日本自民黨的候選人選拔制度及政黨凝聚力

全文

(1)*. -.

(2) A./FJEtfilA;Zf9tltii :. ** '. ~J\.:iM~ , .. :iM3/f(; ( § ~ ;(\) 76,254} ( § ~ ;(\) 70,866 #:iM ( ft:. ;(\) 46,208 ( -0 aJl ;(\) 45,209 (U ;(\) 16,476. i'1i!'i1IliPl ~L1Jn*. 1l;.rmm. r:pJrlJ;. 1ti:JW:ffi~. 254,833. ( § ( §. B JII 1m. ~ ~. ~ .Il; f~ /F§h~~~. O± It. ~. ( §. EI3. frit. ~JW1ii2~~ AI=t. .". .). m. 251,219. C.j/j1t~i'i Z f9tJtii. H s.. ~. ( ell:. .) 67,549} . ) 65,434 #:iM . ) 57,261 ;(\) 53,886 7,089. : }(J't '. ~-:iM~ , ~:iM4/f(;. (§ ~:ln 104,522]' ( § ~ . ) 86,255. Jj. )j5J EI3 !Ilf f~, )( m9,f~~~. (§~.). /f'rll&Z.IliJ. ) ( *± .• ) (~. *±. H L1J fir rP *_-0&t. O±lt.). ~EI3r.t. (. .). 72,093 70,206 69,466 65,081 11.450. 'ilt:iM. 479,073. ftt-l-*M, : Bernard. Grofman and Arend Lijphart, Electoral Laws and Their Political Consequences (New York: Agathon Press, Inc., 1986), p. 160. [ij{tltlft*1-*M, : Wi 13lf.& ( M E ~/:!I'IU ' 1981 ) , pp. 236~239.. ** :. ~*~~~.r:p~.IliJ~.~A •• 1l;.~~.*.Ai'i.~)( •• E)(,~•• r:p)(·.

