1
!"#$% &'()*
A Study of Organization Performances That Volunteers Participate in Nonprofit Organization Coproduction +,-NSC88-2416-H-110-036-E18 ./0-123 456-789:;<= > ? @ ABACDEFGLISREL HI@ JK6AL M!N OPEQRST() U M!A.?VWEGXM!Y$Z ![\C]()^_F`ab A56cdEGDVefg hijklmn opA56Eqr s]topAM!u6Evwxy A![&'wC'z{EG X<|}~fh$Z![& 'A() - M! Abstract
This study has two purposes. First, using LISREL to construct “volunteer coproduction model” to understand organization factors that effected volunteer coprodution and the organization performance after volunteer coprodution. Second, Using two-way ANOVA analysis to research how to combine different attributions of nonprofit organizations (NPOs) with different styles of volunteer coproduction and different volunteer management functions will produce more organization performance. Finally the study will propose NPOs how to
manipulate volunteer coproduction and make the missions of NPOs will come true early.
Keywords: nonprofit organization, coproduction, volunteer. F BA- B AR -F EFRA E! AdEn ¡¢ £¤¥¦§¨©ª««Ey¬ U®¬¯ °±² (Rothschild,1979)D ] \ ³ ´ µ (donors) ¶ ª · ¸ µ (contributors) E ¹ z [ $ º » (¼)(community) (common)AB ½(Drucker,1990)E ] m ¾ ¿ ´ À Á  à A Ä Å ± Æ (Levine and Fisher,1984; Whelan and Dupont, 1986; Parks et al.,1981)
Çm¾ÈÉAÊ E@ Ë ÌÍÎL M!PA NOEkVq ÏkA v#ÐÑAÒkÓE M!YE°8 ÔÇ !µÕÖµA×?ØÙE UÚÛÜ !µÝÞÕÖµßà* áAâãEGäåB½y æ(Kao and Yang,1997a)EçèbKao
2 and Yang(1997b)Aéê ë[ M!YE$ì56Aí î/ï#AðEçñF l mòÕÖµAßàEóônV Çõö÷øõöNùÚ()úÅ ûAüý QþEC ë[ M!YGxyúÅA û z { (Sharp,1980; Bjur,1981; Rosentraub, Mark, and Sharp, 1981; Brudney and England,1983;
Thomas,1987)Ferris(1984)`2Aë [ M!G ú ÅAL '¢PLi'¢PE% 8 '¢A Z¦ áy¬![Ei'¢ A `VÇä$Z ÄúÅA£ Q M!\C´Zz 56AúÅ !"qdEç#w$qlmB ½¼%A&'íîEQ\C´Z A(ä D uK)- 1.@ JK6AM!NO éê YEJ¬AM!*ï NOEÌJ+- *ïYM!NO®,-./Ì 2.ab@ Au®+E z{M!Añ01E$ Z 'w2C®,dA·¸E3 %845$Z B½Aä6´ |Aüä7A GX úÅûAz{«VQq 8sM!E9GC'Aä B½yæ 3.Ð? ì56AÄÅ@ º»-E`:;<AM! ñ01*þE=ç>?@å R 'wÈAAEVÇR 'wAABEváC Ä Å@º»-EÐR 'w ÈAnDE'C'AE FECGÇA! E VÚ$ ! HIA()EUÚJ ª AÄÅ@º»- 4. Ð?z{M!0 1E rs1M!7KE%LM AAEN1O.<$ZM! A[P/AíîÇEò QRSÎTEUV A@WXY¾7« 5.Z 1O.<$Z M!A7KZ[E:;\1O.< @]A|J."þE\å þR^ÆA()E4_$Z a`aîA d^ÆEº'b AMcd^ÆÐ$ZAa` dd1E`1O.<Re5@fAÍ "gEdr1M!A7KÇE ¹h¬#1M!aî ![& ' 6.óÐiCCMc^ÆENF º'b#j P/ì56y ÎE3k$Úy¬1O.<$ ZQlm×?dAnoEÚp¤S ξ 1 ξ 2 ξ 3 η 1 -0.41 0.49 0.62 0.72 -0.89 0.61 0.24 0.19 0.46 0.57 0.71 0.39 η 2 η 3 η 4 η 5
