企業道德的內涵與教學

全文

(1)o. t:~mlfS~iJ4fi.. *.~. ~~t:£ 18811f$(J'Ii*~~n: Warton School f'H'i:&:tfW~~~:f& 0. @:;!Ett~fiiJlJi!j. ' ~lii31f*:&:tfItW~. • ~~jftt:~fj1n MBA S'3liit\tfJ{1itfinI*lMlI:H~ 7~!j:. ~~miB3f:tt~o. Fortune ~tt. ( 19871f 11 J3 ) tE r JIft~1iij~/fftfiiJ*fiiJ{{E? J -Xt:pf!ttml:H : -~Ui§.. *~~_.~tf~.,.~r.*~.B3~M.~J~.MJIft~ • • ~,~~tE_.M.~T' Jt~~~fJ~}~~4it~mm~~rp'~~ tE3.!.~~M~~Ji!.. '. 0. Pfr{iJIl~~M MBA $Uit~Ji!.I1'FMAJfE:*JfE:j,'. iffigq:~ MBA tt:3?:~A.m~m:~j;Zpg~3c~. , pjjm~*i:. 0. , W.:p.~1i f!s1i!t ' f'F:lftEX. .~~~.S'3 • • :rtE.~~~it ••• ~M~fit:p,JIft~ • • /fftfta~.7~.~~?J. liit~ Mf:tt~IIPfrfiJll1iij~/fft~~~;Jtf1!! *!JZ tfJIil ~!r;t~1:.milfi1t MEJ ~i • f1!! ir~~MmjiiJt& ~~~M~.~m~'~~~:&:~~~~:&:tf~~Mttilfim~~~-m~ilM~&o. • • ~pg§ftMliit~mM'~.&.~.-m~fl~ftM • • '~~Am.1n-«~.M~ ~Z t:p , 1n:;!E*f4t1?Pf'Fm~ " 1Il1ff/FilfIJ~ , tt:3?:ttAtIJ.~1*m*i: ' ~lIAMm~~N~j! ~@• • 7.lIliit~B3~~Mttft,~IJi!j&~~7liit.B3 • • '.~liit\tm~~1**.'~~~ 0. ~~liit\tMimjjL~if':t(. 0. , ~33\::fIJ~!IlmMfljJ$*~1iiit1Jn ,2.liit*fl1:.fc5&. B~li:~ , fj:&:~M~*M Bmit 3. *~f~Hft~tlf$!I!Jtm\ " ~1f~:lift1.ne;fi~ 4. ecJffn:~~~~tf ' ~~i'i1Jlj~ilrru~5C~liit1fS'3~* ' :tJt:;!E:&:.ft~IT~.lirE/\r' • ~. iI~liit.M~~if'OO~fi.1n:&:.,@:;!E$ID:&:.~ • •A~ffi*A~~flml:H~z.~fi. ~~$it1:.7milfi1t~~~.M~*·a.~R:&:.M~JIilA~~OOEJ~'tE~m~M~J3$ 0. A~M:&:.fi~.EJ:&:tf~WMl,~pg~~.:lf~tt~X(. 0. 0. 0. ~--~*l~mili~~~S'3I!~JJft.m:li 'Jr~JtOO~J!fi ,~ 1I~:it• • •'jjiDi. 1. :&:~~;gEB• •{tfi1t BtlWifi~. 0. , iffi~fflZ.~~~JfE:1Jn*I~ , ~~liit.**.U.M:&:. ~S'3iR:~~~ljij,iI~o 2. :&:~m~flcM.~fl73-MS'3~~.B .lf~. , • • ~JIilA.Jr~~.:l'E:J~S'3.;g , ftl2iM1iMA. :f:~ffi*ZI3.Ijij,~~'~~.A~.Z~JIilM~o. .7U~=1JOO*' • •~~M~*~.*fl~:&:tf~~M~.~.m.7M:&:.~ • •~ ~.~.~~{{EUr=1JOO~UnHzo " Kohlberg ( 1971 ) S'37E.m.~ft • •. Kohlberg .1E.1Jn~ Piaget S'3~~ , fll1ffl,~~~ft AI 73-~egllJliX. o : ~~tUWIJliX. 0. ~lm.iI~$ljftf1CM~E~. -&~N:;!EftH'L\:&:~*WIflj~MJle '1I~ti..'jjiDi 1. mt:~~ftMOO~~:f:~~B~~. • ' M~-8Q~iJl~~f:J1t~il••m ifInx:~*~~1Jt:pS'3~r~fJh~. ,,74. fif2fi: ~ ~~~ ~ -mfIJ AI 1:) 1tt~ ~ :tiHMI*l:&:~ , B ir'~:&: ~ ~ ~.~ ft1g~JJrJLl:::~p1itft. ' -f:;M~f& ':. ml& 0 ) Jlt~l&5e.:i:~7Mit~mJ{U ' mm1lft1:;!Em.iffi~pm~lJ.fI~. 0. 1 : ftfttrruWIJliX. Jlt1l1'X7E:i:!JJlJM:;!E~p~UIJT{t{tm1l~liit.MmJ{U~. ' .~IT~S'3:f&**~UIJT ' ;z. ~73. • • ~'~~;~~~·~~. ~)~~**m~~-~~'$ffi.~$~~7AeMfi~'I*l~~r:&:.m~JmUM~fio tt:;!EtE~7Ht-:Jm~t:p. , :&:.IT:f.£S'3$~U(t;J~~~ , tE~pgliit.t:pJ!~Z~~ , JLJltmm ' ~~ft :&:.~~m~MIt.z• • m.':;!E-M~~~~Mmgo~OO~~~~S'3.~'~:lf~~~~ ~-~n*:&:.~~~~I:H~Zm*~f!s1'~~m~:&:.m~pg~S'3~@'Nm.:&:~m~S'3* .'nt-t~ftz~.1Ji!o. f& 1 ) 1!frjljij,nll{{Eft1~~ ~l& 2 ) ~fgmfj.S'3~~. . ~ 2 : ~fttMJliX. fll~.M• •~• • "~.flf1!!S'3WI~:;!E.mil~S'3'f1!!~.~M • • S'3:f&.:;!E~AIOO';z.. 73-m:. ( ~f& 3 ) A.~~~. r ~!J5Vj~ J ~~ - ~f& 4 ) ~fittM~~S'3~~. It ' ~~il1i.mf:Jf~1! fi~liit*fi:&:.~~UIL\ B~Mmtf!s1AI73-~1:)r=:1Jmi. :. ~ 3 : mftftt ' § ~.1imt~IJM1I~. - , IIJDt:it_*:t1.nm 1. :&:• •tftMfc51b B!'®iii1Jn • 1fffl.liit\tfi:&:.M~IL\~f~ 2. :&:.mm B~.* • ~.jJ~ Bmii ' nx:~liit.t:p~ 131'l913. " 3.~~~U.~~~ ••• R.~ftfl~'~.~~ • • WI.~~N:;!E:&: • •Eif'RJ§ES'3 0. 0. oott• • • ' .~~UlJTm.M:;!Emt~~ , ill.@IJii:~IJ£\~AIjJ~~ • /F.~~@JJil:~IJ:;!E~!Ilm~. .M·.~~~A-&*.~,;z.~73-~:. ( ~f& 5 ) liit.~tB~~~~ -. -. 12 . J3 .