(3) r. fiI.. ~ T ~.§ tt. ~ "'F. '$. 1:£. 1i:ar jf!L :ft;J /\. ~, ~. ;tt ft. (!Y'. .~~·O~ Jb A ~. :m we. * :t£. 4!; 'it JE. ' •. A ~ ~ M /J\ ••• * •• tIS jf!L iiilJ ~ 1E! I;. 0 fk. ~ jI] ~ ft~~A~ft fr~ fJ 0. ~E~*JE.~*~4!;~*'§m~:m&~*.~'it~~~:t£ D.:m '~I;~~~nJE.~~r4!;W~I;'~~ft~+:m. • ' 4!; ft tr" ~ jTrj - ~ , • ~ I; * • ~ ill fi~ ~ ~ .. r~ * 1# ~ 4!; F..' &:m.~jf!L~~~li.'~~~~~;tt* • • ~.I; • • ~~ B4!;~;g JE." WrAf!!.fl}A~.ft!!~H~1E ~~.'it. J! .~~ili~:mjf!L • • ~~.~.~jf!L.' • • *~~m~~= ~~F§ft4!;~~I~.~:mffio~~~~.I;.~~:m~ o • • ~~.:m:mSR.~4!;'~ • • fk..~~ • • • 4!;~. 1fF. 1fF. q~ 4!; 4!; 4:>: = ~ ~ ft jt 'ft ~ jf!L ~. ~~ * - • iiilJ 31 J1! ~ ~ :t£ * ~ 1~ ~J m: • "/!c = A fr~ IDr ' A ~ ~ ~ H~ ~ T ~ IItfr t!; ~ .*JE..-;~M*-~~'~~mili:m~we.~'.:~ § 110 mt 1"' ~iir fZsl ~ * ~ A :ft;J ~ ~ ~ * J!!l ~ 4!; m! ' ~ _ m ~ :t£ IJ\ ~ ;'f I't'~ :m ;;; :# lit Wr ~ & n' fiI. A fK ~'{51! ~ ~ • ill ~ A. ' Wl ~~4!;;~§~~ft.fZslo:ft;J~~"1E!~~*-MfZsl' m ~~~~§~~.I;'~:t£~§ ~*I;~:t£~~~~~~~ 4!;~ft~~.*~'~~B!~ ~.~ • • ~ • • !fZsl~ • ~~.:t£.~~~~.~1; • • ~:m~m!~~'ft~.¥ • • ~~m.~-*.~ffi'~ ~4!;A4!;~~~~~'~ 6 0. *'•. 'M.£.4!;~~.mM'~~ ft.~ ~.~tIS.-~§.-. ~-~!"'F~~~R~'~A(!y ~*~. ~1;'~. ~~fZsl~.o~.~~. •••. ~4!;:t£*~~.. ~4!;~.~;tt._.R~~ ~mtK'it'ft~~~~:m.. ~~.~~.A~~4!;. ~~.A~~'~-. ar. $~'.~JE.m~~~~. .a~~4!;~~d c.~~~*m: • • ~~oA. ~.*'.§a A • • Tn ili~A*~~.~1E!'. § ~.1*."'Ffm '{Jtfl~ ·0 - , 1~I;Af.II.ljf!L{,*mr& ~ it!! 'ft • ,~ JlU' f A Q. ~ ~ • • ~ ~ R<J ~ ~ 2. l1=l ~ • .f±.1H~.~jJU'M(.J*!~ ( 1958~1990~ ) 0. A ~.. a Wl. 1979.10. 7 1980. 6.22 1983.12.18 1986. 7. 6 1990. 2.18. *. IffiililAlt B. 1958. 5.22 1960.11.20 1963.11.21 1967. 1.29 1969.12.27 1972.12.10 1976.12. 5 i. m m. 467 467 467 486 486 491 511 511 511 511 512 512. C. ~. 413 399 359 342 328 339 320 322 310 339 322 338. w~*~:~a~~·~a~.·. L. D.. E.. F.. 69.49 74.18 78.83 80.99 87.80 79.94 80.31 78.57 91.61 73.74 94.40 81.36. 88.43 R5.44 76.87 70.37 67.49 69.04 62.62 63.01 60.67 66.34 62.89 66.02. G. ;it ~ililAlt~~A ~;gAlt~~A El ~iI;1~ ~;gAlt ~ililAlt ltz. ttf9tlDjC % ltz. tt{9IJCjB % ~*% §. ;it §. ~. 287 296 283 277 288 271 257 253 284 250 304 275. !. 57.8 57.6 54.7 48.8 47.6 46.8 41.8 44.6 47.9 45.8 49.4 46.2. •• ~.·~a~.,*Mo*~~~~~~*~~~W~o. I. 1m. 1m. i.