3 !"#$%&'()* + ,-./01234 567 89" 7.:;<= 0:;)* >?@ABC 0DEFG HIJKLMNOPQ1 RST*U9V!CWXY Z[\]^S_)*`a (bcd efNgS_h*ij kleAVWXYZ[\] PAm)*`an on0p CBCqrstu; v wxPyz)*bcoe{ |}~A {(} `a(b cW=]@ANgS_ *ijk HI<= ., PVqr!"#$VW =]S_)*bcfy z*&ijkA 0kS_ W=] ZW=] )*bc= CW =] W¡>=]d BC *i0 NgS_kM = ¢:£9|¤¥PV¦V{| )*bcdW =]o§¨©ª«X¬e ®¯yz© h°\© ±jk²bW³´=]µ ¶ 8.Q1 ·¸¹)*> ?º»:e34 ¼ :¹½·¾¿) * =»§¨©)**ijk :ELM HIJKLM S ÀÁÂÃÄyz ŸÄ(Æ ÇÈ" ɧNg ÊS_)*jk Q1 ËÌ)* ^mÍAÎÏstqr À(ÐÑ¢f ÐѵÒÓÔ Õd @eS_BC u;Ö(ÀÖ·t×Ø ÙÚ(ÛÜ 0·u;ÖÀÖwºÝÞµ £92VßA à 0áâßAo§*i:E [\Uãäxå§* æç ÖRfqrè鸹êë (ìíhAîØ Rï éØ\¢ð0áâñU ã òº£óôá"õö ÷ føùúZ,Ì1û ZüýþZ*( d @Am)*¾ Aó w HIR r)* hLMNO"Ä,-. /Ä(>?"BC Ì )*0Ng)*bc( `an BC *ij kn Eäx:; <=Z#$ :;)*=BC *ij k0Ng¶B C *i0¾NgkM ÄHI HI 5JKLMX ËQ 1 J\(!" ±0 #¹$%"(FG"ܪS V HIR r V&' r
4 Rf0ª«()t*¤»0S _+,-µe.Bl«()Ì º/HIfS_ t*" (01" 2Ä'÷G
Bjur, Wesley E.(1981), “Coproduction in Human Service Administration”, International Journal of Public Administration, Vol.3, pp.389-404.
Brudney, Jeffery L. and Robert E. England(1983), “Toward a Definition of the Coproduction Concept”, Public Administration Review, January/February, pp.59-65.
Ferris, James M. (1984), “Coprovision: Citizen Time and Money Donation in Public Service Provision”, Public Administration Review, Vol.44, July/August, pp.324-333.
Kao, Ming-Rea, and Dong-Jenn Yang(1997a), “A study on Behavior and Recruitment of Volunteers in Nonprofit Organizations -- In the Case of Kaohsiung Museum of Fine Arts”, Pan-Pacific Management Review, Vol.1, No.1, August, pp.125-140.
Kao, Ming-Rea and Dong-Jenn Yang(1997b), “The study of Service Quality in Nonprofit Organizations -- A Case Study of Volunteers Coproduction in Kaohsiung Museum of Fine Arts”, International Conference on Comparative Management Proceedings, May, pp.333-339.
Levine, Charles H. and G. Fisher (1984), “Citizenship and Service Delivery: The
Promise of
Coproduction/Response/Discussion”, Public Administration Review, Vol.44, March, pp.178-189.
Parks, R. B., P. C. Baker, L. Kiser, R. Oakerson, E. Ostrom, V. Ostrom, S. L. Percy, M. B. Vandivort, G. P. Whitaker, and R. Wilson(1981), “Consumers as Coproducers of Public Services Some Economic and Institutional Considerations”, Policy Studies Journal,
Vol.9, Summer, pp.1001-1011.
Rosentraub, M. S. and R. Warren(1987), “Citizen Participation in the Production of Urban Services”, Public Productivity Review, Vol.10, Spring, pp.75-89.
Rothschild, Michael L. (1979), “Marketing Communications in Nonbusiness Situations or Why It’s So Hard to Sell Brotherhood Like Soap”, Journal of Marketing, Vol.43, Spring, pp.11-20.
Sharp, Elaine B.(1980), “Toward a New Understanding of Urban Services and citizen Participation: The Coproduction Concept”, Midwest Review of Public Administration, Vol.14, No.2, June, pp.105-118.
Thomas, J. C.(1987), “Neighborhood Coproduction and Municipal Productivity”, Public Productivity Review, Summer, pp.95-105.
Whelan, Robert and Robert Dupont(1986), “Some Political Costs of Coprovision: The Case of the New Orleans Zoo”, Public Productivity Review, Vol.10, Winter, pp.69-75.
