由單性學校轉變為雙性學校對學生行為之影響

全文

(1)fiiJ 1r.ift rlt* ~ r ~ ~ ,GdlI!Ji.! liff~ J. HI1J 1 -33 J{. ~fiiJ80'1. B:I.t.£¥~_~_!ft.£¥~fi ¥~rr_z~_. **- JF 1t/.. 1~. ~. •. ~. ¥. *~~±~§~~~~~~~ft~'~~%~fl~~~~~~~~&~.~.Z. ~~~;&ffi~~%~_~~~ft~~,¥~Z~~~~&~~Z~.'~~~~.~. *.M~~ft~~'~~ff~z~.o*~~~*~~~mZ-m~~~~,-m~~ ~~,&-m~~ft~~~~77¥~~&78~~~~-,=~~~~o~~=~~77. ~~~~-~~~~~*~~~~~.=~~~~~~~~~*~~~.=~~~~o. *~~fim:. H~~ftN'~~'~N~Z~~~~&~~~~~~~o. ~~~ft~'~N'~N~Z~~~~~~~~~~~~Z~.o. ~ffi~~%~_.~~~ftN~'¥~Z~~~.&~~~~~~Z~.o. .'... ~~~~~'m~~%~_.~~~ftN~'¥~Zff~~~~o. § gfJil':ltm1\+1im~~~~~ , :!1J~ftN~¥N~ 52 m, %N~~a.~s%Z=+o~~~.~~:!1J~%N~~~,. ~~%~~~ 13. m'. ~~.~~.~A~~. ~~~gfJ·~~*B~.~~~~&N.'fi~.~A~~~~·~~~.~~~~' ~~~.~%~~~go~~¥~~~~~~~*.'~~~~~.N*~ft,~~~ ~~B~-~~' ~~~~~~~-~~. 0. ~1R~~~*_%~mM~. , ~1I'~1iJl1l1Offf.i. ~~~~~~ft~(**~~'~68)'~~~ft~'%NZ~~~~-~~~~~~ ~tt~~Mo. .~%N~,~±~~m~~~ffi~~'Tw,~~&~~,~.~.mo~~~. '~~~~~¥~.~.~.'~W ••~~'%~~¥~@TW~~'fi~&fi~~.

(2) 2. mm.·~~~ft-~.~.~o~~~~M~~~~~~'~~X5@&~~~~' ~~m.'~.~~B~~~,~~.~ft~,~~.~ft~,~.~m.~,~~m. (1961) ifH~~~ft~iiJ~~flJ~'Iff:P1f~.~~~ 'ilttit3iJl{ o ~1!i1ll r ~~lIM J 1985 1fifl!m-ffHiff~ • 1f~~~.~J.&iBUmIfb~~.ltf9lJ ' -ffl. ~jifi~:I:. 0. Coleman. ~ft~~~o~~~~~~~.~~mm·ftm~~-~.~~~~~~,.~~~~. '~~~*~~~~oftm~~~@S~~fi~.ilttit$~~~~~.~·&Wm~~ ~~~~OO~~@~~~'~~~~m~~fflg~~m~~~~Z.~~~(~~~· ~. 771f). 0. , ftU~t'f:.§ibL\MB ,ititJlJl@\ ,.~mt£~:J.joo~m~~~j!m m~ .~~ilttit~.~ ,ititJil(; 1{:;*=l!Omjifj~~/FiJmJil(;, 111Affl~"~JB:1f!~*J!m.l!O 5(f#ft~~. 0. m~&·~~~~~/FiJmJil(;·mW~$.~.~~~~~~.?~~ft~,.~~~.it .:P·~Z~.~.~o&Wit •• B.ilttit3iJl{~m.o~.~fia.ROO ~.~~g.R&~. •• ~~.~~ ••*~~,~~~~ft~~iiJ3i.~ft;/FiJ~.. IJ'.rAffilll~~WJ~¥~ji.1IJ!~mt£z~ift. Dale. ,~~. 0. ~-Ht:W-~fjffJI~OO. (1974) ~m~~ft~.It~~J!mHIH#f:fft-lltittit~mm '. ,~~tJi/tilft~. 0. ~'Iff:P1f.~ta:JWJil(;. m~~~~~o. ~1!i1ll~+~1f'I!i1ll~-8~~~.~~ft.~~~.~ft~ftmz~·~m~ft~. ~m.~m~~,. •• uz~~~iftfi~~~~'~~.R~(~~R.'ft •• )&. .~1*3t1~ ,~ft. ~IU.7t.Z1M' f!!\::I~$.z£*:J.j. 'tI'$'~nft L~.~~BY;~ ~.&fi.5~·. •• :P1fW:l,I)~ r£1JU~@ '~:lL~ _~~~Z~:l1: .E1DZ.~Z~ ~.m.ljij1Jlli~ .:p1fmflj~B. '. E1~+i\.1f. 1!i1llj7g~~~~ftt5 Wftmffl~~.~. ~*.~~~~,\J. *_.~E1~~1. ~~ ,.~~:J.jii. .~(~~~.~,.~~~~ftzm~&~ft.~)jifj~.~~I!i1ll$~~ft~ziiJfi. ~oM ••• ~:J.jOO:~ ••~~.~~ft~~~~itt*'~WJ •• ~ZA.~B,iltt. •• ~.~U~~li~:~~~ ••• ~~itt~.~,@~~m.~~Jil(;.~.~o. mlif~:J.jOO : (I)~~~~.~ , .~~~ft~.iiJliti.~~ ~.jil1J~~rl1l' ( 11-. Z~~¥~.~U.~.)ooo~.~.~~ft.~*~~·~~'~ft~U~ffl'I .(~a)~~~~~~.I.(~.)~.~.~.m~~A+~~~'~~~~~ .4-5111AmiiJ%Jil(;;~.~I.~~Z~~~iiJ~fl.a;w.~ft.~~~,. ~~~ft~,.~~~,.~mM&ilttitA~ •• ,~~~g.~'.~~$I~~~ ~~.~~.~,~~~~~~.~~~*~~~o~~~.~,~.,~~~~~~. .M~OO'.~~.~'~~.~'~.'~~M •• oo,m~~.~(#~mam, ~77. ). -,. ::tM~1. ~. 1960-1. ~~.~.~~1. zflJ '. :;tXJj~~. Johns Sha. .~~~iftA~l. 1Jljta:J '. iiJ.~~·. ~~~~'Jift 3i/FiJ/FiJ~~.X:. 0. ~~~ft~~~~,.~§~.~~~~~mm~~~'~~F'. ••• ~~ftz§ .'~~WJ.:p1fmfl%~X~B~~oamm~$~.z~ft§ •• ~.R~*z~ ~$.~~.~ , m:~. r •• IiI~'J\.z£*~ft '~B.1fJt{,\······~~ji ... fI. Fenner, sl. /til. 0. Lookl eed. #~~~m2lfi.

(3) ffi.~~~M~~~~~~~~~rrmz~. ptfts &lfl ~ {II tic. •. ~. •. 3. ~~Xf~~~1f~f!M~'.~.~~~~~.§:.m~~'U.~~~~.~~~'. , g}\~m. ~ •• *~z£~'U.~~~~f!lJz.~f!IJ~oJ~f!IJ~~~ztk1f§.'OO~.~. !~lit2t ~ ltt*l/)il!. ~~~~z£*~.,g}\~ •• ~~~~z~.m.~mo~~.tk1fff~~m~~.. ~1!!UIl.~. f4 ~ ®1tf?lI. ~.~.'.~1fZj$J~~~,~.lJij§:.mtk1f.m'~fi~~mU~§:.~m~o.e. ' == ft§. '. ~~'.Mit®ZfS. Z§:.litlJij~~:r;i!I!.Za!fi. !Jl~. .It&fJ~!\tiffj, Ll7tlit;ff~~.. , &.. ftiji§~:k. mA:",.~:1ii~if~z1J! 0. '. 1!tJmAz~lit~fi. ftij•• ~£ CHurlook. '. ft{~~z~. ) zif~' ~~~~~~.. ~~:P~~'.~~(~68).~f!:1ii.ffl,~~~:p~~m~z~~ff~~:H~~. ~IbM(~§:.ftl,. M:~~ts'@~~.®mM: •• ;~.~~~z •• '.ffl~~!\tiffj;S%~~.z.. ~r.u®fflmoEEM. ~lJij~.Z~~~;~%~~.Zm.~~,~m.~~~~;W~ ••~~~~~. ft !f.® ~~ ~IH. I!I1. ~g. tli·~M:®M*. ••• ~~~OO*tlfo~~tlnfiiJ.~m •• M,~m'U%~~~~'tk1f§.' ••. ~I>~ftij~. w:p~m~~~,-~~tk1f~~~z~/tiJo. !tilt~-€t. ,. ~~. z~~z~~,~~~~.~;~~~ltt*~m~~z~.~~~.*;W~~. g~+A~~lt~,~mm~~~.~.~j.~®7t~~lt'.U-€t~~lt°EE~. ; MJ~.. •• z.mif~m~j.,~ftij*if~~~. 'g}\j.t!Ji/tiJ-€t~o. ~~.~~:k-€t~~7t~®.~.~.j.,@. f:P~f!~tlnfiiJ lit. ~~m~7t~~~~~-~-€t~~~~~~~~&~6!~~~.~~~'.~~if~' ~*Jt~7t~®~~'~.~~:k-€t~~ltz~'~~~if~.~~~~~~~.o~. :~. *~~~g~®~it*m$~'*if~g}\~tkliliz.l!i*mm~~~~-€t~~,~~~. , ::1tmtk1f fiiJ. ~~ "~H~J~~iID~~~~~.. f!~ltt*f!)& ~:k-€t~ZRJfJ. 0. Jlt~3c.~f't. ZAl§~~,ltt. - ,. f.itit~iI~oJt. ~. i'9~ffJJ(tm-.. ::t'6\'~ jr~~Zif1C. 1960", 1970~ft'. .1ill~iitt"&~fM~EE' ~~&~~U~"'~lli'iJm.~:k7t. ~~n.qOOJijf ~. ~~~M:f!~tk1f~lt,~~~ft-€t~~~o~.~~,~~:pif~mM~m%~tk~. i[; ~ ZfSj$Jw:~~. Z~'~~~:k~ftij~,~.~~~,gftm.~§:,~~.~'~~§:'~iID®~~o. ;Y.I!i~fi!i ~ 'It. Johns Shallvorass. (1972). ~A.mClljfjL=m"'~®if~~*~!Jl' .~~-Jt. ~~il.IfFlJijtk. •• *~~A7t~~-€t~OO,~~.*~~~~~~,@~it~~~~~~MJ~~.o. , tklilifLI::~~. f?lI~'RJ~~~-€t~&7t~®tklili®~MJ~~~'~:k-€t~§:.®*~~~~~M~gM. 7t~"'~'R-€t~ft~~~~*~~7t~:k~;-€t~:k~~7t~ft~~mA~ ••. .tt-::1tmBlJf,J , :'. 'R. ~MJMJ.j.~~~o~~g}\~U-t!Ji~,@~;ffft~~Mo. Fenner, shaver ~. f!~tk1fz§. (1974) ~!Jl '. 1f8rS~;ffizf!IJ. /tiJ. ~~~~~tI. 3~~~ •• fJ~~iC-€t~ft§:.~. 0. ~~-€t~:k§:.iC7t~®:k~~~*®~jf~:;bt!Ji. Lookleed (1976)~~~~:k~~!f.~B ~m:j.[lJe~Ib~. 0. Riovdan. '. t&~~~~~Ib~. (1985) ~~~f:I: ~~flf ~~iC~ftJ '. ~.

