ഏઝᄎ᎖ܗૠᒳᇆΚNSC 93-2213-E-155-035
ୖኧፓਠኳᔕܭଯਏޑՅᆛ।ϩᜪᐒڋϐᔈҔ!
ᓪᇬ
P 1 PǴഌ܍ד
P 2 PǴ࠶ᑉ
P 3 PϡඵεᏢၗૻᆅࣴز܌!
P 1 Plonghow.lee@gmail.com
P 2 Pimcjluh@saturn.yzu.edu.tw
P 3 Ps937714@mail.yzu.edu.tw
ᄔा!
ӧᆛၡጲࠁวޑϞВǴόၗૻޑୀෳᆶٛ ݯςԋࣁቶݱፕޑᚒǶӧӃޑࣴزύǴך ॺගрၮҔьБࣁ୷ᘵޑीᄽᆉݤܭՅᆛ। ϩᜪǴҁጇЎകଞჹ܌ගБݤޑسୖኧϩǴග рঁسኳᔕޑፓਠᐒڋǴаයӧԋҁਏޑԵ ໆϐΠǴၲډଯਏޑسਏૈǶ!ᜢᗖӷ
;!ୖኧፓਠǴسኳᔕǴԋҁਏǴьБ ϩଛǴᆛ।ϩᜪǴόၗૻၸᘠ!1
ق
ᒿᆛሞᆛၡޑጲࠁวǴ٬ளၗૻޑࢬ೯ߚ தِೲᆶቶݱǴय़ჹόᘐౢғޑӭኬϯၗૻǴӵՖ ଞჹᆛၡϣޑϩભᆶᆅ[02,04] ޔࢂ ঁቶݱፕޑᚒǴЀځࢂόၗૻޑୀෳᆶ ٛݯ׳ڙډձᜢݙǶόޑᆛၡၗૻх֖Յǵ ኪΚǵ֎ࢥǵ።റሦୱǴߙϿԃϷٽูӧᎦԋ௲ ػਔௗڙډόၗૻޑቹៜǴܰ܉্يЈޑ଼ӄ วǴᏤठΓޑୃৡǴԋӭޗᆶҍୢᚒ Ƕ!World Wide Web Consortium [14]ගрPlatform for Internet Content Selection [10]Ǵڋۓᆛ।ϣϩ ભޑྗೕǴϣගٮޣёа٩Ԝೕڋۓޑ ᠸ(labels)ჹϣԾךуຏϩભǴ܈ࢂҗڐΚቷ(3P rd P party)ჹᆛၡණթޑϣϩભǶҗܭޣޑ ճԵໆǴҗᆛၡϣගٮޣԾࡓޑݤԋਏό ᄆǴਥᏵཥуڵᏢޣLee et al. (2002&2003)!ޑፓ Ǵᆛၡϣ௦ҔPICSεऊ՞ 11.0%Ƕ܌аҗᆛ ၡᓎቨගٮޣǴٯӵISPޣǵࡹ۬ǵᐒᜢიᡏǴ ٰୀෳᆶٛጄ՟ЯࢂҞၨࣁёՉޑБԄǶਥᏵ Չࡹଣཥᆪֽ܌ࣴᔕޑᆛઠϣϩભቶीฝ \16^ǴЬाჹྣ୯ሞThe Internet Content Rating Association [13]!܌ڋۓຒ༼ྗǴஒᆛၡϣ٩ឦ ܄ϩࣁᇟقǵ܄ᆶᇘ៛ǵኪΚϷځдϩᜪǴӆ КྣႝຎϩભޑբݤǴϩࣁද೯ભǵᇶᏤભǵߥៈ ભکज़ڋભ\01^Ǵܴुрӧᆛઠޑϣᔈჹᔈ ՖᅿભձǴٯӵӧᇟقрܴᡉᆶ܄࣬ᜢӷǴ ஒϩᜪࣁज़ڋભǶ! ҁࣴزЬाଞჹόᆛၡϣύനࣁҌᔲޑ ᆛၡՅǴගрঁୖኧፓਠኳᔕޑᐒڋǴҔܭь Бࣁ୷ᘵޑीᄽᆉݤϐՅᆛ।ϩᜪǶჴᡍ่݀ ᡉҢǴךॺ܌ගрޑୖኧፓਠኳᔕᐒڋӧԋҁਏ ԵໆǴёаԖਏගϲՅᆛ।ୀෳޑᆒዴ (precision rate)ǴଛӝԾϯޑᆛ।ᇆǵၸᘠᆶϩ ᜪǴךॺёаזೲᇆεໆޑՅӜൂǶ!
