從美、日、德的法學期刊看我國法學期刊的問題與出路

全文

(1)~. ~~'B'~~~~M~ ~a~~~M~~~~~ilin -.~ ,~ 7]( "SJ'A.. ". ~~ ~~~ IX..:±..." JK r,":,~ IIf". ". ~~s ~~** 'fo/J)i. B-f" " '!"n i j"". § fltr1". $ . i~ ~. :t '. .::. '. ~ F!J * ~ Mtil ~!!UJL -'~~mfi'" .::.,t¥ltt~Jt. j j ' ~~*~Wlfll.ftjJL. mfi'". ~, E1 **~MtUUJL -'~~mfi'". -,t-Il~~. ,::,,~~~~. ili'~m~~~~lli~. {rij. .'. ~. t~:fIl;ff~. ~·t-Il~~. ~·t-Il*~. M~~. *. ~ WI til :lR 5JL ·~~mfi'". ~. -.*.~.'m##~~~*·~.~~~~~. •• e~A*.A±~~*~'*.~.~lm~.

(2) fl,'R ~. +. .\J it. $!. mt. fl* #:;!. -I<. ~ '<t. ,....,. .. $-Lj ~ l\tl: ~ ~ 11< $:it;! . ~ , ~ ~~ -<~~~. ~. It. **.. :B;~~~. ';\;t! ~ ~ ~~. ~~-lUl~ru:;:B;ttnn. ;1!1 411 l*- . lR~-R:~*:R. .ij:\-ffit$1:;i:B;';\;t! $. '*. .. .. '$I:H :B; $ {nlil t~ ~ ~~~1*-001. m~. ~. .&. t ::l.. ~. ->.J ..u. •. ~nm~~-Lj ~~ gr ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~ I1¢: 11~ ~ I*-~~~~. ~. -IE-. .. I. 0. ~liC !illi: ~ ~. " ~ ~:B;. \tli ~~~ :B; -r,.< ~ ~. . at , -< *~ "**'-«~ ~~# 1*-\i§~-33 . Ill!.>(. nr;*. .. ~.gtl ~. 1i1. IllY!. 0. ~.~*. W~.~ ~ ~~~~ j:g ~:B;at~ f!:l. *~~~~.&. "*. -N. ~ ~~. ~ ~ nll\ ~. ';\;t! n¥~ ~ ~l;: Ill!.>( ~ 1i1 :B;~:B;:B;~~~~-. l! ~ -f::. 411 ~l;: ~ -33. ~. :it;! ~ ';\;t!. ~~ *~. ~~ ';\;t! flI'"> ,. -=1$lI. i~. *~. ';\;t! ill':. * ' +<$1. ~. ,~ ->.J ...w.. => tt. ~ ~! => tt-. ~~. *liC ';\;t!.. ~. 11 iI. 1"° ,~. ~\'='. +<. ~. J:n....... '* ~. tt. "::7. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. L. ~ ~. •. -_"7. ~. .. -•. {*. •. "*. ~. ~. ~ $ ~ I+' I\iIlI\ ~ ~ ~ llii: ,~ I::l. ~~ mt ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ I* ~ ~. +! , ...u. I*- #i ~ ~\1 ~ ~ ~J ~ ~ "='"' L ~ ~ ~ , ~ ID ;ti ~ lJJ ~ %' , ~ ~ .!\Ii! ...,~ 0 ~ ~ ~ .>J,lj> :\11K ~ ~ ~ 4.!li! $< ~ ~ ~ ij~ m\!( $. \~t\ ~ ~ ~ ...u. ~ ~ ~t~ ~\ ~ ~ ~ • • r--; ' P 14 .\It: ~ ...u. ..:W ....l.:,. ~ ~ ...y ;ti ~ -::-> ~ rt- ~ t:>< ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ":7 ~t: ~ ~. ~. ~n ~. ~ii ~ ~ ~. •. fim. I 'H1 *= in 4If: ~ ~ 'H1 .£: ~ ~. {~. :4!; ~. -K. 4J ~ ~ . -i\;!;(. + .-"'". "'" ~ mIT. ~ ~. $: ...,. .. +<. .. *'. .. .. ...lc:". ~. ..:W. -<. ~~. ~ ~. ~ ~ ~. tt. -::->. •. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ I+' fim ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ...u. , ~ ..., ~ ...y ~ ~ -::-> 1+ ~ 'N ~ ~ ~ t>-> ~ *« ~ ~ ~ t~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1m! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ {~ ~ ~\l In' ~ ~ . ~ in 1mI #i 11~ ~ L ~\I ~ ~ , ~ ;ti t~ ~ ~ 0 i\~ ~ ...,~ {~ $ ffi1 ~ ~ $ ~ ~ Iil\iI\ ..1..'I . ~ .D ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :IJIt\ ~ ~~ ,p< ~ 5r ~ $: ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ID .& I ~ n!( -::-> L ..., . ~ ...... .;:l, ~ ~ -tit! "It ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~W ~ ~ :IJIt\ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ $ ~\I =-r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ lin ~. +< . • :4!;. ~. ±. "1". 00. ~. N. u. Z ... r.I'l. ~. ~ffii. 'Ei. ~ .. ~zB-. "+. :! .tJ. rt-. ~,J. N~ ~t D±:.\. ~ ,":". ~.\'(. ~*. !$". ..Ll. ffiK w.~ ••. E{rr ..... ~-<. ~~. ~+H. IIi10. or ~mi t:l....+. E{tf.. we;. W:.;.. itt§;. ~~ ~.

(3) t£~. ,B. ,tt(tj~~Jmf~~~~~~WHUB/:m,'{ij~tB~. tt'l.#.~"~.~~#.#'~. .,.~.~. ft.~. ~.~. 3[liJli:t:f~~ ~I ~ o~:L. s •• '. ft*~. 315. ~~.*~. ~ • • '~~~lft~ • •. f!!111-ff!. "EJ". .~~tt#.~'flft.. ,. ;&ft.+~~lt-~. M~***~~~~~. ?t~o. *'. ~ IE ~k*~Jj f'l ~~~~5L. 71-a*'WA M~*~~liJ~71-A~~ •• :H~*~. ~~~~.~~,~.~. ••• $0 .~~ ~ .!;tr/f ill Jl& ~ ~1#t'ti. ~M~. ~a.. ~ WJ ff] (academic law reviews or law. IJ1 ftJ.flJ~ rlf ~ g';] ~ ff M fl] (bar journals) ; E) ~ f.t ~ ..r/f ~ Jl& ~ f.t M ftl ; azm }iffii"Mt (legal newsletters); (li)~1fi'f)itl" tifU" ¥ltt (legal. journals) ; t:) ~. "~1;1" ~ ft ~ 'tt ft trP Uh .. ~. news " legal journals " or legal newspapers) ; (7\) ~:ff:¥i ~ (law reports) ; (-t) ita o~~ffi~~. *! ~ f.t W*4 -* 51. ,tt 5i ff M ftl ; M~".. ~~M. ~:L ;& (I\).IE 1£ ~ ~ ~ ~. ":¥i~"~M.~.~~«. (secondary sources) ,. A*. # i: ~ ,tt ~t :f ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ffl~~"~~~~"~~ff~~A ( primary sources). ~~~. W~*~. 0. ~~ ••. *1ft 'ti. ,. ~:f*liJ.fi~W$.~*. ~~~ffi~Jl&~. t¥ ~ ( law reviews) , ~ WIt ~ rf tfIP Uh .. ~ f.t M ffJ ( bar fUld.1J1 ft " ~ raJ ~ ~ Jl& journals) , • -t It ~:L EE1 if;t H1 ~. r,,, /}}. ;f1rlf~ff~~f.tii"Mt (legal newsletters) 'lliW{t~. at ~. ~Jf.:f.t~. i! ¥i (Weekly) " ~ ~ ( Biweekly) " ~ fJ flJ (Monthly)' ~:L;& # 1if!. :f ~ 1ft ,tt ~ ~ 1f M~~ff~W"W_~M'*W ~,,~ft#ili. ~"iliJl& • /lfj E1 ~ (Daily) ". (Times) ". • " •• ~~,~f.t71-."~~. '~$~."~~~'~~.

(4) 316. ... j~;ck$~~llifB . ~f.~.·. ~-t+jlJtEl. ~np.o*~. ¥ro~~~~:H~. •• ~. ~¥M~~~.'~~~I~¥M~~fu~m~;M~~~E~ *¥~¥~fflili~~¥~~~¥M~~~~~~~»*;. ••8. .~ili~I~¥M~ili~~#~'.Aal~¥M~ili~~W~ ~$~o. - ... ~~~ f~1r-. 1. ~*¥~¥~fJf ili~~¥mJti~¥Mfl,,2 ~1~~¥M~'*~~*¥~¥~fflili~~¥~~~¥M ~'A~~~~#~I*M~ .~~¥~~. •• ¥~m~'~~~.~¥M~~.~A. 1... • ~~~. ~~*~:H~_M~±.~*. ~~ J. r~. (student-edited law reviews) ; (=)t~ ~ ~ ~ ~. M~~~.#~*~~§~~~~.~.~~~¥1..m~~. •. •. ~'WR~~.~~~~~~¥*~~~~~~~~~~f~. A±~fJfJt~~~~~~. ¥M~ffl~§~~.# ~1 (footnotes) ~. • 1] JtJU.~ • ~~ pig1}lt!fT1l}e;z ;. •• ftft~.%*'ffl~.W~~~Mt. *'t 1!1i ;. ~M fU. pig 1}ttttJ} ~ ~. *. {f~ J}. , lTi. .¥~~~~~~~~~~f.A±ffl~~~¥~~~_t. • '. {~~A lead articles;. ~ ji ~. 2. . 1jj ¥. # *- ~ W~~ JlJt¥1..fJf~ ~,~ji ~t¥. tt -=:. ~ 171- ~ :f. ~ ~ 19r1 W:i! (Comments or Notes) ;. .:t~IDtB)]~ JtMorris L. Cohen, Robert C. Berring, and Kent C. Olson, How to Find the Law, Ninth Edition (St. Paul, Minn.: West Publishing Co., 1989), Ch. II; Kent C. Olson, Legal Information: How to Find It, How to Use It (Oryx Press, 1999), Ch. 5; Robert C. Berring and Elizabeth A. Edinger, Finding the Law, Eleventh Edition (St. PauL Minn.: West Group, 1999), pp. 304-311; Bernard J. Hibbitts, Last Writes? Re-assessing the Law Review in the Age of Cyberspace, at <http://www.law.pitt.edu/hibbitts/lastrev.htm> 0.

(5) :fft~. ~ (Book Reviews). 0. ,B '. 317. ~ ~ ~ *~5!~ JIJtJiJT. ill Ji if,] ~1*H.i5--R~ M. ~.~~-ft.~~if,]5! •• ~o~~if,]*~RMillJi.M~5!. .M~o~*'~.~*~5!~JIJtmiliJi~~~ft*~M~4~ ~J: ftl1t~t1i- (symposium). J:JiJT. tj Fig 5!•• ~ it!.. ~ if,];fEr. t~o. ~~J:~*~5!~JIJtmili~if,]~mft5!~M~~~,~~ft. *. ' frTl ,r ~ ~ ~ ~ifi fa i- i American Bar Association) , -t1ii Fig{f~ifi fai- ' *frTl ,r Jlt1 3'11 {fBififai- J( State Bar of California) , ~J-1k :It jj tt if,] ./frli fa i- ' frl1 ' r ~ ~1 rp ./frli fa i- J (the Bar Association of the City of New York) , it!..~ iliJt[5!.MfIJ ll:l~ Mftl fit {Ij ~ r./frli fa i- 5!;f.t Mftl J (bar journals) ~~~5!;f.tft.ijg~~M~'# •• I~tttt~~~E~~ •• ~~.~~.~~ •• ;W~.~#5!;f.tft.~~M~if,]~ if,] {f /frli fa i-. *. 0. 0. *. ;J: jJi ~. ~ jj ~. *- ~ raJ ff it 1i !fi:f: ( peer review). 0. 1EL ~ ~ ~ ~. * ~ 5! ~ JIJt ttl ~ if,] 5! ~ -W. (law reviews) ~ 5! 1* MflJ (law journals) ~ ~ ~ ~ m* ~ JIJt ~ if ~Il (1t &p.::. ' ~ if. ~Il) ~ i. • • o~~i. •• if,]5!~M~#~.~1t~~Fig.h .~~~~ i.m~ijg •• _o~¥.A5!~M~ •• ~Fig~i.'.#;J:~¥ :1ftt1!if,]~M~~.' fJ5!~rt1'~if,] ~~lt. '. 1M-,. ft.~~~ltitfl:iJl. m. j{;J:~Ji .1!5!~~1fj.~ $1t~tt* t~. (legal writing 0. :Q Jth MflJ »X if,] • • ~ ~ ilJ iit iJL ~. *. if,] I ~ ~ i. (elite students) 1tl!.1M m~ -;f±ff • # 1Jtf;f± ~ , ~ff.j , ~ .ffft~.o~~ ~it!...~. if,]M~~~,~lt • • ill~~. competition). ~ !i3t ~. 0. •• mo.~~~*~5!~!i3t5!~W.~ •• I~'~~ • • • M~ •• fJ5!~~~i.8.~.*~Jlt1~~*o.~5!~M~ • • I 1t fJT ~ i¥ ltl ~ Jm • • ' :f:.]iJT iJ I mu. ** .iE :tit ~ ~ , :l-=tJ M5!•• #*~'.~.X~~. •• ~m»'.~~$~~.~.

(6) i!&*$~~~. 318. ~t;+;nJlJl. • • • ~~¥~~_.¥~A m.~~¥~~. W~-$~o~i~'.~.. •• *¥.~~-~~~~~.W.M~o. .~*¥~¥~m~.~~.W.~~¥M~#~~~ ~{jj~:k 1887~. M ~ ~ fU ~ {*1~~{f:W.} (The Harvard Law Review) Jl:~ M fU l*1 $.i. ~ 1i1-=:. $?1- ft.Jl~ : 1t- ~?1-:i:A :l ~ , 0. llt.:tA r ~~)c*J(Ieadarticle)'. #~~1f.i.~~~~1-t.~,. ~~¥1f.~~.*.~.1-t~.;1t=$?1-~Ii1¥~ ~W.~{~~~j)c. .MM,¥~m. (Comments. &. Notes) !k. ~¥M fU rm # t!1. (Stanford Law Review). •• 0. •• &.~ •• ~~*~. !67f~' ~.&P::f7U ~¥!£3t1!6. •• ~.. W.~.~~~~. ' {!tft1~~.W.) 1m ~ * ¥ ~ 3t1!6 71j-tE)c .:t lW 1991 0. 1986~.:tit. 0. .:tit' rJf~~ ()[t") 3~Jt*¥ 3t1!67'J-tE1IJfJtt~l*1 o;M.§ • .:t'.W~'~~~.~~.W.::f~A¥!£~3t1!6'R~*. # •• ~~1L;.)C~.~Wi!. 0. •• ~*¥~¥~m~.~~.M~*~~¥~!6~~A MfrJ. !6:f~'. * * jl1 '. ~The Yale Law Review. 1~ 0. ¥. ~ Harvard Law Review ~ ~ 1:- -* ~. lttb~¥MfrJ~,I-~'ti. .. !.*~'ti~M. ~o~~~.~~¥~.~~ • • M~¥M~'.~.I±~~. it! ~University of Louisville ~. ~~,. **". of Louisville Journal of Family Law) •. ~ ~ MfrJ ( The University. Franklin Pierce Law Center. M fU (IDEA: The Journal of Law and Technology) A r ~ ~ ¥ lSJt ¥ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ MfU f.lU ~.I 1t ~ ~ . ' • • ~*¥~¥~~M~~.Ii1¥~ft.f.lU~~.M~.M rff. ~ ~~. n". ~. ~ ~4 # 0. ~o~*-~~m~R~~_~~*. •••. ·~.~?1-.Im~o. *.-*¥~¥~~.+=.Ii1¥~ft.f.lU~~~¥M~'#~~. 3. The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation, infra., p. 4..

