制度選擇與契約選擇－戰後臺灣農地制度變遷之分析

*IJJf~~~~~~m-~~;:if}lmtili*IJll~31z

7H

IT

1

ffjr

l

11~1'W~*"J~f¥

rp~r&

• •

•

jt!!$rjll~~~7tffi

{PJ

*

SA

*

**

~

EB

* *

mi

~

*)(t*FlHJT*lmU~ij!f*zJ!mm t )t!t~

Nonh ( 1981 ' 1990) Z*

IJJl~~J!mm

'

f.t~

ilifJii

+~1f*S}~81j:~1IiIJf.t~5ItJDt)7TfJT 0 ~~*Xa"J7TfJT ftfr~~ffl. t

:

1f:£~~[9+1f 1t~a9l1j:ili250~

,

~~lli(~~

871f 2

~)of.J~~~)j1~f9HI~JIJ~[~~t*ili10( fi=i~Aaf.Jf.EI fflIJJtz~ifJlatili*IJN~31

'

PfT&B!!S'J~j&JffO".J1IiIJN~~WA~R'J~*'J~~zF~'

,

J--)SC~ *R.ft' ~~~li~tt~~~o ~~[9+~M.~.~a¥tW.lli~.~~g~~ fiE~~2!z~lli10(m~rtakJflHEBmIJJi

'

EfrHt1:Ff[PJl¥J~NmIHll1t""faf.J~m*5*

'

t:;~ii~~

i5'~ij!f~$S'J 0

.

~~ :

*IJ!!t

~m

'

~*J;;

~~

..

m

I

Jt.!t~~

..

3Z~f&:*

..

~~:tH~~1Jrt

..

*rrr~~$

"

•

~:rz

r%'J1Ltt

l1

~UfH3.j-t

x*~M

ffl~

W

ff

tii

IJ~

ff~

1-t*::t

f

i

IJl:

i£xiu

**j:

iliif

!z*,

W

1

f~ff

2 .$~mMH*.~. M~+~

~ ~=

Ira' , §~ ~

f.jlEl!I1~~~[9+~M1&tl"JlIti!!~1fi ' ~~17tj:~~~~~!t)(lk(~WlMJlj

,

~~

60

~

:

i!ff;

mM

'

E~fJ

'

~~

66, 67

~

:

~aBf¥j

,

rI*fT~W}!]~'I'

'

~~ 67~) ~'E~~1.ff~7.~ SkJt~~~$

,

-~j~ltJ~~~)(it

(

Cheung,1969

; Koo

,

1982)

~IJ~'E~~mff13

7

±tili.im(a~ ~ctl~$ 0 g~17t~ltJZ:OO~

,

~i&m-2i~~

: i&JM tl"J>gitilj ,

l:trh~ti~~l~p1T7}cJEI¥JI~ @.~~~W~$,~m~m~BJMm~.~fJ.~&¥ ,m~fi$m~i&JMm~.~( ~~

87

~ 2 fj)M~~*~JIH~H9U~~.IE1j[~&~ilifl;,{rh~Aa~filfHHMJl 0 -~j:~ftjz~~, ~-2i~~

: iE

3(JMtl"J1fYII

lj ,

l:tffi~~~3f9Jf~pJT7Jc:tEtl"J~*~ff~A~:f~ff~$

, 't:

~J;)m ~i&JM~OOftili"

• •

g

• •

~~.IE

• •

~~m~rh.A~m$~Jl,m~fi~m~~~ mW~~~[9+~M.~~fJ~~~¥o

1Ht~)(ltt~~17tW-~j:~~m~ZJ!mfBm~wgtJs1ft:fJt~

,

~!lt/.$:)(~~mtTffiIJI! @~~ZJ!~

, :Jt

~~

Nom

(

1981 ' 1990)

zmIJBt~ilJ!~

,

f.t~1&jfllJ:n+~~*a~ mttHiti IJJ.i~il1Jot),7t*fT 0 ~~*3tSkJ7tffT

'

ft{r~~~m~Jl

:

~~[9+~M1&a~~tt!!~~

,

Wi&JM.

m

" • •

~~.~*

.IE

.

~

~~ili

~m~A

SkJm

®~J.i'M&

~SkJ~

i&~~~1

~~WA~~~*~~mIb9

'

t),3C~fiX*m9lfl'

'

ff~llit]'11

(

interaction )

SkJm~f~ 0 ~~

[9+~M.~.~~.' Wi&JMftili~

• •g~

.m~.IE1j[.~~ili~rh~~SkJm@~1

, 't:{r

tij~:~:f~~~.NfliIHl~WrFtl"J~~*B*

' '2

fr~l$~f,f~~$1

SkJ

0

/.$:x

7tm!f@g~f7J

'

m~g~17t~M§ 0 ~~§~17t~flilJ!!Ui!ilJ!mfB

'

~sAi&JM8kJ~11Jt~mWA~tl"J~*"J~~

,

~ 1PJ~3<:~fiX*~~fI

'

,;m~lHtlJti8kJ~m1* 0 m~$17tNljt),m~*~1~ZJ!~m~~~&:~~1i +.~*~.~~~~.om.$fflmM. o

Ie '

ffilJ.mt~mW~m'9~m2fli1J'11

iJ3(JMa"JfliIJ

Itr!