2
ьБՅᆛ।ϩᜪ
ךॺӧӃޑࣴزύǴගрၮҔьБࣁ୷ᘵޑ ीᄽᆉݤܭՅᆛ।ϩᜪ\09^Ǵᙖҗჹᆛၡϣ ύޑЎӷϩǴၮҔीፕύޑьБ(chi-square) ϩଛ܄Ǵჹঁᆛ।ीᆉрঁϟܭ 0 ډ 1 ϐ ໔ޑՅࡰॶ(Indicator Value, I value )Ǵӆ٩ᖏࣚ ॶ(threshold)ஒ I ॶጄൎϩ႖ԋΟঁ໔ᘐ(distinct)ޑ ໔Ǵঁ໔፟ϒঁᜪձǴϩձࢂՅ(Porn)ǵ ҂ዴۓ(Unsure)ᆶߚՅ(Non-Porn)Ƕ!3/2!سཷᢀ!
٬Ҕ Web Crawler வᆛሞᆛၡڗၟՅᜢᗖӷ ࣬ᜢޑᆛ।Ǵᒧڗҽᆛ।ࣁ૽ግၗ(training data set)Ǵҗ Training ౢғ Token DatabaseǹځᎩ ᆛ।߾ࣁෳ၂ၗ(testing data set)Ƕךॺၸ ঁीᄽᆉݤޑьБϩଛ(chi-square)܄Ǵჹঁ ෳ၂ᆛ।рঁՅࡰॶ(Indicator Value)Ǵа ਥᏵԜՅࡰॶஒᆛ।ϩࣁՅ(Porn)ǵ҂ዴ ۓ(Unsure)аϷߚՅ(Non-Porn)ΟঁᅿᜪǴӆஒځ ύޑՅᆛ।уΕ URL Black List ύǶ!
!
კ 1!سࢎᄬკ!
3/3 Յࡰॶ(Indicator Value)!
๏ۓঁෳ၂ᆛ।Ǵךॺ२Ӄѐନ HTML tagsǴฅࡕ٩ Token Database ᘐຒǴפډрӧ
Token DatabaseύൂঁձӷຒǴаϷঁӷຒჹ ᔈޑՅӛॶ(Porn Tendency)ǴҗܭՅӛॶ ࢂ࣬ჹКޑཷۺǴ܌аՅӛॶࣁϟܭ 0 ډ 1 ϐ໔ޑჴኧॶǶௗǴךॺ௦Ҕ Gary Robinson ග рޑ Spam Filtering БݤύޑьБϩଛ[03,12]ޑ ܄่ӝ p-value ౢғՅࡰॶǴҔډޑ൳ঁБำ ԄӵΠ܌ҢǶ!