(4) 4. ;M;JtjrM:~. • mJ::t ~m tJllJjif~ , ~~I:fiJ!Coleman (1961) fjifH~B'g;ff7* ' im~it 1950 if.f\'.; W~if. 'itt:!i: ~.~.~~~B'g~.~it&ft.~m,~;M;~~ ••• ~@~.~.aW~t:!i:B'g~fflo Bryk ( 1986) ~.Aif~~.' ~t:!i:~~ §~~~ , &~~~mJ: ' :ft3~itt:!i:~fif ,~;M;Jj~t:!i:jr~ •• ftfifo~t:!i:~~~~.B'g~~~itt:!i:~~·~jr~~~~~Mo ~~.~~'~~~.&"~J:'~t:!i:~~~itt:!i:~,@~ •• ~w~,%t:!i:~~.B'g 0. ~;t. Loodland (1984).~ ~jritt:!i:'*'~~t:!i:~W~H'l1ipJJ~. .~9M:.t:!i:(. jrit t:!i:B'g.~ 1 t:!i:~~Jr1ifli-=3. 9tt~t:!i:.. '. ~. :tritt:!i:. ~ tE~ ~., .~tE~. ~1ltZ;t.,. ~~o. ~~if~~.,itt:!i:~Jj~~~~Jj~~~£B'g • • ,;M;.~~~~'~~.fi(. :1!*if~~IIJU. Feather 1974. Jores et a1.,1972 ) ffij¥t:!i: ' ~;M;:1!:trt:!i:11fim~~~Wfj~1tlI1~WII. '$~;M;.if~ml:fi,jrt:!i:~.~~ •• ,~~ •• B'g~~.~,§~~~~~~~, ~IfPlN~ ,~~.~~.Ji., ffl~.B'g~rf'l'~~~( Jones~.A 1972 ). .*~:I:.~l'. 0. =... 0. , .~B'g:tf::r-~ ~B'g;ff7*o. ~itJ:~fj. ~~~jc1t~Zif1e. Dale (194 ) if~~.' itt:!i:B'g.~~1lf1i'U~ ':15!lili.~ ,ffij%t:!i:.*€l.A-fl~. 1§ , ~11fWII.B'g.~ Feather (1974) B'gif~,*,~~.' itt:!i:B'gmM~11f.Affl1&~' ~ ~tlC~~1HI ' ~~t:!i:~~~~fi<i1<:: Coleman (1961) Jj ~'*'~~~~ , if~~.itt:!i: 0. 0. 1.1If$~~ 211f$~J. 3.1If$lkl. B'g~~,~W~if.~n~~~m.,@~;M;.A~~~m~@~o. ="IiI"'-11illzif1e ~~~~.~~~~itt:!i:,%t:!i:B'gif~~~~,.~.am(~65) Jj.W~,*,. - ... ~Iit~. ~-~:tr~~~~,Jj~~rr~m~Wfj~.,~~~jritm~rr~m~B'g~.,~*~. H.~tm. .'-if.~itm~@~-~rr~m~B'g~~,~;M;~~.~.B'g~~~~~oitm~~. *if~Zj. ~~~.~~~X'.~'~X=~Z~.,~;M;Jj~~B'g~x'~X~.&jr~B'g.. t:!i:B'gf\'.;.;A. ~~ • • ~~.o@~~~m~~~m~~Ii'U~*oif~~.,~:tritm~@~~-~. fit-.tjB':t1t~. ~m~~B'g.~'~X~.,&:tr~B'g~X~.,@m~~~~B'g~X&jr~B'g~x~. 78.if..B'g .if.IlB'g=if. ~9tt.~ •. ••• ~~o¥.~~.A(~~)~.~'*'~~ • • ~~jritm,;M;~~~~Jj~~~ • ~.,&~m~,jr~.~B'g~tt~.~o~~~~.~.J:~~B'gttgno ~~J:~~~B'gif~~*'if~~~~~~~:1!~~ffl~~B'g~tlC.*:ft3:1!.~@ B'g~~,.~~~~jritt:!i:B'gA~.~J!~:tr~t:!i:B'gBt:!i:.~~~tlC'ill~.~~7~ ~jrit,~t:!i:~- •• J:~~;t.,~~B'g~fi,.~,.~~:ft3~~:1!~.~*B'g.~. .~,~~~~~rr • •if~'OO~~~.B'g~.~,;M;.*:1!¥M:.t:!i:B'g.~,.~ ~~~~~M:.t:!i:,ffij~ •• ~~M:.t:!i:B'g~~'~~.~J:~B'g~.,ffij~~~.~ jritt:!i:~-.~~.~B'g~.o ~ji::ftm-fflllJ,*,. (. ~~) }l~-ffl~,*,. (jrt:!i:) ~ 78. ~if..iI!\:ft3~¥M:~t:!i:..

(5) ffi~~~~Q~~~~~~~~~IT~Z~.. 5. !IiIi trtJ JlJ 1m ' lID.:E 51JJ!. ••~f1:~~(~:trfS-~)·~~*fjJf~m~&ft~~~~~.*·~~~&.*m~. if:.ttN~if:.. 'fS-~. :trfS-~tf9~~.~i'<~*o~1nn~if:.R~~~~,m~~1t?J:il!:~:tr5t~~'fiJ:.~. iUIlJi ~~ 5t ~ trtJ JlJ JfI ~JJ!J: ' 1t?Ji'<fS-~~~. ~~~.m-*~.,&m.-if:.Z~~.ft'~1n~~if:.R~~~·m~~B~1W.. iI.:tr~~~~tt""o ~~. ,5t ~if (;IF Ii trtJ. 0. ~ft.~~·.J:.=~.~~~.-*o~ftZfjJf~.~~ffiRJ~$~~\:tr~'&~ :trfS-~~~f£~tli~.J:trtJ~~'!fJ;RJ~ •• iiiZ~i'<'~$ffi~ft~~_ •• ~ft. ~~'.~f£~:15iiitf9~~o. fftftZ~·~~~.~tt.~·~tt.~fi~~trtJfi.:il!:~.~~~~tf9~.·!fJ;. , !fJ;i'<ftfj (. :il!:*fjJf~.~$tf9·ffi1n.~I3~I3Btf9fi~~.:il!:.Wtttf9·fflj~~~~R.~tf9.. :~i'<~~~1W~1fIll*,. .m*~ •• ~fi~·~~~.fttf9o~ft*fi~!fJ;.~$J:.~~~~·fi.~~ ••. ti'<;&~. 13 EBtlilb~rf.l'~~ '\. • ~~tf9;ff-=f •. 1972 ). ~tf9~~o. 0. .m~~~~.OfJ1iPJf~/i1Itf9~}l~. • ~~~:il!:~~~~.~tf9~mJHm1i~. ~fS-J:.m~·*fjJf~ZfjJf~~tf9.:. i5t~.~A -f!li'<.. l.~$~e't':tr~.&~:trfS-~~~tE~tlim~.&~IIJ:~~1i~~o. 1fji'<ilJ:APJf~~,~. 2~$!J5:tr5t~.~_.~~:trfS-~.,.~tE~tlim~'&~IIJ:~~1i~~o. Jt~ • fjJf~~.mfS-~. 1~$~~.~,:tr5t~_ •• ~:trfS-~.·.~fi.~~1i~~Z~~o. .if .. iJf~1i5~. 65 ) tt .!Ill! ifjj r:p f3 tiltrtJ~ •• jt~ ~ ~. EJ!1f~. 0. -'~i(. H¥~mH7J. fS-HfRJ~. *fjJf~Z~~if~ttf:i'~tm'. B1i.!Ir:p77 ¥if:.R& 78. ~if:.Rtf9-. '\ =if::m.~.~. ~ :5c ilt • .& :tr ~ trtJ It. ~tf9tt.;AIi.!lr:pn~if::R&78~if:.Rtf9-\=if:.~.~.:tr~tf9tt.o~~~~~. r fS-Hf fl"1!JJ 1n iWi -. ~~~,m~~ft~~f£-~.#J:~1i~~~.·iI.~~.~tf9CIi.!lr:pn.if:.R'. ff. ~ :5c.& :tr ~ tf9 ~ :5c ilt. ~~if:.Rtf9-,-. ~ JJHN ~ RJtt f)Ul~. ~if::Rtf9=if:.m.~.~-m~~if·ffiftm~.ifZ.ftmRJ~$·ffi~tt.~_.. FtrtJt:EB 1J i'<-*1t?J:il!:8ilTiii. .~tt.~.'.~f£~tlim~&fi.~JJ!J:Z_~o~~tf91i~~.ifA.~.IPJf. 0. 'iI@~~fft7f£. ZRo. m.~.~:trfS-~tf9~*o~r:p~~77.if::Rtf9-if::m.if::~~. .1. :il!:~.M*tf9m~ ~~tf9~~'~1N. ••. ffljJ!1m~lJi!!J5. il1t?JEB~f1:~~M. Ali.!lr:p(:tr~). BIlIr:p(~~). CIi.!lr:p(~:trfS-~). ~~.~A.*1f~.. 77 .if:.R 78.if::R -if::~ =if::m -if:.m _if::~ 204 221 91 116 215 278 148 223 255 258 159 236.

(6) 6. ~~~~~~~M~~-~~~~~'~~~~77~~~fflM~-~~~m~~. 1::~'±. ' ~/1J1~J: 77 ~~l!tf1'g-~~f!1:: ' ~{J~ 78 f!~l!t~-=~£i~~ , {§fl,j*if'9i:!. ~~~mD~~,fl,j~~$ffi~~~_m,_*,~~$ffi~~~-~~*~~~'*. ••U•• fl~.m~·U •••• ~.~~fl.~~.~MBo~~ •• '8~n* .~-.~.~~78 • • ~=.~~~~~-~~~ZA.~~2fflffi:. = .. er~iIB1'. H~IIJ~~I *if'9'e~.~. •• 1t~-=lJ!;WJ~ ~ •• ~~f.f~~ (:j~1l~00i~. 1l:. ~. 78. .79lJ.1t~. ~. ~. 173. ~_~%~l&reJt. ~1l:~~. 235. lm ... * if'9'e:li! tI.~. (:jti€frlj$(£. ~~, I!~.~~. *if'9'eZ~€frlj.;<fqjl\:Ii!J:~~~ '1l:~& ~1l:~~~~€frlj, 1ii8~I\i!.iiU€1' 100 ~€frlj_~rJ.j~. =... 0. ••. r.1f it :n5~. 8~Z"~1[~~*It~: 1l:~ 32. A,. ~~64'A. '. ~1l:if~. UL. 99. if~IA. - , ~~lJ~. ,7. H~IIl~~f.f~I3~$ffi. *if'9'emm1jj. *if'9'e]";~Jfl$ffiIEJf-OOi~JI$mll.' tU111J.~~~~t.5:ii.&m~. 0. ~lQ.lJ.1!!~. • ; (4).f:lgn~~. 1[~~8~lQ.lJ.'I3~~~~'~~~'I3~~~~'~~~:ii.,mD~:ii.,~€frlj. (8mJHE~m~. ~:ii.'.~~:ii.,~1[~~8~m~~~:.¥~~m~,~*~m.,tt~~m. ~"f1'g.. .,~n~m.,~~~m.,.~~m~,~~(~~)~m~,~~~m~,~~. ~:Ii!~1[.4~~. ~m. ,*~~t.5~m. 'A~~m~ '1f~II'~ilat. '*Ml.ZreI1t~ 0.34-0.84. rl'!' • ~.HlI~1ttJ)\~ 0.29 ~ 0.46 rl'!'o ~W.~lli*'~I3-MAm$~~~:ii.m~;WIii~~II':ii.,mDII':ii.,~€frlj. 'IUIii~~~:ii.m~. , UlQ.lJ:I:¥~:Jl!~1[~J!lm.WiJH.(. ,~. 31. ;. (2)mDII'~. *if'9'eZ~l. ,lJ.1.Jr1 ( 771f. ~.$8~i. t.5m~~ 12Mi'!:. 0. (:j1[IIl~€frlj~.It.~. ~~j. f1'g.3I1[rJ.j~~;. ~~I3~~~~'II'~~'I3~~~~ifm-~~.~'U~~¥~:Ii!~~.4~ ~:ii.& ¥~~:ii •• ~:fI:~if~-~~.~. 0. $(£. .~.7Mi'!~;. ~$ffi~~:Jl!~.~.~.(~n)m •• ~~~.~W.o~~.~1[A~o~. ~i1*,HJU:. ••• JI~m,~~f1'g¥~81t~m,~~.~~.mB~¥~ .~~m,~~.~ •• ~m'¥~¥~ •• ~m,mD~.~m,¥~~tt~~~oo. HII'~~~' ~. 8~~€frlj~~~¥~at. &¥~.~~~~m'~~.*.~~~_.~~~~~.·¥~~J:~8~m~~. jfj;:i1t. o. 8lJ~' ~Iii=~~ '.D&¥~711J.

