我國選民投票抉擇的影響因素──從民國82年縣市長選舉探析

全文

(1)o. filJ l3:I' £.?!/.If &II::rYHyilt¥3t:fl?tHJ~.i!l1IilIl!nf.~IIlU~1(fig~-!l:M- ¥ :<¥:... o. ~~rw~. , $~~~&+1f1lr. ~~~~~~W~~¥¥~'.~~~~.~~'~*~.~w~~r*w~w ~~~~:@ J .~I!Il!I3t. 0. tlfW~WZ(IvO-pOO-H-IO£O-£g ':::>SN). r ~itif.fiHt!l!-fI. 37=+V~-1r:f~~:@&II'j]'ijlf.~j§trg.fi!: J .~~WZfilJ~.~I!Il!Il¥J¥:<¥:*. .~I*~OO~+V~~lm.oo~ •• ~~¥'~ •••- . •• W~OO~~~I~#y~~W~ •• W¥+~. ~~~.~~-. '*~~~OO~~_'~.'.~~W~*~OO~V+::}~~fif #Y~~~~~~~~~.~~'*ifOO~~+::}~~I ••• ~ •• ~•• ~¥~#.~.~Y#.'*~OO~=+::} ~~Y~~. ~~I*~oo~~~*~~~~rn'~~~~u~~*~oo~¥+ ¥~~I.~y~y~~oo#.~~~'.~oo. ~~~¥~OO. M+¥~~I.. •• ~~~.~OO~-+¥~~~~D •• OO~.. ~m~~~OOM~~~'~~~OO~.~~~~.OO.~~~.~ oo~~'*rn~. •• ifOO~~*~¥~.~~-+¥~~~~. *gf*f.~*!I! ft:4rZ8~ 1¥l~. ~~a~~.¥fmf~~1¥l~~~.

(2) 82. .~+~*.~~ft~~~*.~.@ ••• ~~~ooz~~~. ... .,m~~.*~-~~.tt~. *~. ••~.~~~*~. •• ,. §.~~.a.~,~_. ~~ft.~,M~~~~ •• ~*~. •••• ~.*~~.oA+-~~~.=g~~~ft~ ••~. ~~~~ •• ~~~~OOa.,.M •• h~m ,~.~~.~ ~~{t,~~*~~.O. ~. if';k:~~ft. ••• Z;$'~. I. i:l'~ftI!.fD:~~r!l~.i:l'.~.7a. ~~{t,*~~.~tto~~~A+=~+-n=+~8~~r!l. •. •• ,~-+=M~r!l~a.o~ •• ~~~g(~+A~)~r!l ~•• JM~*M~r!l , ~38 %~W~$ , .*~~w]~~~~fiIJ~ if' ' )[.H&II~ • .fI}~-f.t lZ3~ffi,G'+)£ , ii~~*r+MJj r!l ~~.~gJjr!l.14J~$,*~53% , ~3f-'~~~-,*~r ' ill .~t.U.~.~f~JG'~~1T. ~M.1~.Attl!-15~~if' , ff1~~ ~M.,- •• ~m~,~~ •• ~ •• ~~.~.~ ••• ~ ~.,i:l'fflr!l~nffl~~~~ ••• ;OO~~.~+~~* •• , ~~ftI!.~~-15A±* •• A~.~,~ii~~ ••• o~An+ 0. 0. 0. 8,~~~~.~~~~~ft,~~~.~~.,. llE~i:l'~t~».~1tr!l*ttl!-15~5*»'fi9Utt*. mr~.J,. •• , )[~~MJjr!lm. ili~~~~o~~.~.~ftI!.~~~rn~~.'~~~ff~ ~gl~4ZA~JUm~~1;7]. 0. f{H~*.·1~.A.~~Jt1\:I?L~. :. ~, ~~.. ~*~rn~~~-15~.A •• ,~ •• ~~~rn;$'~,~~m~A~ .(~ttl!-15'.~'.~)·@IZ3~ •• ~*~.~m~~z. m,%~~~Jjr!l~M.MA.~,~~~r!l~-.~~,~~Jj.

(3) ftflJl~t!(;i!lUR:_~~./;5I~-t'£~ fl82ip~m ~JI.~~. 83. rn~m.~~,~~m.~A.~~~Woff.~~~~,*~ •. •. ~~~~~~,~~~.$~*~rnA~.~~A~~o~~~. ~~~~~,~m~®,.*~~,~%~A~~~m~~~~o. ~~ffW.~~.*~~~~W'~fl~M~ •• ~A?~~.~ ~~~~~~~~?~~~.~~~~~.~rr~~T?m.~~ ~.hm.~M?xm ••• ~~ ••• ~~.?E.§~~~ ~~:imM. ? m~tm~~~~~~~~~:I)t~1iA~~~tJ~,?. ,. ~1H:.\~~~~~~EJf.*{)]tt~~r~~m!. .~~.~~*. 0. .:I)t~$70.6 %' ~ ~.~~~.~1.{J~$. ~~tiC.~, ~~.~~:EAt(47.5%), ~~.~~~At(41 lilt~.~~.~U1.{J3.1. .®:m. %. 0. ffJ1f;~J:. ,. %). 0. ,. ffilflJ. ~ ~.1fH±'@;~~+:EJ1f;, ~. ••~AJ1f;,~J:-~~~-J1f;o~ •• ~mJ1f;oOO~.~.~A 1tJt~M*WmtA'I"~o ~~~M~~~O.~~*~~~~.rn.~.*.~~~$ ;:E.fF-.~. (. Jill 1 ). ,~1r~.;f.~~JtOO~.h7~.: (l)~~ •. • ~.&,OO~+A.~-~H •• ,A+- ~~~$~~~ 50% ~r. , 1r S ~1iI.*1fil! (2).:9~~:Jl.~~i·1f.1t~+~ • • ~$ • .;f.~,m~~~~+:E.AR~~At~~ •• ~,~~ 0. ~+ A1f.~1.{J~$~P*~1J:1i, ~A +=.~~., ~~40% ~~. , SJ:t~3f~l'.~~. ' ~~ ~.3f7ttlc~ (3)mt•• ff~+ A ~~~.W~®~ , 1.{J~$~*J1i~10% , ~~lr~mm~~. •• m,~~B.;f~ffff,~$~A~~~~.m~~Jt~~. ~$. h,.~*~~.~tt.oU~.fi. 0. ••. -~.~,~RffMmU.

(4) ~. 84. f~ ~. ~. '*. 70 60 50 40. ~. .. -~t\.';:I;. 62. 59. --- 0---. 0-. *% 2030. 22 a _ r.-18. 10 0. ' ' ' 37.6. 23 --f. -. -. -. /t\.';5it:l; ------- .:I;m. --fIT.. -0. 41. ". ---~~6.1. ,. 74. 70. _ -. 78. :l;7I-~li*. 8.4 -f. • 3.1. 82. If.J.t(!ii';~). III 1 -&.1£l¥m~iII.~a9~~$~~. nrt~:~~~. , ii1~3.l % ,. Hjt['ilJ~~!J)\~1t~zA. 0. EfllltltZ ,. /J\. a~.*~m.~~fi.effiti~.~~.~¥nM.Wili,~ffl ffi1t/F~~o. .-H~M~W~,~~~ft.fl.~/F~H~~¥-m~~. ~. ,. ITff~¥~1t~I¥.rIL'J1I!M~frl:f±-t-'lWm~~I!WfF~#c~~T.. ~wa~g§'f!i**A. Campbell~AiEThe. ~JiJfm:ili~ft.fl.. 0. American Voter (1960)-.. r 12l'=lIf*~7Xti4m~ J (Funnel of Causali. ~,~.~~.md~~ft.~.~&~~¥~.,m.~§$M ~~~ft.fl.ffi1t%~~m~. R.G. NiemifrlH.F.. 0. (Campbell, et. al., 1960:24). Weisberg~tilltm~fF11B¥.fYj. M~~JI.~-ft.-~7Xti4~~~. ,. : ~fr~JiJf¥. fgB~P.~~1f!-JtB~~~~. ~~.o7Xti4~~~~~,$#~~~-#~-#,_~d-~$. ~~*II~,~7Xti4p.~~7Xti4.,~~~.~~*II~ • • ~.

(5) :m1V~~i)trUIc~89~.I23.----"1$E~1V82:¥amit~.~:f1T. 85. ~.~~~~fi~o~~~Q~~li.W~~~.~*~(~~) ~~.,~~~. ••*••. ~~~M~,~~~. ••• ~Z~.,. W••• ~~*••ti~~A~~.~~~~o~~.~m~AA~ ~~~~~*$#,~~~~m~Z~ti~.$~~M~,#~~ ~~.~1¥~~~JlI~~~~. ,. .~Wtn::~~~#C}E (Niemi. and. r ~*lBJf~~~~~:ru J ~?:tt1T~ft ~,~A~li*W~~.~m~~~*~~AA •• ~.; ••• ~ n::~~~JlIAA •• ~~~~~.~~AA~.;~~.~~ti~~A ~fj(ftU~mAA'/1:~ •• ~.. Weisberg, 1976:12). 0. ~llt. ~. ,. 0. *~~~~~n*~~~.fi~~M~~~~~~~M,~* t;{Campbell~A~. r ~*lBJf*~~~~:ru. ~~, 5lk$-fJ~~.¥ilm~~~Jl ~~~~.$~?:tt1T,.m~~~. :. ~.~ •• ~ .~~~~r. l.~~JRrP:J. (1)• • JR~ (2).~JR rP:J. (3~~~AJR~. 2. f.iff~Bltft~ 3. ti.JM~1~f.f:~. 5. ~±~1ilJRfIi]. fJ!tl:rf;U.Jj[.~~. ,. *~±!. ~.¥il}E~~~~,~~~~. ,~W~~~.~~.¥il~±~~~~~Mo~~. 4. •~~~. '. J fi::~~~~f#~$-~.

(6) 6. ~m;f:~. 7. !§' •. ••• 8a.M,*M~~a.M~ •• H~m.~.~2Z 7ttJT~;jfo. ~*M~~;jf~, r~A~ll.~*J' r~~~AZ%~~ ~~Z~~J' r~.~~(~~W~M)J' r~~~m;f:~W. •• ,m~~~~fi~.~~~ .tt7ttJT°W r •••• Jm ~~+A~ •• ~W.W.,-. ffitt~J,m~~~M~#.M~. ~~~~~=*~.~~~~.~~~±~~*~. ••Z-offi •. •••••~~w~.a~~~M;f:~~~~,~~~~,~~~.

(7) *'~.~'~.'wm.~~&±ID'RNZ~W~~~~'~ 0~. ••• ~V~~.+=~.~'.~~.$.*5.@~ .E£RN '{ rfWMRfB.'= °WM~~~~Z~~WOO~W~~~U~~~ij~~4* o~~~g~~~~~~~~yW'~. ~~~~~g'~~~~~~~~~~m~~'~~~~~y. ••g'.~~~M~g'$~~~~~.g' ••••a¥W& ~:f 'JlI?tl!li~~~U!!~~.y~~~ . ' tP•• ~$.~G81l~ g~W:f~~c~W~'.¥~'~¥~'~4~'~~~'~ • • '~ •• ~.*~U~M.'*:f •• ~~.~U~-.Dra ••• ~$.~=+V~:~:f~~~~~ •• @M~.y•• JU •• ¥~~.*~~~U~* ~W*.~Il~.y~WQtPU~. ta*isk.'. ¥fg¥±{qm§(f*R*~. ,~. o.w~#~m~m~~oow~.y~~. g~.a~'tPM.~:f~~~.@g. .. ••. 'U~~~.~~¥~. .. ~W~.~'-z~m~~~oow~.ya~~:f~~~~. ~.fu.~'.~~. ••@•. .y~~~.M~~~.'r.D~~M~. g J ~ r ~~~~ J ' r ~ilIID~:f~ J -¥1s£ (~G: 9~G8~ , ~ , ~4~ ) .. ~~*#' 0. t;£~ ) .~f.f]jI~*#,~~g~. ,. (3:r£8~. ~~~.!li~.±~~.~~~~~~'JlI?tl.5~~.'*3:r. ·YH~*~~W.lN:4rZ811~~~.~.~~iifltf~N~~II~. 1.8.