(2) 3!~o. 4. • *~~~H.m~ ~ tJ{lt~£!1B.Im{£.. ~lmlfSl"Ji~fi.. ~. =' IJD~n.1JiIii. ~, M~-B~~~IJm~eg~~ii~~m. ~~. lID B9J!t&f. 0. m~ff~fPJ~. , Qi:sif.*{£'1f~W. , ~~iitt~ttt~ MBA B9iitt~1JI@:mmJMHf::lm. 0. ( 1987 if. 11 fI ) tE I P€d5\lJm~~fPJ$:fPJ1)£? J -)C~{ffffEHf::l : -[is]tJ *~~~a~'1f~.,tt~I.*~.B9®U.~J~MB9*~Jm~~,~~tE ••B9 •• ~ Fortune ~tt. ~.~~~~R~¥mm~~~~~o*~.~B9MBA~~.~IWB9A8*8~'~ :(E~.~~B9~~~. , mWF~ MBA lt~mJ....m~m~Z~~££ ' "J~i**c. 0. ~J1t. ft.~~§~B9iitt~m~'~.~~~~-H~~~.B9 •• '~~Am ~Z~'~~*.~WH.,.~~a~3,lt~~A ••• i*me'~MAB9m.~ •• ~ ~m.WT.Miitt~B9~~~IT.'~~~~~Tiitt~B9 •• ,~~iitt~m •• i*~~'~. 0. mi*.*.~m~~.~B9ftff~.mm,.~~oo~tto ='IJ~1E~.~1JiIii 1. {£.~.B9 ••1tfiM B~ilt.. ' mHlfflZW.~~81J1l'¥l~ , ~~iitt~*~.tAWM{£. ~B9~~fiff:~~.o. 2.{£~M~fI~~.fl7t.B9m.E~.~' •• ~WA.~~.{£~B9~.,~~~mA. •• ~*z§~~~~'~~~A~~Z~W~Mo. .TtA~:=::1Jm~,*.m.B9~*w~*ttt~{£W~~B9¥-f.~Mm~TM{£.m.~M. ~m~,w •• ~1)£tA~:=::1Jm~tA~Hzo. - 'Kohlberg ( 1971 ) B97r.~m.~~~w~. Kohlberg M3'Ett1Jll~ Piaget B9W~. , ~~m.~~~~7t~~MJiiX ' -tMIlif&: ":. liiX 0 : m.1JtrjWJiiX. 0. a~iitt~B9~~~~~ •• ~{£~,m~$ID{£.~~WA~~*A~Qi:~MW~~~~. ~~$~~TmafiMm~~.B9~*'~~~m{£.~~WAE~~@~,tE~ffl~B9~fI ~,~~~~¥IJ~~B9~~-'t. 0. 0. iitt~B9J!t&f~*~Jm~~~~~~~*~z'1fW~~~~mafiMB9@~'~~mJ .m.B9~~~~~'~~~{£~~.~{£'1f~WB9ITatt.~.~-M~aB9~&o. , ¥-f~fIJ3I11mB9f1n$*~jij1J1l , fi{£.B9~*~ B mii. 2. iitl:~fi~tI5&b. B ~.;jI 3. *~ftfi.mft~.m ' ~'I-~mB9w~ilt ~ 4. ~Jff1Li*~fi~tl ' .i*iililjJE'I'~~J[;1tiitt~B9m* ' /t~~{£.ft.fi~E.f£j\r' , ~. '. .~{f~.B9 •• :ltE~~~~~~a.nB9~fi~'*~Jm~~~aW.T~~~~?J. m~iitt~B9{lUjL~~3C. 0. 1. iitt~~'l-B9~n~;i:m~B~~. ~~1)£ 1881 if.~+ltk~~1L Warton School ft~{£'1fW~~~{&. OO:nx:~*~~W~B9~r'f4*. , ~~w~m:~'L.'1E.:f~JWfIJ3B9.m. ' 1::ir,~{£.~~.~B9~~~f.J::JF~~. 0. ftffB9{£~fi~.@{£'1f~WM'~~~~~.~ff~)c(. •• ~'~~;~~¥'~. (~f&:O)J1t~f&:7r..~TMm.mM'Mm.B9~m.®#mMg\(;fI.o. 1i?X 1 : ~H~ 1JtrjWJi iX. J1tJiiX7r..~~B9~#~~tttt •• Biitt~B9m~~M,tt.fi~B9{&**~~'X~7t. ~:. ~)~M*~.~~-~M'$ID~~$~~TAmB9fi~'mJ~~I{£.m.Jm~B9~@. ( iiif&: 1 ) 1!frl ~ ijjl 1)£ B9 ~ [is]. .~tE~~B9~~~'{£.fi~B9.M~.~~,tE~~iitt~~~.~~~,~J1t~~,. ( ~f&: 2 ) ~fumfi.B9~[iS]. {£.m.~~~~~z •• m.'~-M~~~~B9~~o~~~~OO~B9ftm'w.§. ~-&~*{£.m.~MWmzm*~~'W~m~{£.m.~~B9~~'wm.{£.m. liiX 2 : ~H~B9JiiX. ~~.Mg\(;.m*~'~.~~B9jW~~WMa~B9,@~~~~.~B9{&*~~~~'X. .'~W~{tZ~~:1Ji*o. "iiJ7t~:. (~f&:3)A~~~g\(;I~~0~J~[iS]. It ' ~~ii~~mrt:J~~jj. ( ~f&: 4 ) i*.~~ff:B9~[iS]. .Nfiiitt~ttt{£~m.IUJ{,\ B ~B9~~~7t~tJ~:=::1JlID. :. JiiX3:m~m,@~g\(;~~~B9JiiX. ~•• ~.'.R~~._B9~~M,~@~~~.~.~{§'~~~~@~~~~lIIm~. -'INJ~1E~*$t1JiIii. ' ~~iitt~ttt{£.B9{§'L.\~fJ£ 2. {£~m~ B3M* ' ~.n~ Bmilt ' nx:~iitt~~M § B9 § ~ 3. {£.~tJmrn~~~.g\(;~f1t-~¥UfU3 ' 7jd'~.g\(;~;JtIU.~:>'f'W~{£.;fr$~~~. 1. {£.mttfLB9t15~ B ~ilt1J1l. 0. 0. -. J2 . ~B9·.~~~A~*~~'X~7t~:. ( ~f&: 5 ) iitl:~~tt3~i*~[iS]. -13. •.