( )
12* ln
, 2
nR
=
C
−⎛
⎜
−
f w
⎝
∏
n
⎠
⎞
⎟
(1)( )
(
)
12 * ln
1
, 2
nG
=
C
−⎛
⎜
−
−
f
⎝
∏
w
n
⎞
⎟
⎠
(2)1
2
R G
I
=
+ −
(3) !ځύf(w)ࣁঁձӷຒޑՅӛॶǴn
ࣁ ӷ ຒ ኧ Ҟ Ǵ ࣁ ന ε ཷ ՟ ी ໆ Ǵ n ࣁ߈՟Ծҗࡋ 2nޑьБϩଛ![03]ǴCP -1 PࣁInverse Chi-square FunctionǴၸCP
-1
P
ᆉрٰޑॶ ߾ࣁp-valueǶБำԄ(1)ύǴ௦Ҕीፕύޑ Likelihood Ratio Test![03]Ǵ၀ଷᔠۓӵკ 8 ܌ҢǴ RࣁoঁӷຒՅӛॶճҔьБϩଛ܄่ӝ рޑp-valueǴж߄ӧคଷ(null hypothesis )Ǻᇡ ࣁ೭٤f(w)۶ԜᐱҥǴԶևߚ֡Ϭϩଛޑచҹ ΠǴԖӭϿᐒᡉፕளޕ೭ঁคଷόԋ ҥǶӧჴሞݩύǴҔٰඔॊՅᆛ।ϣޑӷຒ ࢂதՔᒿрǴ٠ߚ۶ԜᐱҥǴ܌аךॺႣයଷ ᔠۓޑ่݀ࣁܔ๊คଷǶᜪ՟ޑБำԄ(2)Ǵ ߾ஒf(w)ڗжԋ 1-f(w)߄ҢߚՅӛॶǴGࣁoঁ ঁձӷຒޑߚՅӛॶрޑp-valueǶRǵG ٿޣрϐࡕǴջёၸБำԄ(3)ٰளՅࡰ ॶ(Indicator Value)Ƕ! 3/4!سୖኧ! ӧঁьБՅϩᜪޑࣴزύǴԖٿঁख़ाޑ سୖኧǴϩձࢂߐᘖॶ(Threshold Pair)ک Effective TokensޑኧҞǶߐᘖॶҔٰ،ۓӵՖஒ I-value ϟܭ 0ډ 1 ޑჴኧ໔Ǵ႖ԋ”Յ”ǵ”҂ዴۓ”ک”ߚ Յ”Οঁᅿᜪჹᔈޑη໔ǶќѦǴӧ๏ۓঁෳ ၂ᆛ।Ǵӧᘐֹຒפډрӧ၀ᆛ।ޑൂঁձӷ ຒаϷჹᔈޑՅӛॶϐࡕǴᔈ่ӝӭϿኧҞ ޑӷຒ(Effective Tokens)ၸьБϩଛޑ܄ीᆉ рՅॶǴஒࢂ೭ঁьБࣁ୷ᘵޑीᄽᆉݤ ૈցԖਏၮբޑᜢᗖǶ!
3
ୖኧፓਠኳᔕ
ךॺගрঁୖኧፓ௲ޑኳᔕᐒڋǴଞჹ೭ٿ ঁख़ाޑسୖኧǴၸኳᔕޑ่݀פډന٫ޑୖ ኧۓǴаΠஒଞჹঁኳᔕޑၸำၟ่݀၁ಒ ޑϟಏǶ!
3.1 ኳᔕᕉნ ךॺ٬Ҕ MATLAB 6.5 ӧ Windows ᕉნΠس ኳᔕǴঁኳᔕޑᕉნۓӵΠǺଷςޕԖ“Յ∏
n w f( )∏
−2ln f(w)”ǵ “҂ዴۓ”аϷ“ߚՅ”೭Οঁᅿᜪޑᆛ।Ӛ 3000ǴᕴӅ 9000 ᆛ।Չኳᔕෳ၂ǹќѦǴ ଷ“Յ”ᆛ।ϩӧၸᘐຒϐࡕளډޑ Tokens வ 0.2 ډ 1.0 ޑ֡ϬϩଛύᒿᐒౢғՅӛॶ (f(w))ǹӕኬӦǴ“ߚՅ”ᆛ।வ 0 ډ 0.8 ޑ֡Ϭϩ ଛύᒿᐒౢғ Token ޑՅӛॶǴԶ“҂ዴۓ”೭ ঁϩ߾ࢂவ 0.2 ډ 0.8 ޑ֡Ϭϩଛύᒿᐒ๏ϒՅ ӛॶǶࣁΑफ़եኧౢғᏔԋޑୃৡǴךॺ ჹঁՅӛॶ(f(w)) 5 ԛޑኧౢғǴฅࡕ ӆڗځѳ֡բՅӛॶǶ 3.2 ߐᘖॶ(Threshold Pair) ߐᘖॶޑۓஒቹៜډسޑᆒዴ(precision rate)Ǵ೭္ޑᆒዴࣁس҅ዴղᘐϩᜪޑᆛ।ኧ Ҟନаςޕ๏ۓϩᜪޑᆛ।ኧҞǶسޑߐᘖॶ (Threshold Pair)җٿঁϩಔԋǴϩձࢂߐᘖΠࣚ (Lower Bound, L)کߐᘖࣚ(Upper Bound, U)ǴΨ ൩ࢂᇥჹܭಔThreshold Pair (TBiB)ǴTBi=(LB BiB, UBi B)Ƕ ኳᔕύޑLBiBҗ 0.5 ډ 1.0Ǵԛሀቚ 0.5ǹUBiB߾җ 1.0 ډ 0.5 Ǵ ԛ ሀ ෧ 0.5 Ƕ ᖐ ٯ ٰ ᇥ TB5B=(LB5B,UB5B)=(0.25,0.75)Ǵ߄ 1 ࣁኳᔕޑ่݀Ǵঁಒ (cell)ж߄ޑࢂӧ၀ۓݩΠޑᆒዴǴനࡕ ӈࣁӧ၀Threshold PairڰۓΠǴჹόӕޑEffective TokensኧҞޑѳ֡ᆒዴǶҗኳᔕ่݀ёޕǴӧTB7B= (0.35,0.65)ਔǴᡏޑѳ֡ᆒዴࣁ 99.95Ǵࢂ܌а όӕޑߐᘖॶۓύჹسᆒዴԶقനӳޑ่ ݀Ƕ ߄ 1 ኳᔕ่݀ Threshold Pair Number of Effective Tokens TB1B TB2B TB3B TB4B TB5B TB6B TB7B TB8B TB9B 50 72.41 84.25 91.01 94.71 97.03 98.36 99.14 98.88 93.05 100 88.32 94.96 97.79 98.94 99.50 99.81 99.94 99.97 99.85 150 95.20 98.49 99.41 99.76 99.89 99.97 100 100 100 200 98.22 99.51 99.83 99.95 99.98 99.99 100 100 100 