(8) f)t,. _tlll9=',L.',. 1l3~' ~~mfU!\t~~.ttzJi!H~. 0. 2. Mliff:n~ *W~~Ml~~~m~*m~Mo~*~_~~.$Mliff~ ~:.. m~Mlili • • *~,.=~~e9='.~ • • *~Mlili#. -'.,._~~e9='.M-'.MliliMAo. €J'/ltt4lf~~336M~~.*1iIli. 16MJj~309M • •*. ffi;,. ~'3iUil. 0. :st}jH~. ,. :. liMllr~*~271iIli. *W~*Jm* • • *~Ar:p~., Iiff~Jif. ' m:::k1-t;&,. 1L~. 78, 81. (. 27X). correlation. ~, ~A~;f:§IJ*~7i(canonical. ~li7X.$~jC. analysis)fU.M*~. 7i(c1uster analysis) , ~m309M~~.*f.iEL1rnx;m;jM.M z rg IRJ. ' ::f IRJ~ z. , ~IJ¥~f1::lt-~. , Jti*. tyj ~. 0. 0. ~Jl.Ltrl'1J~. J3- 5t~ li'rm4lf~*~27. 0. ~€J'_~'336M • •*~f.iEL1rltliMJIii!izf~. ,. *JI~1LMl~. ,. W. • •*liIlilt.-Mlili¥1it(Primary Selection Unit, PSU) , M-'.lt m-Ml. ,Alt.~Mlili¥~o*~~*¥~~Ml~~~~M. 1r,m~*~MlJtt$~~;f~~,. babilities Proportional to Sizes,. ~MlJtt$~¥1it:::k/J\nx; ~t{9lJ PPS):nj\;li§1-JMl~. 0. (Pro. Ml~f1::~1i" JIG. *Jm*~20.~~Ap~ • • zW*~~~~*~~*,IRJ~~ •. • • ~~If1::;li§fizM~,W.~MM-'.MlJtt~A~~lt.~,~* ~A• •f1:: • • ~M.ili*~m.Mlili~ • •*IiIli.HM-'..o* ~ 1i" 161tHIf!:m1it it ~ ::it ¥IJ. ;. mjl!rU¥ f.lF JU. , W. ~ .liE Ml iffY! Ml ili • •*. 9='.~ • • *IiIliJl.UW.20.k:J.~Ap.I¥J$~f.lFJti#-'.Jlll1[ff,. IRJ.

(9) ~mliH~~il(~*~(f9~9[l;J~-~~1iJ,l82~lirp~JA.~f1f. ~~ 1). lEe :fill ~ #Hm til ;ft -'-. 0. 1i Ji it wt:fill JIj{ 31100 ~ itfm WI ( ~. ,;ttm~~**DC~~Il~. ,1441J;ft. 89. 2 BFfffi. 0. ~':::'Illfm{£. II. }\j---=1f12)i21 8 ~~I1}\+':::'1f 1)i 108 ~ , 7)iU!l~*:I:&a9piIit$ .BFf,~.lEe:fill~~:fiIltil~.;ft-'-a9~M~o*~IIA+-1f~iIit msA.l=l~wt, '€:1'.1!f201il~.1.a9A.l=llt1i1O,559,477A., .~:fiIl~~. *lt3,986A. , :fiIl~*1i0.00038EOC1/2649. .::: '. .*ii!H.~tt~1!:~:iE. ~1. :ttl!.. f:r. Il[. }jrJ. f:r~t-U. ~t. ~-~W.~(~ ~-JI. ~=JI. t&mrtr 7X'fl:lrtr. irmrtr -=:]!rtr. ¥. i~*.. ~. ~~. t'it 1t. t'it!l-U. ta. ta~-U. ~. f:r~-U. ~. mllJ. ~1t-U. f1iJc.,~. . i¥ii'9:-U Bfl.u B i¥i f:ri¥i.u. ~f1i.. ~. ~. :n::. *. ~=fI. 1§'ilfrtr. ~rmJj. ¥~rtr ~lEll[. .1$.. ir1trtr wwll[. 0~~. J!5~~. 1r. .11:.. •••m~). A~~. i'9:. ~. 0. ~:hl-U. 1$1r~ ~1t~. .ftJe:rtr. f:r~rtr. ~1-fo~. i¥itf!1l[. llm.. ~1trtr. 45rm. f:ri¥irtr ]r Il[. 1rEl3~. Jl,wrtr. ::k:W. M]r-U 1rM.u J~1J-U. 1rMrtr. M]rrtr ~w.. 11.1*.. -.

(10) ~~~~ ~ ~ 20~t;J..L 1rS~~i\t ffl~Ml* rP~lt A!=llt ltIf7tlt ;fl4:lt. ~ ~ )jlj. 11Il JI lIl-JI lIl=JI 1Il1m1l lfl' flY. m. if. lIT. 2979893. 106. =t. JrI!JMl*;fl4:lt (~~X#m.XAlt). 1129 876. 10 x 4 x 28 = 1120. 54. 2311431. 28.22 21.89. 70. 2208758. 20.92. 837. 6 x 5 x 28 = 840. 79. 1526117. 14.45. 578. 6 x4 x 24= 576. 27. 1533278. 14.52. 4 x 5 x 29= 580. 336. 10559477. 100.00. 581 4001. *IDf~!tlITtlirR'Jt=!'JJ1394'f!lil1**. 5 x 6 x 29= 870. 3986. , Jt=!'JJ$lt34.98 %. 0. *~Ifl~. ~.~1*n~,8*Zn~Em~~~lIT'fl~a~~~m~.* "ilTfm~1*~~/F1fJmiHfllEjf{2.69%. 0. ••• OOtli~1**~tliM~.~~~ ••lIT~~.3,.~_~ ~OOtli~~,tliM~.~*tIi*Z*.~.~E~~~~~lt:~ tIi*/FtE'1ffliAtE*'iI#'fEtIi;fp~1ffli!tt:hl:o 1.1**~f1t. *IDf~Jt=!'JJ~1** •• ~'~~*.MMf1t*~~~.4o. 2. 1**1-t.·I1:~li: tliMJt=!'JJ~.*Mf1t~~~~.-.?5~~~M.AaM. .~ •• *~*~li:tliMJt=!'JJ~1**~~A~~.tto~~~li:~ ~a~ltlk~.~i!jtlm~~.J®:Aa.~(1992). .::. '. 0. 1J~MJj!iI. .1**~.tt~li:Z ••~,.=!'JJ1**tEtt~-~**~aM f1t*,tE~.~~~.li:.*M.w~~a.f1t/F-.olt.~..

(11) ~1I~~~JUR~l'IiJ~.[Ej~-1JE~1I821f:~1if~~.~tJr. *. 3. PlljJ.*R.~J&mH~t«m-*. 1Uir..~;ft* ~I 001l.ilm Jjjf /FOO1l.iii :tE. 1Ui. ,.. fJ;. ~1Ui~/F7:E 1fW A .f£ ~ 1t ${€ lit A 1t ~ lit fJl: ~ ?. !. ttl ttl ttl. lim 9~. 3ft. 9~. I. fo. •. tE. '*. J!I!. ffi. ~. 3&. fYj. H~. 1:.. n. '" f'F. 1i lit. tit ~ ~. * ~. 91. ~. 1Ui ~. N 3986 1265 129 243 439 275 147 167 13 266 27 3 48 29 57 1 33 19. 6 818 1. % 100.00 31.74 3.24 6.10 11.01 6.90 3.69 4.19 0,33 6.67 0.68 0.08 1.20 0.73 1.43 0.03 0.83 0.48 0.15 20.52 0.03. ~~*~~.~*.~.~,~~~• • -.*~tt~,~.~~ J.!I!*f:Iti~;~l2A ${t*JI (post-stratification) :Jj::c\7l2AiJOmYiJ.!l!. Llrr~*!m:. Ni n Wi=-. x m N N:A1ij:.~.. , 1IifI.

(12) 92. *4 )ijtIjJ_*i!iIl*. N. I§ mIftE. ag fi~ (Mf) lIIiJI. 122. % 8.8. 32. 2.3. ~~. 37. 2.7. I~. 87. 6.3. JI. 702. 50.4. 1;:. 692. 49.6. :l!!fIm~. 20-29~. 228. 16.4. 30-39~. 432. 31.0. .~. 40-49~. 310. ~&l±ffi. 1ftt. 50-59~. 146. 22.2 10.5 .. 60~Jl.,(.L. 278. 19.9. ••. *1li~~A. N. 29. 2.1. 253. 18.2 0.1. j{f!JlIliI~. B'~e~1!i:. 356. 25.5. 150. 10.8. ;{jE1tit. 198. 14.2. 1060. 76.3. .p~~~. 413. 29.6. 160. 11.5. .i¥J~gr.~. 359. 25.8. JJ.j{{±~. 10. 0.7. Rit*. 68. 4.9. m~. 10. 0.7. ~.~Ii§]. ~F1t::t*tillil~.. 149. 10.9. 209. 15.2. 91. 6.6. * 11i/M:I i¥JA ::k1ii-*11im :iI:~*1l'l. 187. 13.4. ltim::t*tillil~.. 414. 29.7. iIilli!'J~.. 234. 16.8. ~F1t::tM:~it.. 38. 2.8. 320. 23.0. .im::t*~it.. 82. 6.0. 118. 8.5. iIil~:li.. 56. 4.1. 97. 7.0. ~F1t::t*Ji.. 17. 1.2. 15. 1.1. ltim::t*Ji.. 25. 1.8. 7. 0.5. iIilJiA. 17. 1.2. 580. 42.3. 1![W. 46. 3.3. ~&Jml. 107. 7.8. *~~. 85. 6.1. 1l*lh~\lft. ftfliJi. 34. 2.4. B'~A. 438. 31.5. *it:ill*tlC. IJ\*. fjJ.pfjJ.tillil.p if!Ii.pif!li.. _flI. ** iff1l1iJf tff~ I§mrftE.~fi~. tlfE~. 53. 3.8. 'iII;/!. 562. 40.4. Jtlf~. 129. 9.3. .ptillilA. 320. 23.0. ~~.~~$~. 305. 22.0. /F~i1l. 59. 4.2. JtUtt(Q~.. 176. 12.7. tff~. 12. 0.9.

(13) ~m~I;UiJjH~~!¥J~.IZSI~--"{iE~1I82~lf,m-R~ ..rMJT. ~5. PX;l1J.*ft~'ti~~. (I}tt5JU ~. ~. !7:.. tfiIT -. A~. "* r=l?J't::r.. 702 692 1394. 50.4 49.6 100.0. (2)1¥1t. 30-39~. 40-49~ 50-59~. 60~~L. it. . . jt. ~. I. frifi*,. r=l?J't::r.. -F1J1ll = 1.547. 52.0 48.0 100.0. ···ti. 20-29~. I.m.. P>0.05. ,f:!t<t>:!Ii!tij:R - 3& tij:. *. R. Alt. S?Ht. S?ttt. 228 432 310 146 278 1394. 16.4 31.0 22.2 10.5 19.9 100.0. 29.0 26.5 16.0 12.4 16.1 100.0. ~!E. *'. -F1J1ll = 137.686 P<0.05. ;ft * !Ii!tij:R;F- 3&. (3)im;@lii~. ;ft. t5:ft£1li tn 11' 1Ef r:p~~#. .1llJl1ljM~. 1r:tt* it. -m. tij:. *. Alt. S?Ht. 356 198 413 359 68 1394. 25.5 14.2 29.6 25.8 4.9 100.00. R. S?ttt. ~!Ef.:ff. 20.7 15.9 -F1f1ll 32.029 27.7 P<0.05 29.0 •;ft*!Ii!tij:R/f~-3& 6.7 I 100.0 I. (4)• •. ;ft. I tf-m- I. j~~'. *. tij:. R. ~. Alt. s?ttt. s?ttt. I. 1220 160 1380. 88.4 11.6 100.0. 91.9 8.1 100.0. I. *' P<0.05. ;ft*!Ii!tij:R7F-3&. 93.

