政府機關落實殘障者就業權益之研究：美國經驗的啟示

全文

(1)

(2) ADA) j. 0. (Civil Rights Act) li;;;a~zH~:. ~.m.N~~~.~• • ~~I~~~~r~. lifm.. ~ 1 ~-!l:II-~ 1 ~-l(-tJll:I-. j (. (Age Discriminination in Emp-. Act) '" 1 ~-tJJ1]~N I ~~~~m. ~Ifil!!IBEm j. itl.~~mrre~~~.m.«:{({I:Ifi~4!J ~ ~. N I loyment. '". !f£k<~~~I!!l!!!BE+. (. .0. ~~llJj-N1:::1. I. 1 ilIDl-N«:t~. W4~~~~~fr~~~~~.~~.~~W0. ~~m::::~~!f£k<~N~~~. ~ ~.mfrlJlR. 0. ~ !ifrW:jf)~.~.~~N~~~. ~ ~.mfrlJlR. N«:t~ ~ !ifrW:jf)~.~.~+lN~~e~~. 0. j. (. ~}L-~~~111~¢:N«:t~E~.:fi~. j. (qualified individual) ,. r 4!J1W~~~~. ~. ~. ~. 1\. ~. 1\. +. *. ~. m:t;~ ~ -Hi~n¢{-ffiJll~~~~¥~ '" !ifr I ~.-!I!R$N ~ j. 1995:58-59 ). 1H~~~IIIlIHt~leI. }L- ( Kohl & Greenlaw, 1992:88-89;Pati & Bailey,. litigation). (reasonable accommodation) ,. ~~ r ij'ilim!. Rehabilitation Act) tlJl7 ~ ~!!!i.'~.m.:Ifi~~~tliiii[ ~~ ~ ~3!!t:i~~.a;niligt!lt$i?~~~. tE~~~.m.:t:K~~~ilIDl- ~ :jnK-Hi~«:t~~}L-. ~~~4.HN~~<~~" -ffi~lt?~~*«~DN.~ o. Kohl & Greenlaw,1992:87-88 ). I '" .11.$-NBt~ ~. lJlR 1 ,. -ffi:jf)~nmI(W:tt11W4~'~1W4rtl'(m\~ln~#.f. 0. lJlR 1llllI\- .. f!1:::j~.mrrlt?~mr~<·:nEl-:Ifi~~~. lJlR 11llll1\- .. ~~~:jf).~~g~~~~~~~:tt:Ifi. ln~#.f~~~jg~~~lt?~ ·~~.IU~~~nnK~#.f~ ~. ~ ~ ~~*«WmtJtW¢~4W1l:tt1~.:Ifi~~ ~ rn:j~~~ 0. ~ ~4]u~.~~W«: ~ ~. 1 ~<4:j:K~~. .mrr:W~~mJ;1mrrtl>{~BE:Ifilif~. 0. lJlRll '"~~~~ '"~~~~~ ~ [I(~~f!lH~~~. ~~,.~~tlJl7~m.~N~.:W~~W«:o. '" ~~iIiM '" $1~~ ,. ~ ~4H:Emrri$~nnK~~*" ~~ '" 11nrrjfflg '" ~~~ ,. ~~ '". lJlRll1lllll\- ··~:jf)-ffi~~~~~N<4:j:j~~4!J~:tt I ~ @W4!JIW!JIi!&~~~:Ifi.t§t}L- ~ ~~~l~~tJt:Ifi~~1ii1 llli~~BEN~~. ~~"'~~~~~.~+lo 0. .. *«~~~.~ ~~~$SN~~~e~~~ ~.m$~DN. '" rn:j1Il]~l~~tJEH~~-Rmrr '" i€d~BE. lJlRgrlllll\- ··f!~~.~~1mr~~~Nlif~~ lJlR~llllI\-.

