公部門需建立更具激勵效果的績效管理制度

全文

(1); ~~¥j ~.~~.l¥J~~oo~~~'.~fi~ •• $rrJjt~foJR~1f.OO~MJ>l:IJJ~*. .~.~Mml¥J&~.~;:lN.'~7.'. ~~J (performance. (confidence defici t) l¥J~}aJr:p. ,. ' %)t~I~1t ~±:Ii*Jiff m.l¥Jft~M~ •• ,*m~fi~~~.= ffiHubIT+~1f:*. 1Ji)Eif'ro9Il~L~~{.'IfF (Kettl,1998). 0. Ii WI ~ ~ WH~ iJIj tE 199 31f: l¥J - ='X [!.1Ci¥. ~ .r:pmlli: rft~~.OO.¥~*l¥Jm.~. :! [. ~~~~7m:;$:xl¥J.~'.~~.~.~. B.l¥JMm*~m:;$:xm.~l¥J%~. •• •. •. ~~m.~~,~~.~ft~l¥J.~~~' ft1r'}i00~Hf~*l¥J1gf:f~~ (C 1 i n ton,. 1993: 1732). -'IlIlJIlSJ• • tEm~ff~OIm.ool¥J~~r:p'ffBI. 0. =rJi~~. , PJ. r~.~~~J. :lNit!. ~1'Fffll¥Jlre{~:lN~m~~~. Jiffit!:m. 0. R 0 b. ~l¥J~~,£~m*.~~~,~~~~~. bins(l998)Mf.~Wk~: ~m~§~fi. m~n@m,~ft.~.~~~~%a~M. lli~nl¥J.m'. ~l¥Jit!~,.~~a~l¥JBft,~.~~~. ~_O~m:M.m,n~&M~~o.~. 1:. ~&~0~~~n~~~'N~~~~~ft. ~-fjw~.i:J1 ~ll¥JpqtEMA)JL. ; ~~fjr:pft§!. 1. 1. (~~. .'M$m••• l¥JpqtE.~;£~oe.. 2.~11J. '±tirn~1!!:W) ~*fTi1&~jf (account. .~li.l¥J~*·~~A,~.~@.offi. (1) ~. ~l¥JMM'. 1!!. ~&M~l¥J~~o.~~. ~~m~.~~. abi Ii ty) l¥J1m*IJro9~. •••. 0. ~@·§WIl¥J.~.~Mm~~~~.. ~'fffoJ~~.~~~.&.l¥J~.~ml. ~ r.~J. ·. .~~ool¥J.M~~'R~.~.oo~l¥J.. ~~*·M~M.~.~l¥JMm~~~*l¥J. ='llllJllSJell.m. ~~~o~7~~~M.~.~Mm~~~. J, 00 11 1. . 1~IHJHt0gBr9l¥J~Il~.~ . :;$:X. M~.~l¥J~mlli¥'~fi.~l¥J.~.~. m~~.~pq§~.~.~~~~.~. 11m.. (2)\.

(2) (l)Mas1ow(l954). (3)Adams(l963) B"J-0SP:fl~ ~~~ ~ !3 ft;] m: A ~ ~ IMff tt ~ ]]IJ AB"Jm:A~1Mff tt~ffi ,tttrW: f~ -0 sP: 'fi '~IJ:f -0 sP: ffij 5~ 1:. ft;]~*~t&fl~. *. ~fi51ifl~:xft;]~>:l<:. : 1:fl~3i: :@: ft;] ~ * ~ ~ flt liH& (1i17~ {E >tlili. JE)ft;]~*;t±tr'3~~&!3. ~"fJl.B"J~*~~~~~'&. *ro'lm. (!3!t. 0. 7 •• ~.l§. rftJJj. 0. iTiF3I:}I , Rob §~M. ~*. ~1IJ?l. 1t ,~m:~1I]]IJ fI n:X Ff B"J ~ ]]IJ' J-.J,J:l¥Jm*. o~.. r:pftW flUI~ ~orn. ~OJm. 0. ERGJII~%~~'&jBlllfJ9!BJHii. BAD !OJ Ilfj 1'i jjfij fI. ~,. B"J§fmtHlf!I!~. ,~;g~BJHiiffij ~.flft;] §. ~9!Pffi~lJJpx~i¥pxI fF~~ OI. Ib{tit '. ~84). a. II fI*1t.~'l1li1Em1ttl -0~fi&~.r:pm9ft;]~~WJII'.~. (meri t system) ,5§ima~i ~ ft;]I~~~' • • • ~-1I~Wft;]fm ~o{Etlm~*·®fj%~&fi • • ® • • ~£:t.n-~~*IJ. .ft;]WJ!I~.~~ff~.'. -0~fi&Wlli. m~Y~fiTffi'f*m~~ft~ft;]WJII~':¥r ~Wflfj)~. ~~fift;]. '*, ffij. 2. iMl1Jjg~lI~ (l)Skinner (1971) ft;]!~5§ifl~·~;g ~ iT ~ ft;] f!t~:::t ~~ "iT ~ B"J ± ~ o~f3 : lE!~5§i , ~iI] , ~.lI. 0. (2)Vroom(I964) ft;]W1~fl~ A ZP/T ,l;J;m f* !f)nr~ fliT ~. ·ffij~~W. r fI~Ff'~fi5§~ft;]~~,m.§~ • • , ~i¥px~§fm' • • E px*~~~~~ **fi!i1Jft;]~.J o• • ~*.~~.r:pft;] f!I!':¥r*R.M.. Hodgetts~~~. .~E:mfiff~/j\m~~~,. 0. r~. JIIJ px~1~H\:~fiWf!I!ft;]~{J'*'Jfl Pet e r Drucker{EThe Effective Executive-~r:p ~~r.~J~rD.l¥Jpx*J. 0. ':¥r~&)~~. JII~Nii. (MBO). fl~' ~~AIiB"J£*~*. ?t ~jjfij*li: ~!i1J~Jt1:ft;] rjM ~ !I J • ±!I 7~ {E mi:l1'i rm ; ~-~A't1:~~B"J rpx ~ !lJ '±!1~!3~"!Jl.1'irm a (3) Mc C 1 e 11 and (I 962) ~*fl ~ . ~~A.lift;]~>:l<:?t~ : px§i,x~ * ' fin &~;VfD~* a ~.{t< px ~ 11 ]]IJ & ~ tiffi ~:f!OJ ft;] ~ 'Jrnrt. ' :::tPffi*~ a (4)A1derfer (1972) ft;]ERGJII~ · ~ Wf)~~*~~,&fl~1~lE~_ 11 ~*~~,& : ep1:f¥ ' ;~{~&px~. a. (4)Locke(l978). I*J {EB"J)tliliJE) ft;]~* (2) Her z be r g (I 959) ft;]~1JJ - f:l¥,fM! ~~. 0. ~. r.~WfIJ. ~~~. m~m.~.~mMm~~!OJ!OJ~ft;]~~§. (~n. ~'.fi • • ~.~fln.Ffft;].~·~~. ) ft;] ~ 1M ~ {It • !f)U~:t.n- Jt ~. ~WJII~.M~&.~~~.§fm·~fi~. *ft;]W1~5§ifl. IMff It -. 0. 0. ep~n -~~. 11m EH~ft;] rm lIJti. 0. ~pxJJJm:~El~B"JWJII~~. (Performance.