(14) ')4. .i!& #'i. *. ~. (5)~t1fWll. ~. *. Att. s7H~. 187 414 * 234 1JJif11JJJlaI§!llif1 320 fii1iif1fii1i1ll 118 f-4 **Z,HLt 112 A 1385 1=1. 13.5 29.9 16.9 23.1 8.5 8. ] 100.00. 5fdtti~*t<{. IJ,. .. m. n :. P<0.05 7.3 5.6 100.0. ~*Jlij.il;l:iI/F-~. AfiVI'.(tt. Ni : A~iJlf1<JifJ:.tt. ni : A~iJlf1<J~*tt ~ •• f1<J~*ft*tt.~~*6m~:. rm r~ •. ~_~~f1<J~~.~~,*w~mllil~.~~~~J\ .~~A~~Z~~J\. • J\. rm.~~~~~~J\. r~.~ff.J\ r~~~.J\ r~~.m.~J\. r.. ~~.J\ r~.J~~tt,~Am~~~~~ffAf1<J~~o~. ~~~.~~.ttf1<J.~M~M.,~~.~o -,filij.W1laq~~. ~.~~~~.~~-~~mA~~~~ffA~~~£~~.. 1966:12) ~*~.W~ r ~. ~~ J ~Am~.ttz- , mLll:ff:flBtRf1<Jm~jJ ( ~.~ , ~83 I2Sl~Z-(Converse,. 0.

(15) ~1I~[%!2:~t:tc~B9~.I25I~---"1$E[%1I821¥!Wm~~.~tJT. ~ 6. (l)'I:!t}3U. f:OCIjJ.*1JO.ft.*ft~II:!t~~. ~. 1*~#.tiW:. Alt 725 669 1394. 52.0 48.0 100.0. -F:HtR 0.0001. 52.0 48.0 100.0. P>0.05 ~*-~iij:e-~. (2}&f~. ~ 20-29~ 30-39~ 40-49~. 50-59~ 60~1;.,tJ::.. lIT. it. iij:B. *. Alt. S?tt~. S?t~. 404 369 223 173 224 1394. 29.0 26.5 16.0 12.4 16.1 100.0. 29.0 26.5 16.0 12.4 16.1 100.0. ~W:. *. -F:HtR 0.002 P>0.05 ;fl*-~iij:e-~. I. (3}jml'lfl[~. ~ il'~~~~. ~~. 1t Ea. .p~tIt'#. JI-mit\iiM$ j[ Ap. :re *. (4 __. lIT. :if *~' ~r~ it lIT. ~. iij: e. *. Alt. S?tt~. S?tt~. 289 222 386 405 93 1395. 20.7 15.9 27.7 29.0 6.7 100.00. 20.7 15.9 27.7 29.0 6.7 100.0. *. iij: It. Alt. S?tt~. S?t~. 1229 152 1381. 89.0 11.0 100.0. 91.9 8.1 100.0. ~. ~W:. *. i. -F:HtR = 0.002 P>0.05 ~*-~iij:It~-~. #.tiW:. -F:HtR = 15.996 P<0.05 :if*-~iij:e~-~. 95.

(16) IJ\. '*. fJJr:pfJJ~~~ ~r:pf.lj~. JIi. f4. *,*litljj: A. J1ft. 1=1. 1* Att. * s5Ht. 354 237 352 147 126 1385. 25.6 17.1 25.4 10.6 9.1 100.0. R s5Ht. -HJ:. ~JE~*. 30.8 19.4 26.7 7.3 5.6 100.1. -¥-:lJ{J[ = 74.150 P<0.05. 1**W-HJ:R/f-Jt. --. ¥) °m-M•• ,~~~~~.W~~.~*.W_~'~~ffl .-W~~.~~8_*~.o@m~~~~.,%~=.~~. W,. llt~tf~~~~~~8_jj~¥Jllj.. ,. ~,UMmlli~ffil!1tZyg. llt*1i1f~?Jl:f*W - .~m ~ mt~ 1t~1Jf*7jllj. ~{I'~~ r~'m!Jmr. {I'~ ~ 0 7t1~~8~m-~ 0. I;§. 0. :. Fl. mJr,,'1~W~~.' ~~.~~.~~m. Ji!i. 0. ,. '. m-~~/Fm-~ ? 1F1*~. Io7t1~~8Am-~. ,. 5 7t1~~li. (j1fJJffilmJili~ 3 ~-FJ=f). Fla. mJr~'~ftMl-~ ~.~7t ?. FIb. ~~.~?. Flc. ~.~?. ~j1fJJ~~&.~~7~~'~~~7~~-&M.~~8o. ~~. 8 ~m~~~~lli : (1)~j1fJJ~W~~.~~1Jf~1iI~~~. .W~.; (2)~-*~~~W~./F7m, l&~y!~1Jf. 0. ~~~-*~j1fJJ~m~w~.~7t,~~~.~*~.$~~.

(17) ~1Ii1~:J:§!:~~.i¥J~.IlSl~---./1tE~1I82&fDm~iI.~f1f. ~7. 97. :!itIDJ~ti'=:'.~!JlI¥J&JJI~.(N =1394). R.Jitllt. liR.lIt 7t It. N. 0. 26 6 24 48 57 516 170 141 90 18 55 245. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ~&~*. .:If :i5JIt**. %. 10.1. 6.5 1.2 4.0 17.5. 4.9 1.1. 5.2 9.2 10.1. 31.5 6.7 4.4. 2.5 0.6 3.1 20.8. 44. 289. %. 99 45 58 70 58 221 55 38 30 6 13. 700. 7.1 3.2 4.2 5.0 4.2 15.8 4.0 2.7 2.2 0.5 1.0 50.2 4.11 4.67. 4.61 2.11. 5.59 1.88. ~*~. N. %. N. 65 16 73 128 140 439 94 63 35 9. 1.9 0.4 1.8 3.3 4.1 37.0 12.2. if ;I;. ••. *~&~~~~~m·m ,m~,*~o .:lf:i5J.lfif,~&~;f!f~7wt.o. **wt•. ~. 8. :!itIDJ~ti'=:'.~:£JiW¥~l¥JilMi~(O-10)~(%). 57t~T. 57t 57t~. fIIt&~*. *.&~~m. R.Jit:l:. fer :I:. 11.5 37.0 34.0 17.6. 30.4 31.4 17.4 20.8. 23.7 15.8 10.3 50.2. •• '~*W7t·~~m·m~·. .. , {l1JJittllWi. ,. WiA'i'~. ff'f,fi~~~lIo. L. 1iR.:I:. ,. !1F7H~3.1 % ~~B93'i:~. 0. ttIt£*X*.

(18) 98 *w~~r~.~~~~~J. ,~~.~7~,~~~~~. ~.~~:5t~"*~~~.~~:5tFJf1~Z~ ~m~~~~~.~~~. 0. *FJf1~z~AlO. ,. If~. ,~~~.~~~~;&z,~~. -10, 1f~~1il~~~~~.~~~1!, ~~~:I;~fI~~ o:5t,~~~&~~~~.~~:5t-.,~. ;. •• &.o.w~~~n. ~~.~~,~~~~~~~~,~~n~.~~~,~~~~~. .Am.~Am.~~~~.o~~~m.~~,#~*.M~A ,"Jf{~~.o .~• •. ,. {{£~~~~ M-~z~~. r~.~~~~~JM~9FJf~o. r ~.~~~~~ J. , :ff18.5%~~~.~1! , :ff49.7%~~~.~1!. :m1r~~-?Y~. fI~~~J. , :ff31.8%Jlfl~• •f1ljm. m~~1f.~1if.l€l1J~-·.1~~A,. 0. t£ r ~.~. • •k:ff.m.tt~ao*:ffIf~tt~~a,~* • •. i~:ff~n~'~~~~1i.~~ t£*W~~rR':l:f~~ k. 0. , :m1r~:ff~;f§IUJ~J!g 13 :. (l)rR':l:fKlb : ~rR'~~m~1J~-1lBl1~~A ( ~m~~) (2)rl3'~Klc. ?. : ~rl3'~1i~1J~-.~1~~A ?. mm:itiJ!g,~~1f~@l~,~~~lOlk~l1oIZ5lA*W~~~1Iitt. ~W~. rsfl '. ,. ~~if~~-~JE~arP. '. FJf~*~rPFJf1lt!1~~.* • •:ff. .?'!ffEmfi~-arP~~~1i;mffA. 0. :m'IF~t£KlbJ!g~. ,. Wt~~. ~m.~M~Aft~,N*~mJl~~.~~ • • ,~ • • ~~~. 10. 0.

(19) fI(; 1.11JU~ tI!:~Uj;t1!i!!1¥J~. f5l t(-"~ ~ 1.1 821f1j rP tiH~.~tIT. *9 :5t It -10 - 9 - 8 - 7 - 6 - 6 - 5 - 4 - 3 - 2.5 - 2 - I O*~. 1 I.5. 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 6 7 8 9 10. 99. ilIii .~111 a9 ~ Me* %. N 9 1 1 2 7 29 16 17 1 62 I. 56 350 116 2 146 6 104 I. 63 I. 0.8 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.7 2.6 1.4 1.6 0.1 5.7 0.1 5.1 31.8 10.5 0.2 13.3 0.5 9.5 0.1 5.7 . 0.1 4.7 1.8 0.7. 52 19 7 15 1.3 0.2 2 1.1 12 100.0 1394 it lIT ~~: *~~~~~I.1~.~~1¥Joc~:5tlt~* ~~~.~~1¥Joc~:5tlt **~OC~~ ~ 0 5}lIT~. 35.4% l€&~. JJI!. 0. ;. 0. ,. ~31.6%. J£if!;.PfB~~fVj;f~/F!I!it@:t&ilifrn:liMtt1~-f.iLf'*~A,. lclI~, @l~lm. 7. iIT.Klc;&~:liMtt1~-.~~A,~. r 72:7 J. 1¥JA,~127A,. I25IJIt , *:)(1¥J7HJTWf;1~Uf]Klcli '. , fRtEKlcli , ~q~-® A,5tflT. l€&. , f.!Jf[J.:f£K. R~98A,t&72:. '. ~;Jik1!f1¥J. 0.

(20) ~10. 5't AA"=- PJTtG:aq f~:iliAJiJf II! ziSC. N. !I1~.:j1!~'.B 1I~.$li1fE. 384 49 3 252 15 1 27 49 2 127 26 272 1207. !11~.~~ ~~.:j1!~'.B. ~~.$li1fE ~~.~~. ... Jr.:j1!~ ~. 1i.~. T /F~Jtt. m. ~. A-. tt. lOt. ~11. 5'taa=-tG:~~~- .aqf~:iliA N. !I1~1;. 469 12 285 2 28 23 98 57 223 1197. II~I;~~ ~~.. ~~.~~. ~. I;. ~.~~. T /F~I;.JI. m~ AlOt. 31.8 4.0 0.2 20.9 1.3 0.1 2.3 4.1 0.2 10.5 2.1 22.6 100.0. lIT. j:iMt1PJ.1'*:ilAi¥.J~.tp. &1.9% , lOC~T?HIT' @]~. ,. % 39.2 1.0 23.8 0.1 2.3 1.9 8.2 4.8 18.6 100.0. IZ5Jj:iMt~.1k.4ftUUif.;ff* 9A~2.3 %. r;E\Y J ' r ~~itt1'*:ilAEfT.JIt. J.

