臺灣政治民主化之鞏固：前景與隱憂

全文

(1)e•• M~~~z.m: •••••. WI. ftlt~~~±1tz.oo:. fr_.~§*. ~. ~. ~. A-**. ...\..L. .E " ~IJ. c::::J. ~m-~m~*.~*~~~li+~·~.~.~~~R~~ ~~~. ••. B~.-~~~. lfHIm/J\fti3I®~~~lJtJJ. •• ,•• ••• ~,. &.m~~.~. ' ~:tE*fi~J1!®-JltM1l:~.~~*. 0. •• ~:tE*~~.~~~~~~~m~~.:~~S* m~~_Z.~'fl~Z~~rn~(ft~~~~rn~Z~~~~) , ~~fl~Z~~~_&A~~M~x~~~~~~~ •• ~ttZ~ .~(Ho.1978; Winckle and Greenhalgh. 1988) ?&ffil ' IE?& ~.:tE *~M1l:$. 0. •• L~~*~~.~'~E~~ •• ~$~~~~~~~~ ~ •• '~~~~~~~.(~~.~.~.)IE~~ •• ~.~ ~~'~:tE~~L.ft- •••• ~,~ •• ~g~~.~~. ~~. ~. ~. ~~·H.~.~~*.~~. ••. ~E.~Z~~'~E~~. •• ~~~.~~ •• ±Mzr~.~li*~~.~J.~~M.·. A+li.-n+~a·$~ •• *.~~~R •• ~tt~~®.&~ • • • M ~~~~.·~*x~~.ft~~.~~·~~z.$m~.~ •• ff· *x~. ··~.~A~~*.~$~R~~~~R.D.

(2) ~. •• W~ft •• M~~_••• w~~~nQ •• ~.~SMI. ~$~~~.~~~$¥~nO~*O~~~E.M·m~~$m .~. ••$m••• d~~.&~E.·&Wd.~~ •• &.~. ~.~~.M~.*. •• ~~~M~¥mQ. •• ~~ •• ~ •••• ~d ••• ~.M~~.tt·~~m •••• ~.M.M.&~ ••ttW•• ~~ •• ~~M~W~~Q. ... ~*.~~~~k·~ftM~.~.~Z.~ ~~. •••M•• ~.m~.~. ••~.~.·~.. ~d~~.-~~~*~~A. ~.*~.M.~·~~.S~O~~~~~*·~.*~~B~. .. &.~~~~.~. •. ... ~m.r~ff-~~Z. •• ~~W ••• ~.*·~.~tt.~ d •• ~~~£~~~~~ •• M·.M. ~~~ ••• ~W •• ~~~M~.m*.~~QW.k~.*~. ~~~k.e. ••• Z*~~ ••••• ~·~~.~ •• &••. • W-~+A~M.~*~•• ~ma**~M~M.·~~.~ ••&•• W~M~~~~.~~.~ •• M~~~.QQ ~~·~~®S~O~~WM~ftm~W~~~.~m~~~ J:jt~ £ ~¥Illlt!!.~ nt'!:J:jt(snowba1ling)~mf1j • • ~ • • ~.J.t. &~~ • • ~.~~ • •ili~ • • • $ • • ~~±W.W~*·.. eMnMMmM@g• • ftMWm§~ • • ~wr:r. ;Nft.~mti••. , 11 WAaL;f].J£;gJl!lttIU'~#MJt«ift •:l!-lIMjI*". ~~~.~~~~L·.~+~~~. ....... •••• ~mw.~.~~. ~.~~ • • • • • Q~ • • $~~~~d,~~~~~,~~m. .~~®·.~. Ma~~*$tt·m~~. •• Mk~.

(3) ft• • M~~~Z.~:ft ••• ~ ~'tl!tE €t.~r€I". 81)I;:51Jft.. ~. Jii!agjAfi q:tA:ff;flJ'I'I~agJtH'(Ting, 1991, pp.80. El-t::;O~ftlJJJ~ ·1l~.~JMtE€t.ag~1fUtfr€llJJJ~il. .. ~mm~Nti~nti~ff~. lIifitjag~IJJJ~~~(Gold, 1986, p.3). Wtt:1t'tk~JJt-RagNti~nl! M.~·~Il~+~~q:t~$~ag. .~€t.ag~r€I"Jii!,.@~*.~agl!~-~W.agll~.ag. •. •• ~ •• ~~ •• ~Z.~tt'-~W*.~~r€lNtim~~~. II ~ r€I ~:¥ l! ~ ag.ll JHI~ IL'. 0. •••• ~.ag~.~£~*.q:t,Il~ ••• tEAO~ft~ ~~~~.~~~~m'ffi~~~€t.ag~r€I~~B:ff;flJ'I'*ag. 1!'~r€I~£~BJJt~€t.~r€I"Jii!ag£~.M,~£.~ag~fi. •• ~*~JJt'Il~.~.~r€lagtt~B:ff7I~ag~I!°M.~ ~ft.~£.~agl;:51~tE*~~B:ff~~ag.~,~~.@~~,. *~LB~ti~~Il~.~.~r€lag.~~~JJtft.~£.~ag* M.~:ffmag~~·wn*~£~agIJJJJii!,tEAO~ftagft.Bil ~y;E(.iJ ~. £.m1(democratic consolidation)ag III Eit ' lIlti.*HtIl ~. .~.~r€I.~~@ag~~W. ,~£.~ag~~~*MtE~£.. ~ag1tAA~m~.~ag~Mo. •• ~£.m1~g.ooff~r€I.~. --~. •• ifitj---ag1W.mBI~ , ffi~lJ~1t~1W.ag~:ffI;:51.~=f~~.. :ff••• ~agJJt~'~.'~£.~~$.m(.iJ~.JJt~£.~, ~~~ag~~~*~fr.~£~.~~.~.Z~agl!~'l!m~. ag~'~.~-~RB.~~£.m1aglllEit·~.~~~m~£~ R(~.~~.~R. ••-.)m:ff•• agm~oI;:51Jft,*~Z§. ~~tEI~*~:ffHIl~.~.~R1W.agl;:51.'W~ •• *M~.

(4) -"~.:i::itJl• • ~. 8~=~~~*~~*·~~~~~~~.~~~W.·~~ .~~~.@~_#·~~~$.~~$~£~~.~~~~M.·. @~m~.~~~.m~~~~~~~~~~~~~·~~~~~ *~~~~~~.o*RW~·~~~~.~~~~n~~~~W. · £J!IlJ?t .*:m:~f1/f---*±1it~~~IHt~~~iI!i~'P.~1Ul1W _~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~W.~mM£J!~~.~o ~1it~~~~~~~~ffi~f1/f~~~~1it~~,~1itm~~~ (~'Pa~.,%~~1it~ ~. ~lMlJltt. 0. •• ). ,~~~~~.~IW~~~.~. .1it;@tM.IW~.ttflLipset~-JL1L1L"f:~. £~~~-@~1itJ!{4: J. r~. (Lipset, 1959, pp.69-105) · ~i1Ul~.'P. ~~~m.~~~~~~n~~M~f1/f~~~~£~~zIWM~· ~~lli-'OOi3I • • i£M.~¥.~1fIrm r~f1/f~~~J!t*itfj~~~ *~. •• ~£.~J. .~L~~~~Z.~~$.~. •• ~-£.. ~m£~~~~~n~~~~~$~~'W~@~~m*~L~~ Lipset~£~(Cutright,. 1985). 0. ~5'~. 1963; Bollen, 1983; Bollen and Jackman,. • m~.~ E'J ~1it~~~iI~.~1j]A • j'lL"~£~~. ~ •• ~.~·~J!~-~~~*~~.~~~~~~~~~'Pa ~.A~£.~~~~;m~.~£~-M~~~~~.Mm~~. ~~~~~~8£ttlW%~~1it~~~~~£~~IW~~o~~M.