(3) II •. Measurement Study Team, 1997). Z '. PfrID!i~)&tgfl (performance. 0. M§. manage. me n t) *~Jli"t~-lf'tl[]foJ1=f)&¥A1Tm~m. 1. tiirrt!~ (e s tab 1ish in g s t an dards) : ~nID!n -5 EI tm ' liH~ftH1! EI tm*~Hr5~~ ; ID!ntm~£t:J El. me . itpxm~EltmfY;]tgfl~~. AI;]tE~1i~.~~W:EJ!. -H@§,ft~~~tg~fY;].~~~~ )~JEtJ. T[g~1T;jrgfY;]fM>1<:. :. (-)~~~fY;]rrft§~@§'fi. ~. )& tg:E1 OJ ~S 1t~t:st 1r ~ mJ3l;] ft)~ ~*IJ::t] ; ). ~IHf. @(EI. m1~5!.. ~ ~ &' ~ !74~fi~J3I;] ~ {}1If}[&:± ~ £t:J. ftEl~. mmeEl~ffi~i';o. lt1~~. 2.fIj• • ~(measuri ng perfor mance) : 1ffi1J~.~1iJ!ll{i'K~t')&ffl '. ~~if). *~>1<:: 1.1jf. ft1J~i. ; 2.Jt. ~!!f. [fi.. ~~tgfIOJU{!n ~:±ftMtJ3l;]8'Jf*lj. *-1':l*AI;]1iJ!l&\~JEtJ.1~W~1iHJ. ~~*. )jt;. Mt ; 3 .1iJ!l&\~Ji0J3fi 1=f)&. '. E13. Itt-~~~~Ji)±.~)&1atm (perfor. ~~~~. ~N~~J3I;]~~h'lH~W@§'. &\~~. fl:%f@. 'fiE13~)&tg£lo1 tJ.1=f. )&~*IJ1Tif~)f[;f~ 1J;fO~~. ,. · ~~j;~~~ff. tJ.&jil'Eijm~fY;]U~. T?1IJ=1I. !lfY;]If'F&,~~~~~tJJ;fEHDJ. E13~.. (=)~:st1r~m~~~~~I~fY;]tg. 0. ~~lIt. AI;]7!1'.)\J 3. ru:atl.~ma1-ff'@j.I~ (compar i ng performance to standards) : J1t mance indicators). 1J;. 0. ~~~fu'~~~.)&~)Jm (performance. ([g) ~tm--ffl§i¥AiTfY;]:st1r PX. mon ito r). ':± ~tE tt!/f~.~m:5)n\l. ~~tgfl~1=f'JI!!f. (steering). ~itPXm:~~J3I;]~~~No~1=f~lli. AI;] f'F ffl ' fi E13 SA U{! fY;] ~. )& ~ ;fO 1atm · ,tlli ~ii1fili fr~ J! no )JH~ tg :EI:%f fY;] I1'F!I>1<:;fO 11 Ael;]1ff§Hti:. ~)&~tm~rf3'el;]~~m. tfftJ.1l$1E '. E13m-~~iTft§&. '. ~lt1~W. ~*IJ. ' tgfl:%f:ttl. (correcting deviation from standards) : KITill.tB"J=1I~~~ ~~~~~$fY;]r~:EJ!~.J. '. 1T.t; -)&~ ~rr.. -JJi ~ttpx. •.. --- , ., fFJ. 0. 4.~IEfI~. ~~ 0. r. flu ':. ·lItm. ,~~)&tg~fY;]~W1=fM. ~:t~~1I~~~~fY;]~.o~.1. .fY;]~J. '.fu~-Hftm • • ~~tg~B"Jm~. ~fY;]:±!I~~tEm-1l$lEm~~~J:~. , ~.:%fn. ~:%f&. ~. 0. f'FJ:~. MtE°. ~~. E13~)&tg~fY;]~~OO~z'~~~. , ~:EJ!~~@*notJ.1l$1E ' W-*. 5(;j~m~ iI&.1J~. ='. - , .~~III!-.~m!Jfill. .~~lIm-.ieUftJlRmJR~. ~tg~B"J*.*.,~)&tg~~m~it. ~~rrft§~~:st1r~mJ3l;]ft~~~·. PXEltmB"J-.~~~~·-H@§'~~~. 0~tg~t;~rrft~~B"J~~,~lt~~~. ~~13T?11j1Z!l1l~*2V. nl~MlI~. rrft$M~~1i·n~A~~ftm.~£t:J.. .. ~93) :. ~~Jfn. 11 f!ifY;]~ iffi J: fY;] f , ~~.

