以解釋本質探討中學演化論之教科書內容與教學

全文

(1). .

(2)

(3) !"#$%&"# '

(4) () *+,"-.*/ 0 12345678 "# 9:; &< =>? @ AB;CD:>

(5)

(6) EFGHIJ K

(7) L:>MNO @P &QR:>

(8) STUVW>? XYZ[\]^ _`,7a;GDbc:>

(9) d;GZef gh ijkl&mgh neopqr%KstuvE @ ;GDwxy

(10) :>

(11) z{ |}~:>M z{ UVWRef&m KneY ]d|}~aS UVWRx& ij z{KeP]d|}~

(12) 83

(13) NMNOF. I UVWR&K&.

(14) % "#&." D4 ¡F¢

(15) ST d£:>

(16) z { G¤2"¥ ¦§ ëzL ©ª«¬p ey®¯°H}GK ±J². 1.

(17) ³´µ ¶·¸VAB¨FN ¬p ¹ºs"°RK

(18) ±J »¼½ V>. ¾¹ºs¿|ÀRÁÂsÃ6 ¨ÄxÅ. dÆ¦Ç 4

(19) ÈÉ©Ê¾Ke ËÌ ÍÎ¹ºs ÏÐÑ_Ò J £GmÓÔ=6 ¬p ¹ºsÕÖR×EØÙ©x¾K ÚÛ zÅÆ¦ÇÜÝÞß M±J@ÜÝÞßàár%Eâ ãY ÜÝÞßäåy

(20) æç9èéêë

(21) À±J ±J6 ìíî íï~"ð de"# ñ4¶·E ò._±J6 56 óÀÛz´ô"õö÷ø=~ùúb Ã6±J 6ûü ñ4d¨Výþó RÁÂ_R ÁÂsEîGþó Äx Äx ,

(22) ü UVWChi a GP6 E MRÁÂs¹ºs:>öP = >P 8ì¹ºs¤Pþ å@íî ö

(23) IÑ Chi 2005 M. !

(24) f 5 "AB;GZ#y¿$K. ±J6 ìíî å@% ¿$&

(25) ST Chi DSæ ' () M_±J

(26) *_+k

(27) ST

(28) ST > =¸¬p ¹ºs

(29) STD, å&Ädìíî ® 8 -./0 1 ¬p ¹ºs2 RÁÂ9

(30) À±J =ÜÝÞß s345À¹ºsÑ_ÒJ :6Waldrop 1992 AB;Gs¹ºsã 2.

(31) ÜÝÞßä¨Ò7Ex8¹º. 89èést±J

(32) . ½

(33) :; 3´Ç#@÷ø8 d£ MNO÷øÜÝÞß ä<@:

(34) ½.;G=´>?@.A=´ BC.£; G ?D.;G=´ E9êëFG±J AB:H

(35) I" °À?D: J®8ý? 8 . !

(36) ST,ÜÝÞßäK@¿$ GC.L¾M,@ N K 5ì±J íî E/0

(37) O±J6 "¤ "°¨zL PIz{QR.±J"DÚSòT.U9VW XY Zà G¤[· #\]F^R_Dà k §ðG¤ ¼bcádGst. . .

(38) Waldrop 1992.

(39) '

(40) ()*+.ee;/ 0 34

(41) daSf+_2ge. 3h,Oi4[· jQRa&k [·@l¦.

(42) UVW `m[Ó'AnoKp( CqÇDÚrstuvW '! 3.

(43) wxyK ( ð 'K ( å<z |p l6`m :}½. v{ ½dy

(44) d;. `m)~7 +. 9Eâ .¯. E

(45) Ç:l6 =34@9: ð9 ð9 _

(46) > d¨ . UVW¨.« _0 rl al6_s, ¹ ¨!l6_)s¤ijO KC :C:l6 =]=´#@%

(47) ?¨ mäâ ,Å\[· k v{8 M

(48). ¿¡_K¢8£W l6¤h v G¤ 9d¥Ø¦

(49) d".:;&< 0 "¨,> 5. Ó8p K§¨K¢$% [·"#z

(50) 8 z [·

(51) 8¨"-¨FD0. '

(52) (©Dª42« "# ªHorwood 1988 Unsworth 2001 ¡'

(53) ( ^R "#¢¬®¯ $% UVW 5"°¨ Vý

(54) V°±VýH&²³f 7àá? !#@K a$AB

(55) AB;CD:> õ ´åy:>õ´ ´ÇÄx8£ ÷ø µ¶ z z . 8£µ¶ô"ðõöð·¬ð*:ð@ð¸¹ ÷øº» 1998 1999 2000 D¼½\åÚz 8£ ¾¿! ÀÁ 9"ABõ´.

(56) Cý?Dy

(57) æçDO £F¢ '

(58) ( UVW 'ÂÃ( ð 4.

(59) '( ð 'ÄO( ð 'm(4¤h

(60) KÅ2ÆÇJÈoA É'

(61) (? '

(62) (yÊv0ZAchinstein 1988

(63) $ÇËq

(64) 9dVW stÌ8 å@Z%>p¤@ñPK@ÍP ñ PÎ

(65)

(66) UVW 'Ï( ð '"°%( ÍPEÐ

(67). V'°±ýH?( #[·&Ëq

(68) @P V' ( ð 'ÑÒ"° "( .Ó ÔÕ }Ö70 1-1-1 F×

(69) ¨

(70) p Ø>pÙÁK@ÍP ÙÁ f #ÙÁËq ÚÛV O

(71) ¾¿ÙÁf =:Ü=´

(72) Ú Û CÝÞ

(73) åy

(74) ; 8\H9ç¦.

(75) ßD;àDxáaâ Vã8ä å§6æp ç7\ iD@èaâ j»TU Gl6qé 3h9ÙÁp CÝ# Þ

(76) åy

(77) ¾¿iêë:l6qé 3h úì:6íUVW '% ÇK( rs$`m

(78) 'wxîK(&'ïK (. 5.

