臺灣土地改革再審視：一個「內因說」的嘗試

(1)

Ith:

l ID

f sanitation and )etween various

cal theories and lonstrating how

the thoughts of apanese practi

nial rule, this )\-vnward or a t , the changing the differences cies - as well model to the :ation, Ie author still 'atory Office, ":1 ~~1t) t A-t-¥ - JW ' 1i 89-124 ~"-IL-tlf-*JI (-IL-t-lf--tJl t:!:!I&.) 4' 9t 'lt 1tt:;t.i:iIIf >.t.Glf~ffl~-ft.ot

• ill

±!tI!

ek

¥N.ijI

-

--11

r

~

00 ~J ~.~

*

1 ~i:!t~

"

If~

JT

rl

* *

~~

~

-it#-

:f

~±!~~t.-'F-1fj A-z~ ~ , -:AL V'-J.

r

5'~

[!Sj

$l,

j

Ji]

M-ff

a{].i.-l-l.'l,}J , j(o j~

~~~~_~~.i.. ·a~~.M~~~~o~~.i.~~~.~~a-zt· ~~~

.~ r~~«j M~~~~~·~~~~4~~&$k~~L#~~~ffl.~~~

-z

r

liJj-)4{ ~~~t

*-

'

.:it {rut± ~ ~t. $-t¥J

;i±1t

ttl ilV 3 ~~~

#-

t Ah±

tt

I\\' ~5]' 11::. '

a

~~4 ~._~~M* o ~#-.~a£~.~.±~ r±~~l.'lJ~~• • '~~

1~1r,#~.tt -.f ' aft ~ ~:t .iltlit ;r-~-lf ;r-~*-1t ± .l~ et$.ilt jjt 0 ~~foJj-~ifLMJ± ~~t$ .ilt7R t%

r

'::'--1:: 1i.Aotlij

a

r

/t:-J~.:htI;JiJ ,.:it;r-t~i>

r

4J1-** $,-

oo J .ilt ¥., iU~ft-JJL

r

.::.--1:: 1i. A:fliJ 113?~ ~i!m

#-

r

5'~ I!l :6U {)lJ M-~

; {

'2~

r

~~.:htl;J1 J )'l'J;r-;).\. 'E ~~E: ~~.~~#-r~[!Sj~j ~.~u ~~~~~~.~~~.D ·~~~.#-±~& $-.

fit

~'"Jt Jt ~

fiE.

~~i\n tfi11::. ' ~,jJi ~J'lt$,-'l.1'-Ilt'l

*

~.ff ' it~f-~

fiE.

~t.~~&; ffi7 ~!Jt J1!~9lJ~tk. ; j15'~ }l'J)t.J.-J.ii~jiJ±~~t-'f9lJAJO.h' ,Tr)~:f1f~~€!ry rf§l ~J!l1;i] (state theory)

J

~

fiE.

~~i!J.t9lJ no A ~Fn1

;i±1ti

it-t

t¥]

un

{.;J • _;t:t 60 J.'l H:.&. ~E..h

-Jt

~'1Jl~it

E

#-

JH: k 9lJ#b'!

'f

*

tH~ , ,7ij;r-~u~iL ~

*

0

H~mii i1] : ±J~~t.$ , '::'--1::1i. A >fli ' /t:-~.:ht~ , fJl{ro-;Ji'l..1. ' :iit/t:-&]

*

11: ~ ;j~ ~l.U4t/.£l' :t.t f-1f )d~-f .$.;t..j.t ~*f' -1t liH; JL.&. {!Iff 6l} SJt It::ff (.,1 -#-JlI:.

a

:

*

0

(2)

90 :::~Jt;Jf-~. ~A4~-J!Jl

-

"

FI:I~~~illt&WF~JJ~ = , ~rrrrrt'!~

-=

'

If-thl

f.I3.

iffi

TriiJ

It

II:!£:

K~

FI3 Z

~ill1

[9 ,

-=

-I:;

.li

7~m

.li

'

0tt!I1i~~

/"'\

'

*5gffij

~

,

rR'fljM!~&~~1ii£

j;)

Q

1 Jt

151 if$t

±tili25CiJZ

PfT j;)

fig~JI&iflj jGRX;l¥J~32tt

'

~~M151:9H±1J:fITz~ ~. o~~m

r

:9}~~J) , {9lJtm±tilia$(~zmJj]]J~~151i&:J&nmi&:zlE1it

;

(1) ~±:t1!!

~.~m~*~J~*~151~~*~ , .m.*~~±~MW~~.'~~tt.~

5!t:fJi

'Ul

flj

f.iti¥

J

it*'

*

;

QX;±tfu~1f£i&:mznt!ilJ~~ ~Z3Z:~~jifJjF~'1~~~WI¥JIUJ 1*~ 0 lZ) !MH'~f&~HijHilltzcp

, tp.~~$;&

JJrtilf~M~~Z/f0ZP:fil11Ei'*1tf

'

:&1ffi~ *;Zj;)*~¥Uj:i!Et~U1i1U~1'~~

,

i.§.;I~iHtt151~~~*lBI¥J~tti}~

,

~n%=WUt"Ji,*itf:

'

iJ;j,

f~*~.:y~55UI¥J:m®i

'

It~~~z~M:mtflj7q${,@g\(;±j:ili29:1f£il&m:Mliffa"J~~i

c~m rj7q~~J) 0 *x~llt~~1iH~*1l*JJW3 ' ~.~f1CPtili~ ('§~i&:J@Z~ ~~~) W{ffil!:~j::~IUH*¥UJ~m1i:iJ ? 1ffi§l1:EThJJtt1H~akJi&:m~*~~5tR~zT

'

X~~~l¥Jti.*~~~.?ffim~@ , *xl¥J~N,]J~_.~ti~~~ r~

~IDtJ z~m:tJHefflDtz~fiBJzJt

'

~±t1!!~~~lfrwlltt~ffl)~i1fti~~f.~zTpfT

~mft"J*5*

'

~f~~±ttQ~~a'9ffr±~~~~7J~* ~151mJ1Utf[ll'~~7t1r;:&fmj~ 0

(ll Tseng Hsiao, The TheOl)' and Practice of Land Reform in the Republic of China (Taipei: China Research

Institute of Land Economics, 1968); i"?'i .t..:fi.· (f:)l.f Z.±.JV.t .f..) (:i;il:; : <f1~Ll#~t~.*'·:t-~l

t

·

1954) ; .I. .[",

t:.

~~;L'

<*

i'lr '±'J~~.t.f. ) (:t ;J1:; : l' 1?!lJI!:.Jlhlt :itp~ . 1955) ; ht~ilJ"

«

t

~Z .±. Je. i't.f.

(~;it : 1':!k: 3t4h1*-tf, ;f.l: . 1984) <

(3)

i$-7H£ tJmz~'

E

Ui

;

(J) ~±:ttE

l

'

~

J1tJ::

t~~

f~F

-m-

~

t'J

a<J

/U1

6f,{tf*

'

&(ffiJ!

]~IlUI':]1~{tf

'

~~JjffifTtJ9~~ :~~i&J&z~ ~5$~Zr

'

t1~J:iill r1i g;g~f-¥ZT?ff 5t1t&rJij~ 0 : China ReseiJrch t -#!l-.l/,f~.t-Jl1t . o/ liz.±.Je.&~ .l'!t .±. JEl'.t$.j1j..jf;lJ/. 91

~~m~~oo~~~'*~ffi.~~±~~~i&.~~r~tE.mJ& r0

tli!.~tlJiJ , jfz7f'fgjS rmtf~:ft:E8J

Jr)(Jff'

~~&:\~1G.:y

j;j

IDtE!fj

S

"J

0 ~1t-*~J5JTtw

1TEfJlitf~)J$*¥j(iSJ5J~~r~lj=f~:i£~

:

(-)~~m~B"Jt'~

:

f'F:tf1t-~*~Rn

.&;j§-

i&Jff~lUlt~~rEJ!ff8'']m!~:tM~

,

m~K?'£1t-±:l:tQJ5JT~{m&11E*jHIB"J~IDJ]

,

:l:tQ~

~1ffi~zra~B"JtJ.l~

,

&i&)ff~§Iim$r~1¥J1Ti&~7t~

;

(=))(,w:@]RmWf!l!rnnB"JU~

:

~@we.~±~~¥~7~~~~~'.~*)(ffi~~I¥J~~~ffi7f~'ili~

~~ffi~W~B"J*~~~~~~~*~~m*M~'~~~7H.*)(M.EfJ~

~~~Z~ , ~~.~m~~B"Jm~~~o

,

mHrnB~iI

~1t-M~B"JW~ , *)(.~~±~~.~z

• •

~.~w*~mfi~~R.

D

a"J

i%S*

'

1fz~W::W~1m1T.&ffct:~~iJJZ$~51!1T~-g 0 ~*~~a~m~

z

YfYi:

'

*1€ri5JfU7}.=-fffFf~Zf!l!~~illt

'

7tJJUR

: l!t!'r1~~

,

~~~~*lHRJ

?f~ , &ffr±.)(1~fjj~~

,

:;tt.:t

B7tJJU~illt~Dr 0

~tt~.g.£*J:~.~1t-ft.~A.,~.:t~.&m~Z~~~#~

E81t-.t-J~¥U1i*::t~8'']1~~

,

~mJJR*B"J~$mlT@&*S:m:ilI¥U~~~~

,

rm~ E8D~@AB"J~flJijrl~pJT5 1M!s"J 0 (4) ~.tH'

Po

p

ki

n

Zgifflfti

'/f~~~M~9M~i&m

~~ ' ~.~~A~illW~*.:t.ffiW:.~~*~*.~~.~ ' ~A~.&

~*~~m~. ' ~N~~W.~~*.~Z.hl ' ~~~~~~~EfJ.mo.

3@ffir

;f,j ~

E8~1"FBJ~it

'

'&:rffi1~f~~~f~j;j Ut:M9tB"J~~~~jJ~*BJ:ttQ::t~1t~

rp

m1iQ:lil*

0

Popkin

~.M~ff~{~Wf~J

.5tJ1§'I":;kS9m5E

i"FJij

'~H~~7ffIi

(3) Anthony Oberschall, Social ConJ/iel and Social Movement (Englewood Cliffs. NJ: Prentice·Hall, Inc. Oberschall, 1973); Charles Tilly. From MobilizatiM/ to Revoltllion (Reading. MA: Addison·Wesley Publishing Company, 1978); Mayer N. Zald and John D. McCarthy, Social MOIlements in An Organ· izatirmat SOCiety (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 1987); ]. Craig Jenkins, " r~csource

l\lobilization Theory and the Study of Social Movemcnt~: Annuai Review of Sociology 9 (1983), pp. 527-553.

(4) Samuel Popkin. The Rational Peasant: The PoliticaJ Economy of Rurai Society in Vietnam (Berkeley. CA: University of California Press, 1979).

(4)

92 fi'lt :JtSJl'»', • !f, A4~-JlJJ

.~M~.~ ,~m.~~m~~~~~~~~ '

••

~~~~~Mm~~

Pop

k

in

-m~;g~~~3mib~pfr .D)m:r:j] ft~±::~~1ZSl

'

h~EI3~il&1El~~jP#=ti~:il::!*

*FJ~~t]f~m.~.~W~Jll¥J)jiliHful: ' :&~~fJgB~iI.~ 0

f

Arm '

~7)i~

rm1J!!1IlJ

1~\:f~l¥J{tm

'

~ml£'11l¥J~lR/fD;g~Wffd:W!~mv

'

3m!IWI¥J~~~&:\~~m!#t~H~

~Jf!J~.:y~~~~B~Y5llljr1t 0

*E:tfijW~*&1IJ~@~~fllj~~ l3ff"j~ ~M±~l¥Jfi!!!~

,

~~jfttlt~~B~7tf~&

:;t:t

rt.,

~fjJ~~J~ft\ZM~~·Htt: ~~

Et9

±

~~

lZ9

0

lltfifiGJti

jfr

:q::

?IC~

IZSl

W

a

l1

ers

t

e

i n

a/'Ji:!tw.**fC~~rmmJ,~Jf!-~B~~m 0 (5)

Wa

ll

e

rs

t

e

in

~£~~~7t1~:&flf~~Ifjf

lZSl

'

JJj~iI*EI3~~~B~ff~ff*i1!1Tmm

'

1ili~~~JYl~h~EI3~tEi:!tjit1{**~

cp

,

~,~\~*!~tHi~~*/f0;qs:~3tf-~pfr~~1¥J 0

+

11

ttt*c~

,

[ffi1Jl¥Jj{*:1:~ t~'~\~*~7mm;!t:21-q~~$l't~Jro'~

,

/fwrj:iJj~EI3jo]~~F~*8"J1~~*~~!Ut~

fQlII

'

~1fU~5lf~~e9~~m:ll 0 EI3~~*±~B~*ft~iEJjjfWl'&~*s~~J~f1U

~ , ~llt

• •

~*I¥J~I:&I3~

••

W~R.~m~~. , ~-m~m~.~*~

ff~~itr~;f&

:

r§N

±

iQ

, ~ltJ(B~cp~~*&fllj;ij!m~J1.N~A}~* 0 ~Jlt

'

~~Et91j[

$~~~W~~.~.~~.~~.~~.~* '1ili~&mm./f0~I¥J~mh

S 'rmm-m~m_~~m~Nti~~±.m~I¥J~*±. , ~.-m~~&ti~~

±~Et~~~H&~~ 0

Wa

ll

erst

ein

Rjg~~t5~tf~15J)diJi~~cp~~;Ff~%

Ste

w

a

rd

...