(5) ~.~~~~~z.m:~.~. ... W5. ~_.~*.~~*Z*·.M~~~tt.$~ •• ~ •• ~£. ,.,J' t'. fJitacJilfF;(f1Rftu~lJ.tt. •. · J31f.~. r 0~~~J (civicculture);(flltJ. '~~£.M.~~~~·B~~.M~.MVM*~J3IfIJ~~ti~o a~~~~.~~*ti~£~. ••Z•• ttZ*·~~.M •. • ~ •• M~~~OO~~~K~·~~O~~~~T~~m~~£ ~~M~~~~~~*~.mo*~-~~W~·~~~-Mm~. acJ~.~*.~*~mw~~~~~·~£~~~.IJ •• ~~~. ~~ •• M~~~~~~M.~ZOO~K~.*·~~K~£.* ~. I!!I • • M~~~ : a~.~11 ~ ~i&1ti~(reformers)~ 1*~~. (conservatives)It{lJ.&ti~*~lN!~~(moderates)~lti~~(radicals). Z~~~~~.·~@K~~~V~~.M~~~ffi~~~£~Z n~. •. •• ~o;(f@*~~.~;(f~ ••B~~~~£~~W~· •. ~~M~M~~1ti~.~~~~~~·ffi~&ti~*~~lN!~~. ~~. ••• T~~&~~M~MZ*·$~*e~~~~ffi •• ~. ~~~~·~~~~I!!I • • M~~~Z~~&;(f~.~~~,;(f~. ~1ti~*~~~~~.w.~~~~·. ~~~~m~~. •• ~~.~~.~~mm,. •• ~£~z.*om;(f*~£~·~~~*Z.. M~~~Z~il~.M. ••(pacts).. ti**.M.$IJ~IW.i-'\;.JlJL.. n.i-'\; · >j(;ft-~~~~~iiJtmJ{U • 1t{!l.~~~~~K~(O'Donnell and Schmitter, 1986 , p. 19; Przeworski, 1992, p.l08) 0. .~~~.~~;(f~p.~.m·@~~M~n~~~;(f~P ~.m. 0. Huntington (1968)milii!U~VM.*~it*# • • ~~:l!. ~~.M~~J3If~~M.~~~·~~VMM~~.M~~.offi.

(6) O'Donnell (1973)]!I;11kT ~tI+Ill ~~!if ~~f?tJ~1i1f1Em t:f:l ' ~~ !if~~.*~M.~$~~.M'~&~'W ••••• ~.~o ~~*~mt:f:l'I;1~~!if~~~*1i1f1E~~~~H~'~~~~~. =. ~. IDl ~ ~ Htt jlHllt!! ~ raJ fliI. iU ~(Rostow, 1970) IPJ ft ~ , * 0. ~~mt:f:lI;1.Mx~~.~*~~~!if~,~~~¥~lt!!~~~.. ~mAX~~.~'¥.L'.~X~~~~.~zlDl~H. •••. •• ~~.M~!if~'W~~. ~~m~~~~~ ••• Mx~~~~'.Mx~~ •• M!if~~ -~ fliI.~.-~M. ' lIlfijmlt!!Ii!~::f1PJ W~(Diamond, 1992, p. 4n)oflil~' •• *~WIPJ.tt.~~~x~!if~.~~.M~. -~~raJ~H~'~.Mx~~~. *~. •• ' mit!.l!tiflil.::f.mA~~.~~*~.f~{preconditions). (Karl, 1990, p. 5). 0. ~~'~~@*raJ~1i1f1E~~W~'*~~Z.~~~~1i1f1E ~~~~.M~@~,~~~~.~~-tt.~~~~~~.~~. .~~~'~~.M.~~~~~~@~~~~~.t:f:l*·::fWR. ••• M.~e~~o~. L*.'~~~M.M~@~1i1f1E~~~~-tt ••~~1i1f1EA~ ~.ttom.'~-~~W~~~~ •• M.~~ •• U~~h~ .-~.~~.~~·IPJ.&.-~~. ~.'~.~~~.M.~~~~. ... ~oo~.~m~~. ••. 'b. .¥~lt!!~~~~~M.mA.M.~~.~~~~~M.'~~ .~~~A.~IHlM1I:lI1J~M.(Chu,. 1992, pp. 36-37). 0. ~~L~ZM~,~I;1~~~.mff~¥-~~*7m~~~. ~~.~. •• ~~'bR.*.~-tt.!if~~~~*~.e.~.

(7) 8 •• M~£~Z~~:ft•••§. 200. t~~~~'~~~~~R~-~W~~'OO~~Tm;~.~, ~R~~~~~~~.~~~~~~·~~~~T~~e.~~~,. tt.~nmti~~~~~m*~w;.~'~~~-li.~~.~ l.~~Z*~e.~~~'$~~~m*~mw~~w,~~~ ~~Tm~~~li.~Te.~~~~~h_mho~A-M~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~$~~li.~~~~.,£~m~~~ ~~~~~~.o. •••• ~-AAO.~~M~ •• ~~.~~~,~~ •• I§Jj~Ifl1itJtt:li!!li:~. •• ~--.JI--~GobachevllHrM~~_. '. fl~~M:li!!~~~~.~mft,~~~Jtt-:li!!li:~m~~ ~~~~iii&(Nikasson,. 1994,P.216). 0. •• ~~. ~~ • • • t±lIJ~~.~T. .~~.~~~~~$.Z*'~~®~~~~M~~Ifl*~.h IYfH~ile~. • j(llil}ft~h~:iEL~H~~~Jff~~ ~~~ ,. ~~IJ~(fledglingdemocracies). ift Jff ~ 1£. 11_B. ~ (Whitehead,. ~5i:*~J1J. , ~&tifEfPJ&~~.h1lI!~~ 1986, p. 44) ,. =IX fi&.. ~. El :;$: ~ ~. ~.~$~~~~~.~M~o~Jtt'~M~e.~~~~~B® ,~~ft~®M~.S~.~~m,~~tie.~~~~.~,. ~~~£~m~Tm,n~~-~~M~mM~.~~~~m~~ ~W~m~Ziio. ="'~~.1iI. •• ~~$M~~.M~~~~~~~~.m~M.'ffi~ti. &t ~ ~ ~~ • • ~ ~ -. ~ ~~ft~AJtU(democratic regime)~ Jlj'[. qB•• ~.mo§ftti1it~~~.M~~~M~:~.ftfE ••.

(8) ~.~~m~.~~~~M~$~*~WOO~§~~.~~~~~. ---. ~~-. ~~~.~.~~~W~~~~~(~~)~~~liAtt'B ~~~$M~~~~~~~~~~om@~~~~~.tLM~. ... ~~~~$.'Wfi~~~W._.~¥®OO~LB~~~~~~' .~H~~~.~._.A.~~~~LI.~. mw~.~.. ~.~~.~tt~~~~~~.~.~m.'~~~~~M~$~ *~. I. ~~;r~.~J9T11!l~~~~~.. .*m._.~®.(Huntington,. 1991). 0. I. El~I;AWli~itt!tt~. m@~~tint-.m~. ••. ~~*~~~'ffl~~~ •• ~~m.z~. ~~m*~~ttm~. ~±.~~~~W~ti~~~°tint-~~.oo*nt-~.~±~~~. ~~~.~W~'~R~ •• ~~I~R~~~~M~W ~I~~ • • ~(Q.m~~~.~)~~.M~~. '.. ••• ~ez. ~~~-M~~,~~~~~.~,m~I~~~~±~~.~§. ~'~-~~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~'~~.~J9Tli~. ± ~~ r~. =... ~. •.. J. Valenzuela, 1992, p.19) ~~. (second transition, Mainwaring, O'Donnell and 0. ~L.~WJ9T.~~-_.~.~=_.~~~~'. ~~nt-~~L~*I{I~ .~~'~&~'~~. _*z-. 0. lf~.)E'11:. 0. ~A~±_.~~~~~~~-*1i~~. •• ~~~R~~~_.~~~~$~~~. .1fL • ~~_.~~~ • :f!Q~PrzeworskiJ9T • ~~~~IDI~. .)ttl. ~_.~~.~~~!lZ\?&~~lIJnt-~~. ~~~~±_.o~.~~~.Z-,~~itt!tt~.~.IDIff~. •• ~~~§~~m~'W~A~~~*~%. §~'~~~OO~.