% '

t

tttf.f

mgt~;g~~a"J~*~~t'1JD!-jJI1H*S"JT1it~~j;I'~8kJJ£1:~j

o

21t1J1t '

ftfrr~f.t.e~t~~~j\s"J~*~~~t;!Hfj~jC~s"JJ!~1~M~

,

~';JiH~i&ff;f~l1'

~A~.o*e~~~2

~fiX

*~~'~i&JM~

~8kJ

~ltImWftm

'

~*~i&~fl'~·~

~.n~~~m~~~ItI&m~~.mw~~ o

,

-'i&fffi~~~px:$

Coase 1937

~~~I¥J

r

Jiij[€ij

a

~*~

J

(The Nature

of the

Firm)

,

PJ

~~~

Coase

Jf-Wl

~m~

fI"J1~

~1'F

'

1fi§i'iX~f!

' Coase

~ Btl"Jt~

t±l

:

lfif{ijteJlO"J

~1tI

'

~

~ 7~1g

x

~

-362­

IIJ '

i\:~ 60 ~ ; ~m ') 21l}~:Et{>;l:"l7J1!1.$ • ~O~""" JJ:J..e. J ~~

t

m

ffE

j

±

Jth1lit

M\J

t

~~t~PJTrj(JJ:ff,JM~ ~W-H~i&Wf~1iiJftil[

(

: 0 -~JS]~Z~~, '~ff~~$

,

E

I:lJ

j;J$

t

'

{El.~~$m~i&jf S1!l:t*)(ti~m~~ll~

J

&

ifi91

li

+~~*~~

t-1fM1&S~Mtfu~l

'

n

&lJ!s~~i&Wf(fJ*il& iction ) al~m{~ 0

N

!:

iii!;)

m~rt~~.§.f

ffi

*

ll

li

)

*)(7t~!l!{~f5lH~ ' ~Ai\:~~*l~~ ' ~ z~mfum~~~~~~E

g:

iD '11

T

m

WZr

J'l

9

~t'i>JP.l

1:'!

!?f~

,

~\~~~~i&JM~'"

,

~~f-tif!(Jffft

A

) ,

1=iT

~f;t~

Coase

lfYJ.

w-

lZ§

,

~~

T

~1tt~

mIJ1.t~~W~~~m-lftH&.lII~:ttl2*IJJJ[~i!z

,

H

IT

3

:$:

0 Alichian

&

Demsetz ( 1972) ~IJmtf:jIll~~1:.iI (team production ) 1ffiZ*1':W~fD7t

f-Jflj~

,

m

t!1i~~~1:.£~~N:A8"J1jj1i£1:. j [!Jft ' ~~1ftlWl~1:.ilpfT~1:.Sl~~Jl1f

~16

'

{WJ1fjI~px*

'

~ti~~\~a"J

'

Hl&il~H~P~~'fl~lM~ApfT£1:.a"JrJH~ 0 Williamson

(1979) ~lg$~~~~1~izm~iii*§ (dimension) 1§fPfT~~

,

~fffi£1:.T~~i::f[P]ff~~tfJ ~m.,~*~~~~px* o ~~~~)(~·ft~~~m~~.~~~z-~ : i&Wflli If-Jm~' t!1~fi7.~~~~* o .~Z 'i&Wf~ill~i&fflm.' Et!1~.~~.,ft rrlMi~~~~if!(R1m~MU.&~rm ( superfirm) ( Cheung, 1992,p.57) , f'F~li'H~5$1!ilj1JSl*

" aWf~W~f'F~~~~a~ZMilm'&~~~~ 'ffl~~#m~tt~~li~tt~0

It:

M

'

~~lt~fIJ~ 0

tE-

AS

"J

iit

W

$ ,

Mz~#~~ff~

,

t!1:f~JU,¥-}E~fi

'

mf~0~M

.if=ASliit

W

t E!n~MilflWIE&0~~;f~i~~0~$~fir~~JHj

,

1EUlt~a'>J0~$tml=iT~

~m~~m~, ~ftW~.~m~ o ~~~~~.~~A~~' Am.g~~m~~.~ ~n±f.$~~tt

'

ttifID3{fJF0~$mt!1~f~~~~1Jrt 0 ~~ffi±.pxA~*~~ ' 0~$ mf-J*Jlfj!t!1~Z~1Jo

'

rJtR~t.b~1g0~$~~~~PX*

'

1B~il1:. jW~S1*~'ffi"'I~JJl*~* i\.~~$m

'

lltfiW~11s"JtJl*~Elnt.bpJT~~~i&Jff 0

ft{mt~ Coase pJT~~tf:j*S1:Q:~~*J!~

,

*m*"i&R1~1:.S1JJ~:lzg

,

~.~Wfft±"@'~ :~J!~ (social contract theory)

f

§

,iID1'tJ

0 ff[t1il~*~l.Irne~:gt.b(~iC~)llIH1

..

Elfljal@A~

7idtJm~;ffiWT1ift ( H obbesian jungle )

m'

~

,

t~ , W~lfl}(~~~

,

fr~TfHH11j

,

~Bl!l:t

~1ilJ~~~fF

'

j;)~*J!Ha"J~tj~

,

!l:t~[P]~~D"J~j~lj

,

E!nt.bfft±.~~

,

~}E~D¥A1Tffctfl ~r-Ja~*Jl*~E!n~if5(R1 0

aR1!!5tt.bfft±ff~~f.J

(

El

D

rtll

ili

I

Jlj

OJ1l.l[

)

z

1!ilj

H:ff

' x~ff

t±l¥l5$1!iIJ1J~~~*~

,

~llt

"'11X~~1J~!&fj1JS1~~ 0 ~~Jl~Ift±.l¥J~@~~z~1Jmfjg (violence potential)

7t

':f

ZfS

tS]af.J

1

Wr5rf

'

if

!l:Wf1

±1±

~~tE~

1J

~ffE7t~

1J

fID~~5m~~~!II~

rei

t'&

PlT~

ili

l

la

"JrJl

t ~~~.~~~.~~~.W!&m~S1I~ o

~~Z

'

i&

Jff~

1:.