(7) tt:~. , B '1!e9$~'W;FfU~~~$~ltfHUe9rc'~Wllilffr. 319. M: Harvard Law Review( 1887 ~ M~ ill flJ ); Harvard International Law Journal ( 1959~ M~ $ ftl ) ; Harvard Journal of Legislation (I964) ; Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review ( 1966) ; Harvard Environment Law Review ( 1976) ; Harvard Journal ofLaw and Public Policy ( 1978) ; Harvard Women s Law Journal ( 1978) ; Harvard Blackletter Law Journal ( 1988) ; Harvard Human Rights Journal ( 1988) ; Harvard Journal ofLaw and Technology ( 1988) ; Harvard Latina Law Review (1994) ; Harvard Negotiation Law Review (1996). 0. -1f1tr!:.§.*~~~~-&ill~+-=-{i~i.t.li.~. ~_M~·#~~. •• ~.M~~MTi~~~.~, •• ~a~. §'5;tI~_'~*I~~o. tW if 240{i • • 't! ~ ~ 1*: Wl 172{i -M't! " i*1}It!~1-fWJ flJ Wl flJ ~ , * $- f{;Jt,l. 1& .1999~ z.Jjf. ~t f{ ~ ,. • ~ 11 §. 0. • •. ~ • • ~fl1};l:.*x~~L-=-~±:&' #Jif70$-{i; 28{iiL:t;JtJijf,~. 0. .11 t::J itt Jf& tJIi!!h.:t ~ ~ W*4 Jf..:t - LEXIS-NEXIS{t J'Jf if ~ 1f MflJ (ALLREV) ;fj *4,tf ~ ljjz 565{i - M 't! ~. r5 't! ~ 1-f M ~. ftl ~11.~ffi*.~.!iJt .-n{t2002~12}J J'Jf!iIJ~'&1~~_ MflJ #, ~I (Current Law Index) if533{i4 , ft- r~]IJ ~J&.96JJ[~1f 0. :tJlR. (Subject Headings). 5. 0. Washington and Lee University{t2002. ~ ~ tJf. ~t !iIJ ill 465 {t ~ 1f MflJ 6 l). • • 't! Ji jf, ~ {f M ftl ~ 11sJ ' t.iI 0. #J *~~.!iJt!iu $40 $- {i ~J- Jijf,~ ~:tJlR ~ ~{fM flJ. 0. 7. "Periodical Information:' Marian Gould Gallagher Law Library, University of Washington School of Law, at <http://lib.law.washington.edu/clip/period.html> Ibid. "Most-cited American Legal Periodical," Washington and Lee University,. School of Law, Law Library, at <http://law.wlu.edullibrary/search/lawers/. mc-menu.htm> .. "Environmental Law Journal," New York University, Environmental Law Journal,.

(8) 320. .*••. il3I:*$~~~. .... ~-t:;+:h.AA. ~.m~~_M~~¥~~~.~.~. ~'ili~~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~*. ••. o~~~~M. ¥*~~~~~ (peer review) ~~,&~.:t '~~*i~t.i~. 0. •• :t~A~~.~~ft~.~~.M~'~ffl~~±~*. ~*X1ji , -tl!. tl*X.YiltJfJ * 11= ~14% r ttl M.%kilt*J ik J( publish-or ~~~)¥*±W •• ¥,-tl!.~ftY.JfJ*~~**~~~~~ ~. ~.±JfJo~~M~ffl~~~. *. '. ~~. $.A.~M~~~.~. ~JfJ'-tl!.~~A.~~~~.o~~~*.~iliM.~ •• M~~. Mfti ~ ± ¥. ;ft. rlT ttl M. ~ I1E 1W MflJ (Journal of Law and. Economics' Supreme Court Review' Journal pf Legal Studies '. ~~. ,& Crime and Justice: A Review of Research) ~ ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ti ~ fJ!. ~ ~ • ~ ~ ~ t.i W11:- • ~ t.i ~ ~ • :t MflJ t1 ~ : Law and 0. Contemporary Problem' Tax Legal Review' American Journal of Legal History' Law and History Review' Constitutional Commentary , Journal of Law 'Economics and Organization' IJ ,&Florida Tax Review. 1t. 0. ~1~~ffl.±~~~* ~.M~~~%-~.~* ~. Mfti ~ ttl The National Journal ofSexual Orientation. m. 0. ~~~~.M~±~.~D~fJ!.~.~~¥M~.~~~¥~# tt ~ _ $~' , ::$:;11 Michigan Telecommunication and Technology Law Review9 'Journal ofOn-Line Law 10 'Richmond Journal ofLaw and Technolog/ I. 0. • •. *¥. ~ ¥ ~ rJT ttl M. ~ ~. MflJ 1if. *" **fp]. €t: ~ <http://www.nyu.cdu/ pages/clj/rcsources/othcrEnv Journals.html> . <http://sunsite.unc.edu/gaylaw/> 9 10. II. 0. ~:f:ll::~: <http://www.law.umich.edu/mttir/) :. mfIl::~. :. 0. <http://www.wm.edu/law/publications/jol/> <http://www.richmond.edu/-jolt> 0. 0. 0.

(9) tt~. 1l-=f~~flJ. itl ¥. ~. fltr1tJlMl~. ,8 0. '~I¥J$~WlfU~1X~$~w:JfUl¥Jrc~~lHNl:Bn. Duke University-jtJtt.~. ~tfz.. 321. :J. , M-]iff ill )l fltr 6{l :ff W1 flJ 1:- ~~ 1& ~6 :tE -{OO ~ hl- 1: 12 J1. 7r ' University of Southern CaliforniafltrLegal Journal on the Web ~~-M~~.M~fltr ~. _~. :=t '. ~:J. •• M~'. tt ~ 1V- fltr ~ -m 14. 0. ~Mfl'~~. _~~$'#~~~~. ~ ~ ~ Mftl §. '. :ffM~'~. it. 0. -ili.. Washburn University fltr #ij. r,. M~'. *Md1:. ~. Find Lawk ~ ~ 'ti fltr ~_ ~~ 3c6 •. 13. ~. ft:. tf m18100. 1!! 11J ~ - M 't!;fa • 't! fltr _ WJ ....115 Eb !oo 1} ~ ~ ~ I;t ill )l fltr ~ ¥ M ftl k i* m]in- fltr r iJ I ~i -ttl J (Uniform System of Citation) , -i~ ml~~ r j[ J (The Bluebook) The Bluebook~ tb ~ 1ft H:. ~ m' 1~ *- ~. *. *. 0. *. .~,~.*~~ I;t'~~.ffl*~ .mfflft • • ,~~ m*1~*~ ~~ttl)l16 ~~1;.tt, -Mti~~MfUfltr¥f~ --jt }'n- iJ I. m~i. *' '. 0. ~. t+ *- jlf, ~ §J m.. * *' I JtJ 0. iJ. ~ §J fltr ~E it 1* #. A .J!J.~,!#-~ ~~~~ffrff;]_~ipArnold S. Jacobs 11k 1987lf fn- m~ M!. ft ~ flJ ~:tE (#Jl ~~ ~ _ ~) ~ "An Analysis of 0. Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934" ff;] ~ ~ 4,824100 M;t. fn- ttl ,1f~ ~ ~ MflJ 12 13. 14 IS 16. 11. :. 4--1JJ It:tf A 1ilt tl ~E it 17 1c 0. JU ftt -w. ~~. z. -. m. 11 iJ I ~1. 1}. *' *. ~,. , ~# ~~~. *. ~i ~. <http://www.law.duke.edu/journals/>. : <http://www.usc.edu/deptilaw-lib/Jega\ljournals.html> ~hl~ : <http://1awlib.wuacc.edu/washlaw/lawiournalllawjournal.html> : <http://www.findJaw.com/03journals> The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation, 17 th edition, Compiled by the editors of the Columbia Law Review, the Harvard Law Review, the University of Pennsylvania Law Review, and the Yale Law Review, published and distributed by the Harvard Law Review Association. Arnold S. Jacobs, "An Analysis of Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934;' 32 N. YL SchL Rev. 209 (1987)..

(10) -;. i&*$~i¥PgijB. 322. ~ •• ,~~~roft~.*ft'~.*.~~.~*h~$~%. ~1tf jf ". " ~ ~if A:J~ ttl ' .~flf~! m~:t~ ~ t: ~,ti*~.~ ~ ~* ~ ~ 5i ~!SJt:t ¥i' ~~t'ti5i f: M T'J * ~l~:t ~ J! m~ , ifM. ~'~~~-~~5i~~~~,ftft~~.mif~~~5i~~. ~'~~~5i~~~'~~$~~~5i~m~"5i_~#.~. #~ •. 0. ftft~5i~~~5i~~~~~~5i~~~~ili~~~~. iE ltl jll1jl:~ , ~1#t'ti5i ~M ftl ~ *:1: ~l ttht ~ JJt -100 :I ~ ~ ~. *. ~. " r!1 ~5i~MfU flfflJ %±".~*jf e. Mtif ~ fi ~ ~l tt ' W11 llb ~ I ~:t ~ ~I 1& it :{f 1£ " ~ fi * ~ FEI~ $.- ~ ... 1i}f ~ , ~ ~I 1& 5i ~ M. •• ~~m~.~w*"ltl~'£*~-~5i~~~~~*, #1&$.-m~~~~.5i~*.W# . 5i~M~~~~~,~m5i. m•• e.~1ftt~~oOO~'5i~1i}f~:{f~~~~~*.~M5i ~,.~. , T M I~5i~. r~1;ft~~ ,. ~J-'& ~Jlr~'~#<J0flfif. 0. 5i~. ~f:~ • • ~~5i~~_~.3m~I~~.~5i~M~ ••. I. it ~ flf ~. 2.. {$: ~ ~ i'- ili Jtti 5i ~ Wi fU. 1JU~ ~ ,~,,~, {§. fUl ~ " (bar journals· or bar association. periodicals) ~.~~.~~~ffl~{$:~.i'-,~~~~ft~. ~lft~~Jtti~~~~~5i~M~o. ~'~~if~~~* 5i~M~. •• ~~~. ~M~*.ft~A.3m. *~1i}f~~~:{f°B~~~.i'-miliJtti±". ~~.~~~~i'-~i'-.'~$~~.i'-.~5i~A. (~~f::{f •• ~5i~.3~A±)~~I~~.:{f°if~ftA f:~ft~ •• ft~~~~i'-iliJtti~5i~M~.~~fi~~~. ~,~~~~.ft~*.D~~~i'-~{$:M~~&.:{f*.~~. 5i~.3~A±'~#~~*~5if:~miliJtti5i*W.**m ~~~~f::{f&.D. lI. ~.

(11) B. {:(£~ ,. ,t~H'81't;t1tWlfU~#:~$~WHUt8ro'~Wte~. .~ •• mill.~~.M~. ~,. .¥~~r. 1t J (the American Bar Association) rJT ill •. 323. •••. Mtv The ABA 31.aiJ1.it Ji:.. T~~ • .i:.Jlgtf,Jjf-.(sections) rJT ill • ffJ r~ ~ ¥ MtlJ The ABA JournaltV f<; ~ X ii t it If ~ ~ • .i:.JlgW~'~~~iitm~~ W~i:..X~'~~ ~ ~ ii 1t it it 7r ' The ABA Journal ~ ttl Ii. JA. r ~ 31.gip • • J .~Mi:..g4·~ • • • ,t?Alk±31 ¥~.~~or~ • • flip. it J i:.. Tift?: 100 jf-it (sections) , .i. ¥ m~. 4 r~ ~*i:.._~.*o ~r •• ~.itJjf-.mill.~~.M ~ if§. • r.J JA. The ABA Journalf; fiil' ~t fx ii 1t 'i! J~ 4. ~. Journal't?Alk r. 0. 0. 1.. • M tIl iL:f5 : Criminal Justice • Family Advocate· Natural Resources and Environment ' Jl:~ 7r ~ if J!;.r. it 11 ~ ¥ !;t 1:. rJT ill Jt[ ~ • # MtlJ (~jtr1 ' Student Lawyer) , ~ ~1 JtX.1.!f tit • ;f} ~ if. ~ • flip ( Young Lawyer)' ~ - M~ • ffr A ± (Compleat Lawyer) tfrP (Experience) ~ t4t Jt fjip. M. '* 0. Jl:~. Ii. ~. j*.. illJt[o r~31.~.itJjf-.~lli~-. ::If 1;f 11 ~ ~ ¥ Mttl. ~A¥m~'AA~~.. :f5 : Administrative Law Review· Antitrust Law. Review • Business Lawyer' Family Law Quarterly· International Lawyer • International of Affordable Housing and Community Development Law • Jurimetrics: Journal of Law • Science and Technology ·Labor Lawyer 'Public Contract ·Real Property 'Probate and Trust Journal • Tax Lawyer • Tort and Insurance Law Journal • t?A lk Urban Lawyer. mill.ffJ. 0. J!;.r.. ¥ m'ti ~. ~ • it ~. MfrJ ?J{ ~ ¥ f,jt !f,.. .~~'~lkl.!f,.mill.~~.~~~~.ii~i:... M'OOit~mr-1OO~.. ¥~ •••• ~~o¥mfttf,J.~.. it~. ~~~IJfJtt~' 3:.¥~{}z¥~.. MtIJ1:!!,~t~~'%. t4.

(12) 324. iI&*$~ff~ffi!. .. *. *~o~gM~~. •• I~. ~.~I~o.~. 1t ~ ~ ~ Mf ~ , jT1 :. ~.~~~*a~ft.,*~~.. m~~~~*M~**~~**~*~~ Tax Lawyer( Georgetown University) . . Urban. Lawyer (University of Missouri Law Center) . . Business Lawyer (University of Maryland ) . . Public Contract Law Journal (George Washington University). ffl"'$ . .-. 0. ~~~~.~~.m~~~~.AA~~#. ~U~~"'ffl"'$"'~*"'~~~~H~. MflJ ~ ~;f} ~ . . l*J '{J- ~ The ABA Journal £ 1~~~~~ft~~.~.'fi. .~.o~.. *' ~ ~ ,:t1i i: ~. -~~~~~~~. ft~W~. ~*~~~~~~.M~.~i:¥Wmo~.~.M~~WThe. Record ofthe Association ofthe Bar ofthe City ofNew York ~~ -. jJ. ~ .$ r~ ~ ~. Practitioner s Society. 0. '!. 1t Uh. Journal~) ~. • M flJ ' f-. Jt~7r. '. jT1 L C. C.. The Journal of the Patient Office. 1M . . t~ . . ~) ~ ~. *1*r'ti:;r-jT1~**5!-. ~ ~ ~ ~. 0. *. ~. Uh. tiJf ~ ~ ~. 5!- * MflJ. *. AA;tiJflli~~~.-W~'. Connecticut Bar Journal . . Pennsylvania Bar Association Quarterly . . California Lawyer . . ~) ~Delaware Lawyer~ q 3.. -&.Jt.. ~*li}f-1EJ:.. $~. 0. :a:..it m·ti (Legal Newsletter) :a:..A~~¥~.~~ ••• ~.~ •• ~m~,-&# .~~~'fi~",~~:a:.~.~~_~.ofi. tttt:;r-~m~~.f8~A±W. ~.~'*M. '~#~.Am~. ~m'.. ~#~.itm.~.Ai:¥~~*~.W~o~~~~A~#~. •• mm~.~~.wm.~*"' •• ~.'~~#lm,oo .mA:;r-* ~~~ft~li}f-~m~o'!~~~'fi-#~~. r~. . ~ )ill ~ ~ ff rl:!,. '. *. jl1 ' ~ h. :It Ea JiJf C]\l] :t ~. ~ %t ~ ....