(7) m~~~~.~~~~~~fl~~rr~Z*W. mJN-~BrroiU~~. HJ~ • m/!Sl*Uf~ ~~£*fU41lij:. :*. ;;f.Jt~. • ~t3C 77tl. ,ffli.R :. ="if1i!~~ H;ff 1l.!Ji! ~ 13 ifliglH71 *fi~~~n.!Ji!~l1t..=.!Ji!a~M~~·~m~ •• ~ •• w~~ ~~l1t.~=.!Ji!a~~·~M~~'ffl~m~ •• ~ •• w~~ Jf1~. ~. 7. ,. ~~ff~~,H1T. ••,.·~~~. ••• ·~=~~~~~. 0. {:1;ff III ~Uffi ifli:It ~iIH71 ~79.!Ji!~l1t..-.!Ji!a:w. • *lifli:ltrJj~ 100 171~ffl~~ • :pjEH~~"~ffl~~ti:W •. ~~~~~~~~,:pj~~fflfi~~o. lm .. StIt:n5i *fi~~~sPss/pc~~~~e~~~ff~~~~'~ffl~~~~~~;ff~.. ~1!iI.~ffllOO PI. A.. •. ~~,.~.~~&~.~.~.~~~o. 9J:kitt3C 99. ,., if~itl: -'If'~.!Ji!~'If'~~B'If'~.!Ji!~l1t..!Ji!~tE~~ma&~tE:lt~~tE:lt~~z~~. H~ 0 JltOO"~ ~. BIf' ~II! ' :43 (fJj. E. Jm~. , 11:t§rrom ~11:rrom~ , fiCi!1 'l1t. tE 0.34-0.84 ~ft1!i:(!f.tf:.A. i 1f':i1j II! ' ~ (fJj fSJ.ffijlS.,~. fjJt tf iLl/j. i.m~. 0. II. 'tlm. ,~11: 3Cf£JjWi ~JjWitmafl:.. : (1)~f~~~ma ; (2)~f*l*~ma ; (3)JtM:t§~m a;~~.~~ma;ffi~~.~ma;Mfi •• ~ma;mfi3C~(~ft)~m.; (8)tl~M:~m.; (9)~f~~~m. ; QO)fi¥~~~~m.; MfiA~~ma ; (I2)*t~1f' *ff~m{Qg:ltz~~ma~~. 7ifiIi~~.. 0. f7gtE:lt~~~: (I)€l.ft~ft]~; (2)1f'~~ ; (3)€l.ft~~~~. ~~~ tf Ilttf:. :P!i tJ.2 ffij II/F tf:l. *· €l a -'- ffl1. j,jJij €l ti 1i~ 1lJ( (n]. 0. 0. ~~OO1l*. ff. tE 11 ~ ~ ~ :. (1). *. ~~. ~.;oom~If'~.;~:43WIf'~.;W*~If'~ •• o~~~OO:lt¥~.B~~13 ~~~;ff~~~tE·@~~;ffm.,~.~~~o. *ff~z~.~tf*~~(:k~'~~'9J:kit~)'~B~(-~~,_~m). ( n~ •• '\ 78~.OO) ••• ~~.~fi~.~z~e~.'~~~/!SI~~.~.~.~~~o§~*l~ ~ma~121m.~ma.-~ff' ~ff:=.tl§~~.~.~.~~tE ; :pjJmF"JtE:JI~, ff.tE '\.!Ji!~.ijJj. 0. :It~.7M.~~.-~e'~ff=~~~.~.~.~~o. :;!t N:i ~~ .ijU~ l' : HIf'~~~,~~&¥~l1t.¥~tE~~~a~Z~~. ~¥~,. m&¥~l1t.~·tE~~~ma.~~z~~.~~~~~~3mi.Ro. ~EH-~~~I!~.~.~~· :;!t wilks. A. 0.975. (p =. .33). 0. ~i.RIf'~~}J1j. ,~m&.~~z.~tE~.m.~M~.~~o~._~~~~~.~.~~N:i.~.

(8) • ~ ~I. IlW. fIi •. ~. ~. HlJ. a BlJ. M. ~ ¥~mtif. M. SD. M. _*fi:ltif SD ttt§fi:ltif M. SD. M. SD. M. tfI1Jfi:ltif SD ?f.~fi:ltif. • • fi:ltif M. SD. SD. M. SD. M. SD. M. SD. M. SD. M. fi:l. SD. 3C~(~tt). 14ttfi:ltif ItJliifi:ltif ~:f!tm. A~mtif ~li\t.Z.. ~3. !ij. '" ~. ~. !ij. It 11: it. ~. 78.. ~. ~. !ij. Ii: ~. !ij. • 11:. ~. Ii Ii Ii. ~. ..... -. ~. an:. 2.81 1.88 1.86 1.48 1.70 1.22 0.60 0.56 0.53 ---- 0.68 0.41 0:56"" 0.84 1.10 0.34 0.54 0.74 0.96 0.69 0.88 0.34 0.51 0.03 0.18. (N=58 ). =~a. 11: it. (N=92J. -. 2.72 2.28 2.10 1.88 1.48 1.54 0.58 0.69 0.44 0.60 0.47 0.71 0.95 1.14 0.35 0.63 0.88 1.19 0.79 1.28 0.30 0.50 0.10 0.40. 128. *. o.tJ WriUUf _ !III. 11. -*. ~ :iI ........ 0. ~l'li1I~. o. II. '0. -{f.a. =~a. ~~~~,~a&.~~'~~~~~~m • • ~~Z~~.'.M~. ~. 77.. 11:. tt. I. -~a. (N",-78). (~63). ( N=97). _~a. _~a ( N=39). (N=126 ). ~ ~. ~ ~. W. 000. ..~ .• .'. ..~ ._, .. I:..;). 00 00 00 00 00 00. *. ~ ~ ~ ~ '/lI. -~a. -~a. m• ~~. 1.11 1.47 0.30 0.52 0.20 0.65. 2.50 2.20 2.06 2.08 1.68 1.63 0.69 0.68 0.46 0.64 0.46 0.59 1.03 1.09 0.50 0.78 0.82 0.87. (~166). =~a. *W. 2.03 1. 76 1.23 1.12 1.28 1.28 0.39 0.58 0.17 0.38 0.29 0.58 0.55 0.76 0.21 0.52 0.53 0.63 0.42 0.57 0.12 0.33 0.02 0.22. (~lOS). •. iJ. """ ~l .E.l IlW. ;if ~. \. 2.53 2.01 2.14 1.77 1.63 1.56 0.57 0.67 0.39 0.65 o 49 0.67 0.89 1.07 0.42 0.71 0.72 0.85 1.05 1.31 0.25 0.44 0.11 0.35. (N~182). -~a. (~88). =~i!k. ( N=80). ;E!]. .::I. .. ~. 2.82 2.22 2.41 1.92 1.66 1.64 0.76 0.66 0.69 0.73 0.41 0.54 1.00 1.07 0.41 0.75 0.87 1.10 0.76 1.06 0.33 0.47 0.10 0.30 4.27 2.65 2.91 2.34 1.84 1. 71 0.69 0.68 0.38 0.63 0.34 0.56 1. II 1.17 0.37 0.70 0.96 1.20 0.96 1.27 0.38 0.59 0.11 0.54. 1\. o C. ~. '/lIl2!: .::I ~ ~;E!]. •. 4.50 2.56 3.41 2.42 2.08 1.68 0.86 0.74 0.62 0.75 0.56 0.74 1.24 1.35 0.55 0.84 1.17 1. 40 1.18 1.43 0.32 0.55 0.14 0.60 -. ~ l'lllB **W. .::I. 4.18 2.47 3.27 2.22 2.06 1.63 0.70 0.64 0.37 0.60 0.59 0.76 1.03 1.13 0.52 0.76 1.06 1.09 1.08 1.26 0.31 0.52 0.11 0.42. ~. 4.04 2.60 2.88 2.22 2.19 1. 73 0.65 0.70 0.40 0.63 0.54 0.77 1.10 1.29 0.41 0.72 0.84 1.17 1.11 1.45 0.29 0.50 0.09 0.45. -~a. ........ 4.08 2.22 3.37 2.05 2.23 1.66 0.83 0.69 0.64 0.67 0.52 0.67 1.45 1.33 0.38 0.63 1.18 1.03. ~. 1.44 1.58 0.43 0.56 0.06 0.29- . 4.37 2.53 3.17 2.18 2.10 1.53 0.90 0.73 0.63 0.71 0.62 0.76 1.33 1.27 0.42 0.79 1.12 1.16 1.21 1.49 0.28 0.50 0.18 0.59. ~. ~ HOOOOOOOO~OOOOOO 00 00100. ;E!]. ~ttr~Jf~""'~~tt. .::I>-'/lIl)iif)!!IB)(j.~~ ~. .. co. JJilI. ~. ;m. t;.. iW. i:Ili. :'!!.

(9) m~~~~Q~~~~~~~~~rr~z~.. -. .... -. ~*iI.lf*~. .... p. :Il oc M OC :c OC M .." <:> <:> <:> <:> <:> <:>. ::I. g. '"" :>. <:>. -. ~. 'l. 'I'. ~. ..". ;, <:>. -. ~ <:> <:>. OC ~ <:> -. <:>. . <:>. ). -. ~. .~ ~. ~ l. _. <:>. ,,. .... -. <:>. ~. ,. ~. Q <:>. ~. <:>. :;. <:>. <:>. <:>. ..". ~. <:> ..". <:>. <:> <:>. ~. to. - ... -.... CII ..". -. Q Q <:> <:>. .... ~. M. ~J¥i.1Jiz.~JH:t:mM*W1~. 0. ~4. ..". ..". <:>. ..... M. ..". <:>. <:> <:>. <:>. , to,. ..... .... to. M. ~. ..... .... ..". M. ~. <:>. <:>. <:>. <:>. <:>. C/l. .... CII. ~. a! 3.65. ..... <:>. ~. ..". ... M. 18. ~. CII. ~. Q <:> <:>. <:>. . .Q. <:> OC ~ ~ .." ..... .. <:>. l~. Q. .. (I). !HI ~. -<. '--. CII ..". <:> <:>. .. •. ~. Q. 4 ffl7.R. M. -if:~. M. = 0.979 (. =if:~. SD. M. SD. FM. i~(fiijM:) 1.10 1.25 1.02 1.15 1.50. 1m*~. 2.76 2.22 2.64 2.13 0.82 ~tt~~ 0.45 0.76 0.38 0.07 2.43 tt~~. 1.93 1.66 1.84 1.59 0.38 j(j(~. 0.94 1.18 0.92 1.06 0.24. 0.72 0.66 0.66 1.14 ~~~. 1.09 1.42 0.94 1.24 4.71* 7I-~~. 0.49 0. 681°.43 0.64 0.38 A4.~~ 0.29 0.51 0.32 0.53 0.78 0.53 ~. 73lQ.43 Lg___64 I 5-=--17* ,ifM5;1:Z$ 0.13 0.51 0.08 0.38 5.02* .m~. ,- ~jJ~~o.71. -. * ~7.RiI .05. *~. 0. m~4~~·-if:~~4.ft=if:~~4.~~~~.mnOO~~~,~~nOO~~~ ·1fM5;1:~$m?J}\~~o. Iffiij~~:iitE~1Jim.r~leJ:zl!~.5t:mM*?J}\illf{lf· ;U;wilksA = 0.94 ( p. <. .01). Iffiij~~:iitE~~ • • 1JiJ:Z5t:m*5*W1~ 5. Iffiij~~:iitE~~.I!~z~~.'.~~~FM~ :tc~{l). ~. ~. ~ ~. tt. *. ~. ~. ~. jJ. ~. ?t. ~. ~. It. ~. 1m. •. .'. M. I. SD. ~~(2) !. M. SD. ~:tcf!t~(3) 3.84 2.79 1.84 0.72 I. 1.24. 0.50 0.46 1.09. 2.57 2 27 1.62 0.70 0.69 0.67 1.23. 0.73. 0.40. 0.70. 0.43. 0.73. 1.03. L06. 0.81. 1.03. 2.44 2.15 1.63. 0.81. 0.70 0.69 0.67. 0.60 0.52. 3tD:( fiijtt)~. 1.25 ~ tt ~ ~ 0.42. I. (12) ~. 14.60" (12) 0.49 5.20" ~2). ~. ~. 0.20. 0.55. (12) ~. 0.51. 1.08. ~. ~. ~. 1.20. 1 48. 0.97. L29. 0.52. 0.26. 0.47. 0.34. ~. 0.34 A 4. ~ 1fM5;1:z$ 0.13. 0.50. I 0.09. 0.39. O.ll. * ~7.RiI .05 *~. 2.57 2.52 0.63 7.66". 2.59 4.01**. N. 0.99 I 1.26 L31 0.97. i I. ~~m. (12). ~. ••. FM. 3.1.2*. ~. ~. I. SD l.. M. 3.42 I 2.49 2.53 I 2.10 1.89 1.64 0.60 0.67 0.35 0.60 0.50 0.73 0.95 1.15. 3.62 ~ 2.87 ~ 1.98. •• •. 0. ~. (I). ~~~f.f J¥i. 0. FM. SD. 2.57 3.58,2.45 0.30. ~. <:> <:> <:> <:> ..". _if:~. SD. ~5. ......... 0. Iffiijif:~:iitE~~ • • 1JiJ:.~~~~.. -if:~. ~ ~ ~ .." M. <:>. M. .03). ~. M. OC. ~. =. <:>. M M. ... -. M. ~7.iV'l~fiij~7JU d~~&~~¥11~ EH'1Jirl3'~~3t][f'FJfl. ~-1-1H'1Ji.JU!t5Hfi ·flmlffiijif:~:iitE~f:t{.1JiJ:1n~:~· ;U;wilksA. ~ ~ Q <:> <:>. ,. . ~ ...... <:> Q. 0. 9.

(10) 10 m~*~~.~~~¥~~~~nm~,~~m~'~~(~tt)m~,~~m~. &A~m~L~~~~~~om~~~.~~'~~~~~L~~~L~~~~®m~. ~~~.~~'~~~~~~®~~'~¥~~L~~m~~~L%.~~'~ffi~~ ~~~~~,®~~ft~Z¥~'~~L~~m~~~L.*~m~o. •• tt~~'~78.~~'_~~. .~~~~m~rR~ILI:$~~~ ~wilks A = 0.89 ( p <. ~~¥~~~'mn.~~'~.,*~m ~~tt¥~~,. 0. .Ol ) '~~~~~L~~~~m~iPJtLL~~.~.~~~FiiiM1~ 6. 77~~~. 78. ~~lt. F. SD. iii. M. SD. M. 4.24. 2.54. 2 54. 2.08. 121.77-. 1.94. 1.70. 82.03". •. ~. ma m. fI. 3.15. 2.27. tt. *. ~. m. a. 2.08. 1.68. 1.55. 1.49. 24.90-. ~. n. m. a. 0.76. 0.71. 0.58. 0.65. 15.13". ?i. ~. m. BE. 0.49. 0.68. 0.42. 0.63. 2.27. m~ 5c~ (fiU 1~t) m fjf. 0.52. 0.72. 0.43. 0.63. 5.92. 1.19. 1.27. 0.86. 1.06. 19.46". 0.75. 0.37. 0.66. 2.29. 1.21. 0.75. 0.95. 17.28". ~. {I. m. ~. tt m. ~.. 0.45. ~. ~. a. 1.03. • A. m. I. 0. I. I. ~. m. a. 1.15. 1.42. 0.81. 1.18. 18.29". ~. m. a. 0.33. 0.27. 0.54. 0.47. 3.52. 0.11. 0.50. 0.09. 0.39. 0.51. ~li¥i:ftL.. m~*~~77~~~L.~ft78.~ltL.~~.~m~,~*mfl\tt~ma '.nma,{lmma'5c~(fiUtt)ma\~~mfl\.~mflL~~.~®ma. ~~fiU.~\~~&.~~.~~fi~~~LZ~~. ~.~\~~&.~lt.~'~~~LZ~~.~.~~M1.7~ffio.