8

kJ

JJj{Mi

3l

*E.S~~

fft±

W!

~

~

kJ

(~fl

ffi

'

illfD~'

~t~

8A "

f-!~

*

j[

, B.:

~

8S

~

,

~

353

ffir

)

t

{§

i&Jff

akJff1£~D~#m±

.

~

*l

t.E

W~

IJf1JIJtt=1!11~

0

4

j;)

~

~

px

*

tr.Jf(j~gffii§

,

i&Jft~1:.

I¥JJJj{[Zg

{

*~

j

~~1~:Q:~~*

'

{§i&R1fftEJ-:J.~~

,

ff

tE

W~~1ft

~~

px

~

~

1Jo~

~

~*a

l=

fj~7t

0

~R±OO~f~

Jj

M!

r'ffl

'

~

W1jfi1*&~

1J

rf§

ff~

7t

@c~

2f

ts]

,

.

~

px*~{

~

a

l

ff

ct

llpx.

p

JT*Jl~l¥Ji&

Wf

'

1t~

*

l

tt~11~1V!5tl1?!~

,

!Rlj

j!j

l

l'l1

al

~7t~

IJ

~~~

,

ff

(f]mIJLt

rt

ll

~~fi

~~~1~fft±

fl~Ua"J3C~px*

0

li

z

'

If:W1!iIIMM

..

ff

t±

't~~&

~1J

mff

~

ft

c?t

~C~JS] ,

m

,~

~

*

~F

~~

SkJff

rtW!

$

,

if!(Jf

HJl*~8"J!Rl

mlj

'

l

i~~~5m?a

'

m

~

-JE

{JJff

tl

~

f

~N8

1

0

~*J;;

'1

1

'

~

~

I

J

A

{r

'$D

~

~~~Jr!(

Jff

'

~if:1f1

Jl~IJslm;ffiWT~**

ii*1m

;

~

~p

,

~

&~pxE.S~

~Z~,aJff~$ll

• •

~s~~~m~~~.~

@~

A

~I~

'~

~­

~

.-~

.

m

M9.mt'i>J~~~*,mW~

i&Jff

ii*.mll

,

~

••

a~~~~*{JJ~~

.

:

l

4 ~a~mM~*

••

Q

m

=+M

q;tt~a"J?t*JT~

,

:ft{rrfiJj;)~/ij

, ~

~{{E3(~fJX*}l~, ffctfl~*"JJ!~~{{E~JFlJIJ!!~

8"J~~~:St;fJT

'

~1r~t~PJtE:i&JffM~f.%tJ1-g-fD5ifflWi1!i-8"J-lmI~tt3l:tJF 0 ~~~fiI.§i

,

~,

ifr±iWlfJX~~1f~1Jm1JE1JiliJ~W11~a"Jffd:ilfJX~

,

1t~3i$IJ~~1~3(~fJX*

'

l~;frJ~~~t)~] *1~o~~~JffR~M.~A~~m~fflI~~-.' ~~i&~~~~fif.%~~~t ~~

~~~

~

~

w=

~~~mW~~ofi~

~

~

m

~@A'~~~~·~~~

~~#~~

'm

A~*~IJ~~*1~S"Jff~-tl!'ffPJT~[P]

;

~Z

' if

)(~PJT~WS"JJjJ1fE~m1fE~z~~ Q

1f

T­

~~'*~~~i&~~

ffl~

~~~

S"Ja~,?t

mi&~~

~~

~~

~~a~.~

~.~

~

~

o

='

~1&~ffitlWft~~U~~75it2~*,'9~tI

tE~*¥J\i&~:&fft±~J:W~1JfJX~Z;fIJ~f~*1~8"J § fIM~T

'

if9:JffpJTfl{~a"J¥*J}] ~f.%~:fI-~1fi~**1fg~[P]~~8"'JMInHHIIJ 0 Efr~'EIf~

:

(1 ).l-)}t~1JfD1JU~IJ

S'-J

ff~

A}t:fI

-~1-r~~I{

1M

f~*IJ 0 (2)~~H-~~JJHt&fD{*~~~¥~1JfD11~IJ 8"'Jl~Ff 0 (3)Mm-~~~{~¥A1-rfJX:<$:l¥JilitiffiW{FffiJillfr~11lffP: 0 5

r~1JfD~JUIIJ~ffttfr~m"'J11~ff,x

,

~{~ifr±iJ~*"Jfl~ff,xW~S"JflZ~'M¥A

ff ' ~fjW

-~~JJH~

&

r:t:

1J

f

Dt

JH

IIJ '

U*11JEWOO1i~1IJ (&~IMiJ) a"'J~?$tj~(compliance procedure) 0 {§~ , ~:itfD~'fH~~~f§#~a"'JnX;*

'

~lI:t~ijJffEnt±Hc~IiW~~r:t:1JfD~J1.~lj

,

~~QJ1fE~~&

¥*1JtJ[~IJfF/ij7t~8"'J~1il

'

pJT j;)1:E~r*l~~Z9i-

' f/lt~ffii1E

~*B:s"'J~?J!