(79) 1-1-1. E P A

(80) . ½*

(81) :C*$åKðñ 12"¨$

(82) p ò: ;èó:ê ÚÛ d:èóô_ FGÝ

(83) H] ¨ ,l6Eõ öõ ¨7'

(84) IZ ¼b( e_2÷

(85) Ý óÀ"¨¶ø\^R ùxst&ú°E\ d;"° ûuüý s "° û &"°P)À$Òµ¶", st 8=

(86) Ý8"° ÷þ óÀf ÙÁ:IE \ C8P)ÙÁÇh "B G¤"& Û = D:> ÷þK ãY;W¨>¾M :> D:>

(87) ÝÙÁÇ&f &¨:>¾M > > CD:>

(88) ÝÍ¾ÙÁ O d;W¨>¾M > 6.

(89) > D:>

(90) Ý;K"°P)ª" &# ÑÒ O 8

(91) Ó8"-¨*/ 0 %@"#% N" $% ." 'Vý.9.

(92) . ?( ü· =v D. ñ·W 'L@ 9.

(93) p á

(94) Àö?(!_;G. ¡ x _ºa_ghe .. ¢³´Æ ¶·W±J6" % 5ü· 5ý¢±J6 9

(95) G¤ $_y

(96) P 8îG=´#y9ç.

(97) P. . Ç

(98) C~ ðËq

(99) MNO =DFIZ =£K¾xK6.ò 5 Ñ.H &^:Ùëd: ÙÁMNO '

(100) (2 dBDÄxy:> ST µ¶¨ k§ \ G¤¨" k§\UVWSalmon1998Óy

(101) W !ðàáðÃ G¤Éyz

(102) Horwood1988"R

(103) G¤R

(104) G¤x"#".^R

(105) G¤ z

(106) Dagher & Cossman 1992 Talanquer 2007 Treagust & Harrison. 7.

(107) 2000 Treagust & Mamiala 2003 ¨ÁpõÑÒåÚ

(108) STò. >p d: À¡Vý.åÚÔ_

(109) ST ,k§ R¨" #.VYi".&"°.^RÀÚ

(110) ST å_\LF B z$ DãYVYZÊvEð 5" °Vý

(111) å_ÞßÃÊv dDÄxa0ÀåzL ¨6·7. ! 2 ZN6 5e ðJð. eÓ@ "°¨

(112) pC^Rýy

(113) ST ="3C ^Rýy

(114) ST "°" "ZÚÛý?="¨56"

(115) p

(116) ST IZ3Vý?úìI76#$° âE0 5 ½ ÑÚ % 5Eâ &ñ·îGb¯ óÀ _'(ë e ðJEzkFE\ _"°F ) dHDZ

(117) S TK ÏÐiDÁ =:Ç9DsÓð*H +_>p _,-^p./mF012"3F. 'e(¶ H¶ø.FÑÒ °4. D±JDÔ ¨¶ø. 56. d*¤±J¨5 \¶. 0ÏÇÀ@6b À [· d*Hå76 8E gsW '8"°¨BD. ÷ UVú@Óe"°.ÇWF8. 9 :;8:3^R =ÂJ 7<:9(å@"° f= "ZDÓ@ "°¦ íÀ>?Ùåy±J

(118) :(>¨_"°. úìÏ 8.

(119) µ¶a¨ "pd**Rs VYåysí? Jý ÅB4R?åys ¨¨?Ó¦ CÐF@) =¥ 6{

(120) Àö>?Eâ ¾è /~IåÚ[· 5 6 :Ñ²7A 8¨åÚ[·p ñ4¨B$~CF. 6z$=¨®D 6z$´Dâ =É)Ï ü F6 ñ ·G`HIJ 9âºkÀ@a²F. ñ· d£±J6 5

(121) ST_±J6"&"° PI DF*×?83JÀ¡À 'F89ý<:( "°

(122) DZ Salmon

(123) STK åy Ã

(124) _

(125) ½ýCÐM'RÁÂs(?","° ýãRåys?Vý´Çåy

(126) *: ÷ø? 8'RÁÂ s(KyÃ

(127) =KD$_^RÃ

(128) )L

(129) À ~?åÚj76 ª1E.

(130) ë. . ±J6²9´MghÆ¦ s¬p ¹º. NOÇPQð RSC úì;GRÇ aS ìT0 UV 2006Campbell 1960Hull 1988Toulmin 1972 =¨"#. . V>6WÙT ò 5.E x¾KDxÇ,x7 ¨ 5±J6Ô ì¨åÚ. ñ4 5ñ·DÙWõö[·. 9.

(131) &ô"õö±J6 ÷øÙ

(132) Àö 12mX. 6 ŸZ !_Ûzô" ÷øE: 8±J6" [.¨V ý\]¤^_.îGþó E¿|G¬p ¹ºs 6 µ¶D ."°G ¨±J6Ô ". D7 Michellene Chi ` %aFerrari & Chi 1998 b§ Chi Ø¾K H7T./0GP6

(133) ì íî gBM¹ºs_H`â!FE 'c8Y(P .£d '²=8Y(_:>P !_Pþ íî 8 ¨ì¬p±J6pHÀíîHDw: ãYe ½f&F± Jå@¤ghðiðjkIü· ÜÝö Rc8YÍ¾ àá sK

(134) æç: èO p &/0k§ý¢àá ¡ Chi F¢. 'c8Y('²=8Y(KyàáÇlDý:>?¨ÑÒò. _'àá( 5â H'àá(;Gk§7

(135) yST À9mlÀ 'àá( æçNný¢

(136) _3ÀCwpõÑ Òé '

(137) ('àá( Ôò½¨FÑÒ Gñ4Ô oû T¨ óÀû»E\ E'c(D xst_]G'c ( ð’emergent’Ôoû 3p[é ÑÒÀÚò .FãY H}7 7Tqrs & tuv 2007 ÑåÚò 5Ñâ M¬p wûâ> ¹ºs 10.