(11) :inz.~.. rn1f!.t!l:~~"~~. )mf.l'~~m~. ·:@:~'~~;ttlf 0. . ~ #{. '~l1t ' =tQ~1t!J = 0.89 ( p < 'IJ~. 6. I. 0. 77** f 03** f 00**. I. ~ ~7. '2*. 0** , 1. ,. luI 1**. I. •. • • •. I. I. 'ti:. If'. M. SD. ~ li!1f':it ... ~5!fllY.i7m~~. I. M. SD. I M. SD M. SD. ~ ~If'~". M. SD tQ ~iJ. #{. •. I 13. I. •. ~. ;ft ~ ;f1J. I:. 'ti:. ~. (N=212). (N=145). (N=224). (N=156). 7.53 2.72 7.41 2.27 8.48 2.67 8.27 2.58 7.81 2.12 8.47 2.40 8.21 1.79. 6.50 2.59 6.55 2.55 7 68 3.10 7.03 2.66 7.61 2.08 6.32 2.38 7.77 1.57. 7.50 2.68 7.53 2.58 8.42 3.00 8.30. 2.88 8.10 2.42 7.43 2.80 8.09 1.87. 7.04 2.51 7.24 2.73 8.17 3.04 7.42 2.51 7.34 2.41 6.70 2.56. 7.20. 6.89. 7.33 2.50 7.81 3.03 7.48 3.03 7.16 2.81 7.52 2.79. 7.04 2.69 8.00 3.25 8.14 2.66 6.78 2.40 7.21 2.67. ~mulf':it". ~. 78. t!t. 1;:. ~I-(N=216) ~ ~. (N=l QRl !Vl. 1.00. SD. 2.51 7.75 2.59 8.71 3.07. M. SD M ~~. M. SD M. ~~If'~" SD. ~-~~-~~=~~. (N=1l8). ~BU. Jlf. SD. 1. I. ~. (N=92). ro=-~ BiJ. §;ft:e:~. f ' ~,f§m~. l. ~ mulf'~". I. I. SD. ~. Im~If':it .. I. -~~=~~. M. ~. t!t. 1;:. LM ;ft :e: ~ I SD. I. •. ~. ~. 77. ~ BU ~~BU. ;ft ~ ;f1J. §. §. fltIl. ~~'~~~'~~~~~~~ff~~.~L~~ •• ~~. 7. ~ ~:;; MPIHt~7 ffi f.I. 11. 2.34 6.99 2.56 8.30 1.90. 7.34 2.73 7.21 2.82 8.24 3.03 7.30 2.92 7.40 2.08 7.14 2.53 8.44 1.61. I. 1.. ~. ~ ~. -~~ (N=216). I. ~. ~1;:. =~~ 1. ~. ~ ~~. (N=269). (N=255). (N=255). 8.00 2.52 7.71 2.60 8.67. 7.77 2 62 7.84 2.49 8.96. 7.76 2.89 7.55 2.81 8.71. 7.20 2.56 7.40 2.59 8.28. 8.12 1.69. 7.99 1.67. 8.04 1.99. 8.44 1.91. ~EB=~T~.~.~It5}~k6*' !!lmwilks A. = 0.98 (p < .01 ). ~mlf'~~.

(12) 12. !Jk 1f. itf 11:. ~~~~'~0'~~~~~~~~~~~~Z.~.~~~. ~8. .~*~. A ( ~~71U ) B (~ 0) e (~~l.f) AXB AXe BXe AXBXe ~. • p ** p. ~! if.' .I1Jl. < <. SS. 46.36 143.03 155.18 15. 75 3.57 3.50 12.83 16422.62. df. MS. F. 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 2344. 23.18 143.03 155.18 7.87 1. 78 3.50 6.41 7.00. 3.30· 20.41** 22.14** 1.12 0.25 0.50 0.91. l.f. 0. ~~~¥~/J. (3) rn ~HORJ 9i R~ffl. 0. rn~~1. ~ ~ Fa • i!f~ ~ C n~~~~~z ~1O.. .~. A (~t B (~. .05. .01. e. (¥~. ~,~0&~~l.f~'~~~.~~~~R~fflon~~ • • ~z.~.~~~*~oo. AxB AXe BXe. mff. A. o. x B). rn~8~~,~~¥~'~~~0'&~~~~l.fz¥~~~~~~~~~~~~. • p < •• p <. '@~~~.ff~~R~fflorn~~~.~'~~~~±Z~~'~~~~~~~Z~ ~~~~~~'~m~m~¥~~~~Bm~~~~B~*m~~~-~~m~~~o ~U~0~'=~0~~~~~~~l.f~~-~0~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~, n¥~~~~~~ft~~~.~~~~l.f~~~~ft.~~o. ffl ' 1L~~~0J. OOrn~9~~~~¥~,~0&¥~.~~~~~~~$~~~'@~~~.~R ~fflorn~~~.~'U~~~±~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.'~.~~~~ ~@x.~M~~m~OE~~0~,_~0~~~~~ • • ~~~-~0~~~~~. ~9. ~~~~,~0,~~~¥~~~~~~Z.~.~~~. .~*~. A B. (¥~71Ij) (~. 0). ec¥~~). AXB Axe Bxe AXBXe ~ • p .. p. < <. .05 .01. (4)rn~ 11. SS. df. MS. F. 46 33 59.75 81.24 32.94 3.80 11.45 2.01 16137.88. 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 2344. 23.16 59.75 81.24 16.47 1.90 11.45 1.00 6.88. 3.36 8.67*· 11.80" 2.39 0.27 I. 66 0.14. ,. n¥~.~'. ~~~0~j(Iij; ~1l .~. A(¥. B c~. e(~. AxB Axe BXe AxB. ill - p •• p.

(13) ffi.~~~q~~~~~~fl~~rr~z~.. t5H1T~. F. 3.30* 20.41** 22.14" 1.12 0.25 0.50 0.91. ft5tt1iM*~§13 fI]~J: :f$FfH~~. lto~7I"~~~lt~'77¥~lt¥~tfg7l"~~.~tfg~~78¥~lt~~tfg7l"~~o ~~~10~~7I"~~t5c&7I"~~~lt~~tfgEfa~~~:tf • • ~ft,@.~~.~ 1i~mo~~~.~,~~~ftt5c~~&~~~~±~t5ctfg~~ZEfa~~~~~,_. ~EfFa'~~Ef. "1fU~~lt ~ ,. § flUt fb~ 1!W 5t 1i. ~'M-:tf~flJ~ ::£itfg7l"~~~. T~ •. -. F. .36* .67** .80** .39 27 66 14. tfgm~'W~~~~±tfg~t5c*~~.~m~o~U7l"~~~lt~,. 77*~lt~~ZEfa~~~ • • ~~78~~lt~~ZEfa*~~o ~107I"~~t5c,~~,~~lt~~tfgEfa~~J:Z.ft.5tt1i~. J!ft*1i. SS. df. MS. F. A ( ~t5c~U ) B (~ ~) e (~~lt) AXB AXe BXe AXBxe. 55.31 31. 76 134.72 37.75 3.36 0.98 38.48 21041.56. 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 2344. 27.65 31.76 134.72 18.87 1.68 0.98 19.24 8.97. 3.08* 3.53 15.00" 2.10 0.18 0.11 2.14. 1m. trftt5c~~ZEf ~tfgm~~~o. 13. ~. < .05. p < .01. *p --. OO~~II~~7I"~~t5c'~~.7I"~~~ltz~~~ • • 7I"~.~ltJ::tf~1i~ m'H7I"~~~.7I"~~~ltz~~~~.~J:~:tf.~±~~*o~U7l"~~~lt~. • 77 ~~lt~ , ~t5c.~~~tfg • •7I"~.mMtlIJIIII-I ftfffi ' ~ 78 ~~lt~, ~t5c .~~~tfg • •7I"~.mMtlIJlIIl-2. .ft*1i (~~~U) (~. ~). e(~~lt). AXB Axe BXe AXBXe j!. < .05 p < .01. *p ... 0. 7I"~~~,~~,~~lt~~tfg • • 7I"~.J:Z.ft.5tt1i~. ~1l. A B. ftfffi. SS. df. MS. F. 60.81 25.98 9.68 95.12 16.32 36.28 97.17 18240.00. 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 2344. 30.40 25.98 9.68 47.56 8.16 36.28 48.58 7.78. 3.90* 3.33 1.24 6.11 1.04 4.66* 6.24-.

(14) 14 (m;). (m;) ~. 8.4 8.2 8.0 7.8. ;ell... J@1 /F )Jj I!;. 8.2 8.0 7.8 7 .6 7.4 7.2 7.0. ~. J@1 /F )Jj I!;. 7.6. 7.4 7.2 7.0. -. •. -:tr~. ~Jt=~~¥::1:",. ----J:1tQ _JJ:tr. (5)EB~. 12. i. J!/Ffi:ijlJ1~JtlJ1~. 13-~. (fi) ljJf 7.8. ( i@j ). ~ /F. (~)~---+----~. ~. I!;. il1-1 77 ~~Jt/Ffi:ij¥~~/Ffi:ij. /Ii 1-2 78. ~~~~Z~J@1/F)JjI!;~~.5H(jj. ~~~~Z~J@1/F)Jjl!;z~~.5j. il o. f:(jj/lio. ~~Jt/Ffi:ij~tQ~/Ffi:ij. (. 7.6. ~. 7.4 7.2 7.0. /". ) 77. ~[I]~~'~13-.a·m77~~Jt.'.ft~~-~~~~~~J@1/F)Jjl!;m.~fi. 11 3 /Ffi:ijl zr;f~/F~B. '_~~¥~Z/F)Jjl!;m.~~'ffiJ:1:tr13-tQ~~~,~~J@1/F)JjI!; • • • ~~&Z.. ~. 0. ffi~78 ~~Jt., I3D~.ft~._.~!!ft¥.f&:. ~*~z~Hi. · ~D=~~~~~.~.m.:fi1mz.~. •. '=~~Z~J@1/F)Jjl!;m.. EBIl3~~. ~azm.·. 0. ffil. ~[I]2 ~~. 77~~. 77lJ1~JtZm~. JtZ-~~~~~78~~Jt-~~~~~.~J@1noo~/F)JjI!;·~77~~Jt~78~. JtJ!-~~zml. ~~/Fflij~~~/Ffi:ij~~JtJt~J@1/F)JjI!;1i~1[fFfflz~.. •. .Jtlj9J~. fi. 78. ~1f. (6)EB ~ 13 .. 8.2 8.0 7.8. •. ~.liJlt=MI3. 7.6. .~~=~~1'I'il. 7.4 7.2. /Ffi:ij~~~/Ffi:ij¥~. ~.f~~~!!ft. Jt¥~z~jg/F:iil!;~~.. ~:±I'I'il¥~~::1:. [1]2. 5j-f:(jjil o ~.. 12.. /Ffi:ij~tQ,~~,~~Jt¥~~m~/F)Jjl!;xz.~.5j-~~. .~*Ii A ( lJ1tQ 1JU ) B(~. ~). e (~~1t) AxB Axe Bxe AXBXe. •. ~. ··p<.Ol*~. ss. df. MS. F. 76 34 8.67 0.46 14.68 82.98 53.75 2.99 13900.50. 2 1 1 2 2. 38.17 8.67 0.46 7.34 41.49 53.75 1.49 5.93. 6.43·· 1.46 0.07 1.23 6.99·· 9.06·· 0.25. 1. 2 2344. ~13 .~. A(~. B(if'. e «~. AxB AXe BXe AXE GJI:.