(3)

(4)

(5) ~~~mftfi.R~~. ••. ~~.A.ffI. ••. ~-~~~~.m'~.ft .~ ~~ff m~~W.M • • ~W~'~~~mw'~. § 85 ~ ~ WJ 1'1= ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ 17IJ ' ~ .-~*gftg~.'.7~*B~~~W~ *~mH.Z *~.~m-.~,ga. '~.~A'A~~~~m~~A~~.~~ &'~~±w±»~.*m~ ~~., ¥~~.Z M~~.0~.~~~ft~~. m*. m m. fi. 0. ••. •••. ••. ~*§ • • m.W.~BU~'~~m~~~ ~.AA'M~~Wm~.$~~.~Bm~H. +-. !qj. j[f,t ttl! ~ 17IJ ' »a ~ B • r~ ~ 80 tj[ ill • ~ $~m~o@.:tE~' .m~IY3' 5Fm~A-tm. -aBa~0§~Ag~.*:~m • • ~fi ~~. ••. ~u. •• ±••• • ~*~~.*m.~ • • • =.0. ~§Afi~$a~.A ~~ FIT 1W • r~ iffU • WI 0 ~ WJ • ~ , 11 .~.~:tE~w~a~z~.-'.$'~$ ~ ~ 't~ A .. ' , ~ 17IJ jf. • A a ~U 0 ~ P) n r~ ~B~ • • • • • • • ' ~ffi'&fim. a 1D.I. 1'&. ±•. m. B. ,±. - ••. ff.1'&"H~~ti~Z ~ti.m~. ~~j[f,tm~.~~~~~ • • ~~=~Z ~.~~H.~am~~. WJ,m+~~. ~~.'~M. .-~~H~.. $B.~.' .m-~~!qj~ fi.~m:tE~~~~~aB~tt ~A" .I~~' TA~.mW fi.' • • ~~~, 1'1= W 1'1= ~ ifrt W\ • W ~~ " ~ I ' Et9.. I±I:tEff;fi'. ~~,.Z. ~~.fi~ T~~~~ 9U, M~fI ~~~~. @1 83 ,@ ~ B. ~~~*m.B~~.1D.Im~mmM5Fi:tE~ ~,~~" -.~.lt;m.~~O~.W: ~0Z ~ ~ M ~ ~ A m 17IJ • P) ~ • ' ~ ~ m 11-. *. ~7~.~A~.~. •••. ••. ~~~M. T,,-~mfl;m~ff.tiW. .H~'I.MA*._~.~W. "RZ.ffttl!W!Hm*'.~8. 1t.lllm~;j)t:Wllltftf-, m.mgOOA8.~. ••. ~1I1:E' ~~.~. B • fig. m _ m f1-. ,,~, • • I ' $*m~'fi' ZM .~1'&~.ff~C.BfI~~.0. ltJ. ~. W. ~. •1.i *• •• m. 14 '. ~ ~. "m~Ill~~~ff.A:tE~;m.$. ~. m~. ~. A±. ~~.~~±,. ~. • 'fi. 14 r~. ~mWljj\,. ~jf.m~~~Et9:11Et9:tE$~~M~ ~'tiM~H.a.~Mmmfi~. . ~.A. f;. .4-=--t .::. f; fiJ Jl .. A. .. 0. +. T~~o. ~_~~. ~. ••. ~. -~ffZ. .w~jf.. m",. '~~~$ mM~~. ff :II 7 ~ B ::t~~. _smA *;:II± ~.. ~. ffi~~m.

(6)