(3) ( ~~ 6 ) ~'iliftff:J~tf,~JtU~rOJ ... u·J!iif~~mm:;<J'~~~*.~~m·3t~*~~B~RE:.~m~A~~G~~.ft •. ~K~~~~~tf,H.~~~*ft.'-OO~.*•• wm~W~~~ID~.A~8.m .~~~~o@~~~~~~~~~~'~U~~~~ •• m~~~~~~~H.~~~.~*. ~*JJ'. ~~~JITi!'f~~~JtIJ. ~m*£~~~~m~Mo~~A!iI~~~'@m~RE::;<J'~.'~~ARE::;<J'M~'mm~. · $E!p~1¥ltE.m~W1~.m.~. 0. =" ~tf,rr~~#lUITIlJ7tmmfl:±~~~ (DeGeorge, 1982) : -m I§ ~IDfU · -~~lt IDfU I§ ~IDfU ( Teleoloical Theory) :±51 : -rriIJ~~tf,~fi~3tEl3~rriIJm~~~~!f!:~tEf:!l rm~ · rm:!prriIJ~*JJ' · tJ:;vfIJ:±~~~~ ~~~ Deontological Theory ) j{U~~ : HltJfi ~~~1i*#lUlTrr~~iif!l ~~~~~~~f:jg ( Effectiveness ) ~~$ ( Efficiency) • ~Ii 0. 0. (. 0. ~~§~IDfU~'m~~~~~~~~~Trrm~~~~~~m~fto. ='~~~~OO§~OOA"m~~*~'=m.OO~~~.~~~fi~~j{gQ@~~tttt~. ~~~~~~~xff~ftQ'.~*~*~~~~Am~~tf,fim~'~~~~Atttt~~~~ ~~m~(~~) ·rm~~X~.ff.~~.m*~(~.) .~:;<J'~~:=:OO.oo~~;f§m'1[ m~. i5i ~t.ij)-mJl iXllJ tJ /3?i- ~~tf,~~* o. .. ·. .~U~~HIDfU'~AIlJUHm'.fi~~H~"~:;<J'~.~fi~':;<J'3t~•••~~.* JJ" ~rR'~~mtl:±~j!*/3 : l.EI3~~~~~~tfi~· ~~~~~~~f1.m~.~£*iI~Ul 1fiIJ:;<J'tf~~~~$~ ; 2. ~f1$~fIJ1.itIllIl:tjtJll ' ~H~fI~~.jJ$J!tJll.* ' m*tfi~T~. •• ~~J!~~~.,gjJ~xfformJ!iif~m~~@·~T~~~.~ •• a, T*~ "~m:" ttm" #m ' /3~1Jfi···~ ~-!l3! r .ft~ J fjtfi!il.l*~I)Hit~if:l: ' @ 0. #ft·~~·~m~~~*~W~~~A.~~~~~~~MMo. , m~~ r A~ma ' -;Rfl*:ttl!~ J 'm~IL\~®:~.~~fffij~~ ~.:z._~ r 1WJ~~IL\A*~~ J ' ~.A~iS~~m'L\~' ~~91~ftH~~m/L\J!~WJ 1I.~~f1~~.~Iil1i¥i · ~~~~fLfIJJtUR~~titJll~~fill T ' J!m~~:Jt r ~/L\ J ./GII! ~-~oomi~ A1flHt~flA:j\~. :. .::;r;:<l!f.ta-~IH*~ft Q. tEMa~*jJoo. 0. ' :JttJfL~M1ttJlt~~IL\. 0. ~~~~1i::~~~*:±~iftt.;mM~~~fL~. ,. ~~~~~~tI~~~.~m~.'~~.~.ffl~tlQ$EI3~~AfiM~~.W1~~·. · M~~~:;<J'lI~lIf!J · J!~-7t.ff ~~ tEm $EI3~A~~.RiIJ~m~·~~~ ••~~~~lt~~m'~~~~•• ~~fl~~~ '~~-flm~~D~·~~ •• ~.II~~fto ~¥~~·M •• ~:Jt •• M~~~f1~.~·mm~~~~~llRft;.m~~ft.£~. 1t;*£:m-.W1~fIJ1.it*~7tM~. 0. ~8~. 0. •. J"~~~J~~~*~~~.~'.rmMm~~ifttfl~tI~-ffi#m~~mo. ~~ftfl~~~~.&.~ft*$~~~ft~~~o 3. ~~"'~~IDfUfJ;]*~~H.. ' ~.~.~~f1fIJ1.it~~.~OO~~~~~:;<J'JE ' 1Iil*~l.. ~.m~rr~m~;I;~o. ~*:±~~.~~~.~:Jt~RtEm •• ~~ft~l*U~'~~fi~.~~~.~~.~ r.~.~J~¥rm8~~:;<J'.~~~~o~.II~~rm~·R~:;<J'IT~.~~f:jg~.~.. ·ffM~~m~~:;<J'~E.~'$:;<J'.~••~~~~;~m~rm~'ffM-&~~. ~'J£.ii1if:Jpqji. 1~~~H$~~~·AA~~ft~~~.:tE~*Ma~~~$~m~~"~l*~*~'#. •• ~tf,~~mtttt~~~~.~"rr~~•• tE~.~~$oo~~~~~m~·w~ffl~ ~~ftm*miio. --~,,:;<J'. •••~~,:;<J'.~.~mU~.M·~.mmA.*~gh~~~~~o. fi.~~.1I1il~.j~. ~~~~~A&MBA.~rm~·~~ ••~~~~~~~~M?m.fioo~~IDfU'~~~ m.§~Ur~~oo:-'~~~~f1£*~~~~~#m;=".~~~~fi~.m;="m H~~~~~;~'/3amii~J!~.~~f:jgjJo. *••• ••. -'fi~.n• •. ~~. -t.J.f. •••~§~.~~~~.ft~~~~~.~ffl •• ~~m~ooo . fffiiJ-~.~~.UA~~.ilI~ful:~:tj.~~ti I§ ~ m~!l~=/N®m~&~ , ~tf~.~ 0. ~£*~~fjtfi$li'tE~~.W~~~$RE:*~.:ttl!m~~-!l3!~~~ilmfiifttflm~~~~. ~~~£*~~~~~#m~mtErM~.~J~rft~.~Jm~oo: H~'i'.J.f.. ~~~"'.wI~~ft~m~~.~~.~m~H&~'~~~~•• ~~mm*~~!f!:· lIlI1Ii!iIiii+f1~fIJ1.it~~~~. ~*±~~~ftfl~~RtEr~*~fijJ~rMa~*Jm~£*~.~'~$~~~~~ ~£*~j{Uo~~·M~/3~~~~~~*~£*I§~· •• ~~~I§~~~~~.OOftfl~~ ~~'@~~A~~~MaR~~f1~§~~-oA~~m~§~tE~~*J!~iif~~m'@J! iif~~mRE:::Jp~tJfUtfljmllf£-ilJ. ' ~~~*~.IlR~1i2:~ ; !l~1i2:~:;<J'~A~m§j(~*~~ti 1§~'rmR~-flIAfmTo. 0. ~~mm~~. I§ ~~~ , 'E:!~fIJ~ " ~.~m.f~~$~~. 0. ~• •. *.'~~'~$~m.~~.I~1i¥i.=~~~~*~§~'~~*~~1.it ·~.~~A~MBA¥~,.~~~=jJOO~~~'~-~~m~,.,~~~.~~~~. W.~1JfilJi~.~.~,m.m~. , Steiner ( 1975, p.226 ) lit ~ : r ~m1R:?ft~iS:Jt1Jfi~. J·~~~Arm~'f1~.~:±~~1Jfi~n~''E:!~:*.~,ti¥~"x~~,,~~~. -. 14. -. 15.