(15) m.tt~~.~~~tt~~~~~rr~z~.. -1c:t£. if:..=if:..~~;z • • If'~.m~~.~ ••fto. ----~:t£. •. -....!J.Jjr. -t}:t£. OO~.121lJ~lf'fijJS:t£J!lijlf'fijJSif:..s~;Zm.If'~ • • ~~li~ffl'lf'fijJif:.. ~lf'fijJSif:..s~;Zm.If'~ • • $~~li~fflo. (1I£). m •. If' Jii. =if:.~. •. ~ :t£ J!lijlf' fijJ. 7.8 7.6. :--.. 7.4 7.2 7.0. -1c:t£ -- -~:t£ "". -.-:951c. '-. /'. -t}~. '-. •. ~1f'~.~Mtf(1ff fMJlU~~ll& ;z~. :~~If'~.m~ 21lJ~'77~if:.. 78. ~. 8.0. 7.8 7.6 7.4. 77 Sif:.. ~.~.- 78 Sif:.. ~.;-. ~. 7.2 7.0 (~). 77. ~if:. m: J!Iij. /. (1I£ ). :S1 • If' :iii. (~). ~ZfS.~It11. 15. -if:... 78. 113 If'IffiS~~lf'fijJ~if:..S~ ;Zm.1f' ~ IU!ZfS. ~.11f:ffi [I. 114. =if:... If'fijJif:..~lf'fijJSif:.m:S~;Z. :S1.1f'~.ZfS.~1t11f:ffi1il. , ~j¥Hi~t5t'JtO£B-frt5t~ ( ~O 78 Sif:..) • s~;Zm.If':iii • • iWi~-t} t5tf,J;zm~, ffiM(*!1!O:95lc-t}t5t;zIIlr::f:t, JlUffl'fiHt:llR' 78 ¥if:..;Zm.If'Jii.f'ilj~1)!;~ 77Sif:..;Zm.If'~ •• o~Ulf'fijJif:..~lf'fijJif:..;Z~li~ffl~([l4)'77Sif:. .~-if:..;Zm.Jii ••• ~~Sif:..;Z.~;@7.if:..;Z_if:..~~;Zm.~.f'ilj ~JliJ~~ 78 Sif:..;Z_if:..S~ (6)~~ 13 1lJ;;n, 1f'1i't1.t5t 'if:.Jj&If'f'itl.if:..;Z.~tE~~If'~.;Z~.~~ • • ft' llJlt::::lIl3.~~~li~ffl ~[l5-1 iiJ;;n , 77Sif:.. ( !1!11=t5t1i'~~tt.t5t~) ·~t5t=if:..~~~If'~ • • ~~~-if:..~~~If'Jii • • ,~r::f:t.tt.~-, if:.. ~.{t~~!ftt¥t5t~IHt ; ~[l5-2 iiJ;;n , 1i'~:t£ •• ~~ttSt5tt~ , ~r::f:t.retJ:95~ ~±~St5tS~ , &M(*SO~!ftt.t5t~.~~~!'fIj;zJii • • ' .re~77¥if:.ll;z.~HH ~[l3RJ~. 0. 0. HJ!lijlf'fijJ~if:.. f:~.ZfS.tljlt 5Hfi~. ~13. If'fijJS:t£'if:..'Sif:..S~~~~If'~.~;z.ft.11~~. F. .ft*il. SS. df. MS. F. .43- .46 ,07 ,23 99- 06- 25. A (S:t£BU ) B ( if:. e(Sif:..) AXB AXe Bxe AXBXe. 59.17 317.38 17.55 12.69 7.57 45.55 188.06 16709.50. 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 2344. 29.58 317.38 17.55 6.34 3.78 45.55 94.03 7.12. 4.15 44.52 2.46 0.89 0.53 6.39 13.19**. .). ~.

(16) 16. g. -trt3t --99t3t ---99tr -&rt3t. 8.4. 8.2 8.0 7.8. 7.6 7.4 7.2 7.0 6.8 6.6 6.4 6.2. 7.8. •. 7.6 7.4. 7.2 7.0. :q:.m~~z~flffilf'~!tFlS~.711ffi 0. !lJ5-2 78 ~:q:.1tlf'mJ~t3t!Mlf'mJ m~~ z ~ fireif' lli JiFlS~. 711ffi !lJo. •. ~. flffi If' lli. •. !lJ6. ~:. ~. g 7.8 7.6 7.4 7.2 7.0 6.8 6.6 6.4 6.2 6.0. .. 14 ,. A C~~ B C:q:. e C~:q AxB AXe BXe A xB >. 6.8 6.6 6.4 6.2. !lJ5-1 77 ~:q:.ntlf'mJ~t3t!Mlf'mJ. 111. g. ** p. ~. ~. - - 77 ~:q:. nt -- - 78 ~:q:. nt. <. Cg) ~ ~. If'. ~. •. 8.4 8.2 8.0 7.8 7.6 7.4 C~). If'mJ~:q:.nt'lf'mJ:q:.m~~z. ~flffilf'lli.1tZP:~.711ffi!llo mJ,~-:q:.~~~m,=:q:.~~If'~.,@~tr~~~~~t3t.~m&,-:q:.m~~~. ft_:q:.m~~~~~~~~flffilf'llimmMo~ffi~¥~~~~W. 1If'mJ~:q:.nt&lf'mJ. =:q:.mz~~1f'3. If'.mnt&W@j. :q:.mZ~~~~flffilf'lli.nt~~~0~ffi!IJ6*~'If'~W~:q:.nt~t3t=:q:.mZ~flffilf'. ~mnt~~.m'WA78~:q:.nt-:q:.m~~~~flffilf'mm~nt~~~~77~:q:.nt-:q:. m~~flffilf'~mnto. mffi.14~.lf'mJ~t3t&lf'mJ:q:.~~~Z~t3tIf'.mmM~~E~ffl'WAlf'mJ. ffi~A. ~lJ~. ,BF. , :tEft A~. :q:.m&lf'mJ~:q:.ntz~~~~t3tIf'~.mM~~~E~fflo~ffi~7~.~¥~~~~. ~.lWfiij-~~;. ~~~t3t,=:q:.m~~~~t3tlf'lli.nt~~~-:q:.m~~~~t3tIf'.mmM,@99tr-&r. .J1{,. t3t~~~,~~t3tIf' •• mM~~m&,=:q:.m~~t3tIf'~.mM~@'W-:q:.m~~. lUlt.Z~.~. ~~~If'~.mM~.m:o ~ffilf'fiij~:q:.nt&lf'mJ:q:.m~~Z~~If'~mmM~'ffi!ll8~.'77~:q:.nt~'. ~lf'mJ~J. ~~~~:tE~.

(17) 17. w~~~~.~~~~~~~~~rr~z~.. -:trt!c. ~. -~t!c. -. -.-~:tr. ~. -fr:t5t. ,""", ,. '\. :1m lJt!c J!:if' 1m. t~~:lt'alt 5Hfii. 14.. IF 1m lJt!c ' 1J:: il ' lJ1J:: If[ lJ:£ ttillJt!cIF ~ J!J:;;G. ~ It 5H1i ~. .~*I(. 55. A ( "Jt!cBU ) B(1J:: il) C(lJ1J::.) AxB Axe BxC AXBXC ~. •• p ~lf[. If[. lJ t!c IF ~. III:. (~) 8.4 8.2 8.0 7.8 7.6. df. M5. F. 49.61 4.78 22.02. 2. 7.39··. 1. 24.80 4.78. 1. 22.02. 6.56··. 36.92. 2. 18.46. 5.50". 16.44. 2. 8.22. 29.10. 1. 29.10. 1.30. 2. 0.65. 2344. 3.35. 7863.55. <. -:trt!c - ~t!c. ~-.-~:tr. ...:::-:: - - - -. -frt!c. (~). lJ IF liI III:. 8.4 8.2 8.0 7.8 7.6. 8 67·· 0.19. (. ). ~. -77 ~1J::. ,- ----78lJ1J::.. ~. 7.4. ). -1J::1Jt. =1J::1Jt. ill 7 1F1m"Jt!c:if'!i'01J::lJtlJ:£Z ~ t!c IF ](jill: ~ :It'alt 5Hfii III 0. ·-1J::ilttillJ:£ 1m lJ1J:: If[& /f~. 2.45. .01. 7.4. (. 1.42. .. -1J::1Jt iIlB. =1J::1Jt. :if'lm1J::I&.:if'fi'U.!J!~!t.!J!. :£Z ¥ t!c1F:Ii II lIS :It'alt 5Hfii ill. 0. =1J::il;;GlJt!clFliIlII:•••• ~-1J::~Z¥t!cIF:ii~.trrnn~1J::.~.=1J::~;;G¥~ 1F:iiJ!.&rrn@~-1J::ilZ~~lFliI~.o. =1J::ilZ~1iIi1F ~. 77 lJ1J:: If[ -1J::. =,-frt!c~,~Im-~~~~:£~m~;;G~~. ffi~A'B~t!c~~+A¥1J::.~,:It'a~~~:tr-frt!c·~~~*A¥tE"Jt!c-1J::~. fF,ffl'rrnlllFlm ?:IJt.J.¥tElJ:£~. m~·m~:tr-fr. ·rrn-1J::illJ:£. ttil¥:£·~*A=1J::IJt~·~T1J::lJtttil~.~t~m:£~ttil"Jt!cmm~~~~tE~t!co ~.MIm-~~*~¥tElJt!cJ!~~tE~t!c~;;G:£~m~fl.~~t~t.J.:£~m~~~ .~.t.J.IFIm"Jt!c~~~.~(A~~~OO·mt.J.:tr~'~t!c'~:tr-fr~~W;;G)~fi. ••• ItZ~.~.~It~~o ~t!clJ:£~~~.~J:;;G~:lt'aIt~.¥~~~15. ·77lJ1J::.~.. 0.

(18) 18. ~ 1J{. ~. •. ~ -~ JJtwu. ffi. 11. *. m. fI. ~. ~. 1m 1J m. •. ~. ~. m. ~. •. m. m. •. 3t 0:'( I'ifJ tt ) ffi • ~. tt. ~. IE ffi. lJ. tQ. m. A. ~. m. /F • •. :!J3. m. • • • •. L.. g:. :!J31J:ftg:. 77.lJ¥~. 78.lJ¥~. 77.lJ¥~. 4.81. 3.06. 3.04. 2.06. 3.13. 2.70. 2.73. 2.23. 2.26. 1.71. 2.64. 1.97. lJl5t1JU (. 1.26. 2.38. 1.77. MJ79~~. 1.84. .t • .t£. 2.21. 1.46. M. 2.43. 2.37 1.85 2.00. 2.06. SD. 3.37 2.52. 1.78. 1.19. 1.63. 1.63. SD. 1.20. 1.63. 1.82. 1.25. 1.58. 1.24. M. 1.06. 0.87. 0.50. 0.41. 0.56. 0.52. SD. 0.77. 0.80. 0.69. 0.66. 0.54. M. 0.68. 0.87. 0.45. 0.15. 0.36. 0.50. SD. 0.70. 0.80. 0.69. 0.36. 0.53. 0.66. M. 0.50. 0.50. 0.45. 0.23 I 0.50. SD. 0.63. 0.51. 0.69. 0.56. o 55. 0.58. M. 1.43. 1.12. 0.80. 0.50. 0.59. o 72. SD. 1.15. 0.88. 1.02. 0.69. 0.97. 0.08. M. 0.18. 0.43. 0.43. 0.17. 0.27. 0.31. SD. 0.40. 0.81. 0.77. 0.52. 0.45. 0.51. M. 1.31. 0.93. 0.60. 0.52. 0.72. 0.72. SD. 0.99. 0.85. 0.58. 1.02. 0.92. M. 1.30 1. 31. 1.00. 0.84. 0.45. 0,68. 0.65. SD. 1.92. 1.09. 1.33. 0.62. 1.21. 0.91. M. 0.37. 0.37. 0.30. 0.15. 0.11. 0.31. SD. 0.46. 0.36. 0.32. 0.51. lJg:S~ (J. M. 0.61 I 0.50 0.18 0.31. 0.08. 0.00. 0.06. o 02. MJ79~~. SD. 0.79. 0.46. 0.00. 0.45. 0.15. M. ~. m. M:. g:. 1J:. ... J SD. M. I. 0.40. ~83.fl:Ff~.~.~.?}~la*' wilks. r 78.lJ!if i 77.lJ!if r 78.lJ!if. 1 = 0.642 ( p. =. o. ~~11frl'lj. : J. ~~~J79:. ••J1t. (1. lJtQ1jlj Xi. lJ.J1t X;. < .' p < .'. • p ••. 43 (2)83. 17. Ii. .~J!*l.~ma. , m.~J1tt<~Et;. ~ffi.~J1t~.1f.. .17. ~jit~r~ :. ~G;t~J79:. .020) 0 ~m/Fl'ifJlJ. lJ~J1t (1. g:lJ~~ftg:~~,~~~m.~J1t~~~oU~n~~~~~~L~ • • ~~OO~~:. lJg:SU X. m83.16~.~g:~lJ~'~lJ~m~~. '83~~.~.'U~~.~~. lJtQ'~ffi • • fi'U1J:~.~~lJtQ,~m • • • oRM77.lJ.J1t~~.Lm~~J1t. '~lJ~*A=.~'OO • • L.M:lJg:• • • ~ttlJg:~'M~~Lm.~J1t '83~~.~.'77.lJ.J1tLffi.~J1t~•• M•• ~. (OO*A=~~.)Lm.~. lJ.J1t Xi •• p <.

