德國一九九二年年金改革法之研究

全文

(1).". ;.J. 1Jn &m ~ -h. j£.j£..b.:1k- ~ ,'..J._ ' Dr-~ 1f~'~ ~ /~/U- ~ J ~ V~~~Z"""/.J ~. I·. 1,1 I. I " ~.,.. ~~. ifk *. ~. §. ~Irif. PIJ" §. "'1f:~il¥:~ZM~w\ffi.. .. ~. -"~~*i*1+~. *~Ur.Jf~Z'~J! fFZ~14JJ. .... -- " ~j.tt1til¥:~A:r:1+~Lf::Zi: [Ij"1+%:ztrr~. .. ". . 1. ~. " {-traj~#]~*mUWZ~fUI~ ftrt& . . ~ Ii! jf~Jfi lk. :93 . Ji' -A"M~Z~1f~lt. ... ~.~:}tt~. ~"'rJfMt. ..::.L.-~. -:l:-. 'JL " PJ'J. a. ~#; '-tE ~~~1tJIJ. - J\J\j1if~~1tJIJ!E T~IVf~~. * 1). ~j iJ~f 1 0 ~[¥r131fZ~. EI rV:-r1flij.::i'?-±IIti;:I::17~-tilt CIH!~ 1.c;; ,,@, ie" -'I9ll11> ~ s. (. ,. F.ln,*,rtfi1flijt&-~. l-' P?I"- !,'j. 1tc.~ "iiI... 'mff~~a~*.~~**.ff~.~. *xlfrm1+:i:~~i~tnH~xZ Rentenversicherung" rtltt Rente f%~{ttii~. 3i:1t Leibrente ~A~~fi:AA~ , ~.!lt Rentenversicherung ~j.~AIE:WJ. ~il¥:~A~omft.~1+*mmB*m~WaZAr. o.!lt-mMt~m. 7X ~j.HtrZRentenversichrung*~~3t~m!rtlo ::(£.!lt~Jlnj.Htr, JEM r 1+ J nJtl.{,'[WaA }ahresrente {§. .!lt7Xv!V'tHj.~ , fi:M{fi:Z trr.::f>'¥Hj. r 1+ J ¥{iLffiiv1~~j. r R J A¥NWf14A Monatsrente (;(i-$~FJJl1fA'Jf.*xt#{li$-fr it.!ltmi ,{tt::f>$t.lJftM Rentenversicherung ~A1+1:il¥:~'o {J::Lt';b T Jl-J Z ~IPJ J, *xltt.fRmm 1f:{fi:il¥:~ J :iI1tf:E~R::i!f ~Z Rentenver 0. 0. r. 0. -63. fjlj.

(2) f{7dE~ ff ili'. ;t'I§~ 2 ) ~-1LJ\:tL6f+-. J31L!3li. ~2Y+-f:;M. pq~.t. ~1*~~/F{itE~1M. ~T •• r-1L1L-~~~6f~§~&. ~i{rtJ T ~{lmjJf~jC 3 a. 1fi.1t;, Gesetz zur Reform cler gesetz lichen Renten versicherung. (I'. r*JJIM-.ttt-¥ J&{I:1~EfT Jt a ~~~~ft~~'-1L1L-~~~ 8. Rentenreformgesetz 1992 '. 1L. t:p~. +-=Jtfiep~. rtE1tff:t~. J a 1&jf.~;tm~ , Itt. rJNJftn -fl fi:mi;flj ®J 1l{t{f:~m?V J. -&~~;t~~W*'ftAU~~~~. tJJH[tt~~1f~1filJIfhu ~¥!i~~ft~m. ~t\j;rt~&f~§~m~. r ~II'''''' ~--7Xf~aJim~raj£-:tL1L. lU."'"A-;-,,,-,,. }j -. 8 ~ ~fJt. a. ,~ 1;:£ lit IH~!1. sicherung i&~~;EJtfjit~~. ,. ~&fo~6f~~militt~~~~&ill~. lt~~li'l1j~~v~;ffjllitJtJJ.t~f*foJ~-Z{llHW;ff1~ ):i-ttl. 00. "Landesbericht Deutschland", : Kohler/Zacher ( Hrsg. ), Ein Jahrhundert Sozialversicherung, 1981, ft IV, r Jtz3t:tJjjilm" Jl. Kohler/Zacher (eds.), The Evolution of Social Insurance 1881 ~ 1981, 1982, ~j r ; Peters, Die Geschichte der sozialen Versicherung, 3 1978; Stolleis,Rentenversicherung-Bilanz eines sozialpolitischen Fortschrifts, tJ. r ; Ruckert, Entstehung und Vorlaufer der Sozialer Fortschrift 1991, gesetzlichen Rentenversicherung, . : Ruland (Hrsg.), HandSuch der gesetz ~~J. TIV,.&1t [QULf'I:~J9f¥R.~Z~Jt Entwick lichen Rentenversicherung, 1990, lungslinien der 100jahrigen Geschichte der gesetzlichen Rentenver'licherung , RP Kohler (Die Zeit von 1891-1957), Hockerts (Die Rentenreform 1957 Hermann Die Zeit von 1957-1991 ) .& Heine (Die Rentenreform 1992 ), .MRuland EfT¥t1TZ [il]-ft:ijf , 51t{1J, r 0. 0*. :m-'&. 2). *j'(rpfJTfII}Z~1I. 3). II lit 1X ~ iti&. (. ~. ) M-*[ij~#Jf---i3tr{,f,m£iji~*Z'@~ *JtEfT'31 0. (-~~O~+_~)IV,.z.~&.M~.~M-~.o. ~ Bundesminister fur Arbeit und Sozialordnung ( Hrsg, ), Diskussions- und Referentenentwurf eines Rentenreform gesetzes 1992, 198R ( ~.'J. rMfII}*!fl1J~Ji(~) ; Geisler/Knaut/Kramer, Rentenre form 1992-Sozialgesetzbuch VI, 1990; Blum, Die Reform der Rentenversicherung, Deutsche Rentenversicherung (DRV 5/89, ; Heine, Stolle is, Die Rentenreform 1992-Bilanz einer 40 jahrigen Rentenpohtik, D~V 6-7/89, 333 Ji ~j r ;Kolb, Rentenreformgesetz 1992: Konzeptionen und ProbDRV 6-7/89, 344 Ji ~j r; Ruland, Das Retenrecht-~euregelungen durch das Rentenreformgesetz 1992, DRV 6-7/89' 353 ffitlV, Ruland. Reform der Alterssicherung, Zeitschrift fur Rechtspolitik 1989, ~ 377 ti IV, r' : Ruland, Die Rentenreform 1992, NZA Bei!. 2/1989' ~ 5 1i IV,::-' ; Ammermuller, Ubersicht eines Rentenreformgesetzes, Die Sozialgerichtsbarkeit 1989, ~ 133 J{ ~j r 0. :m. :. :m. m. -. 64 . r ;.

(3) oj(. ::u: 11. .tit. + <. o.

(4) rglm+t;WJ. &*fE:~i't'~. ~mM'.I(m~-~Zw.) '~A. ~ti~z~~~~?~~'*x~~~ ltt1li~. W~1n'-jLJ\li~ 11.8% zt:t{91J~~. , rmffg-iftffi"rp~itz:£. z bt f§~{l~~n 2.1 % ' ]!. *.~~mmm'~~~~~ffi~~~. JL/\ 01f: 9.7%. zJt1L1f?Jri$~. fnJm-1L-tlilk-1LJ\01f~P B%}jIJ~j. 0. *12.6% 1k 12.1%. -Jl\ ~. ek$~~~. ~~. lit. }jIJ. 12. ill:. 0. OECD ~. Gennany, with. one of the highest proportions GDP allocated to pensions, has appa. - '\ -+1t1* ~-ZJltfff-Jlk5JL {f {fr: 1Wd~ z lrv-¥ jt ~~lI:M'~ ri. rently succeeded in reducing and sta bilising the ratio 13 {&1f-1LJ\J\~. ' rm. 0. ~m~I~ri*m~~ooti~~~90. ~~~¥~a.~. *_OEDZ•• '. ~~~z3t{tm#fi~~=--mJ~. ~~~~~. )~~,~~~. (~~~-·1L=~z~M~.~~~. ~~~{fr:M#~.~~mm~~M.~ 1j 10 0 1f~m OECD m*0;tt~~ ( §. ili=ffiz~~m.~.). ~~~~~~0~A~~.~{fr:~)Z. !tf.ffit1~U~JJ~-. lt~~:1Ju1tfff~. tt f91Jii-t1- jL/\O~ z. 9). 11. 0. OECD,. r 11) 12) 13) 14). 5t;lmI~ Ii!. 105 JH_:n". lPJ iitrtt '. 14. 0. '. illi~&~\~.f{~*. M~~.o~lIt#~~~:lIt-~~~. ;ffIflJI~I\l~r~1f:~~1j'iLMliUlfff$~ OECD, ~ 81 1f: '. 10). 16\~Jf~t:MiTf{MIi. '~.Ift~~ttft'P~ ~t. N:1*-W:1JJ / jt S)l'W '. +_iiJ~ 51. ~~¥.l&fY] T :'rfi:*~1fi!J It~i~. ~1'fI&$l1t~~*~-1LJ\li~0;tt1f {fr:E~f6" GDP. ;W-jLA-t. Refonning Public Pensions ,1988 k'J.. *ftitt~tflJ i!&~utfJl1{ n~{t nfDf! ' MJl1{$~ ~HiJf 1t ' 1%. 0. ' 1*-W:Wl /1i EIJl ~ ,. 1tJt:~ 19 J{~.:J. r. ~ flutE,. 113. J{ tl.. o. 1960 tt19iJA 4.3.% ' 19851f:fftlA 8.9% Social Protection, ~ 33 Ji 0. § OECD, The Future of. 0. , ~ 20 J{ k:.{l:.:et*,.p]1 f:i Ruland, - (NZA) '~5 ~~.:J.r 1957 lJ-ftHtlf-t rIf] ~~ zJM1':mHlHft r ffl:t'lJ¥ J Kapitaldeckungsverfahren l!lW Anwartschaftsverfahren' M 1969 1f::i§ 3:':00 1* 1T Mi ll)( Mi f1 z tID fI ;fi J¥ Umlageverfahren ~1Il1t-~1j'i , ilN$OO Zollner, ~Jtt-- , ~ 141 ' YJ~* , ~ 62 Jt:{X~$OO Hockerts, *1f1liff;fZ7t;: l1!mlE' .tlt~3t{1tf;fflI~.Jii{g;~~-1fg1Jlz3t11. (§1383 RVO) ;§fMiJ.tlt~3t 11tf;fflIz~iht ' YJ ~*)(~$$* 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 66.