M

i

n

tz

...

Wo

lf

~.~.~.W~. , oo ~~~R~~~.~~~~~~.~*~a~.~§

*iJ~T

'

l~'fffl¥J~F!-~~e~A.D).4~~ifE~~±~FJi~m*~cp

,

ft!!1r~]w'1-'1

B~ffd:~~$&.~~$~~¥U~m8"J~~

,

:tE~t1l!'I~r5t~T

'

~\~Jt~~~Wi~

1~' ~*B~*~~~~.~~cp~~T~.~m o .~~~

••

~~W.~~

Uffi~

...

~m~~~~~ ' rm.~~~.~~./f0~~~.~~~~ c~CP '

~*~~~:&~.~~~~~mM~~m

• •

~~~ o ~-ffi~~M~.~«

Pa

ige

fliJ~M;~~B"Jm~iiJDlfi~~1tt~*~,5~r.l"1~ili1JiID

'

ft!!g,~~..t.iIfj;~~&

(5) Immanuel vVallerstein, The Capitalist World-Economy (Ca mbridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979). (6) Steward Julian H. Steward, and et aI., The People of Puerto Rico (U rbana , IL: Uni versity of iJli noi,

Press,1956); Sidn ey W. Mintz, "On Redfield and Foster," American Ilnthropoio/?Isl 56:1 (1954). pp. 87

(5)

~~AM:m:.~

r:p

0 ~B9pJH1J~~le~ ~~

fm:11!]/[J

J~i:\~W13=t~~ tfr~~tfJ7t1t~ ~IZSJ

Waller

st

e

i

n

(7t1t~1ti*zJRi:

~

:tE-ttt)if.

if

*

t:1t

1§:1J1¥J:Jl*::t:~ J1~A*lJgIO§/.:~ ~!13Z~*

I¥J

~IJ ~~ftl

~

~mj§~~*3't:

It9

llt

'

~

m

8"J1fi:

t/f'0~f¥J1kJj~U1T 'm8,;t~&J.t*~

"

M

i

ntz"

Vi

olf

*

Ei<J

i&fcH'~~~

.c

cp , 1

tMr~

W-

f:f

~5t/oJ~~~ff& ~

5'

}

rr

i;f~(lHffi r,*~

cp

0

;!¢

r:p

,

~ 5lwr::t~~~ 'IT,1e c... ~;/( I!!t ~0 ~C\~-L)~~J!!tDIl \'ersity Press. 1979). niversit)' of 1I1inois 56:1 (1954), pp. 87 ti'lt.±.Jt.r-t~.jIj-t:il 9.

8']~1±l ~~~MW*~F'M*L¥J~~

,

WlJ~DAD r¥J:*ill:~IIJ

"

)Jfi:*:f1~8JWctitIUl1*

f~rW~8/Jm:t~~{*J5JTJU({~~ 0 Tffi~fi~~l~D'J.~i«t±l*6.m~fjlj~tb~ft;]ifct~W'~

. ' ~Hm*~~§~~~~~,m~e

••

~~

•••

~~::t:w~~m*.~

HEflzrdla9fJj~oPaigeW6.1fS~*::t:[@~~7liU7Jil:~fH~~*fl'lf '~fiffj~~~3W~

*iJffij~$5't-~

,

~rml:E=**!tlU5*Z~

,

S31Y~*±~a9tJ!iSJ3~~lii

'

1!f~~ *r:p~ll~J1~i±lg~r~~RX1fSU1;jt~IiJ:&1JcTla9m~r:j:JJL\ 0 (71

~ct1f{x 1t1ti?jgllfRH!iitff~/f~tijill~.W ~~100~ 8'Jtm~~

, is

~MJJ:t)If~7f~;£

~

it~~

.m1Ul11f-

*~m

fct

1fOO~ ~~

I¥J

Jff( [Z;] ,

mJ

ft!:~IlN}j$;

ff

*

=t

~f.t~

IJfi:

*1F~

*

j::~B"Jffctfrx1tmHt~J5JT~fJB"JJm'I~1~mHfiJW!l~ 0

S

mith

~lWJ~r#l~~*cpr¥Jil3n4F-l

IDj)(ijL' ;!t~11Jf,*i:\~*§~fIi~Zra'rfJfiJ~

,

mHi!:E8~r!:lilJJi*3t1tfii*W*:tit!

ffi±1nt1t~*~~

J

IUI!

S'J

OOg:g

0 (8)

Sc

o

tt

::t:~~~B~~!1ib~-filXm~E!~N

.[@; , 1ili1F~&:ttm:r*1F~*.:tJ~iB"Jw±wH~~~~¥Uji*-=:t~:&r~~...t~a9m~ 0

S

c

ott

~lHl~ t±l!tgf1nl3:E!

(

sub

s

isten

c

e

t

hic)

r3~tet~, ft!2~~rrMjf;2js:±~mfW3

'

7filfill~

~~~~i&~w

• •

m~~

••

~~£*~~ ,~~~*.~~~~~~~tt ;

t&m

j ,

1~*r3"Jji*::t~~Wl

'

'IW?5C~U*~2!zW

'

;(£i!t:wnH~:&.~~jBOff~~~

T

'

R#!~I¥J5E~1mt=E!!tt11*~ziTIi:;;"iJj

,

~m~~;gH&!t*Et9~mY-lli~m~Jr:

'

Wm.~.~lXml¥J=t.~~ : ili lZSJ~ '.~r¥Jm*~ili.~~~m~.~.~

jln~tg~ 0 (9) El3J:t:iJ~

,

w±i1Jt1tOO~~gRli~llU~~?,ijLa'~~~ff!flm~i$*1t~$ x1t~$r¥JMrllim

'

~~1'*1Ctt~~ct~~mvr¥JWf~~fElf%a9 0 ~D

T

urner

W

Killian

ff,.tW6~' ffi±.~itlJr¥J1t~7?J~El3~~~I¥]ffct,*'~m

(

no

r

m

s

)

~k:i51'fi8ff~

g~

• •

~A~ffi.~ ' A~~7m~~~Z~,~~m~&~~J:~m~

(symbolic

commun

icat

ion

)

*91fliT8,]ffcttt~~&1-T~mJ;t 0 (1 0)

(7) Jeffery Paige, Agrari(nI Revoluiion: Social Movements and Ex-pOI·t Agriclliture in tlie Underdeveloped

World (New York: Fress Press. 1975l.

(8) Carol Smith. "Local History in Global Context: Social and Economic Transitions in Weslcrn Gu atemala: Comparative Studies in Society and History 26 (1984). pp. 193-228.

(9) James C. Scott, The Moral Economy of the P(!(I$fml: Rebel/ifni alld S IIbsiste7lce ill SOlttheast Asia (New

Ha ven, C1': Yale University Press, 1976).

(IO) Ralph H. Turner. and Lewis M. Killian. Cnllective Behavior (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice·Hall, Inc ..

(6)

91 *"'Jtll!-~ . ~A4~-.JI)l

*X£*Ljft7f~rtu~:@lli3~ml!R~ifrr

'

Tfjh~~tf-ffl;r:af~W[9'&~&jJ?i@~mfR

'

p)

F.jfd:f!x1tfjftj~3;l~1'fm1i1f~S'J:@~£~ 0 -ttt!iit~m~~13Sm~&7f~

,

-nIDi

EI3~1:n~*3::~a"J~1'fzT' ~J~**~~S'J~:k1~ , ptr~~tt9~*~JiA~I~

Bdi~t{gJi~&if.gj8'g/f'0ZP:~mU

IUl

f*

:

~-

1JIID

'

ili~ S3~:{fji*1lf~::t:~t'l9~

ruT

'

I~J~1$:~tl''.1~mm11lBJ!¥U!iEliJj

,

1I!€$f¥ffJt~*~m

'

~Hflffl~7f¥.J:~fIJ

:m~i¥J~~* 0

=

'

~jtJm.flH$fJJIHi5l!.mz~~

.~L' ~M~*~~tt~~ffRm~i¥Jm~o~tt~~.~m'R.~&

.ffl~.~~mJJ~ ' ~~.~&~~.~~.~S'J.~ ; ffi~±~'*.m~

if*L~F.!sE!?~M£*:jgJ:W~tm~*raJ0~

,

ptr~1lXA~lHlflj1Jem 0 ~rm

'

IJJJ

*mmz.' .~~ffi~*.m~*

• •

~i¥J~&Wfi~'~.~.A~*~ft

~'gflA~i±tMI~m

(

tl

D

-

EE

=::t:

)

,

Jimrttl~J'f~liAAlfllH:fl~±±tH~1jgr 0

.A~5$~~~R~~~~OOM~~M~'~D.*~U

• •

*~ o ~~~

Pfljffl7f:;fti7f:;~1J~

,

*jilmitiprr~~n~M::t::~utl!

:

tl2f.f~1Jl1ti21&m1rn~~

,

~rm

f±~Emrmt€i±tilifIjJfJ!JfJ~~B''.1~i!€ruJf*

;

m~iJAPRI&15tfti&~~8'gJJfft

'

iff

*mtf:t~89±±1Mif!J 0 Ill) 1Bl?~1JJ:t7f-' ~TfjJ~*ffi~~n8~MUlJj(1i:~m~ii '

~~fHm~

S'J1W*fttl:tJ

fr;a

m

' iIf.i

lI:tE.1Je:k

~

J5l:J]l:

tt

~~~

m3

u"11t

I¥J

±

±tE m

t~

, 1M

EEl

/gj m~

1t;m

PI

Ji

5fl!'li~!lJ ~flElf fl'gfm

J1

'

ffl1&J;tU

~t~fffEf]DfitI~inffi~g&~~ El"Jjl~

1~

,

1iiZ1~jfz~;@1U~~

rJi

A

ffd:

Wr

~~etljT

ss

Ji

~ ~!fj

0

(12)

IHm

{

f:r*

!¥Jg§:g~zp:

JJ.jff&

>;g:t~m*M*It~e.El3ilAPfT1jtt!

'

l*;tttMllt&!~BSI*11=~/f'*5EihU*

'

jjf,\Ji!:~~~r~Ajfd:itmlEil*~ff

0

mJ.lf~~IDt

'

lli

A

e.~~&~m1:.

'

ii~g§$ljS"h

~m.Am~~._ow±~~~~~Rm®~grili~m.A~8A ' @~~ J

*

0

Oll *~;.. (j1r1~-i ;"'#l.\lYJlJtje~4-ltr.,~a$.-tt'±'*/!JJJ~ (.1.» . «ft~) 11: 1 (1981) , 1t 19-31' :

<;Jt1~{;'f,fJ~fI]oj:il'jt!.~1!fJliIll!a.:Jt.1t'±'*fI:J~j' ( T )), C1t)f) 11: 2 (1981) . If 26-'~6

(1 2) ~~~. OA"1l(i;:"l!f .±.1fU: 'ii'*';l1m}l!.)hf~A61 '±'~~.il 1700-1895} <:i: 1t : '17 "*=kJtt:r.t.il1:I~

(7)

1m.

fmj

9g.1J!rnn

'

l-~ :R1'~

,

-/5fHj

89~*1${{,\~*

a~±:~B'9tm:

H{lfli~/f¥'}~~U

~

i#.tm

..

fit

~J;.-t&

:t-4B .. *ifjfD~

~}fj 0 ~rm

'

~

A.. flit

A

fftt

~ill] {y

o ~*~ 0 ~Jtt~ 111[LHf~j:\, ,

rtD JJ:

~.I¥:J:1J$

, m=

~Ulm1i~f§~r!

'

~Jt!rfP.t~

,

H~

ill

n&:g~a9J!:@

:

B~][§t~:qs

JJff

/I:

~~JJ§:~llJtf

'

"'. ti!rl!HsIFr)]{

'A

'

ffiHi1fJE:

981) . 11 19-36 : . 26-46 • : 'F ~$}J-JtI';t..iiif1;. ~~.±.Jta.~.j1j-ti.it 9:.J

~a*~~~.g~~~ ' M~~~fiT~~±~~M~.,~ma*.*

3.ld~fi1f~.ii!Hffl~

,

tt7'C$¥JJfB'9~~~§f~E§~r)li~1'Ji&mL~B9±t~~~

,

~~~

s91t8[1]1:gti5t~~~lt

..