(13) ~~. .«.~~g'~.fi. , B. '~81$~Mflj;g~~t:M~WHU81rp~)¥HJiI.ten. 325. ••• *~~~.~~$~g'~.~$. ~~m~~~~~~~~~o~~§~~~TL~~~L~~*. i! ~::t lli Jt[ Oxbridge Directory ofNewsletters..,'J ~ 1,600{i ~ ft Ii ~~ lli Jt~_ Jf:r Newsletter in Print}lU "'IJ ~ 1l,50011 ~J J:. ~ ~ftii 0. a. ~18. 111\0. 0. ~ l: ,ti~ *1! ~ ~ ill!~ ~ .i. ~ 1!:L MBureau of National Affairs. ( BNA ) , Mealey Publications' Andrew Publications ' Leader Publications' LRP Publications' the National Associational of. *. g G ~ ~ Ii -m BN A I:.i. ~ ~ lli Jt[ Jf:r ~ The United States Law Week • .i. ~ ~.=. E. -mr 15 j{ lli ,~Jf:r (loose-leaf binder) The United States Law Week~ ~ M. Attorneys General ~ 5--i ~ .... tn- plf 111lli Jt[ 1t: 0. 0. 0. ~ :g~ ~ (parts) ~ - :g~ 17t ~ -. a ~ 1t (General Law) • t{ ~ mIt. ~$~~: (-)~~~~q (Case Alert) , ff~1!L~:fijJ*llfGl:lli1t ~ ~ ~tl jjc 1f ~ 1iii ~. ;. * ,. ft Jff M (Legal. News) ,. fl Jff fftr iz:. ~ , BNA 111lli Jt[~. , rr ~ ~ t;).lk -a=] ~1f4f~ t{~ ~ -m +{j:'-l: fftr ~ 1t 1! ~ 1! tV ' ~11 • Criminal Law Reporter •Family Law Reporter ·lfealth Law Reporter~ BNA 4:ft 8 lli tu fftr ~ 1t 1! M 1!:L tiS- : Daily Environmental Report • Daily Labor Report • Daily ~ !ift~J ~. *. 0. 0. Report for Executives t;). lkDaily Tax Report~. 0. Mealey Publications. lliJt[~*~~'~Jf:r.1f·~.~W~.ftA~~.'-M.g~ mJ.=.+~lt~~{f:1!~*~. Lead'. ~Mealey's. ,. "~11 ,Mealey's Litigation Reports:. Litigation Report: Pedicle Screws. 0. rl:t..~1t1it-m. •• M~~*~*~::t9&~~~.'~4.fl§*~ Andrew Publications lli Jt[ 3i. *I. ' 18. +It ~J. ~ i! flJ ~. ~~o. f1 flJ ~ 1tii ~. "~I1Electromagnetic Field Litigation Reporter • Repetitive. Kent C. Olson, supra note I, p. 86..

(14) il&*$~wHiii. 326. Stress Injury Litigation Reporter . . Cl.1kSexual Harassment Litigation Reporter. 0. Leader Publications ttl ~20 ~ It ~ If 1I {t1 Wf 'W~;ttl mI ff,] 5!. it!! m~ ~ , LRP Publications ttl Hi 16{t :t1 ~ ~ j! m1f!z . . ~ ~ . . .I1t:f;~fJf;fEJ fijI ff,] li1!m~~ The National Association of 0. Attorneys General ttl ~,~. +~{t~0 ~1l . .. m£~mIM"'ffl.~;ttlgff,]~. Wi. ~1*.. a.~. 1!~~~o. 4. ~ itmf fin ~ ~ ],ltM flJ (Legal Newspapers) ~itmffin. #tiff,].~~. ~~.~~.ff,]. ~.~~,~. ~~.~~.~. mo~~mffinm~.ff,].~~~~~. g'A.ttm. ~. o~~~~%.~~. ~. ~. ff,]~~o~limfM$. ~mffin~.A.'W#~li~ •• o~E~~'.. M~*%. Mm.~&ttlm'~~~.~~.~~~~~fi~o ~~.. 1i mf ~ g. itmf~~L~~&M'~.~m~{t1~~ft~. ff,]. ~~ J1- ff,] ~ 1iiff. 0. ttl fU ff,] ~itffiJf!ifJ ~.. ~. frp. *. l§ ttl fU ttl 1± ~ 100 ~ rp WI ~ # ~ ff,] The Legal Intelligence . . "!tj]T! 0. Chicago Daily Law Bulletin . . 1} t~. Pl. ff,] Los Angeles Daily. Journal . . J;),1kfJL~rpff,]New York Law Journal. -. ~ ~:ft J!f !ifJ. fi ~;fEJ ttl lUX.. ' ~ frp. 0. 1970+r#1~. , Legal Times'". , J}. Massachusetts. Lawyer Weekly . . Lawyers Weekly USA . . Connecticut Law Tribune . . New Jersey Law Journal . . Pennsylvania Law Weekly . .. ••. Lawyer ' ~ J;), l§ flJ. ~ ill ~. l§ fU ' ~ I), flJ • ~~ ~ ~ 1& ~I),~.~.~. ~~.~. ... ~~. #. ~. 0. ttl ~. 0. ~ ff,] ~ :ff iff r4fJ E1. ~. it ~.i.. *. ~ l§ ftl . .. ~~~ . .. ~~~*'J;),1k~.~:ff • •. *. 'If. ' ttlNational Law Journal. '#~$~~.~ff,]. ~~. ~.m. III ffJt :t ~ ~ 14 ~ fi • • », Index to Legal Periodical~:f #f i! .li:j:. ~ it iff f}fJ E1 !! ftl . .. ~ American Lawyer Jl~ J1 .:;:U ti 0. *%. tl1 Texas. ~ jS:g. fi. *..

(15) t'£~. !!i! ftl '. ~}J. , B. '~l¥J$~WHlitff1tl!m$~Mf!Jl¥Jr""~~tH~. ftl:l iti± 't iJl rtJ ' fflThe Legal Resource Index#t The. National Law Journal, Legal Times '. A't iJl N S.. 327. ~. If<.The American Lawyer;?']. 0. $ Ji 5if*: ill ~ flJ #J. (Loose-leaf Service). $Ji5if*:ill~~#J~~f*:~.'f*:~ •• 5i*Mfl'~5i •. •. g'5i.fiM8.'.~'~~~~k.~~~~.~~#Jo. ~A~A$Ji5i_ili~fl#J~5i •• m~A~~'I~fl#J.. ~'~.m~ill~-*'Afl.~5i~~~~5i*.&~5i.g I~'. 0. ffl-tt~ A1:~A. '. $Ji5i.lli~f~#J~5i*.1! (treatise) ~. ~'~A.~l~~£*~5i.m~,-ttfi~.~5i*~~ •• ~~~5i_~~~i~~~f#*~o. $ Ji 5i _ill ~ ftl ~ it ~ ;g • ;l. Commerce Clearing House ( CCH) CCH ill :rJiFederal Securities Law Report' Standard Federal Tax Report tL~~ , BNA ill ~ ~Environment Reporter' 0. 0. Labor Relations Reporter '. ~.J.lf<. The. Research Institute of American. ill ~ ~ United States Tax Reporter3/fP.it ~ ~ 5i1tftl ~ $ Ji 5i _ ill ~ flJ #J 1i1i ~ % ~ *- -jffi- CCH t¥J Standard. (RIA) fJT. #J. 0. 0. Federal Tax. Reporter~RIA ~ United. iHJ- ~ 1:. ~ ftl 4m. ..::.. ... States Tax. Reporter:$r~. +.::.. 0. ~f IJ.. "*~ Ii ~.5i*Mfl~~~fi.~~k:$r*-*5i*~mill~~. ft'.~~5i*~.o~-tt~~&.W~.#fi.~~.M~5i. .M~~fiW~'~~~~~.~5i'~~5i'~.~5iA~D 5i.*.'.~. ••. '~lf<.-~~~;g~ •• *~~5i. ••. ~~. mill~~A*~ft~.~~.MftM~~# •• ~~A~~fi.

(16) 328. ~*$~iff~lli! . m-t:;+:hJiJ.!. .'~~~.M~~W~~~~~~~~.~W'.~~ •• ~. 5! $it rJT ttl AA'- ~American Journal ofInternational Law ' ~). lit ~ ~ 1f g~ ta it ~ The Environmental Lawyer ?t jf: - .t!:. itt mt! tt4: ~ ~ 1& 0. 1f~tait~~OO.~.MiliAA'-~5!_~~'.~~ ~.~~ • • ,~jf: ~~.5!1f. ••. ~5!1f.. ~ili~~~*A$~~'~* ••. m~.~~. r.w·. ,~~tttt~~AW~~~o. ~.5!1fM~~~~?t~~~+~~~~~o#~~~~.. *- it ~ M ~). r. M flj ~t X tt ~l JfJ ~ *- ~ (frequency of citations or citation counts) 19 ; eHt;{f 11:t (author prominence) 20 ; 8$;{f -4 *.i.~ ~1l (survey of expert opinion) 21; lil.1!!H~ 19 . 20 . 21 . ~{l:. Cameron Allen, Duplicate Holding Practices of Approved American Law School Libraries, 62 Law Ubr. J. 191 (1969); Olavi Maru, Measuring the Impact of Legal Periodicals, 1 Am. B. Found. Res. J. 227 (1976); Scott Finet, The Most Frequently Cited Law Reviews and Legal Periodicals. 9 Legal Reference Services Q. 227 (1989); Survey, Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Productivity Survey. 65 eM-Kent L. Rev. 195 (1989); Janet M. Gumm. Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Scholarship Survey, 66 eM-Kent L. Rev. 509 (1990); James Leonard, Seein' the Cites: A Guided Tour of Citation Patterns in Recent American Law Review Articles. 34 St. Louis U. L. J. 181 (1990); Colleen M. Cullen & S. Randall Kalberg, Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Scholarship Survey. 70 eM-Kent L. Rev. 1445 (1995); Fred R. Shapiro. The Most-Cited Law Review Articles, 73 Cal. L. Rev. 1540 (1985); Fred R. Shapiro, The Most-Cited Law Review Articles Revisited, 71 eM-Kent L. Rev. 751, 755 (1996); Interpreting Legal Citations: A Symposium Sponsored by the West Group, 29 J. Legal Stud. 317 (2000); Symposium on the Trends in Legal Citation and Scholarship, 71 eM-Kent L. Rev. 743 (1996); and Fred R. Shapiro, The Most-Cited Law Reviews, 29 J Legal Stud. 389 (2000). Robert M. Jarvis & Phyllis G. Coleman, Ranking Law Reviews: An Empirical Analysis Based on Author Prominence, 39 Ariz. L. Rev. 15 (1997). Gregory S. Crespi, Ranking International and Comparative Law Journals: A Survey of Expert Opinion, 31 Int'l Law. 869 (Fall 1997); and Gregory S. Crespi, Ranking the Environmental Law. Natural Resources Law, and Land Use Planning Journals: A Survey of Expert Opinion, 23 Wm. & Mary Envtl. L. & Poly Rev. 273 (Fall 1998)...

(17) tf.~. ,B. ,t~!i¥J$~MflJ~ft~$~MfU~r<l'~.iHjfJ.I±\~. 329. :f1tJfJ ,tt % (library usage) 22 ; ~A lkCfi))t; J;t ~I m,tt % (citations in judicial opinion) 23 ~A 1: -W tr. t~ ~ jJ)t; ~A ~ - JJllit'it It tt. m. *. 0. 0. .~~~'it~m*-W~.MM~o~~lk~~.**~*~.mo ~A ~ :X: M flJ z. ~I Jk tt ff », -W ;t~ ffJ 1: {1lj ~ Wi 1m ~ i± 2002~ 9t$. ~ ISI0- ~ Fff ill!~ ffJJournal Citation Report ( JCR. m. 0. -. tr.. I. Social Science Edition). 24 ;. ~.::.. •. ~ ~ • ~ ~fi ~. '* *- ¥ )t; ¥ m. ( Washington and Lee University School of Law) Fff 11= ffJ )t; ¥. :Jt~. 'W tr. Journal Citation Reports», Wi ftl ~I m>elk. t¥ Mt ~t i ~4. · ~&jt J!~ 1,700.-t±i-#~~Mftl j-i¥fJ1ftl 'fL*,i±-t±i-Mftl z.tI' 0. 0. tr. fl ~. 0. Journal Citation Report~. iL ~p :m tt (Immediacy Index) . . t;Llk ~l. m. ~~. tt. *t ~I m~ 1t Wi. m!¥-1t M (Citing Half-Life). ff ill. tr.. (Impact Factor) . .. (Cited Half-Life) . . 1t~~ ~ 1~JfJ ~. I. JM~-M~i±~-~."'~~z.4ft¥m*mo. • •kw~ Citation Reports Z. t¥ tr. · ¥ ~ ~ 1~ m~ PI ~A 14 9;D jjJS Jtl:. WI fll lit!!-IJ .h?~~M~ftMM?~~M~ill~ • ~?~~M~* 'it It ~l m? ~A 1l Wi flJ f.;m ill ~ MU~~, lk ftl-t ex ~ I~t % Journal Citation ReportlJ ~ :j~ tt z. ~t • %m_ ~~ Wi ftl Rtr ffi if Jiff ill Xli ffJ >e.~ ~ ~ It Jt: 1& ~I ffJ f ~ tt 17~ 3111 • (* 1~)t; ~ -w Mu) i± 19981l1999if # ill ~303 ji >e:$: · ffij i±2000~ tt ~I 552Jk ~tllJ~:j~:rz»,552+303= 1.822 iL~P:j~ttz.~t.%#t~ 0. 0. I. 22 . 23 . 24 . 0. Max Stier, M\Kelly M. Klaus, Dan L. Bagatell, Jeffrey J. Rachlinski, Law Review Usage and Suggestions for Improvement: A Survey of attorneys, Professors and Judges, 44 Stan L. Rev. July 1992. Michael D. McClintock, The Declining Use of Legal Scholarship by Courts: An Empirical Study, 51 Okla. L. Rev. 659, 660 (1998); Deborah J. Merritt & Melanie Putnam, Judges and Scholars: Do Courts and Scholarly Journals Cite the Same Law Review Articles?, 7/ CM-Kent L. Rev. 87/ (1996). Journal Citation Reportjff4J~1t~ir' ~5e.f:J*lilif~~:tr1:<http://www.lib.ntu .edu.tw> 0.

(18) i&*$~~~i1S. 330. mt;+fL1Jl. 'M MfU ffi: 11 if- rJT ttl ~ ffJ ;t ~:f± 11 .if lit:Jt.1tk ;t :f ~I m ffJ If fSJ ft " 'fj1J. ;11'. ~WJfIJ:f±2000if-#ttl~186J";t:f' iTii:f±2000if-1!j-~1 }f]37?k '. JlIJ iL Rj11~ tt~37 -T 186 0.199" 1t{ itll:rAl ~ lk 1t.0 ~ , Journal Citation Report rJT ;IJ ttl 200 1if- 99{l Ad. WJ Til z. -w- ~t ' WI ~ jf- J1tl. +. ~. : Harvard Law Review • Yale Law Journal • Columbia Law. Review • Stanford Law Review • University of Pennsylvania Law Review • Virginia Law Review •Michigan Law Review • Cornell Law Review - New York University Law Review - {J.JtLaw and Human Behavior25. 0. • • • • • ~**.~.~M~ffJ~.M~-W-~~¥~~ ;iflWestlawffJ r Mftl~~1f-W-Mu J (JLR' Journals & Law Reviews) l;,( lk r rJT 1f ~ ~J J (ALLCASES) J- ~4 Jt ' it tr 1995 -- 2002.if rJT ~I}f] ;t.. ~ ~ 1tf it ttl-W- ~t -W- ~t ffJ ~ roo ~. Mfll # 1f 465ft ' iTii Mf ;IJ 1fj ~ 4f ~ : Harvard Law Review - Yale Law Journal 0. +. Columbia Law Review -Stanford Law Review -Michigan Law Review Georgetown Law Journal - Fordham Law Review • Texas Law Review - Virginia Law Review • {J. Jt University of Chicago Law 26. ~ ~Jl~**.~. ~~ISI0 ~ rJT ttl JiOC ffJJournal Citation Report ~ -W- 1:1:. ~ rJT ;IJ ttl ffJ WI ~ :M flJ • WI 1m ~ ;fFJ JiiJ ~.li ~ Z. ~ ttl IjlAF111 :f JiiJ ,tt % " 1990if- Chicago-Kent Law. Review. 0. •••. m. + •. 0. Review1t{ it WI f,J lit ~ 1tk:M flJ rJT ~I }f] I}: ftrJT it ~.~.~Mft ~. .150~ rt ~ * .. ••• ttl~z.~.-W-.Z.-W-~·WI+~jf-M1t{1}:. : Harvard Law Review -Stanford Law Review -Yale Law Journal·. Columbia Law Review' California Law Review· University of 25 26. ~ ~http://www.ea.sinica.edu.twllibrary/icr/LAWI.htm.. ~ ~Most-Cited American Legal Periodicals, http://law.wlu.edu/library/research/. lawrevs/mostcitedmethod.htm..