(4) ,..,..,. 0. .. ~~ ~. 0. ~~~~~~~. 1II-P< "oya. ~_~~ ~ ~~\!!!I!:l. client relationship ~. ~\!!!I!:l~~ ~ ~1<1!I~~ • • ~i!r~ '~*,~~tr~~~~.~~~ii\. r ~.~~ J (patron. ".. ~~\!!!,~ ~ ~~~~1f£~~~. .~~~~~~~~~ l~~~~~~~~l~~~~~~~~~~~~~€~~~~~~.~o~~~~~~~~~~~. ~~.~~~~*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o ~'nH\!llll~~_~~~~~~11~:t\jH!~~:ttl~~~~~.-K:)ll:iH~~~~. 0. ~~~~~~~m~~~~~~~.~~~~m~~~~~~~~~~~~~o@~l~~.$:g;:t!~tr~~~~. kobun ~ ~~-it~). ~*.Lj ~ ~~~.~~~N~~~~~ 11!:l:[email protected]~~~. .~~~Nl:l!::g;~i¢~~~~~~~ ".~~ ~ ~~~~~\!!!I!:l~i¢~~~~~.~~~.~~~~~. bun ~~N. ~m~N~~.~~~~Nl:l!:~~~~~,¥~.~.~*~~~~m~~~~~~o~~m~:t!~~~~~~~~m~N ~~.tr~~~.~~~m.~N~:g;. 1*"~~.~~~ ~. .~~~m.~N~~~~ ~ .:~~~~m~~+t1 ~. ••~~~.~Q.:g;~~o~~O~~~~~~~~~~~m.~N~~.~. l:l!:.$~~~'~~~~~N~~¥~.~~~~~~~~m~~~:ttl~~~.~~:g;~~o. ~~~~~ ~ @f$~~O.\l:t-~tr~~~ ~ m~4W. 0. 1n,IJJI!:l~~m~:g;I$!~><~111~~~ ~. '~~~.-K:~~~~~~~~-K:~~~~~~~~~. ~m.~~~m~~llf~~~.-K:\lIlIll~lfI:-R{~~i!r ~ ~~~~~~~~. ~~~~1F o@~\!!!:gll~~~~~~~tL-·· ~~~.~~~~~.~~~~.~ '$1~~~~~~fm~~~!.~ ~ :I$1~.~ilit~. oIlK 1~l§ ~. ~~~~.~~~.~~~~~N~~~.~e~~~~~1~o~1. ~~~#~~~~(~~tL-~)~~m~~~~~~-K:~~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~.~~~~~~~I$!~.~o. ... 0. .11'1II*~~.*~~~.~~~.~.~ •••~.~~.~.*,&.~~••*~.~~~.~.~*~~~~~~ ' ••~.~.~~~IlK~.::tl tl!Rl11 '1II*~ 1~~J.R~~~r--.~$.~J;tj ~ ~~~~.~~.~~ .~~.~~.1~.. ~~~$1~.~~.~~.~~.~. ~~~~~.~~.~~~.i!r~. ••• ~:g;~~~&o.~~~~:g;€. i<JJl-.w;~~ ~ .~~~~~~~J;;:laIl\~~~~~ ~ ~\!!!~~*!;k~~~r--.~~.~~~.-R ~ ~~~~~tr~$~~:g;.~ ~ laIl\~~. ... ~. ~. 5l\-R. ~lI19!i~~:lllKllil!1'itf;lllli);:;:,~ Leon Epstein, Political Parties in the American Mode (Madison, Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin Press, 1986), pp. 134 -144. ~lI19!i~~~~lli!~5il!itHiI();:;:'~ James C. Scott, "Patron ... Client Politics and Political Change in Southeast Asia," American Political Science Review, Vol. 66, No.1, March 1972, pp. 91-113. i!!lll19!i~lIl!::~5il!~~~::1!!);:;:,~ Arthur J. Lerman, "National Elite and Local Politician in Taiwan," American Political Science Review, Vol. 71, No.4, December 1977, pp. 1406-1422. James C. Scott, "Corruption, Machine Politics, and Political Change," American Political Science Review, Vol. 63, No.4, December 1969, p. 1146. :!t:l@) Nathaniel B. Thayer, How the Conservatives Rule Japan (Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1969), pp. 39-42.. Gerald L. Curtis, op. cit., p. 82----84,. m*~~.~~~~~~~~~~.~~B.

(5)

(6) - -. '\.