(5) ~m -1L1L=i=f:i=f:~2x:iJ1.t~ 1ifF:re. j\--I--=i=f:7\f3 . lltj~. , ifW-Jt:ft OECD. ~. ~~~pm~~LNVZ1§~*m' rm)~it. 18.93 % 17. ti**1j~~m{~z* ffi~~. *ffi~'~~~±-~m~~~~~~. 0. 0. ~rWJzf:lfAa~~'~~=O-Oz " ,,'o~'~:..L,,'o~O ~ -i..l ~~"=" -1:M-? 'if. 11 /t~......c........ ~ ~. 20.49%11=0=0~Z 24.37%. 18. 0. mr. ~.~.B~*W~t.!E-~&~,~~. Aa f:t~Z r~~.~p1g1id~f!~ , lkJ3.f5l 1. AD*E*.Z~iI. ~~~o*.t.!EM'*~1n-1LAOIf. m1nlli~$r~~l1.iP}£~m¥J. zf:!fAa ttf7JJJ.t 15.70% ' =000. =0 -. z. fx:E!"JA p :If-t 151t~~~~m~1fz r~~. If. .'~rm~~m~m~I.~*~Ap. 20.48% ; ~1n!PJH:fAAz W~&U*~u~ 15.51%' 17.12% 1120.35% 19 *W. f:i~~~)lt![Z~*. 0. 1&11 OECD Z. t.!E jff , {£ -t 1mL± ~ I. ~. * (to. 18.86 %, 0{ 11. 0 0. ~. ~~-~~z~.~~mlli'#-1LA. *~~~~~*~~~~~~~~B*. JL!f{E~~ (-§ti5)ffi*zW~l1*. l1~~)~~f:~Aa(;\+li~~;\. .)'A~I~~~zAa.(w~. +li~Uk)Z~~~.~~~**i ~;1=t: it/\ ~ ~ rWJ 16 0 fJ( -1L J\. 0 ~ ffif. ~ 59:Wl). Zf:Irf.A. ~~ (~~). ~. ~. - 0 Irf. ~. 2~,.74% '. ttf7JJ~ 1000: 352 ' fEl.tt{~&UM~~.t. 0 l:t{7u~. 15.51% ' =OOO~~ 17.12% '. Wf:!fAp ( 60 ~0{L ) z. 7t~=OOOlfz 1000: 422'. =0. =0. O~Z 1000: 478 ' =O=O~z 1000:. = 0 = 0 If ~. 556 ' ~l1=O-lilfz 1000: 747 200. 21.74% ; ~rm!PJ-H:fMz-t~-f-Y.gm ~u ~. 2. ~!~*E~.Z~iI. 12.53 %, 14.63 %, 16.36% 11. 1~ . ~~ili~$~~~& • •M~~AP~~~~~M.'*~~M~-&~~.Mom t£"t-~fJEm-lt¥~PJ~Xtf1l ' *~IIZ~W'f~Ut!![£,01--:tL-t-~tljj:$A 1.9% ' -:tL)\.)\.~jW{i~ 1.4% 0 ~,01-HjJP:j • •{£-:tL/\01f:tl:L't.*ZHjJtfJ• •A 71.9 ( -!J:.. tt ) &. 66.5 (. J5tt). ,-:tL)\.)\.1f:,~IJ*~tiA 78.1. ,01--:tL7\01f:A 18.1 (-!J:.tt) & 15.3 (J5t'i:) 17.1 0 t~..t!lV!SlLJI § Zacher (Hrsg.) 618 & 619 Ji[ 0. & 71.5. 0. ~,01-7\-t~lfifz f:t1]~.. ,{£-:tL)\.-t1f:~U*~IJA 21.6. &. Alterssicherungim Rechtsvergleich, 1990, ~. 16) 17) 18). OEeD, fPJn:tL ' ~ 33 Ji[. 19) 20) . I1t-!l{f:tLJI § Zacher ' ~n-1i ' ~ 615 Ji[ 0 Bundesminister fur Arbeit und Sozialordnung, Sozialpolitische Information, 1992/1 ' 1 Ji 0. [PJlllin [PJlIIJn. 0. 0. 0. m. -. 67 .

(6) ~t1Y+1:::;W'J. il;!{*U2~~ffifa. ~~f±ill'fm~JI!tm-1f~{~'d~tlJiJJlz J;~. , ~~TlttJ~Ao~1tz. ~j ifJt*~~mz BY:'~~~ 1: J,f:. ' Jtlj. i:tr~. ,. ~. lli1*1f-fiz;ij!IE Flexible Altersgrenze ~%.A+.(*~l~~.~~~~. 0. o Z tt{Ju~ifJj;t:k!;1* 21. ~~,. )£i~=+E1f-~. *~. \0. 15-1Ci tt {§HH!. 90 % ' ~-~ n)\ ~ J1t I*.?P. 79 % 22 liJ¥~J1t ~~ 0. 1ffizmIE Vorzeitige Altersgrenze ' (~~~tt*lA~+E~N~~.fi 1f~t\+~. ~~~m~z~~~A~. ;ij!~~~~~Zill*1ffi.~k~~~. 23. 0. ~~>ft: 15~ rm~~. lli*. ,. ) ~*~1f1f~ 27. Itt. *~~*~,~~~W~~~~~~.. J5,It*. <li~zAo. * )\/\. 80 %. ~ £i {CiA~. 72% ' 33 % 24 Itt ~;~. *. 0. II. 29. % n;;: 1f ffli;;\ +- 1i. it ' 19-}L)\/\{fJ:tU&+:g. .~m-m*%fizl*~o~Itt~~a. ,. 0. ~.i. ~~'~"'/I~"A.. m-1f.~+E.~~fi t-t~ms~--~* IEllii*1f. fi' 31. HE. ff. HE. Berufsunfahigkeit. btl. ~~{f-. Erwerbsunfahigkeit. '~J(z~j}j$-~$$~fi~. *. M -M;:,fi!., ~Bii ~ Z-'- s It&c. flT.'_:n" ~J ~ /'" ~ v.y. 0. 1-):; -fR1: Id; ~ 'j1..\ 1f~Wt. t:iIi. '. ~mrtto. ~~~.ZM. 26). ••• ~*~mffi$*o. ~ ~ itMH,t ,~:. ~ /G mE l'ff 110 ~ i!t1 0 ;.t§ ~ Schulin, Sozialrecht, 3. Aufl., 190 JH:J.f ' Ruland, Rentenversicherung , ~: v, Maydell/Ruland(Hrsg.) Sozialrechtshandbuch, 1988, ~ 733 J;[ ( 765 }'if~:J."f ) 0. 28) Zollner'. 110 J'H:J."f. 0. 30). ~]tt=J\.. 31). gl § OEeD,. 0. '. m36 W. 0. -68. ,. m.

(7) J\+-:tf::1\f3 'l!i'). ~ ~ -:tL :tL. ~-~~"f".!illi: B m-:fL-to{f. =:tf::tf: ~ c~ 1it ~ Z 1iIf)[;. L. *± 1W" ~ ft jf{ tt ~ ].f, ~ ~ 34. %;. OC. %' 78%. 1 32. Oift. 62% , 1~%l~~. ~tt~~w~ 0. '~L~.J. r. J LF~~Jllt:t~* D. ~~~~Rm~%.T~~.~~~A. r. ;. ,. EB. 0. {t£. L~jm. tf'MJt~~. 61%. 3.J5.. (fJ. 0. o. J LF~~JfJi ' ~U L~j;~N:~llqj:~ o. tfJtt't!. a(~~.Aa,:e:. ' . =O-=:~O{ft. 117% 35. ,ffl ~ , 1~U~. ill~ fffl Jtt ifIj ifILt:n ' ~~{~U~~§ o. {tdf{tt";)l , -. ~Jt$~&\~. 22%~ 23%. 37;. JLJ\J\~ 18.7% L 1*. 000 -O-O~ff.J~Ij~m. :n~ 25.9% ; ~. 36.5%. 38. 0. tLJL -'. ~. 1f:t.~~~~~~~tiJtt~OO~m.t. ti~~~Ro. 'A 79 % ' -' 81 % '. -. 0 1f: t.. 113%. 33. ~. "' ?x.~fI.Jf. 0. 'AQ~1tm.~t.. 32) ~. ,. m11. ~. 0. -~AA:tf:Z~~**.I~.~+~~~~. 1677.10 ,~R:. '. jt:*JjIJ;f§1it1i~ 62.5%& 70.3%. ,~.~ 0. ;zfs:jl$t. 'il § Der Bundesminister fur Arbeit und Sozialordnung, Statistisches Taschenbuch 1991,. 7.11. 0. o ~{tJiJfm*z.:f±lt~ :tt~,~M Bergman/Vorselen, Ageing and Social SecuFinancing, Report at the Request of the Generalof the Council of 1990 , 14 18.7% 0 Art. 2 AnVNG. 0§}ifJJ$:&t~. m. , ~15. - 69.

(8) P&*1*~lrH~. J4'~-M~~OO~M~~~~=tc~~~ A{f~]t!±f'E1tiSJJ! '\ *±ftm~'\ ~Jtit;~'. t~-At=~z~~o~~ft-~t. -~~¥~~~.~~~~=~&¥z !¥5! 39 0 ft § m~II:~*±ft ~. ~*ft~m~~~.~~~~r~~~. , ~W1f~Jff. FDP/SPD liit¥JL~AArll'. ~11*.~~ ~ ft. e~~~~~~Z&¥'S~~-~. J\. ='¥. ~ R1i& m. tlif jt* if j:\ m: ttl. ~ JI J4' -. *. beirat 41. ~*±ft$j[ rp~ ~. JL J\ -. !J)\&P~H1&il~f~. ft~.~~fiW~~T~ •• ~~~. 0. I. Sachverstandigen. kommission Alterssicherungssysteme. ~ 40; 1tll1f~H1 Efr~iJLZ;(};fI~. fl:*. .'Q:!1i +-t;Wi. Z¥li~44. 0. ,~M' -}L/\'~ 'rf.. ) ~iliAltttrmmt .". ftllt~¥Ii~* ~ ~1. Sozial. ~~,~~tiJ4'A~~~~~.~ift. -~-t~1=fm,.I~L~· JiJfm~z.. A0~~ill.~~~~5t~~.~~.. lli. lli&~m~o~~~n.~~~-%~. ~!J\mJ4'- ~J\ -~~::m. -Bt Mrp~ :m. z ¥Ii "'a- 42. I ~1=f=tc~z. lit ~~ ,. ~'1L-t. -t1=f~~~*.ft~mfi~zrJiJfm~. 1i!JJ ~ 3f ~ *IJ m: 45~~;tt {f~z ~:P:L& itJH±ft~~.~~ ffilt- Sadwerstan-. ".~~~ftJ Transfer-Enquete-Kom. digenkommission fUr die :So~iale Siche. mission ~1jJ4'- JL -tM -~ JL J\ - ~5t YJ'J. rung der Frauen und Hiriterbliebe. ~ili~AA~~~¥Ii~'~~tiAD~~. nen 46 fdt~~~AD~Jrt)ryr~*4 rl'l~JIl%'. 0. rp~l[t£ lli~~1*~?1¥~tii. 39). Heine, ,. 41) . ~. ~ff~'@AtiJ4'~~~~~#t~~. 430. ' ~ 141J';( 146 J{ 0. ;f±iJ"Ji:r,,~;{i~1t~~:t£I1n*f!1JW:j:tltmH:l FZ-·1lM83tlt,,*~A1-t~"'. iLt1-t. *,. ~. ~I1n.fl~~Hti.W~~.~~~~fi~z;{ift*o~ffB~W~~fi¥~~.. $1*l±litlll (§§1274, 1275, 1383 Abs. 3 RVO) 9=tjt*:ftll!~!!f!1J. 42) 43). 46) . 0. (§§155, 156, SGB VI). 1Et-~~*Zm~]}'1fB{Lllt7X?.t!¥ 0. o. Transfer-Enquete-Kommission, Das Transfersystem in der Bundes republik Deutschland, 1981 (1tJt~~ 19 1i ~~ ~ ) ~~]}. Zur Einkommenslage cler Rentner - Zwischenbericht cler Kommission, ( 1t~~ 229 A ~~ ~ ) JltQ!lf.lft¥li7'f7}JJI1~ Vergleich der Alterssicherungssysteme und Empfehlungen der Kommission, Darstellung der Alterssicherungssysteme und cler Besteuerung von Alterseinkommen, Unterlagen zum empirischen und rechtlichen Vergleich der Alterssicherungssysteme ~~H Moglichkeiten und Grenzen einer Annahrung der Beamtversorgungund die gesetzliche Rentenversicherung. BverGE 39, 169. Sachverstandigenkommission ftir die soziale Sicherung der Frau und Hinter bliebenen, Vorschlage zur sozialen Sicherdug der Frau und der Hinterbliebenen, 1979.. 70. '. i'.