'

1:E~~~~~1.~

1-rffd:fl1~a"JIl~

, ~ffctW1fi.t~HElllir~-%

m~IJS"J-g-JJlliW0lE'11 0 6

r:t:1J~~~ljfD~?$tjff.~~IJX:~~*8"'J~R*1j , ~QJ1fEn1~7t~~W

'

ffi]illt~fFffiJI~J!f[IR 1lg~~RJiS"J~f~3(~fJX :<$:

,

MzAAr~rff4~~~nX::<$: 0

ItIlI:t

'

1fffd:flMIn11~IJZ9i-

' &:

,

t¥ftl,\

A~JifBl (public domain) (Barzel, 1989) 0 1f:L}~~jfBl4Jffi*;flj~~*1~S"'J@A~*'§*~

,

~?J:1.

~9i-1±Iil~H~{4~ffi]~1~ 0 9}1:E!i!JH~{4a"J~1~ ,

X

Wl?i3&r:t:1Jtl~IJs"'J~1~ 0 fb~ §

Z

'

@ A~{fJl~~s"'J1T~Wr:t~1:1ftIJ1:ERff~ra' 4JffW1LmtJ (interaction) 1¥J~~f* 0

iIEA~t

J1

*~f

lj

~t~7d

~R

"'J1-r~

,

~~$IJm\~I¥Ji&~i¥A

if

!z:ft~~~

1J

fJXffiJ.z

fI

J

~

.

1f~

~~

~ljif

9:mS'-JfiJE

'

I

'

1ff,f

0

1±~*¥Aif)(1f.~!H?fi

*

1~

,

~1:EtW1J

Dif)(

FffWi

A

' ~1f

{

lE~

rfft±~m

flJ

J

z~

ili

T

'

if)(Jff

~~]!!

~~

~iQ!iHl~ll

'

IfHffWJE~~

~~:tjftfi

0

i&

~T

ffifh~R~

it

fi

Tz~*"J~lH¥

'

~n~

mfff~~~

:t

il*fjS"J

17AZ-

0

INlI:t

' :ft{r~QJj;)g3tif

9:H

tTffi!,€~"J~

m

a"Jt:N::$:~IN~ffi*¥Aif!z~fIJ~tP1i*{~ 0 7

i&Jff!%

~

*

¥J\if!z:§-a"Jflli;ifffi]

Tf1lf~W~m

z~

*

"J~t¥

'

ltIffi]mfffW5J

~MgHj

0

I!l

~t

'

if

)(JffO"J~ffl!it£

~

1:Er~

~

¥Ai&:ftf

IJ

~~

*1tl¥J§

Hi~iWm

T

'

1J

~~~

1~

~~fJX:<$: , 1~ffr±~~~"·

-3 64­

ili

It

k '

f~

fffl

jj #~

,

if9:m

.~i:~~R*IJM ~§z, ~ 1J~ 'i&Jff~

Is

tion)

0 l&JffTffl~ l: 'i&Jfff.t~

•

it~1:Ei&R1S~ l1JD~fJTa"J~*1

!3

El3~1'S"Jij~[I ~ffii8Z' "'fiE7t~CIJ~~~ ffiif:~IJ&~

1

1J

@gzpt~

,

~Iji& 1f~~{f~~ , jB~j§~~¥~ 1HI1*~1'X:~ mfiE5t~c~W IfAi&~Wr1f

:

$iM:tJ

:I: '

~~ ti~g:nrt

'

i&R1fflT

ffi.

tnrEl~7t~ffij ~

,

~~$IJif!zM riiiilj 0 fI}~ , j

..(f.]

f~A~*J1

*i(

it

15rt

~

*"J

j ft~±tfu*lJt. IJLta"J~jI

,

f

~

ff;f

J.t

±tfuifilJI

I¥-J~~ 0

10:<$:>

,

hot)

{'PiJ~~

0

*'JJf~~W~¥J~m-~~l~i!tAJihffi'JI.t~~z?HfT 5

:tiftk '

{t£rmf£m~~tt1JD 0

:"JJ!~~

~~Ilt1!11J'~~

f;~

,

if!x:lff1f~¥P.if3l:%fft-Jflj~ffiimwrW;EBXmJ~M~tiB~

,

thIffi~~~R*IHI*1t 0 ~OO

~F ~~~WI~,

.~~.~~~#~A~ * '~~M@m~~.£.~'~~%f~g~~.ffio

iX*

'

1~fJj~HHJ~1i ~

..

~

~8Z

'

~~ffL±~zi&Yi:l*~~l¥Ji~~

,

~l1E~~~*~f7'l~~ZmtEft~f.t~~*~~ ~JT~S"J±.ft

'

~~Rl

3kJ ~RffiIHI*14:fjQJ

,

j~ 1J~

,

i&lffz*J:l~iQm~~~~~~ 0

[lgllt

'

Jffi:5t;f.tf~ff~;f~!'t91fltIJ

'

mfJ~~Ml

(deregu­

~~MZ~~

c1'f

T­

lation)

0

~~$jl~31ffi]2~~ i&lfFfffl~*/;JZ~~

,

51-l1!mtJE~1:S":J*6*~~rRJ~1lliJs~~tH~ 0 ~1IN~1l1'JJif5X$Z

I

'

i&J0~t~~~~mZTffl

'

/f'PJfJ~¥P.ffNHF"*jC~

,

lZ911t~WjJ::~U1Hl$s~@A~~11~

. it

"*

1fif3l:H1

o

"J

IJf.:5t;

1f

ffiiff

'

iW**JTS":JmfIJ~it

'

fJii&ffE.%*~~~fIJ~

, f/

1:EJJf-

5t;S":J1filt'j

1JDm~JTs":J1filtlj

,