(7) Jt, fiB --. !J~a}.1}. ~ Ij', ~. o::;$:~. ~ 0 -::;$ ~p. ;;.;;~. .~. ~ ~. .. *. ~. ~. '<. .Q,. $. , ?t =t ?t. :!(. :IF JI 'If Ie. ~:. ' J!. iii] lk !~JJ JiJf t!t r! II ~. * UJt. ~ jji. ;g. 1~ {J!. Jt. JD. Ii:. ~. 1t IY-J i j if tI L n:=tfFJlo¥fi:. -WUr!. *r!. 'L' ""' ~ 1~ ~ ~J ~ ¥t!t~. '~J;. ""'. mi~*. fT5fI1r!. •••••. ~• • ~~.. r•••••. 11 !t!m:. ti. ~t. ;I;. z. ~ +1Xpq~?t}l. (19 {:; tic • IY-J. ~IY-J. ~~. 1!ttfo~it~. lkw:. L1tt. Jr.::f ""'1E:.""'. '-' f9~. o it. Ii ,~.~r. **. ~*. N'$~tf1f-~. 1!!*m1-"~' tI fa if ' J£ pq. (J<J -:fE ~ ~.I¥J~.flitlJ1f Ill?(. fiI. •••••. A. ' 00. ~. J*m~- • • • • • • ~ • • • •. jm.-•••••• ~ •• *. RW. JiJf. JJ: i& , (J<] ~ 1fwrit. i!if(. IY-J. •. 1lt~. ~m. IY-J. 1X ~. Jt tJ 0. A $. IY-J. m~1it~~$:. 2 3 4 5. ~.*~. 6~~L. : Masaru Khono," Rational Foundations for the Organization of the Liberal Democratic Party in Japan,. If. ~. T. 0. • • • • • ~.... JUHI~w{. ifiIJ. 1f~1E:.1f-*.:::1ffi1f-itfffj ?t1r~it!fa'-' 0 it~ fti + 1m IY-J f:)z ~ '.16' J£ ~!. f!;J Jllj. * 3.. ~ m ~ 1%. JG? f:)z m: .::f ~ IY-JIY-J Jt?t W Ie :I: JJf: f' ~. ~J£(19. jji3l(1Y-J ~. *. itJft!t!. L-1!If~. r,,~. 15:®( 1J!. J; \I IY-J 81 fI '¥. IY-JpqliJAJGJr A 00 IY-J It £.t IY-J :ff a RW !jJ 1C' • til IiJt! 3t 1iJ~ tf, it '.16' ~. ~=t(19. I:SI'-'¥. Jt. ~.R. ff ' J; --, ~ ;I; M lk pq ~'lf1lM ~ i!if( :Ii. 1f. -=. it. .::f, ~IiJA~litA/\WN7t ""' ~ B IY-J /\ J; 1-" 0 1£ Jt 111' 'Hi: :«Il a jji 1f- IY-J ' 1f- S :ttl!. JB 1C {iiIil.!'i+M1f!tJf;]-Ul' ~ r! ?t ft J:j ~ ~ ~ JL IY-J Jllj *JG :ff,.UJt'{:;IJJt1f JiJfnJ5. r!1t~~. ti~. f:)z IY-J ll.::fr!. '7t~1i. 0. --ffijit~. 0. ;. UlIli]Ul;i&Jt~~JtJtitXJm. ~ iii]. ,mt,. 0. 'i'iJ ~. 1ft:.. {iiI 11 .::f • ~ ~ J; : , 31 ?t IY-J , pq:l: ti pq 1$:fir JG !fa 1f! 00 ii JB :ttl!. If{ nJ5 Ul ~ ""' !'i {i f:)z ~ ~ lfr1.:lFJf@A-·?~1f-'1Y-J 1fl1tl1. 11F 'i'iJ ;f J; ffi!:. Je. 0. ifiIJ ~. ll' 1t ll.X;. ~ ~ {i Hl 1f;;; 11: ~ 1f- 1::; , *.Jl'i!t 31( J:j ?t :ff ~ , ~J. m .:1J I.~3f-$~JlJ3f-. .''' .". It 1lt - JB 1~ f9tl ~ m: ;jgt IY-J ~ ~ ~r 1M 11M ;f ?J(IY-J :ff 1f- JJ: It ' 'Of @ ;f it ~ 1£ 1lt ?J( ifiIJ -F :«Il ~ '*5 1!i '$ 1-" ~. ltlY-J.'!2o{:;~~IY-J1ft:.~1IM~~jji:R. IY-J !t! ~u @ .::: :«Il I. 191J ~ ~ jji :fE ~i ~ m. .::fr!lV,~*it--, ?t :«Il ~ lll(; IY-J .p fl. ~. 0. ¥w:aA-r~1illl;f1.*:l:OO~ J!. fi~. :«Il fiB r! ~ , :fE 4i f:)z. 00 f J1.i f!;J 1!If *@ if ~ *h Wl Ii Ii1'J l% ~ pq .::: ' 1iJt; 1ft:.. A.::fil.j(Jt'. r!lfr1.A~EB'1Y-J. J,. Q...,. ~. if ' * pq ~ 00. 1t IY-J ~ $ !fa mt X IY-J jji '-' ~ 1:)z. "..., 1:..,00 .§. ~. ±.. ~.". ~. 00. ,. m'. or!ll'-'it~.. ~ ~ ..0;" ~ ~. ifiIJ. ~:ffflMit$pq mi ifiIJ ¥fi L- IY-J ~. '? ~ ~ '» n r:l ("') f:: J, :l. ~.. ..., 1'". ~ i!if(. *=. (f}. ~. r!'-'mJ;ijIj'lf, *fi-=.IY-J1iJ;J;. c i' t'" c. i'. IY-J tI. , ~ r!I.~¥fi±-='. ~Q:C'J~ =" t'oo. ~ ::T'. .0"tl. ~. 'If --,. World Politics, Vol. 44, No.3, April 1992, p. 374.. * • • ~~~AB~ • • ~m.~~•• ~-~¥mo. [l!l. J\.

