公私部門合夥理論與成功要件之探討

全文

(1)~.-----::------------------- ~lt:tfll. ~rs,. San,. Whither. earning, 'earning f,·. chaos:. ~*fJ] .. ~nl1J. olution.. '1e: The ~arning. I. OJj:'t:~. ...... El. 'nlJ. ifelong. ~!It '~DfPJ~~~~. S~:WW.fjHl!~-*~*Ji!I!. ~~~~~~~,tt~~~~'~8tt tBJ!I~J£1t. 0. ~~~*mrr~~~~~W~.£.'.1VG. :day. ociety.. (1993: 9-10). '. 0. .lli:,~.~~~~~r~~NmJm~. Jf~Jf;fW~±~fifrOO~Ok]0~rtl5. IBB~ •• ·~ft'.~~OOti~.~~. 1!! it : *J:l: iffi Ii 0''1. r. ff ~ )( 1t 11. ~ in. ~~$m'WBmrr~~~~$*'.~.. ( Reshaping Administrative Culture) ,. l~m.m.W.~~s~.,m~m~~. 0jE;=O-O J (Path to 2010) ':5€.O'j. 1~~hW*~.~mrr,~~r*~s~. ~lW. J (Next Steps Program) ,. .iJ.1if J ' ( tho. big government). 1:fJl~liV~ r:p. 1.,~~~.m~h.~~~~~M. 00. "f ' ~IVG r /f"PJ1Eil!. J. B'j. r.. I ~~. \m. ~*/J. (Efficiency Unit) , r 0 ~~¥ J. d••• ,~~~~~~·mg~A~$* (ungovernability). I. J. J. (Citizen. Charter) , r ~R.~IJ.~* J (Service Quality. Competition). ,. r. IYJ tm. mfli;. fIi~ Jj \. m. J. ( Departmental Deregulation Unit) ·1.~.Ok]r $)f. •• '~OOmlVG~~~.tt~~.(#.m, ~ 80 : 199) • R. Mayntz V)\~YJs ' lli:~. +1f. NSM) • r fT~r!'flt1IB~ J. *'m~.~OO~7=.~~.W~a:/f. Flexible Time) •. ~Ji J1ttL 1T ~ fj. ~~l!.tt,.~.~.·~l!.~.~W~.. J.t J. (Neues Steuerungsmodell,. (Administrative. iE.Ok] r fTJf3l:El 1~1tJf~~ J. ( the Administrative Modernization Policy) ,. 95.

(2) 1m JIj B"J. ~IS- ~~J\itJt ' t§~~li~~:tfttBW3iI:BI¥~. ' EI iIJ it::: a5c 1fi J (Autonomisation. B~~B (rr~~. Reform)' fjffl±W~:/:tBfrjB"J' ~JT0~rgllfl. J( New Public Management) ~iIJ ' ~~8"J ' ~~.~ ~ZP~~~ff J. (National Performance Review,. , & 86: 68-69). 0fLtl~rF. T ' r:p*BWB"J{lt~ • •fJJ~~jlff.~-~IS-=. 0~iE5cm&i:. -B~+m~,m~*:tf. 99.49% (~~t~1i. '&. BW~I:B~. 88) ! ,. ~~~. J. B''lfJ;A '. ~.~~'~®.~B.~~~ttWft~tt. ~IiiIJfJ;A. ( iIlfJg~ , ~tl~{~ , & 87a : 20). 0. ~D. and. ~tJ. 'ii£-f®. J (bottom-up). ( Kooiman' 1993: 4-5). 0. ~ ~.~. ,. 0tlGr9~J~,W&rs9fL:g~r9-~ft{'F' ~[l"IJft'~. R. Green. ~~miIJ0~$~'~~~B"J • • ®~~o. iIPJA~ (~ifBitt:@.tI:WiE5cW:fI}~). Governance. ,. ffiH!x~-' ~rl=lllli:J (two-way traffic). mMB~.'.ft:::x,§.~B"J~~&m~0&. On. , iE!{W1'fi§. ~.ttB"J~m'~~®. a~1~B"J.~. ®~.BWmiIJfiB¥~B"J§B"J'~~~. (. ~.. ". ,. :{£. Reinventing. Government) --Xr:pfljl:B ' 15'B.~$~¥iT. ~ ~. 15'. ~ ~. I'I"J 0 fL $ F9 ft. (public-private partnership). ~. f~~ElJl. - ... .~~WB.~B"J0&$*'~®.m~m.. ~D. : ~~W~~ (Bernett & Krebs' 1991) , ( Giarratani & Houston' 1989 : Jezierski '. ~~:tf~BW~I:BB"JB~~E+=;&~A+. ' 82 ; ~~ , & 83) , B* (~~~, & 86) WltflJ &j (Bouckaert ' 1993) ~~* ~Jft ' ~fJt~ MBffi.B"J~B,~n~~~~.~B"J • • ' iJ I ffl ftH~*,~~1Jr~ '\lfz~tJft~fj,~~~ , fBfB1M1i~ft~~(l=IliTt!t$c ' ~U~WrBJB~. E:tf,r:p*BWB"JmR• •W~~~iT.~-. ~prrWJ~. W~~tHljJf5t~~WAM. ( 1996 : 38). 0. 1990 : Erickson ' 1994 : ~~I3Jl. ;. tJft. ~~~'~MB$M~,r:p*BWB"JmR • •. ~&~A+-:tf'R~iT.~E~~B~Jt'. 96. 0. 0. 11~k.g.~. ~1~~t1. '~J. (partne. Singleton ( 19' ~~ J ~1Ill!.'l~. :. (-) A. Ro. ventUl. ~~W0j:!;$. 1. R.mm.~WM~e~~~~~~.~,~. ~*W~~~~*g.mff,m.B"J~I:BWM. ~. fUH*, '. ~~~:@,~~-'~~~BWOOti• • B"J~~. WIfiH[;tJ*~~' ??a.m13t8"J15'iE5c,§f~.~~. ~-H.. ::;:k::{FI. cp, fi¥t0fL. (top-down) B"J;fJ;A*m{~ftfJZR ; Bt®~~IlJIi=. 0. W L. Hubbell. EEl:;,JiR ( lE!. 0tlr5r91'1"J~f3&,~~a5c.e~!05c~~. ~&ft~B"JffB¥iT~(rr~~&~~~'&. Ii In I'I"J Jt rtJ ' ; i~,{!fI]. ,. ~~'~'iTBW~iIJJ • • ~ffi&T'. :tfiTfliUXrg J (Public Service 2005) '~rfHB"J , X'§25c1fi~~ .J ( Public Service Reform Act) , 87b : 2-3). ®~1f. ( 88) B:{£iE5cWB''l~JjMiE5c'&P*''JW~*t~B''Jm1if§. NPR) , 'iE5cR~ffl}~.~'j[ J (Reinvesting Government Lab) '!JO**B"J' 0Jt-OOE. 0. advan (=) K.. cr. iIPJfJU. ~{§1. *1BlJ. (-=) R. PI. ( COl. ftf4. EI. ( b.