(9) e•• M~~~Z.~:~~~ •• w N~~~~.,m~~~~~~~~~.~'~.ff. ... maili*~e~~d*, ~~. •••• ~m. .... •• ~.~ •• ~~~ •• mM~'.d. ~~.~o~.~~~~~~~~.~.~. mM~. a*~~~~~~,~~~~~~,~~m~m~~~.~m~~. ~L-:~m~~$W~~~.~*~ft.~$~~.~.~~. ~~~.A~~m,.*~~~. •• m.~~.~~.~~m,~. &~,~~*~~.~.m~*~~.~~~a.~&m~m*, m~.d~~~~~m~.~~m~~*~m~~.'~~A~~ ~~~fftfmti~~~7€t. r ~~W~J (disenchantment)-. '. .A~. .~~~~7€t~~mm~om~mm-nm~~~~A±~m~~. ~.~~~~~*~~~,-nm£~.ili~~_~~~*.~B ~~ • • • • • ,~~~~£ • • ,W~*~. •••• ~~~ ••. LI'/ij~~~o. ~~L,~. •••• m.~'~~•••$e •• d.~A'. ~.~ild.~~£.ftilJLmr. '. {ffiiJ~~~~ (~~!Jl'~~~ • • ) ~. ... A~~.W~~ili~o~~£_~~=~m~m~:e~~~~~. ~~.~w~,#~~~~~.~~~~~-.~~~~. ~.. (liberalized authoritarianism or dictrablanc1a) : • • • ftilJ ~ a.:tf ~. •• ~~T~A~ •• £$~~~~~*£$~.~~~~,m. ru~~~~ • • ~.·~~7€t:tf~~.~~~A~~~*~ • • tt iI.~ftilUt; ~:tfJlt.t!~~-.~I!ll~~~(Iimited. democracy. ordemocradura) : • • ~.~7€t • • ~ii.l;~JOJ B~ftilJ~~ • tHlti. .!it ~ ~ A. ~. • • ru. *. ~. * ~ • ~J. ~. I!ll ftilJ (O'Donnell. and.

(10) Schmitter,1986, p.9; Oi Palma, 1990, pp. 154-155; Meaney, 1992, pp.97-98;Schmitter, 1994, pp. 59-60). 0. ~@/F~B9~~t.il.1;Ifi7Rili. ~~.~~*B9$~tt,~~m¥~B9~.-~~=*~*~~*o ~~'fl~~~.~~~LB9~-~~B~~~~«.~B9~. fi~~'~~-M.~Ld.#~.B9*~~'*~*~~.~B9 ~~W~*o~~~.~B9~~OO§'¥~#~~*~ • • ~B9~. 7€:1 00 {-t Z. ~~~. J5( Wf (democratic government)*. ~;g ~. Htr AA. ~ B9 t.:ti. *~.AA.~B9~~'@~'fl~.AA~~.~~*B9~~M.~ ~~(Share,. .~. 1987, p.528) 0 OOfl lIt-Bm! '. tt.%~rR'. B9 ~fiiJm ~~. ? ~~.~«*JlL~~~¥m~~J5(Wf.$fJLB9:tt~ , !Rl~ r.. ~J-~~#.*~:tt~W~~Z*~'@~~~B9~~~~.~ .*~J5(7€:I.~~.hB9li~~*'OOW~~J5(7€:I • • g~Ho~ .~B9~'~~.~~fl/F~W~/F~B9~O'~~/Fm • •-@. • • • ~/F.~B9~.W~.ili • • ~. '~~M~mdJ5(7€:I.~B9.. , liInlt~~J5(WfB9~~M:.3~:JVH.(Linz, 1978). 0. ~lIt. '. ~~.~Z. ~./F«~~~B9.~/F~'OO~«~~z~~AJ5(7€:IIT~~(~. *.~~-.A~)ITA*~~m~B9.~'.§Z'~~.~~ ~. ~. B9 /F R ~ ~ ~J5(Wf B9.~ , ~:fl-~ ~ ~J5(7€:I. Jl.U(regimes). B91ifa '. ~-~.Jl.U. '. /FMfU~iE~d~~iE~. , m~~~J5(7€:IIT~~. Z~B9li~,J5(7€:[email protected]~A~ITA.~B9. m~'~~~~.~~~B9~.n~~~-~~~:fl~m~B9~~. • JlIJ(O'OonneU, 1992, p.18). 0. ~~~~~~.~~~fiiJ.J5(7€:IIT~~~1ifa?d~.~fiiJ*.

(11) 3' lit ~r€H~ ±:ftZ.1OO : ~. ~. mr:JJIi~III.. 211. ± _IGI a<J ~ ~ ?Przeworski (1991)~1.4 ~ ± _1GI1t JH~#tE. *~~~rr~~.M~~±~~~~M~~~a<J~-nA·ffW~ m~~~±a<J¥~*:llnltjt§ a<Ja<Jrr~1Y1Hlffm¥t]!::ka<Jm~. 0. --. LinzJ~. II ~ ttl-1I B~.IGI a<J ~ ± ~ f€:lli:onsolidated democracy) ~\ ~ 1f r. ------. 111.=:11.$1 : (l)tErrl\\k · i2:1f{fWrr~~~IIi1Jii!-@~~~±a<J AJlIJ*:llnltjt § a<J ; (2)tE~~k · U-ft k~::k~f(~r nltJU§ffi · I!P ~tEMI~~~~Z~·~±~~~~~~M~~II~~.~~a<J. nA ; (3)tElU!k · ~~~~J&~~~~~J&j]ii. • 1$B~WltJ*tE. ~1I*,Jra<J7t;~~~~*,J~lilbrrM~~~(Linz,. 1995, pp.I-2). ~Przewoski~~Linz. ~. · -11 B~.!!!:.IM a<J ~ ±U-e- q:. a<J 3f1f a<J nltJl ·. ~~M~±~~~~~.A~ml\\~-~~. •. 0. •• ~·ffWA •••. Jlt-~~1fjj!*m~~~±a<J¥~*:llnltjt§ a<J~. · 1$M~~~fl~. 0. N~·tE.M~~±_IGIa<J$i.Z.·r-1I~m~~.@~. ~M1fD*~±.IM?k~~~~±.IGI~~~-1I1GI~~.a<J~ ~·1fjj~~.~~~~a<J~~1fjj~~]!~_IGI~~~M.~o.@. ~~1f@~~~m.tta<J·~~.@~¥t8ff~.ft~~ma<J~~; 1f@~~tE~±.IGIa<J.M~~~ttl~a<Jo~8~3f~·~~¥@. ~~1f~*~nlt~ •• ~a<J~m,@w~~.1f~*~~-.~m ~a<J~±AM·Jltmm~a<J_. ••• ~~±A±~~1I-1I~~a<J. m.·~1.4tE~±_~8Ma<J±.§.~~~RM~a<J·A~.tt a<J~. •• ~·Jlt~Ma<J~~rr~~~JltZOO~~&~~~±~~a<J. m~~:ll.~±~a<J •• 1f3f~~·W~~1f-1I~~a<J~*~. ~rr~~.~tE-~·~-m~~a<J~.~~M~RM~a<J~.ft.