~~~JEfa"J~~~M-r~mr5t;1fffi lj

,

f£NFx~~*ii-ti7~1JD

'

iffi

A

fr,PJ

!E~m8":JfjB[IJ~-tiJO"J~Y 0

i&

/ff

pJTm1~1¥-J£

~~~~' i&lff~ffi~~m~zPJ~~. , ~m.~m~~~~®~ofilJf.:5t;~.~

~~~~~fi

.fi~~~'

~IZ9

.

~ffii

~~~~~

~

~~

,

m~

~~~~m~B~

~~

~ffiiJ!~g&~1 ~

, ~IJ

~~nX$fI~:gffilj®i1N1JD 0 fi[lg~ftl!.9H'f[lg*

'

~f~.tJmfrbt~c~ ~~Zj!t~ , ~IJi&lff~1f*IJmtfE~~liIiJfS/;J~m

'

{£1~M£ffi)Z.W<1~~f~~jfti 0

~a.@.~~~~~~~~OO'~M~.m~~~'~~W$~.~~~~~.m

Af

T

' ~Ji~

~

~~

Jil!

_{'1~~~~~~~~~~.~~o .~Z, ~&.~.~rt~~~.MffiW~' ~~W}

ce procedure)

c {§.~,

It~~~~f5X*ft~~~.n~ o~~~~~M~m~~.~.'WB.~aff&.

l~l

l

' ih

::f

-mfiE

f.l

;ifi

_{fiE~~c~W{i~s"JiiI±\W~~ZflJ~f§r-rff~}

_,

_{flljf~1=I~;f.fM~~f§'&S":Jf:!)EII:± 0 ~fllJ}

_'

~~

,

1fJl~it~1llil.;! _{Hi&fffl1£{JE~if3l:fif§;E~m1JOm~~~:?¥;l:T}

_'

_8ft

_{Am~U~.n~S":J~.}

_'

_t

_J.B

_lff

I

*,J1J:i:

'

~!{t\:Wflj~~Ai&:ffIJ~~~.n~ (~D§*#iltIJ) S"J~~~*

'

f'@&;!liJ~j*m

~

,

rm~{!~.H~Jlmi.c _~~~~

_,

_{~fff.t~*~.nrti1H~:g*IJ}

_'

_{~1llIJ~~Wjih±~~*~~t~S":J§}

_EI3

0 (lHJB~11Z9~ , £,fj.ft l;'

~1ff1\%

~

Ht~*

~

~

J'5s:

\

iffi

nJEa":J~jih*

'J&:

~~

jih

i&U'i

'

~

¥

'

J

3(:~f5X*S":J~m

'

l

'

:ft:lJ

:

ltWJ

11~LA.:

~Ull~

,

~

_~

_~

_~

_jC~iffi

_IMW

_'

_&'ff1£~~~

_~Ji~

₁

₀

_~0ft

_~Ji~1

_r:p

_~*~

_*fIJ

_~B"J@lA~*1l~

_~1-r

~lj

B/;J

!'I

lt

0

~Ji

§ ;Z ,

l~

I

i~

¥'lif3l:R1

~

tih

it3l:m~

~xs('

li

B

~

,

3Z

~

~

I

tfeit

3l:Jff~

-

&B"J~fflW~1llIJ

'

~~l{t(m

Jffi:)Ic

1*

c

ItlJ

0

~~

,

i&Jff*

IJ

~e"J~

Ji

1-r

l~Jf

'

Mz/f'~

~JEe

"J

~~

(

North,1990,p

.54)

'

~

*

fuj*

~

1J

f5X~Zflj~

,

!

~

_I

_A~m

_.

_'

_.

_~~1llW

_~

_fi

_~Jf

_~~~~fi~~

_~ft

_~

_o

_~~~'BJff~

_~ffl.

:

A

' l}X1±

1

.@ii

r

W

d:

~

_I

_nA~*1~1

_'

_p

_JT1Ea

_"Ji

_M

_Jf

_'

_W

_@

_A

_:&J

_JHlR1T

_~F~'ffWE]W

₈

_"Jm~1*

0

t

m

0

i£

!x:!ffT

mfkfi

~

/I"

ftlJ±tih

*

IJJjJBft

~i~~

~~

~

,

Mi~~

E.%

f1.W

'

£$J:~

@

A:&JJl*~~ff!9

H

'f

l

~Jl

r

J--)~i£!X:

0ffHl~~1~

_iQ

_tr.J~j!