-=-ftj~IJil:

'

]J(tth7f~if!U~

,

Z

~mLiiJ;)7ct.lHlsJ~fJ.]J(tIMIl

(!:E

M

)

s9a!zlE:am~i&}fftE-

J\

1L

J\1j:.-\:if=j 01t5

r~.:tt!!ft;l;JH~IjJ

*

0 r

±t~~ll'

~fliJJ 'M1&MiH@]1\if:-:t%nX;llt~I11 0 E8~±tilifJlltLa1ftg1ijlH'J~~*:fIJJ~jj(~

ffl~~~'~~±:tt!!.~~~~ili~~¥B*M~i&~~$

• •

~.~~~8~

Ji:j

dtlii

lT

0 j~ff*~iJ~jd§Afis9mlt

'

~t1J&~-jLO-=-if:-+=jj$ifflj~'%m

fL~Jc

'

m;@:/f~~~*ffimR);~'1JD*m~

,

~11p.x;*f:fi-i51W

'

UilJEflHfl*

0

1Wiif:

E~=+aX~fflj~'%.1\.'~~~if:-1\f=j-B.lt*m. ' ~~0~~~~

*~TtllHti 0 ~T*~IJ~;fifff~~H1!f!

'

~'~JfJ~~ r,§,:fF*!RJI&**~JH!IjJ

z

m

~' M*.#±~~.~±:tt!!M~.~~W#~ff~~.mBfi ' ~~A~*M

u*~JE:nX;m~m~±~ ' W~~.M~m~~#~.M.~~'~~~~B*

7j

R

il&

}ffF.t9

r

JiCff]J(mft:

m~

00

0

9\:

~ mL~MUP ~

B

t~

I±l

'

#!Hf

~~2?z.~3!1[

r

~

a

*

i&J(';fiID~5f1i#rffiJ1i~ffB9.jfJ:.~~~9:

'

fl@J~1x*fl1§~'!i::tI

'

mflt)~*:tI

SJ

illLlt

fr

A*~mji* 0 J (l3) /f~' tLtillt~nX01§±tili~~i-jj9fl1i±:Lfu '

jt±tili

M~.~~~W. ' @E8~M

• •

I±l*~m®~&m~*m.fi o B*.~~~

i~1fttll~;ZJ;)*/f0ZP:S9filffi3tIJNJ1g1'Jm*1f90)z:1jt

,mfl

J;

)fflG:ll

r~1rn

f¥r

J

B9:1J~*~*D~ffi3ZI1~i¥JOO~ 0 (l .1) ~~!W{~~~ffT' J1t:flfFf0ZP:~llH!B*UgrRYfij

~'r~{%Jj~:tfB9flj~~~J:{g=t:g''J*Ij~~~*5-&1£-1ff '1mt~1±l 1~m11¥J1rnfJliE:li!:1,@

OO~~' ~A~.~~M*ti , ~

••

mmWB9m~m~Z-o~~ '~.M~

Wl

1EB

fllili-!fi6L

'

a

*~m~~g~~~*:f:ilitili1:'BJIDi;~flj%-¥JI¥J 0 i:iJt)~1±l

'

tEc!X:=@ffi3~1/jUJ!t1JjIjj

,

B

*M~i&1ft~~;Etr~*IJB9 0 J(15)

(13) 1, I tJ ~.QlI:.if

*'

'

4~ !!Jl "1i ';'f , ( !:1 .f-'.t.-Ij j.1<, r UI) l ~» (:f :lt : A /lll ~ Jl&.:fl. • 1993) , Jf 41 0

( 4) .I.ji.~ . <;;I:AlJlfr:t:ilitz.±.Jt~.J.t.~,±,j~JlUt) , ~U{-:f;.s.ri!tHt!!.~~~:t:IlfI.' H:i'f~~Jt-t-JP \~.

:It : :Hlf jrlAt· 1966) . Jf 52-86

(8)

96 f;lf:t..iJfJ{.· ~A4;r;-JJJ

l!Q

,

=-t;1i

iJtm

-~

••••

~±~a¥wu

••

~-ft~ft~-ftE=~~~-tli.

m · 0~~.'&ffl~~~ffi.~~.o~~~.~~.~.m.~m,¥«~

OOB.~Am~,~~m~~-ft~~~~0~am~

•••

fu.~A-~~

.It

;

(16):f!};g '0tlli~~JH&.;W;ff~-11IZBJ\1f.~m.lMimF@

,

~l1n±-ft1i

-i:f.zt&

Jlttl~f]!71N0M ' ~LItJ:Jztt!M~±±jjrc&¥t¥Jilll%-~}E ' OJ~nH'if~-?fr~~t~~o ?}~ffiJ ' /f'~~~tfJf3Z16JIB~m

'

*y±~tliHiff~m±fuf:ElflE#1ljftl¥J~~

,

t:ffit~~1D:

~=-tli?~ffU~0±fu11x~Jii&~~~~

,

~r~$EaJi{$*~~{ro~R~-ftllEli~-JLIi.

-4"-

'

~~~)ic&:\~Ji~BAa~ 0

=

tli?~ml¥J~~~ rmJfu~~fll~l'~~~2t:~fF~IE~d1~~lI9:Wl~!t

-=f~t~=Bt+li , ~mM@:~~±tMfi~~-=f7t~=B-t+1i~~.r7t~=t~i

t+1i

'

/f'&-=f:B-Z

=

S-t+1i~~;1t~~

,

7f'~.t.tr1JD

'

1F2t:~fFft1)IE~o'1l&

1!J,~1'FtmB"J~U11t~~1'§tf.l3.J

'

'8l¥Jpgli§;1tfr~W-ft=O~1~.1fili~*~O~=

.m.~ o -ftlZB-t~ ' .~.~ill~$~*B~~~~~.u r~~¥.

001i

OaJ

II

%

J

'.*.~~'fii&*,§0~.~1li=t1i~m

'

iffiff~:Bt'§'0~t!JJ;)

rJNY

-:t\1f.~~±iQP'3*m-=-~~~J ~Y~~~m' rm~t1WJitB=-tli?JJtffl '

ft,ifIjrn~~zW~~ftJ1!Effi~jJ$it*fAfJ ' f2Sll1:t~7

J,WmZ*

5i-

'

(17) 1~H'~mfJ;,(~~1=i

¥A

fi

J:

S

'91!J

jjE , ~

*

fit

~:If.

IV

0

(l8)

tE

~

rA' ,

{If! ~

W

~

2t:

~r139 ~

*

J.l

~'6:Hl!U! ~ 5x

16) fl<.fiJ"f· {ft !J(i - !f , <f-~"t~'±'Je. tt..f...u..-ti!ll1f.oi!lIU:.1it~1tR.~> . «iJi.R'I'I?U 131 (1999) .

175-209 0

(17) .1ft

-*-

*

Jt i$i. , ( Af-

*-

'P 3.. -\: 1i-~;fll..i<..1~~...:1t:.~>U.) (1949) 0

(1 8) ~Ril 3.. -t "" 1f. "" jJ -=. -t 3.. El oj: i1/f ;{j .i. /$" Itilt nA

r:-:{

~;fi ~1k

t-

A'ur-

*-

~.±. JMr ~t.ti:1.1; .J, -=. : - JI, ;,

1U~.It ; n - A.Jtt J'.f/~ Jt:.tb{1I. ( ~ ~;(j ~1kt-;r; - ..!U~ 3.. ok:k. -tr #-"i » [1947 11'-6 fl J . 1i 86) rU1

3.. -h ',1f. -t -=. jJ 3.. El •~ ~;fi 1tJl'1-~J!~

*-

-fit, ~l!-k

r:-

':li ~ ~Hl1<lJ ",

r

1f. J.t .±. Jt1!.,1i !R

at

~;r. :

r

3.. -I- -\:

1f.Jt.i~Iil .i.~fIi} ..Lit ~"'''(-)~.ff..L1t~ !e. m a!f-JllJ!f z #lJ:f,~ : (,=,)11* it.lJ./~.Jt ; WilrJ'.Ue.,ffi. : 1"'1:

IItHHt.Jt 0 1 (H: '";(j ~-!l; 1t ~- ..ad~ 1!S ok Jdtif ~» [JI:. ""'t.% 11)(;j,ti.JHtA H: i¥l' ..tHt Jt-kII ~~:f

*

ilHll%)] [ 1947 11'- 12 AJ ' Jf 86) ;;r-~~ft.i1tn}J.i.a~JUd4!>;t..lt-k· ~rAii'4'-&;·*'±'!Mtjliz.i..t<

JJL~J .1l:tA ../i-:.lr-• or,~ il!:..1J"! ~r *-.fIt..&.. 3.. -\: 1i-;~:fJl . Yo.. , {-jl:.»*,ll.~

r:-

~1J1 3.. -1-"" 4--\: jJ ~~of: :It..U M.fILi

1r •1t

r:-

3.. -\: 1L ~:;f.l1z1111

**

..

4t Sf /II].?i!,

*

il. :

r

i!.'h'I.;{j -t-*'~Ji.~ . :#t4t Hf l\ll J:. !bl1 ;;r-.&.. . it!b Je

(9)

~if:rs~!¥J-=t1i~ ?JfI~~

,

~1tfz :tQ~*P3A -~~ E- jLn

-fF:.<::

~ *=-&a9iM~Q ~~

,

:t;tt~~m

7 L

IlR

li

.¥- Ali

:cfb

~

if-

1

19:1I

~(~M ;~~"f-5-}Z-=-S :fFtm.iEi.llJ~

7Jz

111im:fB*~a9= l-~ rttit~~ i&:&:,§0~mt)

'JA

g-=-

tn7~m

'

~

!\Wi

m

1J;Z

.!]7. ~~ ~H;11

X

61 9l[f

~

fI

~ Ifl ) 131 (1999) , 1f Z~.J6 )t,.::. : - ;if.,;t 6 fI J ' 1f 86) , ~~ **~,f- :

r

3..-j--t:

'i!!. ; (E..J~fr Jl!. Jtl:A/1 ; (I'lll

'If ;(J 1-1 n. -& 'It ~~:Jf ~

b' sf.:Ut-It .iTt Z .i.~ ~ h\..i. i-jt.9Hu~.!I.-l

flo;R-;r-

a

'

*

d7 Je.it

t) (1: ;it : ItH:. '*il'

:t;t!t '±' .I6 .:t $.*~;il/. 97

t

'

(19) ?~~1Hnm~

,

!1:fB~f.El.Z~*lJ;Z f{J]/f~fEH!~: 3Jlji

,

fE!tlift t!:t5fH~If~mJ:EO

~.~~~

• •

~,~.ft~~~~~~~ill.ffi~ o ~ ~~ , -tIi.ffi~:

~~~~~~.~-ft~ft~-~.ff

• •

~~~~z~~~a~~ff o

.~~ftm~-ft~ft~~*~~n7~~W-tE.mm.~fift$~ '

W~~O ' r~.~fL.~mttMllJfHmi*J

..

rIi.~fL.~mtiMH}iHJ.$~1J1g1;Hiffi~IJJ

-.

r:;:

~~*JJ¥rmfL.~mtiMjU'J¥Hctt~$JJ!J

-.

r~f.j!l1:11HT

r

-

t

E

J

tihm1H'~jQ ~

m~:mmJ

'

"&

r~~~~t\%mffH'J

r-=

tIi

J

j;fuf]~~~*,§.~#H~J ~o~Tt~

ffi~m~Z* ' ~i&m~*~~W$.~m.n.oo~~,w~m@~~tQ~~

tE:&~~@J0pfT!H2 0 ~~fJj -=-tli~ffl.zJt1J1g '~l1fi\(;TTttHT

r

-=-

t

Ii

J

ttM.EI.~ ~~~~

,

~

lItf:

m5t

55 U

nX:

:lI:fifi

r-=-

t

EJ

ti

ME!

~

ffii

tf

'

~J!i:~

ffi41t

/f'~~

aU

f:

m~~~W~~~&2

••

'ili~.~m~~~w~.Z~~~~o ~~tt.~

{it , ~

illt

flkJ

rril)[

$

%

:Mz

i~ ~1:EifJ11iJ' ~ ~l¥J~

A

~B~~-a~~ ~ ~19~

~, .~~

• • •

~-ft~A~+=~.-ft~ft~~~zOO~.~~.!¥JAA

~,® -tE.m~:&~ffl~ffi&$~*m~~1:E~~~M~~U"&M.

fr

0 (21) ~5'i-' tlIfjf~lL~!¥J~'

r-

tIi7~fllf,*1fIJJ ~~-

AIl

-~*uu' ili~7t

m' ~=tE.m_fiT~~Z~~~K~flkJ~Wm~ , m~

• •

~flkJ

• •

~-=

tIi.f.El.8"JOOMifA1'J"6Jfig~~z~~!¥J*~ 0 ~!H~'i~J!~~~W~t1L~f:ElI

W

Er''.J5~JJJ"6J~7F

:

1988) , 1i 346-347 0 dJJlI:.iC.iX1j.,.(..t."T4fi.*,,',t;-*:f~;jj-il.tJ{.f-1J;#-3..-t:Ji. it~:W.M-*~~.ffi.~ _,lUI-'W,f,r

#an..;#-~~3..-j--t: • .::.fIaB~R.t , ..t."T• • *~;{J il.t**;#-3..-t: Ji.~.~~.M4'• •~ il] :

JUf-iJ .±.Jt. f." 1w !~~ ~ ,

*-

-3f! M*~ti! M'!! , jrtit1t 't/~:l'f-~~3.. i;" :Jf ~Jt.,T.J ~ tf; -.::. -

*-

11(,

1: ' ~.{!-.·.uut~;{j Je..#~, ·!ttM-A4ij,;;-.ft.!-:tu{or.fft.1t ' J1}~~;{j $"{IB $l' MJ-Z £ -l"*.JlIJ ' ~.fJj 3..-t: Ji.Je.;fJl;jtijt , tSi.£JR.t:-~ J1IJ • ~!tA*,,1·r4fi4t ' l£*"1ltk-li,f-0 ~R.1~J!f:t~ , ( .±..;e.i1..f

0 tAH ' 1t 361

(I9) fiiJ J:.i i ' Ji 339-368 0

(20) Shih-Jung Hsu, and Michael Hsin·huang Hsiao. The Impacts of Class Diffenmtialion and Cul/llral

Construction on Post- War Land Reform in Taiwan. ISEAR (Information Service for East Asian Re search, Program for Southeasl Asian Area Studies) Occasional Paper, No. 2 (Taipei: Academia Sinica, 1999>

(21)

r

:f~.;tj¥~f.tJrJe..Jfl"'ikJ *{~JIUj,~JN 3..-j-A• .::.Jl-t--El &,3..fI.::.-j-Ji. El ZXix1-1f~i!~' .3F.~

(10)

98 1:~~.IJj-,t · 1f,A4~-.JIJl

r.~~8*.~.m.~J ~H~~~.H~~ '*.~~~~~o*

-

*-

ill

:iHt

~ ~ ~

99

~ ~

,

Of;\;

iFl

i!t.

:

r

'*-

«iH.~,

t1C

1't-fR

7 :.f

~

,

jt

Jt

i:t:*

>t

89,~ J;f£ ~ 0

J It

&itlf~,

M:

~:

r

it

:.f

~~:it

1m

~

,

~ *:i!~-1OO

*.~~I~I*.a~:.f~-.~~~I~ ' ~~~

• •

fi~~.~

)f-t

A

~BkJ ;ftt,ftl ~ ~

$

iTO ~

IT

a.J

0 J(22

~~' $~*ili*~ : r.~=tn~mR~fi~$% , ~~~~~ , =t

1i~fJ3.89fE1~~~~[9-I-!tf-:::t~~,.§;~

-+

;

\

!q::

'Jt:IitB

-

tli~mj]A8?-~S'9oJl2~)

W~

,

'11W~~:J.D:±tM.ElI¥J$~~~JE¥U@~fEJQ/E

?

fIHJi'i'~±:Lit1$m--01If

!&t

:J.D:±

lli;fJ3.EJ(]m5Em

:

r±fuf£r::f1~~:i&J±t!!{!85tz;\ 0 *,J5E±iQ;f.El1%~tJ!:t&f]MH~:tili

1Jil85tZj\~ ' JJ!!!.l:t@.tiQ1~ls:sz;\~JEZ

:

~&:l:iQ1Is:Sz;\~ ' 1~5U;"JJt~

~~o

irrPJ[±fu

fJ3.

m

?:t

Jt±iQ

fJ!

'

*~~1~$mJt±iQfJz±fu:1J' l~jilli=.1fzZP::t5]tfufl 0

J

~® ' :~~fia~W:Jj):~$.z~~~-.m~ , mJt :

ff.~~~~.~A =~8 ~~*M-OO E O

••

+:

r.~~~~

*

if-

~

A

~Ji

8 A

*

%

= =

1m ~ ~If

+

~

1m

:

r

~ ft.~ [fJ Il7J J'ik ~

*

~

1t

~

=

W=~~*'

•••

~.: ~~.~

••••

~~.,.~~~

••

+

~~~~E~#o ~fi+~~

••

~J.~ ' ~~fi* ' ~fi+~~.

jf,!!f:l '

# .. Mi

P}f)l - ttl! .~ 0 J (24)

-.~a~.~~.~~~~l¥JmJt , ~~~U=tli.mffi~~.~ rfE~

1~~

,

mLtm1m~iliffX:. r:;:~~f~1=f*lt±fumfflfjJffEJ f!l!~~=1~ 0

Jtf!

'

;e-

'

~fJ~~'§0~t:tltt;wll-%~*ff::1f~Plz~5e.

'

mPJE8IE.~rra~,§0~·~~

~~~~~~~~zn~~~ili*~~:

~

•••

*.~. :···~M~« ~~&~M~ '*~~.~~~~ '

~~~.~~~

••

o···

••

~.fi~~*~~ ~~~.*~

••

~

=

~.

~

A

:

r

••

~.~~~~.

,

~~~*

..

~

~~

~

~'

.

(22) ~iJJ Of, f!fil. - lf- ' <fi'f'fl :&t.H!:.?.t.fli--tlkll.1f-0 i!Hl: !1:..tUtt'!re4> . Jf 177 0 (23) J5l J:. "ti , If 188 0

(11)

t\.

[19

j[

Yi

0 ;f-f F~

,

~;t§ 1;, W:. '~EI ,/l:R ~"'J'~R-II!!J

'1ti"fkritJfiii:

-f

fz

l'

jj!$1$

,

=

t

lfij~J8~8~oJ (23) :ttlz$.~--O(I* ~~tl:ttlzf§.~~{Mt!:l

\;ff

,

~~r.J~~ ~1f~~:!S]±1QfI 0

J

'*

I

~ifkffiJ

7~ ~

-t1*

-=

7mjf~4Mf

,

IT

-tier

71-

~ ~i&~utJ I$.~J ~1,* 0 ~'W

'

~J1 :i&~'§0~~il&

.

BA

j:)fL;t , 1Ffjf~1%~

z 11!!.:t

':ft

:1:i'If.1.Jei'!t-'f. ·~i.il/. 99

:!m

:ffL7G

1~J!1t&

1:-

~iE ~

#J

t&

fl

t~,tJ

-=-

it

z

-,

~

IV.

iE~

4!lJ

tJT~

f..ttM

0 J(2S)

?~f(ij , l1:trJl9!~jHft*llJ1Qi&~ZPJJE

'

:ttlzi&!ff1JJ~~*J~)'MJzttZWII%~:@ 0 ~9}

~m~.~~ , ~~jj!~~.~$.1$~.,~~-@

• •

~.~~*~~m~,

wu~ntE IIfMt~fk~JJt~mtIH)jfaU

cp

,

:M~ffiW3~'JIimgt11~m~n R~tE0 if

i;~~il&)ffpfifljU5JEB 1}!~~3iHJ

r

-=-

-t

EJ

±1MfiI

fF~ttt~tliN+itU ~mJ:E' 1f*j:ih~11

U~~1fWl~-1f.' Eb~\i%mi\!H~m~, J;)'~ll::!:t!r±:fE~~{IBJ 0 (26)

lZSl

JJt,

m-

i

tm

\~rP1:EfliWJ1JfIDS'9mJEff~~JJH§'i1'-i:)lB~lJl~

•

Lfitln~31H:l:Yt~t~t\j,

I

it~~

~y~ (m ) ~=-1f. ' !ifft~*~~I\U~1i.if.' ~i¥jjf;~~**~~~7\~0 J27/

:{£-fL

-.if.

'

~§7fll*,9E!n~¥uWj

,

~k(;J±1!!m:§7;ffliIBW~l1n~f!}~

,

frn~-ili~F'gtJ}fJL'1m

${J}likl~flll*m±1Q 0

tE

l1:t

AAr!itzT

' PJ~~~~Jmmilif@l!Im ,

r

=-

t

E

.

wHli11*

~J~~tE-fLE-4-~7\~~nt\j* , ~xcp~~mJEmM~&$~~'ffi~

Bm~~»7\~~$~' lfti&~B~~O~ft~-~B~.~o~*m~Aft

iL5bH~1~Jj5E-~M~F.¥,7\.if.

'

1:E~~Mrl3~P9

'

l*fEl~81JJ.~U~~ 0 J'29)

~l1:t,

••

~-ft~ft.if.~~tE~mM$.~~Afi~~~£.'.~~~

~DS9&~J1Qom~~I~i&;ri1liUn~-1L~~if:+=~

1i

RI¥J

r~~~~m~f,*{jlJJ

~=.zm5E' ~~~M-@

• • •

z.m~T~t. :~

- , 9t~~i&~1t£.Jf!o

="

~~~IU1Al~Am~IJ~~z~'1t!-1Tm}iHJPJI 0

(25) ~;"t;{iltJlt· <i:~-1!fJtJ1ti;!-4-#~ U .IllJ-» ( 14~Ii-+.f\T-1t)

,

Jt 51 (26) {~Jtf:t ,;-;, , ( J:.. Jte.<k."'3!:>tl» ' 11 377 ·

(27) .l. k!: ' ffdflff.. • ({~J:..Jt. ?t-f. ) • 1f 72 0

(28) ;r-~Jf-jf(.:A-.tir 11

T-

fO) .:t..R..Af •-ft.~ij ~, [' f).. .;;;-at-t~fIi] ~ht*-;fj-•"t~;'-1:: Ji. ali,;fll' it

T-

Ji.

-

JIII'*t; iM:.;jf )jjjf1liJ1.~*.f~!lt iJ fIi] ;'-1::,£~,fiL+HU lIHr.n.· M;1flH1 J $'-.JtA'·jf,,A-· H:)\f.f!i,.ft (1949-1997)

.±. Jt.Jft.1lt~H't-r~tj!JJMIJrfli]J:..jt.i'.t$j!.'±'J~;A5(.;totJ~jU (1:3t :

4 '

~JtJltJJi-JL)i~' 1998) , n 73,

t~~.M.·.*~~~.~~A~at~~~~~+A-++-A+-E~~N~*.m~Jlt

•• n

ijid4.~ *;l~:

r

~ tU~,ld:

m

'

~tt*.tf. A;flll>~.fll ' :1r tf~ tU fJJ ilUJht '

'

is

-

Hf iW 51:. 1-~-;,A .i. R<. ' 1! #.J!'t

~• •A·4at~~~~~ I;'-1::Ji.J • • •~~~*G~,~#'.~.~~(.*)~*fIi]~~,

.il-hl;.;/J , i!!. tAt-t' ~51:. 1-I'rH.A~ -e.JL~ I!!l .:t. - 0.1 ;11:.

a,t

~

,

<1: ~;t4i..f!l.41111' .±. Je •.t~z tNl.) ,

4t~~lHJlx:;, • (-i~ J:..Jt!!.L'.t~x.~) (£ 3t : Pl if;t -!ljl • 2000) , Jf 9 0

(29) .L'(d! ' ~ffl.ff.. ' ( ..t;%f J:..Jt!:.~k~) • 11 72 0

(30) 1, 1~ 1Jl#' H: ~;tj ~tX.1t t,.$Jt 1t-~ itll4' 1t~6ry -1gj~;;t~ _1'U!;;#Ul (l946-1951) 1 ({:;t. : ~ilt t:I:I

(12)

l{){) .J:~ ~.ffl-~ • $ A4~- .J9)

.=:

"

~~~~J!r3Z:I~Z7tifrJ~JJj 0

RB

"

~~-mJff~~*:rJJ 0

E

"

~:5!t~i&Jff)jffii&¥~Tlr :&~!@l6I:Jfff)jU±l~rf'l~$JJl 0

/\"

:Ii~A~~JjlU 0

-I:; "

A

1fu~~Jtit.:y

Z

IfflMI

0

IZ9Jlt

'

~'i&JffFJT1Mna"JtHfnj;l~~UiH5W~~zf¥HIjW~~1'f~m

'

ft(~11*~J.

mJE~~~X~"~~ir~1*

'

(31) 18~'i'a~z~i&JffMz~~31iM1$: '.<§~~~~;fIJ

m~.~~.~.7 o~.~~Z , !@• • •~~m.~$m

••

~~~M~~

;j-'~ , A;**]:1J5l~*tI£~Wd:t"a9~~

,

m~~*tti

'

=-tE~f1iB"J.1Ji!!ftlj);ttl!

1r'l¥JfIJ~~fftfiHI[!¥J~~ 0

,;%1F.f~~.frZ.~m~~~

,

1fu*~@]tlIDi : r~*l¥013k:1C,\JHiff.=:-t1i ?rotfil:fDfjf~~;ttE8 !¥J±ti£iIjz~1l#

'

A

1r'~ffl;ft¥U1tl!.PJ~g~1I~fU~JlJJ

'

~~'i"~

,~MJ!¥JttB1J

A

±

'

!ji!jJJU~~'iZ8''7~~ttrm~~FfTlf~~~.RW~£:iit~tililfi5~

it!?::t:

,

~jitlr:tl'flj~±:l:i£aQ:li: ' ftl!1r'~PJfjg~NJ:t!¥J 0 J (32) B3~~'~.~1r'*iHr

~*±itEt:

'

.1f

t!!