(12) ~~.-M.~~~.DmAt~T~£~.~~.AAW.t.M. fi~~z~~~~.A(~. ~.~.mk~. •• ~)m*z.tfi~~~§.m~. •• ~.*#.tR~~~~.~~~~~.~t. ft~A*~~.~tt~~~~~~t.8m~~~-®~*~~B m*tftzW®~~~~~M~.h :Ii*~fiJ~. •• ~~~ •• ~~eB.~. 0. £~-~~t.M.~~~£.~~.AA~~~OOM~t~~. ... ••• m~.ff~ •• ~ •• k~*.d.~t~~ ~.~A~~~.tWA.A •• W.~~~~ t~~ ••• • A~~~.t~~~~.&£~~ •• ~fiD~~£~~~AA· •• z.B~~Ar$.z.~J tWAr$#z•• J .• ~ ~~W.'~£~~~ff •• ~~a~ •• ~~fi~*.m.D. ~~£.~~ ••• ~.ff~ •• ~~~mr*~~~,~m~~ ~R~~.AA. ~~¥~'~~~. •• ~'~~~~.~~~~kS'~®~~~. ~~~~'JI¥~l±"'~~lQU~ • • ~~Rfi.~h. t. !iIIE~~®rJj~~. •• ~~AA~B~#~~,m~~~~AA~A&~#~ ~~~'W.~~.~~~£.~.~ •• ~AA.'~ ••• ~ • ••••a~®~~· •••• ~~M~.~~~M~.tt .... ~ ~~.ff~. ~Jt;~.. 0. ~;r·.~&£~~~~~.~li"'~~~~·~£.~~~. •••• ·~~.~-~~~~~fl•• ~~~~.M~.m ~o~-~.m~~* •• ~a*~ ••••••• ~~~~~. -~. ~t¥. '. ~~~~~~tt •• h~~~I1if. 0. ~-M~.mJlIJ~fljtJ~.

(13) ft.i!il£ra~E1tztm. : llII:lUt!,.~ 213. ~*L~~*~~~.~(ft~*~~~~.)Z~~~.~~~ m*'~fi~~.M~~~. ••• ~~~_~*tt,w~~.~~. ~fitto~~z'~~~_~~~~~'~~fi~*z~~fi~~. ••• ~~~Z~ ~Ji!: ' :«IlLinzwr~ , ~:fl~IT~*16'~:fl-lI~*~Jt. : ~~Jffl ~~~~~~~.~ft&.~ •• ~_*~~~~o~:fl~~~. 1~~~~m~~A~~~.'W.~~-.~. Z~~~~-$~~~~•• ~~~~~~'~~'~~~~.~ ~~~fi~**~~~~~*.~~~H~~.~~~~'~~Ji!: ~m®~~fi~*(~~Ji!:A~.~ft~~*). •• ~~~~~~. •• M~.M.:flm~~~~'~~~M~~gm~~~m~·~ ~~** •• ~.~-~•• Mz~· ••• ~0~~~.'Wa •••• ~~-~~~~.~,~~~~.~~~.~~~fi. :O'Donnell, 1992, pp.18-24). 0. .~·~~.~m.~-lI:fl~~~~.~~~.~*~om. •• ·~~Ji!:-lI~~tt ~*M ••• $~~.,m~~Ji!:-lIa:fl ••• ~~.~~~~ q~'.Ji!:-lI~W:flh~~n~~~~.~~§.o •• ,~. ~:fl~*~.~~~Ji!:-lI~.tt~~~. L~~~.~~~ff~'~~~L~~~~&~'~~~.~.M. ~~*l!Ul. 0. $ ,. f:~L±~~B'9~J{. -"*-±*• • iI.~.it .~~~.~~~.*.~,~. ... ~.~~~~~~~~..

(14) .. ... .~~~~~,~m~~~~~~~~~~AM~~~~.~ n.~~.,~~.~~~. •• ~ •• M~r.n~ •• J ~~m~~~.fi~. ~~. .. ••. ~~~.~~~.r~. (~~~,mM~). ,~. ••••. •• ~~~ow •• m~ •• ~.~~M~w. •• m~'W~Am.~• • ~~ •• ~X~ •• h~~m~o~ •• M*m.~.M~ •• ~ •• ~'~~A~~.~tt~M~~~'M~~Y~~ •••z ~~~~~ft~~n~ili£~~~~~. *'+Am~~~~.~~.·m~ X~J;t~X~. 0. •••• ~W.'~~~*.. Jltll~~--*±~*f4~~. t. •••. ~ m~II~~JfiJ. m~.~~~fi~.-m.~E~~m~o. ~~. ~. •••• M~~&t~.~m~_~,#~.#m.Am~. -. *±~. JllJ;HJHt~t.itH';~ -1JIA~~f9IJ(Pye, 1985, p. 233) •. .~~~-tt~~.~~~~m~~.m~_~~~~,.·~. •. • ~Tm~_~~~~ ••• ~'M~-1JI~.~ • • om~~~ ~~~ •••• n-.,~~ tt~~.m* •• ~~m~~m. ••• -~m~.~ ••M•• ,-~mx~~ •• ~-tt~~.JllmiliX.hM.~.~ •• t ••• ~~~~h. o~~,~~.~~ tt~~.Jll~t •• Mm.~-~ £*~.~,.~~.~~~ •• ~~~*~,~~.~.~~* $.*~Bom·~B¥~~ •• mM~'.~*lI~.tt •• ~ *.n'~X. -*••. m.~.,~m0~~*0~~.'.* e.~m~_~AA~'*.~~~. '.~~. ••••. ~.~o. •• Mtt~~ ••••n.. •• '••••~~'~.~-AAO~~~~.~*..

(15) e•• ~~~~z.~: •••••. ns. 7.1% ' -nJ\:li~:Ji!5.6% · -nnO~(fJ~BlfhtijV-f!:Ji!5.0% ' n n= ~ :Ji!6% (Taiwan Statistics Data Book, 1993, p.l) it?& jllllft 0. ~·. •• ~(fJ.~R~~~.~mili,~-nnO~~-nn~~. Z~,~.~~ti~Blf~m(fJ~~~~fl~~r~(fJ.~'WH~. ~ti~~~~Blf~_(fJM~'~~*~.~~Blfht~~_.~~* ~tt~§~,~~-~.~~.~.(fJ.,~~.~~. ••• ~n. oo.a •• m'WHfl~~m~~iliOOm~olft~~~~*~~. ilifl~#~~~(fJ~~,~~~ht. •••~.*(fJ~~fl~~~~'. ~~~(fJm~~~~'~~~~~*WL~~~~~_fl~m~.· .*~. •• ~ •• ilifl.~_· •• ~Blf~.~~ ••••. '~~. .5:E~±.~. (fJ § mrflllJtmht~-~jr{oon~~. p.35). · it?&~.~lli.~*:iltmt.4E~~#~~n~Blfht~ ,. 0. ~lft. (*. . . •. 1994,. m:Ji!•• ~Blfht~~B •• ~~-.~.n.~.*,~ht~Z* (fJ~~ •• 'B~*~~m~tt,~ti~±~~@(fJ~~~ht~_ 1m 11 n ~E lit. 0. ~.(fJ,~m.~~~Mtt(fJ.~~~~~~.ffi,~-nn =~-nn~~z~(fJ~.~~ti-.tl.OO.(fJ~~~~~~~. r~'~~tl.OO.~*I~'~.'~.'. •• '~~'~~~. ~~~~.~~~flm§H.(fJ~§,.*~~.ti~~~§~r.. ~~~-~~~-~~-. •• ~J~m~.m.ww· •• ~~~. ~~~~~.~.~Z~ (na~JJit,. •. 1994, p.IO). _Z*'~~ti~nnO~-nn~~. 0. ffij~~Blftl. •. •• ~M.~(fJB~~:Ji!. ~~r~·~**~~~~.(fJ~~,~~(fJ.~~~~~~ft~.

(16) ~~ft~~~~~'~~~&.$~~r~~A.J~~r~~.J. z~'~~£ffi~~~~~~-nn~~. ~~~~~~~fl.*. .~~Mn,~~~~.~~~~~,gffi~~~~~~*~~m ~~I*~iftrRHILt~~jJ (ft-:k~. .~~,~ift.tl.~.ftOO~. , 1994, p.l). 0. te~~~~~~.~~. ~~~~~V~~~~~~~~om~,-~~~~~@~OO~~. ~.g~~~Wfl~~~~~*~·~~~@~~~~~~~~~ ~~. •• ~~.m~~jJ.~~fi.t~.W~R~~~.~~.. 7~@~~o~~~~.~~.~~~.~e~~ift~~~.~,. ~~~~*~~.~~*. ~~x~·m~~.ti~~.~x~~. ~a~~~'~E~.~~nu~~.li~~~fl~ti$.~.~~. •• ~~~~J~~~o~~ ~~.X~*~.~~~.~.$'~~~~.~~fl •• ~&~. m~~~ti$.t. rWA~~. %~~.,~~m~*~.r~~J~~~~~,~ti~~~.X ~il~iI1t~~.~z-o. :1}-1lIm~m. a~g*~~~--tl.lY:l~ , 1!~~.~Ati~. ift~~~~~.ofl~e~~~~A~I~tt'~~~~~. ~.~~~.~~,~~~-n~~~~==A.#~~ ~~~. •• ~.'. .~~.~.~~.~~~~.M~~~ift~.t.~~. ••~M~~~~eAc*$. ~e.M~ •• ~~~~~z*' •• ~*~ •• *M.m1ll~~ ~~~tl •• ~~~~~~~~Ao~~~~L~~~~~.~A .~ft~.1lI~~~.~~.'fl. e~~*~~~~~znu'~-1lI._~.~·H~~O~ft*.