(9) J\+=iF/-;-F!. ~YA-AAli/AA~~la.~~. tt§'~-:h.J\li ~~lli a.~1jl~. 1*11- ' ~llf.ltl~¥llt1xa1fi 47. JJ~. ~~~. 0. llt~a.~,.**~~&.~~~~ ~~~~~ft.~~~~~X~.'~. *. 8"J ~1ti 1MJ't£ ~ ff tt- 5E~ 48. 0. '~flmlf&:ltEa.~w~~~. WM~~ •• tEWti-~~~tt.~&. ~1*fi-~m.~'. •• a.~M~~. !EmjtJIwXe~:t.*~lf&.E8~ ~~o~~~~'~~a. .:wt. JJ:A . 0. (~~tt. .JL./" ~. ) tEf±.J:t~l:!I$i!.f± ~ 49 , ~ffijtEllt~{&~-T m- A1: hl.1¥rt*~~l: ' f!U:t~~&ti.Jt~ ~~~~~m~llt-a.o~.~~,. .~. $A£. Kohl ~tf1tlf&.~. a.. m=~(-AA~~li~~8)ij~.. .~~.~~~~:ta.A~~~~~. •• ~~tt~. ~A~~Ij~~W~Jt}1X1f. 50. 0. :l$i!. § ~ :l~15"fAlf&WJ ra, ,. tE~lf&:l. ~~tt~.B~~~lf&'illtt~:l~*. @~~~£**.~~'~llt$i!.~a.. [!1!1tJ1t.tt~.tft~f±.~~~~{\. 47) 48) . ~~ Ji.*;t~fli$7t. ,. 'm~~:l~~~wa.~. flfttj;'~~~~~. 51. 0. f±~:ltP.. 0. ~f*~ ) z ~z;f{!miI;tm~#-mt Zacher, Alterssicherung-Spiegel der gese 11.sc'1aftlichen Entwicklung , DRV Nov/Dez. 1987, 714 JfQJ.Ttt&.Zacher (Hrsg.)' q:t~T 629JitJ.Tmj~U*z-1N:#. AD. ~;t.*,.~¥~&¥~§~a¥~Hz;t.~~.~~W.om~tt.~~M ~-¥~~~~~~~ti~~~~.Z.mo~~a¥QJ.M~.~~z. •• ~~~. Battis/Krause u.a., Alterssicherung im Vergleich, 1988; Casmir, Staatliche Renten versicherungsysteme im international en Vergleich: eine Studie tiber die Systeme im Grossbritannien, den Niederlanden, der Schweiz, den Vereinigten Staaten von America, Osterreich und der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, 1989 0 !P.~ ~:t(~tiiJfJi:~1J ~j~Jt.J\t Max-Planck &1l~*±1W"7t:iiJfJi:F)fWlJz!tttiiJfJi:~:Jt:~{9!J 0 "ttt-.li F)f,}1 i1J!; Alterssicherung im Rechtsvergleich·.I!P~~·iITJlJZ)j.x;5f~: ;fflJ¥-iLA --::¥¥ltil~Jj{~~t±1lti1&Jfizj:i}lf~l#-~ Kohl, 40Jahre Sozial staatsgebot - Christlich-demokratische Politik fUr soziale Sicherung und schaftlichen Ausgleich ' ~ : Bltim/Zacher (Hrsg.) 40 Jahre Sozialstaat Bundesre publik Deutschland, 1989 ' ~ 133 Jl~jT ' ~:J.& Zacher, Vierzig Jahre Sozialstaat Schwerpunkte der rechtlichen Ordnung , tXM~.~~ 19 Jf I2J. -r:' ( 95 ][ ~j. r). 50) . 0. Sitzungs-Prot. Deutscher Bunc.estag, 10. Wahlperiode ' ~ 152. 0 .. tt:=:,. m61 J'i ' ,}I tl Heine' [PJ. ~~r.~J:Z±~M. BT-Drucks. 11/1274' ~ 1287 J{ ; BT-Drucks. 10/3496' ~ 6582][ , jt~~ Heine, ' ~ 158fi& 161 :ff 0. -71.

(10) iH!!l+-t;M. a*~~lf¥fit . ± ~tit. 52. ~-~li~~-~~=.~.~~~T. o ~.lltll~f£Jff ( *;JJ$ ) ~~fJ*±. !;'{I*Pi1¥='W.llt~Pi1¥=~~~'~~. &.~±.(~~~-~Ali.m.W. .llt~Pi1¥=~~~~.~.~~~~'~. ~~~) ~-~J\i\..T-JiTImB.. W.~Pi1¥=~ MjQJotli~~. epm CDU/CSU' SPD ~ FDP m.itt.il~~~}f-f m. Diskussions- und Referentenentwurf. ~ 550. ~~¥Jtf£.m~>1titf'F ft9. , ~{tj{tlift-t9w*±~ati~~~*~. Jl~~*.itf£}f-f,. ~T J:~.~*;f!;'{~~.~;~. ,. ~~o.~.Ji~MjQ,¥Jtf£.W~. ~Pi1¥=ft~.~~~•• ~~~~.~. &.~-~A~.=Ji~B~~~~.. .~.W~~TM~~l!ijo.-~A=. .WT.llt~Pi1¥=~~~~~Mo.llt.. .liJi!lY BKohllnl.ifijmfl~±~. .~AMJi~~ft~,.llt-Pi1¥=~~¥Jt. .~~.W.~~1¥=~'~~~.ifij~. ••. ~A± •• .llt~Pi1¥=wo-~A~.. '~-~A~.T-Ji~B~. =Jl KohlltlJ.J!ii{1J~mW.~Pi1¥= ~ f4Jilm&ti.' r*±.~1*-J. f£.~~~ti&.~~~~(~~. a&ti). ~~~o.~~~.~~~T_Ji-a ~it.llt-~~o. (~mI.W~±.m)~~mflti.llt. J:~¥Jtf£.~&ti.~itfF,~1!ij. ~~T!;'{H{1J~ti.~.m~~~~~. •• L'.llt.mm~~I.. T.~~W~.~~~~£~J:~~.llt. ~~~o. ~~~Pi1¥=~~o.llt~~&ti.~*~. ~~±.m~r~.~1*-J~-~Ali. ~~~.~.llt-.ft.~~oo~m~.. •• m~IW.!ilf£Jffiftft.~ ••~. .,11•• ' ~mJ.llt~itf'F,#fl~ffilf. ~~~~-M~.r~.~~M~£* rp, Ii J ~ I fF IJ\ jf. Arbitsgruppe ". ~n1itrm~. 0. , .!iI~=?X*.!;,{. ' 7t»tl. Heine, IPJtt~ , ~ 158 Jt Heine, IPJtt~, ~ 160 Jt. 52) 53) 54) . WIDitto. 55) . ~1J.OO Heine,. 56) 57). Refonn-rechtlich, sozialpolitisch, finanziell, Sozialer Fortshritt 1990/2' 98 Jtl.;A T ( jtJt~ 98 ) 0 91 § Heine ' ~ 152 J( 0 Sitzungs-Prot. Deutscher Bundestag, 11. Wahlperiode ' ~ 60 J{ , 91 § Heine' fii] , ~ 158 Jt 0 IH~'1f:1i£pt*ZllJ.j(n "Kronberger Kreis" l.;A.&ti:.~\f~ti.tlt tc1f:1i£a*!I!:±ul1f 0 ~1J.f;ll Heine • • ~ 157 Jt 0. 0. 0. IPJtt~~ 158 J{ I;rf.& Niemeyer, Die Rentenversicherung nach der. - 72.

(11) ............ J\+=~:f\~ . mm-1t1t=~~~~¥1E-::'iF~. 1fiz~*~JtU. Grundfragen der Sicherung des Sys tems der Alterssicherung 58. 0. 1L J\. -. -t1f- J3 ~-t B{QjiSIltIlM DGB ' !i~.M DAG lkJii:lIM BDA ~. ' ~&P :. -1f~~1'fWf¥~.;ffiIlt'£z~*~JtU ~T*M;. -1f~**~~I~**Z~~W~. Itt.~~J(~mW~~~¥.~Z. ~;. ~~~)~H~*~~.~'~m~ti. -ii*I1na~Zfm~~. ~1f~a~Z~*~~~~~~-~~ 13.-3&ffjfj 590 ~~*i:~JtU?tBtlJ!. -~~~~~lkAQ~~'tFf1f1f~f¥ ~~~tFf~~z~~~m~.1f~~. ~~~1f~*~.MZ~~~'I ••. W~~IJij?t~61. 0 Mz.~ ~lkJii:lIMz.~ 60. 0. ~ltt~.~~ 'I1naMtlU'~!E ~~1f1f~f¥~~~'~i:~ft~1ftt. ~ , ~x.J(i.~~~. It*~~~Z~~LmtFf1f1f~~W~ ~1Jij~~~~~tFfW~z~go~-1L. Jll] ~nfrJtFf~. ;. AA1f~jfj$tFf.m.*Z.~~~~. I {l1f •• ~~'. , tt7Xa1fiifHJtra~*±~. .~a~M'm~~~.zi:.~~~ ~~oa~afiz.'.n.m~hl. &P ~ ~ ~ m-= ;ffi H ~. Haushaltbe. trafmmfJcrR~~J. (Nur Fortentwicklung lost Problem) ~~~*~ftz~8~01l~ltt~~* J]{~UZr*J~. , ~~~n~ :. gleitgesetz z~aA ~m~ T1frl1f~~1. 58) . Heine, IPJtt.=:, ~ 152 J{ , ~lIz1f~{¥~tlt.Uft~~7t:Lttlt~ , {!! ~EE~ltff1J ~~nft~~~IPJ~~Z§~IT~o~~~mVDR~~II~1f~{¥~tlmz.~m 0 ~II § ~IT~z~*f&19liif~B!l Hendler, Organisation und Selbstverwaltung. fiil. der Sozialversicherung,.: v. Maydell/Ruland (Hrsg.), IPJtt=:i\, ~ 224 J{!;A. r. o. IPJtt=-,. ~. 59). Heine,. 156 J{. ~. Hci~,lPJftttoEEft~~li*.#~*L~*~WZa.~.H~.~~~B • •. 0. M'~~*~.Tr~~lIa.~*m~&~.~wZ- • • ~*'~~ili-~~~ ~fI.~I*J~ 0 *ft~n~IPJZ.~IlJ!;A VDR Jift1R:lliz$IH!j' Zur langfrististigen Entwicklung der gesetzlichen Rentenversicherung, 1987 l\~f-t~ 0 ~7~ , I *Z 11 }3U~~lH"J~ Stellungnahme des Deutschen Gewerkschaftsbundes zum Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Reform der gesetzlichen Rentenversichrung (Drucksache 11/4124) , ( ~~{4jj.ft Soziale Sicherheit 5/1989' ~ 149 J{!;Ar ' !;A& 6/1989 ' ~ 182 J{ !;A r ) 0. 61) . '11 § Heine, !P.ltt-=:' ~. 144 J{. 0. -. 73.

