. (7\) ftfr'ill~~5EmJL,\. ~. , ~I&~~mlb~rt'l~ , 1ii{ifX{r'I¥J~~tfu. 0. tE:*zr:Z1i1H=JlW ' ~~LTff § 1¥J1~t.U~~~B:$,~ ittWii 1UJ~~ , ~53U~fX~ ~~mTLM~ftl¥Jg.*m@~~I¥J.Mo~~.MI¥J~MI¥JRlli~.~z~o. B*~~~~~~ft.~*I¥JN~~U~~~~I¥J~~'~ffii~I¥J.~OO.~. . '~~~~~~W8* •• ~~Zli+I¥J.~o~®~tE • gtlE~~SA. '. ~#W~iiiJ~ft~~I¥J19:j{. 0. •. B~MOO'8*. ~~~Ij~)tMtf~Wm;fD~cw±m*1WI. ~~~mmnBm&B~§m~mmD.~~-.'WB~~~$~~~~,m. M~&~~al¥J~~o~~WB*~M~~~~.I¥J*~~~~~m~~.ffl~ ~~. ••• mMI¥J~gT~o~~fX~~~~~~ff~fflff.I¥J.~W~~'M. ~~~tEmM~.$iim~B*~~~I¥J.M&N.wm.~~~n~I¥JIAo .~z,tE.MW~*~~~g~l¥Jg~$'~~~~~~7-mm~I¥J~. •. ••. ,~tEW$~tEB*~I¥J~~~W~$'~~.~~~I¥JAA~o.~~~,~. ~m~m*B*~~.mM°tE~~'~~-~~WB*~~~7$B~~.~ .5E.~.&$~~.~.m. +1f: ' !cfflJ~~ ~Z-=.~jjli) ~~J1CBftii'mm. •• E.(m*B~-+.~ftq •• H~,mM ,§3-~~ii~/t;:~ I :tzm=~ J ~wllfdl¥Jfl~~B. 0. ••• #~-ftft~!cfft~B*~~~~.,~~~aN ~$llimM.~~l¥Jm~'+~~MfXmI¥JBftiism •• ~~~~a~~~~ ~~~ . o~m§m~~mmB$~~~ •• I¥J.~~~~l¥JittW •• ~I¥J~ • • m,~.~m'-m~m.~I¥JM~~.J o~ffi5Elli~~-.~.~+~ • • lli~'1s§~tf.lli~I¥J •• R~-=.~~~~,~~~~~m$~l¥Jm~o~ B*~~.a*~. m§m~Tz.~~.ffMz~$¥~~o®$~~OOA±&&~ . ~~I¥J~~. ~~m~oB*~mffI.~~mm~~~'Bmiisma~.~m~ $RI¥J~. $'~~~~&**~~~MaoB * ~Mff~ •• '&~.£. ~ ~~ • ~.~ili~: ~. •M. l.a~ .m*~~~B*~m~ - @~.I¥J~~oJm&~lliB. ••• ~~fX~l¥JaMili~#-~'~~*L~.o $.~'B~~~¥~~l¥Jamili~mlli~R~I¥JAA~o~7B$~Z~'.

(8) * .m~~~.~~~w~~~*~'~~~~~.~~~A~mm.(~~~. ••. ~~~~) ,.mft~ ~m~r_~~~ J ~~~' . ~~.&~~ - ~m~*o. ffi~B~~.~~~R*~: r. ~. ~H~*~m§~'~*~.'~~~. ~~~~'~~~~~ .m~~ffl~h~~~~.'~&ffi~M~~~~~&~ ~~i$fJtW ~ tl ~~$J~rj@UJUE: ~~~M'B. 0. J. B~R~~ffl1~~ 'I:1~lIp~$*~N~i¥JM:ft. •• Tffi~~~~~o~~-@m.~~~~A.~~~~aoB. *~-ftft~~~~r~~~~~~~m*a . ~&~m~~~~~~~~ ~~~. ••. , ~lltfl~. ~*lE*1}~-fL~-~+~if1iB~m = ~1i )\5m~~. - ~~tJi ~ ~. , ffH&ili*1JoAiI!I'. 0. 1lt5i- ' ~~1~~m~~. 0. J. , B*,~~~*JOO~. ~~**.m~ft.~~ . ,m~~M • • o.~~M '~-fLft A~~~8W. .~E*~'B$~~m~ilW~~~~~~*~-,*~.m~MOO~*.~ 3ZM~Eo. ffi~~T'*.~W~~~~*~~~~.~.W~~ ~. ,. *.Mt*~~;fj~~¥IJ~IDJ~¥153Umff!fl~~~mt~. m*~~~m~o~~~~ft~~. ,. ••• ~~~~Wtt. JM~~{r~f-t~~l!fu~~PJT. ••• EOO ,~~.~~~~~,~+=~m. M'~~=M~~~r~~~~~~~J '~~~W~T~ ~ ~~~.&~.m, 7\T~~~~~~1fH7\E .m ~ ~fFta:AE. J. 0. *~mHm:BEf;trm]Uili5liJ~~ml7\~'*~jt~~~W r~. 0. .~~m~~~~~~~1i~.@ftE~~~A~~~.~.o~~.tt~. ~m . ~E~*.~ft~~~T~~~~~E~~M~~~~~IfF~-'M~ ~g~8W~~1HI~~. § ~*~}ff$F~~?6~~.*a3~JJtt ~[mt:7t~~§t~. iJIz53U. 0. ~ffj]~*l~.~WfJ<:. *N~~~$~*4\i~ '~~W~~YfHE*:7t~~~F&lI. r ~.R~5liJ~~ rHI,!:1Jo'jJttmJ~*~~*me. M J. ~~ *. 0. ,~mme.M~~~'EL--a[9@. (~~1}HI ~*~ ffiltt ' 1Jo'j]ttmJ~' *~~~ , W~~~~~ffilft ' 5i-:x:g:~~. ~ ~. )&-@W •. •. o~~,~~~~~ •• ~~¥~ - ftft = ~~~~r~. ~1fH~*tliJ~~R~~fF1E6~~ .tf J 5i-ft: . ~" ~ffiJ*. 0. ~~~:t£*.~~fIJ. ffl~~~IDJ~~'W~~~~*~~§~.~ta~'~HK~F&~r~~~~fi ~fF~~~~ J. ,~~m:AE~.g~~~ ~~ '~~ -M~ft~ft~~. ,~~.