(7) ...••. ~ ~~~~~~ff~~~.o~~fflw~~ ~ ~M~~~~fflB~~~~*ZZ~I' ~m ~~m~~~ti~~®~ • • • • ~. ••. .ti.~. ••. ~.~z.'~'~. $~. .~I~.~~~A=.~¥E~o7~'~ ~'~m~*'~±'®~~.~~~o~~ .~*'m.~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ '~.mm~~~*M ~~~.o ~M.~ti~~~~~~ • • ~m.~~M~M~~~~~mfi~ffg.. ... ••. •••. •. ••• • •••. ~~~~~$~*~tt~~~~~*'m~~. ~~o.~~w.~*M~'®'~~~~. ~~ ~~M~~~tiffl®~~~~~~~®. ,~. m'~. ••. ~~A~.'~~.~~~. mE~Ro~~.ffi • • • '~~7~ ~M·.~3~.~~~fi~.~~o §~~·~*~~~mw~~~,~~ ~ • • ~'~M~o~00~~~~A0 ,~ '~ fj ~ JJti ~6 ~ ~ ~ tE ~ ~ ± fL ]!.~~~" B.~~~~I~' 1£ ~.I~~!lJ.~~~&.~~.~.. R~ ~. .~ ~~. JE.. !lJ. !l'. 8~. AE. ... .. ... '*. ~~~]!w • • zmg,~~¥~~z ti~, '.~.-~M .$.~~.. •• ~. ~. ~IJ. Z. ~.~P~. *~I&af1t£.Af.'. OOI~~. ~1'f:'. 31. S~MHm~=~~m~~.~~,~~.~ ~~tE~~~·~§ff~~~rr~~~~.$ ~ I ME 51' J1 ~ ~ ~ ~ fig -, 00 ~, ~,. 6 ••. ,. m. ~~~~.~~~~.~'Z~~g~. ~~.M.~. alllI:Ig""'1* ~iIt/~. ~~ a. ili • •. '.z~.. A~fJi..~~*!lfMm~1i. .~~~~~.~.±o&.~~~~.~. ~~~~~~~~~~tE~~m~.tE,~~ .m~5.A~.E.liI ~~I~I~ ~oAl.E~o.!lJ~~.~~~~~M~. ••. m. ~. ,. R ~. •. I-~.~ ~~~~~ ~~~.~ ~U. § ~ It ~A~. ,±~.. ~. ~~~*. I~. .f~~~. I. ~. . ~L~. m'~$' ,~~~~ • • ~~~,~~mI~~~. ~~ • • -~AOO\ffi~z ~ 00 J: jiJ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ti ~ § '~'~oo~.ti~~$~. .... ~fig~~,. ti.~~ifI~. 0. .~~A~.~~~~.tE. ./,~.. ~~00~.~~~J:"~. ~. .A~'I~'~~~w~. {}. rO~. 0. -I. ~-t"::'~'fIJR"A.·. ~. ~~~~~W~. .±.~~~~IUl~~til~.

(8)

(9) ~~. ~~ffi~~~~~. ~~. 00 ®. -. ~®~®~~~~. ~. *,. ~. ~. E~H.m.'m.~.fi~OO~.~Sfi~ wm •• ~.~_fi~~~~*.~mm~fi ~z7®'®~ff~~®L~~.Wo~~~. .~~m~m~m~*~~ffi~n~. ~ ~ ~ 1ftg 11 1ftg 7 ~ ~ 3'& ~ ® ~ ~ -~~~oo,m~~~@~®A. 0. ._ffm~11®tt.~, ' . ® w,mr~OOfi~~~ffi~~1'. ~ ~. '.~~.~m®®~~~a~ ~tt~ mm.~*.~~~. ~. -. ~mm. ®~~m~m~fio.. ~~.~~.L~ ~ffi~~~~'~. ,~. OOO~~~~. ~~~~~~~~~. ~ ~. m. ~. ~fiz. Z.~mA~a®®. ,.~. •••. l'. ~~~. ~~® ~-~ -~~. 0. ~~,~~~.~~~. -z, °tt~ **. S. -. (l). ~m~~.~®~wI. ~~~. -m.. •• A B®± ~ ~ •• ~ ~ ~ ';:; ® WII ~ ~ • I~ • W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ • ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 11 11 • ~ ®I.'. ~ff*M~'.W~~. I~Z. ~. • • ~~~®m.g* if m p). ~ , ~ *I m ~' m _ f-J 'I ~ :It • ~ ~. fi. ff It. A. ±. .m.~~-.~~'.~@±. ~.~ iF ~ ®. ~. I~.fi. ~.N W~.~~~.~S~.ft~~ ®~Dg®®~~.M,~zr~ftffi~~W ~~~m~1'~~'X~m*,m~.*.~ ~®®*lm~.~~®~~~~mozw~. ~m~W' ,g,~~~~,~m ~~~~ ~~.~ ~w~.~.m~w ®~I~. ••. ~'L~~~r~fi$~ JI1f{ -. ,. ~. JtU. ~. , ffd:. ~. ••. , ft z. ~. ~11aw~a~.®§~~~ • 00W11aW~fiW-A • • •. ~ JfJ U1I flP ~ Jtu • '*±~.~~~L~ ~~~®~~.~'11. fi 11 ®. 11.I~~A~®.~ oo~~.N~~~~fi JtU W 1J! 0 • ?1j ffd: fI ~ ~ ~.~~~~.W.. m~~*®~ ~~ ~m~'11~~~W~ ~*I~~~~w,m~. ••. ~~.M'~~~.*. . lJIL. .f-::.-t-..::. .'I'IJ. Jl-.. A. .. 0. I~. i'F. ~. •• f-JI. ~ .-~ tt1J~ ". .oo~ .~R ~ 1'F ffi .m~ ~~. I.~ ~~~. ~.~. 'z~~. ~ ~ ~g. ~~n. 7*. •. mrZ$. ~ 1'~~~ ~*~~. . '. -,. ff.'.. ~~m. ~ ~g ~ ~.~. ~fi1'~ .~~® A.~11. m. .~m~.