(138) :6Góx

(139) ±J ãY9±JèO

(140) 6 Ù ©«y!% c&ÜÝÞß

(141) ä åyF¢ ÜÝÞßäGéP6 ä1Kz :>_hßJ+6G ð® { 78 'ÜÝ(Kû7|} % gh Å. ^RÜÝÞßK

(142) Äx. UVWÂ~ Ið ð R ð,m ÓÔ¤±J½ ÜÝÞßäæç¨"° ¶. 6¿|¹ºs7±J. 9

(143) VYe"°DÔ±J TG¤" " ¯ÜÝÞß ä ;GD

(144) ì±J6?åÚ-64 z$ E. !"#$% "°:("¨"p dN ñ4KÔÄ 1997Aleixandre 1994 "°N KÔ¤ì $ " L:> xèB"° ÷þ "3¶÷þ"°÷ : & ª 1995 ;G k ^" "M,ð ^R "PM, ½"÷þ:C*"°÷þÑuvE D "#$%4

(145) ö ì

(146) O

(147) z Z"° ~ E "° !G÷þñ Ø¾!DÄxZÊv . 11.

(148) ¯ 12GÞßÃÊvK"°¡¢ 2006 £¤¥ 2004 Unsworth 1997 2001 :Ñ dDáÄQ¯2gÆgh 6 G !"° P)¦9x§ üUVW0UV2006GeÞß ±J6,ì ¨© QRª"°«÷þ PIz{ ¦ ü3V¬®2002!Gâ|J KäG"° ¸¹" ÷øHC÷"° Ô.¯æç 5¶.. '

(149) ( = \ "° ñ4$%Ej¨

(150) Ó8 8 Q¯,MN '

(151) ( ð 'Ó8( ð '

(152) ST(. 5, 6 "° PI¦# ü G±J6öU AB 5"°_±J6 PIp &Ä;G° Rö 5±^RÀÚñö¤5ö G¤ö ²ã ³ö0 &Ä-;NÙ¶´4 56:>ìµC "° _±J66 b c½G ±Jy ±Jàást)Lå@HÓ8. y

(153) =åy

(154) _y

(155) STuüýs AB;GZ

(156) f. d£78 ²=ý G¤

(157) ST K 5"° Vý

(158) =D e"°Vý

(159) ±J?AB F

(160) S TR_±J6 "°. åyRDýY?åd7 1E. 12.

(161) &'( ¶F56 Zà ¨. kWÜÝÞßäã¹ºs ±J9

(162) =

(163) ST MD·_¸ê±J àá 8 ãK "&"° .¹!..9

(164) :ÑF¢ 9

(165) :>MNº5 @.BC.. »>?D¼. %MkéP=v 6 6½¾ V0 1-1-2 F×W. 1-1-2. . 13.

(166) .

(167) . \ Zà 6 ñ4 W¿

(168) ST,ÜÝÞß ä ¯.±J6","° PI ±J6ì ÷ø ÀGÇ *× Á.±J" 7 3;W7Â@ ¤ åÚ 4 5 ñ4¤W[·V^W. 1ð W8."°»±J6 ¸÷þ ÀÀ D"°.Ô_±J6öPI VWÚÛðd.±J ö

(169) À78¦xÚNÙLðd"° PID fSò . D."°_±J6ö ¸÷þ0 ¡. [·'0"°_±J6ö »ý?( ¨[·^D@W[·. 10"°_±J6ö »ý?. 1-1."°_±Jàá

(170) ,>?. 1-2."°_±J

(171) ³ÚST?. 1-3."°_±J6 Ã *_+k

(172) ST?. 1-4."°_±J6 Ã ¤ÜÝÞßä 41?. 14.

(173) 2ð ÙWG

(174) STºL 5±J6 #Dö D _Äxe"#GRÁÂs ~ &MN Chi aGc²=8YP îGþ K

(175) ì±J6 íî #ÄÅÆ Z

(176) ST K 5±J6

(177) Àö±J@ å@ ;GRºL Ã

(178) d;R7%RPºL àá

(179) K st K

(180) ?R )L

(181) Àö Hè7. DG^K@ñ4[· 2.WÙ@[·3;7K@W[·W. 2-1G

(182) STäG±J6 ;G7Úº5:> #D&ö?. 2-2. ±J6ö Ç

(183) STÔ È?. 2-2-1¨±J]} _±J

(184) *_+k.

(185) ST?. 2-2-2¨±J]}: _±J

(186) *_ +k

(187) ST?. 3ð ÓWGÜÝÞßäL 5±J6 #Dö ò9Ø òMÜÝÞß;G45¹ºs _±J¦.

(188) 8 D ¹ºs DÚ:6Ee?½D "° DÆ¦ ÇL>?=@.±J

(189) Àö 78 jK_"° ÒJ. 15.

(190) ¬7 DG^K@[·W. 3-1DGÜÝÞßäÉäE ±J6 fý?. 3-2._±J

(191) ¤ÜÝÞßä 41?. 3-2-1¨±J]} DÜÝÞß äö?. 3-2-2¨±J]}: DÜÝÞß äö?. 4ð -W 5.M

(192) STp _±J6ì ÷ø ¶ Ù ABÀ D;C82K*:

(193) ST = ±J6D

(194) Àöp AB;G=^;G 5D"¦Ç

(195) ST S p _±J6ì ÷øÀ Î G^. [·W 4-1C.L¾M Ñ

(196) ST¯±J "â ±JöDýIJ? Ñ

(197) ST¯±J " _±J

(198) ý?. 4-1-1. 4-1-2. Ñ

(199) ST¯±J "â _±J

(200) ý?. 4-1-3 Ñ

(201) ST¯±J "â ¨±J] 7Ê\ ? 4-2@ Ñ

(202) ST¯±J "â ±JöDýIJ?. 4-2-1. Ñ

(203) ST¯±J " _±J

(204) ý?. 16.