(9) iW '. ~J~gW. - J~J1l. '- [§i;I '- ~ ~ Ef3!ilf~li~g5Q [g \!; , .::ljtiBlti4e [g 0~~~ )il}~ , ~m ~~~~n~4e~JY~~}Viti r n§}~}~~+.f~~if 0. 13i~~jJf~~~ ~f4e%O=~ ~;~l 4~. ~ J ~m,[g0~~. ~~~ ~~M.~m~~Y '~~~~hlm~,~go~H ni~HI[~ 4-~ , fH1~ ~W ~~ fil~ Ef3~ , ¥~~r&r~! ~ilirdfn1f?GtPI~§ ~$¥~ !} ni~} *il4!$* ' f! 0~~ ~ ~lN{B~WtP M'~?f¥ r D¥M~!fiij§li~Mf:t{$~!!f:l~ffl tP J HB~:r~ ~ili*8m J@.~ili* ' mHi~ ¥~~ni~Ht ' ¥::'it ~~ = ~9Y!ni£~Y-1fu4tf 0. 0. ~. ~4e~~ , ~~+.~ .[g 0~~.~~ ~ ~tP~WMo~.g~±-ti.. ~'~W~.±-W9Y!W~~@~~.*m ~ ' r%O=4e8~~m~. J Y ~~'@~.~ilW.~ ~~ U~~.~~~DmW~~Y~~'§~ . ~¥. ~~~fu'. r~ ~~ ~~W J [g0~~ . ~~ ~ ~tP~~ ,@~~~@~.e~. o~ &~ 4e~~ ~ ~~~ W4e[g0~M@W~¥4e@~~~o~~~~~~.~ JJ- li* ~ T ~~ Ef3~ m j!~w~. , Jj.~~ WIg~Jj. y~~~aRfWM~ElJ~~!?~~ 8. = ~~~V¥¥-~8'~MT~~4e~m+~9~.~.W¥~' r[g0~~ .~~ ~W ~ J 4e ~W. ~3. •• I~~Ef3o.~M~.'-@5~~4e~~W~. ni£qjJf ~¥!M~WI ~ fl:fLWi!J'Hg:$l;. , a~;i}4e~~r~~g!f~slz¥:¥WlitW~~* o~~:&f~~~. ~W~~li*G ¥~~a~V¥¥-~W~M~~~~~tP '~4e.~~W~o~. ~~~ ~~ *~~~tP@W~f:t{~W*~~~'~w~~m~r~~~~M~~ ill*IHE~ tP. J. 4e'!; d ~-P-~~ , ~~~±=~~t~lJ~:F):~~m~~~~ , &!l[gj n! •• M~_ mfu*~4eK.g~~.o~U~.~.~.M.* 0. .4e~~&&~. ~~~~~W~~nK.g5. * ~~'.::l~W~~'WJj.mWmfu*~~~~ ~M'~?f¥W~. • •• m~~Ef3D~nu~~~tPM~~~-~@~'.~.M. ~tPM.fu~~fI:f'~nK~~ID~~o~n r W.~. •• * J. ~~'~m£.. *m ~~~M~~~V¥¥ - ~~fI:f '~~~ ~ ~4e.~_~~~Y~n~ o. ~~~ .. r Wil(jt'JI~~Mf~ J. 'fu}Dq~Ei. 0. +}2iliYsf. r .~~Nf~~~. E1fYJft!;l*~Hf,~~tP ni£~~~ :[f. J. , ~~1§l. ~~~=~~ ' .m4er~~~~~~tPJML~ ~~fI:f~~~~4e~.o~~ 4e~. ~~~. ~~ffitP~~4e~~~~*~~,~~~o.~~~Ef3~~m-.