(19) ffi¥~~~~~m~~~~~~~IT~z~.. 19. fj[o. ~1f. •. 78.~1f. 13. 2.70. 54. 1.97. 38. 1.77. n. 1.46. i3. 1.63. ;8. 1.24. i6. 0.52. i6. 0.54. 16. 0,50. ,3. 0.66. 0. o 43. 5. 0.58. 9. 072. 7. 0.08. 7. 0.31. 5. 0.51. ~~~l3't~~~ft~~~~~~m~LZ.~.~~~. ~ 16. 93t.rftl3't. ~~1!frdl. ~. "*. ~. SS. df. MS. F. : 45.42. 2. 22.71. 654.04. 10.3. 6.34. ~1ffj[(B). 46.67. 1. 46.67. 13.19-. ~~ijU. 10.68. 2. 5.34. 1. 51. 364.38. 10.3. 3.53. '"t3H1U ( A ) mP9~~ (SI A). 3.5'". ~~1!fP9:. X ~1ffj[ ( A X B ). "'1fJ.r X mP9~~. < p <. - p --. ( SlAB). .05. .01. OO~~17~.~~~~~"'~~~M"*~m~;g~~n~~¥.fj[,m-€t~~~. ~~~~"*~m~~~~w~~otJ.~~.~'~.~~~Z~~~¥~m~~[j[~~ ,m~~fj[~~~¥~~~.~t.r~~¥~o~tJ.¥.[j[~,n¥.[j[mM~z~~,. [email protected]~~~~"'1ffj[ffl~~z~flo. 0.72. -. 0.92. ~17. ~~¥~¥~~~~~~~~*~~xZ.~.~~~. 0.65. 55. 0.91 0.31 0.51. o 02 0.15 ). 0. 2kjfi)f' (qJ !Jl. ~~1!fr~. ¥~BU (A). mP9~~ (S/A). "'1ffj[ (B). tJ.93~~±~. ¥1ffj[xmpg~~(S/AB). 7~) Z~H~~. F. 35.42. 2. 17.71. 443.49. 103. 4.30. 27.32. 1. 27.32. 0.97. 2. 0.48. 215.83103. 2.09. 4.11-. ~~1!fP9:. ~~BUX¥1ffj[(AXB). .~J.r;g~~. M5. :. llE'Ufl ~ .YlfF: l~zlmjU'Mr. df. -- p. <. 13.04-. 0.23. .01. ~~.18~.~~"'~~"'~~~h~m.Lw~~~~~.~.tJ.t.r~~±Z.

(20) SS ~~~rlll'. df. MS. F. 6.32. 2. 3.16. 5.70··. 57.11. 103. 0.55. 0.47. 1. 0.47. 1.64. 0.11. 2. 0.05. 0.20. 29.99. 103. 0.29. :. ~~211j (A). mP9~~(S/A) ~~~P9: ~1flt. (B). x !J1flt (A XB ) ¥1flt X mP9~~ ( S/AB). !J~gtl. •• p. < .01 (5)~. 20. !J~~~'~~~nm~Lft~'W~~~m±~!J~!J~'~~~nm~L~~O. ~, ~~~m.=t. W~.19~~,~~~~!J~~~~~1flt~~~,~~.m~L~~~~m,. ~~9~~U~~m±~*~,~~~~~~~.~m~~lt~~'W~~~m±~~ ~~~~~,~m~~Jt&W~~;**~~~~~~~~~$~~~Z.~oWA= ~~,~u~~m±~~~¥~,~~~.~m~~lt~~o. ~~~n. !J~~. SS ~~~rlll' ~~ glj. df. MS. F. ~~~p. : (A). mP9~~. (S/A). 5.40. 2. 2. 70. 53.03. 103. 0.51. .5.24··. ~1fB. *1flt ( B). 0.001. 1. 0.001. 0.008. ¥~gUX~1flt(AXB). 2.70. 2. 1.35. 6.13··. 22.67. 103. 0.22. ~1fJtXmP9~~. <. ~1fB. ~~~. ~~~P9;. •• p. mP9~. .01. (S/AB). •• (6)~._. 2]. ~~iiti~~.f@;1. (7)Eb. 2~ :t~~~~~.

(21) ffi.~~~~~~~~~~~~~rr~z~.. !t5t~~. F. 7'~f. m tif. 5.70**. /' . 0.9 0.8 0.1 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1. 1.64 0.20. 21. ./. :tr~. ~f5t. 'X/ ,, ,. -.-~:tr~f5t. ". 77.1f./lf. 1ilI9 . 78.1f. fit.. /F~¥f5t&/F~~1f.fit.z~~. tE7'f.t@~~J:z5t1ffi1ll. M~.~~~/F~.f5ttt'iJ¥~,tE~~(~~M~)m~J::fr~fto~~~.~. 1J ~H.~ J: !t1)£. 0. ~,tlk~~:£tt'iJ~~~~:fr~~tt'iJm~o. ~J::fr~][fFm,. mtl :trf5t~:£tt'iJ~ ij; z.f} TiiilL:::. ~20. Z.ft.5t~~. 0. t~~. SS. df. MS. F. 10.63 119.61. 2 103. 5.31 1.16. 4.58**. 1.07 2.52 72.17. 1 2 103. 1.07 1.26 0.70. 1.53 1.80. ~a;:t~ra' :. _f5tBtl F. /F~¥~.~~~f5t~~tE~~(~~)m~J:. (A). ~pg~a;:t. (SI A). ~~~pg:. 5.24**. _1f. fit. ( B ) ¥f5t Btl x ¥1f. fit. ( A X B ) ~1f.fit. X~pg~~ (SlAB). 0.008 6.13**. ** p. < .01. @~.21~~/F~~f5ttt'iJ~~tE • • mtifJ::fr~ftoa~tl:tr~~:£tt'iJ~~¥~ :fr~~tt'iJ•• mtif'Tiiitl~~~:£tt'iJ¥f5t~~,a •• m~~fit.~1)£o. m~~22.~~/F~~~tt'iJ~~'X/F~.Z.tt'iJmtif~fit.:fr~RoX~tl:tr~~. £tt'iJ~~~~':fr.~/F~.tt'iJ.,x~m~tt'iJ~~.~~:fr/F~.Z.o.

(22) ti Ff W ie., JlfI lJ'f. 22. ~. ~~~~~~~~~~~~*~~~LL.~.~~1k.. 1k. 21. SS ~Sit~ rf3'. df. MS. F. 2. 3 72. 3.23*. 103. 1.15. :. ~~i11J (A) M~~ii\. 7.45. (Sj A). 118.56. 1. EJ:ft~fI] r. ~. ~ii\~~: ~~1t. (B). ~~i1U X ~~1t. ( A XB ). ~~1txM~~~ (SjAB). <. * p. 0.99. 1. 0.99. 1.98. 0.82. 2. 0.41. 0.82. 51. 70. 103. 0.50. ~. ~. ~. 1. t-. ~. EJ:ft~~ -. .05. 1 ~. j. *~~~~ -. ~. jl~~~~ f. ~. SS ~Sit~rf3'. df. MS. ~mi~~~. F. :. ~. .~~~JJ! r. ~~i1U (A). M~~Sit. -. ( S/A). ~. 3.35*. 1.14. 2. 0.57. 17.64. 103. 0.17. 0.30. 1. 0.30. 2.33. 0.04. 2. 0.02. 0.16. 13.65. 103. 0.13. ~~~~: ~~1t. (B). ~~i1U X ~~1t (A XB) ¥~1txM~~~ (SjAB). ~~~n. .~~. * p. <. M~~. .05. ~Sit~f. =,~~~,~~-~Sit~~~~~~LL~~. ~~l. 8~.~~n.~1t~~.~1t(OO~~~'~)~~~L~~~m~.1k.~~.. tlJJ1k. 23·. 0. ~rn=~.:rm~:I:.~IEfU'~.~~-*5*. ' wilks A = .894 (p< .000). 0. a.~~~.L8 • • ~L~~-*5*'~OOtlJJ~o (I). rn1k. 24. RJm~~.t£L.~:tE EJ1X~~~L:fl~~. ,. ffijli~/f~~.~1t~mfj. *~. ~~I. *. p. ** p.

(23) m.~~~~~~~~~~~~~IT~Z~.. ~~~~. ~23. ~~~~£~-~~::i~~mI~if.It ~~~~~~.~L£~~. F. 17: 3.23*. f3:ft;ilfl] 1.98. ~. 1ti. $;.. 0.82 ~:ft~~. ~I@;~lii~. iU!~~lii.. ~~~~. ~Oi1i~lii.. F. ~~~~.. 3.35*. 23. ~. !Jj. •• ~~~. ~. !Jj. 17.~if.. 78.~if.. 17.~if.. 78.~if.. 17.~if.. 78.~if.. (N=74 ). (N=74 ). (N=159). (N=e 159). (N=213 ). (N=213 ). M. 7.55. 8.04. 7.12. 7.83. 7.23. 7.39. SO. 2.63. 2.27. 2.94. 2.59. 2.79. 2.47. M. 7.60. 7.77. 7.27. 7.97. 7.32. 7.55. SO. 2.00. 2.46. 2 75. 2.50. 2.67. 2.53. M. 8.67. 8.90. 8.18. 9.14. 7.79. 8.38. SO. 2.30. 2.64. 3.19. 2.58. 3.19. 3.09. M. 8.47. 7.95. 8.27. 8.27. 7.72. 7.77. SO. 2.36. 2.61. 3.00. 2.69. 2.89. 2.76. M. 7.93. 7.94. 7.55. 7.77. 7.42. 7 59. SO. 2.13. 1.82. 2.84. 2.21. 2.72. 2.64. :M. 9.02. 8.20. 7.45. 6.42. 7.53. 7.85. SO. 2.20. 2.14. 2.84. 2.71. 2.70. 2.88. M. 8.33. 8.77. 8.19. 8.21. 8.19. 8.37. SO. 1.69. 1.42. 1.96. 1.64. !. 1.98 L. ~. I. 2.33 0.16. ~~::ird}. SS. 0. 1" mI ~if. It ffl tIlIJ. I. 1.92. df. MS. F. : 86.86. 2. 43.43. 5571. 95. 443. 12.57. ~if.lit(B). 64.12. 1. 64.12. ~~Z1U X ~if.lit (A XB ). 14.38. 2. 7.19. 2197.71. 443. 4.96. U¥~~~. ,. ,. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~L£~~.~~~. 24. ~~Z1U (A). iii ~.it ~Fls~.. ;94 (p< .000). L. ~. ~. 17:. (SjA). 3.45*. ~~::i~:. ~if.lf£x~V'J~~ (S/ AB). * p < .05 **p<.OI. 12.92** 1.44. -. i.

(24) 24. ~z§~~~~~~~~orn~=+~z~~.~~,~~~~±~~~~~,~§~. ~~~~~'W~ft~~~~~~~~Z~~~~~Z§~~~~~~OE~~~~~. ,n••• m.~z.~§~~~~~.~•••~.,m~-§~.'.~*A =~m~,~§~~~~~-~m~~o. ~rn~25~.~~.~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~'WA~-~ ~.~~m.~z~~~~~.~~~~o ~~~~~~~. •••~. ~.~~.,~~~~±~~~~~z. ••ft.~~~~oAn~~~m.~z~~~fi.~ ••ft••~~. ~z~~~~o. *. 1. ( ~ijlj if 2 ( ~7JlJ if 3. ( ~BU if 4. ( ~BU if 5. ( ~tJU if 6. ( ~tJlj 11 7. ( ~tJU 11 8. ( ~BU if 9. ( ~1:W 11 10. ( ~BU 11 II. ( ~ijU * 11. * * * * * * * * *. 12(~ijU*~. SS § ••. df. MS. F. ra' :. ~~BU (A). $pg§. (S/A). 300.04. 4706.34. 2 . 150.02 443. 14.12**. 10.62. (B). 131. 48. 1. 131. 48. 5.95. 2. 2.97. 1746.56. 443. 3.94. ~~7JU X*~~ (AXB). "'~~X$pg~. (SlAB). .. p. <. 33.34** 0.75. * * * *. ~.$~~.~,~~~~z~~'~~~rn~~~~~M~~~~~~·.~~ ~oorr~~.~~z~~~~~~(~~~m~~~oo,.~~.~oo,~.~~~). '~~fi*£~.~tt~~z~.'~~~~~26m~o ~.·~A~.~fi~.~~'~~~~~~.~z. •• ,&~~,~~. •• ~~~~~.~~~$.'~.M •• m'*~~.ffl~~~.~rr~ z~.z~~omrn~~~.ffi~~.~~.~.~.~~~ ••• ·.~~rr~z~. ~~.~z. ~~~~~~'H.~~.~z~~~M~~o HJt~mT~z~~:. rn~ 27 '~9ifl • EH~t5c.~~~~~. *. 21. ( ~tJU ~ 22 ( ~ijU * ~ 21 ( ~ijU *:tj 24. ( ~7JlJ * 1: 25. ( ~BIJ * ~ 26. ( ~ijlj ~ TI. ( ~ijU 1 28. ( ~7JlJ 1 29. ( ~ijIJ * 1 30. ( ~ijU * 1 31. ( ~ijlj * 1 32. ( ~tflJ * 1 31 ( ~1JU 1 34. ( ~7JU 1 35. ( ~7J1j * 1 36. ( ~BU 1. * * *. .01. ~'~~~~~~~~~~~fi~~.z~~. rn~26. *. ~ 14.(~ijU*~ 15. (~BIJ ~ 16. (~BU ~ 17. ( ~BU ij 18. ( ~1JU 11 19. ( ~ijU * 11 20. ( ~ijU ~. *. ~ • • P9: ~~fi{. 13. ( ~7JlJ. , .~.~~.~~~mT~~oo1t~~ftr~. * *. *. XI =1tm'. X 2 ="'t!I: X 3 =~.I X 4 =~.: X 5 =~.;.