_,

_iffi~

_*fIJ

_~t~*f

_tS":J*5*

₍

_iX~WT

_'

_~~

₇

₁

_~

_,

_~

₁₄₆

_1!~~

₁₅₁

_{Jr) ,}

·r

f.t±tth*IJJi

Ed~*~~~

rt~

*

~~

lH

~t

Z

~

Hi '

£

*

J:ihj~

Jj!i~¥Jii&=l3~*

~

IJ~

f~*

HJT~

~~~jfHI

0

~~t

.

~I:

0

Jo*

)(~m~g~{5t

Em

l-

)

~1&~i1!J~

j:tl!.

*'

j

J.t

~iI~WU

'

ffl

*g~{f.PJT~t±i

e":JJ!

ffi1li

f

~

6 i%:h;IB!mHt~*~~¥~

m

.=.

+

M

$

,

!il~~~RttBmUJl2~31

*f§~15t .D)JW~~~1f~1Ij:iEmIJ]j~3!~19IJ

'

IDtB~i&JFf~D1i1Jf!1JJ!9i-ffl,ifl

' ffij fl-

Aa~~~ nrtz~~

,

ffij@jAEdJ3.*~B"Jl-r~ , ~D1QJ~@1~~fiX*

'

wmIjJizrl3'jI~*§f[f'l=ffl~~j

o

~{£~~B~@jAEHJ3.~l-r~wmIJf.t~3IB"Jf[itJ~mff,

,

*)(Uffi:iill~1~M!jmmIjJl~3!510l

M~M : ~-~M~~~~m.~~~-+A~.~=tE.mzM,rr~~M'~~~ ~:tmmIJJi~~11H§glI~~L'ijgtfi

;

~=H~M~~~=+J\~~[!B+=~

,

1f~H~M

' i&

Jff$t

~~r~~~~'ijM~mm.~J rM~=tE.m.~J , ~m

• • • •

n~zl~1

~o~-MM~~~~+=~0~~fiz r~~M~'ij~rn.~J~~~~+~~M '

J;)J~tH7t;ffTW~~ 0 ~1~-H~M~IJ7t;ffT~-*~j:m2!{$1~~i!lajmmIjJiB"J~iI

'

!tt~Wll ~7t;ffTS"J~~~~+~J.-J~&~4-

t

!l!j:t£1f1fiIJz7~fltJi~W{®A lT~r~'~D1QJ~~Ri1J~~1W; 0

-

'J'Cm~)]m~~[gll

+

j\~t:l}WttH~~!i!lffi~1Jl

~IVI

§

i:t~1l1~!lnf~m'iA~~~i&JFfmIJJi:0~

{1iiS"Jitw

'

&-H~R7*PJT1JifEa"Jpff~fi~

~~rM'ijA'~~%Z~~~~~ t~§~~m~~ ,.7tXM'ij~ , ~m~~Atf

W

0

J

(~i*~tB~+E1~

)

0 ±jilipJT'ijfizfB[IJ~ r~~r*fJ'ij~.NmIj9i-

'

1B~11f~~fil ~z~[I]pg

,

&1B±j:ilizJ:T

0

J

(~?'*~tBt+-1t*

)

0 1lf1~rr5j:t£z1l!J-f.HtUnf.M#

fF

;fi

,

~~~~ r1if!iJ.-J~1J~*$S±j;t!2zflJffl J

(±j:t£

i:Em/\

+1'* )

0

l!I

Jlt

'

~jt£l¥Jf~ffl

mPJm~~~~~Jl6b

'

tJfF~~~~*i~s~fiflj 0 .7tPJT'ij~~

,

PJ7t~WtPJT~!f7JJzfiflljC :i:f$$~(!ln.tm t&g~15tf$" ( Cheung,1973,1989 ) , ±j:iliZfilIJB"Jf§~17t~"'E!.~~ti

'

]}\

18Hi

'

~~fJl{83W 0 13*/J\ruJ.DJTJii;ti:i~Mj:m&¥M

t

~?,*&±j:1!l~w~§~mrtf;f.t±j:1!!r

lIJZ,~f.m~rts"Jf~~z 1f*ll&~t:rliIli1~Jf~1JD.DJ~~ElJ3 0

(

-

)

'

BIT

±j:t!2~~m +{t~FJlfEfL~J!!mpff~fjzf$$" ~7~~A7~~t!ttJ~§*.#;g-~~ 0 m~'

1f

.~

J:' r~J~

m~

t~-fE

~

~§

M.'

~~.~~

.~

B"J~~'

~~~~

W

~

o~~'~~-~@m~~B"JW1fimrrm~~,~.'ij.~.R. ,m~~r~~.I~

•

{I

~

j

J\

~

J

(±j:1!l¥~$-B

~

t{~)

'lltJJUJiJi:'

~

1~

{

I

7t:ft1f~fi

MP

¥

1m

f

f1PJ

~~~

l

l;a

,

~Jt11B~ztl:HaIOOJIJtzTW~{fu'ij

~

~

MR

~PJTtHz

~

~

fJ

f§~8"J

~*

Mz1'

~

5?

:

ffij.El

'

~nfre

!

~m~tH~,~~(tHmA)'ij

.

tH.~~@

A

~t~~W~~APJ~tH

~m~~.

'

~

{lBaz{i7t:~14~t¥Hi~lIjPJiI 0

-;

iI

it '

ffii

ft

Aa~li j~1:J§R

f'F

ffl(f{]

,

j

l

~1&!'Mili*IJ~~~7t[q

J '

tE!l:tB~M

'

Eiit1~

:

,

:(f!l:tB~M

'

i&

lff5t

l~IU~~ni\z~*,~~ ~~~:f\+~t)Jifj

,

1J!J IJJjJ"J~3!