(10)

(11) ~~~..y~~€m~P.:l~. 0. mg:fii\~. lEt. 1 ~~ .. tllIIH'{II~~~. HiI~mtm*~,g:{(4I)c>~~~[l-<nR 1 ~f£I~~~~-& ... ...~~~~Iin~~.{DIII~iiii~mt~. ~HiI$~~fltl\!~~i*NIWIa. .~00n. 111:{ ~ \,Om:::). (. 0. 0. -a-.+<8f!!.<~:tK~. ~fltmH!l~~~-~\I;IJ!~HIE. ~i*~!IE~I1I:{($n<~~N~~. 0. J. ....T_ '::I. 0. 0. 0. *H~~~m:::~" ~~. __ 1::0. ,. an. 0. ~. '". .. Akabas,S.H., et.al.(1992),Disability Management: A Complete System to Reduce Costs, In crease Productivity, Meet Employee Ne eds, and Ensure Legal Compliance, N.Y.: AMACOM. Kohl,J.P. & Greenlaw,P.S.(1992),"The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990:Implications for Managers", Sloan Management Rev -< iew, Vo1.33., No.3.,pp.87-90. ~ Pati,G.C. & Bailey, E.K.(1995),"Empowering ~ People with Disabilities:Strategy and Hu- ~ man Resource Issues in Implementing The ~ ADA", Organizational Dynamics, Vo1.23., ~. ~. ~~~(111:{~) or~~~-h>~~!IE"~~U~~~. M. .j:tf~~~mt~~~IIIHP!!!~~${~~~&~ .. ~~.~~ i*$g~~m+l~!lH>< .~.lRll!!!IE~=$.~.1* .. ~~~~-h>~.j:tf~~\!Il~ .~~" ilt1><~ ( 111:{ ~) r ~$:iji~~.I\!~~<~ .. ~~~flt~~lRll!!!IE$.~~.~mg:o ~P.:l*~~J o-a-3~.$8f!!.~~"~~"~. ~~~~. ~~..y~Iil~. ~~~m... ~.~~~~~~~.~~.~~~~. \tH~" }§~~.fii\~flt~~~~*.~~.~~~... 0. .. *~~~~)c>~. ~~~~~flt~~-R~~ml(I~H;;l1III+H~~~ .. }§~~ .~lt!!;~(on~ .. :F-Irn:j.j:tf*!&li~l:I$.ml(~flt~~~~qj ~ .. ~~~~~~ml(i!i~"~~$:~ .. ~~~~~~~ lIffalEI" ~~1P(~~~~~~411~. ~-m..y~Iil~ml(~m..y~1i!il411. ~R~~~~~tt=~-a-m«~.$>-R~-<-R~~":F-I~. 0. ~~~~~+<8(II.<~:tK~~~~~~~). 0. ~~=$.!IE-<~.~~... ~~~~~~EI:1'~~I¢~ ~~~~'tA .. ~1*~=$.1i!il411" ~flt~~~~P.:l~ .. $r~1III~~~-Rml(~.~:ttl 1IIIH~-a-. (. ( 111:{ ~ ~m:::). .~.it: ~~t!i. n. ~-~~mt~~~~~~$~iji~o1><~+<8f!!. ~ 4tI\::t:::JzllJ;:: lID( .J.J411EJ-J.

(12)