250 99.41 99.87 99.97 99.99 100 100 100 100 100 300 99.76 99.94 99.99 100 100 100 100 100 100 350 99.93 99.98 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 400 99.98 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 450 99.99 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 500 99.99 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 550 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 600 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 650 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 700 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 750 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 800 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 850 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 900 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 950 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 1000 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 Mean 97.66 98.85 99.4 99.67 99.82 99.91 99.95 99.94 99.65
3.3 Effective TokensޑኧҞʳ
ךॺஒ߄ 1 ύޑ Effective Tokens ޑኧҞӧόӕ ޑ Threshold Pair ܌ளޑᆒዴѳ֡Ǵёаளډ ঁ Effective Tokens ޑኧҞჹѳ֡ᆒዴޑϩթᖿ ༈Ǵӵკ 3 ܌ҢǴךॺёаวѳ֡ᆒዴᒿ Effective TokensޑኧҞԋሀቚޑᖿ༈Ǵ Effective TokensޑኧҞຬၸ 150 ਔǴѳ֡ᆒዴςຬၸ 99%Ƕ! კ!3!ᆒዴϩթᖿ༈კ! ԜѦǴךॺΨวၨӭޑEffective TokensҔ ٰीᆉՅࡰॶǴஒၨӭޑीᆉਔ໔ǶࣁΑ ёаԖਏᑽسᆒዴکीᆉਔ໔Ǵךॺ௦Ҕа ΠޑБำԄीᆉCost-EffectivenessΔځύoࣁuplfot ঁኧǴAPRBnBж߄ӧ܌ԖޑThreshold PairΠޑѳ֡ᆒ
ዴǹACTBnB߾ࢂѳ֡ޑीᆉਔ໔Ƕ n n n
APR
Cost
Effectiveness
ACT
−
=
(4) ߄ 2 ࣁ Cost-Effectiveness ޑीᆉ่݀Ǵ Effective Tokens ޑ ኧ Ҟ ࣁ 150 ਔ Ǵ ё а ว Cost-Effectiveness ܭ 7.2467Ǵ೭ࢂ܌Ԗύന ӳޑ่݀Ǵᡉฅޑ೭ࢂኳᔕӧคݤளޕՖᒏന٫่ ݀(optimal solution)ΠǴளډޑ߈՟ന٫่݀ (near optimal solution)Ƕ3.4ʳ ന٫ୖኧۓʳ
ਥ Ᏽ ॊ ޑ ኳ ᔕ ่ ݀ Ǵ ך ॺ ё а ว Effective Tokens ޑኧҞࣁ 150 ਔЪ Threshold Pair
ࣁ(0.35,0.65)ਔǴӧѳ֡ᆒዴکीᆉਔ໔ϐ ໔Ǵٿ࣬ᑽϐΠࣁനڀԋҁਏޑୖኧۓǶ! კ 3 ࣁ Effective Tokens ޑኧҞ 150 ਔޑኳᔕޔ БკǶځύ”Յ”ϩޑ 3000 ᆛ।Ǵၸीᆉϐ ࡕޑՅࡰॶ(I-value)Ǵ๊εϩ߈՟ 1(εܭ 0.8)ǹӕኬӦǴ”ߚՅ”ᆛ।ޑ 3000 ǴՅࡰ ॶ(I-value)߾εϩ߈ 0(λܭ 0.2)ǹԶ”҂ዴۓ” ޑ 3000 ᆛ।߾Տܭ 0.5Ƕऩஒ Threshold Pair ۓ ࣁ(0.35,0.65)Ǵ߾سޑᆒዴࣁ 100%Ƕ! კ 4!Effective Tokens ޑኧҞࣁ 150 ޑኳᔕޔБკ!