(4) I •• ~W·~~~.~J:~¥R±~~~ ~~~ •• ffiHtt;~~·.~W~;ij!-~ I.~m~ ~1¥J;ij!,. &±~tt9. °R.~~~~I¥J~~nfi. • §.~mJ(~.~·0~W~~M~~~ 1§."fl:~ffi!:1=fW:E.!l!~~B'9~.~:j:§. ' ~i tfUliffO).. RflIJHH.~ ~J(~.~fo:j:§.* IMi&Jfffjffi~. tf~m· ;j<:l.fj. ffi&§~ffi0~W~~~~.M~~n~~ In~~§.;~~·m.~.~~~~.. H ; 2.Jf. I~[O]J~UW. ~~MH}. Im**BT~. ~Jff~~fIt~.~~.~JJltHtxM. 0. ~~~.~.~m~~~. o~ut·. ::>erfor. '. 0. ftx.R±~)ElB'9fJj[fllj. , R.. ,erfor. m~-.J(~w~~~*&.fi~~~' ~~-.~~R1=f~~~ffi!:m~-~,~~. •• ~.~·~~~RX~~~~~Iffi!: s'9flffiftf:. ~ffi!:. 0. II. ,~n~.. fW*1f.%l1i~'*IJllFf.J pqijj. ~.~ffim.·&~.J(~~·~~.~. fi~%r~m~~m*o.*~,~*~.n. o. •• mJ (one size for all) ~~.~:j:§. ' WHf rJ:~-.'~~$~J ,~~*tttt~ • ~lDIn\U~B'9.HfD~IDHiM~$r~ . JiIU~)~. M.~~.~~~~.Hn~r-. -'~M.~~II.~~~.~~lIm~. lOari ng rds) : Itt. .~.~ffi. •• J(~m.q~~.~.ft~ li{j!ItJ%rB'9~~~fDm* . flljJ(~W:E.!l!1NRX~. .~§. ormance. -~~W~~~~~Iffi!:;&~'.~W~. ~.~m~~RX~·~~. ~'~55tW. ~~RX~~)El*J1ffij~)JJj{rui~ -. •. 0. .~w~~m.~-w.~~~~~~. 0. :. '.~"IIRfi rS'WJ. (steering) mJ. OECD~~J(~:j:§~~: r~.~~~fj. r'JI~J. viation. MJ. ~J. 00 J: ~ •. (steering) :Sxfi~ r~. ·m~0~W~~~ffi~~.~~~~. ... • • *~.J(~.~~.~~~§.~. ~.~~.~.~,~~~~-.~~. fFm =.M~m. ft~~.m. , Jt~.;{x ;ij! 1§ fjg'ltt M' mill. JfE1H:lHfJ E.!l!%r:;f~. .... •• RX~OO~*'~~ •• ~~m.. m.§ •• ~~~~.~·~1lt.~~~. ~f§. (performance indicators). 0. -~9:~. ,utili. ~~·W~.~~~~m~~~.~.~.. oJ(~'f. ~~~~.~,~.m~~~~~~$'§. J:I¥J. fi~~~~~.~*.~H~,~&.m~. * ' ~.~m.~ffi!:fm~?1lj~~tJJ~ : 1. ~1I!5!•• I~ : fljffl!f!fl5::k:f;~* .'.fi~)"~~~ ••• M0.~. E'Wm. ~~.~~.RX~~§.'~~~~~.~. mff'~~0~"~~§~'~~~. J. ~{'F. 1.~~m.~~m~. '®~~~Jff~. ~~m~~Iffi!:ffiff~*~W~M~I~o. e EH~jiiIJ. ••. ~.~~'~~~Jff~J(~W~~~.~. '. f{~~Jf. ~HI¥J1ifK. iJ:~~~'~ffimm~1lt. •• m~~~~. ••• ~~~.~ft.~.1N~~ I~*o~ •• m.~~.~w~·.*~ .,~~. .l!n~~.~rg;Ell!. 0. §.. 2.13~~~.ffigmJ~111\ : -@~~~. ~W~~~.'~. •• ~%r ••. §.. .RX~~~o.*. JEffi)JJj{ E3 m-m.. ·.~m.~~ 0.

(5) •. II. 3. f1EitH~JHW~l!jUmmJi5"l!5.t~ : 1'I ~Rffl.~W~~.~~ • • lli%. frrfI';J~.~ . :illzfFl9Jt5fj7t~efI';Jf:&fJJ 4. ~¥fmtlPl~::2~~i.J : iC~B/;J~.Y:::Z W~~.~~ • • mM~a~.AfI';J. 1. ~fBnmJ.;l~!J~t'- (pre scr ipti ve performance indicators): I1tlHIji ~1'I~.fI';J~.DJM·Rfm~~ •• ftB/;JHji . WPJTB.rr~~.tmt)}lllW, ~~ . UPDJt~9;D.~fl';JW~ 2. ji~nff.9.~'8U~t'- (d esc rip t i ve performance indicators) :~tlif§. 0. 0. ~~~·U.l9mM~ft.~.frfI';J. tNfJJ . ~a*. f:&R~~~,IJf:~Ij~jIHJHt~*fI';J. .• ~.~~. ~.$§. 0. oE CD~ 19971fm lli f§~JJ.!t~. ~.·R~. y:::z. $.fl';Jm~*&.~. 0. relevant) : ~~JEI!!E8fm*tm (demand side) • IJ)\ ~IHx£ WfJIH¥t & f§ ~m flJ rJm 1* A (stakeholder s) fl';JW!6 . mlli)'iJTiiillM. 3.• m'l1ff.9.;l~lJ~t'- (pr oscr ipti ve performance ind. 1.iBl~fUt1I11n(policy. r",'M;. ~.E8mllimMr~I!!~MJffiB.. .§. m~1'Fffl·~~.~~tE~~~m.. fI~. ~~1lM~o. 2. 5.tm.tff.9i5"l!n (a na 1 ytic a 11 y soundness) : &:\~.rr~~JI'iHifI';Jf4. ffi~~.ft~~ftfI';J;Jl~.:n~. OOMftm~ffi~~~ffl~ 3.~~'nl(easy. interpret) : mfJt~. ~*Jt~R~~~~~)~~~tm;jf~5f4. 4. "EIT)~!I.n (measurable) : tEJit4f1';JJ{ m~.1&1:~1'I~*1:fl';JDJ • •11°. i&JffmMtEf:f$J' IfF' xft ' ~fMW A$~:ntm 5T:ft . IZSIJlt • i&Jff~X£$~ tmfI';J.~W~i&~~·.~W~~.~~W. ~~W~WA$:ntmffi~~~':illz~UW~ fI';J~'ti. (managerial flexibility). 1'F~~. .WBW_fifI';J.