(21) ~1l~~N:)UR:~a-9~.~~{fE~1l821f:,*m-(l:f~$i*tIT. 101. J~~~~*~,~~r~~.~ff • • J~r~ • • ~. &r. ff• • J f!g*}jIJjJA r II~. J ~ r ~ • • J f!gJ!Jltffi~o. ~.ft~.-~ .lWlI~~JU:!. ... *)(lV.r~*~. 0. m.II~.~~ • • • • A~.~~rM. J l:1f~iti'I1:~~?. f.Itf*~~*12. 1)t**~~~. 0. .~~.~.~'~M.lWlI~~JU:!'~~~~ • • ,ITffm.~~.~, lW1I~~~~~.. -0.84) ~12. ,. ti:~~.Z.~,. :m. (ff!g.A. ( f:f:!g.A2.51). 0. 1£ r ~.~lIaq.Be J ...tZmlUJ~~. A lt. lJL~lt. fJ$~. ~~.. 286. -0.84. 2.76. II~.. 481. 2.51. 2.70. t. m. IUftt. -16.37. P<O.OOI. =' ~•••AW.ziUe • • A*~.m~ffA~~~~~~~~.Z-o~m • •A *~,. •••. .;j-~ITff~. 1971:7). ,~ • • ~~m~~ • • a~~. •••AmA~.~. , ::r-1f1~.A• • ~fJiJ.~lt±:~fJiJ~i[;(J!(Bone & Ranney,. 0. Page~Jones~~m.~.1~.A~lWfJl. '. .~m~~.~~. w' ~*~JJi:tE19721p~19761p*.~ , .~.f~.AlW1I~ • • ~m~~.~~.jJ ,:il*~.~~i[;(.m~(Page. 1979). 0. PJJ!1~.A~~.-m~PJ~m~~~~.. 1I~1'*.A~~:/JW. Iml'ltmr:. ,. and Jones,. 0. *~~:jIili 1\Jj{*;lJQ IV. 7. fW ,. :ll1\Jj{~.

(22) G1.. ~ftl~:tE ~1r':iii 100 llm- "P. '. jj~ -Ul1!9(i~tA t21ttfA ~:;J lfX.. '. ~~--'Ul~~At21t1$jff:lt!!:1rJl. :fi*,J ? G2.. ~~l~:tE~1r':iii1OO,*m"P. $i? G3.. 1t~1!J:tE~~:iii1OO,*m"P. '. j]~-Ul1~~At2~.,. /F:1\:". '15? ~.~.1!J:tE~~:iii1OO,*m"P,~-Ul~~A~.~t2*~~. Xl!tJf.? GS. 1t~l~:tE~1r':iii1OO,*rP"P. ,. ~~-1JLf~~Af~$~~~jJt2. 5.9l?. G6.. ~~1~:tE~fI'~:iii1J,*m"P. '. ~~-fJLf~~At21t1tm~Xl!t. ?. ~~*~~~~~tt~~~,W/F~*W¥-1OO~~**M, :tE&,*m~~~1!J~.*.m/F$,/F~~*.~m~.m~~~. • • • m,&.~~t2&~~~~.tto~~~~~M&.m~~ "P,~m• • ~~.A~¥~M.~~~A,*~m.~ • • ,~. ~~~w.~r~.~~A%~~.Jz~.o ~¥-M.~f~~AJI8m;~.. ( 1t I!::HT~~.) , J{UMt-r 1 7}- ,. A~~.m;~.,~~67}-J~Z,*.~~.(1t~. ~) ,~.~~.~~A,7}-.$rul~67}-;*m.~~~~A .~ft!!. • • ~ • • •. ( • •A./F$ ,. /F~30A). $ J ' r m/Fjff J ' r mjff J ' r /F~m J ' r 7}-. 0. :(!Il~m-~~ , 1~¥IJ7&13. 0. r ~/F. , J. '~~-rO.

(23) :&~~ ~~rH~~~~.I3I~-"iiE~1l821f:JlrTr ~~.~fJf. 103. *13 Pfi.1~:iltA.JT~.zf3~~Mi ~J1t. f~ 1Jj A. ma~. f~ 1Jj A. N. 0. N. 797 174. I. 2 3 4 5 6. 57.2 12.5 8.0 7.5 4.3 5.9 4.7 100.0. III. 104 60 82 66 .1394. 1;tr. ~*.~~~~~. ;(£{S{.pzrd1. ••. 58.0 10.7 8.4 5.9 5.7 4.5 6.9 100.0. 809 149 117 83 79 62 96 1394. W:.~.M ••• A~%.Z~.'. 0. ~~~-~~~~ ••• A%.~*.M*~ ••••A% .,.~wrM •••A%.z£mJ*.'. •• ~~ •••A%•• ~; •• ~ %• •{!. 0. ~Im-)1:.qt.14. •• ~. 6*,.~. 6*;.~.~ ••••A. 0. ~~.-~ ••mMM••• A~.~~rM •••A%.Z. £m J. ~J!.L:fl1ft!i.~tt£J4. 0. t;£.15.~W. :. ~:fl£J4~. ,m. •• ~ •• ~ •• A%.~~~;& Z,~~.~~*~~ •• ~~.~ •• A%.~.~ ••• ~. M~~.~,ft*~.L~. ~o.~*~.~:fl~~~ • • • A~m~~~o =.,m.Ui;e.iI¥1Iz~. t. IH,'. ~1.ll!'l'1m~W.{f~.1.ll!iIfU(responsible party theory) ~. L.

(24) 104. l!& ¥it. '". 'fI Wi.f~JIiA~.Z~JEe:. ~14. N ~jjg.1i. -6 -5 -4 -3 -2. t. -1. 0. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6. ~ 1I~.1i. 96 49 69 66 90 100 465 101 83 82 54 73 66. ¥:1!f ,ti.N.iHt~(issue votjng)~JjU~JH~. Z. ,Jl:lib§lf~ift;lt~{,\jijM(policy. mpbell~Amili. :. 6.9 3.5 4.9 4.8 . 6.5 7.2 33.3. 7.3 5.9 5.9 3.8 5.3 4.7. 0. JiJf~.J[!H2:~. , iii1§'. preferences)fffif1::jt:f.\(~i:k:~. .Mf.\(~~mJEl;.rF"fIaJ{~{'t. :. 0. Ca. 1It.M&\~fli:iI. ~~.,fffi~~&y.~tillt.M~M.z • • ,~&~~~ift. tillt.:f!~~~~.:sLJ;I. 0. (Campbell, et al.,. 1960:170){fi:;lik¥:1!f~tE. .~~ift~{,\jijM\ti~.A~:f!.:sLJ;I~~~\&ti~.A*A~~. {ftz!Yl ' 1t~ilijj~-'IIf5J!t~'U~-flaJf5J~ , ~~~~!J. 0. fffi~f.\(~. i:k:~~~:;Iik~.~tiA~ift~~~M\ti~~ift;lt~rr~~{ft,~ ift.~~~~f5J~'jI&~ , J9T~~~*,J. r ift~{,\jijM J W r f.\(~i:k:. ~JZ~~dft~.'&~W~o~~m@~f5J,~mtE.~,. £~ffi~r.MJtif.\(~i:k:~~~.,-H~~~~,~~~$'.

(25) ~11~~:&~t}c~l'fl~W~~--"fff~11821fRrP-R~$~fR. ~15. 1iMi~.zjJl~,. 105. 1£ I ~.f~jJl.AJf~~z~1le J I¥-JttIlrB,. ~~. A ~1tt.. ~. 286. 1iJ~;i;. 481. -,¥-:M3~. ~*~. -2.81. 2.67. 2.01. ± ~ )]'{ IZSI {JJ 1£M':/Ji!mftt. i¥J ffiiH~~llml.E.. I.E.. til[. mUiti. -24.38. P<O.OOl. 2.63. 0. *1i7f1E{l!;j{l±HltJJiJl*~.q:ttlt~r~ i¥J~~. '. ,. ~~~*~~~tlt.MB-.i¥J_~ofi~i¥J~~~:a~ • •¥ -.i¥J_~tlt~~,a.~~~.i¥J~~Ao. l£*~.W~~.q:t'.~~~~~Ai¥J_~.;j{mtl • • ~. _Jfi JR.Jl. 0. 0. *1i7f1E;j{~JJi. : (1)~~~f* , (2)~A1f~ , (3)~ ~ q:t~jG~. fi{/,~ i¥J r,,~~:tmr. :. (1)l£~~~f*_Jfi:/JOO. , ~~~.l1~-.i¥J_Jfit~tltM ?. (2)11~~A1f~i¥J_~~ ?. (3)~r&m~ ~ q:t/J\*jG~JR.Jli¥J_~~ ?. ~Wi~tim - ~i¥J&~~:D~*16 1f;f§I'~i¥J t~*~~J1!. ,. 0. 1f£**PJ ~*m. :(l)-=.~.. jtJt~~ ~ q:t/J\~jG~JR.Jli¥JM~. , (2)~. ~.;j{mli~~~A1f~i¥J_~,m~m,~~~§,~.~~~ ~~i¥J~~. 0. ;f§&:lm ,. ~~.J{UN~;j{mtlt~mi¥J_~. 0. l£*x*~~,.~Wi~;j{~¥-_~~~~.tltM~,~~. 1* ;. 1P.I~:lm. , ~~H~ffi%Kii.tltM~ ,. B9~~*:tm*17EJT~. 0. ~~.z;)\~~. ~M'f,If.~1!W.~. ,. 1* ' :tmllt , ~.. ~~Wi~;j{~~. ,. ~~1!W.

(26) 106. i1& ¥€.t. '*. ~16. -ll ~~. •• ~W.~.~=I1tm~i5!: •••. ~~~1*. ~A1¥:lir:. 1I~.p/NJ~. %~:*... N II~;I;. N. ~;I;~. •. 315 244 22 3. ~/G~. 10. ~:f1I1;1;. if. ~~Jlti!&~ ~/G;t. ~;ft~. /G~:it. m~ A. 1=1. \IT. 22.7 17.5 1.6 0.2 0.7 0.1 11.7 6.3 36.7 2.3 100.0. 2 162 87 509 32 1387. ~17. ?t_ 0 2 3. itiIT. II N. 937 261 124 72. 1394. 206 464 13 0 16 0 140 86 422 37 1383. 14.9 33.5 0.9 0. 204 254 9 0 14 0 132 107 623 37 1379. l.l. 0 10.1 6.2 30.5 2.7 100.0. 14.8 18.4 0.6 0 1.0 0 9.6 7.8 45.1 2.7 100.0. iiJij.:tE=-I1ti5!:;eI¥J~'" ~. •. ~. jig. ;I;. %. N. %. 67.2 18.7 8.9 5.2 100.0. 834 260 199 102 1394. 59.8 18.6 14.2 7.3 100.0. _,~w~~~~~~&~~,~m~o~o. •• ,a~.~~.~W~.~~ •• ~W~,~~rM•• ~tw1lz~m. J , ~.m -33?:+3 ,l!1:m[tl]. • 1* ; l!1:jJI[tl] + 3~. , ~ffilil ~.1*. 0. 3~, ~ffil!1:~~~ •. ~~f$AA:I5L. ~~~ili,~.~tw1lL,~~~~~~. '. ~~18. •••~IiI~.o. 0. ~*~.