-,-t;E~fflJ¥]W5*~~lJef~1ilifr'ff.Jflj~~¥U*Jl~91ll1~~

,

lZ9J1t

'

~.~

'~

• •

A

~~~

*lf&.

a9

~.

o

~®

• •

W~1'

~

'

~~~~000~

3Z:~=-t;E~ma9~rr o -n~n~E~EB , ~~~~~~~~m#.~-ro

m:$~ , ~*1tl!.1r'~-Jt!;31c~z~=-l:::;E~fili&m 0 1W*VK~i&&.llfJJ$--t;1i~IDa~

mt:jJ1:j~t~~jF~~~~(.f]3i1J1S"1t~=-t;1i~fil1Jg~JIWifljmfj8"Ji*l!l 0 ffu~7ft

:

r~~~)jYID

:

m*mrr

r

=

-t;

E.I

:l:

tI!t§.'

~~m~~~, ~~~~m.~, 31i~T

~~S"JW~

,

~~F'm~tU I:t9 0 ~:If;~CPfv%$~~iJ~~~

,

~ib~]i:m.If"Fft

fl

,

~t€i~¥JrfjIfFAffi'.il'jr16ZlIJ 0 J(33J tE~::!t** , -{lL~;ga9~~~l'{1ij~im~

1\:iilla~fil~~:{f~~~

,

illl.fi~*i&Jff~tJ(*1mi1j-==-t;1i~fii 0 ~~ , ffl': :~tfiTjf¥]$f~

.@.~ili~~ r=t1i.~J~.~,~a~~m-m.*~~*

• •

=

-t;E

(31) if>l~ ·!/;" Jb't-l1i Jlti!t"ff;i€.zw..J1l-~J ·*,J ~'* ~Il;,-t :r.-4-:r.-}]

z

r.f iIJt;(j ftlJ~H[JMtiA-~ ~#hkj .'J..

r

:£

~;(j r./J~~Jt!!..tt~ -*. j\I;·'Jf:it·n:l~.r.sJ ' Jlt.-=-ik#.~hiJ;(j· Jf.t.fC.t1 t'tki~~i!' -!i'I!,:f.i ~1I(tr (~-AIdf.

;,*-:k. ..) tk ~l't-JE ;!~ c

(32) ik"!I~' (.;i--'.IJl},t1({£ -;: , 7i<.~;t·;,-tA4-> ' (~t,jUt1".1*) (f ~t; : fi.. .Jt-. 1965) . Ii 36 ·

(13)

,

f1X~f~f9U2 ~~~8JffHIJ ~J!lfJ=iJT/f?i4'9

8

9 Jf1ftIHM

fBfIQ

~ffHJ-"tE 1J' ~ffl~~ t!l'J~

f

fu

~-1j

ftJ

~1§J1rtkm~ IJr~

,

129 11t

'

'rJjt?!.{

0-

00 I¥J

=fj~~tt-{)f =tn~fil8J ~ 0 lfu~7F

:

tftM~

,

~*'t?-y i~~~I1tft ~

7ffl

~~

fI£ ~

,

~

Jr

trtHl'

9 $t

~1Um--tE I;, ""~it-J ,~ r:t -1l't' (~-AIJ 1f; q 36 0 it1'\'.u~&~*ti~ ]01 .m' @fi~@~~~~2T '~~

• •

~.~~M.m

•••

~t~~~o~

~ji--fi~{i!H¥}ttg8~:EJl~~

,

f!nlji.=-t1i~filEf{]~tt~~1tEt-J1;k

,

::t;¢~iih

±W$.2~~.~IW.~.~~&-m~(~-ft~ft~1i~~~~)'.~

ffi~~.~~mEt-JU~M~~mm-m~2~.~~7M~m

• •

OO~~ ' ~fi

~~@~.0pff~g2~~

,

ili~~*Jf:(£~~Aqif!im~

I

1tf'~~

,

-J!tfih.:E~~1init

~~nmftl!~Et-J$. ' .*$.~~~W®~~U~~o ~AH~Et-J~,§W~

±R~~mW*~HI.I¥J$~i~~~fri(;fPD1l:tZ$iJJ

?

1t!!1M~1ilJJji~!jit11fufF~BJ:fU

£±?

*f&~tMmJ:jzltrQ~~a"Jm~~

,

~~ItSJ~ rm~~~J ~~

,

~3gffu1nl'tf}

~fji~ --tE7J9tmtfJiI&.o1fuI§tl:l 'I~~W1i~jht~fH~iillhma~,~5jut§~:

rtJ(;

-1;IJJJ~lw.1;£~g ,oi~ill

r

.:::.-

t

E

J

~f'§'~&lfYHffl¥J~~

,

~&'~**};{'Itilli

i@ 0

J

J1?f~.WfIDfH~~~1:i]~

,

~ r~~

,

i§!1f!i&*{ffEt-J:±f,!jl;

,

IDtmJtl;~;5

,

j;U@

2i1H~7t

r

7tiil1~~J I¥Jg~ 0

PS

)

1@1~tt~a"J~'~~~A~/ff.lttff!lifJl~8"J1!fI

±~' lli~~.1i¥.~~$~.~~ , ItSJ~.~*.w.w~~~~mom.

x

lr1*iffillllt

'

~'i&m=7t)ju~-ft[gfL&-ft:n04~~~1)f$~.:y±t!2h~\W-mil&Jff

'

A±:~2~ 'EI~1fcJ1[±ih:±~mjfHf

-=-

tE~f:fiil&m

'

"qr

J;)J~ltJ,tM~J3.~.?t.V;

~~gr5 0 (36) w~J!t$~~§~1¥J

'

'i~ili~-J!:t~M~m¥~~~flU2~ffi

:

.a'

~

.~

~

I

~AJ'~~~

~

I.~~.~.~~.~.

'

r!

:i

'*

tl:J ~

J

§

0/ '

11

~ ~

:1i

W

-&

;fa

±

t.+

~ ~

,

±

'*

ifHI'I)

1:JJ

e-HJi

:

r

~

~~

~.

I

~

-~

.aff'~ffi.~~~

'

~

~.~

~

~.~

(34) ~./i.,I.-t.

H

.:

1'\'fHhll.)ljjif

)

~\f:R>li..) . 1i 243-251 0

(35) 1"1 J:. i i ' Ji 252 0

(36) ~m.=..-tAif-*,- r~~;QJt;(.f1\'t (}-.u'Je...tJii-;,j!t~~~AO..::.ibtJJ' Jt-I"l~$,:

~.~a.: *~~.# r'="~AJ ~• •~

•

ra'~*,~W~~4L~~~• •~.m

Jtrtit-

~*' ~it-4-z.JJI.k. . ~ii!.;1. !~,,*,4tl:11B ..x.U·#i~~A!~

it-

;tZJe-iJl:i-' Arb ~iii: of P~;Ii. Jel/;\;

(-;ji") Jtxt:tJ'{t'4fJt.ii~r~:k.;f" ~i!.y~"14-.e~~f!t - (B.:1'\';{J4f!#'="~AAi.fl+lIU'

1950 ' Ji 124-125 0 ~,rJ; ~itt,i[, it

*

rrr

»0 0 )

~~.=..-t~.-A-t~a ,*~~a;(.fx#-~.,*+ r'="~AJ ~.a~~~~a~41~**it

~"~~.:k.*· r~&*~~M~~e...tM~~~~¥AO..::.~~tM~~~~+~a.~~~~

(14)

702 .f~!tPJt}t· ~A~jf;-·M ~A~~~'m~'~~~ '~~.~A.~.~ ! J

••

~g , .~ T_±§.~~.o.~*-~*~

• •

~*_±'.T±$~~g., ~~~ T=~.~.'.T=~~AJM~~.±.~~~~~~.~· ~.~~

• •

o ~*±.XTT -

• •

4' ~tt~m

• • •

I~~*

••

,~-*~±~~t~.~·.n.~~I~'~~~*~~~. M ' ~A~

• •

~M~~Tc ~ 9f--~wrfifl~~PDT : ~-.~± ' .~~E

• •

I~~~

• •

'~~~~~~lA.~T=

71'-

z - ,

~~H~

m

I\.,' , ~

iJJ

1t!!.1M

ff

~

tl

I

1t

J!! ~

;f1t~:.f ~

it

'

V)

J;

ifJz

ffif

.~~~.ft~tl , ~~~

••

*m.~ '~~~l~_.mft , ~.

*.~

•••

ft~*'~Afi~~.~~~.~

• •

~+.'~-*~

1M

1

taT

)

;ltJt-iE~}jJ!iI*1*-' ~)f,jtEJf:lUt~1 -.~:m~~:fl':itl!..i

if!

/lJ ~~f(.tdi ' ~:It ~f.9} ~

,

1!lHJl..it

~~ 0

9f

*-

rf1

flg

~

ffi:

~ ,~ ~ ~?Ar

tJt

:

rA.~~~~,:Itl!.±~M~~m~'.~'~.~-@A~a

••

~·

~*.~~'m.*~1 , .~~.~.,.~:Itl!.±~~~omA~±

~

1!

1m

It

~

)

I

it

if.]

il

~rf~7;u

1tt

)I~

.f

IJ

0 Jl38)

EEJ:pJTjz/t

,

~~n¥J:JfJ1fffi**1U/f'~~t£ffP%l¥J:l:11r:Efj

,

ff!!~~.=:.t1i?~f.H~g~

)llfjfIJmfJB-j-1[gJ:1:~®:[2§ 0 ~5i-

'

==J\$1tftri.~~W7~.~Jjj 0 ~~=

J\~{tfl¥J~~ ' ~'~~~~~lr%L

"'

f.$M:&f~iffimif

'

(39) {~~~~~z~$~

U&fi~~7**~.~'~

• • •

~~~=+li~E~m-*

••

~'EE~~

.w~.~ ,~m~~

••

~oo~~g~E~,~g~~~~~ftH~Z~~

@~~

7 .=:.++

=

~Boo~m~**.~,~.m.w

~~

iJiJt

'

~!iffl~~~

1f'M

m~~

:

r***1fil5~~i!H

Rlr:fL

+

~{tf, ~

(37) ~I (J *~Jt

.

C1:~_1hJ1.JIiJDiJ l-'.-!: -f'\;'-!.) • Jf 252-253 0

(38) JJ] J:.u. . Jf 253 0

(39) ;jJt41~4-.jl.J,F.z~.I'.f (¢.:f:~_{i;fJJMR7l-'.~1l(,*-» · IT 216-219) , ;fi .j;-~n l' ~.::..::./\..:jr1t·.rnJE.-c-:t·1f

#~~aI• •'::'~· ~.ffi~• • • •~A~ ' ~~A: ~~£ · #E~ ' ~~~ ·~~~' &~~

(15)

1i;~'Nf)jc it1i;~~ ,

,

~

1m

Jt

1M

'

I

fF

ft~

:i!

ff

ftV~

jf!J

(t.;

J&

\~1'

J

=

' !;I.~i&Jff

(HI

)

if!.

~

,

it

-

*-ft3

a~

,

:I{g£ ..'- ~ '" ry ~C 'ET"NJL : ~Jil~~, m~.±~£ ~ t;]i?~f.El~g$11J .jfi.g 0

!Z5J.m

-=-=

~ffiJz~~~~

it~

'fiJ~

~

~~

zffifFs'

,

~

f}P

~Fifj

mi

~

fL

+~

1tf

'

*t

.~ft,Iij IE. t:;i-1f

, Jf]

" .

a..(tllJ:. .fi'lt ±t6~.bl'i.~fi~)L ]03 ~m

:

.It.i&l:t-

-

*-

'

j.t'f

,fJfNg,

0 J(40J ~~ ~

j3

*~1~M~~j.t'

?

~~~~.Ii~~1tt $~ff.Afr~.~

_•••

~.~.~'

_••

ffl

:

.ft_••

~~ ) ~*~A W~~.A~~R*'

••

~~§.~£. #'AA~

••

' ~~~*

•••

~~J~t.g'OO~'4=·=A • • ~J • • • ~*

••

' ffl~~m~w~t

• •

,~

••

~,~**

~

A

~.

ili

~I~~~~~.~M~

•••

~.

'~

~.M'~.~.

J1.i')f~ ~

*-

4!!Ht ~ ~+

0 (,11 )

83I1tl=iJ~D

'

==J\~f4a<]~~~~ft~J!I:~~~gjlt" ~iffi 0

' ~

t-HifB":::'--G

1i~{§'a<J[OJ~

,

~1rHg~tl:Jl&-n~~i&m~~twrJG 0 -tL~fL~fJ~cp~*r~&

~Miffij3~~-@~mffi~.~&S.~~~ , ~~~~~cp~*~W~AA~'

~

• •

~U~~~~~~o~~~~.~-fL~~~+=~~~~

• •

'~~~~

~~*~.AA~m.~.~.A~. ' A.ili~

••

~ '

•••

~ili.~-@ffi

a~~~AArJG o .~1i~-8 ' ~7.~~~

••~

S~.R'~~.fi~D.