(205) 4-2-2. Ñ

(206) ST¯±J "â _±J

(207) ý?. 4-2-3 Ñ

(208) ST¯±J "â ¨±J] 7Ê\ ?. 4-3C.L¾M,@¨"ðâ Ë,ý?. 5ð ÌW 5ÜÝÞßä¯±J" _.±J6ì ÷ ø ¶ Ó VY

(209) Àö ÍDKD"°_±J

(210) :6 Jo

(211) z .ÜÝÞß

(212) z ¯D" °_±JÓ8

(213) EÀ V¦D·_±J ìè7. DG^ [·34 5W 5-1C.L¾M ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ±JöDýIJ? ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J" _±J

(214) ý?. 5-1-1. 5-1-2. ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â _±J

(215) ý?. 5-1-3 ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ¨±J] 7Ê\ ? 5-2@ ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ±JöDýIJ?. 5-2-1. 5-2-2. ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J" _±J

(216) ý? ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â _±J

(217) ý?. 17.

(218) 5-2-3 ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ¨±J] 7Ê\ ?. 5-3C.L¾M,@¨"ðâ Ë,ý?. 6ð ÂW 5

(219) STÜÝÞßäÎ>¯±J" _. ±J6ì ÷ø . k¨_ÜÝÞßäã¹ºs±J9

(220) =

(221) ST M-D·_¸ê±J àá á

(222) À~ ; 8ã K "&"° .¹!..9

(223) ì_C. &@.ýD?&¯D?D¼ Ï 6-1C.L¾M Ñ

(224) STÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ±J öDýIJ??. 6-1-1. Ñ

(225) STÜÝÞßä¯±J"â _±J

(226) . 6-1-2. Ñ

(227) STÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ¨±J] 7Ê. ý?. \ ? 6-2@ ÑÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ±JöDýIJ??. 6-2-1. Ñ

(228) STÜÝÞßä¯±J"â _±J

(229) . ý?. 18.

(230) 6-2-2. Ñ

(231) STÜÝÞßä¯±J"â ¨±J] 7Ê. \ ?. 6-3C.L¾M,@¨"ðâ Ë,ý?. 19.

(232) . . 1 Ð» k§ fe+D de f ^ @e7å@e =:CÐM2ge ÑÛ @eª 4 k+ÖAudi 1999CÒ 20041Ó 2001 ¨6 Ô 6,ò 5¨ G

(233) STð

(234) zðR K 5

(235) f:Ñ6 %. F¢

(236) f 2 :¨ 5'

(237) ( f 2HÍ s 5'±J6

(238) ( fF¢±J6

(239) f jGÃ,àáKySTK56 dGÄÕ¹ºs ÜÝÞßcðx8 "Z+K56MGåKyK

(240) ±J ;G.±J

(241) :>ºM |}!9:À ±JÇ±J9

(242) . 2 ò 5;N

(243) ;GDÄxST µ¶S2ðÖaJz½D· _

(244) G¤0 2-3-1 F×× My

(245) ST¨.F¢ '

(246) ST¯±J"( ¯±J6

(247) STiDµ¶

(248) . Ã

(249) àá

(250) KS. 20.

(251) 3 Chi x¾K 6¨©WP6 MöD2P .-D~ P KP:>p ì£Híî Ø. ÑØ ö

(252) I. °R Chi ãÀ

(253) ST '

(254) P( à -& ÙyD29

(255) z&ST¨. ±J 9

(256) Ã

(257) =±Jàá 9

(258) x8¹ºàá .C*:+ k

(259) ST¨. kÃ

(260) ½Ã

(261) R ÁÂD}L S2ÔÕ D:

(262) àá

(263) :> !þÚ7

(264) Àö. 4 ÐM

(265) k§ 12 Salmon T¾~%V/ò 5 F¢

(266) k§' 78 st( k§µ¶Ó4£ UV6 % 1¨±J ÙH 78 UV±J 78Ó st UV±J78 steF¢ E çaS.8Y ' ÛÜ ;GDÃð àáð!Óy/^=*/ S2

(267) iÝ·qÀ Ez²=st 78 E:É

(268) 5

(269) functional explanation 21.

(270) F¢Ã

(271) E GðÌðã >¨ 7 Þ~ðß à KstHðã G>¨ !Salmon1998¨7`W 'á ðâ,ãkW

(272) ÚÀ(. + äåÃ

(273) ¨. Ç Måy

(274) ¨Äx UVWeðSCðaSw*/gQ R Uæç ã æçFã ¥%Àè5é¦. 3h åy

(275) 'ã( z jyÃ

(276) Ã

(277) ¨ eÔ"ê.* V'ëìýJo?(2Ã

(278) 'PT :Úí| 8ëìØGÝ·í|( ¨. ° î Salmon / .Ã

(279) ï

(280) Óyñ4STE 6 universal explanation !

(281) 3;7 6

(282) theoretical explanation Salmon1998 #7

(283) 0ðworld picture&ñòäcosmologyåRÞ !klK

(284) Ì :3¤8Yhó UVWR F=ma K

(285) rZ & R PV=nRT K

(286) ôþõH Ì ÚÅ,a$ÒáÅñöW4

(287) @ jFg÷ø¯@ ù{&õöÞßfit it into a pattern or system of beliefsThagard 1992U VW±úl ù{G±úÔF¼

(288) ¢,õöû²¨Ó õöüý~( )F¨ùRÇ4Ð

(289) ¢. dy÷ø z{ UVW

(290) ª4. 22.

(291) **ÀF:> Í¾JKitcher1981 Q Thagard 1992E 6

(292) jµþÀÞR ·¨ùK¦ ÍJµ¶ij,¬pr R2 6

(293) :> !ä1K

(294) :HR±ú&ß#K ¼

(295) Ì =R¨ùF:> ÍJThagard 1992¨ . °î Salmon / .!