(27) ~~~re=!:5C~fk:~!¥J~.f§.-1tt~~82~!trP~~.rtHff. ~18. m.iI&jB~lIz~ie. 5tli£. N. %. 3 -2. 102 131 202 652 154 81. 7.3. -I. 3 +1 +2 +3. 107. 9.4. 14.5 46.8 11.1 5.8 5.2. 72. •• a~ ••m.M.~.~~rM••~~.z£mj~~ ~IfFlfi£A? *191ri~lli~~£A~. 0. ~:ll.~3tf;1-1!f:tE*~.. ~.~~:ll.~.*~~,~~~.~3tf;1-1!f~.~~*~~~o rm,tPf~jj~. ••• ,~~~~:ll ••• A.lli@~~~ ~JIt~~r",~M~}.(% •• .p-Jj[1itm:~~.~, JtJtI:::tE.p. ~~~+A.~~ (j<j.~,. ;k:~~ft* ••~OO. 0. .~~~$.R~23.9%. ¥~~~A +.~-Jm~*{t* ••. ,. ~:ll. , ttl;Att1~~$"F~::f~ , I2SIJIt~A~}.(%Jt1t. ~~I2SI~~~£~r@~~~J,~~~*~*T'~~T$ffi. ~. 0. Elfl;A~. ~A +-.~=Jm~. ••• Jt!f '. ¥Jt~$1~{~.A.lli. r-~-@Jl;A.ft@~~~~.~o~~A+=. •• M~.~fi. (j<j~~~ ••. , •• A~~.lli~~.~,@I2SI~:ll.~@~~~ ~~.~.p~~-,ffi#~Iri,EIf~~~Z*,ffiMmff~ ••~ W.poI2SlJlt,~S.. /Ii]. 0. (j<j~~~.,m~~~Tm.~~m~~.

(28) 108. 286. -0.97. 1.46. 481. OAO. 1.41. -12.71. *~~.~M.~**~~,.illA.~n~~ .~. 0. ~1F~~r",~~j{Or. P<O.OOI. ••. ,~.~. :. H~@.~*~~H~,~. •• ~~~.~,.~.~ •• ~. ~~-.? (1)1i'~.:fL (2)1i'~M. (3.~~~:k~ 1~~ ~.:fL. (4)~~~M~~~~.. (5.~~~:k. , ~·'lftBW#CJE.:fLl'!.. (6hkit~~~M. ~~. ••. A± ,. *~.~.~,~.wmffio~*.~~:.M. ~lt~d>. , 4Hti4.3 %'&2.8 %. W#CJE.:fLl'!M- J ,fti32.4 % , ~~~~.JL. J ir{Jf~ I. • I ~~~M ,. ..¥.~::£~ 17j(it~~~M. :il~~;l!. ;a:~. ~JIl:fL. ~~~~M-. 0. •••. ~. I ~~~M , .'lftB. I .'~.:fL J • I ~~~M ,. J ,Jl%!nO.4% , ~ I .'~.- J. J ir{JfA I ~~M- J ,Jl.IHti27.5%. J ~11.2%. 'mIfA1:I!~8,!t;l!m~~. 0. I/F.. /FJIlJA±o ~~;a:~::£.r.~.JLJ. • • l%'. r.~~M,~~~~.

(29) ~ 1!l1iI EMlU~UJ;!:~~ ~.l25J *-~ Sl\ 11821F~f!i~liI"'l*tT. ~20. :¥tati~til.it~ ~.nt. % 2.8 7,6 11.2 32.4 23.2 4.3 0.4 2.1 3.8 10.7 1.6 100.0. 'N. iim3lil1l:.. 39 106 156 451 322 60 6 29 53 148 22. ~j;f ~3l* tH~:JE raJ 3IiI 1l:.. 71<. it~j;f~!l7\ ~j;f~!l7\,. 109. • • ~~~~3IiI}'[d.-. .j;f~!l7\l2A~:JEraJ.-. .m.JtfikitJe. f~ iii f& ~ Je. ::f~JI! ~ A. 1392. I=l. r_*_M, ••RN ~~~~~~-J.4*, r.*_M,~~ ~~ J.5 *' r ti'!1C~- J ~.6* ' $ll:ultlil ±5/lt r .'~~~ J3?:±5/lt r•.~ .-J*~1iI1*3?:6*,* ••••• ~~-o.&.A~~. ~~J.2*' r~._*_MJ.3*,. Jf.~~-rwt~o. .~.~. 14?. •• m.M.OO.~~r~~ •• Jk~~ •• ~. *21.ffi~~14. 7EfIiJ~-OO. ••. 0. 1l~.OO5i:*~ lt~Ji.OO5i:*~~.[Il]~. o. li.'fii5C}(f~ffS. r i!&~1~1f: J (political. trust)~~Il.$ff~1iffJtk. ~.z-o.~muoo.~w. , :;I!:I:~OO. ••••:;I!IiI~Il.~.*.ft.1iff. Jr~JL'(Survey Research Center, SRC)~1958~31lli. 0. -=:-t$~*. '.

(30) 257. 3.65. 1.29. 421. 4.15. 1.01. -5.18. P<O.OOl. ~affl.#.ma~ma.~.~~~MA.~~~ • •AA~~. ~~~~)~*~am£~~~. ~~~~~~~*~~~~~. ~O_\-+¥*,.#.m • • • ~~~afflma., ~~JjjtWnam~1~1f::fj~-llttr~. ~ M~1~1f:WnaJff,. ,. • • ~~. f9tl~Q~1958¥1fifi:75%. 1El.¥IJ1980¥ JU~tJ fo.lt125 % (Abramson, 0. 1983:12, Figure 1.3)ii'ifafflm1f:• •MJL\Jm~~Jj~~~~~'Ut·W1JJ :fFa:::t!f.::pt;fI '. R~/G~nalti3'&~~.~~~*. 0. (Miller and Miller,. 1976) ~:i!!t~.~x**jijFJf'5I.~,"~. ,. *~~~. r afflm1f:. J. ~~~rJjaJff~ma.J,±~m~A~Jj~~aJff~~~~~ ~:J1F~1f1~JL\~MrT5i:#i~.Jl;. 0. *~~J;1~an.!i;fli*.$ll1f~~~. ~~.~MB~~.,.~~~~affl~~'ii'if.m~mM*• • M~. r Jja,iffm1f:. J. 0. .7'\:lra!~nr. (l~j~~aJffmJ:E:m*ajfilfi¥. :. , It/Glt1f. r ~~~m:tJJ: J ~{Em. -~~~~~~W?~@/Glt~~\/G*lt~.\1flfi¥lt~ .,.~~1Itlt~LI?. (2)~r,,~ 1&H{f/G~IH~aJfftt ffi:{E.ml:~fIi~l:FJf~~~. mm \ /G*;ftf1~ \ .ilJm1~ , )I~~l!mm ?. ? ~~l!/G.

(31) ~IIJ~H~fltJJUfc~as~I!J2SI,#--"tft~1I82'¥~·m~iU.~f1f. (3)1fA$t. :. i!if(R'f~$1It1it:mHi!d~¥tlJj~., ~¥IjJj~.. ,. III. XftVc~:i!'/i. a9M1f , mJ!.T>J!IWJ;l'mJ~$t.~ ? (4)1fA$t. : i!if(R'f J!ff ~ a9 ¥ *$.J! iE 1Ii a9 , mJ!.T>J! fPj ;l':i1Hi$t. ~?. (Sl1fA$t. :. i!if(R'flL~ ~1it~.~ stl':EJ!ff~jlj a~r&~. , mJ!.T>J!1WJ. ;l':@:lI$t.~?. (6~ IWJ.T> 1WJ;l':* :gfH~ i!if(R'f 1rAtl5J!mIt, ::F -t"-kf5 a9 ? ~~ti:AJiAa9&~:tUl~22J!ff7;R. 0. :ffE~22PJj)J.~tf:j. :. ~~ti. i!if(R'fa9~ff.~::F.,ft~tii!if(R'f1rAa9~.0~&MIt.q. W'1f-¥j)JLa9~~ff~~a9~~oXi!if(R'fr~~~aJ,a~ ,~1fJ!ffM,.~~1f.R~ • • i!if(R'f~$ftVc~~:i!tta9M. .~~~:@::Ama9~m(~~)tl5J!-~a9,~J!~m:Am~. nX: r tii!if(R'fa9f~ff. J ,. ,t.ffi. -12?t.¥12?t ,. ?t~$, ~7;Rti. i!if(R'f~ff.~~,iE?t~$,~7;Rtii!if(R'f~~.~.,~?t~M%. Jt~23. 0. 1:E*~r:p. *iE?ta9~~. ,. , tii!if(R'fa9f~ff.*~?ta9~~ , ~1~53.9% , rm. ~f~30.6%. ~~tii!if(R'fa91~;[,' • .T>~. ,. tii!if(R'ff~ff.a9f~.lt-1.21. , li7;R. 0. • • fi~ • • ~*M.a9~~,1:Ertii!if(R'f~ff.JL1f~~ ~?~*~~~~MLa9Ii~**o~*~~.~~A~,. to..... ~R'ff~ff.. J .f~ , f~. -. ~1f~ff.. '. f~.Ao.20. 0. 2.81 ; rm~*1l ~.f~~A~. Jt~24. 0. rti , tii!if(R'f.

(32) 112. ~~. .~rtiaR.e.J*.~~.~~. (1 )iltJM#c},E m:kiltJfi Ilif. ' 1t/F1tre. IW 1I;fiI:;q;c tEjf! -11. 58 260 266 338 184 284. 4.1 18.7 19.1 24.3 13.2 2004. 1390. 100.0. ;t~LI. *~~/F. /F::k1t 'II %. 1Iif. :m1it1t ~&. A I=l. lIT. ~:~&~~r~~~J' r/F~~J'. r 1E~ J , IZ1.T. *~ffilo. ~F! /F;flHj§f. /F::kffi{j§f -'¥ff!-,¥i! JJl1iIffiff! ~F! ffi ff! 1!W&. if lIT. 49 238 453 325 114 211. 3.5 17.1 32.6 23.4 8.2 15.1. 1390. 100.0. (3 ~ /F ~ ffil ~ iltJMf$: $= j:;: fliR:* iI tt lIT. I¥J l'& ~ N. -1F! ffil # :flll'iffil~ ~F!. • l'&. /F::kjaj~. ~F!/Fjaj#. 1!W&. if lIT. %. 292 399 4 289 50 357. 21.0 28.7 0.3 20.8 3.6 25.6. 1391. 100.0.

(33) ... ~mI~~f!i(~fRj¥ag~.12l*-tJ£~ml821f-1Mi*~.~fJf. U~~~~. M.~.*$.~~.~. ili/f~~.. ~*~.. lf1fMiUU~. :ff1il6~. ~ •. iii. Jfl!.{. ~ A. \IT. r::l. (5)~/f~~~.. N. 85 507 8 360 160 268. 6.1 36.6 0.6 25.9 11.5 19.3. 1388. 100.0. r .M'~~lfiT1it71Ht1fid:wr~f.IilJ~m~ 395 425 2 216 61 286. % 28.5 30.7 0.1 15.6 4.4 20.6. 1385. 100.0. N. iii. ~. •. :ff1il6~.. iii .. ~ ~*~. ili~~. ~&Jfl!.{. A. \IT. _r::l. 113. J. (6)~/f~~~.*lilH?t,§ ~~~jt~i:'~~ ili/f~~. . ~&Jfl!.{. 298 476 2 231 96 288. 21.4 34.2 0.2 16.6 6.9 20.7. \IT. 1390. 100.0. ~*~. 'I'll M. 7f,f. :ff1il6~.. iii. ~. •. 7\ ' i&j~9;!I~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~@o~~~~~.~~~~.,.

