醋酸正丁酯反應蒸餾系統之設計與分析

Ö7ÒÚïE7ãPڍ6b

I2

»+/F< €

= ‹

ß–E7ö6ÓÞE7!öãp•*ØÞE7ã+5Íc'

Ó\7</E7!ù"¯áˆ‘ÔªQߧF¯ ØÞçGQ

΍jÀá  >9œ–}E7ã+*XÖUÒÚï&€(

6˜#EE7¡•ô^^Q
Õ^Ø^^âb^ áX
÷ÖUÖUjØuˆF¯ô.y¯=÷bE7ϼ<¤Æ)

­6˜u:¦9©êÞgÎAY^ }E7ã+*XÖU ÒÚïÞ&€ªQߞ¯Ͻ( ؀Úa¶B

oßE7ãÖUÒÚï(6˜

 

    

     

$%#%

7KH FRXSOLQJ RI SK\VLFDO VHSDUDWLRQ DQG FKHPLFDO UHDFWLRQ RFFXUULQJ LQ D GLVWLOODWLRQ FROXPQ DQG UHDFWRU UHVSHFWLYHO\ LQ RQH XQLW RSHUDWLRQ WKH VR

          

                 

                 

              

              

+/ ÐéÛá Ðì Ô¼ÝéØ2 

Journal of Technology, Vol. 17, No. 3, pp. 445-453 (2002)

 +/ ÐéÛá Ðì Ô¼ÝéØ2

Ø0 

ßGÚ< &P–E7ö6ÓÞE7!öã p_*ØÞ+P½A™æ঍iØ+ÍE 7ã²Øƒ|¯²Þ&P+Î7á‰

îµï& ½lG ½</ ½E7ã€ÚB

&  Yï0Jäïƒíž6ßãUHFWLILFDWLRQE7

`éVWULSSLQJìΡ¾i…I­ž¯E7!ú ØÍãp‘^zE7¡–E7¢Cßã

¡`é¡ß¯ÏE7Ï6Ó:Ì_*E7ã

؜ÞE7ãÍc'G’Á«²(o8¤XÎé

|E7¼<¤‡6ÀáE7Ž<E7â˜ Ø DužX³ÏŽ<6ÓiÌ+už3 ï<<Œ<Š<X</E7³%žáz6Ó

³GÂ$„*ÏB6Ó & þ¶ŽƒÔå ħzˆ"6³yœ„*Ï>@v}ü<ãÞ^Q6 Ó:±Âq6Ó„*Ï(oöF¯ñáß'ñ€ó

ÀáEUã6Óߞ ÖÂÞ+{\È Pƒ

Z¼ (DVWPDQ </3¦µtÞÖUåïÞî9EU

ã&€EU¥½<௢ίa?/!Z¼¾ž

ç/ÏçÎn‹ßŒìÎEU!öãZãpÞÖUåï

&€XªnØZEUãpöÌZmÞ÷Ï0\

p»¼«²ÞÖUåïÞà¯XÎEUã5Íc' :9G­­'Yc</EUîË*}EUãÞ^Q –4Ñ*+{\Èí–</EUØ nÍo}

íg

 4ãpÞF¯â˜í</EU*Íc–ÉÞEU

?¤

 Íc²</EU¼<¤ž£EUã}é|

 tà</EUcÞEU$ãpž‡6Àá

ßEUã*ƒØÍG5]¶Íc­R

òÈUá4</ ½ïÎy/Ï4ãp–E UgGÚH–6Óãp½ ‘Ô­'}

Ø4EUã€Úäz6Ó\U</EU!