(4) \?. ( ~~ 6 ) ~'Wi189~~IJjOtUJErP:J. 1:£ Kohlberg B33i~~J!i~~~*fi~ , ~M~~*!J!tt1fJiJf;g.1fz.%I~{7J-TlIJii:;~·~ ~~z.~~om~••z.~.Y ••~'~U&JEz.ft •• m~~JE~ ••• ~J!iB3n~,. :p}jlU ' ~~S91:m~~«;~~*~B31:m ' ~~*g(S9 8 -TM..i'Rm~Afr':!t{J\S9~~~. .'1:~*:!t~~ft~~~B3•• ,g1J~.~offjj~&1:~S9~~'.T~~S9.~ ••B' :t§ftT*i! ' ~m " ~11f '\ .m ' ea1J1i:"'~ r tli1I39 J 1J1i:jl.i'R~utS9~:I: • m. ~.~~.RB3~~,~~~g~.mM.~.m~~o. ~~~um*~~.z.1:~~Bo~S9Ajl~.~·mm~.~~~'~S9AM.~.~'m~~. -. "~~rr. B9~J~RJ".ajjrHI.:EJ!~m! (DeGeorge, 1982) :. -a 13 139. '. ~a3i. ( Teleoloical Theory) : -fiibB9~m1J1i:~~EB~fiib?JT'\{1:B3fii!j!f!66-fi:l.iI jfflJE ' ffjj:?prribB3*:!t ' U:9JfIJ.:Efta«;~ .mft~ ( Deontological Theory) jlljWla :. ~1fU. 0. @ffjffl~.M'~~'.mS9~.*~•• ~.A.~~~~~.~M.o. 13 B3~. 0. aB3*fl-:l&JI~~J~fiaS9~.. 0. ~y.~~~~~. ( Effectiveness ) ~~~. ( Efficiency) ,tit. ~~I3~.~'~~~~~~~.~~Tfia~~~~ftB3mJ!i1o =".m~B3~OO~~MA"m~~*.'=M~OO~~~lI~~S9rra~jlUom~~~. ~-~OO~YA.~~&GS9'm~~rA~aa,*a*.J o. :ifi:-Ti"~. : r 1ilJI~z.'l)A~~z. J. '~.A~l~~~11f,c}.,. 1n'm~~ft.S9~~~lIll\lFj '~~~~~flJjlU~liE~ij1JJlf9}.tm7 /iX;m~~11R~M.B3fi 0. ,m&GS9W•• ~~~. i~W!~~I'i~11f'c.,~~~. ' ~m~S9~r ~/C.\ J .~~. 0. ~M.tl-~~OO • ~J:.J~~M1I!IJ~a~/c.,. 0. ~.~.1i:WlIi.*.±ftft*~M'\{.~~~'. .~.m~.m~.~~~o·~ft.J!*~.~.Am~~~fia~'~.~.Atttt~. ~~a~Wl~~~~ilif,~~JE~~m.ilif,,~~~~~m~~o~EB~&A~M'\{z.*.~~'. m~m~(~.) ·ffjj~.X~.~M~~~M*.(ft.) '~~%I~~M~OO~~ffim'. !lSI~*~~*.S9flJ~*~"'M~. a~.'&~m-M~~RJUe~~.mmS9J!*o. ~n~~EB~A~~~RibB3m~'~~M.~~~~~~S9~~'~~S9i1I.~g(~~~~S9. ~ftULS9M.'*ARJU~m'~M~.~1:~~~~~S9fia,. 0. ,. M'\{fk~~.~flfIJ. ' JJ!~-"'.~. 0. ~~ • ~m. · ••-.ffi~~fi~'~~ ••~.aS9fl~o •• B9~·M ••• ~utWlM.~ft.S9.~,~aWl~~S9~.i1;~.~.ft*~~. :!t ' ~r,mmS9tf!ilif,.:E~~* e : 1. EB~~.g~1IS9~~ , ~~~~~.ft.J'iJf*JI'!<.K:...~4"'~ 1I!IJ~f'ltft~«;S9f1J! ; 2. ft.~S9fIJ~lIIltij1JJl ' ~~j!HI~~.1J!JF~1JJl.* ' m*E&~v. r&GJ'\r~~J~~~*i'R~z..~·~ffjjmmlli~ft*.ilif,S9-ID.m~~mo. .~ft.S9fl~~~ft~.ft.~~.~i1S9Wl%lo. Htt-t.J.t:. 3. ~.y. •••(6j*.~~J!i ' ~.~~~ft*fU~~~~~ooz.~~m~~JE ' mi'R. .~~~~fi.a~~'AA~.fi.~~.:~ffi*M.S9.~~Rmft."fti'RB3~~'.. ••~~B3llimtttt~~.~ •• 'rr.~ •• ~~.~~~OO~~*f~S9m1l'~J!m JES9fi'-&*m.i1I o ~~.~.AftMBA!J!1:ffjjg'~ •••.m~S9~~~~aW?m.MOO~M~'~ a~~~u~~~OO:-,~~.ft.~*~.gItMB3.m;=' ••~~1J1i:S9 •• ;=' ~fl~B3~~;~,ma.i1I~~~ ••B3~1Jo - , tii£fltit• •*tltfllftlJ93•• fi~.~*~.gItMS9 •• ~m~rM ••• J~rfi ••• J~~OO:. HJ1tt'.J.t: .*.:Eft~.ft.~.ft~r~*&flJ~rM.~*J~~~*~QL'~~~~ ••~. B3~*i'RjlUo~~·M.m~ ••~.~*B3~*I3~·*.L~~I3~S9~.fi~Mft.~~ ~~'m~*A~~~M.~~ft.S9I3~Z.-oA~1:~S9I3B3~~~*~~~S91:~·m~ ~S91:mM.;JpJ!j.::JflJ~ai!ft-ibtl, ¥&¥&~*~.~lS9~~; ~jl~~~~A~m~~*B3~.. · ffjj ~~-'{IIJU~ T. ' ~~Jf~fi.i'RjlIJ~~~utWl. fB~~~&' ~w~.m~~~~j!lfi.· ~~~~.fi'.S9~'>; 1:£Maffjj~ '~W-f:iL~.. ~'1£.iiflagpqii. 13 B3. ~*.:Eftft.S9.ratl1l!lJ~.lL~m~tl1I!IJS9J)i.i'RJlIjL. ~orfi••• J••jffl~.~~g~S9~~o1:£~a~~mg'~~~~S9fi.~~~~ft*. m.mz.rram~:9J~o. I. 0. 0. -. 14 . Itft.~ , ~~Fm'fi.~. =' •• ~. , ~• .gfi••jlIJS9t1]ifPJ ' ~~Jf.lMA~*S9g1J$;.~lmfU. 0. ~mil1l93.j.. H4-t.J.t: ••••~~ •• %I~~~i1B3~~~~ut~m •• %IIi~~OOo ff:W-~••~~j.::JA~ft.~/Mul:z.ijll§a~~ § ~ m~Il~=!J\rrJ?JTm:ftS9 ' ~YS9 •• 0. ~~~*L~1J1i:~ft'~~Y~1fB3~~~M.*~ut*m~~~%IIiB3~m~ft.?JT'\{1:S9~ 1'~~~Ytt1fI~~~~M~Y¥1:~~~m~~&~'~~~Y••%IIi?JTm*B3fii!j*' - •• ft.S9ft~~~~~o~.?JTm.S9I3~~~'~~fl.,.*~m~M~*~~o~~, .n*~&S9fi~*~,~~,,~~~m.~~.IS9l\1Fj.=~~.~*S9I3~'~ft.B3fl~ tflf~'fft ' ~.~.A~ MBA!J!1: · ~~1:£~=~OO$;}i~J~ , ~-~~JiJT~Y.%I~~~.S9~. '1110 ..S91J1i:.fi••••ffi~mJ! ' Steiner ( 1975, p.226 ) : r ~M~Ut~.~1J1i:B3 I§J~ J '.~.Affjj~ · ~~.~.±~z.1J1i:~1l.'{I , ~~ : *ttS9 " ~!J!S9 ' :)(1tS9 ' i'RJEB3 -. 15. ..