(296) ï

(297) Óyñ4STE ½åy

(298) STëgh.wá 7 mechanical explanation F¢àá

(299) E GðÌðã >¨,+Z

(300) # ðã >¨,+ZUV

(301) %Rå@VýH å@

(302) Ç²û pö8Yhó )L9â¥+kef& 8 Salmon 37å y

(303) opening black box ¨ Äxgh UVWfð eðeJ&ñò 46al¦

(304) p 34¦@à á »Machamer 2004 Machamer et al. 2000 Tabery 2004 UVW e.¨

(305) ¥p UVWKPVýð²³fVý7 j GÞàáK

(306) E R Chi àá

(307) 3;G7²=8Yàác8Yà á° Machamer Darden Craver2000 E 7 0+Z =÷ø^70^+Z 9â)L@ H=c. 23.

(308) 8Yàá ¨. .GÜÝÞßäKstE 8 complex system view y% éP6ä1 äå@º5 +Z+ :Í¾RJ+ ! º57 +Z+K'ÜÝÞßF 5 2 . £aB. iÞ,±J6 56 ¨ x¾£¯ ÂIJðÁ

(309) daB¨ÜÝÞßäEj _à 6.ÜÝÞß 5 R¨±J

(310) M:> ÜÝÞß;&x&á ³G^M y+Wxº5multiple level \$¤^$8Yupward and downward causation cemergence éPholistic :;J+ð:;¹] z nonlinearity xª8Y 7"ZÔÕ ª4_7K Zi. ð: äº5DÒÍ ! Ö.ádecentralized A self-organization¸J ÜÝÞßäR¨

(311) 78p ;7c8Y ¨

(312) ST S. ,²=8Y>_

(313) . àá

(314) ²=8YE ;GZ7 +Z+ '67F7 =c8YE Ö²=Z7. +Z,+.'éP 0 d£éP:_E, .F¢ ÜÝÞß¯±J" \i¿RÜÝÞß @+ Wx8"Zxª8Y ðcð:;¹]ðxº5 >piGàáL. 24.

(315) x8"ZL :;¹] %öº5 DÜÝÞß. 9 ¬pey®¯GK :á2±Jàá dG¤5 Q d\| 8)"°F ¹ºs D _¬p ìá£gh ä1K ¬pEêë!|ýyÚAgh G¤gh z {½¨\ I,,º äö"¬p9ª4 # d8"°s t±Jàá ª1°R k§ .¬p¹ºs 417Ì¢W@ Ë ,ð>+O:>ð7Ã«:>ðÚ;ghðË,$|%&Ohlsson 1991NÙÌ41 '÷0"°¶ » Pk ¨"ê >pG'º(Ì( Í&x§ .¹ºs7ÒJ Í8¹º,ÙëÇ x8"Z x8¹º). 10. !"#$. F¢ öºM E ±J6:> .±J 6 7ÓºM DÖ±Jð±J z$ð±J àá Ùº M32¸Í7D*5ºM UVWºM'DÖ±J( ;7'Nn eC±I( ð ':NneC±I( GS' ;.±J6 ! :Nn±J >¨Ç+RÜÝÞß st±Jàá 7ªSE 25.

(316) GKìâ ±J6ö . 11. !"%&'. F¢ öù{0 E GÃ ,0 .±J6: > G³0z{}ÖK 0Gz{ ;:±J 6 Ç¬ýyºM G¤ÙºM ¸Í ;G-. û st À /ÚäGÇ¨ìâ±Jö ¤

(317) I ¨WNð 0T. .VWXYöù{0 ,%z¤P1 U. 26.

(318) . . 2.E¼bcátÍkV^W. 1ð_ò 5. Zk§ðST 5À

(319) f½¨6 %. iZÃ

(320) ðàá

(321) KyST G¤ 9

(322) K±J6"dG 58F¢ '

(323) f( ick¨\ ¼b 2g

(324) ST&

(325) k§ E:µ¶¨ 6 %¼b÷. 2ðñ4¿Y3Fèó.0 Ù4%(D Ó©x` 8F:Ñ'6ìFD@.&C.. 3ðF¢ÜÝÞß¯±J "7 (c_FP, "ê, "{ d(c_±J6ö (c_ÜÝÞß+ ¯E :|}FDÜÝÞß¯Myö " d:|}ÜÝÞßFD+ ¯""ê kCDSæ Y úì:'6ìE\EF D" ^R>Þ"ê D>? Y. 4ðF¢

(326) ST_

(327) Àö78 5 (c_±J6 56 E :|};R_562gMy

(328) Àö 78 5ð¨.F¢ '

(329) ST¯±J"( ¯±J6"

(330) S 27.

(331) T iDµ¶

(332) . Ã

(333) àá

(334) KSE:µ¶ò .F56 !

(335) ðÖaJðS2ððð 2g

(336) ST. 28.

(337) . . Tñ47Ì ÷þL56K¾xK 0ò 5 F7OÑ 8ÜWÙ àá* 9: 12À vk . Chi c8Yàá f=H KSTàá Ôxâ KÀ9À cåyàá Fàá;¨9 ½¾'

(338) ( _*À# \K@gh ÑÒ 5WW

(339)

(340) G¤W-ÜÝÞßä WÓ

(341) àá é (àá,

(342) åKgh%é 2 9â. ÀÙÇ4F- ò 5ãYãÇ"#p kÀ±J6. å@öñ· _è7ÀWÌ±J6Ô"# ò 5G^ X YòÑÒé ÷þ TC_. . C]d¯@aÑÒâ . . .56"#. _

(343) k§R E= 5

(344) k§2¨"#\ rR.

(345) )* '

(346) (a*/_)*+ RÊ. Scriven1988M4

(347) @. 29.