ù"¯á¹i€ÚÔ©|˜'bQ–ïÈ«ÿ Q=\FF¯ô|B˜:¦&WˆªQ¹žF

¯Q› ¬ë§ÞF¯ ØÞçqQŒëH

dFE7ãÞAy‹’Á

 E7œç$çÈ«Þ#Eis¾y‹E¢E7

œç/ Q$ç/ QÈ«ôDÿQˆ


 €6˜(*XuË<&W >iJ

ˆ¯€Ú6˜F¯ž–QA­ä&W QÞ

™òt©cìÌYÜîâ:¦Q     

î:¦Q     Í>:¦Q 

   :¦&W©ê"at©"Þ ØÛ

1 E7ãùP

 œW >iJy‹Ï™òœW Q£i Qð

¤6˜œW–t©€ΗÍc:¦&W¼Ê

  ˆªQ¹œW– ‘Ô


­Ï ØcoÞ[¥KÏ'ñL  Xà


 Xà
 éÖF¯ Ø^¬Þ¯ß­%

ÿ{ÍœÞ ØY°ጠ P Xà


µK3éYÜÌG Ø  Y°} Ø y¯a÷˜E7¼<¤    !
 "KÀ á'bQ ØY° Ø*XÖ7ÙïE7ãp4

### P$! Xà
%}4Q &' Ø! Øà¯|

÷˜ÙßÔE7ãpu( 
)Ké"

Þ ØÛO} ØØؐÞE7ãp

ÀáE7ã–</E7y‹04ï<

<Œ<E7ëH3áE7ã+ƒ¥½<Hc

€äzE7ã+9oAs¾'ñþ‘Ô

—J%Û¥½_ÜÖUÒÚïÏØQÞc _ØÍ'³Þ؋çžäƒâéˆ{

±" céˆsÖϳÞ':Øy‹

7á4n^½ /½Á=½©Ò–¯V‡

jޒÁ    ö   4z½˜

²6¾cØÎP¯ !" ö #"" üÞÖUÚ︙

j  K4Q'c²§¯ !" üލj

_î4 $""# P/i΍jµßôD}ÖUÒÚ Ô4E7ãp–ï<E7*XÖUÒÚï&€‡

΍j#EÞ.ê} &KHP&DG >9œ(Î€

­#EE7¡•ô^^QÕ^Ø^ ^âb^áX÷ÖUÖUjØuˆF¯ô.

s2Ö7ÒÚïE7ãPڍ6b 

2 }E7ã*XÖ7ÒÚïùP

y¯a÷˜E7ϼ<¤Æ}6˜ÎPªQ

0\ÖUjØuÞÖUX4î<ßÜ</

½Ïئ‹wÅ7 ¨Þ¯ß4':¦‹ÞPB

FƒßåUßåï
    X&

DÅP0c˜¯ÏÖUjØuޯੳ4 }ÖUE7ÏUØE7ú»¯àÞÖ UjØu}¼0ƒ÷FƒßåUP¯W 

13ãÈ`¹áÞÖUOPW  13

ãYáÚ9 ½'Y¯àÞÖUj ØuÖUÞg˜:ôÏ,z  Œ  !

/iÎAúßôD}gb
ÖUjØu

A.êÀáE7ã+ßÖUjØuYãÖ UÒÚÔ–E7àXÍ+{ŠÃÖUÒÚïÞ

^Q}–ÖU0\

ßÖ7ÒÚïE7ãPڍ

ÎAµÏÀá   b9œ(}ÖUö ÒÚÔEU*XÖUÒÚïEUãp&  ΀

Úù€EUãp06ßã¡EU¡`é¡ì Ρ¾ßã¡ö`é¡Þ¯á¶B"Ø ãp÷<

pdp:¯a¡¾ïí%cØν!öØÎ J6³!</EUÏ4EU¡0–Y–EU



_{ }__{ }  _{ }_ _ +∆    

pdˆ+½¢6c_9j9c_9uœ

^ ù Œ p 0  j «  J  j 9 u œ K  J ù  p

³äzã³G\žÊ/E7ƒàX¯Ï

¶*™Rªç¨/H &KDWHOLHUV SULQFLSOHi•ß3 E7(¯Ï^(–¹E7¤é|ØÖUÒ ÚÔE7àXÖUÒÚïj€Ú'X³

Ø Ö7/ÒÚÔ/Ö7ÒÚï/jPÚ'X³Ï

³/öáX(1atmí)