(5) W:w~tt-;1Jlliifi. 0. M~1Jlliifi{E:ll::~tkW ~~ft:ll::~* llt*~jIJmiil. o~ii.tt-;~~*~,tE.A~OO~.A~.~tt-;ii~.~;tE •• ~OO~:ll::.~fifi$. 0. m••~1J.fi~.{E.~~tt-;~fi~~*':W~AA~~m~tt-;.~'1JlliiW~ •• ~~ tEjtrs'~~te-filiit.I¥-JWiiijtt-;*51 t.J:I: EB1n:W~AJttt-;DmJEt)~.Iiit.tt-;JlilBfll&liit.rr ••• '~~~~Uii.tt-;.~*~~:W~AAtt-;fi.~•• o:W~AA~*tt-;e~llt~~•• 0. AAtt-;~t.J'm~Iiit.~~tt-;~~o~:ll::~~~Am~'¥.L~~m~W~tt-;~~~ffl~. ~'~~iEiitt-;~ffl:W~ffi~$K!1~.~~~tt-;if!ijJfff:o ~.t.~~,{f. m~ tt-;~ r J~W1(flfir~ J 0tEff ti1ttt-;:ll:: ~ J! ~ /lQRP:If!::~ if1l ' {!I. tE ~ ft:ll:: ~ tt-; ~~ *m~~ 0 EB1n?JT~~~~if~tt-;)}. ' ~~A¥.LR:If!::ft~IDn~:~~m1U]~;m . ~~K!1~~ ft~Att-;*17} , ~Rnml1!;,~flfir~ 0 W:W~flfir~. ~~tt-;.~m~~~WM¥£~·@:If!::tE~ftliit.*mtemffi~,±~tt-;~~:If!:::ll::~~~A £1n.~~.W±~A~.m.tt-;~.~oo~~,~~~tt-;~.~~r~~Jtt-;~B~~.~ft. .0. (;:,);ffi 1Wl-;fIJld.lt.]ilJla-~ ~ ~~~~,{f. ' m1iIiit.Jt:ll::~tt-;~*$1~~~.J! ' ~~:ll::~ik:.~W*tt-;ftl~1U1 .fi.¥MiW~'IT~ ; @mftiid::.J{IJ~~ , :ll::~tE~if~f¥*~~J!~~~tt-;~if ' jtik:.~¥1j ~~m1U]fl~~mtt-;~.'~~:ll:: •• ~~ •• ~Wm1U]fl~~.~~tt-;1U].'~~ ••if.tt-; ffti1t:ll::~tt-;~/lQ~:If!::JN:*. fiX:~0. ~:ll::.~1U]tt-;fl~~m.~,~m:JN:*'*I'Iiit~'m.*.~.M.·:ll::.~~.~. ~8m1U]fl~~.~~tt-;fl~ •• 0••L~~fl~~.~~ •• ~tE~8fl~tt-;~.,V~: IN:*~*I~~~tE.*I£*A~~JN:*&fltt-;~~;H*~Iiit~~~~tE •• ~fl~~e~. ;®tE*ti1t~OO~m~@~m~.tt-;fi.'Iiit.tt-;~~~~.tt-;~.'~8~~~m~:W.A ~/IIm*Jtfrtfi±IUtt-;~t.J. I. ~RP:If!::eti.~. 0. ~8Jf~,{f. ~~~~~m'.~:ll::.ii.*~~~~~,jt.~~~.A~.tt-;M~'®1im:lf!::~~* &~~~~~o~~~~:ll::~~~tt-;~I'§*~.~~-.ii.tt-;:ll:: ••• W~ii.tt-;±Vo _~ ••~~~~.~:ll::~ii.tt-;~t.J~ •• ,frtfi.B-.AHtt-;~ij.~'~*ii.tt-;V •. m~~.I~~~£~.~tt-;.O :r.~~~M.~~fttt-;¥J,r~.llt*~~.~. P1rH6~~~. J ~ I L*lH)t~itJLf;~~~. J. 0fffjmlU:ll::.pg~tt-;ii.m~~@~ , !'JitfffiiJ. ..,-~qf(*-t: ' fiX:~~1U]flJit~1nf.lj~±~tt-;~~~.1lttt-;~{}. [; . ~JIt, r e fJT.~ J :If!::~miiij:lf!::~U~ r. 0. J tt-; • $K!1~1JntJ- r ~~ J ' :ll::.~~A~. M1t;il.-~m~tt-;~~Jff(Jfo. tkW~~~Wii.tk.~n~~~~~.(.~~' ~) :1iit••• ~.'M~)}~. lJij,~ffi~~~~lfB 1iit*~.~lfB:1:'f~ffl~.{}~.tt-;.~ , f*~1Jn~ , mw: ' ~,~ , 7fi~ , mtl ~., •• ,m.tt-;~.~M.(g~ti~)tt-;n~'*.BA6tt-; •• '~rn~ •••tt-;M 0. fiX: ; M~)}vr.tt-;ii.~.~~ : 1. 3tm~u~*tk~~~ , *f57ftl!JE~tt-;~!'fg ( pat love) tJ ~~~3!~ . @t7J~*~5f ' ~~Nlfm?JT~tt-;Iiit.)(1t?JT:ft~tt-;:n~*~JEftl!tt-;~~ ; 2. ~t~* ~W:!&.*OOfF~~ ,~~ 'ffftW~ilHJttt-;f'Fffl ' *lf~~JE ; ~ffi~~~.J{ljreii.tt-;~~ , .~{E~~Mik:&fiM~m~m~~~.'W~Iiit •• ~.~~~W&K!1tt-;frt.qf(.o~.~.. .~~tt-;IT~;JN:*~m.~~~~tE.m.~±~~JN:*fl~tt-;~.;JN:*~Iiit.~~~tE.. .~:iiijtkWW~~tk.-.,jt*tt-;~~~tE1n~.~1lW~.¥#W~.ik:~'~¥.fi. IN:*&fl~~.fl~'~~~m~~~±~~~fl~tt-;~WoiE~mtElT~.~.*~£~ ••. ±1Utt-;~~o~~~R~.tt-;ft.~ti.'~~••Ao. ~M*·~~:ll::~~~J!.A~ •• tt-;if!.,.~m1U]~.Att-;fl~*r~.Jfl.'.M:ll::.. tt-;rfl.J ••• ~)}~,.r~.~)}~Jtt-;flfir~oJ!.-~~'~•• )}~.~¥.Lg~ 71. #m*I£*A~lJij,•• #~~ r *~.~ J ; 2. ~%:~L ' 1l~~~~ r ~%:flfir~ J ; 3. ~tfje~~iJjji, ~~ffl~#M~ r .~.~ J U&4. ~.a;;~fU~~L~ r ~•• ~ J 0. EB1nm1U]~a~~fl~ii~8~.'~~.~fi.m:lf!::-~m.ffi.tt-;I~,tE*~*~. $~~~teMik:L~~.tt-;A.n~;@:If!::~Aiim::ll::~~~~ffljt. •• tt-;iiij~ffi~'~~. -.fi.tt-;.~n~~-~#~.~tt-;V~ff;mo. 1m'. eJ Rm~J!I!JJj~jfagft~1.J. ~~m=/J'\~~1U]:ll::~ii.~litt-;~. ' ~Um~¥IJ:ll::~~ijrp'~*Jt~1tffi~ : §*:If!::M A~.!'Jit:ll::.~m~Mtt-;~ •••Mik:;m-~'~.fi.&~a.~.W$tt-;ii.m.'m ~:tE~~~n~:If!::#~~tt-;.,@tE6~~~~~-#e~~.~tt-;fim;m~':ll::.~.M M~*~~~ntt-;fl~,fffj.JItMtt-;fl~~~.tt-;,~8.M.T:ll::.ii.~~tt-;ffi.O ~ 7 :ll::.ii.*Jttt-;ffi~71- ' tE*~~1i1f~mtt-;:ll::~tk~* ' oo~ttt-;.:If!::fiX:~WOO~~Ii!I\~ tt-;.A • ftl!1r'W.4WJ!f.B~ e Btt-;-ti±Ji!. ' ~~Jt:ll::.~~AlJij, MBA ~1:m g , 1iit.~Iit~ M~)}~.tk.n~m~~~~Dom.R~~~~tt-;~ffiRRtk.~'~:If!::-~~~fitt-;n ~o. H~-t~,{f. EB1n.~)}Itt-;~.~,&~~.~tt-;¥.ffiB'.~A~tt-;e~~~~~mftliit.~~~. ~*~R~o:ll::~V~~~~~•• ~'~~:ll::.~~Att-;e~.~~$~fiX:mW~ii~tt-;£* -. 16 . m~•• ~~~lJij,~~~~,~~·tt-;~:1:·~Rffl~.~tk.~'U~.*~Ji!.tt-;~~~ 1:i'i5*~£Ml*tt-;~.rp'~ ( Dilemma ) ~~;ft , .~~1:tt. ' ~®qf(.jI;~ij~~tt-;M. ' ~tejtii.tt-;~*t.J·~~qf(.jtriiij~~'o. -17.

(6) -~~. -----. -. ----.. •.