(17) .... ••. ......•• t.MW. e•• M~~~Z~OO: ••••• ~~~~".t~.~.~ M••. 2D. •• M~.~~~~·~~~~~~ ~~~~~ .M*±~.~t~~~~ •• ~.M*±~ •• z~·* •• A OO.~~. ±.~.~ ~.~. ... ~A~.W~~~.~.'ill.'~~~.M*±. •••••m••••~•• ~M~m~'.&MmWT~. -00. a ~lt1J~~m~11. .. ~AAO.ft~~·. 0. ~·~.~.M.~~.~·. 11~~~~.M. .. •.. ••OO•••• M~M.fi~M.~~ • ~~.~. ~-OO.~M.. •• L~.ffl~~·~~.m~&M~.~~~~. ~-OO.~M~'~~~.&~A±~~.~.w~~~rft.AW. ~*J~~~w~~·~~~~.~~ft.~.±.~~~* ft.~~±~o. •. ••. ••• @c~w~~'~*~~~.~ •• A± •. •• ~ •• *~.M~.L.~.~~ ~~~~'&~M •• ~~~~ •• ~ •••Mffl.M¥••• ~ ~.M~.z~'ill.*. ~~'fi~~~~~~~~'w. ••~.~* •• ~.~~.~ •. ••M•• o.~.=~~. L~. ~±~. •.. •• t~. ••. ~.~~.£~. •• ~.(fi~)~*~.~.~~·~~~g.UTM~. •• ~ft.~±~~~.~.§ ••• ~ •• ·&~filt~~±~ ~ •• ·~~~~m •• ~ffl~- •• ~.~.~.M~~~¥.' ~.~~$~.*.m.M •• a.~ •• oo.~-@m~~ •• · ~~IiI~rmML ' ~1::~ • • 7Ht(~Jj. · 1993. pp. 47-48) .~. ~*.~±.~fi~m.~~IiI~**m~~.~ft.fi~·~~ ~~. •••••• ~~±~•• ~OOz~.o.

(18) Fa. =... ;J::~a$itfill:ff. (-)tR.;t.. (liJJ~.). ¥~~~AliJJ~.~~.;t~~~~~~~~*~~~~~,. 'iIt J;,( ~ ilW ~ r ~~J. 5:t;t. J (quasi-Leninist party)* i~B! liJJ ~;I; tE ~.;t~.*~~*ftt(Cheng, 1989). 0. 1t<.J1t-mi!'. liJJ~.J;,(. ;t.~~~~~7;t~*~~tl.*~·~;t~*~~'liJJ~.~ ~;t.~m;t~~~.**tR.h'. }ttl ;. ~tl.*~1riii. '. rJ;,(;I;~;tJ~A.;t~~z~. ~~~iiitt~liJJ~t.dl*±:.(state corpo. ~~~,~~tl.~Z~.~.~~.~;t~~.o~.~.;t~. ~±:~~~~'liJJ~.~m@;t;l;.tt$~~~.(~~~liJJ~. ~Dd$~D.). ~=M~~~. •. •• :.;t~~(h;t~~~~~~~)J;,(Atl ••. ~~~(~m. ~81~). ,J1t~_.&.~~M~_~;t~~tl.*~~. •• ,;t.~%.Mm'.*$~~). (*~.,. 0. ~.;t~~~~.~·liJJ~.tR.;t~~~.'iIt.m~~~~h ;t~~~A~~~~liJJ~~~~.oUh;t~~W~'liJJ~.~~ ~8~fi;t.MW. •••W;t.H.tt, •••;t.;t~.~~~,. ~~~;t~~.,.;t.~.,m;t.A±*.ff~-~*~~.' @~~~@±:~~.~~~.~B*~.Z*,-ft~~.H~'iIt ffx~~~.ffliJJ~.z~~. •• ' •• ~X~~N.ff;t •••. ~~-Mm~M.~~.·@~.J;,(~~~.*~,m~;t.~.. ~fiff~~;t~~~M~8*~'~.~~.M*'iIt.fi;t*~A ~~t*~~.h(.*~~~~h) o~~'U.~.~~~..

(19) ir.ift7i1~.:E1tZ"/i\l. : lPIftW.. 219. ffif '{Elm Mf8 J: ' .~EJf ~ ~ ,'itt ~ fl ~fflUiH~ ~;;$:!it ' ffif ~F ~ ,~,;¥; -MA~~~.o~~~.~.w~~H~~~~~.~h~A. ~,{E.~*-~~~r,~~~~~~~~~.Z~~.**~ ~.o.~~~M~~~*~~~~~. •• ~,~~{E~~.~!it. m•• ·~*{E~*~~.d.{E ••• ·.~~~m•• fl.~ Jtf ~ ,~, ~ - Jl {i lit ~ J.I ~ lllU1! {Etl•• ~~~~~OO'~~.-Jl~Am~~~~~~~ffl ~~~.*~.~¥~,{Etl.*MM •• *.~~tt~m,~~ ~tl.~~; -~OO~~g~*~~~tl•• ~~~.~ ••J: .~mJ: •• ~a~~.,.~~mJ:~&fl~h.~M{E~~~ Q. .~~~~mJ:~.~'ft~~~~.~!itEJf.~~.~.~'d. ••~~IA (~PiIi~~ • 1991) m~~:Wl{E- • ••m.r.~~ •••tl••~~~U·{E~_~~~~ •• ~, .~.f&.tl. 0. ~~~*M~~~~~&fl~h~~~~0~~ m~.~~~~tt~~.~~~*~~.~~.~., .:Wl.~~.~m~. ~o.ffif' ~~_~. •••• ,~.~~{E~H.~H.~~.~. ~.~.o. •• ~J ' ~fl ••• ft~~~~ ••• H~~~~~'ffif{E ••• ft~~~ {E.~.~~~.~,~~.~~~EJf~r.~~. =~. ••• ~~.~~~~Ur,~m.~~m~~~~.~~~. •• J:~_.Q~.{E§ ••~~~ft~.~~~ mH~~,~* •• a~~~d~~~~~ •• ~~ ••• '~ ~m~~H.ff~m~~~~.~ •• o~.'-MwA~H~~ ~~d~~-M.

(20) m~.~~mA~~~~m~~.~.Afl~~~~'~-~~~ ~ftz~'~z-MOO~m~~~m'-~M~~~~~-~~~. ~+~'*~.M~~~.flMm.~n$*. •• ~~~~~ ••. ~.·.~~~~~~~~rr·~~~~~~~n.~~~~w., ~~~~~M.~$~~·~~.*~~~-ft~~o. •• e.~.~~*~ •• ~~~,~*m.~~rr~~~~ .H~OO~~m%·-Mm~~~n~m~~~.~.~-~~#. fl•• a.~ •• HomA'~AO~ft~M'~~.-~OO.~ ~~~~M~~.~~fl.~·WHm.~~fl~.~~~.mk. •• ~~ •• ~£~~ m.ofl~~~.m.M~rr~~*~~ ••• *·~~~~.* ••• ·~ •• **~~~*W~,~.~~~ •••• *~.~ ~fl~~·~.m~.~a.~~~~.~. .~~~~~~~.~~m.om~·-M~.~~.A'ffMtt #~~r~~±~~·~.~~~~.~~~~~~~-M~.m. •• ~*m~fl~.~~~Zk·WH·~~±~z~'ffM M~.~~.k~flm~.ft.~ •• ~~.·~A ••• M~.· ~. ..M ..... ~.~-~m.~m~·~. ~M.~m~~~.~~.~. ~~~~o. ... •• ~~~ •• ~.~A~~~.~· ·&~m.~±. q&fl.(~~.~~.). ~m~.~·-~A~~~~~~~.ft.e~~~~±~.. ~~~-M~W.o~~. ••• k·~~.~~~·~.*-MA. «tt~H~~~~.m.m.~*Mm.~.~±a~~~~~~·.