(12) ~1m+-tWJ. i!J:*~.ff.. ~.±.zfft~'±¥:(E~:llt~.1f~~. '\ yoAll. -t-frf; 1k4 ~-f*~. -. .~~~~~~1f~r~~z~#w~. ~~.jJt. ,. ~.~lttJ.~,~~r1fI~(m. A'f~ItJt~m~. .~.)'~1f~.J~l!Alkl~. a$'~Ma*~~#a$Jz£*~. , ~:ljt*l:fnjlltfXa. M,w~~.~r~.1f.I~''f~. ~'W¥~~tr~~~~£*~.~. ~~J'~.~Wm~~.Z~.~~. If. Z.~o~~rB~m~J.±.zfft~. ~~~~ittJIf:(E.If~~-ill:t.c~ .z~ ~. 0. 0. jt~Pm-1f. tnrum-~. ~mt:t~tJ9 J1Ji!:llt~Itf.~~Pjj(.. W"'t-~~tI. ~.fl°:(E~.~~tJ9~.~.~,£. Jttl:(E~ ltt ~nJtjt~P*1:lt. ~ 1l Biedenkopf. mZnJt'Jt*.~~~~~.~~£. m- ~ lli z £ *~ ~. At:t~ 62 0 ~Jt.±. Gumdrente. *tJ9~~Jft 65. 0. ri!. .'-~.M~~~~.Mz£*~~. *fID$~~~al~~tJ9-Ei:ii:. • *ft.flZ~~~~ollt*,~.~ MAzB~m~-§m •• ~~A~~. mM~lk~~.~'*.~~~~ w~re~£*~~.~'MJt~m$.. ~o. .~,a~m~oJ~~. tl* Biedenkopf l!AlkJt3t1t=t-z. ••. •• A~m~. ••Jt~-AA~~~~.tJ9~~~~ a~.Jt~fJ.tfllt-ittJ. '±••• ~'~ ••• &~~~~.1f. e..it4it '. :(EJt~~~F.~K~Jom~~~a. 1fo~~l:%~~~~~'.~Am-~. ~~ffZ~~'ftJt~nOOltllt-a~. IlfJ.~llt~~~~Z~~. *.~3t1t=Z.~,~~llt~.±.jt*. ~TI~~Z.~~JW~~.~~ 1/1:.0. sf~:;t$t:t~. 0. :(E*f;il: ' llt~.±.£. sl~~'1~~Zfft"J63. 62). , '1~pJtJ!. Jj~£*1f.. 0. Biedenkopf, Die neue 5icht der Dinge, 1985, 400 0 ~ - -W- Z ~ IYl tit #- ~ MiegellWahl, Gesetzliche Grundsicherung Private Vorsorge, 1985 ::(£~.~at.p ; It.Jtmt#- ~ Ruland, 50ziale Wld rechtspolitische Bedenken gegen eine Grundrente, ZRP, ~ 354 Jll:Ur ' I:U& Ruland' rnJtt.::::7\ ' ~ 816 Jll:Ur • • Z~.~~~~::{£~M~I:U~IZ~.A~§.'mn~~~Z¥~'~.I:U~ ~A.Jt~.~_ IJ~Jttl'iz1m~~1Yl ' tit#-M Lampert, Soziapolitik, 1980 ' ~ 166 JlI:UT Jttrxa1ttl:Untr ' f!l1ffi~ffU1}ZfffiiJA.'iPJ i3.1JUA1F~ilH. ( 1223 RVO & §10 AVG) 1fllz~lYltit~ Schulin ' , ~ 170 Jl ; Ruland, IRJtt.:::: A ' ~ 748 Jll:Ur .~~Az.II1~Jttrxa1J.p~*:m:*.a ' #-~ 5GB VI ' ~ 0. 63). 0. ~). 0. 0. 0. 0. 1*l:Ur 65) Ruland, liilntrtt, ~ 817 JiI:UT o. 0. 74. j-.

(13) !\+-=~1\~ . fliI-Jt.Jt.=~~~a!c¥7!-:c..iF~. z l'l7tlGflff. .::. " 1~ra'~~J1;.~~JNzn.. 0. ~ttJ:~7t*Pl'&IlI1~~$tjJl§. ~Ji!.1t~l. I~Ll:FJf~. 67. .jJL Pl* Wlft€1!~.1t:7t*.~Zt.. , ~i~IHI tE.tItiXi&1fi q:t. .'Il~-1LJit~Z~~i&1fi1!~~. ••~tr~~~~z~~o~~A-. ~ JL tE {t ffIj ~ f.J Generationsvertrag £fttz*±1t~~ , ~-fl~1IJ.'I~. Kapital verfahren Z.~mri&~~t&1I11 ' ~p f1i llfl ff Umlageverfahren Z Mf! it. .~r.'I~~J~~~~.~o~H. ftlBl ~f.J zJJ.;t.jt* J!tt- J\.J\1L ~ m. ~ZnA,jttt-1L*t~~~#~. ~ 68 0 .tIt1~ , ~ m.tIt-~~i&1fiP}f~. W~~FJf~~~~~~~~~oFJfm~. jrz Jji tt~ .~~ (Rentenanpassung). 1Bl~f.Jztl~i1Jm. .Jljt~*ffU~. ,. ~p ft*flff. !J)\~jrtt.tltm~ZJ: 69. Mackenroth tt-1L. 0. M!~A.I=t~~FJfm1:zrR'M. Ji=~FJfM~rFJf~*±1t:ttfl Wilttl'. 'ti.tlt. tt-1LJiJi~~~.tIt-£*.~A.~. ftlBl~f.Jz~*m~.1:~~zA.!J)\FJf tE~~ 70 0 ~ffilft£mr~ Kohl.~FJft&. jt-~jJ;f1HtA~tHtJjtlttti~~.&~.. tflr~~**~IIIft**z~~ffil1lJ. Mil I%.FJf~i Jbn Pl.~ 66 Schreiber 0. 66) . Mackenroth, Die Refonn der Sozialpolitik durch einen deutschen Sozialplan, 1952 J 1&.~ Boettcher, Sozialpokitik und Sozialrei~nn, 1957, ~43 i~-F 0 :fllJz1&I!fUf #-IVJ Kaufmann, Demographische Bedingungen einer Optimierung der wirtschaft lichen Gesamtlastungsquote der aktiv erwerbstiitigen Generation" : Kaufmann/ Leisering, Studien z-~m Drei-Gener~onen-Vertrag, IBS-Materi;lien Nr. lS.it.tlt Iffitf • ~Jt.~~±'SamuelsonM'i958ifJ9f.;£Z)Ci\tAn exact consumption-loan model of interest with or without social contrivance of money !Ji!. Mockenroth zMiIt :flAtHIIRJIzi& 0 ~)CfiJ.~ Th~ ]£)urnal of Political Economy 1958 • ~ 467 J{~. ro'. 67) . 68) . 69) 70) . .. in. Schreiber , Existenz~icherheit der industriellen Gesellschaft, 1955' 1&. ~ Boettcher J IRJ mrtt ' ~ 75 J{ ~ r ° ;ft] IHJ 1& ~ lit #- ~ KaufmanniLeisering , De mographic Challengees in the Welfare State .... : Oyen (00.), Comparing Welfare States 'and their Future, 1986' ~ 96 J{ ~ r ( JtJt~ 107 J{ ~ r ) 0 IRJtt-1m 0 J!..tlt~Mf}}flJf:flMzM.Iit#-~ Schmahl, Okonomische Grundlagen sozialer Sicherung,": v. Maydell/Ruland (Hrsg.), IRJtt=*· ~ 151 J{~r ( jt Jt~ 175 J{~r) 0 ~#-~Zweng ~, Handbuch der Rentenversicherung, §1272 ,tt. I,ll ° , #-IVJ Ruland. IRJtt=*· ~ 819 J{~r 0 Heine, IRJtt-=.' ~ 151 J{ 0 • • -t ' t£ ~~~a.Z.·JtJt• • •~t£~~.~&ft-tz~~~ttR • • ~~:fl~~Z W~J!.&fi ' lit#- ~ Zollner, IRJtt- , ~ 144 J{ 0. z. 75 .

(14) i&*~.~it . mlm+-t:;J1j. .J~£*~~~~~~a¥~~'re. (MA•• ~~A~~~~ ••• )W. ~~~~R~~~~.~w~m.~. ~aa~rtt.~m(~1fA~~m~. Moa¥a~.mMm.~~~m~. it ( ~§m~Jll~MWJ ) 71. ) W*~'1Mt¥Jt±.~il J ~~l$' ~ep r•• J *5!jt*imiPJ~~1fA~. ~.~re~~~~.~E~~a.~~. ~m~.'W~~~~1fA~~.~~. ill}] ~. *R~o~. ••ffM~~••~~~~. 1f*-re~*~#~m~.('1Mtt.. m-1fg*.-=1f~m~ 72' JW.~ 1l/l,*T~~~{-t~~ (m{-t~~. ~il)~.~~o.~~~'. •• M. ). ~~~.~~A~~(~.~~)*m. *'~~a¥~.-~A~1f1f~a¥. ~AQ~~~~~t¥Jtt.~it°~~~. ~Mm~ft~~~R~T~~-~~. 8tr~ ~ Kohl ~~~~~*lij(J{tl-. •. 0. 8tr~ Schreiber ~mmre~~~t¥J. fl1f~~~~~~il~~~it.m~.. m~~~%~Wff~~~~~~.mo ~.~1f~m.mtt.~~~~. 1f~~J!.:f~~~. ••~. -. W:oo.;t~. ~o. .W.%.~.~m~A~~~~ttn tttA~OO.~tfci~UJ~ m:fW~. ,. ep ~. m~~J!. :. ' {-t~~~~~*R;t~. ~~a¥~~~~~~.'~~~.m. m~A'~m:fW.mtt.~~m~o. ~AQ~~~.~m.~~o.m~. m~~a.'.~~/lA~1ii)£t¥JiI. ~M'~.~.TmM~§. ~T~#o. ••• ~~. .r*~ftitJ~.~~a¥~£*~ J{U 0. ~9t ,~~~a.~, ~ftm~~. ~~~~*~~~',*T~.~.tt.. ~.~ft~r •• JW~.~~~*'. ~~~~r~. ftftJ~£*~. £~ft~~~~~*R~~~~~~~. , EJffl1f~~J!.:f-RP~%ll!f*:fW. -~.~~~o~nffM~~t¥J~.. I.ft#--W.jf(~~A Q ~~JiJT~1Jn~. lI=JIJL-&IYl.~~*)C~fli$?t. 71) . §154 SGB VI. 72) 73) . §§56, 57 SGB VI ' ;fg[lL-&~llIt~rJll*±~fli$?t. 74). 0. 0. 0. llIt ~ rJll. Kaufmann/Leisering, Demographic Changes as a Problem for Social Security Systems, International Social Security Review 1984. Vo1.4. ~ 388 Ji 1;.,( r (407 Ji) 0 tf~rJll Kaufmann/Leisering,. IPJtt/\/\, ~ 3 Ji1;.,(r ~~~ ~1t~1iJi1;.,(:tt 1m 1:.~!iX;:fiWJ1ftltt" 1:.~ .Hi1iL:tt1JU iff:fill L?t tIT J1UfiHfi 1t1W~ I'-~~ ;;EJltfl• • 0. ••. 0. (~3~.~) '~JIt*.T~*L.*MMm~fi* • • • '~*iff.~.B. 1J!f • ~§'~ilJjt • • m1,J3&71nf~il!lU!jJtfnX;~~~~~!1J!fr,,'f! 0 tf~M Ruland ' IPJtt-=/\ ' ~ 819 Ji 1;.,( r 0. 76.