(7) 1UI~~~~~I!M,~.iiJiEB~l&. · ,Q;'~'§Ji5jj}iHI~~~MJ!l.if~~;t:ijjEB~I!~~{" Kohlberg:fl: 19761f.I±lJltiEB r ~~~Ij~~f{i!:~t7t'fM J I=j:l · 7IHJlli+M~1! : (1)1!!il(2)M~(3)~ MfJmt.f,(4)~$(5)1:.Ifp(6)JJt1:f(7)~~EB*Ji{8)i!&Jff Wi!&~(9)~ ~tfUf]Jitl:ftEBIE~(Io)ii :fl:':&~~~ EB~l¥l=j:l · fF:i5~~fi~J~H~mlWgmz~:m;fft§l~l!if : (I)~$M'I'/ ~ZP:IE~ ; (2)Mltflti/ ~lt~if ; (3)M!Lj' / ilf'F ; (4)m~/1f~ ; (5).:&~EB~~.ii/lE:~EBiitl:frJlii ; (6)~~/3:: ~ ; (7)JN:*fIJ~/?fi.:i5t1~ ; (8)JN:*fU~/~I;i;*AtI ; (9)JN:*fU~/ EH~U~J.t:fl ; (Io)~* flJ~/.:&~flfU~ ~ T~~B9i1~ · fF:i5ltJi~~pgEB'J{{7IJ · ~~Ji1(;M~ · ~MM~EB::g~~. '.~~'X.~JEBW.~~~'~~if@~.1:.**@.~I!.EBft.~~.o.~~.. 0. 0. ~'~T.~~¥1:. •• EB~~~m~n'~.EB~~~~~~~~~~~EB;~A.~JqI.. itfU¥tQEB~ff~lm:~ · ±.51l¥iitl:fr!i1jr~\fFRiiB9~~. ~'15Eiitl:frM~EBW~~,iitl:frM~EB.M~M:~.,tI.'~~'. ( Lindblom, 1977). .. ,~~jjij£~M~W!1fitJz ,. - , ~ Aa~~.:RJJtB9~;g~~~m t1M~-!7J.:& •. ~1:..ll.~~~.'~~if@~.:&~iitl:frl=j:lrm.J,r~$J,r~$W1:fJ,r ~~~J~~~M~W!M~~. ~z · MBA EB.:&~~~~~ibl:PJt15E~XllEBftI!iIDA · 5i1tjtfl~J.tEB~~[J~mHI . t1 ~iliitl:frfljt.~~~z.~om~:fl:~~~~~W.·~.R•• -~.m.EB@R~.~,. •• ~~M~E~. ~l!om~~A~Mif~~~':& ••1:fA~~Ji1(;fiif~~OO~.~$.~~.:&.iitl:.~~'OOfl. 0. mlUl~I!~~~ffl~o. 0. •• ~ilo. E'.:&~RWAEB~.rr~*.J::.~~~M~':&.±~':&~.~EB~.;~Jlt'~~.~B. $':&~~~EB~.'fi:fl:.:&~mMI=j:l~.aEB~il~~H~o~~R1:fA*~.EBrr~.~·. ~••@1f.•• 1:.~Am:m.:&~m~EB••• @o~~JJtIE •• EB~~ ••• EB~~~~ •• fl. .~~IfF.~I=j:l.a~EB·-.&if':&~~~EBm.~.~1:.if~.~~EBAIomu~~.. EB7t~'U~TM':&~:fl:flAI'flJN:*~fl~*EB.aRm~~.·m~iI*~EB~ft§I~~. .fr~.~±~,~. tL ; ~ll~®~Jlt~~EB*6* ' it1itil.umr5EBtk:.fM{~Wfi:R:IB'ff{i!: ( Akers, 1989). EB~~iio. 0. Hi ' iE~~ : 1£§fjt~fjJj~99mJJj11M1$j~R11 .:&~m~EB~W:fl:mffl~EB**~B~~~·.:&~m~EB~.#~~~~A.:&~~ffEB± fJ1E '. jt**z~~11~H~**~JqIm'h1. 0. 1f A:fl:IUI{}.:&~~~~ffm~EB~~~. · **il UJ::.EB1M. ~'fF:i5m~U~E~M~.M~.:. •• ua':&~~.AB •• ~~~~~ff,~m.~~5~Tmrr.:&~~~. ·.tQEBaBR~~~~.1:..a~~n'~~~~B.~.M~~.~~~'. .~n@~~ifm':&.~@BEB~n~rro. (*X~~.~*i!&~*.~~~~m.~~JqI •• @~1:f~fl,~Jlt~~o) M.:afu~~~.w~~~mr~. m 1li. :i'. j£.id:fl~fc;. ~. ~. · ~Jlt.:&~Jtiitl:frEBJtik~~m.£~1*~ EBomua.:&~~@.iitl:frEBJi •• ·.a~1:f •• ft~.~.:&.r •• JEB~1:f·OO~~RfM{. ~.t'I!:IfIJ~rmlf,;'". ='~~15Eiitl:fr~~~*~.~~~·.:&.m~ ••~-M.:&~~~mIfEB~I!,~Jlt.:&~. ~T~~.rIEaJ1tn'fi~':&~~~EB~I!~Jt5l&.~EBD.·±.~U@.'U.&~ ~.EBm~o.:&~~m5l&EB@.m~§~.15E.:&~~$EB~~m~~~1:f~~·~~~AIif ~~.:&~~~EB~a~J.t;~~m.~.:&~~~mEB@$o-M~~±$~~.iitl:fr~fJlEEB':& ~ , ~~iJ£~~ 13 EB~iitl:fr 13 EBEB~.i¥ft ' ~1m~~~'jiitl:if~:i:EB@!jfl 0 m·~~jt~.if~*EB~~ii'~.EBJi1(;*#~UOO.~to~ffl~:m1:f~EBM~~.n~~ -M.M~~EB~~~~o~~~~.I=j:l'~~.~~~~~~~.~MBA.1:.-M~XllEB ~~~~ltEB~~·~OO*~~.1:.~~~iiEB~~.@'~~-®Amm.EBm~'~M':&. Ar~*M.m~•• ~·~*tlnmmm.~JoJql.~~.~EB~M·mu •• ~~ • .:&. iitl:fr~fFEB;i;*~~·~~M.EB.'.I!i,u~.:&.~.m.@.EB~~m~o~~r •• -. 18. pq. !. '(n"m~jll. 1£.tfiWl. ~E1] 1!f1lli1i. 'llrJ:!ll~*;t:fi. Ii mill.! If, <P S~J II:.IIfil.lll. ~.J\:~.IT~. tflil$fF. ElI't\J~'!li ttl if'l .. it;tf1l. i;(liT1'f-7j'i'iIII. T('F2f~m. II:.II'F;~~. flll:~~3':. '. r::lf'§i~. ' f\';.Illrp1m. :qokfH~~U12J. 1i~T II. flJirMHlc. {i~!\ll!~Z;itlli1.0E7;J7!. ~*,fIJ1ti.:il':~fIJ~. iro ~~ MIL II. ~*,flJ1iil)it:il':~fIJ~. ~lJ;'f~t'i:~A.mtill~'L'.f!ll. f1~i[ ~l*2)!1! j,Jl7;: rlJ}~j!iJ!l(l.lf. g. ±~. f[;fj PJ ItltiJ. :w: .!\ll!J:!IlJ·JI'7J1t~U~. ~ ~ fl, '¥. ~~r::#"iJq;ll'!tJ:!ll. * •. ilitA~lIiIJ. i¥iPJA IEUl, Jl!. ?fi~EB~$X~~lfo. ~<f. ifi jt;.ffi. ~~~J!m.i1i. ~llijb[.]Tiitl:frEB~~W!fr · :l{fjt~~ A1:.mEB~.. ~'.:&.~~EB~.:fl:MBA~WI=j:l'm~.1:.*~EBJi1(;~,u~.:&~~~pg~EB~~~. fill. ll\1J!~!IClJlf: ~j/j ;1},m~a~1t. -'~~iitl:frfl':&~EBm~B~~.·iitl:fr~~fl.:&~rr~EB~~nt~~*~5i*'m1f A~•• m:r~~iiJ~':&.:fl:iitl:frl=j:lm~MEB;i;*~~o.:&.EB •• ~m~iitl:fr~~'I'm'. •••• J.~~ •• *-.~. :Ja1E ?j~i'I;. il] ?I~~r;UJ f)ili1!lt~.fIJ i.'t. ~t:~fOrli'tt- jllRilIi. :il':1!.iE'/lI;li ' J: Ti~n&ililll Pi'. kilt ~-T'ffii;'" -f Hi m.;1!li. (ttl!lilI.Ill. r::~~$ilt;~~ IBM r::#$~~~ llPiff ± iID~(t]~MHtt ~ :il':.u'III!?ffmll ' m.;~'!t.lll Jt~&,fc;?ff.1l : &.fcittti: il!HJ i: m jg{ fc;1tI: i: ~fmIm!l!l IJtiLJlr~1II! :il':.IBct.'J?ff11l : ij~:l:.!~fll1'il!fj.jtm Jt~Jili't,''lQmll : &fc;li:.ij.j Jt~B!:I&'if;lt'i'l l£~Jilfc;'lQ.1l : li:i*;~iilt Jt. tlUb li: ~(t] r'f- J {1':~Jilfc;mlll : ImM.fIJ~1Jl1II! :1£ Ji i:E &. fc; ~ tl!l!b,{g. '*. .M*~:. ••• ,rJt~~ • • j • •H.·. -19.