(8) EEIlE~$!)~*~~. .. ~.t;;::~{nnt§:~~$!)~ ~ ~~ ~ 111~. ~!g}Itl-<jBlIf.{.~~~;ge~Ii1!~~eI-~~~.t;;:: ~ .mm:-mr~~~~ll!i~.t.t;;::. ~ ~.~~~-R~. ~~\l:l:i ~ rII*~<--1:j:\(~~;ge~~I!I!1~~ne:. 0. ~~~~~~~@~~~l~~«*~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~~.o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. 0. 111~~~~~~{nn~12!~. , +«~~,. ~-mr~.fJJ*~('-,. 1~.111~ ~. .. ~. D(i1~.\ftI.~~. 111~i!loi~4a~~ ~ ~ae~~;ge. ~.\ftI.~:/!m~:W-m-mr~.~Mmm:-33~ ~ .$1m1l-<~!g}~11Mmm:m)!1f~~ll{~('-,~.\ftI.t.t;;::~{nnt§:.~~~. 1~$!)~.E~~~t§:~.~*~.I!1!1~~.~.~~ •• -R~-mr~.~ ••~~.~.~~~ • • ~~ • • ~. 0. ~~~\iH.~~~~\WItl;ge~~~-<jBllH~~. mIl-<ae~~~~:i!t°. 0. ~~~E~~~.~1!I!1 $!)~o ~~j;Ig!!:. ~1~~~.~.g:~. ~~~~.o~!g}.~~~~~mIl-<-mr~.~+<~~~~~~~~~~~j;Ig~~~~~~~~~-mr~.~~~~~:i!t~~t§:.~. ~.~~-R~+<~~~~~*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~!g}IlEItl~~~~$!)~~~Mmm:~~.~~~-R. 0. .*~~~.~~••mm:~U.~~~~t§:~~~~.j;Ig~Ii1!~~~-R~~~~~~.~(.~~~.«~~.~~~~~. ~.~~.~~Jf'<~) ~~~{J;:~{nnt§:~~~1~~ .~~~-mr~.~~~1~~D(~~:i!t~$. ~mIl-<MIlE.$!)~~~~~~~rII*~:j:\(~~;ge~~ •••~o:/!m~~.~~~~t§:.mIl-<*~~~~.~.~~.$1m1l-<~.. -RfJJi!~*~~-mr~.~~l~~.(rII~~~u)~Mmm:fJJ~~.~.~~-R~~~~t§:~.o-mr~.Mmm:~~:j:\(~~ .. .. ~1!I!1~~~~rII~~.o~M~~~-mr~ • .g:~~~~~~~~-33~~o~~~rII*~#.~~~~~~~~~rII~~~~ ~ It¢~~-mr~.~Ztl-j$~ ~ ~.~4a~~D(mIl-<+«~~ ~. 0. -mr~ •• .g:~~-i!f=~~I!1!1~~~~~. .~];!;g('-,;lt*'~~~#.~~ ~ -mr~ • .g:.\ftI-33.('-,~~~~ , ~~ , r F§~~~~~IFZ'\+1~ J ~. #.~~~~~ ~ ~~;ge~~~~~lBI~~IlH1~IFZ~~~~. 0. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~(m)!1f~.~.~~~~~~~~t§:~~,~~~.,-mr~ • •mm:).*~i!~F§~~~~~i! loi~~ o~. ~WJ~lI~~~,*~~~~ ~ ~~)j~~~~• • m~1t- ~ ~.~~~~m*~ ~ ~~~.*~ ~ .mm:~N~~~j;lgi!!liiH~~-R ~. v,i, ... ~,.""":,,,_."--, . ..........,.~~_~~.. Henry Hamburger, Games as Models of Social Phenomena (New York: W. H. Freeman, 1979), pp. 213-215. ~ l'iE:~ Chalmers Johnson, MITI and the Japanese Miracle (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1982). ~ l'iE:~ Thayer, op. cit., pp. 207-267; Chitoshi Yanaga, Big Business in Japanese Politics (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1968). :!;\j~ Michio Muramatsu and Ellis S. Krauss, "Bureaucrats and Politicians in Policymaking: The Case of Japan," American Political Science Review, Vol. 78, No.1, March 1984, pp. 126 -146. Michio Muramatsu and Ellis S. Krauss, "The Conservative Policy Line and the Development of Patterned Pluralism," in The Political Economy of Japan, Vol. I, eds. Kozo Yamamura and Yasukichi Yasuba (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1987), pp. 516-554. ~. m*m~_~~~~~~~~~~_~.~. ..,......1IMI!rIIIS'!:'Q'.,,~,.