(3) ---------------------. &3ttf:lf¥J ojffi~if:. It . 1}fk.g.. .!,. *& 0~ $ ~~ =t- -i!': *c 0 fL fiG F~. ~~~Is=. 0~!f!<:. f 3t ill f¥J. li~I¥J~~,#~.~AOif:~u*l¥J~mM. ,'i!.UI fT&~. ,. (~i~~. ,. ~. 83 : I). 0. ~~. ,. *i'?~AJJ. .fffi~J. - ,. ff~lliI~. 1:£::$:firHt. ~. Singleton( 1994: 2-3 ) ~l!I[J;) ~f[[gfll~1f!tj' ~ J LIl~}j. ~[pJgf~. ( - ) A.. kL}~$. ,wa. 191) ,. ierski '. (. ;~~. WltifU 1:£~1iJ ~,~,. jtfL[g&j. 1&M'M'. :. (. (winners of all 0. .+.+0. '. E~~~. -flf§M"*J3.~'111J'3~{*l}lG~~ ; E~4F~~L~. Rose:1:E7!W;j1l]5R:f ' I1tI"Fs's'3If!WJ. .fffill.*~tt,gU1fOO.~Mmtt1:~.1:. '. ~1¥J~5R:,m~If!WJm~m.*~*m~Io g~~ ~4F~-fIRPf,f,ijif* ' fffi~f§'M' § fJ~~. ~ff~.~l¥Jm.tt~~,~m1J1f~~m1J ~f~Wm1Jg~~*6*1¥J:@~ (IX; 87 : 611). 0. ~1:~'g~JI¥J~~.'~Am~'. ) K. Cherrett : jJ:M~JU~!~JtI.la'3g1'Flt~H*1l f,. ~ .. J. l'~~~-fiMm~I¥J • •m.,. 0. '1. I. AlRfto.I+-;§Y,1 ~ hh- ';IE I /.::>-al{, IIIJ:?'C~ Y:.I7GXfI'C"),,.11 'fllll~ C1;f';9 J. ' l}lG:;!:fJQ]~W19:~Jla\~1fFdl (joint. venturers) Lrml* ' Jjj~RPjJ:Mill"~llt[Pj. S 7' 15 I¥J iflJ:@ ( mutual advantages) fffi:tt:[Pjg{'F. !~g~. ~w~. -;r:;; LB. ~f*. 0. f* ~ RX. I1tI"OOett.~1¥J. parties) 1¥J~'11~Jl~. ' 5t I/.::>1.-:1 ~ AJJ ' i~ rffi ~ 1f G.. r traffic). fF. (marriage. ([[g) G, Duff: g~n~-flgf'Fl¥Jrm{*,. 1:£f*iM0fLg~~I¥J.~LM. partnering). "J. 0. :@.~~~.m0. ,; J. ?1J. convenience). 0. tom-up). ':I. (strategic alliance). til! tU *6 g. I. 1};fA-g-.;Z~)i!i. (. *um'f,~ J. I. $, • •0Ug~I¥J.~W~fflL@~~-~. ~Ml'ff~. I. , ?fO~~~~j:lH~ ~fi4Ft~>G\ (non-core) a'3r}]ff8 ' .L-~~ @.m.~:@'~l¥Jl'~'~fi • •S ( outsourcing) s'3:@'~. ~~;Z JJ.!~ 1=f jjt. o fL fm F51~ g ft ~ f* I¥J*6 tfij"~ [Pj m mE. @l¥Jnfliffi. ~ftt:tIJ. .. jJ:Mm.~~*n~~~~~,fffi~U~. ~Jn~l5~"~~~ff~~.,~m*~[Pj. ~mff~m~*~mR*l¥Jg~,U~. ~:@I¥J§.~,~~m1Jg~o. *~~l¥JtJj~. fLg,~ n~0fLfiGF5. 0. ) R. Pollock : Mij f~ ~ J;) 1: s~ 0 BJ ill". ffitf:lW~~~. PH m. 1:£ ·-~J3..f~{'F' *6 gf-'J. M"fljUs~ .1:/1:£ ( master/servant) W §E13*~~ fljus~m 1f/ 1f ( buyer/supplier) , &:9i- imt 1c (companies). '0 I m1J J :tt:r8J~pX:]!! f:ES'3. 0. I. 0 tL g. ~~ J. (public-private. partnership) ,4§.*~1f~t!l'-' S. Langton WJ~0fLgf~~ 1980 if:{~1&fiSim1Ts~M~. , Fs~iJ!:Ifu~ , !l:tffl1~,I$, ~~!f!<:Jff ' 97.