(15) =. J\+=~1\F.J . ft.itf!. *. 11111- tt.tt. ~1f.~ ~ 7! ;Z iff ~. Jl.za*J{tl~mIfF;g-{¥. tt~~~'-~1f1l0.Aa~.Za. ~.z.~~~~~;g-~~~.z~~. *tt~1it-nAn~T~nS~~~a *tt~ s li~ 78 ~OO~~*~J{tlz. 0. ~~.fi~~m~~~~~~~AIfF ~rsfl~m:bt[ 75 0 ~ttZ9~ , tt~ r ~. 0. ±~~'0~am.J!~1f~~Z~J!. fiUit jff J fAj~mif'iA~~{¥!t;g-J!i~~. ;g-(~~*I)~~it~AQ~~Ztt. A~~{¥!t;g-(~~~m~m.~~{¥. 1tit~o~~~~.~~'0~a1it~. $Z0~A~)~tt~Z~~*f!°oo. .*Tli.~~~ ••••• '~ffi.. ~±~~~~.~.~~~1tePitftllt. ~1flif* 75%Z~~~ 79. ~~m~A~~ott-~ft •• *~~ .~.~~J!~~. 0. ;'~~ffil~~aJJ*f-Ji:~. ••~~~*o.llt. jJ~~~~. -~~.~~~.~~~~m~tt1t~. llt1X~~a*jEi~~flf~1itMJt~. ~m:bt[z-~~'~~~~M~$.~ ~~.!t j] >j( ~ 76 0 ~1it llt ~~~. .Zr~~m:bt[Jo~lltffift,a*tt. ~'0~Aft~.~~Za*.*m~. Ift.r:fl:lflf {¥!t~. m-n!\li/. ·~Ilt1X~~a*ttZ 1ft ' .llt-rR'II~. ~a*tt~m~Z-~~~~=~M , ~~*~~.JffUJm~~"*tttWl. *~~~m'~ft~*~$~ •• ~Z. *. ~~~lftB.~r~1ittt.tt~z~t. ra," Berlicksichtigungszeit ffiJ. ~ ~ ~. ' ...... ~1f. ~~#.m~~oa*~~~1fllt~m. ~~~!t~~~Ztt.it~~~m~~. ~,~~~1itoo~ft~~~zm~~~. ~~~~.~~~itf!'~~~m~~. ~:fl:~~Z~*~~ot. ~Mi1lz0~A~~!i$lJ~. IfF~~MZ~~#tt.{¥.*~~.. ~~>j(~1f1fIlA~Zi:*. 75) 76) . !It#-~*x~ffi1flH)t. 0. J 77 ~. •• ~•• ~. 0. jt1t#-~~~llltlli:i!i- I ' ~ 144 JiIV.r ' IV.lkEb~~Il.~1l Ruland tt~EJftJU~ zl!Hs- , jt1t 39 Ji IV. r 0 tE~/ilt±.1*~W~J} llZi!!l{ftliJ1t Beamtenversorgung. 11tIJ.JH±ft-Hl1ii Sozialvorsorge ' 1tll!.ftliJ1t'Mt~1¥1t1*~-~1*. Regelsicherung 1k 1f: ~ 1¥ ~ ~ 1m ~. Zusatzsicherung z!!:I: 1fJ} WJjJ 1m IV.f:ffl II r"" II! !It #-1JIl Zacher, Grundtypen des Sozialrechts, FS fUr Zeidler, 1987, ~ 571 Ji I2lf ( jt1t 583 IV. r ) IV.1k Zacher, "Bundesrepublik Deutschland".: Zacher (Hrsg.) fjij;iEIi. ' ~ 152 Jil2lr ( jt1t 170 ); IV.lkWIiltt Ruland Z~1§'-. ' jt1t 35 JiIV.-r *lfl'fIS~~ , 24 Ji :f.fllzt&IYl' !It#-~ Heine, fjij;iE-=:, ~ 161 JiiIV.r 0. 0. 77) 78) 79) 80). 0. 0. fjijWI;iE' 162 J{. 0. ~*x~ffi~*. 0. 77.

(16) iJlm+-tWJ. f.k*7*,msi6' . ~5If1::f (Jtjt.~i!±~) ~'a. za¥±!ltfm-~~~m.z flHt.~. ¥~M.~5I~(Jt~.£W~).. ~. ~~~~~mw~~~~~z~.o~ ~m~~ti~ti.~~.wzm~£~. Jtm-Jjfffl.~It~lk.~ 11( 1¥1t~Z9~ :?3trJt~ 83 0 Hu:il1t~.*±.1¥Ii.m. ~Am'~.~.~~zIf1:.m.~. -JL--~w~~~~~~~~~*. Ffj£ , £{y!1~fJJ'J\-T~.~~flJJt-HJ=Jm. ~ Reichversicherungsordnung , fft~. .~tf~*~~~~.~.£.~~ 1( 81 0 fttjfl~ ,Jtm-~JlzJfftll!J)\ti1. *~~~~~z$~.~m-IAz~~. ". t.t~~i!ifJtJJfz~i!~.ilitl. 0. f1(-J\J\JL~IHI~~~Ii~~JJ. .; '~It. ' w~.. ~m-~~Nf1~z. 0. • .ftfttlil~-JL. L~~jfjjJffJt~WjJff.MElfl.ft~~. !I~!{.':f C}t~~~3i-BJ: ) 1~flJ~A 1¥~ 84 ~.~j£~~~ItZ.I~ ( Jt~r3C ) ~J!Mf'..;, }ij~tIM~1~f5l!i«' . '4~~j!tlm-~JL==~jfjffll~i1f-Jt ~ItpW*~{t~lU!.'~J9J:f ' ~fim' ?f85 b"n¥I~~~1¥It~£iI~ 0. ;L'. ~tim- ~ i!ill .1t lfirm ~flJ /F~J ' ::~ 11r';)\ ~ MtffJ[ ~'1J6 ~tt z 9~ , ~ 820 '", '·3l4IJt§¥.ij£Z § ~WjJffiIJtJj£.~~1¥ ./' '.' .t. . :. ,.~ IJ ~ ~ ~ lk. iPt, {9ij:ruY Das 0. J. I. :.. • a" .' . , ... ;ff~A*aAjlf'f~f\1j· •-.' :.ifF...., ~.. g;. , . .;' " ,.. ~"L. .~rt ..•. J !';l. j). I ilf~..tt.a •. ...... '.:. _. ::.- ~. z. ,. Angestelltenversicherung gelungsgesetz. ~1 '#iJt~\Hu~ft"Jt.±Zl%*~ 'ttiX~~a¥tf~~~.~~~L. 81) . .J!~lll'ms1il~. • ~ 35 JitJ. r ;. - Neure -. 0. tfttfffJfff ' ~~~~~T:!m~. #~.~mm"'~~~-.~~~~o. BlUm fIlJ~:=:. ' m 281 JitJ.r. °r~Jlt,mIlt't<JJlUI::.'. 1\1 § - JLAli:1f:HRJl'fj9jz-=f:kt'fJ'f ii:*,mt -f«llfTfR4ij--=f:k lfll£ z ft ' jt-llj:.~5C 0. .J!iJlUiJ~tJ.~9lAM-t AllIJ3 ( EI 1993 :1f:~= -tImOOJ3 ) 4ijJ3:Ra »i~Z.n:f!li 1VJ ' it~-t.jj ~mjtt&Af(JjPJtm~Jttrdfi.~ (§§4' 5' BErz9G) ft • • • • • OO ft.n.1VJfRZ.~.t~~-f«~~.* • • ~D~ (ffi• •d~o.Jtt,-.am • • jj~~9l=at~~.~'m~ • •~ali-t. 0. ~. ~. 83) . (§69 BSHG ) f!P Gesetz betreffend die Invaliditiits und Alterssicheruhg·7',:JI!J·'8-fJl Zollner ' fIlJ~ - , jtjtm 83 Ji tJ.r ; tJ.& Kolb, Gesetzliche Rentenvel"sicheritrjg , . : Sachver· stiindigen komrnission Alterssicherungssysteme, Da.rstellung .dex:·Alterssicherungs systeme und der Besteuerung von Alterseinkommeri, ,193 " 19 JitJ.r 0 ~#Jt Zollner ' f!iJ~- , ~ 110 JitJ.r 'llA.& Klob' fpJmr,~ Zollner, f!iJmr~' ~ 114 Ji& Kolb ' fIlJmrtt 0 .• ; .: ZOllner, f!iJmr~' ~ 130 Ji 0 0. m. 84) 85) 86). (>. - 78.

(17) 1\+=~*fJ. f!~-fLfL-~~~Q!{.f:E:ZiFo/G. ~Tm~~-M~'~~a~~~~~. M~*Jjj(jttlg.T. 3U:i1trtm:t~it ' :3t±~. ~fp~-~AA~:ttt.~.,~~~. r~fp~rt. ~M1t(iij~A.~J!~~!!iM 87. ->. J\J\~fp ~-JLIi. j4.1tjtIJ~-~~]ifpt±.~7tA1t7t~. 0. $Jtt~-fp~a~rt~-1I§11!i. ~.:t. •• o~~fttt.~(iij~,~~. A+li.(Art~cl):t~.~rto*. a~~m~~tt.~~j4.1t~.*IW. .~mA~mA+~.:tm~'~~~. ff~~~ili-*~ott.~rtj4.:tI~. ~.~m~.~~~ffi~~.~~~~. §. ~~=+~~~tr~~~~~~-~~. ~tt,~~tt)~~~~~~:t§~. •• (iij~~o Jt'~4t.~Um~~11!i*±-t~~jIt " WJ*. ~~~~a~ffij£:bnrt. 89. -~-~. B~*~rt:t. $~tt.~~~tt"a~1t(~ 0. 11i. " ekJft-Z£~>Ji. ~~*~".A.~~~~~".A.*~ ~~~".~~~~~~~I~m:t~. El. ao*.a~~m-.:tm~,~~~. ~~-~~-fp-~-B~m~~tt.. if-~JttIX~~?!i~:tJjj(~±~f*it. :tm7\i} 88 ° Jjj(*4t;mrt. tiA.Q~1t~~~~M~T~~~'~. ~~m~m~~S*:trt*~~~.~. ~~~ti~~~1t:tM~,~tr~~:t. A.:::::.s_+*o. ti~o~(iij~~a~±~~.M~M.. ~~j4. SGB. ~D rnJ~~= fI:1l*Jjj(jW. ' ~~~~. •. :tm~m.~~~~:tg~o~~~=. . 87). fdJ 90. '~~.~~A.~fi.~~~£ ° ~IJMr11 ~M.:t?!i1f!Jt~~D. ~~Jl.*IJ$1j!!~ • ~ 48 JH:1 r • Ruland ' FilJtt= ' (DRV 6-7189) ~ 356 J;{Ct r ' Ct'& Ruland, (NZA) ~ 10 J;{ Ct r 0 ~m;f±-t-~~~ Sozialgesetzbuch' (SGB) §-JL--tli~®WtfUI:.fll 0 ~EJlitr}.'.f, >. 88). , e.0i$niK1T1l ' iWJ1fm-jUl,!{IJ ( 1975) • ~fHJY.U-t-~~~,!{U ( 1989) '~A • .%il'&Wj."~1*1JJJ ( 1990 ) ,&~+.1T JJ&WJ¥ ' ltmt~~ , tltffB1,&Jtwm-1lfB1Z{tf'l: ( 1980 '&.1982) °1flltlmU-t If:: '. ~~~~!t~~. ( 1976) '~li.ftt*~~. ~~~1ttr~M Zacher, Das Vorhaben des Sozialgesetzbuches, 1973. 0. ffH~~~!t. f.ff~zm"J ,!{IJtif~M Hauck, Einordnung der gesetzlichen Rentenversicherung in das. 89). Sozialgesetzbuch als Teil der Strukturre{orm, Mitteilungen der Landesversicherung sanstalt Oberfranken und Mittel£ranken, Nr. 12/1983' ~ 474 J;{Ctr 0 Zacher' FilJHtrtt ' ~ 25. 9~. ftm~~'IAz~~~~ • • ~• • ~~~~~(~m1fZWtl~~+A.) ' . nllll'H\i~~~~~,&.fIHII~~~,!{U:JjfT~JL 0 ~~M Kolb ' FilJttJLO ' ~ 101 J;{Ctr' Ct'& Hendler, ~tt:f\+~ 224 J;{Ctr 0 ffl]zi&:¥:ittiliitf~Jl. Wannggat, Zur einer zeitgematien organisatorischen Neuordnung der Rentenversicherung der Arbeiter und der Angestellten, SGb 4/89 • ~ 140f{ Ctf 0. 79 -.