#oM*~·.~m~~ ~~.~fI';J • • I~·.E8m~fl';JB.rr·W ~~DJU_.m.fl';JR1'F:n~Wfil9·U& gff21%~)t5IbB/;J_iT~Y:::Z. f§~i;~l9=~ru!. :. . Ca ter (1991) Wf. J}J~:f. ·. ~~ff<. ~ru!fl';Jm~o. .Y:::ZWfIB/;J • • f§~ ~9i~ r$J ~ rY:::Z*J fI';J.ftf§~' r AJ W r~~J B/;J~ ftf§~ , t)J~.!OJ 1J#"*11 r A~ J ' r~. .'. .~. .~f§~l!!tNR~mMB/;J. !OJ '. m~. ~~~JfI';J~~11m~o. ~T. ~E8. ~m.. m~. 1* • • • ~.'~fi_fi§.'.~. ~JFFi1fj~iT~f21 ' (reliable) ~)jf~fI';J (unambiguous) · 1: ' 9!~~{i,l.twB/;J (c ompre hensive) &DJffl11 (usable) IZSIIIt, Fort uin(1998) ~~l9~JE ~~~.~f§~fI';J~\ .f~f!:f:l9 : 1 .IH§.~ffl ~ ffiJ* . • ~I!!JEi'iBA • ' fIij. ' ~tI ' DJU.rrUPl!!ffl 2 . •~f§.I!!DJmi:EI § .fI';J~~It. ~llt. 0. IffW. (eff. ijZ (e fI';J~. 0. 0. 3.. g~jIJ~M§~ifVlitl!!~~JE~§. ,. '.

(6) ·criptive. 4. ~JH')tt§~1Jj~1&~;'11. s) : J.ltIU~. '. t!!f,t~t~Jt5~. &8/;J$~~~Ifl1l\~!l~tffi~*IJ8/;J. 0. 5 . _~')tt§ twl¥J {:t!;1Jj tHOl£ffl ~ &:\@i IOJ ~. ~~~IUI ~ 1m J;)JMft«. JtpJT1-t~(j/;J~~&{&N;'11. criptive s) :. 1i¥Ij+iit~tw. J.It_m. 0. -. 1. • • J!iUlU75iEi : JJ!Ht'f¥iJJ:Jiiffm~1¥J ~h~M;J.It*,~@iMM.~.8/;J. 0. _%l:t§~&:\@i~. *. 325-326) :. 0. 6. _~')tt~~1l\@i~~:I~'tm:!l8/;Jt~tw>.~~. o. fm (key performance indicators ,KP I ) 00 :I: ~fl. ~ ~ ii IID 8/;J ~ fJt ~ fffi %I: fm 8/;J IJJUVJ § (l§ 89 :. P!liifi'l1:. ~tJI~. ;f§Nm1:I~~g~r~. . 1Jn~~li~ilSfi16 ;. fff:m.Y&BkJ. §.I¥J-.tt·~tJI~~.8/;J~~tt,~.. ~J.It'.%l:if~~~m~8/;J$'~~. ~*&B!.. ttWOJ~~tto.~~,tJI~~~JE_Y&t§. ~*-mr~. 1$1~l*Jj~~~±le/;]~1cifriJEM~*JttJI. , fffi~~5t J: r ' gJ5X~~IOJ.~i!)(• • ~')tf~Ff 2.~~I3t1BSJ75iEi : ~~;f§H8/;Jl£ffl~W I±\ :illz ft ~ JE~. ~')t gSfi16 (j/;J tJI ~. ftiIJfffi~jtj. .§tw,tJI.~.'.%l:t§tww,~m~Jt. ~§fm;J.It*,1Jjm.;f§H$fi~~. tf::- ~n 11: tJI.. ~~tt~.mtt;fffi-.~~8/;J.Y&t§tw,. 1~·~~*mRtJI~8/;J~g§tw~~rrm. ;criptive s) :. J.It_m. lli · R~~~§ twQ1cJ5XJ: rm~-·.8/;J.~')t. m. ;. 1~&~tJI~'mM~iim~. I¥J.%I:*. 0. *' o. 3.• ~jf8RBSJM. :. ,,~1Jj.:l:m~.%1:~~$.$~~8/;J~. ~f1.f4tR. A'~Mft(. l ' ~j:~1J[lOO:l:m)r~ ,. .fi••. j/;]t~~. flU!. ~JiJtffi1'. 0. ~~. ~IB~e/;]0ifZ't1~i>J. '. 1l\~JlJ;J~.8/;J. ~ttM:l:1C!P!.1,=e/;]~Jt~ji~f1. ·jim*.~@i~~Jt~~. o. 0. ~tf::-afi~a.~.~ftl*J~ • • ' .. J. *'. ~~!lBSJ IgUI. : iWf@] Ite/;] [ffi}~,!P!~. rY&tffiJ A~$J ' o .Y&HHJ. fT~%l:00.~Eg~1'f.J;J.1CJ:I¥JIJ5li:l. ~'.Y&~. 1~·~~~.%l:t§~J:'OJ~.~.ma. ='.J&fiB.lBSJ~1I. ~ OJ {i§iff!. 1ff'if~8/;JIZ!lE' en~);!f. (economy) ,~* (efficiency) , %l:tffi (effecti veness) ~0 f (e qui t y) ~~);!ff~t~ffi:;:!pr.~J5X*rEl' R9~lfE ' %I:*&IJ~t~~A~±'~8/;JN;{~ , ~')t l~OO.~ftiI1'f~}lJ5X § tw~ § 8/;J , 0ifZ &iJ. r s t ron gijJ;~fPiI±\-ii.~')tif fm)mf¥ ' J.ltWHPi§-a--tii±!lmom (Amer strong, 1994) : 1.IUfi~~WI3t1 : ~~~fl.~JHlt~£.EU~ momffi~a~ , ~ft*IjJEru~r~~~JiJfiE e/;]§tw 2. imaHi~P::]~ : *ljJE_~:Q:thhJE~ , §t3pJf!l~J5X8/;JI{'F--±lf~. ~. iguous) , (compre ). 0. ~J.It. '. :Y&t~tw(j/;J&\. '. ~. 4 .•. 1~~afim~M~ii.M~~'l£~.Y&. 1Jj JE ~ BA eplJ!ffl 0. ~J5XJJro. ~~JE~§. , ~Jt~')t{fffl~~il55Rif:Em~(j/;J~~. 0. m•• ~~.~~~~~afi~a8/;JJ5XY&o. 0. 1.~~~8/;J~g~iiA~~~~0ifZ8/;JM ~')t. 1¥J~~~-gft.'lJ!fim~~~.. ~o. =, ila.J&tfB.lBSJIUIU •. ~')t if fm. J;J. *9J8/;J 1. ~~Ame. 0. .~a~'.%I:§tw~fm~'.%l:OO NU~t '11 ~JH')t t§. .~t§fm,tJI~Mtt~ • • ~'0~.