(348) Ì jJvDÔ'Èo(ES [·½ !ÄB. ¨

(349) å¢. 0Zæç:(¨Jv'Èo(. 2gST [·d34

(350) UVW

(351) Vý4%@% àõð

(352) @< û= G¤Jv'Èo(ES [ ·Salmon 1998 i4[· jQRz&k@l¦

(353) 8 >?û»Äudi 1999E'

(354) y0Z À~××y Ìý¤VýH ^ÚI; &ê@ÓK( xÉa

(355) k§'A9êë1( say something more about ½V k§ ;CBC'

(356) (,#ØûW '»( description UVW ò.E"¨^R'

(357) ( ð '»(Kap *DBC&"R UVWHorwood1988QR Bell , Peters «"Í§A§¨ Ç Ó@" W. 1ð

(358) ^ïàWextrinsic donor acceptor doping… 2ð»«¨ n-type è)P h) 3ð»E

(359) ¨ p-n junction . deletion region and junction field ¨ 1 .

(360) ¦§. _k§âL 2ð3 d"ABîGÇl

(361). ,»Dý:>#\ :(e edDSæ UV^ïKüýW 4ð

(362) ^ïàW '®#e(. 30.

(363) 5ð

(364) ^ïDEeFJ z G9HId| >? 4 . '

(365) (2 j'k§( = 5 '

(366) (j¦¸.

(367) ÀHorwood 1988 Horwood QRÀ Bateson1979 stK »,

(368) E:> '»( i¾¿ JK JK,LÔM:èó²=description is purely information and the bits of information are isolated from any network of relatedness ='

(369) (FÚJKdGN²ÓKexplanation is given when connections are drawn between and among pieces of information d£s'

(370) ( j.EkÇmapÇ@8Y ()Þß.!k§ U. Jv'G9(EFG;GDFO ;GÉ%

(371) 8å@

(372) ØNPÇ @8YQW 'e@R S^WTUVWX dÖ. 8 DDFO Y( >?û»Äudi 1999EçFDe;7

(373) ½ ïÆ¦ÇKye

(374) WÌ,aS0Z@ ÌUVW? YZ *4[2Ó8K

(375) å8Y

(376) U8Y

(377) JvÀ'why( ES [· *\K,WÙy

(378) WJv'how(ES [·2âJv Ì'Vý(H i)LÌH Ñ JK» :Ñåy» dCÇ8YÑ ÃAudi 1999 p298 = Horwood ¨2»,

(379) Ë,p !EDpABCR'Èo( 31.

(380) ,'Vý(åKST [·K '

(381) (,'»( UVW '

(382) ()*dS ];DEeFO(G¤'»D^_ ÑD^_+,0 ( ½ ! åyG'Èo(,'Vý(K iC¨ ¾M ¶.DFË @¾M.FR

(383) -&¨Jv'Èo( [·p **j4µ¶ÀÄx÷ àá » UVW¨Jv'neÈo0%R(å[·p ¨C ` i4Jv'8neDàP( ½¨@.µC 4[·l ¦

(384) !Ø¤Ç'à£F

(385) «+,¨«hóQ\hó~( Ð>?û», Horwood ñö ;NWÍ¾ '»(:¤8Y i4

(386) ¤8Y = why/how KS[·.;¤Ç'8Y( 8 ;

(387) uvE

(388) ;Dxy ST .¨^C56E.

(389) £Fp[Ç ò. HDx 5Ñ

(390) ST Abrams & Southland 2001 Bogen 2005 Brandont 1997 Dagher & Cossman 1992 Hempel 1965 Horwood 1988 Kitcher & Salmon 1989 Salmon 19841989a1989b 1998 Scriven 1988 Sterelny & Griffiths 1999 Talanquer 2007 Thagard 19921999 Unsworth 2001 Zohar & Ginossar 1998¨x. Wesley C. Salmon ÐbM8

(391) 59èé. Godfrey-Smith 2003 Thagard 1992 gDx7~% 5

(392) Salmon. 32.

(393) 19841989a1989b 1998 2. 1989 ¾ Four Decades of Scientific Explanation ÐMcì 9 Jê76E1Àd 2005¨gå ~%¨ é ÀÑÙ©¾ EG:>S¿$

(394) y:>S TlêUK 5 Salmon FK

(395) ST

(396) W '"z (K]G

(397) åy0ZF8 [·ST S Ó S

(398) WJv'how( ð 'what( ð 'why([·p

(399) óÀ Salmon \ d.é 2g&°4V>?» Thagard , Dagher a ¨ ,"#gh F Ô_

(400) ST . .

(401) Hempel1965 p425E 4a

(402) £"a&H êë; d£â+¿ H8 AB;Gs

(403). j"z µ¶A

(404) p ^k Salmon dZ

(405) ¹! 7YW '"z ( f

(406) ¦§Salmon M D-@W þ%R empathicðgç symbolicð)$ goal-oriented ðG ¤ scientific F¢þ%R E & > h d£'> ( Vij kl:m ap ABCs'A¿ ( åy

(407) ¨_Ô8ð&ð·¬ =± w ÷ø ºLwå aB;RÇåy . 33.

(408) gç yÊvÔ { äån,¦§ 37'¦§(. :Ñ gç:óÊv d;0o& peðqÆaðrPZ% i4n¦§&Ea 08ïD¦§ d£D~ ,$ F GàsR

(409) K¿ E 4 EØt

(410) 8d@f+. { )$ y;À~e ð K e y {3;G7Ky5ST ïD¦ 7 6

(411) teleological explanation Salmon #F±7Ä d£ÞRD¦ Zà,K E UVWï~6 XÇuvw0 åD¦ 0Z ÀxyU aS 0*_Ã6»e ±J\z ¦{ d_å S#yST _z¦ 7Ã

(412) functional explanation Salmon #7E åy

(413) ë,SC*/ + ±Jewª4 UVWý|[0. }P~*=z*³ ±J¨;Gs 8À| [0 b~[:Ñ }KàD¦Çb~KPÚ>+8Ã. 8Yt

(414) ;G"AB=´Ã

(415) dy

(416) Ø¨¨ : 6, =:Ü \ l 6&£ðD~¨X. í

(417) 4G àrZK

(418) =:RD{R e+Z <â.

(419) D&, l6 34.