(25) m~~~NM~~~~*N~*~rrmZ~.. t3t~~,. €:I $:. ~ 26. °lfUIf\Im. iit:?t''i'1t7l-A. ~-~Iiit:?t~1f\ t:1'tiJ~t3t~1:. jfif{j£ ~ 78.~ 1F. t.t1T~. F. 14.12". 0.75. U~m~~). t t3tlJlJ .. ~ft~1:fJ.m. !1:fJ.mZiJt. Jt1rt3tMi~. ~. 1. ( ~lJIJ * 1Ffi ) (~lJIJ * TlI) 2 (~~Ij * 1Ffi ) (~~fj * TlI) 3. (tQ~U * 1Ffi) (1Ffi* TlI) 4. ( ~lJIJ * 1Ffi ) ( TlI) 5. (t5c7JU * 1Ffi) ( tQ~IJ *.~) 6. ( t5c7JU * 1Ffi ) ( t5c7JU * ~~ ) 7. ( ~7J1j * 1Ffi) (1Ffi * ) 8. ( tQ~U * 1Ffi) ( .~ ) 9. ( tQlJIJ * 1Ffi ) ( tQ7J1j * m~ ) 10. ( tQ7}lJ * 1Ffi ) ( tQ~1j m. ) II. ( tQBU * 1Ffi ) ( ft * m~ ) 12 ( tQ7J1j * 1Ffi ) ( mil ) 13. ( tQBU * 1Ffi) ( tQ~1j * ~$:fi. ) 14. ( ~ 7JU * 1Ffi) ( tQ~1j * .#1: ) 15. ( tQ~U * 1Ffi ). ( 1Fft * .$:fi. ) 16. ( ~7}lJ * 1Ffi) ( . #1: ) 17. ( t5c~1j * 1Ffi ) (~BIj * ~i1) 18. ( tQ7JU * 1Ffi ) (~7}lJ * IE. ) 19. ( tQ7}lJ * 1F fi) (1F fi * TlI ). *. ). L!. (1Ffi * TlI). (1Ffi *.~). (1Ffi * mil ). (1Ffi * ~#1:. ). (1Ffi * .i1 ). (~.). 21. ( ~7JU * 1Ffi ) ( ~7J1j * ¥~) (1Ffi * .~ ) 22 (. tQ7JU * 1Ffi) ( tQ7JU * .~ ). 23. (tQ7J1j * 1Ffi) (1Ffi * ¥~ ) 24,( tQ~fj. ~~. ~1:~. .. 1Ffi~.~fJA~.Z.~~M. •. 2O.(tQlJIJ* 33.34". ~OO. * 1Ffi ) 25. ( tQ7J1j * 1Ffi ) 26.( tQ~U * 1Ffi) 27. ( tQ7}1] * 1Fft ) 28. ( tQ7JtJ * 1Ffi) 29.(tQlJIJ*1Ffi) 30. ( tQ7J1j * 1Ffi ) 31. ( tQ7J1j * 1Ffi ) 32( tQ~u * 1Ffi) 33.( ~7JU * 1Ffi) 34. ( ~7J1j * 1Ffi) 35. ( tQBIj * 1Ffi) 36. ( tQlJIJ * 1Ffi). ( (. .~. ). ~~Ih (~~U *. 25. fU') (1Ffi * In. ) fHI). ( 1Ffi * lJU. ) ( m~ ) (~7}lJ*J4~) (1Ffi*J4~) ( ~7JU * J4~ ) ( 1Ffi * J4~). J4~ (~~U. (. ) * J1t(.'~ii) (1Ffi* ( ~~U * J1t(.,Hii ) (~ft * J1t(.'~ii) ( J1t 1L.'itii ). xl=~mTlI(fifiTlI) X2=¥~IIIi:(fifi¥~). J1t(.,Hii). 3.364 3.840 107.621 107.630 7.197 7.243 46.563 46.864 2.249 3.701 64.304 66.941 1.587 1.892 98.142 98.385 6.045 6 783 119.064 119.123 .300 .731 77.787 79.243 7.960 11.613 114.009 119.474 .152 .445 26.277 27.251 4.318 6.961 72.334 76.066. X6 .~Rt.(fiYfi.~) x 7 =81i1i1HI ( fifim.). x 3 =/m.rdlmJl (flfim.it). X8=J4M:~tt(.fiJ4ti). X4=J:a!.#1:(fiYfi.~) X5= • • • ~(fiYfi• • ). x 9 =J1t(.,.m (fiYfitUl). p .499 .698 .000 .000 .126 .299 .000 .000 .690 .717 .000 .000 .452 .929 .000 .000 .196 .341 .000 .000 .990 .994 .000. .000 .093 .071 .000. .000 .927 .931 .000 .000 .3&5 .224 .000. ·000.

(26) 26. ltJ;;LSrIfff N. % N. % N. %. fJ. lttUu~. 12 12.12. 20 20.20. 67 67.68. 100. 6 18.18. 1 3.03. 26 78.7. 33 100. 53 82.81. 5 7.81. 6 9.38. 99. 64 100. ;@ru~~_~~~~,~~z~.~~~~~~~~~m~~noolt~~U~fffo (::)Jt~ ~ tUft Z;«ti;:. :. m~28m~'m~~_~~~~~Z~~'~.~~~~Z~~~Mlt~~~~ ;ooru~~.~~~~~Z~~·fl42%ZA~~~~~~.~~·fl35%Z~~~ ~lt~~8rifffo. ltU~fff. 31 31.31. 59 59.60. 99 100. 9 27.27. 3 9.09. 21 63.63. 33 100. 23 35.94. 27 42.19. 14 21.88. 64 100. % N. %. %. lttl. 6fr~. 9 9.09. N. N. fJ. (Ii)tf~ • • ~:. 1::1 ~fff ;. (:3J4'~~Ih'~IIZ;«ti;: ru~29 m~·~~~m~~.~~~,~ru~~_~~~,~~Z~OO~.~~. ~~~~~~~Z~*lt~~6fr~~o ~Jt ~~ 1: B!t!1IiUi\ Z;fjJi£. EB~. 30 m~, J1'ilIfB~~~~~ ~ M.~~~~~~ • ~~~.~OO~iJg~afl:ltilj~ ~~~~~~~~~J:~~.ltU6fr.aoOO.*oo~~~~Z~~,~*.~mw~ ~~~~1:~~.ltU6fr~o. m~ 31 m~. OOEB~l.

(27) ffi~~~~qwm~~~~fl~~fimz~'. ~. tif~tA frItEf. ~. ~~~8iJi~~~~.at.~~Z~.~~~. 29. •. ~1I!fr3i if~. :tc~. :!13~. 0. ~30. if 35 %Z~UjJjtjg. if~. :tc~. !J}~. % N. % N. %. ~~~. 17 17.17. 37 37.37. 45 45.45. 99 100. 16 50.00. 9 28.13. 7 21.88. 32 100. 49 76.56. 10 15.63. 5 7.81. 64 100. ~~1lk8iJi~~~~~.~at.~~Z~.~~~. N. % N. % N. %. •. -. .LttAfrI~. 21 21.21. 22 22.22. 24 77.42. 7 22.58. 0 0. 31 100. 33 51.56. 30 46.88. 1 1.56. 64 100. 56 56.56. 99 100. (1i)~. tAUIUI:1J iifi Z ~$. ru~31~~·ru!J}~_.m!J}:tcif~~1lk8iJi·~.:I$}~~~~Km • • ~:1Jiifi.Lt tAootEf;Wru:tc~M~m!J}:tc-fr~~~~·~~*OO~!J}:tcif~~~~·¢.:I$}~~~ ~31. ~~1lk8iJiW~. .LttAOiItEf. :: 1lk 8iJi ~ It:l$} tjg. ff:l$} IS mat 1tiIJ m. N. ~.1.Jl. ~ ~lft.Lt if ~ frI ~. 27. if~. :tc~. ;¢lt1lk gilHill~ !J}~. N. % N. 20 2020 9. %. 27.27. N. 59 92.19. %. •• ~at.~~Z~.~~~. •. -. .LttAfrI~. 26 26.26. 53 53.54. 99 100. 1 3.03. 23 69.70. 33 100. 1 1.56. 64 100. 4. 6.25.

(28) 28. ~tE~~f{UI15im.lttl1W~. 0. ~ft¥~~.15imZ~$. m~32~~·m~~_.~~~~~Z~~·~*.~~~~~~~.W*~~ 1W-.·$~~%Z~~~~¥~~¥~~ • .Ittl1W.$om~~_~~~~~Z~~. '~56%~A~~~~~.Wtl1W-.·@$~~21%Z~~~~~~~~ •. .Ittl1W. .$.&.It1W~$o. •. $. -. •. ~. $. % 11.22. 20 20.41. 67 68.37. N. 7 21.88 %. 18 56.25. 7 21.88. 28 % 43.75. 32 50.00. 4 6.25. N. 11. N. (Bft!JIili1lt@J15imZ~$. m~33~~·m~~_~~~~~Z~~·~~~~~tE@J~1lt@J15oo~£~~. ;m~~_.~~~~.·~~~%Z=Z~~~~tE~~1lt~~.~.o. ~. 33 tl<~£. -. •. tl<mM. 6 6.06. 18 18.18. 75 75.76. 7 % 21.88. 1 3.12. 24 75.00. 41 % 68.33. 15 25.00. 4 6.67. N. % N. N. 99. 100 32 100. 60. **~J:~if~. 100. 1. ''-I')!i~~~ii ~tt1500 Z~l':E. m~M~~$·m~~_.~~~~·&m~~.~~~~~Z~IiIi·~~~~. /f\ IijJ '" ~ Z ~. 1l~~~7j~. 2. /f\1ijJ~mzlJ.

(29) ffi~~~~~~~~~~~~~~rr~z~.. ~34. ~~~Sffi~lJ!~~fi~tt~.~~z~.~. lEHlUg.. :~L'til ~.:fO*fl-13(. :~ ~}ltr fl-13(2 ~Sffi lJ!~L'til~.1tt.AFlfj. ~. 29. 1fiI. fl-13(. 44 % 44.44. :k~. 24 % 72.73. ~~. 52 % 82.54. ~. 55 55.56. N. N. 99. 100 33. 9. 27.27. N. 100. 63. 11. 17.46. 100. ~ .... ~~·~~fl~~~ttfl~lE.L'til~.o W~.6~~Jiooz~m. ru~35~.M·ru~~~.~~:kfl-~z~.~Sffio:J$]~~~.~.fl~~fllE ®L'til~.;ru:k~~~~:kfl-~Z~Sffi·~fl=~Z=L'tilA~~~.~.~~~fllEOO ~.·@~fl=~z-L'tilA~~fl~OO~.o ~35. lEoo~.. ~13.. fl-~. 21 % 21.21. 21 21.21. :k~. 21 63.64 %. 2 6.06. ~~. 52 % 83.87. 3 4.84. ;$Jioo~£m:~. .0. ~~~Sffifl~~.6~~~.~~Z~.~. N. N. N. 1\iii~. -. I I i. 57 57.58. 99. 100. 10 30.30. 100. 7 11.29. 62 100. 33. -. ffi,tf• • • • ~fl-£~m~~*·*m~z~m~:. 1.. /F/i'U~~z~~L'til~fI('H~~Ilfl~~. 0. t.A:k~~±.Z~~L'til~~. • ;tt~flf;Ig.~. Il:J$]~~~~m~'mt.A~~~±.z~~L'til~~·;tt~flf;Ig.~Il:J$]~~o. Sffi.:J$]~~fl-. 2. /F/i'U~mz~~L'til~flf;Ig~~Ilfl~~o-~m~~L'til~flf;Ig~~Il~~=~m~.