(18) m~+-t;M. sc*~~~mt. r:. ~~A(~%~~)~~~.I\+li~. 91. ~iffitJilfi4Ji~.L~~MHt 93 0 @~. -'~~il~-+.. .1\+=~~'~$~~OO~~o~~. mMr ' 4ij:moo-1MIJL~tl1M 0.3%L. {t(tftt!Hi ~f.J L~*)ffij{tl ' A Q :t ~~~~~.~.L~*fi_n~~B. ~~.. ' !J)\~Pil~tnM 10.8%. 0. ~.L~~~.o£~~-~.,:t~. ~~~4Ji~.~~L~.~§=O. A~~~*~~~~~~.o.~,. O-~~~1f~J1-' !J)\~P~tt~-OO. ~W.~m.~M~~~~#'~~W. -~~=OO~~!Hi4ij:~~1MIR~~. •• ~••~.~.o~~~a. 1MIR,~~4ij:~=1MIA~~-1MIn;~. ~.~. .*'~~~.L~~*~~~~E~. ttJtU. La.~~o{t(.a.~'~~~.L. (t(.~~~~LmJE'~~~A~=O. , !J)\~PiJJ~l\+li~. O-~=O-=~LIHi'm~{t(••~. -~mJEjt*a~. $4ij:~~tIn ~~-iOOn 94. 0. ~~~~.o~~M~mM~~Lm~. mJEmOO~~jt~*M.~~L~#'. ~§oo~~~£~o~W~~OO-~. jlt~~~OOL~.~.=:~~~95. ~'~~~OO~~Lm~~~.~~; @~ • • A)ffi~.,~~~~~o{t(. =- ' .g~~il~"Jz~Jta~ ~ .:r:1'1= z4tJlJ. .a.~Lm~,~~O-~~~'.. 9». *~ZM. ~). a.~~~tt~~~~~.~M~~.~• • o ~~a.~~ ~ ~~n.~ Z~~·.T. •• ~~.m.za ••• ·~~*~M•• J.~. •• ••. 0. ••. •••. ~~.~.~.. •. •• ~Z~~*·~.~ ••. ~.R~AZ&.R.o£~~-M~·~~a.~*~~~m~B.~.o. ( §300 Abs. 2 SGBVI, ~.~~Hib$1;t~~ 46 ]{ ~""f ). 0. fH!I~~~~~}k~!f!::¥it. $.*~£*~~+~.M~R.~.~~A~.~m~}k&~R.~~Z~M·. f&1t1n~~a.A1fm.Z~. 0 (1fIlZ~j~J~~.lff.~Ruland· '><'''-'---' ~ 746 ]{~~ 820]{ 0 ) ~~a.Jt~~li.~~AZ I fit{>jWH~ J Jt~H!lfilJ~JI! • ~ep.~~z fit{>jM~ J IIMI1'~M~.;f§~Zl*.' @£1nj!;f±1rIH!Z$• • ~J~.M~~.~~~£~~.~~~~~o.~';f±*~Jt$.~1n.~~. W:ll:-.~t¥tIJ.~t±**,Jll ' fl;f~1fil ;f±*IiJ)1!-• • ~ J Sozialstaat. r. *·. als Proze ~. 93) 94) 95). r. .~~.~ Ltcher, Der Sozialstaat als Proze~ ,ZgS, 1978 • ~ 15 ]{ ~""f • ~~IIij~. · Was konnen wir Uber das Sozialstaatsprinzip wissen? • : FS fUr Ipsen, 1977' ~ 207 ]{ ~""f 0. §41 Abs. 3 SGB VI.. §41 Abs. 1 ' 2 SGB VI.. §41 Abs. 1 ' 2 SGB VI.. 0. 80.

(19) fllJ-JLJL=1f.1f.~at:¥:tEZi}f~. !\+-1f.1\~. , ~Htr. ~1;1~tflS7tI~z~~$~A~Htr~o. ~~~~z~~A~*~.A+li~1;1. ~.~lli~zm~'~I~~A~MA. fi.~~.-~.NzI~'~~~. t+M~~(~~¥~.*l;1fflA~. JL!\.1L~t!Ml!f*z~'t'ilJ!~Ii:A*~. ~. .~.ttzI~'~~~z~M~.~. ~.~=7tZ-ztflS7t~~;~MAli. ~.-f.~%o~.m~~~~~. 'li~rt~'=7tz-~~;~M. ~.~lliI;1HtrzJ~IJ~~~. , itm:1~1;1 0.5 ~mA.). 101. '. •• ,~~~.~~~o ~~~lli~ •• ~r~~-~.J.~ ~~IE;' jtJt1L$7tl!f*itJtJN 97 ~ •• ili.T.~M~.~Zm~*' ~~.Z•• ~~~~1L-•• ~~~. ~A~J]t~~A7tBtl~~ 20% ' 40% & 60% 0 ~1l]~~ ,. ~.~.~~*'~.$7tmf*.N. ~~=7t~~~~'~~~mI~~ I. A=+li¥rt~ ,=7tZ_~~102. .MA~-. 0. *1;1.~~I;1~.,.~=7tZ-'=. 7tZ-&=7tZ-$7t~~z.1*~. 0. A'. 103. £~Uu~~~~~.~~m~r~~~. .J]t~W~ZA+ZI.;~=7tZ. .~a*.M~Aem~'~~.*ill ~~Z~~.W'-~OOM~~~z~. ~~~'W7tzA. ttl. ~ 't~OOJttl!thn*±-tztl~il. ~. , 87tZIlY+ 104. ;~7tz=~~ 0. ·fPJt:~~al1.1*~A. 0. •• I~z. §~'~lli~«.*~~illf*~~E.. ~. tflS7t-jf!f*$IJ zii!iffl .~A Htr ~. •• ~.I~z~l1m~o~~lliHtr. *fit,\ +li~~Htrjf!f*z ~1*Ii:A 99 o tflS7tl!f*z.~tft7tA-. ' l!P7t. ~. A~~=7tz-~~,=7tZ-~~&. .I~W*.~~~.M~'~~.. =7tZ=~~=.100o~.$7t~~. 1lMM !thn 0.6% z~~. z~•• ~•• ~Ii:A~.z.B*'. 7.2% ) 'itI;1Etill-~A. 105. 96) 97) 98) 99) 101) 102) 103) 104). zm~'*.1*~A~~A+li~~.. §1248 Abs. 4 RVO IV.. #- J! Geisler/Knaut/Kramer,. IPJmrtt. 0. (l!p4t~!thn 0. ~.. ' ~ 51 ]{ ~ T 0. 0. §34, SGB VI.. §42 Abs. 2 SGB VI. 1f:~~1f!.]t1lAff!tZ:1&lIJ3tm#J!~j£. r 1f:~zJt. J. 0. §34 Abs. 3 S. 2 SGB VI. # J! Geisler/Knaut/Kramer, ' ~ 54 ]{ 0 Ruland, IWJtt.:=., (DRV 6-7/89) ~ 353 ]{~T (~370]{) §§76f. SGB VI 0 ;ffIlZf&lIJ3tm#J! Geisler/KnautiKramer, ]t Niemeyer, fPlttli li ' m 100 ]{ 0. +. 81. 0. - , ~ 113 ]{W,T.

(20) ~rm+t:;WI. i&*7*~lffiit . a~~zm~'~~~~Z~~~~T. ~~~~~.lia~zli~~~~.~. I2A ~ ifiJj , tl:Nt ~ 1t -II ~ ~ 1m 0.5 % ( &P:Nt~~1Jn 6% ). A~lff~~li~~f,fMrFl' Wartzeit. 0. ;"'\-l--1f.:r*a'(±'~~llM. .zm.§~*,£~••~~re~.. ~,~*~~~~~~~~~z~.§ ~o~7Xa~~.~-AAA~I2A*~ .n&z~ll.ff~rdj Iit-~~~1.4.=:.. , o)\&~:Ntw.tE*lrff IJ\~z-HJ:Il~)t. 1l~12A$~=~~.~.z.ff~~~ • Kindererziehungszeit 106 0 ~ Il Z .=:.~.I2A~~zA•• ~'~~.~# A/\~ 107. 0. , ~7Xa~(Ajii.Jjjt~:Nt.ff~w.Jj\~ , ~T.Itt.~~z.ff~It~Ji7~. 106) 107) 108) 109) 110). ajt.:.ttfi1.4 r{If: ~~ ~ J Berucksich 0. J1t~m~~ll.~~i. tE~~.~~z)t-HJ:~~~J1t~~.~. ~7X~~a~~T~*m#Ht{itr~~. ~. m~100'~~~.1t-.~~~.+. tigungszeit 109. rJlz~=f~1(. Z. ~lff~~'~~o)\~~~~~.=:.+li~. ~~.~z~~~*'~~m.M~~ ~(&.ll{~a&A.~~~ Renten nach. Mindesteinkommen 110 Z *f Btl ~ 14111 . 0 ~~+~{jf~~ fi~~JJ~~tiJi~. 1ft•• mrdjzJfm~.IU:Ntfl~! 0.0625 JrInT I2A iftJJ ' jI;~jJglt1t~~p fiJi m ~zJfm~~~.'~~~~~~~Z • • 112 0 ~7~' ~7Xa~tt7X.tE~ ~~*A(mI~Z*.~)Z~~~ Iim~m~1.4MutHjf~~fi 113. 0. §1251a RVO, §56 Abs. 1 SGB VI.. §56 Abs. 5 SGB VI.. §1246 Abs. 2a S. 5 RVO.. §57 SGB VI.. • !!ill m- -jL 1::; -=: 1f: ~ n& lr JJfi iWl IV.:ft f!f; JJfi ;Wl'~t ~ 1f::fit: Rente nach Mindesein·. kommen J zJ,1J fj( 0 ilJit ' fLtE-jL1::;-=:1f: IV. ntr I~{!f;m-1f-:f5]I~ 75% (jtJt.:Jik~. r. ~) 'HJt.~~1f:~~=+n1f:~'~~Jt.1f::fit:~'~W.1f-:f5]I~ZS*Z1::;+li~ IV.~. 0 (Art. 2 §55 a, b ArVNG ' IV.bt §262 SGBVI ) it<ill&:iJ7t ' t1t~~A.~. ~A~~mT~.ffM~bt*ffT~Z~~M~~~~=+n1f:~~1f:~;Jt.W~~ IV.S*Z1::;+n~~~.Z~~~I&.IV.~~W%.~~IV.~.,@:ft.~~.1f:. .0.75 frJJi 0 111) 1iI!f$.Jt .Geisler/Knaut/Kramer, , ~ 93 Ji ' bt BlUm' , ~ 282 Ji 0 112) §68 SGB VI 0 1iI!ffl.Jt Geisler/Knaut/Kramer, IliJntrtt; BHim, Inlntrttbt Ruland, [liJtt = (NZA), ~ 18 Ji IV."F 0 113) §57 Abs. 2 SGB VI.. 82 .

(21) ~tI.I-1L1L=l:Fl:F~~lIi1EZ.iFf~. A+=l:Ff\J3 ~. FJf~1:p~~~.~mFJf~~~~A~I. , .f~Z1t-J~. WI Z1:p~m<.0ft:A:. ~-~~JiFJf~~~*1:p~~.Zf~ {If 117 0 FJf~r ~.Blj 1:p~m~ (Ra£) J. 114. ,Jm mffi{~1&Jt $za Jtitii CSt) lit)!. &-1:p1:p~. lahresrente =. wt. £ f! z a Jt tt{If. 11M A. .1:p~zaJttt{If7~~.o~.a1fi. Prozent. ~zm~:~1:p1:p~'I~~OO1:p~lit. satz der personlichen Bemessungs grundlage(PB). -;Ili 1ft _. .ff1:p~zm~A 1 ; .~gct~1:p~. x. ~ f! ~.. m_AO.6667 118. Allgemeine. 3I~~~Ul~m.llt. ~a1fi~~trm~z1&WIm~zro~ii. Bemessungsgrundlage (aB) X. 1* ~ 1:p ... Anzahl. 0. dg.m~Z~~UlWgom.llt~~'. der anrechnung. .T~~ii*'~~0ft:A.0ft:z.. sfahigen Versicherungsjahre (Vj) X. ~o~!lt'*M.IIt~*Mm.*~m-'. tlft$aJtttii Steig~rungssatz(St) a1fi{tz1:p~m-.0JtJ!tlA : 115. ~.0ft:FJf~~zf.itf*j[~~. 119. 0. Ji ~ Monatsrente =. ~.0JtzR~rurF aRw = aB X St -;- 12. MAliflli. Ep = Vj -;- PB. Personliche Entgeltpunkte. (PEp) X. 1:p. *.. aktueller. Rentenwert. ~~1:p~.A¥~~M~1:p~~~FJf~. ~zM~~.o~gz'~~1:p~~~. Btl1:p ~ mIt Rentenartfaktor (Raf). r.~~ffl**Jz~~jt*~.IIt~a. !lt~FJfml1mAlJfIliJ~mit*~ AZ llif iii J Entgeltpunkte (Ep) W. 1fiW~FJf~ao*~$~~.~~~FJf. ~r~ffl**Z~.,~~ti~*Ilit Jt~. :J!~~:Dt.ag J 120 tE.iE£filJ ~.~~~m-.nft:z±~~mo*~. '. ;ft;!ft~ii Ausgansfaktor(Af) ~*zfi ~oFJfmliflli~mMA1:p~A. ••W~. ft~1*~A f~~AtI.Ztt{If 116 ,114). :. m.llt!J)\~~,!lt~1:p~a1fijt*~. (aRw) X ~.. 0. §1254 RVO. $~~tI~~~FJf~rti~~m~~~. 0. :fl1M~fYjmtft. J! Ruland, ~at-=: (NZA), ~ 11. 0. =t\ ' ~ 211 J{. 0. 4txxltmt~~Jf'JHttt~ft"*it. mtft.~ Ruland, ~lWat '. 115). §64 SGB VI. 116). §63 Abs. 25GB VI.. 117). 118). §68 SGB VI.. §67 SGB VI.. 119). 'l{JlJmtft.~.Ruland.. 120). ~!tJJ$lJ~' ~=:flfr~ 6 J{. 0. ~at= (NZA). ~ 12. 0. 0. -83. J{ IV, r. ' 0. ~at1i. J{ ; 1% Schulin, ' ~ 48 J{lV,r 0. ~at.