(420) ½>?

(421) Salmon M3;G7KS K ñ4Ë, ¨_ ¤8Y Wy;G:¤8Y 6

(422) theoretical explanation Salmon 37 unification & world pictureUVWPV=nRT å@{¨ Pð V EõiDß#\ Ô EÖ8YÔ ½;

(423) ôþõ÷ ÂP å y

(424) EWÙyÇ8Y &sàácausal mechanical UVW² ³f 7àá å@

(425) Ç²û pö8Yhó 9â7+kef& Salmon 7åS

(426) opening black box :ÑåKS

(427) 2 þ"5 d£>y;G>pRKyz{K

(428) G}P~. ±JU DiÇ¹ºðcIðÚgh !_ 6

(429) = ÙÁ@ } ðUVð« !_8Yàá

(430) 0 2-1-1 é ÀF56 G FSK

(431) ST Salmon ®¨ SÊSÊst R 'Ze( ½2 d;ne Ã6

(432) 8.E

(433) 'e( d Salmon ¨S.F k§

(434) 'e( E Salmon ¨2gò.FtÍMk

(435) WÓySTWÃ

(436) . 35.

(437) "# $ % ,-./ 01.23. !. *+. &'() &'+ 4&'+ 89:; *+7 56 :;!<. =>? DEFG @ABC HIJKL. . 2-1-1 Salmon 1998.

(438) *À8k&ga [· Scriven1988M 4

(439) @ jJvDÔ'Èo(ES [· Lý@'Èo( [· . v{ ;GÉ

(440) ½ !ÄB )*+ ¨

(441) å¢. 0Zæç:(¨Jv'Èo(. 2gS [·d;Salmon j [·STÓS

(442) WJv'how([·p

(443) Jv'what( [·p

(444) Jv'why([·p

(445) V0 2-1-2 ýè7+k+Zp j348'how([·

(446) . ¤V. ¤h¦§p UVW. eðÍûðØ0 ¦§p j348'what([·

(447) ¤ ýHp j348'why([·

(448) . 36.

(449) ¨ gh. DåÓS

(450) UVW

(451) Vý4%%®õhow [Æà ¦§what výD°±whyWhy [· 3;7ÓST WST¤n, ij _'ÈoH( why should [· åS[·3DKy:>

(452) 3hWV'Èo X42@( å@[·¤n :CDÍä¸Í v{#V. ña[¤'ýA CÏU=A(p gB4 *:

(453) =ij ¤> WÙST Èo[· ¤Ç¦,z¦ F¢¦ E. D@tÍ,1 UVW'±J( ¬p¦§ E ®£> ¨_eP èu)$&Ù@ey K\zD¦§ ÃÃ 6¤_Zà

(454) dD¦ UVWaï~Xuv D[g ý4ïX gCJvW'8A4<X uv( Salmon E @

(455) NPÇðZàð1p jy 6.

(456) ¨\ .. Äx 6

(457) UVWLÇ Ã6ð. x e = Dj¨åS 6

(458) UVW ijO¿|xð¬p¹ºs¿|Ã6½. |e¨"DÄx. z¦ E'Ã(

(459) ¨±J, \*WÓSTwhy does 4h JKfactual information åS

(460) µ¶!,àá D@ R·¬ UVW

(461) à ®8 .D·_x^5HSæ. î 37.

(462) 2-1-2. MNO PQRSPT PQ. >?»¨M

(463) DG^yW±ú

(464) deductive explanationð ß#

(465) statistical explanation ð {

(466) teleological explanation ðc {

(467) emergent explanation¤J+{

(468) reductive explanation ¨±ú

(469) åS

(470) ST. G Hempel ±úl ù{deductive-nomological model9÷øOß#

(471) !Gß#&à« 8YÔÕ G45±ú

(472) c 8)*+&ÄxE:èóR±ú

(473) K ¡ 38.

(474) {

(475) !*ë*/ UVWGõ ÃKJõý>¨ [ ·åÓy

(476) ._l^C]]GVd 5c{

(477) ¤J+{

(478) !¨ t

(479) 8YÔÕpC Ky

(480) ¸: E Þß÷ÜÝk. !&7éP wholes :;GRÒÍk&9ÒÍk&7 parts. !KJ+ â!E MÞß÷ÜÝk !;GRÒÍk& 9ÒÍk !KJ+. Thagard Thagard1992M©¾K

(481) ² .ü· g KÔa$Òá ½M

(482) öa$Òá z*ª4 8g d

(483) fdG 5gM,a$Òá_

(484) f L\DG ^ÂySW±údeductive ß#statistical ¨ùschematic S2 analogical 8Ycausal Êv Rlinguistic and pragmatic åÂ¢2 . K¢W±ú,ß# _Ô() % Hempel hß µ ¶ Salmon &2gF 7

(485) &0¸ "37¡. st 8¨56±ú,ß#KST

(486) p .ñ4°î SalmonðHempel &0¸ "3 KT

(487) stâ-¢

(488) AG Thagard stñ 1 -. x¾K_

(489) 9D÷øO ä1 Hempel F ±úl ùT 39.

(490) deductive-nomological model G^Ò7 D-N model Salmon !EùT! Hempel , Oppenheim FÎ> :Ñ&^ Salmon d*¢: Oppenheim =²E Hempelian modelSalmon 1984 1989a 1989b 1998 Thagard 1992 0¸ 1991Hempel M

(491) y±ú 6% ¨6%¨ µ ¶,ã6÷ØìáD@£¤klgeneral law

(492) å¢$% jF4Ð

(493) þ¥Çå@klFGùTd;Ð756lù{ covering law modelG^¦@U0¸ 1991W D@a[' Èo§¨ÇX C©ÓK(Jv[· D-N model ;GI7 1-1LýeP;¨LýªP. DeP ªÁá_>P&ªP ªÁ !ePC©ªL 1-2§Ð¨Ç«. 1-3«. ªPX 1-4§ ªÁ2>P&X ªÁ/ 1-5§©ÓK

(494) µþ-@1-1~1-4 1-1 ! Ã d£@£ ¤klgeneral law1-2~1-4 H

(495) U0(Ìinitial condition åÚ Î7

(496) ¢explanans d£0

(497) Z% e1-5 ã6 d £¼

(498) ¢explanandum Ð

(499) Ã 40.