π ³/°& $PRO %PRO &PRO 'PRO

$     

%     

&     

'     

%&     

%'     

&'     

%&'     

Ü$ÖU%ÒÚÔ⇔&ÖUÒÚï'j

ß Ö7/ÒÚÔ/Ö7ÒÚï/j€Ú$ç/¤^

X $ % & '

$QWRLQH <ô

$    

%    

&    

'LPHUL]DWLRQ ñô

'    

'    

81,48$& <ô 8LM

M ÖU M ÒÚ Ô

M ÖU ÒÚï

M j

L ÖU    

L ÒÚÔ    

L ÖUÒÚï    

L j     81,48$& £ô

7    

6    

ϳ/áX¤^



³ÏÒÚÔÖUÒÚïÒÚÔjÖUÒÚïj

ØÎì.³ÏÒÚÔÖUÒÚïjÎÒÚÔ

ÖUÒÚïXî9KRPRJHQHRXV³ÏÎö' î9KHWHURJHQHRXV³ÏØXáX<ߞ

<³ÏXÞÌwγ/õß<

:±³ÏÞXߧF¯ö ØÞçqQö‘Ô QäzÖUÒÚï³Gu|Çiy¯aßä p:\0

}&W b9œ(i€ÚYn$ç/¤^B

ßYï4 /H\HV  2WKPHU>@Þ[¥é»Þ}ÄU

È«4"â˜È«g˜íEUϯÏa

<œç/ôB:±ôB+E¢ž ÖE7?¤

39HQLPDGKDYDQ Xà>@

 +/ ÐéÛá Ðì Ô¼ÝéØ2

ì E7ã€ÚÄÎ.¯g

 ^ g   ã p " ~

ÖU ÒÚÔ ß㡕ôã½! 

âbž&   `顕ôã³! 

EçDWP   pdEç  DWP

ùNPROKU   pE«  DWP

1 .06

D D D

D N

U= _{Ö7 ÒÚÔ}− ^{Ö7ÒÚï j}

Î 7 O…„*ÏEU?¤Ώœ a

,Lu9ÿQ.₀₆Ï$ç/ÀÊñôÀáß$

ç/¤^} 81,48$& Qð(ÿQ<ôÃ_J

©.₀₆☏<­4 a°& Q›0.₀₆

 <

/iÎA3áÀîÃ
 }(

E7ãpN_IƒE7?¤ñôΏœ


+uÀ^±Ö¢



 





H[S 7

N₁ = −

Î % ƒâ˜œ°

ìY} >9œ(E7ã€ÚÄÎF

¯gE7ãpÏF¯4؈-w„(3-«

ßã¡`é¡Þ•ô'( 
wÖUÒÚÔ6

¾} °
ˆ-^
 Þgí

E7¡uï¸uí¸âp04E7ãp0

³ÞîÊQ6¾

B)¤

 

















_L+ _{M+ M+ L}+ _{M− M− L}− _{M ML}− _{M ML}+ _ML=

M

M] 9 \ / [ 9 \ / [ 5

)











M= Q9− L= Q.

 

 _{ }





 ₋ − + =

− Q L Q Q L QL

Q₉ [₉ 9₉\₉ % \₉

/

îÊQ

 





 + − − + =

+ _{M+ M+ M− M− M M M M U}

M

MK 9 + / K 9 + / K 4

)





 M= Q₉−

 

 