(21) ~~.~m~w'~M.~~~~~m~~o. •• ~~~*.~~. ~~~'~~~~~.~Y~.~.·~~.~~~~W-.~~ .~L~'~M.~~~ti~.~~~~+~~~~~_~o.* ~(~~~)~~~~.~~.~.~~~#~,. ( • • • ~m). ••• ~~~ •• ~~.ME.~.~W~~· ••• ~~8.~ ~.'~~. ••• ~~~.~~L~~~~~~~o~~~~~~. .~.5*.ID'~.~~~~.. V.~~~~.~N. ... o#• • t{W~. WW•• ~WW•• ~M·#~.~t{.~M~~g.~~·~~. ••. ~M~~M*~~~~~~y.~. ••. ~g~W*~~~~~. ,.~*.n~~.~~.~.m~~M~.·M~M*~.*~~. .. .... ... ~*.m~~~*.W~ ~. ~~. ~~If. ~~. ~. .... •• ~9.~~·W.~~*.L.'~ ~~.~~.~~o. m.~~.. •• ~.~m~~@~Mo •• ~~~~~~~~~~~.~ '. ~l!JM3!.~.iH$ • • ¥I.fj.Jf~::r*Jf!uHU@~. 0. (£661). ~*¥3!~ '(Z66I)~~.:Y:~¥ii~tP.OOl~rl:ll3!~ '(y66y)~. ~1l~l(Ml.3il1f~ '(0661H~.~.Hlnf • • ~~~~1if ~IlYM~.if.~. , (886T)~:Y:~• • ~1if. '(6861). ' (8860#. ' (L86T). W.~ ••• '.~*.~¥.m~.~~w • • • '~~~W~ ~.~ ••M•• ~~#=~.mM~-·MW¥.~.~~~U •• ~'~Mo~if~~~-L~~~.~~~~. M~-.m~. M~Y.fj'.t{~.~.-~~M.~~.fj.m~.~~'T. • • ~·# • • ~.L~.g~.~n~.n~w IU. •••. ••. -.~~. §.M•• :~.~~~~w •• e.

(22) 222 W~~~x~~~~~'~~~~h~~.iliA.~fi~.~ *A.~. •• ~~x~~ •• §*.o~.~~'~8~~~. ~~~'A~fi~~.~~A~~~~~m~~.~~.~~. ._0. .~fi~.%~~ft~~*.ffi,~~~~~.,~~.~-.j. ~~,c.,§ ~~T A~fUtJ.~. m%~Z3'r' jt1?:~Am~. .. ': ••.. r.~J' r.hJ~~~~~.~ili~$'W~,n*~. .... ~, ~~f:I!~~~~~!!A~~.~'fg{rPJ.~~.h~(IJ._. 1993) • ~~*4!!Ht:~~JI:t-~~ ~m. ' ~841f:12JU2 a 2)1&). · fijt~~zB&~-lJilil.. (cf:t.. 0. },. ~T.~.~.h~~~z*·~~.mm.~~=. i. ••••. A~M*Bjt8~~.o8~~~~.~*~.&fi~h~ •••. ••• ,ti=. ~~.~~H.DA-~~.~ •• ,JI:t~8~~~~.M •••. ~~ro·M~~~m~&fim~~~~~~~~8. ~~.~m~·W~~H~~8~z~~~A~'H~~.A~.. ~~*~~~.~·tt~~8.A~§~~~~'~~.~.*. ~~x*~~. 0. iliA '. ~~.~8~~~JtlAjt.,.z"~*. ~~~~~'~A+~~~*~~~.~'~~.~~ .~~B.·JI:t~~*,.~~. ••. •• A.~. •• ~~~~ ••~~~w •••. jt8~.~oM~~jt~~~m.~~.~.*~.~~~,ti. 8~.~~.ili~.~~~~. •. •• ~~Mjt~.~~~.o.~•. ft~~*.ffi'~~.~Ms~ffix~8~~~$~~-~.. dEz~,jt~Dfi8~~.~.m~.,~~ ~.a(~. ••• ~~.~.. •• ,~~u1f:,~n),.~~~~~~* • • • • •.

(23) @• • M~~~ztW: •• ~.~ ll3 ~~.~~~. •• M~.~¥*ffi*~~~.m~.~o. ~~·~~~~.~~~~nuoo~~#~~~.~~·~. ••. ~~-~m.--*9.~~~±~~.A±z&~o~~m~. ~M~~~~~.~~_~~~~~~.nu,~~.~~~r.~. ~no. J. (~II~.:j!;t\Il) ~. •• ' ~1k~~~~. r *~mJ JYTijl. ®~~.&.o¥*L·~~~~II~.:j!;t\Il.~~~~~W~.. ~*~m'~~~.W~$~9M~~m~~~~~*.·~~~ ~.~.~A&tt.~'.~~. ~~~z~~,~~.&. ••• ~~~.~~.I1~.~~. •• ~.~~~*.·~§nu~~.~~~. •• ~~~~~·:j!;~~ ~.~~~~.ft.~~:j!;.'~~~.~Zr·~~.~•• ~ ~.~Zr'~~~W~~r*~.Z~. *~m~±~·~.~~~~±~~~.~~~~o~~.~~± ~~. •••M·.~ ••• ft·~-~oo·~~.~~±~~~~. A±~. •• h&~·~.-m~~±~.~ •• ·~ •• ~~.±. ~~~ti~~·~~~~~~~~~·~~·~~.~A±~m ~~~.~iiti.~~jiJ~~ (~7I~ • ~1I~ftl. 1111&). 0. ~.~. •. 1'{:m~-~. • ~84~12jj 7 a •. •• &.J1J.f!:(~. m.. 0. ~7&ti.~~~.z~~~M'~M±~&~.z~ti~. ~M~. •• ·&~~±.~~-MM~ •• oR~ww~~1k~±.. ~~.~~.mm·-M.~~~-~.~~~±~.m~~~~. *#(backgroundcondition)(Rostow, 1970,pp.350-361). 0. ~H~.. Rostow JYT~.fUfJ Jtt~ ~ _ . # ~ ~ • ~i1t -~fV ISIUE ilf!l~ILiUlltt. ' 9.! ~. •• ~~~~~fi~.Z~~~~.~W~,~~~.~~-m.

(24) ~..... *-:Y. Ji~±:1tti<J;t~.{lf. • JtUitllt § -tO~1tr»JMtti<J ~±:"Il?l"~ 1JJ*1J¥t'ult-rJ]1! m~· § !i1;~-fIIfiJlfmi~ · § -to••. ft.. 0. ~. ~B~ti<Jmmi!ttal!1t· .B~~.J1J~±:1tti<Jif!"M' ~)£IJ._: ~~·miHm~~~~itllt~.**·~~~~.ti<J~ •• ~ ~~~~.~m.ti<J~ff' r~ ••• J~~-fII~ •• *.~. ~. ±:1t J£ Jt!( ti<J :m: ~ Il:iI ~. 0. .,. 11. *WL,~.±:~~.~-mi!t.ti<J~~~~·~~ ••" ti<J~.·. • • ~m •• ~ti<J~.L •• 1J¥~·M.fIIi!tM •• ~.. ~~~~M~ti<Jm.·~~~~~.h*~~·~~ ••• ~~. ta~.,m~Il:iI~-. mi it.ti<J ~ ±:1t ,IJ,1j -. ••• Uti<J~~mi •• ~i!t.ti<J~ •••fi~ :m: 3f:JIJ ~m m~ ftti<J l~;;'t ~~. ti<J 0. ft.:£.. ~ •• ti<J~-±:~~=.~~*~ti<J.~~h'~.-.W~A~ ~.~.~/~-ti<J±:~~~.{lfti<J'M.~~mit.=T.A. ~~m~,~.mm~~~;. •• M~.m~.ar~a.J~1. *. .o~m*~Ulfti<Jff~'~.~i!tta.~~~~*ti<J~M •• ~A~~~·~~~~±:1t~~ti<J~.~fto. *. •• it.~±:.~±:~~~.*~~hti<J •• : ••••• ~o=.* •• ~~~ti<JfiJ8'M.~itllt~±:.~ti<J~~~.t •• M~~~Il:iI.o_~~.~* ••• it.ti<J~ta.~ •• ~~ *ti<JH~. · ~"~~1f!.~. ~.ll.,;t•• ftilJ~~AO~1t~.it. ~ti<J~±:1t~fl'. .W.~]!~ti<J.!JIJIl:iI(Yu, 1995,ch.4),. at• •.