(500) D-N model ´Çå¬ Æ¦,56 8±Çê@,OÁSalmon 1998 p337Thagard -E±ú

(501) ë */ UVW¹Å4

(502) )p gBCÞRrZkl,DÔ ®ð¯°ðÈ Çø. % ±ú. ã6KAB4st Ì&G^Ò7;!Fï £¤kl¤ U0(ÌF'6Kï£¤kl¤U0(ÌKÝÅ¢EFGH Ô ! -&GåÚ£¤kl,U0(Ì )'HCH( ã60 ¸ 1991 p42d£s ±ú

(503) *d××¹] d£VY±

(504) J±j¹]± HThagard 1992åd Salmon FE.

(505) —¹]7explanation—prediction symmetry thesisSalmon 1998 ½ÄxÅMåyST

(506) òz4=: 8UVW±Je gh÷

(507) EDê@ kl <²±úAB;GaSEFGD ³

(508) ½ABFNDc Ö±údÖ¹]±Jâ K¾ FG D-N model Ez

(509) 47#\ D-N model d: AB;GZ ´µðÓð® kl,U0(Ì K

(510) ´÷ ß: !´÷ ´µ

(511) Salmon 1998 Thagard 1992uüý s ´÷´µ)P¶F"Z ãY =´µß:´÷F7. Godfrey-Smith 2003 p197 &^ Hempel , Oppenheim a dt³·7EzFD

(512) R ±úù{ Ø4#Dß#&¸î ù{K¹º FG Hempel âKdÀ I-S 41.

(513) modelSalmon 1998 p335 2 / 1 01/I-S model Hempel ¯&Æ¦ÇEzFD

(514) D-N model DÚ_à« &ß# 8gÀ#y

(515) ùTW¸îß#ùTinductive-statistical model G^Ò7 I-S model_ D-N model ÞR!klKþ¥+k I-S model À~ÞRß#klKþ¥+k 8

(516) ÀH ;¦ @ I-S model UV^Salmon 1998 Î

(517) 'ý+»¨= ´x¼Û0Q½Eâ g KP£¾¿À(W 2-1-1çFDÀÁÂÃ ¨Äx¼Û0Eâ jCwÅÆÇ 2-1-2+»ÀÁ 2-1-3+»=´x¼Û0 Q½ 2-1-4+»wÅ ¾¿À

(518) >?µþÓ@2-1-1~2-1-3 2-1-1 EzÈ¦ kl i ß#\7D@à« ß#kl 2-1-2 , 2-1-3 H

(519) U0(Ì initial condition 2-1-4 !ã6 8¸îß#

(520) ,±ú

(521) DK@ª4 Ë, ß#

(522) ! 42.

(523) ¸î= =±ú

(524) !±ú=Ù¸îß#

(525) .+k þ¥Çß #kl ±ú

(526) .Eþ¥Ç£¤klSalmon 1998 d£±ú

(527) ^R kl¯ó7Êü =¸îß#

(528) ^R kl¯ß#Êü0¸ 1991K >1DÙWKF+kÌ&þ¥Ç9@ ! FG;756lù{0¸ 1991#\ Hempel åKy

(529) ùT D~

(530) ¹]7 d£

(531) . _¹]Salmon 1998. Ö6 D-N model & I-S model åKy566ù{â jQÓ|É. 56,Êî DadGÊË Da&¸¦/0¸ 1991 ¦/VCF D-N model ò:4d:E\ ¸¦/V Salmon 2g ù{:Ñ :ÜÌ7& ¯7 Hempel , Oppenheim ~ %'

(532) () ( ;É

(533) 56 Tp| ÍSalmon 1998 2 /23S-R model Salmon :MÐ

(534) jÐ¹] gM»@Ì

(535) f\ j»@ÌHp HÌDß#Ô 8Thagard 1992 Salmon M4Rß#ÔK¿| I-S model @à« ß#

(536) Ôo ögE@à«E:6Ge¸Í

(537) UVWÛSalmon 1998W 2-2-1xÉÎÃHÏÐÂ A a Ñ Q½â C&ÑÚ /. 43.

(538) 2-2-2+»ÎÃHÏÐÂ A E=´ Q½ 2-2-3+»´ÇÑÚ / Hempel I-S model 2-2-1 ß#! 2-2-2 U0(Ì K 2-2-3 !@D ã6Salmon !E&^ 2-2-1 à«w@ ½"ØÙÁ 2g8£ UVW&ÄHÐÂ:Ò=Ç 2«dw@ ÄxÇHÂ a :3 Q½dCÓÓ¿®:6H½ 7Ã«Dx@ i40ÆÇ 2«9@ \ 6%jí? uüýs 2-2-1, 2-2-2, 2-2-3 HÀ ½ 2-2-3 H E:! 2-2-1 , 2-2-2 åK@K

(539) =´2g8£W':RQ½ dCÔÔ¿®( ÷ø Salmon M Hempel ù{ ¨\Õ¨¡k6determinism d£ FD ;Rèó R±ú

(540) i4AB NÁ6+ d£s I-S model D-N model K VYNÁ:6 AC I-S model uvE VYNÁ6+ £:C]D I-S model =iD D-N model = Salmon ´|e ÁO ÷ø Mk_z¡k6 indeterminist8g#yß#{

(541) Wß#ÔùT statistical-relevance model G^Ò7 S-R model åy

(542) ST_ß# Ô :R_8YÔ d£¨_z¡k6 FÌß#{

(543) S-R model FFDÔ_4Ð

(544) Ì 8ßßî¯ ½:þ:Ô8. 44.

(545) UVW4