(4) qFgflJ~JHl~Mt& 1~JJVi¥Jm ~1:.E~*.ij[W[t. :1}fLff~r~~~ffijpxi¥J~{*' :tt~W=1£HM~$fij. 5Hti¥J~. M.*k'~~~~W~. ~. ~~~~~§~~~'*@-~'&~I~~. ~~*&. ( 1983 : 256) : C. Bradford ~'6f.i}:1}fL~'HJi!:. i¥J~*oW.lf1; :tt~:1}fL$r~mtJ~{*l.:tl$Jf~. ;ff;raJ~*. m7~~m.Ri¥J~~tt,~~w.~~m·. =AJ:JJ:~~*mjJ:r¥' ~p~W~~m{lL1f)t. {'F~SH*J,",. i& 1M ~! fL $. ( 1983 : 326) ; M. Stephenson, Jr.~'6ffil§:1}fL ~'~i¥JJE~ , J:J~ B mt tf~B'~m7! ' ~p:1}t'fIW~~nLff~r~ra9-fl1ilJJJa"J. 1&~JJIJ '{lIMz.1W,~{fi;~5} 'pJT1f~W~f1§~. 17tl*5}~. nrQ] . JJJ~~5} I~fllI!r~ , ~f!~;f§~Ef1~~~ ~{'F~~ , :a~umjJ:r¥i1"~~:tt5&* ,~~. *'*~.. ~~ .L-.Tff. m1~'~f.i}: :1}fL$r~i¥J~~*~£:fj);~-~=jf. , 5}JJU{~~7 r :1}~jf{f J ~! r flJf~ J 'E13. .L-.:JJ. :1}$r~1£rwnljl~nrPJ 'fLff~r~~U~~J:J~. (_) m{. i&1M&OO.~~~~.~.~~~m'ffijffi1i. ~'=~U~~*@i¥J• •ffi.'1£~m·~. (~)~{. .f!i!:tt~.jJ (Lasser' 1990 : 155 ; ~1JJjll,;g ,. ~~~fMT. ~{*. ~i. r~. i¥J. ~. (trilateral relationships). ~ 88: 8-9). I. .~i¥J. 0. J:'. m~~m·. v. Kouwenhoven ~1J~ffil§:1}fL~. '. (~83 : 61). ffil§~raJi¥Jff,±~§ ~&ff,~~tl!:rw~. ([g):ttl. (E) ~fn. 0. ~ffil§:*§i&1MW~*OOi¥J1iIJJJ'1£~M~n. ~m¥~U~'6ffil§ , :1}fL~'~~f*nm1:.E:1}fA. ~.i¥Jm~.~W.{f~T,m*~~.w~. ff~f~1i~3&!fll!:f:1 ,:1}ff~r~WfLff~r~~pjGzp:~ll. (1\):1}f. ( 1:;) ~.!j'f'I~. *M.i¥J~~§~;~~n~~~.~~fik. .·~~~W·&jf{f5}.i¥J~~'1:.E:tt.~. (A)~'. i¥J5}Iffij1fm~J:i¥J.~'~=~~*~1i1JJJ. Ii7f~Wi&*/J\~1l~iJf1:1}fL~'rf7 -1~tm9;H. !:f:1 a"J ~,~ fet Jl:t 1£ ~ * 3&! fIjU';g £ ~~ zP: ~ i¥J it!! elL) ~ J3 m'1f~ffi~i¥J~ • • 'ffij~px-.ffi1i~~ M' ~±~~a"J~{* (~83 : 1-2) JJ ' Jl:t~ , ~~~9P!Jj~fi.~ ,:1}fL$r~~~~$ (+). B'~JE~ : :1}fL~'~~gj!J:1}fL$r~ffil§~IE]flJ~ffij. ~~~:1}U$MOOti~~~~*W.{f5}~. u.-m.~m.mm~ffijpxi¥J~~~g(. fllI!r ' f~~m5}ffil§ r ~1'F.1* J (cooperation, ~) W r ~~~{* J (partnership) 'rw~f*t~i; ( ) J ff~r~1:.E1iI}]3&!fll!:f:1 ' :1}ff~r~15tM -fl r ~~ (r 'tiJ' r:1i:3i'!1J i¥JfijfS' ffijfLff~r~~U15tM r[[l 1}fA~ il'!1 J i¥JfijfS ; 1&~~IJ*m:1}fLff~r~:f£lilJJJ~ 1£ft r. mjJ~~i¥J5&*~tt.§fi~£~5&*W5& ~~ ( 1993 : 120-121); ~~~1J1f.Rm.i¥J. ~~. ,. ~. 86 : 22). 0. 0. ffij~P'J~~~~aJHW~'6ffil§r :1}fLff~f~mJJ. =,. ~1* J ~ r ~,~~{* J xffiffil§ r *r=ff~r~ J (the. third sector). 2 ,. *m*MJEfU~i¥J~W~~PX. -·fMFfJ.~~:1}ff~r~~=1' ~:fj);fL$r~. fll!:f:1,~px-.ZP:~li.·~~~W·&.~.'HA~. , ffij :fl:~:fj); 98.

(5) - - - - - - - - - - - : : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ltt:1,1. '~~$~. :.ltjlllfrlf~. flEH~. ~~W , ,' jijijf~~. .. ~tt~lJM~o=~Z~~~R1£~0~$~~. ~~~~~H~w~m~~mo~~M1£~~. ~~~&~ff5t~~~M, riS~IJM~J$~. ~~.~~$,M~ • • Mr0~iS.J~-. ~~~~~M~r~~H~J. m~?0$. ;OOriS. f'FIDH* JZ~f'F~*;tt~~;fIjJ~U1ftft<~f'Flt. j;ftJj~ff~0~$~Z~?1£1£~m~r0U. {9rr*5}~c (~. ft.J.~~-~~~~W.~o~~.~.. 82 : 12). 0. ~~~~~*~~~,~Am~0~iS~ ~~tJ~B~Z~i3. (-). ~8!~m r 0fJ,.iS'~ J ~:E1I!EB~a)j~D~. :. (. tJllrjtlJ~~frj£i:. (=). :m'~. ( ==) ~fg0$r~~MiE~~~. ml:M~. ([2]) ;tt~-~0fJ,.~m8~~~. ~~m~~:E1I!.;~1£a.lli~$,--~. ::fm~*~~iS.~m~~~~~~BrM~ J. 1£0 fJ,.. ( t\). ZP~R. ( 1::;) 5ft!,f1~f'FZmJ~ffi!ffL.. ;ttlJMf*. ()\) ~ r :9f.*~t1pq*~1t J ~~~m~~. ~ B~:L1B. (Jt) ~:t. '''-''' rilli:l. i$(t. 811. al1.J~. &.JHf. J ~IM§. Pareto efficiency) , r. (Pareto optimality) , o. 001£;ift;~&;\~~'11U5L~. , ij(JM&;\m~. 0~ij(~~ArtJ~Z~f'F,~M~~rM~ 1If;;;'X*i35c~ J. (Pareto-efficiency improvement). °rmm~0fJ,.*~r']iS'~fa)JHf*Z~f'F. '. ~RH~j;ftJjW.*.tJjf~m~~.~~. jJ,U$Mmmj;f~,~~,~*~). ~*~~.'H1£~Mm~,.AM~.m~. '( +) "r ~iSJj.~ J. ~~m. M,R~.mA.m~~,OO~~~~tt*~. ( 'E1ti5rtJJJ1;~::fli'{fAEtt ' :t~j;fJj.~. • • WR.~mtlJ~'~~.7~~A~.. (joint venture). £i:'~~Z'8~rM~IIf~*~~J. ). (. (. ' fJ,.*~r~iiU~$~ , 0m~r']mf~0;f1. ration) r~~. J. ( ~n : 0*~r~mfji;0~. 'f5ttt r*t~0. lW~rtJ~~.8~J~*. ~$JJ1;~JiH'F8~ro~Jl!Ii . ;tt5}tJT~Jl!Ii5 [El. 1. mfji;~rE1~fJ,.*~r~~Wi!~~>g~. 0fJ,. r. :. ( market failure). (E)m*~~~~~W~*~~ili~m~. 1iftXfi. ). 0fJ,.*~r~j;ftJj~~iSWj;f~R~x:im~. IJ ' EE iSt)Ja!. z.iS~. [~~~tt~~jJ. ). r {Ig;G*lW J (conflict resolution). OOR$~~.~mf$g~~~fg. 0. (-)m~.tJj~iSm~tlJ~~£i:~0UW. ~ff,±~,Ul-~. =' 21~A.g.~;ZI'EE. ~R~ltflJ. r 0fJ,.iS'~ J Z~*~i3~m~lWZ. lIt~ 0. fJ,. $. r~ fa jJ is'~ Z ~ Jl f'l fi8~@. EB ' m~0fJ,.*~r,]fajJiS'~Z~f'F ' ~f~0fJ,.. .·~A~~~mm~0~iS.Z~~,. 99.