(34) 114. ~. #l. ¥Ii. *. ~.~ID1=1f. ~23. I !tiE,t{1f.f~~ffS J (N =1304). ?t It. N. 2:!l. -12 -11. 7 7 12 19 39 45 65 96 96 91 113 113 201 92 99 59 45 28 28 18 11. 0.5 0.5 1.0 1.5 3.0 3.4 5.0 7.4 7.4 6.9 8.7 8.7 15.4 7.0 7.6 4.5 3.4 2.1 2.1 1.4 0.8 0.8 0.4 0.4. -10. -. 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9. 10. 10. 5 5. 11. -sr-i'S]lt. -1.21. 4.11. ~*£ ~24. N~~.~~~,~I!tiE,t{1f.f~ffSJ~~~~~~. ~jilfa\. lI~a\. A. 274. -2.81. ~*~ 3.87. 458. 0.20. 4.30. ~:I:1J.. tiE!. l«:i='jj:. -9.76. P<O.OOI. •• ~mm~~~~,.~.*BI~WJ*••• mo-MA•• ~~ ••••• m,~ •• A~~~.m¥.~~ MA*~.m. .o~~@~.~,~~. ..... m•• Zm~'.h.~~m.

(35) ~1I;i~U~:&~fR.IW~.I:§~1t£~1il82~'*rt.f~:iIUil~tff. 115. ~u,~~~~~~.~~~~~om~r-~~~.~~0~,~ ~~±~~~~~o~~~~~~,0~~~~@~*~~~,~ ~~~~~~.fi •• ,~~.e;~&~~.m~w • • ~~@. .m, ••~~ti~W~~ • • ~~.~ • • • ,~n.~.ffo il~. ,. ~1t!iFd11!~.~~~~~. ) 111!J~.m1,*.A~jtigJ(Jf. J. 0. (Rey. nolds, 1974: 134) {fl~~~~$~igJ(~~~4t. '. 1j~.~~~~~*~rp'l!*lItuJt. -~AigJ(~~~~W~)g.&~~.To*~~~~OO=~.OO. f1=~.~Ji!1!1§ ~m1J. : (1)tiigJ(~~A!fm~~~~. ,(2)ti4t;k;ilt~itffllJ~. jtigJ(~:il&W~l&~o. *~~~t.llttlli:l1tl!~n~. :. 1. ~rp'~. : ~~~ft.~'igJ(W±m;~!~-W 'I. 2. ~rl3~~. : ~1I~1f~tt~~i'il ?. 3. ~rJ'l~. : ~:itUt~{£i'il{£'I'±m; ?. 4. ~r,,'. : tt~!I!~ff~~-EH~ ) &:'~~J!:il&!~-~.~~IWJ;@: ,. ~n{f$?. 5. !~-~.~~.*m~~?! ?. ~it~~~ti:i!lil![ill~ti.~'It%~1l*25m~ 0. ~*25;f~~. :. )!~JjigJ(~A!fm~l&~ lt~~. ,. {flti~igJ(itffllJ~. Tm.lt~.,ftjt~~~.~,~:l1t~A~~~*Z-o. a~~~Jj~- • • l*,~.~.O*,~~~ttligJ(~~~. il~O*,il~5*o*.*~,*~)!~~igJ(~~~*~o.~ :Jt:~. ,. ;f~jJJ~*.*Mi,It%~~:I:5].~1l*26. 0. ~**.Z. : )!~~.

(36) 116. i!i2J€t. ~rn13t3jZ jSj ji!D~.Mt: /F ~. A1~O:$}. .~. , R 1~ 2.191'19 3jZ ~ It , Jt 9=t;ff m::J:$} Z - 5!l1'l9. 0. ,. ~1rs.~1Jt~~.l'I9l~!H~. ? ~iIT~~~31..Mt:4!!€lllf'li~A. 0. ,. :(£. r ~m~. J. J!~27 0. 1::;,~±:fJ(1i~icJ. .m~~I'I9 • • ,~~~ml'l9.fi,B~/F~.~I'I9 • •. 1991i¥.JI:(£-67 zlY11im. t:l'_~:Em:. ~lJmff~~ ~ifUl:Em:. 1T ~ I~HEU~ {iiHI rDl. '. *;lJoM[iJ%Hi~H.j'[. ,. oft. .Mt:f*~. N. %. N. 774 886 527 537. 55.5 63.5 37.8 38.5. 620 508 867 857. 44.5 36.5 62.2 61.5. 327. 23.5. 1067. 76.5. %. jij]~ff~ jqln~!;lu:t: z;{l rDl. :. r~J*~§*~~'~~7,~~~,m~,*~o. ~26. 3::1I~~:i!if aq iE5l:j~~ ~~1ffl& l¥-:l5.J.. (N=1394). * • o 2 3 4 5. N. %. 369 195 205 227 227 171. 26.5 14.0 14.7 16.3 16.3 12.3 2.19 1.79.

(37) .~.W. ••••. ;, •. .fiNG/;ll.¥H1Ul}~~. ;'W~~&G/;l.~~'~~G/;l~.~~.M. ... N•• Y~~'~ ••m* • ;,~. .fiNG/;l.m~.W. • .fi. •••Y~·M. ~~~.m.~'*~.~. I~ • • ~. •• ~0~fu~ • •~.G/;l~~.@~ •• Y~~' •. ~.G/;l.'. : ~Y~~. ~~G/;l:m~. !. ~ • • ~~$f(~G/;lt?~!J1!l.¥~. : ~Y~'U. • ~0~fu~'M.~.G/;l~~.3j:yl¥l}~~~:~y~·U ;'Wri~.. ~. , &*YG/;l~~~.ijl •• ' ~it~j./,:ltG/;l~_ : ~Y ~ "If :. lif~Jt~ lID. ~J ij (1) :. I¥l} fj]~. 0. 1I!ff,*(v) ,. 1I~J~(£). ~~?j. ,. iI. , 111$ ij ~~(6) , ... !$ 4trID~::f ~ G/;l ~ ~~~*M 1{1¥l}fj] n~~w}~:I£!:sjz: o~¥#§.tIl.G/;l~m~4J:lt'~. ;WEfl (Z:£:17L61. 's~uu~a). r. 0. ~'jlf~jI(W • • *Bl:G/;lit~. #§.t~~a'~~G/;l.it~~*~*~.~~~.::f~J~m. L ti~j:: , g.!F- ' :It ~ f~ M~ ~:j!:It G/;l ifffl·.!y # ' :\f. I817 90' [. ~O'O<d.

(38) ~IHl:lW:::j!f~:i~Jm:1H!I¥J&.jm*28m~. EE*28~~~U. :&. ~~. :. -ftN'}~U~ti. EE ftJIIm ,. r ~~'ffi-T. J~. ~28. 11M,JiM. J. ~~~$~l$f~A. 15},. 0. 0. :ff~5!I¥J~~~ ~-1P~~-. , tEf!7aM. ~J1 ~. 7afl.. r It'IfM J ~ 0 5}, r -ftN'Ef:!& J ~ I. ~.~tfj~tI9~±lIm:IlXIiiJ&. N. %. 452 432 495 13. 32.5 31.0 35.5 1.0. 322 495 558 21. 23.1 35.4 40.0 1.5. (2~'~%*. 318 455. (3)11 tit B<J ~ fIt!. 610. 22.8 32.5 43.8 0.9. J 1. i&r€i B<J $ ~ ffr~1f ?;o ~ B<J A*~:!oc411-MA~1f.~ (l)?;o~f7tT (2)~tIf%*. (3)-JiBrs tr:E. n. i&r€ill~B<J0~~* JIflfJ;' ~ ~ iUlJ. (1 )~1f JYf~iUlJ (2)~tIf%*. (3}~~iUlJ. (4)*~, m~. J3.. 5i1f jJ B<J ~lHttrII! ~:!OC M-B<J~fIt!~][~. (1}5i1f jJ B<JtaMl. 11. J4.. fi!:~1I~-M~IBiB<J. litiS (l}/F1I¥. 188. (2)~'~%*. 419. (3l11~. 771 16. (4)*~, m~. *r~tIf%J~ffi/F-~'*.C\~.~'/F?;om.o. 13.5 30.1 55.3 1.1.

(39) ~lIiJiB~~~fk:~I¥J~'H!5l~-~~1IiJ821f.Dm~iB.~iff. ?}-; J2tfmflf§ ?}-, r ~ ~ $J. EI:!.~. 119. r I.HfYf~$j J Mi 1?}-, r If'/f% J Mio. J f.I€t l?}-. ; 13 ~ ta.~ r 5i;(f jJ f¥.J ~JH!B. J f.I€t. 1. ?}-, r lftif% J MiO?}-, r ~~f¥.J~~ J f.I€t 1?}- ; J4$J~.~ r ~~ ~ J f.I€t-. 1?}-, r If'/f% J f.I€t O?}-, r ~~ J f.I€t 1?}-. .*iEff~UE:l1i. 0. 1m;l!f¥.Jliiil ( ttm ) ~-~f¥.J , !2SJJltWfImIi:fJu®*, ftt$; r ~.:E. iil~1oJ. J , ?}-ltEl:! -43?: + 4?}- , ?}-It®:~ , ~7f,~.:£.iillt~ifIi '. jt?}-Mi'/f%~U~29Yf7f,. ••. 0. ,fi~ • • af.l€tm.f¥.J.~,~r~.:E.iil.IoJJ~;(f~. ~~? ~*§,~:i!f.l!fiIT ~IU'f'I1~~. ( ~~30) ,. aMi~:ii.f¥.J.. ~jt~.:E.iil.IoJ(1.22)~~af.l€tll~.f¥.J.~(O.59). c. }\,~m~tI. ~~*f¥.J • • ~,~~~~#~~@~.AT~~~o;(fA~ .~:ii.f¥.J~~*.~.~~~~~~~.~~f¥.J.~,.;(f~~. ~29. ~.~~.~~.~~~~*~*$ (N=1351 ). :fr It ·4 ·3 ·2 ·1 0 2 3 4. N. %. 8 33 99 144 322 233 130 122 43. 0.6 2.5 7.4 10.7 23.8 17.2 19.2 9.6 9.0.

(40) 1.22. 283. 1.83 4.56. 463. *~*o~~.~ ~, £M3~. : 14). *~~~.~. 0.95. 1.86. •• mn~m.~.~.w • • ~.o( • •. ••. ~.~.~~m*:. ~ft~m*~13tJ~:t1Q~31EJf1K 5%)l1U~11iHN*$~. tt..$.$tf:\. a. :&30. /F~ll! ~. m. 1392. A hl. lt~.$lt(42.. :i:.~IDJ~a9~m~1EJ 428 593 303 58 11. r:p~A. :. 0. N. r5lttA. 1it*~m~lftf:\. , ~~il.A1E~*~A ; g~11it r il?ttA J ~. r *~A J ili:1O%. .$. P<O.OOI. % 30.7 42.5 21.8 4.1 . 0.8 100.0. a~~~g~ril.AJ*M1*' r$~J*M2*' ~AJ*M3*,*lta~,.~ ~,~~~fi~mM~a~~~,. r*. •• a.~il.,a.a.~* r.~ •• JL~~~~?~.