(7) 0 : JEMB/;J@]Nl ' W. B/;J;f~ {.'1JH~J.5t~*~ 3.~.11~*i~~W McplID~o. 4.IE~*i~j§j~. 1'Fl'9a.B/;J~t. 7m:g,~)*A. ~T J;J~:I:. : El3tgfl=lfWg~~MHT. JmpITff!1~AB/;J. $m.~lID~'~fi~JE~-$m~. ~EB/;J r.~~J. ~jt~H.. ~. 0. 5. ~~W~II~ :. El3lID§~cp)~JElErtB/;J~. , {1~!1'fJtl:.~FIErt~J&B/;J :n~ , ~IJ~~~mitiB/;J1§~ , ~Jtij , fr iii [III ~ 53!}]R E! ft ~~ J& 53!}] l'9 Z 0 6. *i~~~ : ~~gljI~~gljI ttB/;J:nrtgljI J&Wrull~:n~. JE.~~. ~tN~Fe9JmB9. ~=lffiE13. 3.. E! !iHIj~tlJ. ~. ~tlli~~1~1t7MI1)~Fc'. 1I. rm*J ' ® iEJ1t7OJ ' g~TI:7~m~~I¥J1§. c. , ~~6='=~~it1~0f~fr~tJ].~B9 ~JH~~ml~~,* ' ~ma Trfi ' !&f~if (T1&~E:I:~~B/;Ji~)5t~ , 0f~lii::ff~ .~~~~.~'R~~~.~0~ ~~m~.~~B/;J~.. '. -&:?.J;J*~~H1f. &0mA~B/;J~Fs9R*1f:1J. '. }!~~~. .~~ fljlJ m* ~t 0m A ~ ~ ~~I!JI¥J~. 0. 7. *i~ftlir : jfJT~~gTB/;J:g,Jj;fDjfJT~~ ~E:1J~~. '. '. ' 1.§. 0. 0. ='=0 2 .1l*~1*fJ!~~~~~l!J~~. •. be r g (1959). fl~. iIi :. ,. : Rerz B/;J~I!J--1*fJ!f!! IzlY:. ~~A.B/;J£*~*:5tl'9]1.Pi*. -~!}]~~itiB/;J r~rg:~~J. ; ~-l'9Ail1l. ='lIn. :i:~WE!ft.JJl. fr*fl. 0 fr1'mB/;J~.~tgflfljIJmz~ ,. 1t~~~. ~mllm.~w~m~l!J~mZMB9. ~ r~JiM. :i:~Wj~frfflt~1'f~~. ~B/;J rm-&~~J. -'.M.~ftW~M~.j§j~ • •~~. 1'f~~. m.M~~.~tg~~mM.~ft~,. ~~~m.m~.~tg~~m1'f.~Mm:. .. ~~. '. , ~Z~.~~Wlt\fl~-E9;OlIDroL1B9. :. ~l!J'~~.lIDtt~.~~m,~~. lE~M*M~,.~tg~~~m.~. FMl.1t7 0mA~B/;J~l!J~~Eil1 ,if r*fi0~1T1&J ~)J]XB/;Jng1cp . 0~ A~B/;Jlt\fl.* ' ~t~JI)!B/;Jit,illiX ' ~t~ A ~B/;J~in1f*$ , m~t0~B9 ¥MT1'f~~*~'~1Il 0 ~mllm1~1 ~~ , ~~it1~0mA~B/;J~'iH95~OJl ~~£*B/;J.* . 1'§'lID~t~1t~E*B9 fJH\::fflt~ , ;fi;ffi-~ 0~F9~E~~~* B/;J{T1&~E:1J . ~1j&\~J[~~~ J;J~~1} f~A:1JB/;J)fxl!J~~TJ;J~I~ . :nt!EiJX. 1.1l*JH~g~Iii~B/;J~*~~pgg~lii~. ~~~~~-~r~*J~~~'®. it 1~ 1& 1M mJ itEi 11 *~ pg g~~. ~~ B/;J Fe9 Jm 0 ili~~,.~tg~~a.~~.'ili. M~-H~~~'~®'~$~~~ E!0'M1'f0~1&.~M0'~~. ~~~0mg*:n1~jl~fIJ)'Em. 0 pIT. ~'fr0~~Jm~.~~~~cp'M ~~7~.Iii~~~m'§M.~tg flfljIJmB/;Jg~gt:t'=:]~J;Jj~g~,I{~ (0~). J}]. 0. lJillJti:. l.ffi. •.