(19) ~.·B·.~$.AA~8am$.Mfl~~.Wilim. TIl. Chicago Law Review • University of Pennsylvania Law Review • Texas Law Review • Virginia Law Review • Law Review. l:A JJzNew York University. 1995 if Chicago-Kent Law Review rJf 1t.:t ~ -?It-W. 27 0. rG~1969ifCameron. Allen .. 1976~Olavi Maru .. 1986~Richard. Mann .. 1989~Scott Finet .. 1989~Chicago-Kent Law Review" ~ 1990~ James LeonardrJf if.:t -W It WI 1i. ~. ~*o~*MWIWm. 10.. .:t 54;; ¥ MflJ -t!!. ~:ffi ~. •• ~W~~l:A~*~§mM*~~. : /f[q]wHtWfJt;*5*~~~iW1i~z1:t~MfU Study Allen Maru ,Mann !Finet Chicafo-Kent (1989) Chicafo-Kent (1990) Lenord Chicago-Kent (1995) lSI JCR (2002) Washington and Lee (2002). Law Review iHarvard, Yale, Columbia, Penn., Michigan IHarvard, Yale, Columbia, Penn., Michigan lHarvard, Columbia, Yale, Penn., Michigan iHarvard, Yale, Columbia, Penn., Michigan GYarvard, Yale, Stanford, Columbia, California IHarvard, Stanford, Yale, Columbia, California IHarvard, Yale, Columbia, Stanford, Penn. Harvard, Yale, Michigan, Stanford, Columbia Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Stanford. Penn., Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Stanford, Michigan . --- -.--.--.- -_ _._-_ __ __ _ -. .... .... ... ~. ... -.~. ... ... ... ~. ... ... ... ._.... .. ... -. Source: Cameron Allen, Duplicate Holding Practices of Approved American Law School Libraries, 62 Law Libr. J. 191 (1969); Olavi Maru, Measuring the Impact of Legal Periodicals, 1 Am. B. Found. Res. J. 227 (1976); Richard Mann, The Use of Legal Periodicals by Courts and Journals, 26 Jurimetrics J. 400 (1986); Scott Finet, The Most Frequently Cited Law Reviews and Legal Periodicals, 9 Legal Reference Services Q. 227 (1989); Survey, Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Productivity Survey, 65 Chi.-Kent L. Rev. 195 (1989); Janet M. Gumm, Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Scholarship Survey, 66 Chi.-Kent L Rev. 509 (1990); James Leonard, See in' the Cites: A Guided Tour of Citation Patterns in Recent American Law Review Articles, 34 St. Louts U. L J 181 (1990); Colleen M. Cullen & S. Randall Kalberg, Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Scholarship Survey, 70 Chi.-Kent L Rev. 1445 (1995); Most- Cited American Legal Periodicals, http://law.wlu. edullibrary/researchllawrevs/mostcitedmethod.htm; ~J, If<. http://www.ea.sinica.edu.tw/ library/jcr/LAW l.htm.. 27 . lanet M. Gumm, Survey Editor, Survey: Chicago-Kent Law Review Faculty Scholarship Survey, 66 Chi.-Kent. L. Rev. 509, 518 (1990).. i.

(20) 332. 2l}t;-LfLW3. j])!:*i$~Jj!f~l\lJ . J:.:t -W L:r. 1ffi-jttf-~,~%H.5! :WI :WI flj, '11.. JfJ iJl JfJ It ~ ~ 1* It:Ii! tr ~f :tf.:! Shapiro${. 1987 ~ 1997 +1f- ill ~ ft;J 5! ~:WI ~),. *. o. ${. r~ 'ti '1R~Fred R.. ft;J f.:!. *- ,11 *.: .. ~*.::.o : 1987¥. (t}ij). Compiled by Fred. ~.. Shapiro. Source: Fred R. Shapiro, Interpreting Legal Citations: A Symposium Sponsored by the West Group, The Most-Cited Law Reviews, 29.J. Legal Stud. 389, 395 (2000). = : 1987¥ . ( Compiled by Fred R. Shapiro. Source: Fred R. Shapiro, Interpreting Legal Citations: A Symposium Sponsored by the West Group, The Most-Cited Law Reviews, 29 J. Legal Stud. 389, 396 (2000). ).

(21) ft;+- .:::: if: 7\ J=J. tt~. ,B. '1!~H'B$:~WHUliffX;~$:~WHUtrJrrml!.il~p!i±l~. 333. ~*#fi.M~¥M~'A.m~~~~~.*,.~:¥. *. 4f • * .i.tl ;t Jt ~ ~ IJl.PX tt ' Jiff 1~ ill :t -w tt ~ iE.1t :tf JiJT ~ ~ 1997ipGregory Scott Crespii* mi z;.¥4f. *.i.tl tJl1J l~ 4t4tfi 71ft m¥ ~ ... .i.f.i;fP ill tv ' I;L lk 17li m~ft. * ~ ... .i.~fP ill t,J ¥J II ~ ~ tt tt r~ ~~ flJ ' it 1& ~, ~ tnll£ 11 ~ ~ftT Ftl, 250 ~ 1i. *. 0. *•. z;.~~~~*_~~~¥4f:tflfiM~:t§ff~.~%'.*fi ~M~:t.i.tl~1J'#~~~¥4f.*.;t.m~M~»~1i# .~M~~nill~+~¥J*¥M~otJl~~*~~: :~~~m~oo+~~~~$W~~$m~. 7.46 6.09 4.70 L. If. 3.64. I. 2.62. Mt T I;L J:. ~ tt ~f ' it:tf¥ 4f. m11= 4f {I:t (author prominence) l~ 4t If ~ II - ~9: 'tt J ~ • r~ ¥ Wi ftll! ff -W tt Robert M. Jarvis~PhyHis G. Coleman4t fl ~ ¥-W» rffftl1f: fig .i:. ~ ~:f: ( lead articles) W. 1« 7,102 ft if 4f it ~ II ± 11 Jiff m :t tL ~), 1,000jf fZ J! ~ J:.:i1! iIf ~ 1£.:t. if 4f jf ~40~ l! 1i .i:.tl ~ tt 28 Tracey E. Greorge. *. *. 0. * 0. 28. Robert M. Jarvis and Phyllis G. Coleman, Ranking Law Reviews: An Empirical.

(22) 334. i!&*$~l¥Pffiflj. mt+tIJ!IJ. and Chirs Guthrie-t!!. t¥. /iij tt1l)! ft fl ~ ~.. *. r,. 'tt)! ¥. rt ' 11<.. Tr}f '% f.:t n ttl ijtj 1OO{i. r, )! ¥ MflJ 29 z.. -W ~t f.:t ijtj +-t jll1 3& 1i. *. 0. MfrJ l! trw. George~Guthrie. 0. : Top 10 Specialized Law Reviews Listed in George and Guthrie's Study. ~Wftt11~:g i. Mf!J:gff1}Wili~Fi*~~~~. Iwtt7ti&. I. 1 2. Supreme Court Review, University of Chicago I 542.02 :1 ITax-L-a-w-R-ev-i-ew-,N-Y-U-'-----~------='------+--4-5-4-.2-7-1. 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10. I Constitutional Commentary, Minnesota i Journal of Legal Studies, University of Chicago I Journal of corporation Law, Iowa IConnecticut Insurance Law Journal I William and Mary BiB of Rights Journal i Supreme Court Economic Review ) Administrative Law Journal of the American University ! Harvard Journal on Legislation. i. i. I. i. j I. 441.10 414.20 394.93 381.94 381.62 371.32 351.61 345.00. Source: Tracey E. George and Chris Guthrie, An Empirical Evaluation on Specialized Law. Review, 26 Fla. St. U. L. rev. 813, 831-32 (1999).. '* fl J:.:i!:f. /iij -W rt 1J -* ' ~ ~ : the identity of authors' jouma's'. usefulness' citation frequency' usage studies' user surveys '. ~), Jk.. analysis of scholarly value ' ~ ~ ¥;{f Russell Korobkin 11= lli ~), r ftJ ~.:~J:.ftJ.-*.:f~ ••• mftJ~~;{f •• ,#*~¥;{f.. ftJ tll m* tt »l. iJ -* ~t J:.ll! ffi 'Wi iJ -* ~ it ~~~)!.¥m.~_-~+*~~.~ftJ-W~ •• ~o ~.i. ft -W 1Jt. 29. 30. 0. ... ~ ~ ft. '. Analysis Based on Author Prominence, 39 Ariz. L. Rev. 15 (1997). Tracey E. George and Chris Guthrie, An Empirical Evaluation of Specialized Law Reviews, 26 Flor. S. U. L.Rev. 813 (1999). Russel Korobkin, Ranking Journals: Some Thoughts on Theory and Methodology, 26 Fla.St.UL.Rev.851, 874-875 (1999).

(23) tt~. I. ,B. '1!811.M~!;lmfU~~IfJ$~MfU81r",'Ji!l!~1±:}jI~!. 335. ,1tft#~ ~. M~~~*~~M:H. .;. J*. ~. )fj The. -a. ••• ~·ft. .~~.*.~~UP~S~ft;. '$ ~ ; (li)iJ[ tt~~#1 BluebookZ iJ[ tt. ~ 1?'J ~ ~ ; (NM ttl ~ ~~ :It;. (Jl!1)1!~ ~r. $if. ~. ill~~.~~~~~~~-~~~. ~-* -~,. ft. ~~.W~OO~*.;W*~~~.~~-~. ft. •• ·ill.I~'~~.~~.~I~ •• ~~~~*1~*~~~. ••. ••• ~r.A±.~ ••• ~'~ff~.' r. • • • ~.~ •• ~;W~.M~z~~*A.m~~. ft;ffi~.M~ •• I~Z.~, •• z.I~.~ ••• ~ ~ ••• I~44~~;~.~ •• ~4~*~~4.*~~~ ~, '$ ~~ Jii&Legal Writing Competition;f ~ I if} ..~ 1t JlJ ; tt)M ttl z ill AA. Ht Jt ~ ~ ; w. ~ 11= ~ .i.:f ~ ~ ~fL. essay'. J\... comments' notes' cases summary$ ; (i;~.~ ill ttl ;fIff #1. • ~. ~~~~z~~~~#~~:~.~. •• ~I. AX. '. .'.. •• I~'Aa~#1#~,~~+.ft~-Wft.~;. •. ftM~a§#1S~'~~~~*A~.~~,.m~ ,...-,:, r= .... ". ft;. ~ ... ~. ill AA. ~ ~ ff.J • • 't:£. Mttl ' ~ ~r. ~,I ~. tK. .~~lfSiJi*fj-fJf"iiJ ~LEXIS & NEXIS - WEST LAW. ~~~lf.M.~.~#1~illAA.ltK,~. ~M:f. .; ~~.M~~**.;~ •• -.~.· *#1S ••1[:. P-&.. 0. ~ .. E3 ,*-ik$}tA f'l {~~>L 8*ff.J~ • • • ~'$~'~.~lf*.. A.ffl.~~.

(24)

(25) 1. ~.

(26) 338. Drx:*$~~~illi. ~.~.-.D *,m~N. •• ~W. ~M~mAft*l~.. ~~~.h~~. M.ft,.~~~.~ft. ••. ·~*.. ~~~.~i.D. ~~~~A. ~·m~M~m~'~~A~a*~~. ~'$.-a~M~. #~~mA~~~~~MD~A~aMfl. *. 11 11 4rP1J Y! ~~ -ftW~· • • ~ili M• • ~~~'~. ~ ~ t~Uj~. ·W ~. ~*~~~~ .h~.M~~.. rp ~~1J 11 · FJT ~ ·W.~*.ili ~ffiliMno~. A.~RlAl*~JJ\' ~.iliM •• ~*.'. fil~~)Jt~· {§.~. 'fj1. ~-.*~,~~. ~~~ft.-.ili~ EI *~ ~1!M *~ aM tlJ ~ ili ttJ #i $ tfJ A-. ~no~~W~' 34 .::...3§: 1m M. Jlu l:t ~ ~;;f;: il # •. • - a ~~ ttl. fa'. ~~•. .::... ~ Mttl '. 0. ili~~.~&'. ••• wmw. •. # • • • ~~,. ~~a~M~D~. &(tfJ.::..'~~. )~~. ~~~~~(~ft. .::...~M~~1i. x.. 0. ~M~~*. •. ~~M*.tt. ~~~*·W. ~~iliM~~~±. ),~tt~~~~~. •. ~1_o~A~. .~~~'WA~*~$~m~'M~-ftW. J. '!f~*~m. ~~M~~m~~~~~~~~~mr ~$~mlUii~U~f§rJ~. J. J. '. ,~~*~*~. 0. n.**~W*~*~~m.Mfl~~~~MmBff'@~ffim*~~~~. 3i.:1it '. mjjpjOOtBlt&ffct~~~::J-Bff$1$t§lmiUi~fU~tB~~~;JW. 0. ~llft~~tBlt&ffct ' ~rjf§rJtmJ!f1@;*~~t.t~tiH7i:~J±Hf1@;*~tBlt&~mfrjrr • B~~,~~m~~,m~mflff~mlU3i.:*$~~~~WmlU3i.:~~~ft.~ 34. -fE.4-Hfluu:;'r ,. §.

(27) t£~. , B '~I¥J~~WJfn~~~$}JHtijfnl¥Jrc'Jm~te~. 339. t • • ~ili.~.~*#.ft~o~.~~~~~~h •••• Mf'J if,]~~3[:r ~ 0. •• -.M~~~*~~~~~§*»~if,]I~o.# •• •• ~u*~if,]~~m'WA.#.~m~~if,].w*ft~o:r 1! if fJl ~ ili fV *- f,( , J!U ~ ~ 1iU 1~ 37 0. X~~*~M~~.3[»if,],~~~.if,]~M~~o. 8*~~.~~~#*~'#~IZ~~A~Wo-~W t'.R~*'~~~~'~.~'~~'m~~.,. •• ~.. ~if,]~~m~o.~~~~~.~~M~~~.,3[*~~o/§. *~»~.~~~~f~*fioW~A~~~*~.~~~~~ .~9,-ftWt'.W3[:r~~,m~#~~.~~Mili~~. ~ft°.~.¥~~~~~'~~M~:. 1. EL*~~~.~ r ~~~~ (~tOO)J. 2. 8. *- ~~ ~ ~ ~ if,]. r ~~ 5-i (::N. t. M )J. 3. 8 *-7ftl~~~~ r 7ftj~¥ltt (~t M)J 4. ~*mW~~~~ r ~. mWc¥l tt. (~f.j:~1tf±)J. 5. 8*5-if[~~~ r~f[~~~ (::NtM)J 3S. '~MM~fi~*.&~illlifl~m.. H. ~litf~~fU1o/J~~ ~gffi~:MfU;fElIQJ. ' imffi.S r $~litf~ J. ~NlIJ~f~1itto/i:JfifT) J 37 . 0. M~.~*.. ¥}:1f~ffi.SwJtf-]fU:8mW. 'ffrj;)J:fI!l&~:g~l:mJtffi.S r. (r. J. 0. f§rrpOil~;ijUl~-'~*~ r -'mlitf~ J. '. •. *~~. W~.~OOlitf~ffrlitf~~~litf~~*, ~fi~~¥mrn*.'Jtlitf~~~1o/J~~~~~~~$.~r$litf~.J. ~&~~~~m~~r. J. ,mm.~~~~m~ •••litf~m~~IQJ~litf~~fi~.fi~. ~~litf~~*~~:tm°.