(6) ,,. ~pJ~:$1-~r rJi~1f}m J' r Ah :&'H~~Jfji}m J .. B"J f=r 1& fi m :. Itt I!l DR 2fi': ~ flJ :fit [II e ~ /f ~ !iB ~ rdJ fB[ lltfU ~. W rr:1i:i/iU1lJmJ -==tt~:$1- ITiJijr~~rs9.W0 ~$B ' DJ'z:0 . f1.tt[5r~rs9~~fl¥Jthbhii~1m. i/itJ ' I}j\RIJilJf!l JJI¥J lI!Jff ~. Zft.j~OO.$U~.fiI¥JI~'~~ii~1¥J. m'~fi~1&Jff.~~h.!WJZ.~I~o~. ~. ttl~ r~ ~:1J ~iJ&~*l¥JfU:fit ZrJ]I¥Jft.j~f~tJ*~. r ft.j~*~ J. ' ill(riJiRihb tJ ii~~~. (conflict resolution). 0. 0. 'slfLl!l1Ei1rtflJ~l¥JttftIOOOf~tJthb. llt ' 0 f1. tt~ r9 Z ii~~ mm{*1'fM fi~~~'f!£j( Jff:Jt. hii~'~~.WOO~~~~fixrii~~. ~tf:~f'~0tt[~r9tzDMWf1.tt~~9~~W'Elt1~. ' iH1.ii~J5JT.!WJI¥J~. ' ~~{fi. -$BOOB;OO~~~~-fl~l¥Jil • • • •. ~f.ff cpuJHgE. W~f1tzDJ'z: ,jtJl~lIt*i~0tt~r9Wf1.ttl~r9lt. ~~~wa~~. 0~$~~llt~R • • I¥J.iiW~~I¥J~. mfl±m~WJ:Z~~' slfL~.$ff::1&JffeW' ~. ~J5JT. Z1Z\~. A ' m~ • • l¥Jf~JfJ~~ , f~DR2fi':~Hgfet{~N. J'z:-~fiil** • • • I¥J.~(. >1<W'iRJfJl1. ~mI¥J0~• • I!lOO".~~NiRJfJ'slfL~~. 88 : 51-52). J. 0. ~ j§ Z. 1~ ~-flr ~f[J5$:~ J' ~~-~fir ~.5$:~ J. 0. flJ~WfltJB"J:$1-~' f~f~0f1.tt~r~8"J.W~~. game) 53). , m~-- r 'rm:.5$:~ J (positive-sum (7Effifff"" ~ 83 : 17 ; ~jIH/itjt:B" ' ~ 88 :. tlfft~*j!*tJ1.$fU5Ujg:eW. ~1!l.il*$ml¥J • • w~m.*I¥J.. ~" . 0f1.tt~1. 13. il*cpl¥J~~~m'm~~~-cpftI~'. , mft ffii1& Wf I}j\un. ~m.W:&'f1.tt~r~.WI¥J*1~~.1B' ~HgiR. R1~.!i£~. il• • e$m~~A~I¥J~.Wmm~,~~yj\ @J.7 A~Wf1.mW~I¥J.* Itt)1- ,~~.gIi!. u.rt:l~~. 0. /f{fi~tJttftID~mI¥JMliJEr~, I}j\QJ~¥U~~ff::. 1&J&,mfl~*j!*h'fi1&~~A+t~ft. hl¥-:Jift±*. A +[9 B5.1fHfJJ r !£j(J&~m~~]! J:1J. 83 : 16-17 ; ~~~J:J. Jfftt~r~. ~. (1. 85 : 16-1'. 1¥J~5$:'~OO~mili-f[J.·~~·R~Wm. EJf , %iff::. (87. ,~cpij l~:lt~*~ff,$. ,. 1*Z~J'z:'. ¥{Eff:: ' 1&J&B"Jjfjgp:}]Hgyj\~]f1'ITI¥J~jf. ' mFiU m-m~~~~tt·~~.tt·W • • ~hl¥J. **m 00173 1iJfEi515i). 1=f~E. (A). ~1&Jff0$F. 0. r.WJ2fi':• • ~~I¥J§I¥J~~m7~m. 0. (::::). • •:B"'. ([9)%ifu~~~5$:W~~.WI¥J~.. 1L~Xflj. '. 85 : 17 ;. 88 : 53). !£j(JffeW ' Wij I~:lt~ . ~*~~ . :&.J£e~ mh.~ • • •W0~mB~D~W'~~:1J ~ZjL~If'f:El:.mz- 'l'U!!t :.mR\J~ r ij I~ :lt~tg~*ffjjj$ . DJ'z:-f~FiIJ~ff . •ili . ~ • • Hghl¥J1&J& ' tJmfl~*j!*h J. (. ). 7hffifffrJt ' ; ~*M:B" '. (Singleton' 1994 : 2 ;. '. ~ 85 : 17. ~. r fL$. ~. tt~r~z~~1. 0. aj(~f$~0~f=r!£j(I¥JifJ(lf}i. ~R0f1.$r~ii!¥~mmf*I¥JD:U:' ~~aj(@. 100. ~mm{*I1~~. ~°tE.~1. f$.0~fi1&I¥J~~ifJ(~'~~~.~l¥Jm. G. Duff·. •· • • l¥Jfi1&~.W·~:1J$~~:lt.tt0. *7~mfJ~tzD. ~~~I¥JM~~~~Afi1&e~cp'iR0$M. 0. 1Z\~~0f1..