.~'*~~~.-~1i§.A; E~E8~m$~~~.m~

•••

4~-@

~~W~

••

; ~.~~~'~~~1i~=+a~A~ma<J~.~M'

• •

m~

~~%~lfI$~*U ' ~~~PJ§5*~-yjEffU

; [l3

~J;)'f& ' ~Jff:f}f{fjffl¥Ji±l:lj[~~G*jJf

it

;

[Q]~=+--GEl 'W1i1lHJ!Hm;fNF~HiX:~1JtIJU7 rW51l:J-F$l¥J~~-'*5ffd: '~1T'

~. ' R. ,ftI'Rm ' H.Wm~

••

M$J &r~M ' .~-'~.~W~

¥jfn~J 0 ~f~~i*Et~[f,J~U~~tr}jfli-=---G1i~ffiB<J$j1~

,

~Jlt*1&~ml±l

'

iillJ1:!;;?fl

32J:r¥JI1tlilli

'

~Wf~~~*mfqj~~~a<J~~

,

?~ill®m~mJjffi~~~J1Jili

'

IE

~-=-t;1i~fB~fr~*~r~~

,

/f~~i±lJ7j-E;-

,

~t<U~~~~

,

K~Z , ~~

r

**mmt*,**

~1 ;.I!H~ft~EJ}];1D:~fJi~~~mfil¥J 0 J (42)

~-~oo , ~m.-~1i.mzM '

• •

~~I¥J~

• •

~~ffiX

••

8~~

lWf*~.~~,j]:-aJJ;)'ffii&Jfff;t~*I~&±JtMjta<J~tlj*~fJ~mo~7~~~f1R1Jt,

',:m~'q::f~~'g0¥J];-tL~1i1f-+

FJ

.=:.

+

-

El

~1~7 r~~1f§~f!!*ltt!m~~m

(40) '*i'.t~t-ik1rrr;-Aij~I!!1;k.:k.fr:/HH ' ~ 31 0

(41) 15) J:.1i • ~ 29 •

(16)

704 f~~#Jt~· ~A4~-.JI!J ~J '~B' ~~~~~7~*~'~~.~§~~~~~B*M~~m~=~~ .~ffi~~~m*W~M~o~U~~~~~~~~ :

m-ft*

rrJ.f.l:t~~~JfJ~jJE:*~~ii:~&~*~fJ1119:~' ~mttJ:L1~$Z.* ~*~'~~~~*~~ ' ~rr+-~~MMm~~m~z~~~ $&.~

••

'~*0. (M~~m~m)

••

~.o

m={,*

*ifm=WH'F-*J~z~.i£:~&~*~f£l~9:~' ~~:1tElmtJj~z.t1*

~

,

w~~~m~3trPfiJ1±Rl~WJ~h$~*~~9:.~?£ 0 M~*~z. ~

••

m , ~.m*.~0ff-~=+=~A~ o ~-f~ ~~**z.{;ttff!' (ft~AB:;~:\Hi~~:iV;S

,

~jft~~~~~ , d:l~ffJ '-rtD~gilJ;5§1Tm~ 0 m~. ~M.M~Z.~~~.~~*.~~~~OO~.~MM'.~* ~~~~~~~~&~~~$rt~~*~~oM~**Z.~~~~ 4ijs0n-7fmlm~-8~~~~ 0

~E

.

..~U~

*

.

~

.&

..•

*J;5

(

*M

••

)

.~*

*

Z.ffl.

fljlf~

,

J,:"'$'%~~Z a

~~. ~mffiffl*.&~

••

Z.2. ' #.~fiZ.$~ ' ff~A7fm~.

m

ili

a

m

tf

t*

*1f!'*~fg~.tI:l~J:j! 0

rr~m$~~

'

*~~7~.

~£

*~m

• •

z~

'

~.Mm*W.lli

f1~~1ff

'

~1Jz¥HHfcIT;tt1t!!l¥jit~~m ~0 fffi

'

jg@~)1f$~*~J}J

,

::t.z~

ESl

J'J

~~JM

as

~5<:~1tHtJj

1 1t:fjj

m

t

B;

EfJ1J:m

'

ffiJ

1ff,JJ~1T~ft:'§'~}W

3Z.

~.:Z

'i';fJJ

B

*M~~JfJ~fi.~~m~M.~~~~~a ~~,.~m-M~*B~-$~

~lJ:tit~t1Htmll5l:

'

~~~B*llI~Wf\tB:;

,

3&·~~~1~HT~~,§0~m€$rrf~.

~f)]~mZ§~ a l1V1HJJ$$*~~~-Jt~1\1f.-FJ+-BfJ!m.lt , ~*[~llJtnJtJ

EI~~~m.~~fiM. a~~m~ , ~oo~*Z~.~*~~~.~ ' M~&W

~

.mo.~

~

~~~~~

..

m~,.**~

tt

*~

'

R~~

*

• •

~m

(43) .fflit:#i · <:i~jU!1..:f7J.)IJj7ldlr.,,~.z.ijf :1t (1945-19484'-) (:it ; >k*k.~J!t:t#Jt:t P·PJj±it~·

(17)

L

J3U

&Jfftr:

=

**

:

1=# l::l:j2~if:z

~ @:mJEZVN~~

.-0

;!t

El

Jfj t)j~zt#.

~

0

/'Jf

jTJi*

¥5i

z

t§=~~

'

ffi

~ffl

:;J,mI

'

W

ffi

1it*li

~*

z

~~ffl~

~1t

*Z

Jimw

f1ilJ

A

1'

mfrJJfif

"~~~ilt~l:tl ~J}] , .:t~zmf

f

xWJcz

'if)]

B

~*8~-$1)J ./'d'ilIW ~+ qi',: m :L\~""a;;~....n.

ffi*~

lI

tQJ

t)

~t;I( ,

'lfif

i5G

N

ffjj

!i*~HI!a9m

If-~PIj' .iJj±liJ:t '

;. i\t .±. ~ ~t-'-·iII· ii it ] 05

ifd( , (14) .~~~~fr~~ffiJ.illL~tf.tlitF",5;:mtM1Jj1ii&~,§0~~1[~FJ1o~lit/EJ~

~~tt.~~ ' ~~~.~.~~~~.@

..

~~*~~~Elff~~,mm.

m

D13

~51~tih::t1r't§&"a91'~

, I2Slmm®tj*fr~?JT1[millL~H~

:"~!ltr

'

ffi]~

~tih±1r' 0

~~~* EJkJf*JJ!t!i~mI¥Jm~

,

Jlt7:J

[2SJ ~= **!i'HI~M*1¥J7fM~fi~i:Alim~

t~TlIEE?t~*5fiJ*~

,

~mQJt)~~*~8'9[[j~~~'

;

~lf~~!i1JtJtl2[2SJrFIJ<~1¥J

~t&*ffiI~lft$:t1

'

J&1!~flOOfjffij1fj~/J \ 0 f!}~ , ~1'i:?JT~zBB*4r[:jJ3i~EB

El *

91

~:tf'f*Bi¥.

'

8~!i!U&Zr~

,

EB*4I[;Z1~8"J~JiBl!~1!tl}F",5Jm~Lt.JO~ 0

1'£-:

h

lm1i

4if5*8~f)f1'FiID~1~j/~

5

0 2,41

8

0~' ffi]pJTggl±Hl'9m*it~

6

38 ,

828 001,

~@

~JitfmmM-1fB~

59 .8

%

'

~1tg-r~!q.:.IUt~~~j;'m~

8 85,7

1

4 0I11ftlW*

-

)E~1ij~~ , (45)

IZ9

lit

'

~1fm~l

246,886

0 ni

0 ;1tr~:WJ~:~~~f@*fl~J:7+

'

ffi]

!ltJ:7+a~tt*~f§~f¥J.A

'

-

nlm

1Lif:

+

=fl

fS*l¥Jf~~m~!rf.+

fl

ff1;jtB~ 10

ffl'

i:Q~~mt, tE~Jft~@fl

zFs'

, ;f§*I¥J1J~gtJ:~l

10 ffl

0 (46) 3~@r",5~:tEiEJI:

R1~ll:.

T

r.li!~~f!!*I~~~¥JJ$$J Z1~}1~Jf3~m ' ffiJMJ!jj;iEJl:Jfff.H¥~t~1!

Wi

~J!¥~*B"J~iIJ

'

J1~Ji!~1~r>l'!Hf~1J08~1l 0 ~lH~~~jle/J1Vf~

,

~D*t)

-1L1lB

E!rf.J

\F.!

~~WJ

'

~~tmm*B~1;t;f&~-:fL[g7'\1f=FJ l:~1

84 f

:g:

,

JUT

-

1L[g

-t1f:-F.J~1j:J!J:~1

4

0

0 f&

0 (47)

~lj!-~B"J~Wm~

,

IU!~1~~ffi:,§0~1J::-1L[g7\ff.-tF.J=-

EI

~;fpT

-'f@]rtra~~%

'

t§tba~±JihB~mJtR~~1*If;(

rEEJtitt

(

tihf

:fi)

13&~)(W!jo/] (~P rEB~Jt

flE

TlJ

)

J

*tJjf~ 0 ~tihmJtittZg,JJJtE8~ r~7tJ ~JE

'

ffi]

r~7CJ ~1j~mz#!:1J::

~-~~ti£8':Jn!:!iktl o

!It

rJlitltJ

~*UJi'~~R

El B

*~~~1"\

'

~i!i~l.:ltih § ~

~1j*rr;~U~~ 0 (48) t~~~1lEtH}j$$z:t:~~~jj

,

r

EB

Wft1lEJl

ZtIE

$

,

f*~1J~t~

fJEE[§fJfJl~mt=7C1Lftl1i7tg-r.,

(r'3

lEfJl-7C

'

~~~~t1JO-7C1L~1i5-}) ~:7ttJT

0

(44 ) I".¥.-,"ll. . (~~J"H;'~4/l~ait; : .=.. '::' A;'J:.l>llrlJji -Ui11~) (:f Je : BHI.J:.1t. · 1995) , 1f 100

(45) Afii:k.fft· <Jt,/~;fJl.JllJ~~;f<~r.',v[i:fJl.J>.'i) ,~t#t'lif~.i.~' H,;"'Jt~t:fll~MtJ (i Je : <f -*:SJf~Jit'o/

J.I AJ:.;fl -1tH.!t$Jf Jtflj' ,1 993) , 11 8:3 0

(46) I~B J:. ti:. , 11 87 0

(47) 51 tEl r:;!t.~.tl · (;~~r~~'i;'~4jltf,a,,;i; : '::''::'A~.f'J{f.JJ)-Ui1(.,J) ' Jf 100-101 (48)

",

1-

-

,

«.±.Jttt~~i!~) (-{Je : :t !i.1iNJ ' 1999) . Jf 223-225 0

(18)

106 .f-i'it!tJJt~. ~i\.4~-J(IJ

1jH@~-#0JT

'

-ES-[-f1lEW

8.85

0 JT

0

J(

9)

llt

Jl-

'

t-.t$0ttH1.&m~7T

'

m~

r-l:::;fJ

~+=J=l~~Hlif.Elf.#~R8i3~n3L&~I7q~tlDfPJt-"JJE ' ~-~a\(JE~*i

'

JI)(~

r~0 j<50) t) llt~~J

'

EJ

~D&,~~.~l'T~~'§0~~~~fi1JRffim~1tWlttt~J1~

[i]!l,' 0 rffi~~JltT~IHh¥$~JfJ~~1~t)1itW~tti'lzltFtrvt.

?

m~mttmJZ~rr

'

~

fF:~~EEl~1lE'trPff1~Z*~~

50,743

00 i

'

~EE1~~9:0~±:l:tMll.~~~

7 .190

~

uri,

ffij~if:z~",1:.i¥-j;~

894,

0

2

1

0 Pj ' EElttOJ~il&J1f~~~fl1JffipJT~t~~tt9*

~fJ;J, .p.::f~ 0 (51)

Jlt:9i-

'

m7tt!r1J~J118k]mtjJ3ul9:A

'

~i1i1~r-r!&~'§0~Je-::h[g1\£F-+=R

=+B~n7-~~m ,~mr0~.J '~~*~OO~.~'~.~Z

• • • •

-

rJlit

lG

J

~~5t

2.655 :1}

JT

0 (~2)

lZ9

11t

'1~;fiffiMJzI1:

rEElJlJf\:i

lE

'CfJ W

llt

r

0~*iJ

0

lJD~,

'

ft

U

m-

rJt1t7tJ

zf3tJlJft~

1

1.