(28) 00 M.

(29) ift~. f1+-=-if:t\f3. ,. B '. 341. E51d! *. 1 8 5i 5i * (11 3iJilj ) J TIJ 5. E1 *- ~ f}j if *. 1 8 *- ~ 'fJJ if *. tt ( mTIJ ) J 6. if ft. 5i *. 1if fF.1i}f 1E (11 ~ M) J It-TrJ 7. tt. 5i *. 11t tt. 5i 1i}f 1E ( mTIJ ) J It- TIJ 39 8. ~9:jkJtt~*-*5i*!SJtftJ~~**. 1 ~~*.# M)J It-t~ 9. ~9: jk Jtt *-* 5i * !SJt Ef.J ~ 5i *. 1 l!ID ~ 5i jr 3( # 4.. *. 0. -1"11. 0. 0. 0. (11~. 0. M) J It-tU 10. ~9: jk 1f-. 0. m*- 5i * !SJt tf,J E1 *--0 t! 5i *. 1-0 t! 5i *. X ) J It- Ttl. 12.. It- TIJ ~ jk {If! ? *-*. (11. 0. ~M. ~~. 5i. ~f1) J. *~A. ~ ftJ ~! Ji'f 5-i; *. I~! Ji'f 5i *. it It- ¥l (11. 0. 13. ~jkJ~~jiij*-*. *-. (~. 0. l1.~jkE1*-r.ftr!i-0itEf.JE1*-3(1!5i*.'3(il5i,,* M). (11 ~. *!SJtEf.J 8 *-*. Ttl. 0. ~~. 5i*.1. ~*. 5i*(. 8. 0. ~~.«~~1i}f~,.~~~~. .#ro~~~. A£~'~~W.11~.ft~.~M~'~~~~I#~~'« ~ I E1. *' Ef.J 5i * 1i}f ~ jJ r&J Ef.J 177 fi ~. ( ;f1 1]::t£ Jtt. 5If, 1E 5$ Ef.J 1. *-* 5i * !SJt ~ ~4 t~ W. ~M. ~ *-. ~ 11. M. 0. ~~~A~~~~~jk*-~,~~~~~~,~~.~Jtt*. **5i*!SJtftJ'~hJo~~'~R. .Ef.J. Jtt~*-*5i*!SJt*~~~. ~,.~m.~.£~1i}f~~ftJ.m1i}f~~#~*M*~. ftJ1i}f~o. 39. c*.

(30)

(31) ~~·B·.~$.Mfl~ft~$.M~~~ •• ~.. ~~-ftW~'-~~~~A~~~V'W-. ~. r Jt tt-J ~ Jf.LIt~ flJ. 40. ~~~tt.~. 0. ftM~~#~.. -A. ,»-.~. ~~+. •• '*_~~A~.~'#. ~o~~,~. ~ tIS. r. ••. I.. A&~. ~'x~~mr~~. •. ~3. J~~o~~. 1iJf ~ ~ rlf ffr. J '. W~ 1} ~ ~rJ. r. 1iJf ~ ~. ~J~r~~~Jm~,~n~m~A~o. ffr. .~~M~~~.~tt.*~(*~AA~)'~~:. 1f ill ~ :f1 ~ f;fl.1~ JflJ $- 5! ( E1 iL 1t 2. MfJTftlfj-~ ~ att 3. E1 *- -W ~ :f1 fJT ftl fj- ~ B4- ¥K (1ii rPJ ) 4. ~ 5! ffr~ ~ it fJTfrJ fj- ~NBL (-=¥- A fU ) 1. f;fl. ft. ~ fj-. ). 0. 0. 0. 0. ,#~~~~ ~~. ~~XAI'tt. ~B4-~0/'~. ~~~§.~. +. ~ WI ftl. 5!'.fj-5!'*~5!' ~.ffr~.'. 1fij M. 1t tt }1 5! ' '0~~~5!'. ~'.Mill~~~,~~-ftW. ~y. ~~1}~ 0/ tt-J r. !~. ' #. fi5!'~5!'~M. •• ~~. ffrlI fF '. §(~~~~5!),ti. - Jt. ~~~jt}n:U ~*~jJ. ~ .1fL ~ ~. ~m~~o#~~. ~~f~if. 1iJf. 0. ~/. ffr* ~. J '. tt 11 r JrJ. ,tt. 11.. ' *tIS. AA 1. 5! If it fJTfrJ fj- ~. 2.. ~. !l Mftl fj- ~ 5! 1f. ( B4- ~ ) ( :/.::I- !J. 0. A. r- ). 3.fj-~(~·J: 7itV\)fJTftlfj-~5!1i~. 4. 40. ~J B4- ~ it fJf flJ. mU~lBl~~~~$A. .. ~ :ftl17rJ B4- ~. (. 0. !~(5!1f0)l}0. A ill flJ.:::. WI ). , ~~~g1ffu~. 0. )0.

(32) 344. 5.. iJ&*$~WP~. *,J fJtj TIMES{±. Jiff fU ff (tJ f~ fJtJ TIMES (4i}: fJ lli fll fa M ) .o.~~.~(tJM~,.t. 0. ••4i}:M •• -~~.(~~. ~-~~~.)'.B~H.~'~m~.*.~~'3~(tJ.. MJLM 41 Jt~ Jt ~ (tJ Mfu AA-flJ ~ j: ¥ #tl ~5'r 0. ' j1 ~~)1IJ j: fJl..::tf. m•• (tJ~~~.'W.K(tJM~'~~~.~~'8~~(tJ. ;to. • • -.~.~~~(tJr.~~J'ff~ 1. 8 *-"W .1±Jifff'J ff (tJ j!. j'i( i (5! ~ 2. ~ 5f Mftl ff (tJ j!.~i:. ~m.A~:. ). 0. 0. ~m.A~. ••• ~.M~~*i'.i •• '~.*i'. £~.~.~§,~.~~. j!,. j!,.~.(tJ.M**~~. •• (tJg~Qo~~.~.~m£~.~~~~§~~.~'8 • • B~Ar~(tJ~*4. • • ¥I~(tJ~~mm~ff(tJM~.~o 0. ~.(tJM~,§~. •• #.~m(tJ~~ •• :. *. 1. • ~ j! ~ *. 3 #.! )fij • - t! it- • #Jl ' bt ~ *,J Jiff A ~ , fJ fU 2. ~ 3r. ~ • • it ~ ~ iL j! ::151i:)fij , 5'r ~ (tJ iL j! , A 3. j!3~f!~)fij , ~~ 1*~ , A fll 4. )!3#.!~1tJfJEJiff~~ 8 *-H'J ~~1tJfJE.' ~~-!ij , *-+-110 5. j! 3 #'!~11}f 1E Jiff ~ ~ j! #.! 1tJf ~t ~. ~ 1tJf1I}. ~ i: ' ~ *"1iJf 11} , A ftl 6. ~ ~ (.if). ~ ft roo ~! ~ {f~) ~~ ,1iN)fij , * (tJ j! 4'- ' -=¥- A fll 7. j!3~~ )fij' ~*A~' Af'J 0. 0. *. 0. 0. 0. .~~.(tJM~#§(tJ.~~~~t.~~~~'~.M~ 41. tQ~PRl&rP]fj8"J~~1J);1:. ,. 42. ~ T-~fU r J. IgOR ( I 9931:j:. ). 0. 0. 1993. 8. tJ~. G '.

(33) ..,.M.

(34) ---:0;;. 346. ~. i&*$~ms§ifH. mt;+:fLM. •• ~-.'.~~~*~r-.*~~~~.h~Mh~. ~,m~~~~~~~~W'~~#-~~~~'~#~~~ m~X~~~~%~~~W~. ~#fr~~~~o. ~,~~ •• ft&'ili~M.~~,~*m~~. -~~~~'.A~~~~~.~ ••• ~(. •• ~~~),~m'~~~. ~9*. .ftM~~. ~~~_. ~I~ •• W. ~ili~~~~1. ~~*. ~~.~~.ft~*«~. ~'8*~.~~~~9~'. .~~~~~. ~W~o~.,~~~. ~*'8*~**~~~ffl~~~'&9 ~~~±**~,. .M~~~~.o~~. '~M~. ~a+m ~. a~X. •• -.~. ~*~M~~. ~**o/'~~m. ~. X'~.. ~. ,. h~~i'. *~~~h. ~. ~.. ~~*~~X~~~~. MM~~*'#~~*~M~~.~ft*~MI. ~~~~%~*~ M~~m9*~~. ft~. .~~,~*.. o.I~'8*~. h~o#M~.*~~~~*~'ffiA. ~. ~. 0. g~M~~~~.~~'~~~. ~~~~.. ~~~,~. •• ft~«oM~. ~~m.~@~o~~A.iliMWA~~ili~~. ~~. M. ~~~. ~. ~. ~~~. ~~~~~~,m. ~~~ ~**'W~ *~~mG *M~~~~§~ ~**.~. ~#.o~#~g~~~*. *~~~m*.~. .~~ •• ft~o. ~~m~8*~.m*~~A~~.ft~.,*~~~~~ ~#~. ~X. $W-m~. g~*~,~~~*~~.~~~*~. ~D*~~-~.~~.@. ~'.~mA~~.~.'.

(35) rn.

(36) 348. mt:;+ :hJ~;El. JI&:k'$¥l¥PmfB. .~~~1tM~~~**._'I~~#~*~~~.ft~~ '~T •• ~~WA~~~A1t~.~~.~.~~~.. iiJ ~}Ji~{R*~1:1 ill E}l ~1l1t. ~. 4 •• ~~.h. ••. ~~~. 0. 1:1.~ Jl:l. .~*.~.~5!~.~r5!_**J. ••• ••*. ,~. 3k£~~.:tJL~~:k1?flJ1f45. ~~m~~.~~.~ 0. 1:1~~~~~. ).. !1J1~. .. .~~.~. ~. EJ 0. ~M~f1~'.M~~~~1f+ • • ~~ #~ft±. ,~.a. •••. 5!_** • '*W~tiM. ~. 4±.~.~~**~~~. fl.~~8**. ~.'~~*T.~8. ~~. 0. *~~ft~~.Tffl~'~.ll1tE..:k.~iiJ. aRTffl. ~fl. }.\~±~(~*~±~~. ~1*t~~1t~WJ:t-~~~ .46~. #~ • • '~:k~. '. tiM *~.. • • • ' JJL4 E.ft.! ~l ~~11!l~ tt~~. .., •. ' tt2003.3 f1 ~ ,. ft5!~. 5!~M~ • • ~. .,~~-. 0. ~*~. ~~.,. • • ~ftm. f.I~W:t°. .~'8*5! ff~M. 0. IL. 8*~. :k*. }.\.~~~~mffi. :k•• ~'WR. ~M~'~. •. ~AA~~&~' , $ -:( ') I ,"I:1?"t 7J" aI. ~. M~~~~. ~*~~~. A~~~a,.~.~~*_*M~T. JI. ,"1:1. ~~~~E. ~. IIIJ L... ,.a:.. {f1. '!3. 1IX. "''" ~ 1- WJ. ~.~~ •• *,.~. ~~~'~:k~~5!~~~. I~. Il'l /1"'. 0. ~E.1:1*±. •• ~.*.o4~.~% '. #~mill~~~M~.'~~1:1WJ~~M. n~~5!~~5!~r. $~~'fl5!~~~~~~r1:1h~~no. 46 ftE -~~"r+1F~¥1E. r.:I:r~~~~llt01l!f!;allW' '. R Miit:J=-+.

(37) ~~·B·.~$.M~~ft.$.Mfl~~eWlliR. JL+-=-1f:f\J'3. N9. E- .. 1tft~-t ~ ~~. ~~.~~'M~.~¥M~~~~.. ~W~,ft. ,~.%~. ~~.M~m~~~.~~B*°ft~~~¥M~. ~B*~~~~.~~~M~~A~(~~~.m.)'~. •. M~~W~~.B*M~~.(. ~~~tt. •. .H)'~~~. ~~*Aa~~~*.ftM~~~~~~'~~~~~~*mili .~M~om~B*~¥M~.~mft. .. •• '.M. A~##~~.~~~D. £*~'8*. ~~.#. *~. ~~~X. ,.~.. ~m.~A~~~ ~. .~,~.~~*,. ~8A.~~M~~.. %4-fi. .M~,~~m~,~. r& 7t ) ,. ~~~*. •••. W. ~~~7t.I. ~&P~ft. ~AA. ~. 1t~~1m. 1f. 0. ~.~~~. 1i~+~CD. mlliJW.~M~~. ~. • • ~tt *lli*~. *¥MfIJ ~ ~¥1*r~ f}~~I?&.i1llliJ& ~'-MW~ •• ~#¥~~-# .'~ •• AA~~ f. ~~~M~~-.. ~miliJW.~~~8~~~. JlI:..X". ~ X.. _~~.~~~'4. •• ~'~.~¥~~~~. •• 9*.:tOO~~.~W~' f1 ¥1*1 ~ I f} ~ ~ ~~ ftt¥* ~ ~~ i1llJ7 ~~. ~'R~.4-#~~.~~~ ffij. ~~4~~W4~~~.~M. m'~#~~~~*¥M~#I~. ~*%~*¥¥if~. Mft• •. M~ ~A. 0. 411lif!~Wo. ~~~. (CD) , •. ,~~~.~7t~«~W~«.B. 48*,~a+m~~~'*. .M~. ~oWA'E. (~*fi~~~~.~.M~~~. ~wtto~.,. .~m. *~ft. .~~.'~MA*. ±!.lli JW. ~ fN ~ tr ~. :t;ft 't ~ #E. ~~m~~ ~,t.~,. ~~~. .. '•. ~~.~~~.

(38) 350. il&*$;~Wfllifa. tf.J ttl! 47. m-!::;+flJtr~. 0. tf.J *- ¥ MfU tf.J ~ 51-tt ~~ *- ~ J:. e. ft.~ 1ft. ~ 1t tf.J ¥1t M ~.~~tf.J .M~m~ft°.~~~~.~.*¥M~~ • ~:L ft. •. A.ia'#~~$*~.tf.Jtt~,~-~. ~~.~.tf.J». .~.~9*~.~*-¥tf.J~M~~~'R~_*¥m~~tf.J~ M~~~. •• ~**m~tf.J~¥~~~*~ft~o~-~~tf.J.. ~~.~.~¥1t~~~~*.~~~m~*~o ¥1tM~~*.~M~~.~MaJ:.~~.m,#~~~~. g • • 1t ~ f{ 1# f4 ft ~ ~ tf.J Jf -€t ~ &p fIt ftJ ti» II Jtl!.. ~ _it ~ if. 0. ~~.R,#~~ •• ~~_*ftJ~~~~,~W.~~~~* ¥~M~tf.J~~o~~. ~ftM~m~.~. ~~~.~.¥~M~~¥1tM~~*. •• ~~.tf.JM~o.~J:.~#¥1t~*.. M~J:.tf.J~.~*-~.tf.J¥~M~J:..~ftJl~(~.~) W-~¥~M~~1t~-#~~ftJ~~1t(*~.¥1t«~ftJM ~~~~~)M~'~~.~~~M~~~~~1t~.tf.J~~~. 47. 4'+-?i7i'i''i,·c:F{;:!J , BP~#~j5HfJnI!:!;:~~:xf1t~11~fIJJfHI{1fi 48. ~ Jf ~~ WJ flJITM J& t¥J ~:it:! T. '. 0. J{Jl€E - If'] ::E~ittH~ ~ 7E.ll~ i. ~~~~~~aWJ.~WJ~t¥J~fiM~'. 49. ~~H:lU~l&lli~~*g*ttWJfU. ' 'WtlPDtlJ£illTimes •. ( :;.::L. I) A 1'-). ,. ,jVf4~DVD1t. ( PDFfi) ,. B 1&Po#H~~It&~f4iHlkJPOD1tM~ , ~~3mWJflJ~ ,. WHIJ t¥JrJJffg~ 1t~~fJt;1i:: ~. '~fu~m~.:xt¥J~ • • ~, ¥~ •• ttm~·~~~.*t¥J.~Mt¥J~M' PJ1j1~~~t¥JMil&jjWll:. 0. ..