(41) ~1I,.~tIt~fJc~w~.ffl~---'11t~1I821f:am~,..~t1T. *~Ji;fHlfilH1:~A. II E?:.;W;ilf '. ~fg{ rtu. ~MtE?:.Jit.ilf. 0. r Iflll J jt,~. , ~fg{rtu r €1'?lt J jt,~. (J!~31. 0. 121. , ~Mt. ). iL'tili ~~E?:.Il~~A~~~ • •~.m. •••. ~,€1'~.J!~~n. ,. L~W,~~~~Z*~~~~*.~L*~~~~~~oz~1l. E?:.;W; [7']$Z±mt~~~F±mt~Z * ' ~~.Z~~ ~~~tE[7'] , :Jt:Jt~;W;z1t~~~ , :fIAfi~;~'fA~.; \PJ~~. ,. 1f~±!gIl:*:fI. I;A;~~'ltA±~± , M£. E?:.JiUtJffi)ti¥U:fI-.@;~~'.~.~. A~~*~~~,~*m~~~~.~~~.@~~~*~,~~~ ili,~~E?:. • •m.~%~M-~~*'f • • •. ~~,.E?:.tE~~.~.~,. #. 0. 1JI ,. tEj{&~~1iJf1E1fl. E?:.82~ a ;. '. o. .MMm#• •~1t~~~. ml{~B"~I6"jJ. (. ~.~. *:JfllJit ' E?:.73' 74, 751¥ ; ~fJt '. ,. ~1El~. 1i~ti, E?:.75~) *1iJf1E~~'f • .f!}31UA~~ti1~ ~WJilf~'f.tt{¥lj~*'f.88.2%. ~~~*tJTj\§J!. l.lI! ,. '. ;~'f.lO.9%. 0. ;. ~FJ. , E?:.73~ ;. *1iJf1Emq~. , J!~32. a. *1iJf1E~'f.I;A~fil!~(dummy variable)~. *~' • •~ 0 , ;~~' • •~. !l31. ,. E?:.78~. 1iiftiifiJ.Z.~,. 1,. *~ilf~Tm-.. 0. ?&~.f!}.~~. r± r ~m.i& J J:.ztd3./UJ~~. Aft£. 3ff5J.. R;~I;. 280. 1.66. fj*~ 0.70. IJR;I;. 461. 2.12. 0.73. tm. IilftE. -8.51. P<O.OOl.

(42) 122. N. 1229 152 12. 88.2 10.9 0.9. ~m.~~~,~~.~~L~~~.?. ~~~ ~. 0. ••• ,*~.m~,~m~ •• ,*~.~ffi. ~A. (JVlt33). 0. +, ••• ~~~~.~.~mti~.n *~~~~~~~~?~*.M~~~~~~~~~?~~£~~. .•. ~~A~A~.~&~?~~£~~~.~~~~~~~~?~ ~.~ft~~.,~~.,m.,.M~~~. ~~~.~~. ~~~?. *M~B~L~~llin~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~R~B~7~~m~.W~. ~. ,. •• ~mn~~~~~~.~~o~. 7r~~~.J*,~.A~~~.~B.tt~~.o.~. mAfIBl~~.~~fi~~.~~I¥J~~~~. 284. 0.02. 479. 0.18. •• ,. 0. 0.16 -7.77. 0.38. P<O.OOl.

(43) 'ftflll~~~;WHJc~B9~.fl;jlt-~~fIll821f:"1P~~.!~HJT. fft:li!*1jJf~Jj~-tV I.2.H1V\.1M!J!.tFA §. J!. '. ~~. 123. r f\t~foJ. .~~AJtFA*J!.,~m.J!.,f\t~~~• •AO,f\t~~~. • •A 1 , *34JYflR. ~fN)m.Jttfi. ,. l2.{~MmJ\.1M!J!.~1{I~~.j]. 0. ~jIUQ. 0. • •*~,a~ • • ~~~f\t.*.~A1M!~.~.~,.A ~.j]~~.:fftm1M!. :2)1-fl.. .4849) ,. .~. , *{kA : (1)1-fl.1~~A~~Z~iE(fi z~RE (fi = .1935) , (3)m.i!i5c~~{J( Z~. ~~Mm~. ••a}\~~.~M~M*~ .i"U~ag~.*.(DPP=O, KMT= I). m.~~AJ~~z~RE I m.if¥flz~RE. iiJUtiff(J! if¥1J( z~RE. i!i. ( *~' =0 ) ~±1J({j!*rPJ. tJitJil!Uilt ~MjjtJiit. If ;tJff1~1£ ~. 'lit R2 N. •. b. fJ. t{j!. M~tt. .0650 (.0046) .0295 (.0061) .0316 (.0102) .1238 (.0468) -.0113 (.0077) .0023 (.0128) .0120 (.0209) .0052 (.0036). .4849. 14.18. P<.OOI. .1935. 4.18. P<.OOI. .1096. 3.09. P<.OI. .0829. 2.65. P<.OI. -.0449. -1.47. P>.05. .0056. .18. P>.05. .0184. .58. P>.05. .0476. 1.45. P>.05. .5436 .5301(F = 79.46,P<.001) 573. tt : AlI:lliJttl~.9" , ~Dt.;jIf~Tm-. ' iitJiJdttfi;jlf R~J573A. 0.

(44) 124. i!(P=.1096), (4M!f~fHP=.0829). 0. ~1P5lH~ l:J!$3(AI0W11 I¥J Il!HI~J!t. ,. ~i&lii)jJJ?tfJT (discrimi. Ji-zt Tmi~Jm1l~J!tPJM-*1I~~?t~~UU;11~-1I. nant analysis), ~J!I¥JIEi{H~*. '. 0. ~1P53i,n~MH~!m1lflJ!t,r;)jJJ i¥J!P:1jIU11. ~J!t.~BlFiJ J,;),IE1it7t~i¥JIUiHil:t*. ~i¥JIE1it7t~*.Z. ,. *35. ,. !J)\HP.~Jli!m1l. , 7Rnf~35(a)(b)(c)(d). -*.J!tIE1it?t~*~f~*ffltt. ~ ~iIt. 1m1l1!~~.~HUlU;fJ. ~. jig. :I:. 11. ~. •. ~. Ii ~. ~jig •. m~;I;. 213 (74.2) 58 02.0) 199 (31.8). 74 (25.8) 424 (88.0) 427 (68.2) 82.87%. ~jig •. 11~;I;. 195 (80.0) 115 (26.8) 244 (57.0). 49 (20.0) 313 (73.2) 184 (43.0) 75.67%. iE1!i?}"@C$. ~. •. ~iIt. ~. jig. 11. ~. ~. • • ~. iE1!i?}"@C$. ~.*. : (1)PWJ!f~~. (a)WJJ;f~~Am~z~lEf!. •. 0. ;ff~A.. 286 481 626. ;ff~A.. 244 427 427.

(45) ~fiI~~t!U'H~~as~.l?Sl~-"~~1I82e¥Um~~.~tJT. 125. (c)PN.lIi!l:Jt~lIz~H:f5:. ~. .~13l: ~. ifg. ;I;. iii. ~. ". ~. &. ff1j. ~ifg;l;. 1iI~;I;. 168 (58.7) 82 (17.1) 184 (29.4). 118 (41.3) 399 (82.9) 442 (70.6). 73.87%. ~ifg". ~~;I;. 277 (97.5) 394 (82.1) 558 (90.3). 7 (2.5) 86 (17.9) 60 (9.7) 47.49%. iE$5HJc$. :ff~Alt. 286 481 626. (d)!8.. ~. .~13l:. ifg. ;I;. iii. ~. ;I;. ~. &. ff1j. ,!E$5tlfC~. :ff~Af!t. i. 284 479 618. i. A~~Z~RE.(82.87 %) , (2)mlt~1Iz~RE.(75.67 %) , (3)m.J§i(J! ~1IZ~RE.(73.87%) , (4)i!f.(47.49%). 0. .~M • • ~.~~fi~,.-M~.~~iE.~.~ • • •. tt ,. ~lfj-.~~~*36. 0. 1ft**nrl1{1~%1: r ~ltf~~A~~Z. ~RE. J Jj~~~;J:i~f}(• • ~trnJlUJJ. '. nr~82.87% , 1t:tt:1Jn r m.. ~1Iz~RE.J~r~.J§i(J!~1Iz~RE.J~,~*~.~~~.* ~~:tt~,.~~:tt~mM • •Jjm.JJ~#.,.~ • • o@1t. *~.~M • • ri!f.J~,~iE.~.*~:tt&.o.~.

(46) I. m~u~.. m~~ii. .~ii. (I)m;l;f~~AI *~z~1fE •. I. ;I;. ~ IilllI. ~. ;1;1. ~. Ii. ~. ~~;I;. m~;I;. 213 (74.2) 58 (12.0) 199 (31.8). 74 (25.8). 424. (88.0). 427. (68.2) 82.87% 25 (l0.4). 352. (82.3). 178. (41.5) 84.94%. iE ?i(iH:HJ{ $ (l)~;I;~~A. ~. ;I;. m. ~. ;I;. ~. Ii $. *~z~1fE i. (2)~;I;1ft'1WZ ~1fE. 218 (89.6) 76 (17.7) 251 (58.5). !. iE1ii)}~)~. m?JIIJ••. m~ljii. ~~;I;. m~;I;. 205 (84.1) 52 (12.1) 205 (47.8). 39 115.9) 376 (87.9) 244 (52.2) 86.52% 27 (11.3) 352 (82.6) 183 (43.0) 84.77%. *~z~1fE (2)~;I;1ft' 1W z ~1fE (3)~;I; lit Ji 1ft' 1Wz~1fE. ~. ~. ;I;. m. ~. ;I;. ~. Ii. ~. iE1ii)}I{$ (I)m;l;~~A. *~z~1fE. (2)~;I;1ft'1WZ ~1fE. 1Wz~1fE. (4)~.. 286 481 626. 244 427 I. 429 1. 1f~A.. .~ii. (l)ffi;l; f~~A. (3)m;l; lit. 1f~A.. W¥. ;I;. ~. m. ~. ;I;. Ii. ~. -. iE1ii)}I{$. 214 (88.7) 74 (17.4) 242 (57.0) . I. 244 427 i. 429. i i. 241 426 425.

(47) ~~~~~~~~~.~w~,~~~w~. ~m. '$~~~*.~W. ' f?mlnJl~~flt.:w~Jl[-~~:wJti! ' ~«¥:If!~*3:r~. '£. o~~~&*f•. • /flfu '. trbt1iiN~~nm!f±~i*iMW-kIf. y~~}.~. Btt '. J /flW. 0. (6~. : 3:rZ;8~ ,. ~t~l\J&*f,?rtfl:lf!~¥Jti!~. '. ~i£~ii~. ~¥f~. ). r :ilif~~~~. f?nm!f±~jl~IF~W. r :ilif~~~~Y~~}.~ J 'Z; o f?IE1W~jl~#. m~m~~~'~Jti!~~W~~~~IF~.Jti!~Y~~~~o~ ~~~trw'~~~~~Y~~~:WJti!'.~~~/fl~~o~*~ .~~~~~~~N~~~~W~~.:wtfl~~~,~bt~~~Y~. f$4II:WJti!(I):. 41IY~~}(~)'. ~~~f?~1t~W. ~Wid;j}~. 0. ' tfl¥:If!::sIz:37: '. f$4II~Jti!(£)'. f$. f$4II¥::=~~~1ii~2i:lf!:Wj} 'I. :.M.l\J~~IF~~g~~Y~~~~_'*.¥:If!::sIz:• •. ~. ~~ '@ o jlJ;!J fu~#m~W~ , Y~~}~. .~~$~.%Z;'Z;~~ 'Y~~}~:Wif~$N.%8'Lv~lFnm!f±. '. ~. ~r~~~J~f$~1iiN~¥~~*~~~~~W::=~'Z.~. /fl. 0. o. %6'L8~%I'v8~~~*.~~3I~.~~~.if~.Jl~iiW= (%Z;~'98tr*~~~3I) ¥~f?nm!f±~~~~~~~~.Jl. ~w=~r:ilif~Z~~~Jti!.~J~r:ilif~Z~~.~J. '. ~. 'r. Z~~Y~~.~J~~i£W¥:If!::sIz:'tfl.~.*.3:r=+V~. /flWo • • •~~N~'~!f±~~~~N~~.Jl'~~r.aJ~. aI. !(f~.iHi-!!!~:4fl81l1¥l ~~ ~.~&ailft(f~~1¥1 iflll~.