(7) --------------------~~t1!1. ~lf:. l~g. , W1E*'tt~ IliU ' ~ftPlJH1lfH;fC1¥J 1}jt;iri&~ [OJ £~ ft 11:: 0jt;"§f l!t!1¥J 1t!. fJ:jHj~ (Singleton ' 1994 : 3 ; ~~ SA '. F j2g. ~. ~Jff:It. (. lSJ'. ~W0. 0. 85 : 17 ;. ). ~fJ.:O. '. ~. 88 : 53). Egt[l]~4'0fkaBr~i'ill!~lSMf*~~I¥J£ fi!-~~BJ3~D~. :. 1. jt;[5] § ~I¥JBJ3m i'i~~~g~I¥J~~Z-,~~i'i~~.w. 0. ff5&I¥JMtR:Iii±~rn~1m. ~affjt;[5]I¥J§~'~~§~~~mSAm®~. 1} fk aB F~ i'i ~ fiA1f* I¥J fF 7* QJ tJ 2j{N tR: m. ~I¥J ' ~D1I:t:n~g~i'i.~.w~~[]~f~l1trJJ~*. i&1fj4'QJ~~ff~I¥J~MJ F.}7~~tJ~ff5&l¥J:n. 1¥J• • ~M,®tt~l¥J~fim~&~.~m~. ;F~Jt. A~~W~Ntt~$m;~7~~~~mk§. l1t®ffj~® teEt''] (Cherrett ' 1994 : 8). !'. .ffi.Z~~~.,~7~m • • ~~.I¥J.. 0. ,~. 2.. -a--l7cb~. -M~~,ffl~~~Z~F.}~~L~*g. ,~m~~Wn~~~~£*I¥J~~o~. ~!fj{Jff0aBF~. , fklmr~ , w~.zm1Ji'ill!~fiA1. 'hC,*,~ , ftr]f~fJl$!~~. Jffar5r~, mf~a!N]I!BJ3ml¥J!f~JfH~~W:n1oJ. , *Jl~~~:n~~. '. Wa!N~QJ~~~ttm~TU@~'~~ff5&. "'t.jffi'. f-f~. fi• • ~MmW~.~~ffifiA1X.~ • • 1¥J f,±~rQ~1m (wr~ffrl ' ~ 83 : 16-17 ; ~~BJ3 '. ~~'iJ. ~. f1~I.9<:.. :t11::. r.U"lf: ,,;lE! ,~ ,~. 85 : 16-17 ;. ~ r. ~jIHJlilt:o. '. ~. 88 : 52-53). g:ttY!;. g~~li*,' {§..~~. ~Z@~,~.QJU~~~~~.~&~Ma. IDm. 0. o. Jf&:tE@:lIi'ill!~fiA1f*. ~,/f.~-OO.~Mffl~i'i~'~.ff~~. ,tJ. I¥J. ] 994 : 8 ; Duff, 1994 : lO). 0. 1& f§ (Cherrett ' 0. 3. 01~fH1Wf~Hl:. .. 1}fA.g-*~Z~IJJ~f*. 1}1~f1'l1WfEHf (openness and trust) ~~. f.. •..(. I. A$tl]{lJ:lI '. /ftl]{lJ~ J ' Jf&W::f~1}fk. '.~'n~~ID~jt;.I¥J£fi!°£~1}~. OOMZi'i~fiA1~~~~I¥J~~~m~§-,. I¥JMm,m1Ji'i~~:nQJffili • •Jt:nZM. &\ff.0fki'ill!~Z£fi!j2g*, f~f~0fkaBr~i'i. ID,.m~QJffili~B,@:lI~~~~I¥J~. .fiA1~m~,~~~~~~~m~z. ffio®mff]l!F.}i'i~Z£~,~i'i~~:n*~. ~N. ~ :tE~l1I!;f§fiA1Y.:1t1itJ.1&. ffilimff,gt~.~@:lI&WI¥Ji'i~m1Jg. grJl 1:0. G. Duff, .w~~BJ3~' ~1}fki'i'~Z~JJJ£fi!. {*, n~~li~~fU( Cherrett' 1994: 8; Duff,. *~M~~DIiII-4' ffi7f:. 1994 : 10). 0. ' ~D : K. Cherrett '. r~F~. 101. 0.

(8) ft!l~fi1J~ ~z~-EiW. 6. ~Jm~. AWA *ft'ill~li ~,. w:. $r~ra~;. 0. -Ei'frlJmf~~U Jm~h,. (Cherrett '. 7.. 0ZJS • §if£?~1}. ~!¥~~~j. ,. 'frrmf~Z~. 0lEt:!: '1'. • §~~. ~-. d~~&~M~.~.~£.*~. jt*4*Vffi : f'F~I3~ 4. fJl~@H!t:!:. ~~~~*f. 1994 : 8 ; Duff, 1994 : 10). •• ~W~ff~~~.~.~.~~~. 8. r{~fl¥ 0. 0fki}'. 5. H~~~1J~@i~r~'f1. @n!M~t~ (reactive) ,~ffij~Z' t'!P~PX~t!. JjUfl~MiIDffij i§ , 0fk$r5-Ei'frlJmf~ffl.. ~lE1i¥iJE~~~*B~~tJ! 0fk$r5-EinIUH~. mZ~h~~~~'~~~PM~W~~m. ~.~'~~- ••W~fJl~.w~~m·.. (~¥~~) '~ffiti~~a.tt,~a~~. 0. ~0$~@n!~~~*·m.~.·&.~~. ~[Zgn!~!Jzfmh. .~~h,.~a~~.M.~~W,g~W. r~-Ei'fr IJm f~5~ lOO. -Ein.w~3i;[5Jg~~~frJ{~ftf: (Cherrett '. ~.W~'~~.~1J~z~.m'~ffW~. 102. 0. x.~~f'nmffij i§ ,. 0fktm. ' 0 fk i}~r5 pJt~ !5JilJ pxf$ :±JW. Jjj~g. • r:kJ~. ¥tPE~~. pp.274-275. ~*f§j®~. 1:ERH~~. IJ\f&lItB~~. 1*1~l.-~ml.

(9) --------------------~l't:tf,J. ~~.~*,g.~tt.~,~~ • • ~~~. 7t z~irW~m. ~tm. EJJJ Iil~. ·"ltT. U$MOOz~~~1!,~*0UtmMzm.,. .,m~liJJJfifim~RR.*.~~*.. .~~~.w~§eW*5:W:°~~,0U$M. mo$MOO~.~RliJJJfifi.~,0UtmM. ~1Jm~z. ~~1Jm1~Umm:tE~~ffl~r~F~'tl00 ' fLg~r~Fdjz. If] ~ 1J. ]. ]. ~Uii. :9i_ ' -Ji&#!l'''tJ~Ff!Ejnz.M § e ' tlonJj\0. AWAzOO~liJJJfifi,.~~.R.*. ~. :5f~. 0fLtmr~ir~~lijH*j);~:ttm;JEZ § ~~.Jm. 0. 6. -1f]~1Jir~. ]. 5JTij!. (Cherrett' 1994 : 8). 9. ~7C§eB"J~J.m. 1t,. I~. (Cherrett ' 1994 : 8). rm ~ §. .~~ffifBi~~7CB"J§e,~~ffim~~~,. ~~fiir~lJmffi~~E,R~~0UtmMir~. 0. IJmffiB"J~~,~~~r*~JjJ~-~JZ~,. 02JS ' 0lEtl: iiifH'& 0 fL g~ r~ z ir ~~ IJm 1*m ij!~:tE 1Bt lit 7t~ • • ,.~~~~~~~z~o~fi~ir ~~1Jm1*zij!:lr ' 0fLffl~r~fBi~1JJ1JUl1'f 02JSW 0lEtt'~~m:tEir.~z • •e., • •fi. ~~n@iff_¥.~~ i&0fLg~r~~~~1j1'fftt. .,§e.~,~*.Mz~nW~fi~~. .~~. 7.. ~t7[.Z:W:. (Duff, 1994 : 21-33). 0. 1O.~1'ffB.~~ :tE~B • • ~.B"J.m$,ffW~:9i_z. 0. (sence of crisis) Wftt.~:ElZ&~. ,. ' tlOlit~. ~~~n.M~.~@~WffW~~~m,~. ~gfi0fLg~r~~~, ;g~~~ffi±.gUti.JfH. .~ir~zlm~n~.,_fim~z.M~. I. 1Z\1Jn1mW~1J§02JSlE~~)JjlJW. :ft~~B"J*5:W: t. ~ft§egJ.mZ~. ,m1'f.~ir.lJm~zffilmA• •. tt'. ~ WJji ~. .~~. .~. 8.. (Duff. I. 1994 : 10). ,~~ret~z § e (McCraw' 1984: 53-56). jJ.. a. $UfB"Ji1iJilil. l1.fBtlittl:Jf El. t,. o fL g~ r~ ir~~ 1m 1*.9t~~iri* '11 B"J ~. 0fLg~r~zW~!iJBr~ir~m I H=~:tE. JjJng ,. 0. , ;€qfgbUJ3.~*Ei.~mfEl1J~R"J ' ;g mfEi [BJ i¥J (Levine et aI, 1990 '. Ez~,i&:tEn~~IJm~m~~~ff_¥,.~~. ~0fLg~r~=~B"Jm~*Jf@p. .~~.E~B.~~,.~~A,~~.~. ~*fEl~!iL~ , i&0fLg~r~Zir~~1Jm1*1Z\1JUt~. ~~~ ; =}!Ij~~§3-~~~!m~~1li1T*Mi. :tE~~~RililZ~,~~~~B"J~~Rilil'n. m~~B"J.~wm~·:tEmJJJ0UtmMir~1Jm. IJ\fBillt(t'1~~~D~l!~mH~~~~' ~1~ir'~1m. f*ff_¥ ' :;fi0tmr~fil~~ltUfLffl)r~ , ~lf;ZfLg~r~ ~ • • ; .fLg~r~ifD is ' :tEir'~~f*$B~~. ~. P'J~. pp.274-275). 0. f~H~tJn~fljt1Hr. f!Ej~~~m~R"JtlfIjW~U95 ' -}!Ij.~0~A. 0. 103.