 ₋ − + + =

− Q Q Q E

Q K 9 %+ 4

/_{9 9 9 9}

Î3₉3_.Á•ô</XÁô % p:^

)_M/_M9_M6¾ƒÐ M •^
’ã^ù

i5u9ù`9ùv4Ð M •3^K4

³îÊQß3^5[_ML\_ML]_ML6

¾ƒÐ L Î</X4Ð M •u9`9^…

z 6 g  K_M +_M6 ¾ ƒ  Ð M •  u 9  ` 9 a

 5_MLÐ L Î</X4Ð M •EU?¤

3 "Õ^(ÖU"ï¸ÒÚÔ"í¸)w^â˜

 25°C ³gÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<

¤o<

" 7 " 6¾ƒEUa
   ³!$_-


  4p03</EU–•¸³

îÊQß35_ML"₇5

Àá}ï黤^(E7ã€Ú
E 7¡•ô
 ap:ÖUÒÚï÷bÒÚ Ô¼<¤³g  <i

žt©Î€ÚÍc:¦&9©ê4EUã€Ú

äz9ÀÊEUÀÊÞ9"¯á¹îâôB³ gôBy¯a÷˜EUϼ<¤!ñ©:

¦&9©ê4Ù±F¯Q›0"Þîâôû¯à 9"ÞôÃi©ê4GÚã­E4

ßÕ^ޜI( EU¡uï¸uí¸Þ

¶í
t©ÖUÒÚï÷˜ÒÚÔ¼<¤

ÏEU•ô§ƒ§w¹€ÚÔ©:¦&9

³gF¯Q›ú§äzpdc³ÏÞ¯à

ƒ³Ï%ãØJÞEUϹÒÚÔ¼<¤È

¹4|³gí*Ï¿Ö   ϳg 

EU•ô
§  a'X4p06¶i`

ïÌEUÏ!ã•ô§aÎ4p0$È–EU

s2ÖUÒÚïE7ãPڍ6b 

4 4Õ^^âb25°Cw³g5¶í

E7•ô3<7='X4p06¶

_»9."Lȹ§E7•ôú3±é|y¯Ï

÷bE7ϼ<¤:žäE7•ô  a4ß ã¡`é¡6¾%ãcµ:XÞÖUÒÚÔÞ_

 â&  &  49"F¯gíE7•ô 

  aÀá³ÀÊYÖÖU4E7¡'•E 7…?¤&žâE7•ô Ð  •Œ  • aJÞE74Ð  •XE7•ô Ð 

•Œ  •aE7y‹Jà4Ð  •­Ð  •Œ 

•!À|3E7–äzÌE7Ï!ãµHȹ

§E7•ôú3±” µ|Þy¯Ï÷bEUϼ

<¤Äz}ïÍE_žâv"LÕ^!ã•

¸ôaUž§ÒÚÔÖU4p0EU_»u Þ<Õ^!㕸ô³ÎAúߏ<

^âb}¢‹ÎF¯Ï÷bEUϼ<¤Æ)

&  Œ&  ÏEU¡•ô6¾  a<Ì

^•¸œIwÒÚÔ^â˜øö☰&a

³gÖUÒÚï÷bDÒÚÔ¼<¤o<&

ÌE7Ïã•ô4LaäzE7Ï$È_»

§¹y¯Ï÷˜E7ϼ<¤§w¹€

1.0

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.0

1.0

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.0

reacted acetic acid (kmol/hr)reacted acetic acid (kmol/hr)

10 11 12

stage number

13 14

10 11 12 13 14

stage number 16

15 17 18

5 E7_ô37=ÖU"E7¡_E7

U?¤

ڍ©:¦&WÞ³gF¯Q›KÏ4L­:¦

&W©êH4EUÏ^•ô!ã  a»µ©

³gµiì&úžt©Õ^!ã•ô9"aE U¡•ôÞ:?FÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤

Æ)/i4Õ^Þ¶í^â˜Õ

^!ã•ôFÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤cµ

ÞÆ)