(8) ~. gg~M.~~MA~m •• &~.~ •• ~o 'fflJt J 1ft ' 1U.I±lTM.~ : (1)~fr}(2)M. ~9=t·~T~~ •• ~W.~m.~m~~'~*~§~~~~m~ti.m~~;~A~~~M. Wili6(m(9):z'-~fI®i!:bt~lEft(1O)11: -rrA__. ~fl;1.t3{~~~.im:M. 0. ~~.m.~j[~~J~fi.~~~'~~~~~.~**mJ.~.Ilif~~~&~~oa~~~. ji\~~ : (l)~~M'm /:Z,-zp:lEft ; (2)MIlfl,.~. ' ±:I/Js l.mt.JE.~f'F .&.11:~~Jj! a. ~~mt.MM~ft~~,mt.MM~.~~g:. ~fld,m.'~.~~M.E~. :.~.M.11:/~.~ft •• 11:;W~~/. ( Lindblom, 1977) '~~~~MM.1tIJ;L -. IJ£*AfI ; (9)~*flJ~/@~~:!ifl ;. ~.o&~*A~~~m.~~ •• ~A?~~.~~~~~.~.~~~~.tt.:Z,-~,;mfl. .m~~.~'. ... ~M*·. h,,\ao.... •••*~~w~. .~A.~j[.~~~m.'~~~~~~.mt.lftr*.J,r~.J,r~W~~J~rW. •• ~~o E ' ~ • • ~As9ik:~rr••• ~~4'=-~1tIJ~~.±:~~.~~~~. ; ~Jlt • ~POO~~B ~.~.m.~~~,~~~.m.Ift •• a~~~&~ff~o~ ••~A*~.~rr •• ~'. .m.J.~~MM.~~~. (~fi~WA·~~~~~:!i~~~~H.' ~f§11lif · ~R!R"jj'~~1Wm.~mJfL&IDt~jiJ ft!!. fr1 ~lE~J,i~R:: lii'r~ 6<-,~~. >. , ~ A a~~~:;R!li:~~.:lt.~ l;1Mik:-f;l]~.. 1Y3l11E. ,. <b. .~~I~.~Ift.B~~,-.&~~.m.~m.*.~~~~.m.~.Ioml;1:Z,-~.. *~.ffRm~~Ilif'm~~~~~~~~. $ • • ~~±:~.~~~l;1.~.~~AB.~~~m.~~'~m.Ift~~~Tmrr~.m.. rtJcW{~JcmM~B3*~ ( Akers, 1989). ~m~fto. 0. .. •• '.~~ff.R~~~•• ~.B~~~'OOM~~B.~.M~~.M~~'. ~ft!!.nOO~~~~~.~@c~~~?rro (*Xm.M~~i6(m*~~~m~m~~~~. ·~.m·~~.~~~~~A~~~~~~ J~.m·~~~~~~~Ilif·~~U~~~. ffl.:a~*.~.T.~~mr~• • • • J.~H. .:t::. III. ffi .iliHUftfu'. ~~~.rr.~~~n.~~*~~*.& ~*~~o~.~•• ~&OOft.~~'mM~ ~'~~~.~ft.~~*R::~~@~~~~ ~iI±:ttBIDtIY3~.r.~J~m~,;m~R::R.. ~@.o~·~~±: •• ~R!ft ••• ~~ 0. ~1Y3~~.o~ffl~~~.~~.~.~~~ ~~~flI~~~jj'*€f MBA ~~ ~.~j[Il(J3 ~liimJ' ~ig~~A~~.~fI!fj 'OO~~. ~1lif~~*~~~~'~l;1~~~IY3~~. ~.~~m.mJ~~m.m:!io~flIr~~. :g. ~. 1'1. ~. ~. ~. 'fi:*j:~~fl,iiftjJtmY. ~il~~tp~jb. 'ft:Il. i1i~flI!tl/lll. f.1t~~~~iJ!. 'rrl~gl/lll. ffi.~Wl. ~l'1IfiE~11:. ;fJ.fiI!~AtBJ\'::~~. 'lf~'fi:*'±:~. ' ~zpmt'¥. ,. 1~J!I!.ro'rm. Ii mlUl Gf, <P tBlfii\: .flfil~ •• ~~.fi~ ffi!JfftB1'll~lUlGf, A tflilfl:ftF !3f!.\.~iHIi. ~~$~m.m~~~~M~·OO:z'-~~I~. ~*~~~~·l;1&~.m.~~~~~~. 'l;. @m~/ll~. ~~.R::~.~ • • ~m~~~~,~~~. 1Ll*1&fltti~l~I.t • ±:lbtJlll;1@JR! ' l;1M()I,'~. ~~$llft.~.~@J~. 1~. •• ~~~~~·~~~~o). ••• -~W. :il::3f! ~ :It llH% 'if ~. ifjjlr,i!!l7KJf!: ~11Tf'f- '15. ~IHI. m1t'i.±:ffl IfH'w.:m. ll11t.If'!;W.'i!j:. lIilI:.~~. ~UHfU:lliJ. ~1U:l1 ~ .flljl',!} ';Hi~. -2;-~fiI!itzitllI1l7lo Afl1(. ~rj:' I'll ~. ill lR.fll ~. :IHfHl. ~ i!ij: ~~ IlJltll fiif'1l1[ AAW~jJl J,jli 1:IJ/[iI!lljl(jJf lJ,iJ(E*fl: J(t:m~r'ftp J!l1l.iJ! ~--r'iIDA -F1lifocll. l!ll!,*fIJ~~ffi.;fIJ~. 'll\fI;'j'Z W~AmttV~,c.'J!Il i'j1.I~+01Uj t}i!Jilit~fIJ I,i,: ----. :il::.iER;I1:'..tri¥i~i!limj!{. m.:flI!t'!l'~. ~:It lIi 14 ~!I\ :il::.w,m'$l/i ffil!afu''$I/i ~~~II amt.lx~ '$1/i~!l.1l hX:lz:fiillllRl iE.a.iI'i'!ltll\ iE .fti';',1fl'l/i iE. tBft 1M''): 'it iE:.a.;V'$11I iE~tUb:lz:r.t;B':Ir.f. J :il::.i;fftfri.-2;-iUl:* iE~a.m'!lt.1I. IBM ~:ltlli:1o/.J$~. :Jt!m±ml=(l':lWU~~1l. ' ~1l'ilfJ!l!. : afritlk~ : qr,:::l!l\;fIJ~~m : ft ;V:lz:~ : .tJ:r.t;,li1Ml : ~~ml.!I\;fIJEt!m1m -------. .M*~: • • • ·riE3f!~~.J.wn.·. -19. FE. 5.