4
سჴբᆶෳ၂
ךॺӧ Linux Fedora Core 2 ᕉნΠǴ௦Ҕ MySQL 4.0.20ǵApache 1.3.31ǵ PHP 5.0.1 ک GNU
Wget 1.9 [06] ஒьБՅϩᜪޑسჴբǴ٠ஒख़ ा ޑسୖኧ Threshold Pair ࣁ (0.35,0.65) ǹ Effective TokensޑኧҞۓࣁ 150ǴΨ൩ࢂᇥ๏ ۓঁෳ၂ᆛ।Ǵऩᘐຒϐࡕޑൂӷຒόຬၸ 150 ঁਔǴ߾ஒځჹᔈޑՅӛॶӄҔٰीᆉ Յࡰॶǹऩᘐຒϐࡕຬၸ 150 ঁൂӷຒǴ߾ ஒჹᔈޑՅӛॶҗεठλ௨ׇǴڗ 150 ঁ่ ӝьБϩଛीᆉ I-valueǶ ךॺஒ٣ӃᇆޑՅᜢᗖӷǴҔำԄԾᒡ Εཛྷ൨ЇᔏǴஒཛྷ൨่݀ύᆛ֟ޑᆛ।ڗӣٰǴ ځύϩբ૽ግၗǴќϩբෳ၂ၗǶ ךॺӧෳ၂ၗύǴᒧڗύमЎᆛ।Ӛ 500 Ǵ٣ ӃΓπᔠ๏ۓ҅ዴϩᜪǴฅࡕ๏سբϩᜪղ ᘐǶჴᡍ่݀ӵ߄ 3 ܌ҢǶ
߄ 3 ϩᜪᆒዴ ᇟق ᆛ।ኧҞ ղᘐ ҅ዴ ղᘐ ᒱᇤ ᆒዴ मЎ 500 486 14 97.2% ύЎ 500 482 18 96.4% ӧमЎϩԖ 597 ղᘐ҅ዴǴ14 ղᘐᒱ ᇤǴᆒዴࣁ 97.2%ǹύЎ߾Ԗ 482 ղᘐ҅ዴǴ 18 ղᘐᒱᇤǴᆒዴࣁ 96.4%Ƕղᘐᒱᇤޑ 32 ᆛ।Ǵၸ၁ಒᔠวǴᆛ।ϣЬाаკТ БԄևǴཱུλϩޑЎӷၗૻǴسคݤԖਏղ ᘐϩᜪǴ೭ҽёૈሡा٬ҔቹႽೀޑמೌᇶշ ϩǶၟ Lee!et al. (2002 & 2003)!аᜪઓᆛၡ Ўӷϣϩޑࣴز࣬КၨǴӧᆒዴගϲऊ
2.2% (मЎϩ)ǴӆޣǴךॺΨёаೀύЎᆛ।Ƕ
߄!2 Cost-Effectiveness ޑीᆉ่݀
Number of Effective Tokens
Average Precision Rate of Each Threshold Pair
Average Computational Time (Seconds) Cost Effectiveness 50 92.09 13.0656 7.0483 100 97.68 13.5624 7.2023 150 99.19 13.6876 7.2467 200 99.72 14.1438 7.0504 250 99.92 14.2312 7.0504 300 99.97 14.5000 6.8949 350 99.99 14.7720 6.7689 400 99.99 14.8970 6.7121 450 99.99 14.5844 6.8560 500 99.99 14.6780 6.8122 550 100 15.4312 6.4804 600 100 32.9344 3.0363 650 100 41.6688 2.3999 700 100 42.9876 2.3263 750 100 43.4344 2.3023 800 100 43.8158 2.2823 850 100 44.5750 2.2434 900 100 44.5970 2.2423 950 100 48.6126 2.0571 1000 100 57.7188 1.7325
5
่ፕ
ךॺගрঁୖኧፓਠኳᔕޑᐒڋǴҔܭӃ ගрޑаьБՅᆛ।ϩᜪسǴჴᡍ่݀ᡉҢ җኳᔕ่݀ளډޑ߈՟ന٫ୖኧۓॶǴӧԋҁਏ ޑԵໆΠǴёа٬ঁسၲډଯਏǴسޑ ᆒዴଯၲ 96%аǶ ҂ٰךॺीฝೀόӕሦୱޑόၗૻх֖። റǵኪΚǵҍǶќѦǴନΑύЎǵमЎϐѦǴ ѺᆉჹځдᇟسೀǴх֖ܿ٥ᇟس(ВЎǵᗬ Ў)ǵՋኻᇟس(ቺЎǵՋУЎǵကεճЎ)ǴҾკᇆ׳ֹޑόၗૻӜൂǴёаࣁᆛၡ ϣϩભᆶၗૻၸᘠޑ٩ᏵǶ
ठᖴ
ҁ ࣴ ز җ ୯ ࣽ ᚒ ࣴ ز ी ฝ ! NSC 93-2213-E-155-035ံշǴԜTठTᖴǶ!ୖԵЎ!
1. B. J. Bushman, and J. Cantor, “Media Ratings for Violence and Sex,” American Psychologist, Vol. 58, No. 2, pp. 130-141.
2. J. M. Balkin, B. S. Noveck, and K. Roosevelt, “Filtering the Internet: A Best Practices Model,” Information Society Project at Yale Law School, September 1999, pp. 1-38.