(39) rn.

(40) 352. iI&*$~~~. ill lJL}iff ~. r. 5-! 1r. .i. ~ J (Rechtsprechungspositivismus) tfJ. 5-!'~~#~~*~~*'5-!¥tfJ~.h~Wmft(*lJL~5-!~ ~ j!lJ If ~ ff,J gI}fJ .l: ) , 1k ;t ~ ill ' ~ # ;t.I. fI}J Pi ff,J ¥ ;t. +. .J.~W. t~.ff,J*~'. •• **~.o. ~ill~ff,J~~**.;t.'fi-. 5-! __ ~~~AftJ~~ J #.! 'tt ~1l! ff,J ~ f4 .. (Lehrbuch) , ~ ~ 1i: - . ~ ill • ~ . . . (Monographie) '1!L~tt ¥1IL~;t (Dissertation) :& ttl ± it lOC 1~~ ~ 1Pf m~ t} ff,J ~;t (Habilitation) p\J, ~ CU~_ 0. •• ~~A~Mff,J.~ft;t.,»~-*.o .~ _ff,J 1!f:W ~ (Kommentar) ,JlIJ ~ ~ ~ tf ~ ff,J.I. .. ' • ~1~~ iJtJtM~ 1r8-' Jj.?t 5-! JJ:: "71' m5-! ff,J J;ttt o~:t ~(Sammelwerk) 1!L ~ T9f ~f" ff,J ~ *- ' ~. (Festschrift) " ( Gedachnisschrift) il!lf ~:t., ~ .~.~ ~ •• ~jt ff,J:t 1! (readings) 53 " ~. ~tf~~~£fi:-~ftJ.~W~MU~~~~'w%A~~$. •. ~;t #Jl. ~ ~. ff,J :t. I {~»'.=f. ( Handbuch) I ~ tx. ~ ~f4" fP. ~ ~ff,J~~.o 1i-.~~~Mill~I~~:t»' . ' ';f 1I:;ff jt:. ~ 1M 1IL ff,J MTtl (Zeitschrift) % ~~ W~ :;ff 0. 11l!.. ff,J fi ( J ahrbuch ) , X ~ iJt ~ 1i'-fi: MTtl ~ ~ ;t 1t .:t ra~ ff,J - • ~.:t.~o#~~1r8-.l:A:;ff. 53 . 4ft'~~#. ~¥. ~htfJ. ~pjf.~H~r'¥~ff~~iUllft-J*~U:X~ , tzorm$*~m$pj~ft-JAbhandlungen zurn deutschen und europaischn Handels- und Wirtschaftsrecht, AHW : f~ft-JStudien und Materialien zur Verfassungsgerichtbarkeit (Christian Starck ±~ , Nornostfj/tl5i) 0. ~M~ft-J$ • • ft-J:X.fu#m.~' • • ma~-~~*a.m~~.·0. Veroffentlichungen der Vereinigung der Deutschen Staatsrechtslehrer (VVDStRL) '¥n*$8*~tfj¥U62M; $jfr±~~pjf~!f.Mfi;j~W!f!J ' j)fn;tt.[OJ*~ff---{Jt$. : lahrbuch fUr Rechtssoziologie und Rechtstheorie 0.

(41) 11+.=:3r; 1\ Fl. )c at ' ~;r:. *" #!. 11. 1Jf~. ttl XOC '. ,B. '~I¥J$~MfU~iX[jJ$¥WHUl¥Jro'lm~t±:l~. 353. jltJ ~ It it ~ ¥l % (Gutachten) , ~ It :i tt &. '. if.] , ;r: fl{tX !:f! ~r ~! ~;r: 7'1 A J if ~ ltl ~. (Lexikonartikel) , ~ #.tt ~ ~!:f! l§. ,. J.!11. ..'. if.] ~ {t trti 13 ~# (Repetitorien) , if.]Ij!l ' ~ ~u .. (casebook) -ill.1$Tjfk ~ 1t ' 'ti~ II W 17i *!£~ itl ff .i. ~ , -ill. ~ :f Y ~ ~~if.]~~*~,~# •• ~.~~»mWif.]~~,~. \ I. }f]. 0. 0. ~*~if.]»~'-~WY~!:f!~. *~if.]!:f!l3'~-~WX~. ~»~a-~~~.ttlfiif.]l1* a.~,#.at~~~.#if.].. 1t. 0. ~ l-t. f JlI. -ill. ~ Jfk. .~. KW;r:4~~~.g~Mif.]~. ttl 1IV \PJ ~ !:f! if.] ~ ~. Lernbuch ' Grundriss) , ~:l ~ - ~. -, I. I. tt ~ if.] * {fj3 ~ ~f-t". ~~~.%!£if.].*. »if.]~. ~ ~ s}f ~. § W. (Standardlehrbuch). 0. (Kurzlehrbuch '. .». £:4:J:.;r: l!. %ff~II*!:f!l3if.]~#'W~Y~~~~!:f!l3~~~if.]#~,.i. ~if.]~~a4~fu~»'~~fi~~~~~~if.]~fi~~tt~if.]. *,~ttlXOCIt:i~~'i~~~~.'*.~~l!% ~.«~fu.. •• ~.. o~.;r:l!%ff~~#if.]~~* •• '~.I. •• if.]!£*,~~~~tt •• , ff.~J~~.~fiif.]W#.~ •• if.]m%*'~~ •• if.]M~~ ~ -w» ' *- ffi ~ A ~ ~ ;/t: ~ ~ 1ft ~ 4 ~ if.] Handkommntar ' ~~!:f!~~~mif.]*~.:4: •• ,~_.;/t:~Jfk ~'Y~ It *:4: if.] Standardkommntar ' - WJt. ~ ~ ~ :I-£lJL~.~f.if.]lJL1lJ\' ~~11~1tJf-f. ,r 1!~J ~ rf if.].i.~~~4Ift,. ~~!:f!~. 0. 0. . . . .. .... :t... ••. ~m~~~ ~-A~O~oo~.~~.*-~~~~A**(Dcr Deutsche Juristentag, DJT) , f!9( &,a{f ~ iQ t1] 1:1 ~~i&* ~ Mi ilH=r ~ ~ 11 1if! (~~ 00. mW. I. I 'J 3:.~ ~I:R:. ) ,tJlLfn ;!t ~ ~ EdJHiff5J ~ Hermann. Conrad et al., Der Deutsche Juristentag 1860-1994, 1997..

(42) iI&*?t~lff~~ . 354. .... ~t;+1tJU:l. .J~ff.·~~~~~. ... #.~~~,#.g~.W'.~~. ~·~#~ft.#.~ •• ~~o~~*tt.#.~«~ ~.,~. ~~.~~~~~~~m.o~. ***. 4~ •• *~~ .~H,~.~.~. ••. *•••. ~t. '. ~.~~. ,~ ~~~.~~**~.~~ ~.~~m~~~'.~~.~M~.~. ~~.56, m~~~-~~~~.4~1t ~~A~.(.. ~Jl1~J:.~#. J. ~.~.m.I~~~'W%~~.ft,~ft. ... ~w. ffiJ*t#I1**mDh~JE~. (DFG) 7uA~-tfmDh~~.. ~'~~~~.~M. •• ~.m.I'~.. ~~~~ti~~~~'*M ~~I. a. Mili~~~~X. ~~~~K~~#~.~.~~~. • ~~ 4~-$~ft ~~~'M~~~~~ •• ~ .~. ili~~. ~~oM~~%.~~~~~~~~. #. ~f.#t. '%~'~~)'~~~~MA#.~.~'. ~.~A~8~M~4~~J:. • • ~.~.'~~J. •. •• ~. ~. ' ~11 ~ 1t~ JE{±~K ~ ~. -W. (Rezension) ~ ~ ~~}jf. ft 11 ~ :fj f!{ ~ ~ iL f- aA , ~ ~ ~) ~ it ~~ ~ ffin- Mft (newsletter) ~ JJJ. ( Anmerkung) , ~.., ( Stellungnahme) ~. •. ... ~,~.~~,.~,.~~ti'~±.~'~.~:fj~~. ••. ~~oM~.~~%~~'~*~W~.4~~h'~#4~. ~.~~~~~***.. ~~~'.~.~~~I~.~+A. ~. •• m·##~.*~~~~~m«o~¥~_~MaW~.. 55 . tEFestschrift8~~I&AWebster's?€:xm:Jif!&P~lnt~tfZJ!. 56 . lIf*1Crr ' 1:E1864¥U1944i§:!\ +1'fFa' ,. Q. ~ , , ~:it!!.frj=~OO~m~~~rr :t1lf269*' tE1944¥U19741'fitttijJOT523/.$:' , 1974¥ti19943Z.tti:JJOT879:;f: ,. PJ1'&!1!~if~70* ' :m1:E8*~§7it2,100* ' ::f~~oltt. , ~ ~~. '. fftJl.~:X3Eh~~~. 11 ill ~t T fffi,. ~ Schulze-Fielitz, Festschriften im Dienst der Wissenschaft, DVBL 2000, 1260-1266 0.

(43) fJE~. .~~¥M~'. •. ,. B ,ti!l¥J$~MfrJ:ifft~$~Mfljl¥Jro'~Wtfj~. ~~~ti~.~.*~~#~. .~fflm.,. ~~¥I~.I.~~~~~~*M·.h~a~. ~ ~ 71. 57. ,. jttL~ f4 :f {tlli ~~ ~ ~ 1'f rJf. ¥I1'f.¥ ~5&,. JP ¥i~. ... ~~. r5 ~ ~G t: 'ffk.. T~ ~ 1t1lM.. ~G ~ •. '~¥fJf7K1t~~ ~. 0. " ~jl ~. -. ~. 355. rei 11'. •• ~. M~ .¥~. .'W•• **~M.U'* .~M~'*.4~. :f.~. ~~w. ~~,~. *~~~.¥~M~,~~~ •••• ·¥.mili~W~A. ~~,~~~ .:C. '. ~~Ati.~M~.. ~~~,. ••••• ~ •. -t~ o. IZffl. 57 . lHDj~~f!~HTfJi:~1fi!' l~H!' 3Z:1iX~~~, EJ~Schulze-Fielitz, Helmuth, Was macht die QualWit Offentlich-rechtlicher Forschung aus? JoR, neue Folge, Bd.50, 2002, ] -68. 5&. ~EJ~~~~~.~M.~' ,~~~~.m~~: http://www .recht.uni-jena.de/z07Ilink I.htm; http://www.jura.uni-sb.de/chinesisch; http://www.jura. uni-sb.de; http://www.uni-konstanz.de/ZElBib/Juralwww/fachzs.htm; http://www.jura-durchblick.de/Zeitschriften.htm; http://rzblxI.uni-regensburg.de/ezeit; http://www.jura-lotse.delLinksIDiverses/Zeitschriftenlindex.htm; http://www.juracafe.de/ressourcenlzeitschriftenlzeitschriften.htm.¥. ~ ~ 1: 11• • *4J!¥-ffJurisJRLexis-Nexis .~r:pwww.juris.de;fjbl~:m~S9i!~.;jSj.J!¥ ' q9:~ ....,..~'u""~~~.~W!i+-,~~~:::t11"J. , www.lexis-nexis.deJlrj1--)'~~i! ' ~iJ1fjff4fD~M mmJUi !l}fJwww.vrp.de' jH4~Y , • EJ~tlJm :1t~Jf:ff.i~ ffi5~Wffj~ EJ1:www.gbi.de, www.fiz-technik.deJRwww.fiz-karlsruhl.de (1--), 0. 1:.;jSj.~M~ct~~±mS9.~afD#~ftmmm~'~$.g) 60. tt ~OJehle-Rehml.±:Hf&ffd:teli&S9Der Bayerische Biirgermeister%ttJ.E:!. i1::fU:s:21B §.

(44) 356. jl::!Gk~~~~if!i. ~t:;+fLM. tt.*.~MW*~,. ••• ~m~~M~.~~~M~~. M~fi'.~~~M~~X~ttl~~illM~,.ttlM~R-~~. MflJ ' ~11 m~ ~~~:!t1ft. ffJC. H. Beck61 , - ~ht ttl A + ~ ~ ~ M fV ' 1'L =M-.:l!l: ~ I: ~ ~l1NJW (Neue Juristische Wochenschrift), JuS (Juristische Schulung) , RdA (Recht der Arbeit) , NStZ (Neue Zeitschrift flir. Strafrecht) " NVersZ (Neue. Zeitschrift flir. Versicherung und Recht) , GRUR (Gewerblicher Rechtsschutz und U rhebrrecht ), ZEuP ( Zeitschrift flir Europaisches Privatrecht), ZRP (Zeitschrift flir Rechtspolitik) , DNotZ (Deutsche Notar Zeitschrift) ~ , Carl Heymann. ttl M~ 62 if!. ~ MJ. 1Q. ~ ZZP (Zeitschrift flir. ZivUprozeB) , DVBf. ( Deutsches Verwaltungsblatt) , Verwaltungsarchiv ' DRiZ (Deutsche Richter Zeitung) , VSSR (Vierteljahresschrift flir Sozialrecht) ~ t ~ ~1m 4Jl ±~. 0. ¥ MfV 1£ pg ~ .::. +{t ffJ ~ ~ WJ fV '. ~ {t 5iJ :i •. J1 jj- F), ttl Mi} ~:f it !ifJ ~ ffJNomos ill M~ 63 , ttl MJ. 1'L ~ Europarecht '. ZUM (Zeitschrift flir Urheber- und Medienrecht) ,. Kritiche Justiz ' Neue Kriminalpolitik " ZAR (Zeitschrift flir Auslanderrecht und Auslanderpolitik) , VRO ( Verfassung und Recht. +£Y It ~ frij ~ )}lj ffJ Mfll fz I: B ~ ~ Jt ~ , w. ~ I: ~ i1J +JI. ffJ m~ Mohr Siebeck ill M~ # lli M-t ~ g. ~ fU. in Dbersee) ~. 0. 64 ,. 4io : AcP (Archiv flir die civilistische Praxis) , AoR (Archiv des offentlichen Rechts)' AVR ( Archiv des Volkerrechts)' JZ (Juristen Zeitung ) , RabelsZ (Rabels Zeitschrift flir ausHindisches und internationales Privatrecht), WissR( Wissenschaftsrecht), Zeitschrift. 61. 62 63 64. http://www.beck.de http://www.heymanns.com http://www.nomos.de http://www.mohr.de. ".