(22) Jk*t!~i'f\~ . ~.fHl]+1:;M. ~-1L1L-=~~HtrI2Sf~~'~¥~I2Sf~. +li~*~~~z~~~A~~~~~ IHlJlf-f~ ~1~ %z -t + J 121 ep A. fi*IHfi*J:z ;rttYEWJr~' Ersatzzeit 126. Jlf-f~~$IJJl §. z.&,~.~.m.A~~m~ili. a. tlzliEtI 1Ji:1&ifiHtr 0. vi dueller. Durchschnittswert ( • ft ft: ,\t m Gesamtleistungswert) , it ffij. ( -1LJ\J\~ ) 1RJ-${JtJz~~**A. 122 lff~51tl~aJJ~ , HtrJlt!;0AJf1 r ff & J Entgelt ziIT.IH& r .J:MiL' J Wr* It Jt MtwI J beitragfreie Zeit123 m.%51tlm-. .JtWJrdl~~j,Wt*~A 1J~1~za%z-t+&=. 0. N~~~~m%~~~*.AA~z.m mltffij~1~ 127. 0. ~mtlA ~~m ~ m. tlA.&J.lt(§~~f-ffL.M~. ~.~z~mA~.&'.~~~A~. 0.0625 • ~ Z • ftl ) ~ tJ. 1j It MflIj bele· gungsfahiger Gesamtzeitraum~ttZ1Hf. zll~~1fMfHj4ij:~ Z.&~1~{ft~. lt1~o~.~mZ1jItAA~~mm+. 3?:~~ULT::9:3?:~-=:~~. A.~3?:*~$~.~z~$MflIjM*. Z.&tt~JiJff-f{Jfm-WJfHj~~. 0. .J:WJ~z~~ff.~~ft~~~A~. 0.075 124. 0. ~~J:z.1fAAfHj*~mA.J:M~~. ~pJ!{1fiITAArdlz~fL*J:~~WJrdl. ' {l. -~m-~j, ~~ •• z a %z -t+li125 o 3?:1t~~*J:AA~~;~z*~*J:. M*~~~*.~~J!~iITMflIjz~~ ~~~~Mrdl129 0 1t*.~~*~ ,. M~z.&'§m-1L1L-=~~HtrI2Sf. ~~~~Mz$1j.AAfHj~-=OO~~. m'~~~I2Sf~~3?:~-t~z~*~~. ~~m~~~m~.A-~~Mz1j.. ~IJT.Mr~' Anrechnungszeit ' ¥I.~ jEt:${4zmbnM~. Zurechnungszeit. 121) r~Htrtt, ~ 7 Ji 122) 123). 124) 125). M!ffl '. 0. .*••. *fW$ftfifrJifl' lI'i'Jtt-=:.-=:. • *- 7,11. lj)\ ep. ~z ~. 36%~~r,*3?:-=OO-=.~Z. .-*. 30%. 0. 0. .tlt"~~1f beitraggeminderte Zeit • Jt~iili~.utJ'tWHft]. , tlt~mlPl~ fj r:p'm% S ••• ' ~'m% S Z~%1t.J'tWJ!U:l (§54 Abs. 3 SGB VI ) Jt*fl.JOm)E A : .tlt-WJ!U:lzif!f6.~f~ftt~Mff.tlt.tlt-Wl!U:lmA~F • •Wl!U:lzifl!i. (§71, Abs. 0. 0. 2 SGB VI) §70 SGB VI. §§58. 59 :& 250, SGB VI.. 126) §§71 ff. SGB VIo #- J! Geisler/Knaut/Kramer. Ruland ' r~tt-=:. ( NZA) , ~ 18 Ji ~ 1'":& Ruland,. 1'"0 127) 128) 129). m- 1L 1L -. §§71,72 SGB VI. §72 SGB VI. §263 Abs. 1 SGB VI.. -84. lI'i'J -=:. ~ 108 Ji l2J. 1'" ; IPltt- (DRV) , ~ 382 Ji l2J..

(23) 1111 - it it -lflf 1flt~(iVi W~ iff ~. A+-lf*f1. •• z0~z±~§~ft~*.~ ~Az •• ~~W~~~~~'~~z. *-.tJr 637% ' {§'IPJIffMz~.J1<*J{U {liLtJr 218% 132 0.!Cl:-*,l~Z~~Eb. ~.$.~.z~~'~.'. M. Jtt~~~-~°tlJtt-alJ~~~~~J[. •• o~~~. ~M~z~mm~~~~~~.M~~. .Zm~'~~~~zaIJ.~.Eb~* J[~wbO~m~133 0 ~ffij-=:+~ff'. aA~~mW%zA+'~~~~z.. Jtt.aIJ~~~. B~~~:fliz Wi.. ~-. ~z~~~. •••. •• 'w~~~~.~~.. M~~~MM~z~mW. ZfJJ{J}~~~'l~'~W1fJ9fill~${¥. ~w~Jtt~a.* ••~a.*~~~. ••. .M~~W%Z~+liH~ &A ~Jli tl*ff:il~*~. 0.0625. 130 0. '. ftfW~J1r~~. , Jtt. ~Z 134. ~m~~~~~~~Zn~T~.~o. , 1:tl.lIf15a}f,f*1fp~,·. 0. W%ZA+Zm~.~-~~li~~~. ~~aIJ~.ZM.n~J{tl~a.M. ••. ~~o~a.MJ9fm~~~~-~*~. ~; W%Z~+li~O.0625 Zm~J{u. , ~Plt1J>J(~~J!~J1r7JJ~H~ ( ~~~. ~-~~=~g~~~~,~~=OO. ~EZ~.~.)ZIPJ~~.1~0~. ~~'~~-~~A~gM~~M. lm;¥ilJ3l~1i. .~Jtt'a.~~~~m~:~~~*. 131 0. .~*-~0~~~aIJ.'1:~Jtt~~. 1i ' -+~.:e:.:lJ!l ~. m-.~41~~~. 136. ~~1t rdl ~f-Jll~J9f~J[Z ~~aIJ ~~~~-~li~~gM. 0. J9fill~~0~~m*~~~~~*. ••~oJtt. .[aRWJAl:-~~~*.[aRW. . ~~~.~~~.~%$~~~~Z~. 1JJI:~Jl1t':::fI~m~*zfll: ' ~Pl:1f. *'~~~~m~.~w~~~~J9f.. ~~~~.~.(~~. Z.~~~'~W~.Mmr.~~m. if). J.fc 11'! J z. 2J zTtlfI: ' l:~~~~~. 7J.JI:~.Z~m(~~~ ••• ~A *ff[NQt - 1J~~M~~~lfltm. § 11 ~~ ~.ll 0* fftlf·M '. irfi7J{Hl:Jr 635% ' IPJ~WJZ~~J1< 130) 131) 132) 133) 134) 135) 136). [dBEt - IJ~~M~~~lflt.. [dBEt -. -~li~~~-~~=~~~~Z~I. §74 SGB VI. §263 Abs. 2 SGB VI. SozialpoIitische Information 1992/9 ~ §1272 Abs. 1 RVO. §§63 Abs. 7 63,68,69. SGBVI §1272 Abs. 2 RVO. §§65, 69 SGB VI.. m1 J{. 85. ••~~A.*. 0.

(24) mllY+-t:;M. ~*~"lW~. ~~-~z. •• ~&m~~~~~~. 1JtrHJi!.:ttttZlt{R[RQT - 2J~~1-_ ~~;ftitift{R[RQt - 1] Z • • ' 9J\ ~p. :. ~.ftZ.~.M~N~~~.2'& ~£A. •• o~a~~mz~~~.~. -.~~ilittt.~M*.Z.~~'@. ti~L~W~~~m.l~o*.a~. 137. ~Zm2'llt.m.~~~~.«~.. dBEt-1 aRW = aRW -1 X dBE" n X. ~Z~~.ttt.*~~Z~A1*.~ff Z*.'9J\~~-.~Z~MtttAL.. NQt-1 RQt- 2 137 NQt-2 X RQt-1. 139. ~L~0~Z~~,~~~~a~w~. ~~~ffJ:~-1lJ~tIf!l:ttttZ~jJ$A ~*o.~W~' •• !l.:tttt*~_,. °. ~1*~.W~' ~1~~Z~~.$ ~N~a~M$~~m2'W~~.~. ~~ttt~.ft~*~o~~.~~~~. M*.M~m.~Z~.W~~~ff' ~~~~m.~~~~*~M~-OO~. ~m~~~~~~~Z~~W.&1J~. ~ ttZ~~.ttt 140. q~Z.'l~ff ~.,. *.. °. ffHIIfi5~WJ$?t{Ellt~a~~1:. °. £~Z~a~~IIfi5~~~Z*~~~. f!t ~·:.:t.}k Jf.. N. ffHMfRZa~J:~?tA1*~.&. 1Ifi5t1ftMffijc$?t°'!tiEllt.MlifiQZ m'M••~~N.ft.~.#Z •• ~~~.fi!l* ••~~~.~' ••. ~ ~ W~ ~ allgemeine Be. messungsgrundlage hn~~.. ' W~1$. *.~~.!l1J.&~~.$Z.~~ ~~W' ~~p. :. IIn~~ttt = 1-_ ~~.fi5M~ttt X. llt.MfR~~Z~~A~W~.~&1I. L~~~~tIf!l1Jttt/M~~~~.!l. fi5t1ftM.ttt~.~fi.~Z~.o~~. 1JtttX*~~1*~.$/L~~~~.. ~a~~'~~~li~~~~a~~*. $. 141. °. 137). Wfm1f~¥J.m1f~'B.~*1it~1¥~1*~.lk~. tl1 ' 51 § Ruland' fflJt1-=: (DRV) , ~ 389 J!( 0. 138). §1383 Abs. 2 RVO' ~:!lIl*x~ijljllH&1fiHuf.fjii=OOJL)t1t.;tHH"~' IlPJt1t. 0. Jlt-0Jtt·H&.7!$~XJ9f;iJ. ~o. 139) 140) 141). §158 SGB VI. §§158, 160 SGB VI. §213 SGB VI. ffHt&flflmYff. ~ Muller, Zu den Finanzierungsvorschriften und den finanziellen Auswirkung der geplanten Rentenreform 1992, DRV 6-7/89 ~ 433 J!( I.:!A r ( :1tJt~ 436 J!( ) I.:!Alk Bergner ~ , Kommentar zur RVO, §213 SGB VI ' tt:~ 3. lk 4. 0. -86.