ä}ïÕ^ÛyíY •DØYÖU

ÒÚÔ³G$Þ°AÎA$í½ß#EÌ EUÏâ9"•¸œIÞ¶&  Y–ïEU¡

•ô  aÌEUÏ0zEU¡!•¸œ

Iâãpw^â˜Hc °& íÖUÒÚï

÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤³g<o<&i&

žt©49"³ggíÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ

¼<¤EU•ô§ƒ§ƒÒÚÔ¼<¤K

ãïº4|¼<¤äzÌEUχ6$Èȹ 4^â˜é|Þ¶í*ž” gÕ^ÒÚ Ô^â˜é|°&Þgí@|ÖUÒÚï

÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤w»§F¯ ØçqQÞ:

¦&W©ê­Ï©

 +/ ÐéÛá Ðì Ô¼ÝéØ2

6 E7¡_ô3ÒÚÔ^âbøöâba

³g.ÖUÒÚï÷bDÒÚÔ¼<¤o<

7 E7¡•ô5ÒÚÔ^â˜øöâ˜a

³g.ÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤o<

8 E7¡•ô 7ÒÚÔ^â˜øöâ˜a

³g.ÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤o<

9 Ì^zؕ¸âp0w☠25°C aÖ UÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤ ³g<

o<

s2Ö7ÒÚïE7ãPڍ6b 

10 }±Ì"^g0\Ö7jØuÖ7Ò Úï÷bDÒÚÔ¼<¤³g<o<

ìÖ7jØK0\

Î<$í½k.
 ÖUjØu}E7ã Þ^Q0\ÖU6¾}Õ^Ø^âp0Þ^

Q(E7ãp(Þ^Q’Á

 Õ^0} ° â˜âãp^•¸œzE 7¡uï¸uí¸

 Ì^} ° â˜"aâE7¡!•¸

7Ïâ˜é|Œøöâ˜

äz
ÖUjØu³GµÒÚÔ²Ç4Õ^

¶íÖUjØu^Ϝzí¸Àáï—^Q (E7ãpúJ©^â˜Õ^!ã•ô .ÖUÒÚï÷˜DÒÚÔ¼<¤cµÞÆE7•

ôÞÆKµ/iÎAHÔ©E7•ô  _

&
 }Ì^QY(ãp³gF ÖUÒÚï÷bÒÚÔ¼<¤o<^Q^

•¸Ð


 •^Q^•¸Ð
 

•i& Ö•


 ÖUjØuÞ0\€ÖUÒÚï÷˜³ g!Ït©c:¦&W©ê­ÒÚÔ¼<¤

³gz^Q^a»©:¦&W©

êi©êž4é|í¸E7Ïâ˜4L^

!Þ!ã•ô¢µ

 äz   ÖUjØuÒÚÔ³G.üW

°µ÷ÖUÒÚÔ³G.üÇßÕ^

<"Ø^aFÖUÒÚï÷˜ÒÚÔ¼<

¤ÆÏB&  Y–ïށ–

 é|í¸^â˜FÖUÒÚï÷˜ÒÚÔ¼<

¤Æ)µÕ^<Ø^a–¾

  ^ÏãjÖUjØuaäzE7ÀÊQÞ¨

ع^ ÖUÒÚï÷˜ÒÚÔ¼<¤µ^ Ï÷ÖUa²

äØ^Õ^(E7ãp4^÷ÖUUÖ UjØuaY^ Þ&€ªQ߯Ͻ Øiï<

E7ã€Ú£‚

±_ ¢

ÎAÀá   &W >9œ–}E7

ã+*XÖUÒÚï&€(ªQ6˜A}

÷ÖUÒÚÔ^a^☈âwÕ^ a€Ú©:¦&W©êv4LÌE7Ï!ã•ô

 wé|ÒÚÔ^â˜øöâ˜:¦&W©ê ߐµvÕ^<Ø^wHˆâaKQ:

¦&W©êwž^ µ|y¯a÷˜E7ϼ<¤

­÷ÖU^ñÖUjØua<í¸ÖUjØu Þ^â˜Fy¯a÷˜E7ϼ<¤ÞÆ)µÕ

^<Ø^Þ^Q–¾wt©ÖUÒÚï÷˜

³g!Ït©c:¦&W©ê­ÒÚÔ¼<¤

³g!Y©:¦&W©êž£é|í¸E7 Ïâ˜4L^!Þ!ã•ô¢µ

+

ÎA
¼J»<I 16& (

+ñZº

ÑIö6

,L u9ÿQ

% p:^

)M Ð M •^

KM Ð M •u9a +M Ð M •<9a .HT ç/ÀÊñô NI E7?¤ñô /M Ð M •u9ù

3. </XÁô

 +/ ÐéÛá Ðì Ô¼ÝéØ2

39 Á•ô

"7 EUa

"- ³!

7 EU?¤

L

5M_ Ð L Î</X4Ð M •EU?¤

7 âb

9M Ð M •<9ù

L

[M_ Ð L Î</X4Ð M •u9…6¤

L

\M_ Ð L Î</X4Ð M •<9…6¤

L

]M_ Ð L Î</X4Ð M •^…6¤

∆+ EU

£R[¥

 &OHDU\ : DQG 'RKHUW\ 0 ) ³7KH 6HSDUDWLRQ RI

&ORVHO\ %RLOLQJ 0L[WXUHV E\ 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ ,,

([SHULPHQWV´
    

  9RO  1R  SS 

 'XSUDW ) DQG *DX * ³
    

          

 ! # $%! & $! ''()*+,()*$

-(%%(.

      
 

         !"

  #$ %&

'    ((  )     
 *  

 "  + * ", ,-* .   /"

  . 0(   
   

        ! " 

# $ % &' "() * +,

  !-    

 1

0 & 2 
     

    

  !"

#!"$"% &  '() "*


 ,,,/,,,0 1.22+3

4 566    7  8 
 ) (

8 & % #!"$"%  '

() "*
      

 9RO  1R  SS  

 /HH / 6 DQG .XR 0 = ³3KDVH DQG 5HDFWLRQ (TXLOLEULD RI WKH $FHWLF $FLG,VRSURSDQRO,VRSURS\O

$FHWDWH:DWHU 6\VWHP DW  PP+J´
  

   9RO  Q SS  

 /HH 0 - :X + 7 DQG /LQ + 0 ³.LQHWLFVRI

&DWDO\WLF (VWHULILFDWLRQ RI $FHWLF $FLG DQG $P\O $OFRKRO RYHU

    

          

      !" # # $ % &'()*"+"

 

 

 
 

      ! "#

1R  SS  

 3DUUD ' 7HMHUR - &XQLOO ) ,ERUUD 0 DQG ,]TXLHUGR

- ) ³.LQHWLF 6WXG\ RI 07%( /LTXLG3KDVH 6\QWKHVLV 8VLQJ & 2OHILQLF &XW´
   

 

    

  

   
!
"# $%&  '$(

)$( *+$( ,$ -.+ /& 0( $&& 1$(2 3(

,RQ ([FKDQJH 5HVLQ, ,QWULQVLF 5DWH ([SUHVVLRQ LQ /LTXLG 3KDVH $FWLYLWLHV´
    9RO 

1R  SS  

 7HMHUR - &XQLOO ) ,]TXLHUGR - ) ,ERUUD 0 )LWH &

DQG 3DUUD ' ³6FRSH DQG /LPLWDWLRQV RI 0HFKDQLVWLF ,QIHUHQFHV IURP .LQHWLF 6WXGLHV RQ $FLGLF 0DFURSRURXV 5HVLQV 7KH 07%( /LTXLG3KDVH 6\QWKHVLV &DVH´


 %HVVOLQJ % 6FKHPEHFNHU * DQG 6LPPURFN .+

³'HVLJQ RI 3URFHVVHV ZLWK 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ /LQH 'LDJUDPV´
     

 

   

 



 ! "# $
%
&' $(( )

      !"#!$! %!$$&'