(30) 30. 1. E~.~Ii'sJ~. o. ~%~Jt.~. ~ ~~.~.Z.~~~~~~~.~.~,n.~.~.~~~~m.fi.~M~. ~~m±z~. .~.~.~o. :p.~~. 4. ~~.~'~~~~'~~.~.Z.~~~~~.~~L.~li~fflo. 5. ~~.~z.~~~~mA~. •• ~L~.~,~~~m±z.~~.~&~~~. ~~~~z.~~~~mA~. •• ~L~.~'=~~.~~~~~~~B-mA. ~~*. ~~.~.Z.~~~~.A~. *fi. mM~lIM4. •• ~L~.~,n.~.~.~~~.~.~.. ~Z~"~4. ~~~~~~B-mA.~~~'.4A~~m~o. 3. E~.~~1. &. ~~.~'~~~~'~~.~.Z.~~~~.~L.~li~fflo. ~. ~~.~'~~~~'~~.~.Z.~~~E~.L~.~'~~~li~fflo. ~., ~{tR1. E~.. *~~~.H & 0 *~~~. •• '~.~.'OO.H:.~B_.m~H:.~.'=~~.~~•• 'iI.§i. M~~m.r. 10. • H:.~~=~~.~.ft-~~.~~~i\l~Jt~~r~IIH.!Hm, iI.~§i/nJ "k~~~.~JlU:ll!-~~.ft=~~~~i\l~Jt~.rJHlfHt!. 'iI.~§i/nJ ~. 0. .ft~~~~'. .~~~~m~o ~. 0. 2 E~.~:ll!1. ~Z.~~~~~~~~-MA.~~~~m~o. ~. 1i~H:BU. 0. '. m~. ••~.'m~n.~•• 'OO~~0m.H:.~.'-~~ .~~~~~Mm~ •• ' •• ~.~~-~~.~~ •• 'iI.~.o. rJ:l flj J! 111l ~J. 11. £t!~~-~~;lf, Jim~"k~m±~.t!i, .~~~~rJ:li!~~M~~~m±~.. &~~1iiiH. •. ~. ~~~.~.. /nJfiM-~~.~~. ~'~~~~$~.~'X.~~~~~.Mi!ma~o~.~*x=.~. • '. , ~1-' ' IJ.J~. ~:ll!~*~~~~~Z.~'~~*~.H:.~,.*_.m~H:.~z.~,x Jt.~~m.,&Jt~*~~~~.'~i\lM-~~.zm.~.o~~~~~~. it~:. ~~~. ••. ~~11~03. M-.~.zm.~.o~~~~m±~.~·~.~*X=~R.·XJt~~~. ~lft~rJ1i!!. .L'~~~m±~.~,&~~~~z.~,x=.~.zJt~~~ma~. , ~~:. ~.~.&~fiM-~~.Z~a~.o. a. ~MIJ.J:. £t!~~-~~.'Dm~~~m±z.~,.~Z~~~~.~~.~~.~~~. ~.mM,m*A_~~.'~~W~.~'=~B.~~~~~.mM.*i\lM -~~.z~lii.m·M; m=~m.zEl~~~. II ~~~~gA~~~~Z~~'. • .Ru.lt-~m.z~~~:iE~~. 0. •• ilA~g.~.~~aT~'L •• ~'.~. 4. . li ~ £t!~1iJf. MX-~~I. H:~fPj~~'. ¥H:m±, .. ~.,.~~~~tt~~~~,Jt.~~~~~ttOO~.;~~~~~gm~"k~. ~~~1i~. ••~.'.~.B •• ~.'~~.. 5. E~lkiliZ. ~~ti~'~.ilm~~m~~.'.~~. aT~,m.~~~~~~tt.ft~~.~'L. ~L~~~~~~~. •• ~~.~o. •• ·~~~~~%~Jt.~Z~.'~~~~~~.*~:. !I~~ttiii. :tIatflJt¥.

(31) m~tt~~M~~~tt.~~.~fi~Z~.. 31. 1. ttit.J.lJ~B'sJ~.~fr5m:lif~'~lJ~m~\3t::&"m:lif'?i-~III.~'~3c-€i'~iX~ Im:lif~Jj£iWi~78.. 3c~~!tlJ~I'J'g~.~*om~*~~~m'~~~ •• ~~iX~ •• ~~'~t.J. 3c~~:±.zlJ~¥~.z~.m~~mft~,jJjjt.J.~~~:±.zlJ~lJ~.zm.~m~. [f'F ffl 0 ~ B'sJ lJ~.& Y3 3c -€i'. ~'~~~3c-€i'~iX~~!tlJ~.zrr~m.~~.Iff;ff~.ojJjj~.B'sJ:±~~~~. tI§ ~ 11: 7Jd 0 2 ttit.J.lJ~~e*.4~~'EJ~~~B'sJmA~~~'~3c-€i'~iX~~!tlJ~.z~.. Ii f.Jl B'sJ EJ a -1il A. ~~*0*~~~m,;{E.~~~~'t.J.3c~~:±.zlJ~~~'.&~3c-€i'~.zlJ~ ~~~~:fjj!'(~I'J'gEJ?Xm~l'J'gm~;m.lit.J. •• ~~~'-€i'~~'~~lJ~B'sJ~~. :: t( 78.~ if:LIt B'sJ ~. m~~.~-€i'~w'lit.J.3c~~:±.zlJ~lJ~~~~~0~~~3c-€i'~~e!t~~ ~.z~.~.-~11:o~~:fjjt~~~~.~mA~.o. 1. 1 .lit.J.lJ~~e*~~mjJjjjg.'~.~?i-;{E~~~,mY33c-€i'~.e!tlJ~* ••. 0. :fj3C1f.f'Ffflo .B'sJfJrtiJ,mY3 B'sJfJrtiJo.lit.J.lJ I'J'gjg.'ISMfJ. ~.'li~~IiUif:~:fj~IiU.z~.0*~~~m'~3c-€i'~B'sJlJ~,jt-if:~~~ *:fj~m.jg.l'J'g.rtiJ·m=if:~~,mlff •• fi;mY33e~~I'J'g.~·m.&~. &0*~~~~·. ••~ •• ~I'J'g~.~~~'m~~3c-€i'~lJ~'~X.~'m. ~~.m.~m~~~~~'~lJ~~m\3t::&"~m~,jJjjY33c~~-~~~~~. lJ~~'=if:e. ~~~~ •• ·~~~~~·~~lJ~j!'(~~~~.\~Ml'J'gm~;m*~=if:~. ~Jj£o. ~. l;).Y3~~:±B'sJlJ. &jJjj~tI§oo!tM~·jJjj~~~.om~3c~~.zlJ~,~&~&oNUXlJ~·.Y3. A=if:~~,:If'. 3c-€i'~.~-~:fj.lJ~'3t::&"~~nOOB'sJm.,mm~~3cM*-€i'~'~~~~. '~.zlJ~,jt. 93~. ojJjj;{E?i-~B'sJm. ~~,~~~~*:fj~m.jg.~m~,m*~=if:~~·m~~W~!t~ttl'J'g&. ililB'sJ m~ f!lLIt ~ ~ , jt!t?i-~1'J'g. ,. m~~3c-€i'~. • ~:fjlht.M~11: '. ~ ~.§¥lJ~ttl'J'gltl/JiX8U~.z.*(.\. • jt~3c~ • ~~!T~'H9.:fj~~11:jJjj~~I'J'g:fjlllm. '. ,. ~Dffl§¥lJI'J'g~fi~.. ~~W~~~ff;{E·jJjj~mlJ~~n*m~'M~ •• ~M~·~~~~.~~jt ;{E~~M~x,:fj~~I'J'g~fi~~.·jJjj~~~~~jg.~m~o~~·ttit.J.~.. ~~'t.J.~3c-€i'~.zn~'!t.~.z?i-;{E~~~:fj~~o. li t(.~ ~JPf\. ~ ttit.J.~~~~~,.~~m~~w~.~,~.~*x_if:e~,jtjg.f!lLft~~. ~m~lff;ff ~~. ~jt-if:~~.zjg.Lftom*~~~~• • ~.m~~~~'~~.~m~~*.. 1?X1!HE!!~. ttl'J'g~~afi:~~Y33c-€i'~~,jt=if:~.z.~mOO!t.zafi:~M~*'OO~~~~t.J.. 0. :IJUU,t ' ~ ifI :afi: 1fifJ ~ J] 3c -€i' :.~ , j!'(:If'~. .tt~:±'li.~§~.~~78.if:.I'J'g-if:~lJ~,jJjj#78.~if:Lft~=if:elJ~'. ~~~.M*~~~x~'~3c-€i'~I'J'g=if:e:fjj!'(&~~~mM~~0 ~ ttit.J.~~.z.§~'mY3~afi:~Y33c-€i'~,~~!t~~T~iX.~.z~~,.~~ ~~:fj~oo~.omm3c~afi:~933c-€i'~,;{ET~xOO:fj~~~~OO~.;L~~. IiU1!LIt*il:. .afi:.!tlJ~lJ~.It.z~.JtU~~OOIff. 0 WOO.z16:!JJ1:~Dale 'Feather. ~A.z.

(32) 32 fi~M~.~·m~~.~ftft~~.~.~.d'fi~~.~D~om~ •• ~. ..'. ~.·*fi~MmB.~~I~~.A~M~oft.~~.~~M~~:-~. Coleman, Hamilton (I985~fflWl~.~ ••~.~~f(~. m*fi~~tx. •• ~.;~-M~~~.~*fi~fflm~ft~~·~m~ftft~. m~ft~m~.~,mE~~~ftft~~,~~~ftftm~.~,~ft~.~ ••. fiffl~~~.~. ~~.~~If\II'!J~M~o. vlause. J(l. , ~il~*.tt.~.~Zjf*4 ' ~~1Ij1j.!ltt.~-~~ ~.,mB.~.*~~!ltt.~.'W~~.~.tt.~.~ •• ~B8~. !ltt.~.~~~~~~,.~ •••• tt.~~~tt.~~.~~~.o ~fi~~~~fi.~' •• ~tt~tt~ft-~.o~.*if~*~tt~ft-~.~. (lHtIU'WliH~JtJj~if~. ~~fi·~ft.~~.IDM~~~.~o ~~.~~.~~.~~.'~~~II'!J~m~~~. •• ~~.~ •• ,~ •• ~ft. Trcmsition multiple D: E ducatiaw.. Dale, R.R .(1974. Lee V.R.S. Bl. achievemel. ~.o. ~~~~ftft~(m).~~tt~~@,.~~. •• ~~.o. ~~.~~ftft~'~ft~~~m_. •• ~~~~~.~~OO.~~~.,m~ftft~.~, ~~~~~*oo~~m.~'m~~~~~.~'~~~~~~~~~ •• ·m~ ftft~.~~.~~fi.~.&~~~ •• OO.~.·~ftm ••~~~~~~· ~.*if~B.~ftft~. ... .fi.~~.~.~~~. ... tt.a~~m.~~·A.~~~~='~~~~~. .~~~tt·tt.a~~~~~If\~.~MB;~~~ftft~· ~~~.~Ij~. •• ~-~~~.. o. ~68~ 10 fj9 B. ~~. ' ~ 77 ~ 10 fj 7. il'=ftffi,BOFJ • (. Herbert, W. Mt:. overview.. •• (~)~~.o. W~~~W~ftft~Aftm,~ftft~m~ft~m&~ft~~.If\~~~~.~~. •.. Feather, N. T . (. Johes, J. C., f. H~.#ifi~J:~m.. *~~. Coleman ,J .S. (U. of Educati. ~ftL~~B.~~~'*fi~~W~~~m.:. ft~~~~~.~. • 21. B. ~ 77 ~) ,. il'=ftffi_..11-fi •. 37 ~ '26. ~~~'~OO~.(~6B)·~~~ftftm~.~. J1J • ]{ 1904 -. 1908. •• &fi.~.~.~if~o~.ft.

(33) m.~~~Q~~~~~~~~~IT~Z~.. :ff 1!1J ~ 0 lID Jt Rlt 'tz. im1JJJM!1ZSj : -~ it.'fi'ii*1if~~~ ~~ , ~:f~~Jrii-8C :I:: ' IZSj 1It It ~ §: RltM. ff'. 33. 21 ~. 11t1J ' p.12-23.. fI*7.r .. Jlil~1MI ( .&: 78)'. 913r~m:ltlJ§:~.Z1if~. • #::jtlll~tlLlYUI~~1if~fif!r •. :5KtI:lIl& 0 Coleman ,J .S. (1961) The Adolescent Society, N.Y.: Fleepress. Feather, N .T.(1974). Coeducation, Values, and satistaction with school Joumal of Educatimal psychloogy, 66,317-319.. Johes, J.C., Shallcross, J., Deanis, C.L.(1972) Coeducation and adcelescent. ti~~M:~8C-~1Ii;l. ~ §:!fij. mH: B 1& 1tIJ ~. vlause. Jcumal of EdJ.ooticnal psychology, 63, 334-341. Herbert. W. Marsh. Ian D. Smith, Margaret Marsh and Lee Owens( 1988) The. f~§:Z~.o. Trcmsition from. Single sex to coeabicoitional High schools:. Affects on. ~ It M: )]11 1It -1ZSj ~ 1111. multiple Dimersiors of self-concept and on Academic AefiovemEn t, AmErican Educatimal Resm.rch TOWlal, 25(2). pp.237-269.. RltM ' tl11P:M~Jr. Dale,R.R.(1974) Mixed or Single-sel: schoo? Vol III AtlailmEnt, atlitude and overview. London: Routledge. ;if' (ijJ M: iR It ~ §: Z. &. Regan Paul.. Lee V.R.& Bryk A. S. (1986) Effects of Single-sex secondry schools on student achievement and attitudes. Jcumal cf EdJ.catimal psyclmogy. 78, 381-395.. ( *)(f'F~#$6~ff.£*~'L'~Q1f~m#j:li • ~.JjJj;!£*~'L'~~~!W ). !O ~ Jr -€; &.!J! §: , ~fttIDm.'lID~. l8Clitf5t8C1tIl ' .. =:.iFi& 71,;( U.!t-iFi&tID~. - 1908. ;G1if~oll.~.

(34)