(25) 1t m- JL JL - if. if. ~ a~ci¥i ~ z Ji1f ~. A+-=if.1\f1. ~m-J~)fE. m.~H~~TflHJb z r §e£. .~.OOJz~. ••~a.~*~~~. .MMm-=ooo~.'m~.ft~n {f.,~1tBt 20%ti:tfz~1il:xili 0 ~. 146. • 1m m: ff@ 0)\ ~ Jt f!ij Ii ~ ~ 147. ••~~-nn-~zx#~K~*A. m-~~~,~1t<.~-~~~~1il:}9f. iW~.ftHmWJt€iz. 71< 1$.. .llt;~. *. 142. 0. , .n~.f1} jt ~iit:~_~tI::M. *. o. iliZ~~ •• '.m.n:M~l~o.. , .n*jfj$ tim-*M'*Mzm.M~.tt••z. m~~a.'.nz~~.ff~.~m. ~~~ttW~~M~~o~WAQ~~. ~z~~.ffo*a.~oo.~~iit:x. ~t€ifiitz~~. , o)\RP~JErdJi.~m. .n~Mft~'~¥~~T.~l~o. ~T!It.jiHJPHE.;~. }9f"*Zrp~g~~~tlt~J!~~{t. W.llt-a.~~~.ff=O-O~~ o~O~zrp~H!. F£ " IJ .~4tt 1f 1t<••n*jfj$}9f1f{z1f¥{E ' ** ~.llt~a.~~,~=OOO~.~.. 22 23%' {IH~m ~j:.J{UmtfilJ~Ht=m- 20%ti:tf 145 it Jt$~1Jtff~. 0. ,. ' J{tl{JJ1f~.~. 0. ~.llt. •• ~*Mm.zm.'M~a.z& fi~ , :JtJt~*~iit:Zxt~~}9f1t~148 o ~~~*l:fi.llta.T~Xt~zI ftO)\~~f;~:iJt ' :JtJtJt~.fI5*~* .m:ffMWJ~~J!~~ •• ~~lGo ~m~:i~~.llt.fi~.n:MWJz~~. .nw~,**~a.~~'~=OO. O)\Jt.~~1il:~.~.'M~.~~1il:. •• nzMWJa~~~~n*+.. ~ •• 1r-tfi~IJI Kolb }9fmili.llt~~. O~. ,~1tBt 16%Z~iit:xili. 0. (§1tS§e£. .W.~zMM)@.m.llt~a.'.llt. 142) 143) 144). §287 Abs. 4 SGB VI § 1384 RVO. §211, SGB VI.. mt$ J! Muller. 1~. :. lRJru-tt~ 436 J{ ". ' ~ 53 J{ lRJru-tt, ~ 53,54 lRJru-tt, ~ 54 J{ 148) ~ J! Miegel, Die eigendiche Reformaufgabe liegt noch vor uns : Grundsicherung im. 145) 146) 147). 149). *1'J=t$~~' ~-=:IlIt. 0. 1il:a.z~*~.~i • .llt1fH'O)\~. 0. 0. Alter, Arbeit und Sozialpolitik, 4/1989 • ~ 74 J{ ~ r ; ~.& Esslingen, Rentenre form: Abschied von Illussion, Arbeit und Sozialpolitik, 2/1989' ~ 14 J{~r " Faupel, Rentenreform: Gro(3er Konsens fUr sozialen Ruckschritt? Soziale Sicherheit 111989 • ~ 4 J{ ~ r; Kirchhain-Kleinseelheim, Strukturreform oder Kostenminimierung in der Rentenversicherung, Soziale Sicherheit, 3/1989 ' ~ 71 J{ ~ro. -ffl.

(26) i.3(*~.lWit. -.n~~.~m~PR~*~~~. tt;. ~1m+-t:;WJ. m~£. •• ffM~~~A=:¥'~-m. ~~~-nn-:¥:t~M.~A.n~. -~JI~JI*H!~~~~~:t£!l.ff~. IfJJ#f A:¥~1*~;~:Jie~~. ;. ~.,~~~~~m=:¥&~~:¥.ff M~:t~.M.m~~~. -~:¥~:t~Mm.~m~A~~~~. m~ft1*~ ••~~*~:t~*oa~. ••ff:t.n~~m~~~. .~~~~'W~~~~M~~.n. ~~~M£. f1ti:tIl; .. lIt~i1J :ll••. -.n1*m~JllI:~1fit. ;. -~:¥~:t~Mm.~m~A-~~~. .~~~~'W~~~~M~~.n. ffit:t1l150 ffif~:t. m). ,w*~~-~m~%.£~~M. 151. 0. :t••• ~~~.~-~gjt~PJa 152. 0. m~-m-rmuJ!.& 1§' , ~Tl~~. ~-a~m~~ •• '~~~~rmu.~ ~*.W~. Wf!¥~1*~mlAfl~#i1*~.(. m.. ~~a~~~fT~ '*±it.rR'~j! ~~*~~-~~'PJA~~:¥~1¥~. 0. ' PJl:JYfm te :t rR, g 1ft€~~ m. ••• '~~. lE$.o. ••WB*¥~-@~Z.. ItH:~~-a~m~PJl:~~. ~~~o~JYf~*~'~~!¥~~~~. , m... '. ~@~~±~~.PJ&~~~~~~:t. ~~~~~:t.ff'~~.~~~~~. ~~o~-a~~~~T.~A~~:¥. jt~~-~m~%~~~.tto~~~. ~MflPJ&~~~~~1*~Mfl:tffi~. ~':¥~1*~~T*~.1¥~A~~~. WM~o~~~l:~:tmWf~'mPJ~. 1:m1¥.jt~~Jt~:¥~~W~:t.ff. ' fAj~~. ~~~a~~~*.~~'~$~~~. •• ~~~m~tt~'w~~.tt~. it~~~JYf.~'W~~*£~~ft.. Jlm~~~e~~*~o~~a~-n. .MJ!.£A.*:t~~~~o~*:¥~. ~Jll~JELJI~1*.:ttt~;rr. ~. 150). 151). Kolb, Rentenreform 1992: Konzeption und Probleme, DRV 6-7/89 ' ~ 344 In;,rF ( 349 J{ Ij r ) 0 J1t;~ • ~.$.Im Schmidt, Aktuelle Probleme der Rentenver sicherung, DRV 6-7/89 • ~ 322 J{ljr 0 Schmahl, Erwerbstatigkeit und Alterssicherung zugleich Anmerkungen zur Diskussion ilber die weitere Entwicklung der gesetzlichen Rentenversicherung, DRV 6-7/89 ' 461 J{ ~j. r 466 J{ [,j r ) 0 J1t;~ , Heine • - , ~ 168 J{ [,j r ; Ruland. (NZA) , ~ 20 J{ [,j r ; Milller, ~tt-liJ\' ~ 436 J{ [,jr. 152). o. 1/R$.~ Sozialpolitische Information 1992 ~ 5 Jj 268 Zm.1i :"Sozialbeirat warnt vor Systemanderung".. -88.

(27) J\+=if.t\fJ . MII-ft.ft.=if.if.~&1fi~zi}f1e. .M~~M#.~~~~.I~*.~. ±~'.*~A§M~~~.~~~'. ~ i-.!-~.li. '\ " "'0 ",,0. @~.-.&~.~*~~ArI~J i~I EfJ ~L~~fYJ. ~.~~ •• ~m'~~~*~~B~ ~~#~.o~~W~'~~A~.T. ~~I1~~&~~*R~.~~*fio. ~MUIJn:1f~~~1l. ~&*~~W~'~IJ.tIt~~~&~M. ' W~~J}~.ij:~. '. *X"'ffit~nt.tlt. n~*m~~~W.AQ~~~~g,. ~M~~&m.~~'@m~AQ~~. •• ~r~~~~JA~&. ~~gM*.~.~~~fim~jEM.. WH~~A. ~~~~~~o@~.rI~JL~.. JLt!o. .~.~A-ft&~~.~~,~~~. it~~flJ¥.~'.tIt~~*~tt~. ~~~Il.~tl\lJ ~~~A*~ II ~~. ~.~~.~~~~o~~£~~.~. IlftilJfflf.tlt~ ~~:Jt~~A./J\ 153 °. *~*~.~m~'~~~.~~II.tIt. ~~~~~A~.~Il~*~.~~~. -~~~*(~~~.~)~~~.t!. *~&I!,jEi1!1nJ. ffM.~. $X~o.tlt~~EfJJLt!n~~~~~~. ~o#.,.tIt~~~~~m~~.~~. ~&*'~~~~fYJt!$.t!$A~~. ~jE~A~.~~MJf~.~ ••. .&~t:p.~~1t~.~frj~o. .tIt1fT. 1fr.t•••~ 154. 'M. ~~*Jn:JW.£~J1i § ~5tfi.~. °. fYJ'M~~.tIt~~~~~.W~~~$. 153) :ff1];Jtltll~zll~1f:1ttilliJJiJf~J! Kohler, "Schweden" , • : Zacher (Hrsg.) , IIiJ itt + Ii. • 373 Ji IZA r ( 381 Ji t.U. r ) IZA:&' Pieters, Introduction into the Social Security Law of the Member States of the European Community • 45 Ji IZA r 0 :ff II ~ 111It ~ ~ It ftiiJ ~ j{g .. ~ J! Schulte "Vereinigtes Konigreich" • . : Zacher (Hrsg.), IIiJ ' 497 Ji IZA r ( 508 :~: IZA r) ; Ogus/Barendt, The Law of Social Security, 3rd. ed ' .Jtltm 178 Ji IZA r 0. m. m. m. .r-.m~.~.J.Z,lt ••~~~1f:.MiIIiJ~:ffIliJIZ.'@II~ •••• 7t1f:1tt~1tjJ;f5zJ;!I~. , ~TJLftt!!C.IlP1.4WJJT~m±:~. 0. WNi~IZA1.4:. r Jlftli::f±irfjij. ~~~II~Z~:ff.ff'~-.ff~.m~:f±ir~ltz~hW~~oJ~~~-.& WJJT~±:~II~ •• ~~7tZ-1f:~~ItjJ;f.o~-J;!I~~-AAJL1f:Z~~~.*. ~~IZA •• 'mlt~~m~~*II.ir.7tx*'W:ffmmIi.+~~~.~~Zm ~o~~'-.m~.~.Z ~M ZOllner. IliJtt-". •• m.,~~m.II ••J;!I~Z.-& •• olZAk". 89 Ji IZA r. 0. 154) :ff1I.1l1f:1tt~ltilliJllZ.~"~J! Kolb, Zukunftsperspectiven der Rentenversi cherung' • : Ruland (Hrsg.) 'IIiJtt=, 189 JilZAr 0. m. -89.

(28) ~*~.fIi". PfHY+-t.;W:!. ~~~-~*~'W~ti~a~.~~. m~§.om~~~'~~.~~A£. ~~~,~~~ft~.~~~tt.~~. z~.~~~~~m~A.~'~~~. ~~~~~-~rffiff~~Jo~~~. ~rn~*~Jott~w~'~~~~. J\.J\,-=:~l;J.,*f1\!~~z. .l;J.~.*.~~M5n~z~a'~. ~.~~~~'-~li~~~~~rft. ~~~~~~~~~*z~~~~~~. OO~~Jz~~'~~£~-~Tl;J.~. ~~mwao~~,~~~~~*~~. .o~i!fr=-ft~~J~~zft.,~. ~. , ffiJta ~z~!.iiP~~ 8:f3l~o m'£. ~. 0. *If'ftllEMY -. ~~~L~~~ftm~~~~Z~A~ ~'~~I~~~'~.~~~_l;J.~. .). ~g~~Z•• ~~~~~~~~~Z. 90. (*:t. ffij ~ 1992 ~ 9 }j ,. *.

(29)