!( )*+ , DQG 'RKHUW\ 0 ) ³1HZ 7RROV IRU WKH 'HVLJQ RI .LQHWLFDOO\ &RQWUROOHG 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ &ROXPQV IRU 7HUQDU\ 0L[WXUHV´
 
   

  9RO  1R  SS  

 (OGDUVL + 6 DQG 'RXJODV 3 / ³0HWK\O7HUW%XW\O

(WKHU &DWDO\WLF 'LVWLOODWLRQ &ROXPQ 3DUW , 0XOWLSOH 6WHDG\ 6WDWHV´   9RO  Q$ SS 

D

 (OGDUVL + 6 DQG 'RXJODV 3 / ³0HWK\O7HUW%XW\O

(WKHU &DWDO\WLF 'LVWLOODWLRQ &ROXPQ 3DUW ,, 2SWLPL]D

WLRQ´ %
   9RO  Q$ SS  E

 +DXDQ 6 +HUW]EHUJ 7 DQG /LHQ .0 ³0XOWLSOLFLW\ LQ


 9RO  1R  SS  

 0DKDMDQL 6 0 DQG .RODK $ . ³6RPH 'HVLJQ

s2Ö7ÒÚïE7ãPڍ6b 

SS  

 3HUH]&LVQHURV ( 6FKHQN 0 *DQL 5 DQG 3LODYDFKL 3

$ ³$VSHFWV RI 6LPXODWLRQ 'HVLJQ DQG $QDO\VLV RI 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ 2SHUDWLRQV´
 
 

   9RO  6XSSO SW$ SS 66 

 6QHHVE\ 0 * 7DGH 0 2 DQG 6PLWK 7 1 ³0XOWLS

OLFLW\ DQG 3VHXGR0XOWLSOLFLW\ LQ 07%( DQG (7%(

5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ´
       

  9RO  Q$ SS  

 7KLHO & 6XQGPDFKHU . DQG
   

  
       

      !"  !#$


   6   !"  ,

 4   6   #64(45 6$ 

     
 

  ! "# $ #%  &'()*&'"' +#,,-.

'- /  0  1 /   21 3  

4    5  /67


 
 !

#'%  #,*&' +#,,&.

') 8         9     

/         :*

4 /      


  ! (- $ ,  (,,"*(,,%

+#,,).

'% 1 5
 4       $ 0 

    
 

   ! )(
&  (-(*()% +#,,".

',   $ 0 1 5
   4 1  0  

  *; 2   

5 
 
  ! ''

 
  )#,*)'' +#,,%.

(<    =    4    

RI 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ DQ 07%( &DVH 6WXG\´


 
   9RO  6XSSO SW% SS

66 

 6QHHVE\ 0 * 7DGH 0 2 'DWWD 5 DQG 6PLWK 7 1

³(7%( 6\QWKHVLV YLD 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ  '\QDPLF 6LPXODWLRQ DQG &RQWURO $VSHFWV´
  

    9RO  1R  SS 



 $JUHGD 9 + 3DUWLQ / 5 DQG +HLVH : + ³+LJK

3XULW\ 0HWK\O $FHWDWH YLD 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ´ 

   9RO  1R  SS 



      !  " 

#   $
   

   - ,     !  

     - ,     !

)'&&&*

" 6  ."   7."

-     !  "$ 

)/888*

""   6  "    ! 

"$
     

 
 
 
 !
"#$#%# $ &'

DQG $FHWLF $FLG´
   

9RO  SS  

 9HQLPDGKDYDQ * 0DORQH 0 ) DQG 'RKHUW\ 0 ) ³$

1RYHO 'LVWLOODWH 3ROLF\ IRU %DWFK 5HDFWLYH 'LVWLOODWLRQ ZLWK $SSOLFDWLRQ WR WKH 3URGXFWLRQ RI %XW\O $FHWDWH´

      9RO 

1R  SS  

  2  =  _ \/

 P  a  _ ¶

 P  a  _ [¶

 P  a  _ æ