' !l:tJ

ij

Ml

i~OfPJkl1:.R!ElJrUHlf,

,

~rtpfT~J!JEa"JpJT~li~ f~

,

stftm~{tl!.A;Zf

!itiJ9i- '

$~fr1~~f:1 J~ttl!.z1~fflmim~fJI o

IN

llt

'

!i

j:fu(j{]f~

ffl

~~MffpfTW!WJZmfIJJt

f7t~

"

'EI

t59f;!m

'

*

~t§lJ~rt$f.t±tiMi

:

13

*#=%f~~ 0 {gjf: . fffl] , ~&~rtWJ!t~ 1Eb~~Jl

r

{t<15Hfjl~l!f :1f-1flHJ:1PJ$~fIJ~ c

~

Jl ;

ffii

l3.

'

~

nlf

'

p~

te

1t

~5Hr-J

~

(J!i

'

It

*IJli~m~~~WJ~~-~i&J:it¥1Ij:ih*IJll~3!z

7

HfT

7

~Z'±~~BmJE±~M~mA~~ff.~~±~8Q~@M~m~f.t. ,m~tE

1. '

83~i&JMZ¥A1TpJ

t

*t§&-

~

,

!l:t

fm~

R*IJ

;&

f-

ftt)J

J!Ilm±ttn

pfTlij

ffj

Az±tlli

~$'

0 14

C),

ft~

IZ.~~r~M~m '~~@Az~.~ 'ffii~oom~~ZmJ (&$m~§+-.

) 'fi~ft.~mJE~m-m~~ rftmAm~ftm.W~AJ (~~m~~+t.) 0

~.~~~' A.Am~ft~Mft~tem~~AoJ (~$M~§+li.) rft.~~

~

•

•

'~M~g~~ ,teftAmU~ft.@m~~oteftA~AM~~~ ' .~=~'

p).lM~lI@~jf3

'

ftfiA~D~f~~~pfTWm 0

J

(~ttm~§=+-=-{~)

r

ftti*~jtJ3

r'

tfjftAf~~B~.l;j,~ftfB1@!{Ift~~ 0 m§teft1i~~~-+~~@m~

,

ftfjA~D~f~

RtMPJT~f& J 0 (~tt~~8=+~{~)

a~~u~

••

,teAm~~.~~~~~8~ ,

•

•

z~.8~fi~~~~~'te

.~z 0 teftmIDt~llit.@JflfIJztef!f

'

ftffiAJ&f~{~m~~~zmf'J 0 E) '~fB3tl

*®.z• •

~r~M®m*~tE~A±~~mM~~~.z.J (&~mATI~+

0

_I

)

~mm*1tBfi;zJJl~1~f~-ma"JW

r

*ftBfiAf,f]:Mff~llfIJ~Wftl!.A 0 J ( ~rtm/\.

m+-g)

; m~r*ftB.A~m~±~tem$~AJ (~~mA§~+E.) o~~

0

I

r

* ftBti A

'

mXtthUl~=~z~iff~

,

~*~1'f~tfl9}

,

±tthPfT~Ar~mx{ffi

J (t\:rt

'\B!m+:f\11~d 0

rzgz '

ft{r'~J;)IDt*{IB.m~11*{~a"J7k~:tiUU~

,

R~fIBMmxtiM£l*~=4

' {tB!!

!Ilf

HltltlfJtf!=o"Jfi;r'J

0

i)

'iiiM

miB3

!fIUI '

7k1tBfim~~±Jllia"J¥.t~IJm

~

0

~~

~

iffia"Jf£lftB

'

~

g~~

r

t)§

{f*Jtf!=~§

I

r-J)f:~

{ttlliUl '

1~m ~

Az

ll

tlli~

,

~fJttllif£lm

0

J

(±tth

rt

m-

TI~;\

{'*)

o:(£±

¥M,f.t

±

~m$

~

~

~$

~m~,

•

•

~~~r

~

m

A

.~

temA~

m'm~m~

~~

$~-g

~

'

m~~AoJ (±~$

m

-8

~

A.) r~~

~

M

~

z~~mmm~~

·~

I~g.~'~ilimA~@§m*,~

~m

A

m

~

M

~,

m

m~

~

M~

W.

~~oJ

±

!t!!r~~-§

~

~1'*)

r

1t(~~M~lH£lm*JtJlliz~*~

,

1

jH~ft;~1I:9

1]11H0Z-B~~ltZ

:

... .::. '

l±H.ElA~9:@

§

fJtB~ 0 . . .

J

(

±tlli

r

t

M

- § +PB

{'*

)

r

~~@

13

fJt;UjfJlli~iliUlB~

,

8 • •~mw~*~~. m=+~

~~mA~~~~mm' @~@@MBm*.-~~~~mffl , ~~mA~~~mffl'#

71:

m

0 J (±tilirt~-8+-t:~*) 0

**iStt~i'*ff'x~m~~~.=.:

(-)

, vttili~J1.'lJfIl (±tt!!$~-s~/\i'* )

'

1E!:!t

#:

W~*~~~J1.~®~.rt~Qm (~~ : ~mAW~®A~.~~) ' ~~~~I~t

fIl,

'

1HJ

r

f§'i~~J (~-*~. ~~40~ • ~18Ji ) B"]'I~~

,

~H)t~~J1.~fIll¥JmJ;E1£I1Mt

&1i£

M

' {~If-*:JJDJ;j

fAfj 0

(=)

, tt!!::EI:iJt%@*jf~WZ@]±tt!! (±tt!!rt~-s~tL1~,­ s+~~) ,m~~.~~, ~a@M~_.f§

••

N '~::E~~~I¥J~~ '*$ffi#~

~IiJfHy,J

'

-mI:iJ~~@M

'

Iz~IlJ:tf.tfIl{IBMrlFFfJ~~*~~~mijj'J

'

-m~Z

'

~j:i!!atfMflJ,)W

{IBWHlN

'*'f1Rtlt~ZPf.tfIBJH§'&a"J

r

1'~~J 0 ( - ) ' ~71<mA~{f~71cfIl

m

( ±tfurt~­