3. G.. Casella, and R. L. Berger, (2001), Statistical Inference (2P
nd
P
edition), TWadsworth Pub. Co.T
4. S. Goodwin, and R. Vidgen, “Content, Content, Everywhere…..Time to Stop and Think? The Process of Web Content Management,” Computing & Control Engineering Journal , Vol. 13, No. 2, 2002, pp.66-70.
5. Government Information Office, Republic of China, Project For Promoting Internet Content Rating System, available online at
TU
http://info.gio.gov.tw/public/Attachment/451214 545571.docUT
6. GNU Wget Project, available online at
TU
http://www.gnu.org/software/wget/wget.htmlUT
7. P. Y. Lee, S.C. Hui, and A.C.M. Fong, "Neural Networks for Web Content Filtering," IEEE Intelligent Systems, Vol. 17, No. 5, 2002, pp.48-57.
8. P. Y. Lee, S.C. Hui, and A.C.M. Fong, "A Structural and Content-Based Analysis for Web
Filtering," Internet Research: Electronic Networking Applications and Policy, Vol. 13, No. 1, 2003, pp. 27-37.
9. L. H. Lee, ”A Web Content Classification for Pornographic Blacklist Generation,” Master thesis, Department of Information Management, Yuan Ze University, 2005.
10. Platform for Internet Content Selection (PICS), available online at TUhttp://www.w3c.org/PICS/UT .
11. G.. Robinson, “A Statistical Approach to the Spam Problem,” Linux journal, Vol. 2003, issue 107. pp.1-9.
12. G.. Robinson (May 3, 2004), “Why Chi? Motivations for the Use of Fisher’s Inverse Chi-Square Procedure in Spam Classification, Version 0.93,” available online at
TU
http://www.garyrobinson.net/2004/05/why_chi.h tmlUT
13. The Internet Contenting Rating Association (ICRA), available online atTUhttp://www.icra.org/UT
14. World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), available online at TUhttp://www.w3c.org/UT .