(10) , i. r. i. /Gzti~Efjj:tBflLc. ' ~~Jm~~JJ~;;m{j\:h '. 16-17). ~. 0. J. ~'~~~7iJ.H~~n~.~olZ9tt'. ~awJ. f*B''l:lsHtJj*~, /G~gf!jwfj~!H!.!.E!tt~m1~tt. ~m~AA~EfjiJ.H~~,~ttEfj~m~*0. ~&iit±W!B. Efj~iJ'ffWEfjiJ.fi~-~.~m~~ • •. oo~mIMtt~m~m/GJtfi~~.'~iJ.. ~,aW0. Hf*1~tXi'¥.. ~.§!; f~~ fL. ~tJ1~. 0. lZ911t ' ffUf~lii5bi~1ijJ0fLff~F5iJlI!$~~. :ni~:g (~~~. , .§!; 85 : 85). 0. 15.~JmiJf'FHf*. 12.~lID£ff:gf!f!. {E*,ltrlfE!~lfij"f. 0. •. ~. 0. iJlI!$Hf*m'-fl~JmiJf'FHf*Efj~:lL ' ;}p. ' W~~A:ff:J!!H±B"J '. *~m~~~,-~~~~~.~~~~m~. f!j fft;] ~N~.~J~rHJm flJ:£.itB"J tJ 11:. ~~gPIT~~ {l:3J~t fI f~w fijUW m:ff~ ztitJ ~11: ~. •. .M,m~~.~7£ff~m:.o{E~*.~. $~~. J ~Hf* (Cherrett '. 0. lZ91it ' ~ nJ,;11llW.L:;,... i/;r.U":}::.tF.! t=l. 0. H~~{E~.-fl~Jm~'#d~~~r~. 1994 : 8). 0. m ,. .. Ml1i.t~~~D2. ftfi i£j(::)('E. ~~~.r:j. tiaWmm~M~.~B~m~*~*E~. 16. ~ .~fHHQ] 8"J J8iJllR 0fLff~F~ iJlI!$Hf*o:r tJff~m~-flftiU. EfjgIjt°ffi.~m*.Efjm~,&.~Efj.~. Ijt~m.~~n,~-m.~~N~*.W. ~.,~.oo~• •~~m£ff~*.*.~ ~.~AA~'~~~~~"f~~~~'RaW. {E , J't~\.~ .b!~B'-1;fJi.:)(ft~.~ lZ9Jlt ' 0fLgj5F5~iJlI!$~' , H!t~~~~.~ , {E)tfPJ. F5 rPJ iJlj!; f'Fm:a:--0. mmf~H~B.~~:l:ftB''lfti(t., ffiBP~p.ff. .~~~.~,JtiJ.m.~~.§.,~~. tJ Zf~11'jtB1i. I*J~ 0fLff~F5iJlI!$rmf*lEo:rJtlltf!l!tElj:tmf~. :#~~nlli.~JJ.,ft~~.m~~~ • •. ~~~t!f. .~~.~~~IA'§!;lZ9~mmm~m~~,. 0. 0. ·.~'~~~~OO£ff:g@~.*·~R*~ .~:£.it. (Cherrett '. 1994 : 8). ( Duff,. 1994 : 22). ~Jlt-0t. 0. ~~AiJjiE;. 0. !J \1bZJl:t1t:g~. t:¥FH=£:ruY"""~ 13 ·I1=ilJx~ /'/U!~. !lt~0fLff~F5~JJ~ §. ~tzD. I ~1J€$1Bll[t~iJ. Al Gore. 1996 4 9 A 20 B NPR. PIT0:ffi~¥IH5' (i£j(:WB"Jf'l~fk:\lt~». .H~~*.~~IjtEfj • • &im,~~~~{E 0U~JJ~A~~Ijt~. ~~ill±*7}. •••• ~~.~,.. Kept Secrets In Government). EE. ~a~-/". 7IC '. JJ.E ~:£;. (The Best. CPPITt!lliaH11l.Y. ~~iJ.JJ~n£~zti~li.~~'~~~iJ. *f'I~f~lt~m: (1 )$~*r)a)(fAAm~.§!;aWB"JB'!f. flJm~0f.. lI!$~fIilJ8"JilfF. f~8*~; (2)il&W;r,H'if.mf~JfH~R~B; (3). • • ~8"J5 flJ, ~~~ 8'-1. '. JJijg~~rJJ'tPIT~~:#rPJ §f~. 0. i£j(:J1f .1t:~ff~HrrOOm ~ JI1$iJf'FH f* ;(4 )il&JM~ ill±m~AA~.oom~iJlI!$Hf* (1*'*¥J] ' .§!; 86 :. 14.~m0oo5am. EE~0fLff~F58"J*Jf ~B"JZ¥:~. ,. m-~AA. 104. 0.