(9)

(10)

(11) ~.~$~. ~~~. ~~~. ••. hlS~~~~Il:?J:~.~~iiit~lF~ 1l:?J:.~ • • ,~j;~~~~.,. ~~~~~~. \-Rl. • • ~~~~.~~:g;j;~~M~~~~*. 0. I l!!B~ • • ~*:g;~~~ffil( ~ ~~:il1~~~~ll!K~ ..:!;t~ • •~~~~j; l$'l!!B~l!ll(~. o~~.~~iiit~:g;~~.~~~:g;~.,. ... , IlI~HI!:g;*~~.~~). *. "1l:?J:~~\!!1 .. :g;ll:?J:m?HltJ~.~. ~~~~~. ~o~~~~~~~e:g;.~~iiit~~ • • • ~~~.~~.~~~~~ • • j;~~:g;~~~~._.~~:g;.~(~~~. 0. *. in$!111H1H1.:g;-<.t1~*' ~ ij#~~HI! • • • ~if~~~. ~ , ~~~:g;~~~ii1~• •JlH!ll€ • • ) .~~~~ ~ ~~ , 1lI*-K:~j;:g;.~~~~• • ~~.J!t1W.~ ~. (. • • j;~-~.~.:g;~.-R. .~~~-Hl.~.:g;~.-R······ .... j;~. ~~-K~~. ~#. 1 l!!BHI!~~"1nI{HI.~.:!£i~.-R ~ !J(~~.~~iiit**'. *. 1!\!11~lIi:ij$~~ WilIi8Dl H. Riker, Liberalism against Populism (San Francisco: W. H. Freeman, 1983};George Tsebelis, Nested Games: Rational Choice in CompfJratiue Politics (Berkeley, Calif.: Univer:sity of California Press, 1990).. ~. _. eril;t. 5t! d. ',ti'.

(12)