(45) t'£~. n+':='if:t\fJ. ,8. '~~$~WHU'fIft~1.MJ!~fU~r",'JmWllilm. fUr Evangelisches Kirchenrecht ' f§ ~ ,I1/::. W1I l!. »- J1. -tt :fI:. Jj ~ fJ. ~ ffqZGR. 0. ct ~ Jt »-;t ~. 357. ffq ~. '. ~ ~ JiiJ #}1 ffq II:1f De Gruyter ttl ~ {±65 , FJT ttl. (Zeitschrift flir Untemehmens- und Gesellschaftsrecht) ". JURA ( Juristische Ausbildung)" JR( Juristische Rundschau)" ZStW (Zeitschrift flir das gesamte Strafrechtswissenschaft) " ZSE (Zeitschift fUr Staats- und Europawissenschaften) " DZWIR (Deutsche Zeitschrift fUr Wirtschafts- und Insolvenzrecht) M~,m*fi.~. •• ~"~. /\. ~'.J1.'~.~#~Moll:1f. ~&ttl~a.~~~h~ •• MW**-~*'~~M.~*ffq. '*. *-. Verlag Recht und Wirtschaft ttl ~ r -t 4ij: iT- ~ j~ :i It{i; ffq MflJ : BB (Betriebs-Berater,)" ZHR (Zeitschrift flir das gesamte 66. Handelsrecht und Wirtschaftsrecht)" RIW ( Recht der Internationalen Wirtschaft ) " Der Steuerberater " ZvglRWiss (Zeitschrift der Vergleichende Rechtswissenschaft) " K&R (Kommunikation und Recht) " EWS (Europaisches Wirtschafts- und Steuerrecht) ; l6J it. I;t M fo.I ~ • 1~ ~ t>(., ffq RWS ttl ~;f± 67. ,. Jlu ttl ~ r i!L ~ ZBB. ( Zeitschrift flir Bankrecht und Bankwirtschaft) " ZIP (Zeitschrift flir Wirtschaftsrecht ) " ZflR ( Zeitschrift flir Immobilienrecht) ~. It Mftl ' Verlagsgruppe Handelsblatt ttl ~;f± 68 ~ ttl ~ r 1I rtlr. "M. li~.:l~.~mr1'ffqDB (Der Betrieb)' iu1Itt"'~.:l~m1/::. ~ :It{[ ffq WuW. (Wirtschaft und Wettbewerb). 0. ./t.1ik ttl ~ ~ It M. 69 ffq II :1f Deutscher Fachverlag , ~ 1[ M fo.I ~ • :l~ ~ JIJ :t tJt ffq WRP. 68. http://www.degruyter.de http://www.ruw-ruw.de http://www.rws-verlag.de http://www.vhb.de ' ~9}~l±Ut&1$1i$ttl:JfUAfP (Zeitschrift f'lir Medien und. 69. Kommunikationsrecht) http://www.dfv.de. 65 66. 67.

(46) iT&:.*$~ljiflfHB. 358. ~-t;+fL~. ( Wettbewerb in Recht und Praxis) , :& ft »] ~J- Ii 1* * " jW * ' E1. m& *. ~ If ~ Et-l -=-17tM flJ • ZAP ill~;ft 70ilfij:t ... ~ mJ ft ({tgip ,. -0 ~ft A) iE1lm * f$: ~ -r ffr • ill ~ r 1!L t& ZAP (Zeitschrift fUr die Anwaltspraxis ) , ZNotP (Zeitschrift fUr die Notarpraxis) , BRAGOReport' RENOpraxis ' Anwaltinfo Mietrechtl£ 1*1 Et-l ;\~. fU • Jehle-Rehm 71 ill ~ Et-l ZTR. (Zeitschrift fUr Tarifrecht) , UPR (Umwelt- und Planungsrecht) Ai1}.I.* " Ji1**4fB~1k:1f-;t~ o. ill ~il* $- t: t:tt± :&~t't~~Mu:>c ggDuncker & Humblot72. ,. ~~~.~Mu~*~·WAa~~~.#.,.~.~~.~Et-l. M ftl ' ~ J? :t. t: * . ill. Verwaltung , Rechttheorie. ~:.t± 0. :. Associations' Der Staat' Die. ;tt: 1tI!. ~ 11" )! f$::M fll Et-l ill ~;ft it * $- ,. 73 {[)!. ~~&~~ itkilfij lt1J ~ Mu ' ~t frl1Luchterhand ill ~~:9 ;\{i Wj flJ ~)! {t 1:1 mJ. '. ArbeitsbHitter) ~. it ~. m ;1( 1f. Strafverteidiger1M Jt II :I ~ ~& ~ fU. *'. ± ' M; J A (Juristische W tt 1:1 9;11 -t ~ 1r ' 11. l§ ~ fi ~ tJ$ k -r ffr ~ A ~. , ;tt: ~ tiS #111i. *. r~. 0. ~~ill~;ft~{[~11"'WA~~~ • • ffr'~~ill~M~M ~IJ Et-lVerlag Recht und Wirtschaft5fJ:rVerlagsgruppe Handelsblatt. tJ$k~~·{[$-a~%.~~t't~)!~'f$:~~~'~.*Mu:>C. ~~~Wj~.~tJ$.~:tt.Et-l~t't*.--r.~%1k~~~ ~t k ~ t't 11"1.:£ tIJ 4. ;1( ill ~:.t± ~ 11= - ,. ~t frn AcP , A6R ' AVR. '. ZStW" ZHR ' RabelsZ " ZBB ' Rechtstheorie~ ,. J11r m;1( if 1ll.. Et-l.~.M~1k$-~~t't~.,~~~t't~~-t{t~*~~.,. frnJZ ' JuS " JR~ , {[NJW~ ~k1tgipia.Et-lfU 4m. 70 71. 12 73. http://www.zap-verlag.de http://www.jehlc-rehm.de http://www.dunckcr-humblot.de http://www.luchtcrhand.de. '. ±~ ~. m1f.

(47) tt:~. iL+:::'ij::ft.F3. ,B. .. t~H¥]$~lHrJ~~~$~W!fUf¥JrQ~lmw/:l:t!f!. ,~~~. ~~a. ~~ AA3 (Max-Planck Institut). J,. ~ • •. ..*". ~~.o*.~.~.ffM~'. g;pJf~~'. ~. ... ~~~~.~~. .~f-. Jlh ~#t1i}f ~rJT.$It$1 ill. 'm. a. ' ~G;~Zeitschrift flir. Arbeits- und Sozialrecht ( ZIAS). 359. ausHindisches und internationales. &P ~ ~ ft. '*. .I ~ ~. 1m ~ 1itf ~. rJT ~ I~ f- ~r ~ lJ. ~ ~:t± i- ~ 1itf ~ rJT:# )a] ~. ' ffiJ mC.F.Muller ill )ltli:t± ttl ~ a J11-1\EBeck ill ~ ffJ}tl ~ ~ t' M11 Fn ftl #]GRUR {11J,..l~I~~ (GRURInt.)' ~u~i~~~1t1*.~lJ. 1tiltbi-ffJi. *. ~,~m.f-. M.,}tl*~lJ.~~1itf~*~.o.~~~~.. ~~~4~~~*i-(*~AOOft)'~i-(~~:t±OO. A)~. • i- ' • 1m ~ ttl Xi :t± Fdl' ~G;~ NJW.$It ~ ~ 1f g;p 11 ffS If: *i- ~Beck~1f' DRiZ~i~ II ~ ~ 1I:I.( Deutscher Richterbund) imBeck ttl Xi ; Schiedsamtszeitung~ A ( Bund deutscher Schiedsmanner und Schiedsfrauen) ff,J Heymann ill JtK ~~M. {«i~i~. ~rJT (Frankfurter Wertpapierborse). ( Das Deutsche Patentamt). Fn '. .a.'-~~. ffJ • • ftl #] ,. ~~. a. .$It~ru~. Fni-ftJ ' ftl ~M. mill ~ 1-1 ill ~. •• ffo~RS •• ~*. *.~ 9. !ll~Newslettedi 'l ff,J:f. W ' ~. Mff4. m. ' ZKW (Zeitschrift fur das gesamte Kreditwesen). Blatt flir Patent- , Muster- und ZeichenwesenJ!U ~i~ ~-~~. ,. ,. m~illXi. * Jl:~~rJT Jt tt ff,J. ir, ft1rl *~ liT l). tX. ' i~ il~. Mftl ff,J ff,J~MillXift,.~~ft~~~. jf-¥ ~ , o9.4 • • ~~. ff,J~fiiJo. M~ff,J.~'~~.¥ff,J~ 74. ~ff,J. ~~.. ( Bundesnotarkammer) teJ~I¥JDnotl (Deutsche Notar ) te~I¥JAnwaltsbIattttt!&~7* ' Informationsdienst) ti~mHlffim1i ( 0. m&~.~I¥JMfl~~0.~nl¥J~fite~Mte~o.

(48) 360. iI3c*$~~~. M-l:::+fLW3. ~'~$~~»x~.~'m*fl~~¥~~.~~'ill~~$ ~~~*&~o~.~.~~~»X".~.~~~~.~~M ,~mw,n'fus'~~.M~W.m~~~. it:Je ~Y- ¥1:. ~ 11 ~ ~ ~*:W1 ttl. R l!ft ill. .It* '. •• ~~,~. frl1JURA ' JA " JR ' Jj ~ ~ Zeitschrift fUr Studenten und Referendare ' ~ # -tl!. T- t- ~. ~T*'WK~++*~~~~'~w~~~~~~~ill~~lli ~,j[~iJ w.~jJp. 0. lB ~~*ti~ it Mtu ~. ~ J!J~~~1E~~.r. »:. ~~J~.~'~A~.~~~~.~~.~-K.m~'~. ~~~~lli~»:~*'~~lB~~M.~~~.~~.~.~' Jj~ • • ~~.'W1E~~~. ••• ~~tt~~.~~~,~~. M4#.'~~~~*~~*~4~,.~o~.~~~lli~' tttt~1E.~~M~.~~. ••• ~~.x,~.~~t-tt ••. ¥~,,~rr~~~~£~'~~.~~~AO*4~~'~~lli ~. •• M~'I#*M.~o~.1E~.~~»:~*(.~'ff. ~~,~~,~~,.~,,~. ••. *~,~. ••. *~~~).~. ~lliT.~~'~~T--~M~'~~~~.~_*'~ «~~". •• ~'. •• ~' •• ~·#~~".~~~'M~~.M#~. ~-~-~lli*'4~~-~ft~,X~lt-~~X~~lliN»:. •• M~~~~~.~a~,»-~w~~. ~ ~ • ~ 1t ~ ;fl Jr T- • fl- ~ ~ ill ~ ~ ~ $ ~ if ll! tIl frl1 ~~*'-~WT-. 75. 0. * ,. NJW" ZIP" BB" DB~ , -tl!.if~ll! ttl ' frI1JZ" MDR' DOV" DVBl ". 75. ~f1Efi$~OO$JR~.:f~IHBMfrJ~f§tl ' ~oNtJU~l¥JWissR ' f.I@:ftl¥JZUU (Zeitschrift fur UmweItpolitik und Umweltrecht) ,If 1l ft l¥J MedR. ( Medizinrecht) 'ilJriftl¥JMMR (MultiMedia und Recht) : ftMDlfffft l¥JSpuRt (Zeitschrift fur Sport und Recht) '~~ftl¥JZeitchrift fur Luft- und Weltraumrecht ( ZL W) , )i.~Aftl¥JZAR ( Zeitschrift fur Auslanderrecht und Auslanderpolitik) , rj~J!ii!*HJ 0.

(49) tE~. fL+.=.::q:.A~. FamRZ~. ,B. '{~H¥J$~MfU~~IlllrJ$~;WHUI¥Jf',,~Jl!!!WIH~. , f1 flJ J{U 3t11 JuS' JR ' JA ' KJB ' ZRP '. DRiZ~. 361. , :Ilif. Pft:!!f1 ftl ' 3tl1ACP' RdA ' ZHR' ZBB ' ZGR ' GRUR Int~ , :$ fll ik +jf-,* JL' ~3tl1A5R' ZStW, RabeIsZ' ZZP, Verwaltungsarchiv, 'JiU tt *X P JL t11,tt % ' ~ WissR ' ZEuP ~ , VSSR -if ill 1i itt 1t Lucius & Lucius ill M. ft1 ~ :t± ~ M fU Zeitschrift fUr. M. Rechtssoziologie ' Duncker & Humblot ill I~ ft1 Associations ' ~M#~. ~ft1~~'~r~~fl£. r~~APft1. .~. ~o. ~-if*ill-. m.. *if~~'~K*. ft1. ft1~~(. .),%~~. • • ittM~'~r~~.Rif.~.ft1~~,~~m~o. ill~M.ft1~~~~.K*4M~t11~~ .~~«~oM.~~M~. mw~~r.fg. •. ~. ,~~.~U~~~. ~~~~.'.~.~~M~~. .JL*'ffl~~~a~~. •• M~.~a~. (3tl1BGHZ ' BVerfGE' BGH LM~) ~*'ti~T- ~ , ~ 11. m. .4~Mo~~~%.~'~~.~.'*I~~*X.'~~~~ ~. ~ft1.Qor~fg~. fflj 1~ i! fU ~ if fflj. .ft~~~~,~.%~.*.. , DB, BB ' ZIP ~ Mfo.~ ~ ~ flJ if ft: 10C Yf ~ ~jt. ~o~~'~i!~~f1~.~ •• ~~~$fl.~~~~'_~. -m, ~j~ ~"$". if~ 11 jJ ft1 1~1W~. • *'. Jth Mfuif*~~ JJl1 Jt. .~fU (Sonderheft), NJWJiIJ~~if. fIJNJW-R~. Kz'. a. Jj. TIJ ~ EW * 'tiT- ~ , 4 f. ~. Mftrl illM.a*tl -m~iitn~ ~ ~. i!~~!!i!~ • • '*~~T-m~'.~.$~.~a~,~~ M~g.if • • ~'~.~Ajf-~'W#~~M~~ft1~Wo!! f1~'*~~~. M.~.~~ 16 . if~~~~%*. ~~~~~~.~~.w,. ¥~~-*. ~-ftffl~~rA.MTIJ. !It-if~f£tt!lJl:!~fHlb:fE*UtR:~~L~J1i!i1&8*~~~1N~. , ijl1:E~~5Im~~. L~~tR:8~+*~m'ffi~~~$~~tR:.~ • • *~g~, ~~JG~Jf;H~. 0.

(50) i&*t!*~~. 362. ( Archivzeitschrift) , tt j/;; 1:t.*X ~~ f~ tt fiJ 't! ~ ~ , ~:t r>g :IJ- (t] ~ ~ 't! It ~ j/;; ~H: Mftl. #J '. ~ JiiJ ,I M ~~ J! 4fU~. , ZHR~ ZBB (t] ~:t ffyt. •• J!~~-.*~%W*.ft.:t,~**. ~.ttA~.o. ~~§~~~~ti~~~:t(t]~*'~~~~ARWSXlli~-~. ;flf ~ ZWeR (Zeitschrift fUr Wettbewerbsrecht) (t] *= fU ' &P ~J- flJ ~~~:t.~DM~~~C~.~~-. m&*,~.ftlli~~. ~~'~~~~.m~~M~~'ZW~~~~~~¥m*fl.' MDR~.~. .~ • • a~~~.I~~tt.W~J! • • ~~. 1iJf :9E (t]. , *rt J! 'W. {±.. (t] ARSP (Archiv fUr Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie ) , J! l! • (t] Rechtstheorie ' J! ¥ (t] Zeitschrift fUr Rechtssoziologie ' J! it jft 1iJf :9E (t] ZRP , J!!1? ~ (t] ZNR ~ ~~. ~. (Zeitschrift fUr Neuere Rechtsgeschichte) , Jj Kritische lustiz '. ;if. ~J- ~ JlJt ~ ut -. ••. *,J J! ~ ifJ. ti ~ , 1£t it ~ MflJ X ltft ~~. ~#~~.#¥.~'Jj~~.~~(t]~~,. ~*. ~ ~. ~~.~(t].~,~W~~. ~~I~J!(t]tt.o~~& • • ~.~. ••W. lli • • ~~(t]. • ~~~. ~~~.~(t]M~'. ffl ~- ~~~1r-'ttMftl T ~j/;;.:t Ill. (t] MfU ' *rtDRiZ" ZAP" DnotZ ' X ~ ~ IIl.;f[l M J! *1 .. it jft ~ ¥ M j1 ~ ~ , W:f 1~ Jii • ~ 3~ - il (t] ~ - ~ J! 1f § jf ~ flJ #J ' .&j1 Beck lli J'& (t] KJB 4it A :t ¥ J! ft (Karlsruher luristische Bibliographie) A fU ' :t ~ , it ffl iUHR. J1- jj il 0. +. .1I. 0. ~" ,~~~i(. ~.~~E~~~~:tifJl~~.,~:t~*~.'E~M. ftl ~ 11 (t] ¥:f. a. 1£t~it~~1r-~M~'~:t~*~~~~~J1-.o~(t]M~. ~ PIlI ~*X9t. (t].iE it~:t. (Abhandlung) ~ ~ 1f l7!I .. :E. Ji (t] ~H:..