(11) ---------------------~~t111. ~fhPX*. 16-17). zgli:t, tR&;,)lG:l}. mJf3(~ J. .&~&~~ffi~~,ID~~~g~·~~. fiiEJf3(~OO.MJf3(~.I¥-J~.H~'~~_*. , f~~~~. Z ' Jf3(~:l}$r~;J!21<:~Jt. y B. Bttfl'l;g. cpjijijJJtf£~j£.x~~J!2.x~Jt. r *~. 0. Z{"fm ' !\f~fffiW~rEl~:il::* '. ~*l:ffimt ' :l}fl.tfI5r~~~gf*iE~ B ffd:*. ~F:gflJm. $t~Bm~JGft, fl~tt' !it1fmt1' W7}~tt. Z fi'tx1! ' fffi. (catch 22) cp~~-tJ]. JfrlIf=rm#(zjj[ 1Z§~i&l:l}fLg~r~l¥-Jl'5~g f* ' rlI~:l}fL$r~fElli:tl¥-Jit£m~fi[!.Ij\ ' fi~ ~~~~ • • '~[QJ~~g::~:l}~MRWM. ¥M~rJ]fL$r~if§~f'F' ~rQlmll!lWftH!JJ:l}~$. 0. ~o. 9£Ji:' ~F. r~mmt~J. '. tHt-J r g::. lZ§li:t ,~i&lI'5~~lD1f*.J:)Jtt!it1:l}fLg~r~. 7~~ I'fI'5 ' iifffi IiLff~~~~1t~~ 18J fU iia:fffi. 'J\ 1Blli:t~~mZ~fi[! , ~t~*fm~*~;,fj£.x~. ' ~(fi. Jf3(~~~ , 1t¥iJE~~ _*. 8). ~fiJf3(~B.~~OOhW.~:l}~~1t¥i.N. ~~~r~aJ~Jf3(~o (~~~*m:m~Ji:. ~~MJffiJf3(¥~z-~~~ZI~'~~~. Jf3(~*.:l}~fiJf3(.~ft~'"~~~~Ji:~. !-fjijiU. ~*~**. ~*.:l}~fiJf3(.~m±mm~g::o). CjJd:lr¥ , lZ§li:t '. r~~[BJ~*~~WB;g1];i:t*MJffTJf3(¥~Z~. , /-:> r~. 0. 'iE~[QJ. ••• ~m.offi~,~i&l:l}U$. ff.t~j:t--0fLg~r~. 1jiEli f§li~ ,. , Partnership. ·~[QJ~W&.ff7}~~~m~~[QJ#(~,. ~zp:fi~m*.:g:l}~$R,AOO.~~~~. al'l;gJjt~. .iifffi.ftffd:*$~&~~g::m~*.;fi~. ~~ Oi+. ". ~zA~,~i&l~~ • • ~~I'5WmA'fffi.. Jf3( Ji\J [g :Ji\JI¥-J IJ~. ~ • • ~~m~*w~oo,~m~*rlIOOfiN. ~. H~;. (3). tJf3(Ji\JW ~. 86:. ' {Bf'F. a' r. JIJJ"'~~. ~-1Wf!1:OI. 0. ''''-I:~:::I(;:g+IJY.~. ffi-='UPI J J 1~:rS"1r I§ l' ~il:1. *li ( nonprofit organization, NPOs ) ; ~D : T, Levitt ~ 1973 : The Third. IJ\~li:t&£mZ~ffg' ~rlI~i0fLI'5~Z~~*5. 'he Best. , ~A~':mt6bh. , ~~ , ~Jt~,:mi1*~. i i I - - ' --P!ll:1I11. *~~~Jf3(~.~~~~.:mJf3(~~.m,.. ,.~0U~A~Wiia:;a.,.~0U~. '. ~ ~v €ilo 3J¥! €ilo /-:>- I!W _ --- ilir At:; /-:>- ""_ 1h -rr- -7 -a ult,mu"!"m 0"'-7 :::t-!(Xfll::; OT::7':--X.K.... ~~-:l}U~~.WzA~,~~rlI~-mi&l. B NPR. ' fffi px::m- r ~a J. lJii~I. zp:~. , iifffi. ~. a,.~.ft~~.Jf3(~.W.'.~~Ji\JM. Sector : New Tactics for a Responsive Society' r 0~nj£.xi¥P~~ J (PAR) ~. 1975:tf-1'I;g. ~rm. $r~l'I;g. :t!lJ (Management in the Third Sector) ,&. ~m~0U • • ,M:m~N~m,~.~~iia:. alli:A~ H. Anheier & W. Seibel rfrt~~. • • h~7}~,~m0U$Mz.W~~.Jt. flJ ' iifffiil¥U- r 'tELa J (positive-sum) ~ E] tt-Jo. : The Third Sector : Comparative Studies of Nonprofit Organizations (irri!!:. ~. 1. 105. 1 ;. !i ;.

(12) ffi ' ~ 81) 'rtIlt~JJ~~f'F~~;g~ r ta :JJ!m1* J -fiVf JIHn0ffGF5?fJ\/f ~tnfL ffGF5 ' mHji!::~tn0fLiiBF~*6iJffijmGl¥J. (~8Th). 0. rm_mMJ. iiBF~) W~FdlmF~. (m=ff3F5). m~~m~~J. (m. tJrf~1tf:. :. 2.:rJJWH~.~.~:f§M'IiI*. ;. TXiE, ~84: 3-4""'-'3-5). (3) 'J[ 1-14 (~ 83). 0. ~~-- r rEl~. , ~~ti)~~*~tlii*Mf. (. 88), l=j:l~iE~~~tJU[ .~t 0. rTi&~:::tH~. ulhlHx (. 86),. ~>. 98. '. :. < 1t:~rTi&JMI¥JJ~!L~W.. D~~!!~3t~6' 11,. ,<1t:~fii&JM~. f*'*:rJJ. ~I¥J~J~> 'DiE~~!!~3t~6' 12 '. 17-60. :. 106. Bernett, E(. 0. : gxx1!::;$~0~ • (~ 82) , < m!itJJ~Fa~.W. PI. .m• • :0U$Mjg:JJ~~~.~ > ' r ~rEl~~Wi)$~~Jm J m~'f. '. Bouckaer. 0. (~. 86) ,. 0. L. P:. if. G. P. D. 0~~!!. G. 0. .~t. :. Bradford. '0&.1J• • • ~i)$~. a. ~~~5:n%IHt;~jfft, ~:lr~w*.0~$. (. ~W~(~86). 0. =.. ~)l:. 0. 85), 0'A~Br~tli1JfijJi*~~jfft. 7'" ' 208 ' J[ 1-15. uti~'E~M(~8h). ffii. ~. < m!itJJ~Fdl.Wff~m.~ : 0fLmF~jg:JJ~~~.~ > ' .;tl~. 0. W iff¥1Hl (. 2I J ~~~~~E> ,~. ~~. ( ~ 83) ,. 67. 51HItR'. 11. at : ~:lr~W*.~W.PlLluJf~~jL'. 0. ±. < 0fLg3F~jg:JJm!itJJff~ffJ. ~t. ~~f'!J:J. •. ~~. ~~0'A$M~&~~~Wi)$~~~. .~a~D~.I.~±*I~m~ffi ~j±~ifBx. ,. I". 0. , 56 ' J[ 61-67. (. ~&~gm~~~ft-u~*.~.. :::tH~~. 80),. ~.WJ~.~>,I=j:l~D~~~'2. ;. ~:ij.§. - " r:p)Ol~~ TXiE (~ 84). D. 0. ~MOOmM'~~;W~:ffR~~.~. .*~&,~(. :$. < ~ifB/fPJttt~ . *1ta:::tft . Wi&~11=ml¥J.~ > ' 0~~r;HI~~~ ~~~~VlLHijf~g~~3t ' ~:::t~~. ~~f'!J:J (~ 82) , < 0fLiiBF~jg:JJ!m1*fO r 1} tfilrJT (. ~[!jJtf:l. 1.~~$l:ff*§M'~0~tE. ••m~.o. .*.1}~tTi&.*. ffij*=mF~pJT*~.~~~~1ft$l:ff. 0. (.. >'fii&~m~.·~.*.:::tMrH. .~.EllG~.,.m.~m~mm-m. F5. ~q: tit ffi. ?t;fff: 1,:tA:JJ.~e"ti~A.~fttlIf{25(i'fi. o~~'~B*~~.'. !m1rS:0~~~EllGfilH~EI30~g3F~. ~;. ,<m~.i&JM~&~~..