(48) ~LlIZiI~. 0 (1ilJ}l!¥,1ZiI ,. if ; rh1:?Bi'.~,. ~80if. ;. ~Iii.. '. ~81if. ; *:k:!J? ,. ~82. ~82if) EI3~*)ffi~rjH~~., ~Jjg.~1llif!~~*. r+~,~~~~~~~~$,~*~jh~Jjg.~~~~~A~. ~~~.ti~o~~#~T.~.~ft*~~~olZil~~~~r~ g-.~,~.~~~A~.~.~~EI3M. •• ~?~A~~.~. Z$o 4. ~~IZiI~;tot~~~~~~B:~ ~. ,. ~~A +if~=)ffi~1~~.. , f.i1E~~~a)jMtij'[ , 19*~'n~al~H~*~:k '. 3&~~Jjg.1~.*fi1~23.9%. ~~~JL,(£~g(. ,. 0~~A+-if~=)ffij'[~~. ' f.i1E~. ~~~~~.m~m.~~~,~~f.i1E~~~ti~~~~.~., 8)t~~z.Mi!t'ti~~.jJ. ( ~fi~~ ,. ~82if. ~$~~.,IZiI.~~tt~.,~~~A~~. : 203) 0A+=if~ •• ,~M~~.~. ~Jjg.~,.~~f.i1E~~~~~~~~~,@ti~~~~.~.~ m.jJ*.~~To~z®&~A~Jjg.~.W~~Aif~'~~ ~~*~~~.,~~~.~.W~~~.~o~~~Aif~~. w,m.~w,.~~~;~&~,~~.W.~W~.~~~. ~,3&~~ti~Jjg.~~~~~~~~~~.,~~,~~*~~. .i!ttt~W~~~~.~.0~.~~~~*~n.~0~~.~ .~tt,®~.~nref.i1E~~.~B:.jJ~. ••• ~0~~.~M. m,ti~.~.~.#,~.~~M~o. J5 .• ~~~.~.~m~jJ~,.~.~m~jJ~~.,@~ m.jJ~.A~Mi!ttt~~.°ti~m,~~~~~~.~~~o ~~ •• ~~~~~~~~.~~.,~n~~M~.%d~g(~.

(49) r .,!iI; J ~nl1 ' :!!HHlfr~l3;pjii[iJ}Eill~tlf~ f(a~1f~5fl:fHii ~OO~ •• '.ii.Eill r.~Jwr~~Z~•• ~J 'r~~ Z.~.~J 'r~~Z.*Y ••• ~J :&.*Wo~~rn~ .ii.¥~ r .,!iI; J ' r ~:j;;ti~ J ' r !J;J4iiID.:f~ J ' r ~tU ~f. J ' r ~:f}~JJiJ:( • .Ji J ' r ~:j;«l~ J ' r ~~Z.~~ ~J ,r~~Z.*Y • •• ~J 'r~~Z.~.~Jrn~ o~~OO~*~~.~~~~~~'~~g• ••~~ ••~~M.~~~~~~~ • 00. 0. ... .~~'.~¥OOY. ~~'.iiOO.~~~~~~OO~. o~M~~~~U~OO. 3;hW• • ~~.:J:r=+V~~.Ji~'Jr~U~•• +.~U~*. ~ ~*'!tr. ~ !. 8S : :J:rZ8~. o (£OZ: :J:rZ8~ , ~~Jj , ~.~ ) L~Efla~OOf(~t'l~rn.~ , ~~~ •• '.*Y•• ~.iiW~•• m'v~. OOf(a~~.Jim~.Efl. ~~.ii*~'~.OO •• ~~~~'~ •• ~~~=~~.'~ '~~OO:J:r=+VW'-+V'+V~.ii-~'.iioor.~ ~}JiJ:(.g. J jfi{~ • • ' ~U~•• +~f!lf=:J:r+ V~1¥:I~ "9 o. jj,:$' ~ irHlt. ~~~••~~~*1¥:I.-~~o~~~~~~.OO~~~W~* '.Z~¥~~~~~,.+.-t'l~~~oW~~~vOO~_~ &,~~ • • ~.~tlf,;ti~-~~.OO±~~W~~. Im~~~~;ti~gij~W.'. •••-X. ••••~Y •• -~~~'.~. 61: I :!tt~Ulifif~.w \i1;h;1:8 II Jg~,--~ M.~Galif¥H~:?ifJg ifII ~.

(50) ~~m.h. •• *,~~~ ••••~~ •• ~m.h,H.= •. • •11it PJti~WJ~fF86.52 %~ iE$?t~$ m~ ~. 0. ••~A~re~~~.~£~~~.~~,tie~~~re. ~iE. • • ~o.~~. ~.~.~A*~~.#(%. ~)\~.~~~,a~~~%~o~~~~~~.~.~A~~ :fi!.*~~~~.~~. .•• •.. ( ~~~ , 1987 : 155 ; 1990 : 179). •.. ~.~~tE.t!J:*t!J::fi!~reilt~~.~1I!~~,tI~~ ~~. ~~.%m.~. ,. 0. ~1£. e.~re:@f.I. ,ti.*tt~.~~~.~a. ~~~$~~,~tie.~~~~~re£~~~~~fFmoft~~ 3-.~:fi!,~~~~~.A.reilt~fiA~1I!~~.~~,-. •. • *, •• ren~ ••• ~A~~.~~~,~~~~.~.~, ••••• tt~ •• a.re~n~~Htt0 )t;~mr,,~M ' Jl~e.~~re£~~ •• , ~£~ A.ij~. a XfFAiIt~~.~~,. -'rf~~~:. fill J~l. ffiI ~W.. r~~~a • • ~J,.~ • • ~· A-1UI}I!.~A~~~. ~73. ~74.. ~75.. 0. ••••. ,e~.~~~~a.fi. !iI~.~if:;iiJf~¥fi1!f. , *ililtli , Jt22-38. 0. r 1::;+=.~.fiAziiJf~ J i6!:iS• • , 12:123-188 r a •.~j~~ffiI#?ttIT J i6!:iS• • , 13:131-167 r ifi1:{-I:~~~a.fiA J ~r:p!ilaiit"'-t-L7p , fi.fTJ&M• •JtitM t-t."Jt. ' : q:t!ilaiit"'-t- ' Jt241-274 0. 0. 0. Q. 0. ~82.a. r 1'f.~ilI' ~~tE.*. aiit5t~;fI:I!iI~~f'ij-e~~tIl!a7€t}l!.~'Wf*. ,•• "tJMIII*ft!1!J. 0. e~~. , ~jg;ililtlit±. 0. J. 0. ~.

(51) , ;r;M~ : ~~~. .({rllt~~,,::,,. ';!iH!r?:*•••• If~¥til-~~.'M.23111. :;-ts"L,~. ~~. ~~.~ ''1}::f~. o¥• • ~:W:!M:*r.ifil! J 'W~~¥~ r !JH~jjf£,':I'~~C)l,1[gJiiUi~.~ J o l[Zn~*.~:W:'jfitm\Vf:J~ r 1f• • if.~il!li1JJm~. ,~,*.~ J 0. :W:~.yyg~:W:*~~~:W:til. 0. :;-t£8~. :;-tZ8~. I!l~ai. o. o 17£O-VQOOH-lO£O-Z8:JSN ' ¥If*~:W:'jfit.1li1l ' '':I' til ±el:if¥~ r ~*f.fiH1~~{]J!!!f=~~-'1}::f~~~Wm'ijlf.~il!~~.if J. :;-tZ8~. ~~.~. • it "Jr til ±el: if ¥ ~Il. 0. ~. ~!iH~Wli. 0. '. *. 0(1) ~ fll1Ua Z liI'¥f ilifllf: ~ if til. iff!li ~ ¥ II !!!f - ~ :;-tZ8~ o lZI-S"611. '(-li#¥.*M:.+·l:1ii'¥"~ r *fi4nmi1[$~lin¥~if!l!~~~ J :;-t8L,~. ~~f4!l!f~1f. 0. ~.~. *'. o. .Jj}lf*~±el:3{!~.M:1l. '. L,9-jrj; 11.. '. ~ Ii?. ~*f.iff!li~¥lll!lJ=~Wi"r-*±el:Z~.yli\i. :jj,J:~ifJHJ'ijIf.~ , ~~.fIj2~.. ' r liI'¥f~ifil!.h~.~ ,. [gJ~.~. J. :;-tI8~ JlUjj~. o. , ¥If*~±el:.M:1l. 0. rm'ijlfW~il!~.y.if. 17£0-1;00-H-I O£O-Z8-:JSNii~. r ~*f.if~~l!IJ-~:;-tI81l~~ : '1}::f'e1~~C)l,1 J '~~.fIj21f c r ,*~~~il!~WM~ 'M~ J :;-t£8'e1 ~¥~ o¥_.~±el:!M:*rfMif~¥~.. [$ • • ~m'ijlf.~JWM:~mtil~±el:til°r~~~.yli\i:jj,J:C)l,1~if.iff!li : liI'¥HAI:jj,J:~.il![gJtlUt~ , [$4lIl~HI}~~.~C)l,1~if J. ';tr¥!iW!!!f=~. :;-tZ8~. Sf.¥~. ' • • ~!Jf.I!. c. o 6S"-1 : n r ~~C)l,11ffMYIlJ.~[$4lI~1i1JJ : liI'if~.C)l,1'e1if J :;-t£L.~ :jI~~ , llfH/.\f o .~~.if¥til .y.~~23. :;-t6L,'e1 :;-t9L,'e1 o. .~~.if¥til. •. 0. •. 0. .y.~~i!1.. ~\WW ¥_.~±el:!M:*rfMif~¥~.~ • • ~ m'ijlf.~ j WM:+tmtil~±el:til. 0. r [gJ~~!iWC)l,1¥ift:t!nUMut'*~.~ J Q:;-tZ8'e1.

(52) Abramson, Paul R, 1983 Political Attitudes in America: Formation and Change. San Francisco, CA: W.H. Freeman & Company. Bone, H.A. and A. Ranney 1971. Politics and Voters. N.Y.: McGraw-Hili Book Co... Campbell, Angus, P. Converse, W.E. Miller, and D.E. Stokes. 1960 The American Voter. N.Y.: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Converge, Philip F. 1966 "The Concept of a Normal Vote" in Angus Campbell, Philip E. Converse, Warren E. Miller, and Donald Stokes(eds.) Elections and the Political Order. New York: John Willey and Sons, Inc. Dennis, Jack, et al 1974 "Political socialization to Democratic Orientations in Four Western Systems", in Lewis Browman & G.R. Boynton(eds.) Political Behavior and Public Opinion: Comparative Anglysis. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, Inc. Miller, Arthur H., and Warren E. Miller 1976. "Ideology in the 1972 Election: Myth or Reality~A Rejoinder", APSR, 70: 834-49.. Niemi, R.G. and H.F. Weisberg 1976 Controversies in American Voting Behavior. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman & Co.. Page, Benjumin I., and Calvin Jones. 1979. "Reciprocal Effects of Policy Preferences, Party Loyalties and the Vote" APSR, 73 : 1071-89.. Reynolds, H.T. 1974 Politics and the Common Man. The Dorsey Press..

(53)