5

0

5

0fh'f';J~~

tt-fflj

, i&Jff1JOmZ

~iWLML5t~

~JitffiJi~~

,

fr==)\~flj:~~Z12t

'

m7Jjj~-&~t§.tmtt

'

:ffJJjF{§Hlk]~J1$mz )i-,

i&JFf

Mz:ff

&-

~e~

-t

FHIJIJ~T

r

-

+7\~}3t.~~l~_tt¥JJfffi

J

~;!§t

1iffi

l'Tmf41J '

j~iliJM~pJT~~e!J rr~iu~tl&miffi~J ,Jt-=t:~f~#}i:tBZ~"Uim

:

(-)mJEEl-=-+7\~

~-M1t=~ ,~

r

lEm

J

:gr5

5t'

4j

ntf.t

lG

J

~JliIi:ll9:affi~+=JT (m-t11~O

:

(=)~)(

ffi\}*p~;fI , rmplT~l¥J*p lJji*t~tt9~j;IlEE

rEEljtf.t

1LE

f!

J

f¥J~tE\~~

1,000

:1} JT%"

(1'~1tt~Mi12t*29:~

1 ,5

00

:1}fr) ol2Sl 11t,*p;ZJE~~ r1*f~*~P~$&~?,!

ZmJE~~~-p'rm~~~~~~ffi~~ff-~~~a-TEs0JTMLZ~

(m+{,*m-~)

J

;

rmplT~~B'J~~ftlj~f§ r*pPlT~9:filJ~~$;~~f-JEElJlil1:1lEW '

ffi'1lEiH~tJ!1i' &~~9:U~~~p*WJEltU]!pfr~Uf1ffizmftiffi§

J

(

m

--H

t*m

~) 0

J

:¥)~~5(~;zfJl$~Ij~~I&~Jiffi

'

m$~A5tZI!9+~fr+ 0

~~J$iftm+f'*tQJj,~ , r~fjJ~plTW}~~' ~~P%Jt1\~$~16;!t~fll.f8~iL~J\

51Z+~~:J'i.Z (ElP:ttpJT1I)l:m~~~5Cj\f8~;z

9.8 115)

0

J

1f6}~t)~ftti'U~a~

*

p*~r

.

'

1 ,

500 0frl1P*pplT~5tf

ffl

fll.z:

h

+

J

\71Z+

'

t)llt

&:m

'

J'l

U

~*p~Y*~ll#}

14.

7 0 *A"

Jf83ff1.M

'

ffiJm~~ITJifj.D~

,

tE-

:tL

!l9

-t

1f:'

(~9) .f-;f;~-'f-' ( .j:M'.11i: ,}t!t (T ))) U::Jl: : i:i/.;'iSi~~r :H!l • 1984) • 1f 612 '

(50) F;j J:. i i . If 626 0

(51) .~ii*~4:· <-i:i'.t;;t~hll.JlJl ;f';-;tt r~'.f!.zzJf~ (1945--1948 Jf-) , Jf 32,

(19)

5T,

~k

r

tA

:E~*':J

' 1&.

Jf

~~jim~Z{£ ~JEijz~gf , ~

h1§"

7,19

00

APJT~t$:Jifj{J* ft~7\if:+=A ~l&Z~~~~

It%

Itt

r

0

~tfit

J

[

Dfflz

:$iWntfz

*

Effi{1§"r¥J~JR$z ;:;!tJifEn'~ffi~U

'

~5E§.=.

-!-1\if:

~-t1t*)

;

(=)~9: ~

1,000

0fT~ ~p~$lSd~$ 10fTt)...tz~

Hf:J ffi

~w:

'J!

-

J

(~-HIt~

t

o

J.Et

m~jlAit

/\

tC~1~;f1.I1~Ml t)

lt

t

&

J

tt

'

J'lU

-

iL

[g

-t;if:

'

·~±-Jt.lt+·jHiit 707

-0

t~7J(fs

EIJ

i¥J

zP:

~

J

j9:fJiUit

~

1 ,4

7

4

.j}

fT

0 ~

llt

' 1~;g:Rf~~:tt!E1:pJT

119:

1&

f¥JiiMFl

~

¥

'J

~1: ~it

i¥J-*

'

fll

J

rtr

ll:t

l5T

t~mffiHe ~*

p

pJT{i~

r¥J

±iili

'

iIDf1f~ ~~=

+

0

~Jl 0 (~3)

m~Hfi~*'

1:E

-

n

lmi::;4'

-Jtit7Cffi~&\~J!~1t8':JfflJtit~

:

(

-)

8 .

85

:'L-~

JT Et"J

rl:B

m

lI

E'flJ ;

(=)

2 .

65

5 0-fT8':J

r

0-~;fIJ

; (

:::

)

12

0-JT~J r~!tIi:!~MJ

;

~n-JmtmWt~

23.505 0JT '

rm*pt4iEl:J~Ij~\~{J}~tffil~It~9:~}\j 0 1f;!;jt)CP~*83i::;~lJffi*IT~

,

:;ttJtit7C~=+1Z!3

'

ft lja0~J[&\~~.tfi

564 .1

2

0JTEt9ffl~

,

ltt*8~~lt~·-0~.N7J<

ffl4~~JI9:1I;1:

(

1,474

0-

ff-)

B':J

38 .27%

0 EE~±tiliffl;MffiMili.:tz ~

tri

'

I2Sl

lttt

fu.:t

pfT~g r*wzf8~~0-t][.m

172 .

88 0JT

'

(54 ) Eb ll:tCiJ~O

'

&'Mio9±J;{gffl;f!itttf:tE~:f§

~i¥Jm°1:E.~=-tli.mZ~,m

• •

$~.~~.i¥J

•

...t , m~m~.:t~~ -!'.-~~ , :-X:~~W~CP/J\!ili.:tJ!~Jn~¥U;f§'i'*r¥Jn~ 0 gfHfIt~fE~ftj~

,

1:E

ill1ffir~J]JHJ,:~*H~B9~1~

,

i&)ffm;1&

r

fIE

\;1J

I¥Jmf7t*!&I&m.I1Jtt'

i!f~1#iili.:t~

¥U~1J~-MB':J*,mU 0 rmi&JN~~pJT~~BS r~5t"J ,;jt0-JEilm:>(:flHig~1Bmt~B':J

fiim,

19U

PO'

1ti::E~ft~S}3gt;~W6' r~~=+-ti:j::m-Wn~(G~9:~mm~Pfg;1B~

Wj

@

t

t!

r

f!HJfE'i7tz

-+.¥~+oJ'55) 5~t!!JJ;{;~~ftJ!'~UJ!~~~LB

:

r~~~~~9:~

~~*.'~~~~.~~D~~.o~.~~.I¥J*m~:tE~~m$

••

~.

A~~i&JffEt9~rp 0 J<56

tE

r!&~*p~~J

$5T

'

MtflW~.m*pzp~~::f*~

,

iffi;U:pJTl&mtiZ~

i:t!.

#f5N

'

(:)7) fg1t:i&m~iW3W~::f~;gff~o IiIJ~~i&~a~'a'1i1HlEtIT~:(£==J\$

(53) .}~'it VA'::' -j-.It:' tJj I'f.) .±.:It JiJ:hI" ~.l'f. It r.kp J Jt:ff i!li.f1;.t~ d~ jiJ~ .$. z.k P ;jli;l (41l I'f.)..t >ti r tfJ U;.f,l 'Ii"

J

ilf}i1L~;Il.i!l-' 00 O /":-!f:t-) . .Jt.Pfr ~tfJ Je,z Jil'lJt ~ j§,:;,>..f. -\::: 'I' ' ;(j ~Vdi1Ht. ~ :ff;f!c"St H:~

;tj ~1X:11-~~ - Al, ~ell =k:k. ir#$! ) . 1f 49 0

(50 0 ,474 /":-!f -;. 2) - 564.12 J~ IT = 172.88 J...\..fr 0

0

(55) 51 ~.JII*t· H:iIf~ .f-flt-!t,lJf')t) · 11 142

0

(56 ) ~'J;.fUUi-' .l. :t1=-~;if . (~fk:t:i'.tt!~f}~Jf» (:i3t : AM i:l: JlIi.;i±. ' 1992) , 1161

(57) ~t"'4-.t:l :Yo :

r

.f~je.~3.-j-"'Jf-~-+:it.!Il! tfJJ!;\',..f,Elt->Ji:Kllt1./l--tJi.. £j~!f VAJ:.Z :k.Gf' -A;ff .::.'.::.

r!1l'!1 f' . .:l!i~4f *"iG;lt - Ji.. '" ' 3.-"'~oiji , .Jt. 'I' VA~'f R*1i.:JL1i.f' ,;jIl;t)G:'ft3.A ' :JL3.3.J~"ffi~ it

§, , lIT itJI,~ 1i. 0 I!!I f' • .J!l ~f 4t1t.::. A • li. '" 1!!1 J~«tti ok.t . . ... 'r1i .k f' iiJ lEt .iU!iJ!Ax.Jl~ . ;ff ;r-:Y !t1'ItA. ill

1t.~~,

*

'

.It!:. EI ~~~1'rr.tt.1.. . 1iJ .kf' 519 1', Je. :1J;tr~'" j} 1;-, .i."'~N1.? 4« ~it 0 ItJ z . .kf' ftifHt M~~~~ ·~3.-j-*4-.~~~+-~~4.«.**';-1i.~~· ~t~3.-j-"'43.-\::: '-\::: -\:::

:1v":-~A~.? ' 1!l%:-I\~tIl1+.::.-+1t~AJlit~f .Jt.!fJ~' I~J'{H}fIt · J ~t~~-· H:~oftJltk (T)" 1\

(20)

108 :l~:lt#Jt~ . ~A4-;r;-J(Ij

#~~, .~~~m~.~~.*rr.*~~~~~o ~~fi~a.~~ff'~

1~*±ttEt:8~am~V1f±~lliJl!~~li 0

- f

Ltzg/

\.1f.JG

,

'i~~iI&fM~CP~*~O~fflf

~7f1T~1G~~~

,

fiX~

t:J:1

s

71<~J\+~±tiEt:8'J!nt~~~tf~m7\**ttM~]r

~m.ffi~~r~.*~

••

J ~~. , .~mlli r~fM~~~-&m.*.

*

'

U

••

-

~~

.~8'J~~~OO

'

~~

~

.ti~

,

*~~n~

r~fi**

nz:

j

I¥J

\T

~'~i1rm~, ~9m:mJi~T'&\1!ltfM~ ' P2.~mfl}]~@I-§-J!I!!¥J~~ 0 Jl5b)

fJ£

J

::.j

zjj;

Q

g

CPEJt)1#~D

'

J;iB~fr'B9

r

H?,mH~a-B-

J

-tn~±±1l2d9:~ijE~!(?A1T~J}J

~~.~.~- o .~~ffiUm.~-B-n~~.ffi~~~ , ti~t:p~.~7f.~

tJ*

'

~JT:)fdJf~t{gmf!;JjiliWla.7f-fl8'J±t~a)(1fi

,

J;llr±*tffl±~ter~

,

:t=!;±ttBJ'l1J

fBn~!I9:

'

fi"f:§7~jl11JI¥JIDt~,1:EiHl'mtftlJ 0

1'£-

fL

tzg

/\

.1f.

'

~~~Jff~l[{jt.tl¥JfI]ifj ~~

,

1~'I~t5lJl!Jf~~~

,

~~~~-WITi1PI¥Jfe;~~Et9jIW~~T 0 ±iB:±fr~~Jk~ffl

~~~~~W~~ ' ~.~~~X~~.~ ' ~~W~~~~-B-~ o~~ , ~~

@Miii*~

,

li.z

p,Ff

t). ~'ff1ftl!±fihc5l:l¥

'

7J:ij!~ 7f~m* §1J~

t:J:1

*,

±c~I¥J!JI~

~ 0 (!i9)

ItSl

Jl

t

'

=--G.li7~ffl;!:t'Jt~~:fEl~~~~i¥Ji&m'\:t

' tz

D~~.mgt~7F : r~.=

~.li.m~~~ , ~~~*~ , m~~m~'ll.~~m81¥J~. ' i&mtt*~

~71Lftj:,~7~mm~~~eagmnffi,**~ij~~IDRm~oJ(60) *~~tM~te

:

r~

tt!1251:1fia~*gr:Mz7f~;ff1,tE~±t{g~5fljm

'

rm~;ff~~~'~I¥J~;fI 0 J (6])

~ffiJ

'

~IDi~~~1'J=-t:;1L~mB:;f

,

~P~~:mtB ~I3)jI¥J~m~JI9H

'

~7~jJH~

~~~~~[OJ~ '1~p,Ff~fj~~$JtlJ~~~HlJ;\~= :

r

-;!ik~*~1'Jt~J&~~tlt~

=.m~e

••

I¥J.~~~.~~~ : =~.~~:±~~M.mti

• • •l¥JfLm

l~-wr~~~ft-*oJ (62) :§tt;ff~1i~.~CP ' j[~;rr~~~Iitft::j:~I~:I~~~~&J~'.~~

t~iFFf~f7~iB~~~ffi! ' ~1iQ1rHhJji~*5t~=-t:;1L~fil

'

rmmE&a~.1:J!lll!EB~

-' .~~~5fUJT:)~~~fMi¥J~mM~&~~cp*,M.~I¥J±~25I:¥o *~~~illt~~.=.-t:;1i~m~.fj1ftl!~~~~;m

,

i'iJ

t) 1~~D

EE

[}jfi~:£l&I¥]

(58) ~I tJ ~.tt

'

«-1:;toIf ;(j .t-1k1t :ltS}f-!lt ) , Jf 146 '

(59) Hsin ·huang Michael Hsiao. Covenmumt AgricuJtuml Stral.egies in Taiwan (md SOlltlt Ktma:

Macro.)()ciological Assessment (Taipe i: In5t itute of Ethnology, Academic Sinica. 198]), p. 46.