(25) 8~.M~~~Z.~:. ••W•• ns. w~·~M£~~~~~~~~~.·~mM~.~.~~~~~ tim·~~~.r·~M~mM~.~~~~~~~m~~~,~. ~m~*~~~.m'~~.~~~~~M~.~oill~'~-~ ~~~~~~.. M.~~~±~~§.'~~~~~~~.·~. ... ... -~~~M~~.~~~*~.~~.~H~,ti#~M~. ••~. ~. •• M~~M •• ~~.f.,. ~. •• ~.m~'ill~M~L7~*.~~*oill~~~~O~ft. ~. mWM~.~~.. ~~W.~.~~~~~~~~·~M~~~AM~m~~~._, ~R~~~**~.~·~.ti~M~._~~~wa.~~,~. ... ... ... .-ft~ft~~~.~W~~.~~~~~~.~~·~.~~M ~H. ~.~~o. ~~~~.~.~M. M.m~~. · illtill~ilU'tt~~JlHKirkpatrick, 1979,pp.34-68). llP~~.~#~.It~~£~.1t~JIlJ~ · ~ .~._~~ti~~*.· ••• ~~~~ti~~~~_~~o. ~A.~~~ti;~~~~~.~. ill~·~~ti~.W~M~~~~.~-ftAO~ft*~~~ ~~~. ••w•• ~m.m~~.o§~~~MM·~M~~~~. ~L~B~~.·e~~~~. tt~~~·m~~**~. ••. ~B~~~.~.~.~~~~. •• ~~~tt*A~~o~~·~.m~. ~~·~~~~.~~~H~~~.~M~~~~~~~·~~~ .~~'~$.,m~M~'~m~~fi·A~.m@~~~~· ~.~~JM~It{ti~~~~._1I~(Lasater.1993). ~·§~~~~~O~ft~~M.~~ ••• ft~· ~~~~~. 0. ~~j!~~. .*~~~. ••~~·~m~~~R~.~~~~~~·ti~W..

(26) /. 226 i!it. ••. ••HW·N.k*ge.$•• m.~.~_· ~~ tE Jit:lm IdI ~ ffi JIJ ffltiJ 1t · • .g.. ~~-1Jl ~!lf@ W • liP"_ .• ~~.~m. -/lil. ~*~~~tt.~H.'~ • • *~A~~.*~~_~~o~. •• *~~~.~~~~~. D~°tE.mk·.g..~~~£em •• R~*~A.*~ ••• .1t·-1Jl~£.~~em~.g.. em~.m~.·~.B~~~tE-~A~.~r~~*~MJ.. ' ~1Il~'31 ~1I.1f. ~~~~~ •• ~otE~Mk·.T.* ••••• ~*,e ••. IH=rJlJ ·. .g..tEAO*w]~Jl~ ~£1tmbi. ~.9rlJJlft{~i'M!:~JRfnrP:W. '. '*-ftlH~1k~1h9r*f(.~m.. ,-tt!. •• ~~.~£~~= •• ~t·*~~~-1Jl~~.~H~£~.g. •• ~-1Jl~~~M~ •. R~*~~~~em.~~~~o~~. •. 0. .WtE.g..~.~~~.1t~M·~£.~~.~~~~.1Jl9rtEtl51.~JE~--~~*~.l\.g..~~. tE1k~. •. .g..~. 0. -fjt?.I;H!~~jt.f'. •• ~.'-H~m.g..~.mv~·Jit ••••. •• m~~~1t~.o~w·.~e ••~ ~~~£1t~~~'£$A~~.g..V~l\~~~.g. •• ~.~. A.#llA~,.~tEuDJlk~;ij(m.**~j$~.-~$lfff' •• ••• e~~~•• .g..~.~ •• Mm£$~~h·W •••* *~.-~~o.~~~~ ••• ~~~~·~~*~-~m •• ~.~Tg~.~W]~. • ~g*~~tEH.*~•• '-~OO&~m• .g..~~ ••-. ~~~m°tl51Jit·.g..~£1t~~*~.~~*~m.~·W*M. ".

(27) e.aM~~~Z.~:. J1! -. ~ !l1J1l ~. lIif ~ .:E1t ~ ~1ifI)E tt. •••• ~ 2n. 0. ~lIif~.:E1t.T~~.~~.~~.M*~. •••¥az*,. *~M~~~~a.~m~~.~~~~.,~~~.~~~.*. ~~~~~m'.~'.~.~.~*'~. •• *~~~~~~B. ~.~n~mM.~~~~~~o~~~~,.~~~. •• m~.. ffl.~M~~.~~.~.MJ1!~~~~~m~~~Eh'~~~ ~~.~~niIif. ' ~.*~-fMlMt~lIm.{tfl!&ijl;rHfJjJU~.*~. ~.'.~~.*~~~~*~W8'~~-~~A~.~~*m ~·~.~.*a~~~*o~~~~.~.~.*.m~m. •. ,~~.~*±~~*~~~~tWH~. ••. *~~.~~. ••. ••. a~~8.~~~~X1tWtt~~.~,~~*~~~o~~,~. .~~*~~~~~~W-~~~.~~'~~~*~~~~~M. ~m.'~.M~~~~*~~~~~~.~~H~~~'~~~ ~~.&Ht:**~,.!lj]n. 0. ~.-~~n~~~.~.mt~lIif.*~~~~.~.~. •• ~!I~~-AA=.~~+ •• ~tW~*~ ~~.~.~.*~-AAO.~~~ •• ~!I.~-AA=.~. A~A.~~~. +•• ~(Wu, 1994,p.191). 0. ~.~.~·~~.~~.A*~~ht*~~ *~~~.A~.~~~. , •••. ~~Ul:mt£.~~. ••. ~:l&.@~~ht~. t~~m~~. to~~~~-niIif.m~.~~~. .~~*~~#fi~~.&'WH~~~.~. ••~AO.~*£. ~1JIl~Il.~.~(Ma, 1993, p.209) , {f!~~-niIif*~.l:tl~.. ~.~.*~a.!I~~~.fi~·~~~.fi~(~~.naz.