(51) ~~·B·.~~.mfl~ft~$.m~~~e~&M. :fL+=ifi\Fl. 3~. (kurze Beitrage ) , 1M W1i!.:1f {~jf:"w. ~:t (Besprechungsaufsatz) , ~ §L~. *it tltr M. (Bericht),~), ~~ l! ~iEll&. tt ~§ ,~ 1t ~ t¥ 4f ff.J. ff.J 1- fiiJ :t Jt. ~. 1% 4f. 0. MflJ +~ i::m. (Echo ' Erwiderung) , Jj. :J jfj ~ Jk .. -W (Rezension) ~!#tl:/;k: ~ ff.J *' (Anmerkung) 'll MflJ fttt-M~~+.~+ "t¥0~~.~-W *~ •• ~ ~ ~i! (Sch1usswort). ~Mg~mW~ ~~. Aft.~~.~ff.J. _~~~~.. M~ff.J. 'fJ. ~~.~~. ~. ~. Jk.~:J#it~Jt. ( Stellungnahme) , Jj ~ • ~jj, 4Jf:!~.1#~~. 'M-. •• ~. ~. 0. ¥~. ~), ¥ ~ ~ ~.ff.J. 0. ~. ~m.ili.t±. ~'.~.:1f~.~ff.Jm. *Aff.J 1f. ••. tt ;t ff.J Mfll Jltl ~. 'Mit J. (Der. ff.J WI flj 4~ Jltl.1# mr .. )jlj. .,#mJk§ffft. ~M'f1';JmnoX .ff.JW~'fJ. '~~M.~M~~~A*.'. 1i!.. ftl ~]fl. ~ t£]fl tjJI #~ ~ rlJ!z it jJ 1! ' i~ mff.J M. ~ (Stellenmarkt) ~ ~ t} ,. ( Aus- und Weiterbildung). .~*.~ ~.A. Jj .!#tl ~ '11 ' g] ll:t.. 77 . 0. ~.~. r~ ~M. ~'~~M~ff.J.M~:t.§'~.M~.~ ~~M~.. (Leitartikel). Mft*. ,jJ~~~, Jus-tk-~. k1assische juristische Text) 'f1';J I}, Q&A. *.. •• ~ • • ~'~4f. Jtll.t-, ttft.:1ft±~~ .i.g~. ,.~~,. ~~A. #~, (Dokumentation) ,. ~ •• ',. :t.oM~~. •• ~~fl. .~~M~'~~~~~ff.J~. ' . rm ~ :J. I.~~. r~~~. ~':1f*~~~.~.. :Ja.~§D.mM~.~~. ~~~~~.. ••. tf ~§ ff.J ~ - fl. ¥~.Mff.J • • ~.t¥,. t¥~D.. ~8IM~~~ff.J*~D. flJ ' ~ ~ ftl. 0. ff.J)jlj J~'. 0. ~M~W'.4. $} ~ ~), DIY. *. ~rttWHU~)(f¥Ji:Jlfflimm1m=F@tm!¥u~~. ,. ~.ff.J~4f'I. 11' ~ n 77 It~!J:f ~. *-. r 1f-1j}IDffiI~. 0. 0.

(52) 364. il!x:*:$-~~~lfU. .~~. ••. *~.&.~Wg. ••. ~W.,~~tt~fimW~~M~. ... #~'.~~.~.~»m~. ••. o. •• M~~.~~~W~.~'~~~.~~ ••• '~~ ili.~~~ • • '.~~ ~~M •• '~~.~.~'fi~~ .~~~m ~ 17)-. ~rr.~WR'.~~&~~f~~~W'.m. MflJ 1t ' 7Z it -17)-:Jt #: J! MflJ ZGR ~ • ti ~. (Impressum). ~.~rffl~*.~~.~A.£J~tt~·~~.ft.IJ!~ ¥~'~~~A~~.~.~~.%~fu~~~W.(~~ re~~)*.~.~#~.~o-ft*tt,.~~~~.~#~. -,. ~Ittjj~-&~~Jt%-~,. • • :£~,. lL~~~*JWU-' ~lt. •• *~,~-ft~~.4 ••• ~ffl~M. ~ , mJ'l ' ~:ij~)~ ~ (.1fMt~t;~~t ~l ' ~frl1 ~1!) • #M ~~.tt~*.'.~8Mo~~ •• ~¥M~~r*±~J~ ~ti~H~·#~~£*~~~ •• A'B.~.~~~ •• J! .A'»~~&~~ •• *~'J!¥~~~~~~~W'M~~ ~~.'~~~M~~~*~' •• ~~'.IA~ ~~~ M~it~~~I~. ~~M~.~~~W~~J'l°7Z~*. M~mA«~~~~'.. 1£ • • ~ if;!t i.r.1I JIf1~ ~ ~ h · tt frl1 ~J 7r II 5-i- '. I !If J! ~ tt *X ¥f ~A ~ ~~ · frl1RIW ( j{ij ~ #!*J! ), GRUR Int. (:ll-fJ! ) . ZIAS (*.I.~.J!)' VRU (~J!) . RabelsZ (tt*XJ!)' ZEuP (~~. *.. J!)*,~~~.~rJt~~«~'~~~J!~."J!~.¥~'. tt frl1 Rechtstheorie. *' RabelsZ ~. flJ 1t- ~ ~ ~. Zeitschrift fUr Rechtssoziologie ~u ~ 11 ~'WlL~~~.#¥~~~'. J! ~ ~ •. tBlJi ~ ~ •. ~ ~~. ~. ,. .$ -tt. • • • ~~fflmJ'l-.~.~. ~~mJ'l'~~.~~ffl.~.J'l'~1£~.ffl~:ij~.o. Duncker & Humblot ttl • ~ J! ~ ».:f. ~ ftl Associations ' ~!t:i-:g~ m~~. •• DOOft •• ~~~~:£., • • jj~. :i-~~'~~.

(53)

(54) i1&*$~lW8!jij. 366. m-!::::;+JLW3. ~M~'~.~.~~~G·~~ffi~~*C~~**C~~~ ~«. ·~M~~.~~*~~~~C~.~~~.o.mw. · i~ ~ MflJ. ~ flJ. ff.J ~ If if #. ~. ~~'W«~~A~'~~-~. , t: ¥. ~~~8~~' .'~w.m *~~m~ ~ .i. ft if. ~~M. '.IM~~_.. *:m ti m1\1 ' ~;t ~ 1* m~ -s ~ m _ tJ Gik:. ~. ~~. ~~~. *. •• ~.1=1~~*~~G§.~. ~~.~'A#~.~~~o.. - W. Wi flJ 0/ 1=1 :m ti ~ ~ tt 1Jtj. ~~'~r~~~. ~~M. '. ~~~. ~'~~G*~A~~~~fl~.~~. ~#.'W~~M~M~ •• ~~# • • ~G~~. 't! ~ ~. ,if M % it ~ t¥ jt 3ft1 t¥ tt ifJ f- tinm 1!f ~. .o.~~~1=1~Mm.~~UAnti~Wi~t¥~,~~~.~. ~t¥~'.~.1=1.~'W~*. -!f .. ~~. ~o. a mit: ~ 'JI flJ t~ 5JG. ~~~§~~~.~~.#. '~.#.~~'. .. .i.. ~.~*~~,~;t~.~~~~~.~;t.-~M.~.'«. .~;t'~A~~.~. ~'.i.¥. ... ~§*~M~'M~tttt~. .~%.~.~~ffl_.'~.¥~~ff.~~'W~. ~. ~.~~. '~$~*~*~~~4~. §*~M~~~. ;t'~~'M~. I~~~~A~~~.~~~. •• ¥~ til. ltJ!,o §m~_1=fg~.~M~'~.~. ~.~-*~~. ~~1=1~,~+a'~.~-~.*I.~ti. *' *~~*,J-=-+~{t81 81. ;;-t;-}'" tl<1 -,'". =.-r. • • ~M~§.'~~. 0. ~~~~1J11=fA.~~~:ittltMfIJ : (1 )~fi ':::~.L-JI. §. ff:J. Q. ~~~#c;t;n,G;ll"lafoli::l""'=.

(55) JL+=-~7\,Ej. t:£~. ,t!8'Jl'.t~WHU7@"ftlill'.t~Mfll8'Jro'W!!!Md:ln. ,B. *. j~ 4- I;L ~. Ji if,] r 1f &~.'ti Mttl J. #t 1i)f 1E It 4r'. *Jt :ff. 367. ~:J- r ~. J;t0¥i" JSJc0¥i" i!tft-i~0* " ~x.~~jf ~ (2)1;L ft**¥i ~~ '~'61~~~"~3~~" M~ •• g" •• ~.~g". ~: (lH:J-i!Jlif,]0;ffi"~1t~~.~JLM~.i.4r' ~T1'61. :iL. 0. ~.ft~~m"~#_~.m,,~~_~.~,,.a_~. ~_i!ft. .A~". ~M. ~~. 4f '. ~11 ~. 0. i!. £*A~"*3#~".. (3)~_t~l~~. • tt. if,]i!~.~'. 0. (S)~Jf. .if,]M.~. if,]i!_~.~*.'_. 1t. ~". ". , ~l1fi3i!+ (4)~ Jti!_ ~4r ' ~11 m1-ti!1f it~ 0. 0. -ft~.*W'~*~~.I.. 1f.~~1Eif,]. .~~,~*. *~~. 0. - " ~Jt~ f~1r .~ftM~*§.if,]iliMAA~·~*#ltfi4rif,]~.~~.. : (1).~lliMif,]Mtu "(2)• • " ta.~0.if,]tU#J "(3)lli M~0 '61lt rr if,] t- ~ MfU " (4)~ H1:fi~ r~ ill Mif,] flJ #J " I;L R(S) #~ ft(~~1E •• "£~.)if,]M~ol;Lrif,].~.i.¥~ illM ~A~~'~M~if,]*ft"lliM~~~ "•• ~~ *~. .~fl;L.. tt~'.l;Lti§.~~~.M~if,]~.:ff~~~. if,]Il!Mo ~MfU §.§.~*.mltrrif,]i! 1. ~*it;.~. (~.* ~fll. (9=t if.. , lOIM"tt2 '. 1. 2. 9=t iE it;. *. 0. M~M:ff+~.'.~~r:. i!1f.~'. ft. ~,. 11 A flJ) til).

(56) 368. 3.. il&*~~~~. ~1::;+:hJtJj. i. #J ~4 ft ~ Edt ~ :9E lj:ffi ( • '" *-!f: 5!. 0/ I\..' , *f1j ). ~ ~1~ ft ~ 5! {f: 1iff :9E. *. i!& *- 5! !f: ~"Mu (i!& k *- 5! f.f !f: ~ , fll ) 5. tf )JM~!5!!f: (tf)J !f:M#!5--idt!f:~' -¥- flJ) 6. Ii't *- 5! ( Ii't JfJ *- 5! :f:t !f: 1iff fJT' -¥- if flJ ) 7. 5! 1i !f: *-!f: 5! f.f !f: ~ '-¥ ftl) 8. *m1:: 5!!f: (~1:: *-!f: 5! f.f!f: ~ , -¥- if f 1l ) 9. .:it *- !f: 5--1; !f: "Mu ( .:it *- 5! f:t !f: ~ '-¥- flJ) 1O. • ~ ~ tf. 5! !f: ~ (~Jif- *-!f: ~ 5if- 5! f.f 1:lf :9E fJT '-¥11. ~ ~ *-!f: 5! !f:1iff:9E (~~ *-!f: 5! f.f !f: ~, ftl ) 12. • p.cj ff (:st it *-!f: 5! f.f !f: ~ , if fU ) 13.!f 5!!f:"Mu~ (tf:#C!f~*-!f:5!1f!f:~' f'J) 4.. *. *( *. ~~~~*-!f:5!1f!f:~ili~~5!. ~.tf'~r. ftl). p.cj5!ff'. ~~fitt~5!f.f1iff:9E.g*'*-~~#~#J~~~~~~.~' ~f&~,tt~~.~#J~~~%.. ~~~~o. ~~£~*-!f:5!f:t~~~ • • ~~#J'. *-~~.. ~~~~~~~. ~~~~~ •• ~.. ~o~~"~~~. •••. ,~£. ~.o~rfii!&*$~.~*'!f:~.~. • • • ~flJt 1fifi:f ~ , ill ~~:P f{l1IJ:9r ~. • • ~ • • ~mli't. ' ~11 rtf mM~!5!!f: J '. !f:~~~.~.$,~~r~*-5!!f: •• J~ri!&*-. !f:. .J'# •• ~~~.*~~~~1iff:9E~~ff~.:sttt •• ~, N*~. •• A~~o~~~~. ~.~.. iJltt~q1f'ti, Jt~f~4~wHt, ~. ~~~, .M~. I~~~.'fl~"Mu £"Mu:st~~~~~. ~~ft'.~~.'ill1ffili't~~M'~*.~o ~#J~ •• ~*-~£~~~~~mli't'ill.#*~. ~~~~~~~~,. ~~~#J.ffl~ • • ~~'~~.ili. ••. ~M~~o~r!f:.'~~A*-*~'~~~~1f.A±~~.

(57)

(58) 370. il&*$~~HifB. .tJl5J'%~. ~H:::+fL~. 3ft.~~ilfo. ~M~M*.~.~~.w~~£mo.~_.~~r~m. M.~~J'~~~~.~M~'~~.I~ft~~~~~#~§. 1t, 3ft. ~f¥~fiL~515( it. ~515 ' ~hl.: http://cycu.lawbank.com.tw)' *~~~~.~M~m~~~. ~~. ~~. ~~.~~. 515 If Jl~ jt~ , r ~ ~ f4:ft ~~1t1j1fJE 1i tR J 1F *~ f~ rAJ $}:I~ Jf J: ( if # ~ 516 ' ~:hl: : http://biolaw.law.ntu.edu.twl) ~ fiJ 0. 0. ~. ~.ti. .~. #~~. ~nm~m1t~*~. -. m~~~o. ~M~~'**~*~~*~'".. *~R~~*~~1t~'~Rx1i*~#:ft~1t1j1fJEm.~~1t* ~f'J~~~t.. 0. 1:~*~~~~A,iffLfl*tlL~.-M rNational. Taiwan University Law ReviewJ' ::Jlt-*1r~~5Z.'. *. ~~~. ~M~'-if~M'. ~_~1F*§1t~ • • A. ~RIf. .if~fl'fLfl§1t°~*. ~1r~~~~M~'~.~. ~£mo. C=)1± II ;WI f'J I:~~. •. ~m~1t~~. M~.~. ftM~m~~ • • ~I~~~'. ~*m~~~~'~.. •. •. ~.~ftM~'. 4~~.~. -~.~. 1J.*~.'MW~§nA±~~~~. •• ,~~mili.~M~3ft.~.%'~~: 1.1fF&lF&l~~~F&l~*~if~(1f. 2. it~~~.~li (it~ 3. ~ ~~ .R ¥f JE (If 4. ~ ~ 5.. if ~. 6. ~. *. F&l ~ ~tl Jt ~.. ( If ~ ~ ~~, (If ~ ~ if ~ • ~,. (. F&l~~~~'1f~). 1ff']) ' 1f f'J ). ~.,. 1~. • • • tt. •. -g.~,. flJ ) ftl ). #1ffIJ).