(9) ~~.§. 1. ttA'. r ~jij![~g:}jHf:J'L.<J!¥ijjt~~1f:1Ji* J. 2. *t1itB3~' r ~~:W-l!i::~ili~:m~~ Month, Nov. 1987 0. J ' 1:It:W-~~)(1i. 3. !~J!HIi' r W~~~A.S9ifd:*ftji5~:tg:1f:1J~ Yl ' 1{ 134-150 0 4. ~IiE' :q::o. r iliG&IlLftll1iliG&fimS9~~Jii1: J. 5.1*JWPl~l~' Nov. 1987 0. '~il:~1fiff~' );t]ilillJaj , .a.:m 68 i¥. J. ' .a.:m 76:q:: 12 Yl ' ~ 13 Business. ~lhtfi.rml~ztlM . ;J,~~~J]. '~If'*¥~1f'L.'~¥ ( 1:) '~OO.Jaj,.a.:m 63. r *~FJj¥~fiiJ:ftfiiJ1tf: 7 J • 1:It:W-~~)(1i ' .a.:m 76:q:: 12 Yl. 0. ~S9~~i1=.~M*zrl3'~~mIErPJS9lU1. ( ~PIf'F~m~.~.S9~~t~ff ' ~JiJfilJlX:S9 ~~ff) '~~_&rPJS9IU1.(~~~~ff'MilJlX:S9M**~~ff'~~~-.1r~)(.. 0. r ~:IiliG&~UIITg:Jii1:~WmfB~~¥i*z3lffl J ' 5C:I~1filf~ , .a.:m 68:q:: r ~1f,(}~¥S913 ~ " ~¥lI1Wf:l: J "L.'~¥'. *iff~z~i.~-.*.*(N=~lm • • )*Wf~I~~m~.~.S9.*'~~.. ~ 13 Fortune,. 1f':9it1ll1l~u!jft. ~ijjtS9IErPJJ~mim~). 0. 8. ~OO.~ ( Arcgue B. Carroll ~~) '~~~ifd:*. fEJEfIll.~l3'] , ~m 77:q:: 11 Yl 9. f!);t]R'. ,. '~=Jm1r~~1fi1f~mfB)(~'.a.:~ 78 i¥ 4. 6. ~~9!: ' ~~~ifd:* ' 1f'~.a.:m1r~ff¥¥* ' .a.:m 78 :q:: 1 Yl 7. !t[)(~,. {'f!~mM.Tif~qtl~jtl1MJlpltt. 0. 0. IErPJRmim~S9g~il~M~1:_.~*.,m~~~S9~~i1=.fi.lliM* • • :l:S9.~ B~Z~o~~ff-I~~m~ • • nmZJlX:*'~• • 1:~~~IErPJg:mim~M.~S9~~. 10. Akers, John F., "Athics and Competitiveness.. Putting first Things Firs," Sloan Manage.. .Ui~ If'It S9?1[fif. 11. Buzhholz, Rogeue A., Business Environment and Public Policy: Implications for Manage.. If'F~m~.~t • • nmZ.S9M*~~tl[]fiiJ? ;i!I:q::*~t~WfmfBIfF. ~m~.~.S9)(.If'~~lli~~JlX:~~~~m~iff~:1Ji*&~~J:~z~~i1=.M~o*iff~R. 0. ment Review, Vol. 30, No.2, Winter 1989.. 0. 0. ......~. .;... " fill! i:i. ment and Strategy Formulation, Second Edition, New Jersey: Prentize·Hall, 1986. ~8S9I~.~fi~A.8~~mS9~:1J00~BM&'~~~_ • • ~.-mA.S9~m:1J~". 12.DeGeorge, Richard T. Business Ethic, New York: Macmillan, 1982. 13.Lindblom, Charles E. Politics and Markets. Basic Books, New York, 1977. It Kohlberg, Lawrence. "Stages of Moral Development as' a Basis for Moral Education." In. Moral Education: Interdisciplinary Approaches, pp.23-92. Edited by C. M. Beck, B. S. Crit. tenden, and E. V. Sullivan. Toronto Press, 1971. 15. Kohlberg, Lawrence, "Moral Stages and Moralization: the Conitive Development. iI:*IUI.&~iliIBU~. 0. ~~ ,tlllfiiJ~~If'F~m~.. m'M'~ •• ~lUIm_~U/G~niS9~:W tJ,~~ (. 0. ( guality of working life ~Mm QWL ) 1if. 1:f5l ( Burke ) ~~~WiT ( Goodstein ) ~A.~ 1980:q::«;. Delphi ) i**iff~~'iUit~Jii1: ( Organization Development ~Mm OD ) ffif ' i'fi1tf:¥. OD S9iff~:it~.fi:it5jr.~_llifD: ( Burke and Goodstein, 1980). 0. r QWL Jm~**m.iff~1f'. rm _ . 1: '. ~:p. JiJf iif lUI ~ m. _. ~. M~~~S9~Jm ~ S9 ~ f4. 0. J. If' .gr ~~ ¥!j. Approach" in Moral Development and Behavior, Theory Research and Social Issues, edited. QWL' m Tiff~ QWL ' ~~_:1Ji1=. " m~i1=.&m~i1=.S9 QWL 1f',L.'oJ\;f!'UIiJlX::lr tE_:1Ji1=.:1J. by Thomas Lickona, New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1976.. 00 ' tmDIl,tI*¥m~li!l~:f3( ( UCLA ) ~~~1JUN:lr*¥ ( Ohio state university) JlX::lrT If'F. 16.Kohlberg, L Philosophy of Moral Development: Moral Stages and the Idea of Justice: New. 0. ~m~.If'IL.' ; ~~~i1=.:1J00 ' tmil~~~Wi~ ( OSLO) JlX::lrT If'Fiff~If"L.' , ~m~~FffJlX:. :lr. York, Harper and Row, 1981. 17.Steiner, George A. Business and Society, New York, Random House, 1975.. m. ~. I. ~ ~.. If' ,L., ( National Quality of Work Center) , 9!: m S9 ~jiHl Wi mt 5l ~ *. (Tavistock Institute). ~1fiIj;ftS9j:t~~. (Department of Employment). ~JlX::lrTIf'Fiff~!t[. UL ; ~~~i1=.:1JOO • m~~Inu ( International Labour Studies ) ~:lrT QWL S9iff~!t[UL ' JJ 7i--MmTIf'F~m~ll:S9m~~~. ( International Council) ~~ 1975 :q::JlX::lr ' l:Jfi!fimffS9. QWL 1f"L.,tft~HIi:W • .Ht~WJ** QWL 1f"L.'Z~:lr ( Bentley & Hansen, 1980; Gadon, 1984; Lehrer, 1982; Newton, Leckie, d Pettman, 1979). 0. Jlt7i- ' Ii];) =f~S9~~~fl.A.~IUI~l6}l6}S9. ~ QWL ~t.3tFfm ( intervene ) m_S9J!~ ( Organizational Change) '~rmJi~m.S9~. -. 20. -. 21 .

(10)