(8) :~H 1ft Fo' Jm aq. I El :!iitfIJ~1±1. 3. mtJBjU'tH~. 1ft ~. ~~: tfR~. B'g!3. '. ~iJl~x'§'pxAW~lIi&. :lilH~ tE. , ~~:g lID ~. • Wll ~ i&Jff1W Jill f1k] [g E ' 'El t~ ~~ (economy) '%($ (efficien cy) '%(fJE(effectiveness)~0ij2 (equi ty) ?'!lffii ' ~1B~tJ§~iI: 1:ak] )Jjt~IJJ;)'l?di~H~ , fl1~ ::f~5t EI3 J: tl:. 0f~lii::f~. rB'g$~~.~,tE~%(rn~~*~. Jlt&t!um~g~r'nA::*:!iit~mf1k]~.5&. t~JUI0:x. ~¥.0~AAB'g~.M·~~~~. ~Jillt§~. ~!Aj;)'*M~m ,a ~;2ISi.Ii!.. ~~~t§~}lHr~%(B'g~~. • • • • w.~B'gmm&m**nA::. il:1:.~~.B'g.~'~!A~tl:'i&. ~%(rn~o~~. L~E ~/liJ B'g5&. Jfff1k]ffl~B?'!l~m~M~. ~JillftrJ}jt. dii . m~rc,. fii70J ~}jt~&B'gm :::ft)].~aq. [riii '. 1'. )2§iiffil7L!~. : Herz -Hf'd1!~ 12sFf l~. ~~t~Jillak]HHm~~'ElmJt~. Jff~R~tH~>J<:.~f1k]1ifEi&PX* (getting. resul ts) • ~ffiipx~-l1~.5&~B'gi& Jffo 2. fim~BB.3fmll~ tE0~r'~5&t§~ak]JtfMJ:. 0. • J'. ?'!l ffii ~~fJ):l:. ffl ~ ~n ~ ~ ~m. m>J<:Z}j; , m~.~f1k]0~rt:t'Jm •. 0~i&JfitpPff~B'g. ~~~. J:ffiirB'g~~'Mffii~~%. , j;X&~>J<:%t!lUlg~r'!3 ~T rtJf1k]~5&. , ~7fJE~iJl. JJXAfD ~lIi&IM~~ntl @]ffltD ' ~ffiipx~-1I~~~~B'gi&Jffj;)'7~ , J! fJE~~~x,§,~~~!3~. *7t~iifi*. il:1:)I)Jill.lIDB'g~/liJ%(*. Nm~J. j;).*B'g~ lID1T~m~. •. ~-~)dil1. ~§Ji! El ~.JI. . ufljlJ }jt Z Fa' aq g~D lID rtJ J:aq {fljlj}jt , Y!J1n ~fljIJ}jtzr. uOJfJE't1 • tE ~~1tp · 0~ ~5~B'g/~,~. =' IIIlN. filRlIJ~.Irn.~IfDUfiUI.l. tE~~~rB'g~%(1W~i&lMmm~~M. f:EBkJfiHs ' ~r.MJ. fEl1t~t5 e~~~~. riJr. ' &:\. .B'gt!~. '. ~5[~~!A. 0. 3. ~!!fimim~.~e9!fIlJ~. m~~~t~J-'IHfjU}jt , ~ftffl~~ &&~J:f1k]~~W~%(~ftMft·~. J. ,tE~af1k]~~J:~~~riifi. ' I~5[~1T ~f~ ~ IElID ~ [ZS] ak]t!flJ'J1i ~ 'El t~ : fg[ng~T~~*~f. (WlJftD : JJO~ , m;. ~fIJ~~[ZS]B'gID[gt 0. 1. flf1§t~:t;:Mfillrt.9.~m~~i!il~.. .1fil*aiJil. ~),nA::~5&~~~xmA::~%(W. .!1~Ti&~r'B'g§m.fD ~~. !4"""''''''*~B'g~~t~>J<:. ,. · &'. ~~Bk]~/liJ (~~.~t~. ),. ~5[~A. Bk]~1J px*~flj~. ,. ~J!fJE~.~W~B'g.~). lID. iilHl10t1)aq. ~~~~~M~~B'g~J:tl:rB'g~~. ~}jtBHjH*~. , Mffii j;).~a1ifEi&px*f'F. tB'g*t1)~JI. ~~%(1W~B'g±~~B'go~M*~~. m~B'g.m~o~ffii'~~~w~-. HJ!ft&E:*aq 1fJEiI: 1:J!*. rtJB'g~%(~~~}jt'1ifJE~~~%(m. ~ [ZS] ~::f JE ~ ~x'§' iI: 1: 'L'Jill JI :xB'g. ~B'g~~&.%(~}jtB'gID[M'~~E13. ~5[~. ~OJJ~~~0. ¥Jl0~A~~~±M~B'g1i~*iI:. .R~.~.mM·[ZS]~ti~.~&. I. 1: .. ~x,§,R~,~m.~B'g~/liJ~~T. '1ifJEJJX. ~mB'gm>J<:j;).&x'§'. B'g ~tR fljlJ ftD :. frj ~ , ~ t&. '. ~ ~IJ ~::f. , f~!fo/}~f~f4~9cz~ ,.