(60) {~1IJ"r' fkMl.-~· (:f: ;""1r.st'±'Je~$.:Ii.-t-;&1f-t7.i~LRH:'&i~-t-Ie.~) , Ji 189 0

(61) f5J J:.1i ' Ji 203 0

(21)

' ' 0

ti&

~

B91ifiHT

'

~

J1BCPI!fJ*I~a9

'1~

3"

1\**

trM¥lI

~-?V

f8

m*ftm

~

JLif

r

~~*

*

5-J!!I¥Jil&~ 0 jUi8) 1Jfjg~~fJnt(;J/J 9:J~~j]~~e<] tfj r~

,

~:±:ttBrlU

~

~JjJ

J:

r¥J

~1J~D

tfu.:t:

1r1~

7

~fE~

1=

1ZSJ

1lt

'

fE

;ft

~r:p~±c&1':l9~ r,t~tR :

rtf-=.

~

, i&tiJ

'Ii*M

~

tl!

J/j

!±l

:

r

~ jl61)

3'

~7JHfm :~'ff.f~~ tt~ #~jl"a9n{I1: ~~7~'~~1N R9.:t:~~El3z

iJo

~.:t:i&:!¥J£f~ SOIt/h J(orea: A ), p. 46. 1:i'.f J:..;Ml.Jf.-J!i.~:{J1. 10:

1§JEJ(J07J~=-t;E~fJ3.i&~1l0Th89:±?i~'

ffij;!t

p

fTfflT

*jl¥J

,

7J;lj!mWZ.8·9®tm~ffio

~'IhJJj-J:¥$~l¥JrtJ~mb'i ' jl:tQ1Ee1~:tt!Et1f5/f1~/f~i:ri&JfJpfTN?I&I¥JJEjJ~ ~J1:0 t ,

3&J~

r

5i-

IZ9IDl

J

I¥Jm~1J;pY:;ij!ili?&~$Jf)H\1¥J 0

Ji

..

1}:tt!!

1i5cm

?&fffl ' J:

~f1flj=-t;E~mi&~Z*ff~pJT~~UI¥JK6mff1

'

~f§ilit:iJ~m;IB0:t-lli

1ijzt;Jt~ ? rtlJ~J~;~J ~~iQ~t)fl'%.&i&m.:fj{fi0:tili1itz~i&~8~@~?iiffH~tHt

t)1%1£-1Lgg-t;1f8~==J\~{tj:.:L1~

,

El:1ID~*m::lf~~5€'&'A±f¥Jn1IzW

'

I

?tJ}~~~JJ!~~~:E~ffl

'

/fI&

~~ffiiiJ

&:

m

~tl5j I'f{] ~if

'

ffij ~

i:tt:fi=

-t;.Ii

~fJi

zffiU~~.~W.I¥J~lZSJ o ~.~.~~~.~*m.0~~.i&.~

• •

~?~~1£-1L~-t;" -1LggA1fM'

•••

~7~0.~m.~.# ' fffi~ti

~*:g,f.j~7~~0R]

,

{5iU~D~~mrJfi

..

±m!lHf§I*

..

JJtfi€.m~

..

{&m:*ftlkli

'

.&.

r~fl;IH\W-:tHJ!NIi~

,

.~m~frJ~rzg*~~rnn:;

••~~;lttg.~

z±j:iJJ~~@]

El if

'

~j,**#WI39f83.f:E~1I{rn~~pfT¥t 0 {5iU~o

'

-1LggJ\if-1:f~~~il&}(ff.ffTi&~aJ

f~~cj:J

ge*;if;

:

.

*

~

•••

~

••

~.*

'

.P~.

'

.~~@

'

.~.m.*.

~~~M.

'

~..'

....

~

.ff

'

M.M.

'

.~

'~

.

'

.~

'~

4·~

~

· ~~

'

tt

ili

·~

*~

'

~.*

· ._'~

••

~.~~~ ' _~.M '

...

~ ' .#~. ·

..

~~~M~~~~ o *M~.&~ " 4~~+~ ~,m

••

%~~*~.~.~~~.~, ft~_~~I.A.~ o ~

x~O~$IJ.~~JJl~~1Ii~lWf

'

-n

~-t;4-

FJ

=

+

J\

B

~mJmtJ~[~ ~~~~

BJMf83*ll~'

(

w1f:§

E8~> ~~'4=fj

=

+=

B

M7.~*m~EtJ¥~~ ' :(£~t4l!i0

~~~M.~*.~ , -m.~.;if; :

(22)

110 ~~Jt.ijj-Jt . ~~A~~-.j(IJ

1£

~

ifk

/~111i ~~

4-

E ' -

fJJ

/f

1}

~ ~ ft.]

*

'I~

f

MJl

lUi '

.It:t

/I

*-

W.

~f

g

~~a~

••

~~.~'*.

~A

••

'

~.*.ff~.~.#·l£.

~ ~

#tl

Jt

.1l1

5 /f

j@

tJf

.

Jl

fU~;ff ~I!. ~• •. , ,~ltjj jt !li/C 71~ :f;k)t' ~~ff

'

1~"

.~~.~;.**~ ,x w.~.~. I**~.~ ' .~/f*.M'

.ffi_~.~~'~/fIA.~~ffi~ ' #~~~~.~~ffi~ ' ~~

• •

~~.~~1}~ '~.~A

••

!~

§5fj-{1LWt.l~~Jg~/F

:

«~

••

ff~.~~* '

•••••

~~. ' 1£f~*~~:t~~MM

~)m~~~~ ; ~~~~*.-A~'~~~~*.~ A~~~~~'

%~.~~ft*.~~ ili. ·

••

~e~m

••

~_~~.ffi·~A1£

ffl~.~~.%~ ,a~~~*

•••

' h~/f.A. ' X~

••••

•

=I4.~

••

' .~K

•••

~A ' /fffl~.~

••

M.~ ' ~~ *~~~ ' #~~.~A I~.#~ ! ~ ~~~.~~,~§~~.~mlli*

••

~~&Mn·~m. ,m~~.~ : r~ ~It~~~~~~

,

~~~*fr;ilif~~~fXfrJn,~ ? 1-t*~*Fl"J~~"ftJt)j§J~t.t~ fX1r'Pi~

?

J

§3~mu.~ill~7F

§

2*ffi!B"J~~~m,

r

~fZ9h1t~~~~

El

AJF.f~~~

l3~fUftlj

,

:W;1i1.~fjE~:m:~~

f::l

'

X~o~fX~B"J.R~iH}jillm

B A

1"F~

,

1t<~f;t$~

JDti3tf:EB~~:1J 0 J (66) $$tiR${1-t~utU~~7]\ E1c~~ifPqT.' ~¥m rw-~f't-J~1H#f-~

fJf!.Jf1~~8;t ~

:

~~~.~.~ ' .~/f.M ~~~ ' 4B ~~

••

0~~*~' Jl« ~relm~*.~~£. ' ~~~~*/f~.~'~~~~~

••

' ~ ~~.~~*'~~~~

••

Jl~

••

0~~,* ,a~~~~~~~ ~_~~

• •

~#.o ~ (64) il; Jtj1 ;V i. ' ( J:. JG &. $ Jt #-) , Jl 420 0 (65) J"lJ:.1i ' Jf 422 0 (66) fJJ ..I:.

u.

'

1f 423 -424 0 (67) JOl ..I:. tt ' 11 424 0

(23)

{X j)) ~f

*

*#'1'±;Jt

~W

'

1~"

~gi!lm

'

=m

~

,

jlp

Jlt

:;7

M

if.]

1{fJra'

(jf{t~ , fJ,\ ,

mi 11

it

~1f~tf~ ~PI

'

f1[

ijE

fa

t.W«

~ :

r

{i@ ~1iJ.l-~~t~ttl~

fi:

B

A

~

1-

t*m~

~

,

{t(~lfOJH'~ w~a'Jr~I)H#1~ ~-t

'

J!HX

~.1.ft

'

~ H12.~*:;7 i:~J:. Jt,a..f-J1i-fi it 111

fiJltt

liJJD

'

mfRl&~'J:tJJ1f1~:Pm8~~IfiM~~pJT~¥UB'J75~

,

.R~~~~¥U~1i

0'RlJ:

t&f't'J

m

1J

'

/fl~/f¥MfUTJ% 0

f.t1f~1f:£

B

*~mtttWcl:ti~9:rml~I¥JI!~±i~

,

~~~i&JfJ@:*~~~$J;1t:fB(fii~

~M.~, m.-A~*~+=~=+-B0~Zr.~.0WM~~m.$J

m=. ' 0~M~Z~.~: r%rnBAa*.ffi~Z0~rnm'&

• •

Z0m

Jill '

~4

_B

_AU

_.f

_LWm

_tfu:tf

0

J

fU~:tE1NmTJH~Z~

,

mff!{t(:mtRi~t~7F*

;f.Jf11O'

tJR$~~+=i~mtt§tii: rL5tIlBA~ffrt~0WMtth~fiil& ' m~{t(~

~0~~R~~£~.~fi , ~.~;1t~.a~oJ/f~~~~OO~mQ.0a

aJ

_

t

PJ-1j-i&[l1c1i?mt~~ ~~P~1-:iEJZ~J!

'

~1f~-A[2}j/\£j:.+,Fl

=

+

.=:

B

~Jj-i&~Z0)(gt~~ : rn:~~~~ITiEJ1:~'§'0:W ' m~$J.~0:f[±:l:th~fm

re.~ ' ~fr~.**~~~ ' ~~~$~~M~.0'Rl±~tE~'~~~~0

~JZ~1-¥

'

~~~[l1c!f;f~~P&'0'Rlffl:t1!z

'

~MJIlrt!1j-i&~'g0~~T7ti'fcl~~

,

f,ft0=gj

£m!

/f3&f.JJ

J£

'

JUmi~fH~m~~J¥J 0 Jf68l ~1J~:lL:~IjJj~~~lt. 0

iliOP~r&¥U~~~~~B~~?mt~$ 0 ~~i&JfJ@:*~t~Hfl'Ut1'Ti&*1§'WI~

-ft.~~.~ ' @~ITi&~

• •

~~.W~/f~~. o ~.~-A~E¥+=

Jj -

B

,~~~tiiJ r~iJIlVjfIJ~~~[ljJ ,tE~~~$~1S-cpgtEY3 Elmtii~~I¥JI

~:1~iytf~t)J1i!t~~~{,\

,

;1tfiQI¥JI~~-,&~£~T'f~

,

;fft€~mkM~' 0 ~l1t

'

fitJj

~~1t!f-tE-A~E!if-+=Fl

=+

=

El&t~$fHj-i&:~*7f-.lI9:IH~S']1t.~ 0

mih

I&~w!iJ~jJt7f-

'

r~~jfim{~~tH~i&JffH~ftJ&~~

,

~~'§'0~

,

~~1j-

,

Ed;i~id1Oflrr~~/fJJDA

ji

*

J

'lZSIlIttE*~f~fl~1j-i&*'§'

0 oif

I¥J

lfiJJl

Z

M

'

1'T

~~W.~ft*~8~~*.m7a~

•••

m~

••

~.~ o ~

..

~

..

1E~JJ1~T'iTt)rrtHIBI5:B:

'

~J&~Jtfj±:l:ttl¥J~1liiJ~~

,

rmill:;m1=r~

El

~51 *;f§'~

~·(IBIk~m~ 0

19iJ~D

'

f§lfiJEt9m~I~~ID-tlH~~a~nt~

,

~Ri~~@:~f~l¥J±:tth

'

-1$i&@J

~V o ~

• •

i&Jff~~~:f[~.~~.~Z~ ' ~-A~t!if-t~+-El:f[-ffi

¥J:~i&JffI¥J0)( (~~MJfjJthfl~~-tA1\=i1IJC)

:

(68) 15<)t:t ~ , ( J=-Jt?t if-:!t#) , Jf 499 0

(69) I*-~ft · <r*-'r~J ~ r'J' 1: i'ifJ 6~i''!~~J{f-Y). 1fi!§.-'t)lir~l:~;lJHn.-k't~;f-UlJ~a4'-~i!,