(10) ~./ttw.*~~~~~~-m~*attW.*~ffi.~~7~m~mM ~*~~'~~W~*~~.'ffi~~OOm.~@~~~~m&fifio~ft~m, ~m~~m~~Zff'*.M~~~~~*M~~~.~&.~~~m~~~m. i&! ~ti:x: ~1EWft{'F. ' ~:lL 7 ~tiM J;tJ'J"Tf$>l:}Wjfllj ~ ruJ 1* ' ffij fl ~ , t)i: ~ WiLil!. m~~~7mti~~o~ffi~~~X.R~-oor*.IIj~*J .~r~IIj~* J. '~$£~-~. ,~~~m . ~~~~o~~~*.MB.~ZffM~m~~. ~hR~~~$~~*,m~m~~./ttw.*~~~~~.~g~~Mo~ ~'B~. •••~~~~.~m,~~~ ~x~m~~.tl~-~ttom.~w. .*~~,-@~*~~m~X~iliW.*~m~,~m~~.~~~~~~o ~m.AA15tT. '. ~1i-:X:I 1'F~mlJJ~ tjJ!::lL 2j;:~i!E~/G\fi~~ / G\ § ~ , 5~1~ft. ~~B~h,m~~~~~~~*~~m,m.~~m~~~~ti~H~M~~ ~pN1M. 0. T~'¥. '. J1~~!tHI. filir-0 Pjl ,. 1f*'T:tikl. 0. 0. a~~~~3I~f~~--m*'T~~I~ffi±*. 0. a1~. : Em. ~754 0. 199~~W~~. 0. a1~. : E1J,E[jJif0PJ '. ~764. 0. Bagchi, Amiya Kumar. The Political Economx of Underdevelopment. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1983. Cardoso, Fernando H. and Enzo Faletto. Degendency and Development in Latin America. Berkeley, CA: University Of California Berkeley, 1979. Chilcote, Ronald H. Theories of Development and Underdevelopment. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1984..

(11) if ~ 7~ xJi;f (j~ Ji~~ ~~~ ~~!- : 1Rt1l / ilt- Jf..mt ~ J.f il.l-lfJ/,. 33. Evans, Peter; Rueschemeyer, Dietrich; and Stephens, Eveiyne Huber (Eds). States versus. Markets. in. the. Would-System.. Beverly. Hills,. CA. Sage. Publications, 1985. Evans, Peter. Dependent Development : The Alliance of Multinational, State and Local Capital In Brazil. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, ]979. Frank, Andre G. Dependent Accumulation and Underdevelopment. New York: Monthly Review Press, 1979. Munoz, Heraldo (Ed.) From Dependence to Development. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1981.. $.f] fll " li)- 3c. Amsden, Alice H. "Taiwan's Economic History: A Case of Etatisme and a Challenge to Dependency Theory." Modern China 5:3(July 1979):341-380. Barrett, Richard E. and Martin King Whyte. "Dependency Theory and Taiwan: Analysis of a Deviant Case." American Journal of Sociology 87:5(March, 1982): 1064- 1089. Caporaso, James A. and Behrouz Zare. "Interpretation and Evaluation of Dependency Theory." in From Dependence to Development, pp.43-56. Edited by Heraldo Munoz. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1981. Biddle, William J. & John D. Stephens. "Dependent Development and Foreign Policy: The Case of Jamaica." International Studies Quarterly (1989):411 434 . Clark, Cal. "The Taiwan Exception: Implications for Contending Political Economy Paradigms." International Studies Quarterly 31(1987):327-356. Dos Santos, Theotonio. "The Structure of Dependence. " American Economic Review LX:2(1970):231-236. Duvall, Raymond. "Dependence and Dependencia Theory." International Organization 32:1(1978):51-78..

(12) Furtado, Celso. "The Concept of External Dependence in the Study of Under development." in The Political Economy of Development and Underdevelo pment, First Edition, pp.118-123. Edited by Charles K. Wilber. New York: Random, 1973. Galtung, Johan. "A Structural Theory of Imperialism." Journal of Peace Research 2(1971):81-117. Moon, Bruce. "Consensus or Compliance? Foreign-policy Change and External Dependence ." In ternational Organization 39:2(Spring, 1985):297-329. O'Brien, Phillip. "Critique of Latin American Theories of Dependency." in Beyond Sociology of Development, pp.7-27. Edited by Ivan Oxaal, Tony Barnett, and David Booth. Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1975. Sunkel, Osvaldo. "Big Business and Dependencia: A Latin American View." Foreign Affairs 50:3(April, 1972):517-531. Valenzuela, J. Samuel and Arturo Valenzuela. "Modernization and Dependency." Comparative Politics 1O:4(July, 1978):535-557..

(13)