(9) " ... 4. I {'F§i~t~-M~~;lgi±:~~~*(f;J. , c)l:~~1S~[HJ"JfttalE3l\OJ 7t ~ ~. ~~m5*. .'~~~~R~~~fiI~.~~. 5. I fFIDt:n~Mn)*OJ t)jiftDl~H1Jtti&~. ~~,~~~~~~,~~~.,~. ~9*~. ,. i±:5JI~~n.~¥:jJilz. Etg~IJ~~~~~~~. '. .~. ~. ::f1J!}l1T~. , ffij3Fc)l:~1T~. 0. 6. {tp~~~IDt:~t~~¥A1T I fF~IDt:~t~. I. JJl1T~EtgIf'2.i (warni ng) ~~m~l1J. m~, ~l~~c~' $~~. Perf. 0. {'FIDt:~t~.~$7t. 0. 7. r~~J ~~1tfiI!tm~Etg'OO~~. 0. j)ff • ;lgi±:1&.*eg~~~=,:. lUI. 0. 8. r~~J. orie. ~~*o. f~Mt. JlIU'41J~* ~ Ii ~ifiU It J)j(. 9.}lpx~~eg.l'i 5r,mEtg~~. !tIJ. '. ft~~~~~c)l:~. ited:. 0. 10. #EtitJ&8JHilEtg § ~fig~ Etg.~o. - , fiJt~II.MJ!a9m~Ml~F.ti.~95JDI -=¥~. ~fi. ' ft. $'~~~. tt~~.~~Etgr~~J.~Wtm~Mmw. m~·~~m. ••• Etg.~~~7'~~~. zrB'}ji;t1f;lgi±:~taJ~IDH~. Etg#Eti. ::f[OJ~~~,n~ • • ~*D~~~m~M. 1.M~Etg~~[lH~1~I{'F$Jt~~Ef3-~~. 2. ft{'~Etg~$r~*~&'$. ~*=+. M~~~IZSJ ~)jl~m5*i@}l$Jt~~. 3 .ll':fJllegffllZSJ *~£*J: ~~~~~. ,. ~iI)jl1H151jCmEtgft~$r~&'$}l. 1T5JlU~j\. ·. lZSJ~ft~$r~. HHt~Hk::f r@:~ tiiJE. r*. $m~$Jt~~ 0. 1. 2. fiJa9ti~@.. E. fJ%. .~Etg.~n. $'~~~AJII~~~i&.R~.R.~· IZSJft·.R.~Wtm~MWPX~%~ • • fi. 0. ID1ft~. 0. *' 7'C}lI~{t. ~m~m·m~~. 0. , ~MAEtg. iii;:'. 0. 0. =, •• r.M•••. mm*~~¥~*~,@~~~~. ~=':&:\~t~m~Bg!R¥.ffijJE. 1t1~~. 13. ~$r~Etg § ~IDt:JE~~::f~ 8jjli'{({C. .~fljIJM &:\~flHJf::f [OJ ~~gJW~flru:i *IDt:~t. 7:. , IDt:JE § tI. 12 .&' fi I iUllUilHill eg ;J'!L\. ~~ &It f.iX ~:G4~m~ § ~eg~Jt~~ , illzl~~Ij~ EtgffllZSJ ' lrc~#Jl~Etg § ~fD.~. r'Ji5&tmtlt~crJJ!~foI~. :.~.~ft.J. {'FMM::f~Etg~fl~. ~~1t1~~Jt~!l!r@:~.PX. J.L.Perry,D.Metsh f[JL.Paarlberg. (2006) ~A. I. 11.. j~!Ci¥ ~ Etg f~H~,\ if ~ rM~W:E'n~J. 0. ~ ~ [j ft. (Financial Management. Initiative). '19881f:Etg. (Next Steps. Ini tiati ve). ~. §:1M". 198 21f: ffUiJ. (Citizen. r.W'&~t.J. '199I1f:ft;J Charter); 1993. 3..

(10) ~. ±~IIJJ&*~. lftf;] ri&,rrt~.;;&fiX~5!~J (Government Performance and Results Act,GPRA) 0. ~lll~H'ittt t&M!. r {'FEJf,Jti9:~t~. ~~~~~. ~~$~~EJf,Jr~~~~~. m' 2004 : 2). Rft. :. 1. AlJililmB'9~M§!I : .fB:&fi~.. liliU (President Management Agenda, PMA). tllIlll £\~~ lli ~ f8b¥: * ~ ffil A::;f B"J gt , iii~:glllllmJflfll~ A::;ffl]vz~)'§~. fF1.?Jfr~BiiH9JJ. Mzti9:mM~'~M~~:ITMm~ffB"J. 0. {71 ' ~$~m0~ rti\!l~~. 2001. _~5lgf{t!JifJrjtt. 0. ;ft~EJf,Jm.f«. ~~fiJ'. ili8~i&~&¥ffi&~~~. 2.•~ttjlj)jf, : 8113:& E$ .t~U/l1 &\jJHtfi. ~~. M. ' Mz*~-1W1j).l-~~~~rt:r (resul ts oriented) , m:l:~~£liI(market-based) &. ~~ (ci tizen-centered) EJf,Ji&~ . enat1!:IT-1W1fJt;tu)HEl~~IHacti ve but lim ited)B"Ji&1ff PMA~~!me)(¥B"Jjfg~!!ti . jt. ~M~M~~~_I~'~lli~~~. ~§M~~~t&~EJf,J~~~lli~~·rn~.. 3. i!i1UaJ!jti~ : ~*1JD~§iQ:j~~~m~c. ~~lffEJf,J~~w~zM~~AnEJf,J~~·~. ~'~OO.1ifEM~~~~~~~~~. fff~~tll~~mB'gfiX~5l='F~. ~:j~.~t!jf~fI]~lli~:j~¥iE. 0. ~ftR~1im. ~~flli~t&*. 0. IE~e)(~~I. ~.ti9:JE§'". fiX. 0. \Jlli~&.px ~. ,. Mzf~~j!I"JJ. 'g § '~UIJ.~. {*. 0. iW; ='F ~ BJlJil fc. ,. fu~ztMfL.E$r~. -@I{'F!¥${-* EJf,J ~ ilW tiE n ' Il9 JJt PMA~frT i& Iff tI H:(f~~mJjmLI::~*EJf,J~rE3' , -r2f[!i : 1.IJiJiR~JIlB'9~1im (statutory clean up) : ~*.m:WT~f~~lllii~~5l~~IU'g 5!m {~~ . j).l-2003iF B"JRtll~ 19IJ ' ~1!J!:m~J5j (OMB) ~*i&frt:&E$ r~fi lli~ll.lii~lmEJf,J5!mJsllii. , Mzft~fT.m:~ § M='F~1'f;;&~B'g E$.r:kJ~{'F ' ~-:&rJH*al4~jt , U -¥t'if*_ ' An~:$:~§iftI {'FlH§~ k~I{'F. 0. 4. m8jjl.W.~ : ~mt'iEJf,J~f{t!J.1I3 :&fj~tllj).l-~e~~~t.B"J;;&~. 5.•§ •. .:r1~BIffi. 2.tRIUJI¥'ftllJ (fast-track author. 0. : iii{*~~Rf3j.vz~~. ~~'~~~~'Mziii~~~Mvz~ jf e'g fiX:$:. ,. ~ J.t f[l~.;;& §. fm 1: M! li lJi~E$. B"J ~t 1I1f !oJ ~ffl·m~An~m.~W.m:~~m. 0. 0. 0. ••-.. .fBtllIlll~ff~'§fm,~g~~~~~,. fffi tllIlll e'g 11: ~ , El fm fI] fm e'g ~ Ij. fO tft. ill\!. it y) : ~:IT$JEf¥ff~:&E$r~ flli iii ~:g Mz fi lli 5! m. pJT fiX B"J fM ~. ;;&.k~lIlllmll9.o~~,tllIlll~.m~$. .J&EJf,J~{~1:f. lii·Mz~~.~~~~ft~iii~~~. ~~~.km.fI]A~M~nOO~t&.'fffi. rt1ifEi&t'ltJ&'. fT!IIJ~F~~J!i:.~lii. fIl.fOAnB"J.¥£:$:1:~Ij~* El ~U-¥t'i. i'tJiJIi!II ~ft ~. ~:&~f1£mlJff. : 1982iFf1£mIJ Management. 3 .Ij!lB'9~~ttWtllJ em a nag e ria 1 flexibility and authority) : OMB ~~A.'m.~M.~~.~~~. .:IT)! ' , 1991iFtf;]. 0. 0. 1Ol'~B"J. · m~fI]. ~;;&.kB"J~n'~.&~lli*rn~U-¥t'i ~1ll4~*B"J~.~;;&t&¥W.~D~M,m. .fI]~;;&.kfu.Il9~~~M~W~fffimfiX. ~frT~I!J!WJ!~. ~ $~mpJTf1£!llJp M. ~.~~~'~li*&. t*lll4f1]~ -Tfti&mB"J.~. M~~&'fiX:$:.~fI]~~~mB"J~J.tt'i.~. rt:r~. (M.. (M~1m. ' 2004 : 3). 0.