(13) ---------------------~ft:t1'1. ~~~]~. ~ijf:9'Cm. MN~1fi. (~ 81). lE~t. Ej ± ~lfB)(. Venture Corporation", Journal of the. 0. , ~~~;fIJ~Br~~1:l}:ttfJIESl;L. r~~. ~.,~~B~*.0:~ffB.ijf:9'Cm. :. 1ij±~)(. American Planning Association, 49(3), pp.326-335. Brooks, Harvey, Lance Liebman & Corinne S .. 0. • • ~(~88) ,:l}~.~~~~~m;LM. Schelling (eds.) (1984), Public-Private. 5±~'. ~,~~B~*.0:~ffB.ijf:9'Cmm. Partnership:. ~~~~. ±~lfB)(. Meeting. m~.,.W~(~86). ~~o. *ifD r 0:. ~i11t;~II'_l~. ,2. ~iJ!~. 0. .W.(~83). 0. ,~:ttD.:Dm. .~t. New. Social. Opportunities for Needs.. American. Academy of Arts Science: Cambridge,. :. Mass.. ,~~.~.~.~iBi1100. 8.R;L."-~ ••i11.W. Cherrett, Ken (1994), "Gaining Competitive. ~8. Advantage. Through. Uw~~m. ~n~~~o~~rf:!W*.0:~$~~. Australian. Journal. 5-> ' ~. :@ijf:9'Cmlij± ~)(. Administration, 53(2), pp.6-13.. 0. ='il:)($7i' ~~Jf~. :. HIfl~fIil o,JIUJ~/ . . .. ,. jfi~. 0. :. ;@!:m~m :!!ill: lI'iUi:t. 0. , Australian. Participation Initiation in Britain and. pp.29-35. Erickson, Kith C. (1994), "Partnership and Total. #,. Cost Management: Integral to Enhanced. ~. and. Efficiency:. Citizen. Profitability",. III. Kooiman,. Governance,. Jan. (ed.). London:. Australian Journal. of. Public Administration, 53(2), pp.24-28.. Participation in the Belgian Fire Service",. Modern. Giarrantani, Frank & David B. Houston (1989),. SAGE. "Structural Change and Economic Policy. Publications Ltd., pp. 145-157.. 'tj9'f. Partnerships.". Journal of Public Administration, 53(2),. Legitimacy. Erf:!{,\. Public. Economic Development: Public-Private. Bouckaert, Geert (1993), "Governance Between .'..(. t~. Strategic. Germany, London: Belhaven Press.. ~~~iM. of. Duff, Graham (1994), "Current Practices in. Bernett, R. J. & G. Krebs (1994), Local. ~~o. Partnering.". in a Declining Metropolitan Region:. Bradford, C. (1983), "Private Sector Initiatives. Implications. of. the. Pittsburgh. iBi11i1. and Public Sector Accountability-A. Experience", Urban Studies, 26, pp. 549. 0:~$. Case Study of Contracting with City. 558. lO7.

(14) r. "I. ;:1. ;i. ~. -t ;. ~~. ;. ~=-~~~~--~--------------------------------------------------------. of ... i\ ~ ", -h'L~ (!9 )]. H. H. Green, R. & L. Hubbell (1996),"On Governance. Glenview Ill: Scott, Foresman.. and Reinventing Government", in G.. Mayntz, Renate (1993), "Governing Failures and. Wamsley & J. Wolf (ed.), Refound. the Problem of Governability: Some. Democratic. Administration:. Comments on a Theoretical Paradigm",. Postmodern. in J. Kooiman (ed.) Modern Governance,. Challenges., CA.: Sage Publications.. London: SAGE Publications Ltd., pp. 9. Modern. Public Paradoxes,. ~.. o. pp.38-67. 20. McCraw, Thomas K. (1984), "The Public and. Jezierski, Louise (1990), "Neighborhoods and Public-Private. Partnerships. in. Private. Spheres. in. Historical. Pittsburgh", Urban Affairs Quarterly,. Perspective", in Brooks, et ai. (eds.). 26(2), pp.217-249.. (1984), Public-Private Partnership: New. Kooiman, Jan (ed.) (1993), Modern Governance,. Opportunities for Meeting Social Needs.. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.. American Academy of Arts Science:. Kouwenhoven, Vincent (1993), "The Rise of the. Cambridge, Mass. pp.31-60.. Public Private Partnership: A Model for the. Management. of. Singleton, Gwynneth (1994), "Partnering for the. Public-Private. Public. Sector:. Guest. Editor's. Cooperation", in Kooiman, Jan (ed.). Introduction." , Australian Journal of. Modern Governance, London: SAGE. Public Administration, 53(2), pp.2-5. Stephenson, Max O. Jr. (1991), "Whither the. Publications Ltd., pp. 145-157. Lasser, F. Jill (ed.) (1990), City Deal Making,. Public-Private Partnership: A Critical Overview", Urban Affairs Quarterly,. ULl-The Urban Land Institute. Langton, S. (1983), "Public-Private Partnership:. Wamsley, G., et aI., (1996), Refound Democratic. Vol. 72, pp..256-261.. Public. Levine, H. Charles, Peters, B. Guy, & Thompson,. Paradoxes,. J. Frank (1990), Public Administration:. Choices,. Administration: Postmodern. C.A.: Sage Publications.. Consequences.. 108. OO~. ::f ?I!£ j] 1i~. ~.ffilr"Etat ~/ ..... .J..A~i:. ~~*~. ~~mJ.Jrt. =ij;L.iiHJ'. 27( 1), pp.l 09-127.. Hope or Hoax?", National Civic Review,. Challenges,. "'. _. ---_.. Modern Challenges.. I¥J ff J!ll.1!l. ~Zjq~. J!. ~ Er'1 (Kaul,.

(15)