(28) -,n~~e_.*MwomMe_.~~~.wom~~m,.. lRe_W 0 ~Jfb.*~rP:II~1&~) B-iL-tiLiF B9o.13%!l1JUJlJ -iLAliiFB93.21% ' .p}!l1JUIJ-iLiL=iFB97.72% (il1fj~ , ~83 ' pp. 248-249) ,Jltm1&tiUIl~.il1fj1ipm1~l±~ 0. ~*L'~~~~B9~.tt*B9~~~~~~#~~B9~M~ m,m~'~~~~B9H.~7~.~~~.~*,~~.~m.. B9.~~m,~.~~.**m~.~~.B9~~~*~~.'M §ft~~B9~.tt*m~~~L~M'~.~. •• B9~~o.e.. W~'*~B9~~~a~'~~~~~ffme_~~OOB~~B9. h,m~,Jltm~. ••• ~$*~m~.~~~~,.~~W~'. ~W*mflJJftd4Te1ftf. ' ~~~f.IiI!~~~1~¥UHiWlB9~~~J~ , mI. e1ftf~*~m.m§.*.~~I~·~~~.~~.~8.tt(.. Jj}$ , ~83iF ' p. 69). 0. ~t# ffljJErtr~~J~B9~1I. mlJIt ' ~tJi(~ ~'!!!:.~.B9-¥~ , *iH~e '. ~e_FJT16'~~A,m.~B9rRHI. 0. ~~§. ft.~~~.~.B9*.,~~.~~~~~~~~~'JIt~~B. -iLiLOiF'.ff~~~~±~~~~~r~~~~H~~-~W ~.eI~B9~~J~~~7m-~*.: il1fj~~. r~~m~~~B9._. •• e~.I~B9~.oV~~~~.tt*,~~~~ •• ,. ~~~e_*.M~·~~~~~-B9~hm~o.e~.I~ft. ~m~~.$.$'X~.~~~~~-B9.~ffJj}~Jj}°J .1L~.. '. ~81iF. ' J(1143). 0. (~. ~Si:~e1ftf~itr1&fj*~B9rP:IIJ!A. h'M~e_B9.~mM~OO.~~~-~*.'~. ••• ~B~. *~m.~B9~~'W~~~~~T*T*B9~~'@~~~~~.

(29) Z.#'~M~~.~D~~L~~.W-W~.~~~~.~~. .*'~~.~W-U~W.~~~~~~~~'~M~~.o~ ~~~~w.~~~.~~~~~~~,~.~~~.~.~.~. I~M~~~.~~'~.~~~~~~~~~~~~.~.~~ ~M.M~~~W~'*~M. •• ¥.~M.~~~.·~. o~.m.~.~~. M.~~~.W'~ •• W-~U~~~~.~= •• '~.~~ ~*~~~~.~~(~~~.~)~~~~~~~W~. '~~~~~~~. •• mID. •• ~~.~~D.-~WID'Q~~(~&*. .)~.&~W~R¥'.Q~~*~~ ~o. •• M~ ••• ~~~'~. • • ~*W~~~~y~~.,~~~~W~~~~~~.~. '~~~~~~.~.~~~H~W~~'.~~~~~~~-~. ~'~~.~~~~D~~~§~~'~~~M.~~~M.M~ ~~'~Z~W~~.~~~~§.~'.~~¥.~.~ZMa ~~~.M.~W~»~.~~IDo~~fu~~~.~W~~.~. ~~~Ma~~~~Mmfu~~¥'~~~W§~nM'~~~~. ¥~~~~¥.~~~~~w.*~~~m.~~.~~~*~~~ W~'~M~.~~ ~.*r~w. ••. •• ~~~ij'~~~~~~~~~.~~§. J~~wm.~*.~~~. ~. •••. ~~@-. ~,g. o~.~~.~~~~.~~~~~,.*~~. ¥W•• ~.~W·.¥~~~~~~~~.~--~.~ •• ~ 6~. ••. M•• :~aZ~~mw •• ~.

(30) ••••••• ~.~ .•~ ••• m~ •• ~ •• ~~.·A• •. ' 1H'&lIU.*,Jll~'ltnm:Bfllll'l'-&!I¥J."it~. ~1Ir~ ~±.*'J~~fF. Wft~~• • ~xa~~ m.~m~m. •• ~~~ •• ~fi~.~~~~.~·. •• ~.~~llm~~~~~~.·~X.~~.n. •• ~~~~.~. Wfl~~-$~.~o~.~~±.~~~~~,ft~.~ ••• •• *,J~~ ~§nu~~~*fl~~_~~~.'~~.~. 0. - , 'I'-:t"'!'1 : *~.'~~~E~.Zm. *~. ••• ~.n~~,g~t:~.~.r ••••• :. i!l!tl~.~.fiT~1tJ. ilftHi:>c '. 1i!:jC~U~: •• ~.84~. • J{33-43. ~1I81~. 0. •. g.~~1"4~@~ • • • ~.~.~fi~&~~$.·e~:=+-. tJ;;I1HlII~.JIij f.!I3~. ,. 0. • lIA.lt*II.UtWtl9 • •,Ul"* .. e~t. '. : *~Ep." ~1I83. ' e~t : -+-1.Itte 0. e.~1ii1994~tl •••• ~.~if~fi~&".. ~16: •• ~.84~. • J{1-13. Q. ~~.·. • • • • '.~~~&II • • ~---~ • • • • ~ • • ~.,~.a. ~lf ' tiU'lIfj~.j(.f'iI ' e~t : $~ililllitl ' 1993 *-*~. ~.iI!!..1994~.~ • • 1I:~.".~tIf.ft e~t: =+-1i!:ea. ••,. 16:. ' ~~. ~.84~. , J{1-22. . *1I1UIi:t.JI • • • • • .. 0. 0. e~t. : 1ii¥iililllitl • ~.83~ ; I!tJfIJJ • • • Pi. •. ~1iiliI84~12JPB llfi/i ( .. ) • '*'~It~ •• WM••• tl'~t : jMlilillli*± • ~.8}1. I!tllili~~ • • • • lIw*.=ta . a~t : I1l :ll:.1!l.ilillli*± ' 1991 1!t~.,~.:ll:. • • • ~~ • • • • ~_~·e • • • • • • ~~.ft.Z~ • • IIPlJfttiiliJllt~if!.~~' ~.~. 0. n:ll:.~. 0. 0. ~a~,e~:fi.~IIj(~.~. pp.70-93. ••M,e•• ~ •• ~.tI9~~ •• fIIJlt* • • ' ..::.,~-:t"'Q. •••milf•• ~Jllt* •• ,~IIU••. Q. ~.82~. ·a~t:fi.~IIj(~.~. ••••• ~~. 0. :. Bollen, Kenneth A.,. (1979). Political Democracy and the Timing of Development..

(31) ~jiJl!&7tH~±1tZ~1M. : frIftgijllljiE 231. American Sociological Review. Vol. 44, pp. 572-588.. ------- and Robert Jackman, (1985). Political Democracy and the Size of Distribution of Income. American Sociological Review, Vol. 50, pp. 438-457. Cbeng, Tun-jen, (1989). Democratizing the Quasi-Leninist Regime in Taiwan. World Politics, Vol. 16, No.4, pp. 471-499.. Chu, Yun-han, (1992). Crafting Democracy in Taiwan. Taipei: Institute for Na tional Policy Research. Cutright, Phillips, (1963). National Political Development: Measurement and Analy sis. American Sociology Reivew, Vol. 28, pp. 253-264. Diamond, Larry, (1992). Conclusion: Causes and Effects. In Larry Diamond, (ed.), Political Culture and Democracy in Developing Countries. Lynne Rienner. Publishers, pp. 411-436. Di Palma, Giuseppe, (1990). To Craft Democracies: An Essay on Democratic Tran. sition. Berkeley: University of California Press.. Gold, Thomas B., (1986). State and Society in the Taiwan Miracle. New York: M. E. Sharpe. Huntington, Samuel P., (1991). The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twen tieth Century. University of Oklahoma Press. ___ MOO, (1968). Political Order in Changing Societies. New Haven: Yale University. Press. Ho, Samuel P. S., (1978). Economic Development of Taiwan, 1960·1970. New Ha ven: Yale University Press. Karl, Terry Lynn, (1990). Dilemmas of Democratization in Latin America. Com parative Politics, pp. 1-2l.. Kirkpatrick, Jeane, (1979). Dictatorships and Double Standards. Commentary, No. 68, pp. 34-68. Linz, Juan J., (1978). Crisis, Breakdown, and Reequilibration. In Juan 1. Linz and Alfred Stepan (eds.), The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes. The John Hopkins University Press, Part 1. ----- and Afred Stepan, (1995). Towards Consolidated Democracies: Five Arenas and Three Surmountable Obstacles. Paper presented at the International Con ference on Consolidating the Third Wave Democracies: Trends and Challenges. Taipei, Taiwan. Lipset, Seymour Martin, (1959). Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy. American Political Science Review, Vol. 53, No. I, pp. 69-105. Ma, Ying·jeou, (1993). Policy Towards the Chinese Mainland: Taipei's View. In.

(32)