(11) •• .ltt:9~. , PMAtJ. rfJR.mm~J I¥:JMS~. f.j~mH93!i~Ft:lUf!I¥:J~.mttW.mJ.i'ti ~};,lEHtEllmiID~ 5!1¥:J~~. ,. .. , tJl. ' 2. f.j. 3. fr~t.~~. r~);~J. 0. ~:1i~.m*-~l*JffiHi1Q~ (X'§') ~~. .. ~I)L\fmJj:~I¥:J~~m*tJ&1ifJ?~*~1oJ. $'~ • • • fi.e~.~~ft~I¥:J&~'. ~mfl~~,~m~:1i~.m~~.~I¥:J.. 4. fr~.HMI}q~t:5z~I¥:JOJ~g'ti~!?!I1Ir§fI ' &t f.j~~ • • (~~~~.~.~, • • ~.. , Efj~IJ2004$~ll::: I frt:5z¥~li*~Ji!~rp tti• • maJllml¥:J~~ , f9iJ~5~1C~-f-fc~m :1iilfi I ~IJ2004$ E~70%1¥:J~;F~~m.$~ ~lt~~~8~ , ~fi 72%1¥:J.~ E~1L~.~. tt~W.mWB~~)mllih~~.'. ~. ~~I¥:J~wm • • ~·~~~~.M~.~. ~.f5im.I¥:J~*.~·~~W~~§fll¥:J.. .mW.~~M8.~I¥:J~~·. m*IJ~. ~,. ~~~. ~ffifi_.* • • ~ • • ~'~.I¥:J. $. E*f92%1¥:J~~;F~.~;*lj}E±~Hf~J{~A:tB9. ~*.~·*~.MM.I¥:J~¥·.~~ffi. m~. $A$8~~~~jj~l¥:J~t.~~~. *IJ~. 0. ; frAn.)mtl¥:Jm~.:tm~ , fr2004. I ~65%~.~Ej£1L~,EJtti8~~.~~~. 1:. (Frar. 0. ~~~~~m~m&¥~.n~ffi*~ ~f.j~~~~~~.l¥:Jm~~.~,~m.. ~~7~~~~~m~~~~~MI¥:J' ~W~~~I¥:Jtf7~. II. $083. j,fI.j~~. , ;!ttf7~ttll :. ~~1JE. 1 . &it! NlUFc$~ W~*IJ I¥:J'§' 1'm*IJ~~ ,~SfZ fi~~§l~tt. 2. 5~gp,J. 0. r~!fiU If:lf-\;; r~~J. 3. :rJJ~Itt~ ~±full1'F. you. 0. :". You. get what. measure." lm5!~~.Iml¥:J.mJ.i11. 0. , ~~~~~m~~~.~m. a~I¥:J~~.:tmM~*~~B~~~I¥:J.~. 0. m~*m~fi~~$~§.,~t!~~~~. 4. ~m.~.5~fc~II¥:J~~. • .f5i~W. I@~~m~~.:tmM~I¥:J~~~~'. fflJl¥:J&l3.. Ef3~*. 1¥;~l~.~.fm~~I*J~~~~ (X'§'m~). ~~~&&~I¥:J*.'~~Im.~fi~B9. ~n'. tJ~.~~. q~E~~~~Z~oa~fr~m~:tmm~. mflj~. frl*J;Ph~7¥<g 7fiiJ**~Ji~. I-~~~~*.~*I¥:J~~~m.'*. 1800:9=. o. ~~~~.fm~~£*. ,. :1i. W~,EJ.w. tr'm fJift*. ~n'~~~~~(~~~~)I¥:JM. ,f~)L\I¥:J~f6*IJ~. ~~~ .fmj'f.~-1i]:g. m~Ml¥:Jr~m~~W~*$J. '~fr~~. xB~JJm~.~~.:tm*IJ~I¥:J~~. .. .~M~~~~fi~&¥~~~~~I1'F'. ~~~if:tm~.l¥:JiJl fI. ~~~OMBI¥:J~.~16-&~.~~t.frli~~. ~~~.:tm.~·~7~~mmM~.~.. ~.~* • • I¥:J~fi~~'~~~SfZ.~~. ~umZ*'~~~~.~M~~~.~~. -tHtJtlfL'E: tJ r n J . r ~ J . r ~ J m.~~;!t.~~.~r~~J. .. -. fi. r~*.. I *~~~~f~**. ~m.tf71¥:J-1IfiiffujltW~. (~.~~.,w. *31 '. ~~i*)~f'F:g). 0. @. •• n~~.~~~1. :x. (Ro. 1IAT&\.

(12)