~~~m.~nzm~~oo -+E~~~Z±~$m-S+ ~~.~:r

s+-t:i,*)

' f!~B~:rttf~*~J1. ~fIlAfl~&m*,"J' m~1HJaZff~~fIlm~1j:t!!±z.~rn

ijj'1

1'*

0 15

'~~~ ~

j:ilifIl1'1~ttH~j:ili11is

51

z/\ · ...

MJ~j:ilillm$fEj:ili{M

,

**~{tattJlfEj:ili{lzj:ili~

•

t~~

ill

-

1f.z

ZP:t~tt!!1J!l 0 J Jlt~PJT~~ZP:j:~j:t!!lJl

'

{t<~~{iH~

m

WiiJi{

% '

m~~mHfj±gjffif~l'~ tt~,~Jltff~~~~~-+~~.=.~=+B , J;j~m*m-OOEO~~%~m*~~

~fE~~ ,~m~~~~~51Z.=.-t:li~. Oill~· Jlt~~mZW~a~ft~~fimmA

: r

EI3~~~&~Jfff.t~$%B"JttE1-r1'~ J W,*~,

r

*5~H'E~~t)(J . ot~

,

~~~ , ~20Ji ) 0

~~±~m.~Rz~m'$~-mfi~~~~~O$Wf.t~~~±~zm.~R&1

@m~~±~Z~~ ' ~~~~$~~8-+=~, ~~s~+li. ,m~s~+=.~

mfE'~1HJ.~±~z~ft&~Z~m'~~~±~$~-8+~.&M-s=+.' ~

~~llt1'~~~ 0

~~*/1\jnZ5t;ffT

'

~~1f.tili&!¥Mf~W,etiliZoo}'11 ( attributes) ~ : ifH·I.{~t~j.~

±~~~~#A~~ ,@m~M~.~~m®tt ,±~~.~mI:iJ~~mA~~mA~~

'

V

~ZM

~.fi

~

~~~~

o±~~

ffl

.

~8.~

rt

~

• •

'

~

A

'

~

$·

m$

~~

~

t~

Jia'J8"~~'i

·~

A~

t

~

0

~

~

+

J\

~

ijj'JJEa'J~rt&~~+

~

~1{i'l

~

a'J

±

t

ili

itf.t±j:

ttlO~

~

&fIlflB~pJT~ijj'j

,

{§~EI3~fi~~%~Jl;E1'SjHii

'

:JJD~*mHiHi.¥A1-r

'

~;¥!;$~~

~*~1'

*

0

~

l1

t

'

tx

{r'I:iJt)J~~it¥~tili~

Ifi

,z

M

Bf.Jaj:

ili

m

~f~~~

fi

'

pJT

~mA

PJ§

m

B"J1~ffl

'

~~~~8'w~tili

'

t)j1iiP~=!t~'j~Sf.Jft* 0 ='~~_+A~~~+=~.~2~ma.

~~1t"~~=:

+

J\

~p

JT

.nilia"Ja

j:t!!

&Ifi

'

;¥!;*Jt

l.Mz~FlErt;/iJl~'JS1

&~

,

ffiH~~J\f

f

&':

-368­

~UtA.1~

t)

mllft

ffl

il~{tj:

-8~)\{~) , i§~~

Jl)

,~~'€1rrt~a~t

~

.it

'~ffl8"J~]':iE:

tEl;:

Jt!!1t~-8~tL1,* '­ '~~8"J#1J

'

*g~iJHf-: ~~Z

'

~j:t!!~~Mrn,~ ~7t:7J\fflfi

(

±iihlt

W;­

:

7f'<f

ll.

fltij:t!!±Z.~~ ~-

8

+11*8)l)(~JlJE:

.

HJt~:iihflztthn

'

t~h

,

m.~~tmril~{I~1'{

)

Ii

0 ~ill1-%j:t!!{lt*1~''­ ~~ll'la~JrIlff¥J\fr'\'N7W" )( J (~*~, ~~40'if I ±a~±j:t!!zj~~~~&}:

Ii

1~

,

~

1Z!38

1\+

=

Ji::

:tL1

1*:&~-

8=

+

il* '

tributes)

m

:

~~

pi1

l

~

"6J

EI3

*l

fl

A

EX

ill

ffl

Af'(

ill

~

,

*

183

"

~.El

fm~

{F

r

::*IJ%:8"J±tt!!rt

~±j:1i!O

~

Hi

W

¥,Mr

'

i&

;!;'j

i{$i

~fI

£m

'

pJTfI

tiA

PJ

~

iU

J!

~

IJif-J

c

~~

, fffi

{~tt\tf

1IiIll!e~m~~*kJ~~-!itH~H!il!1~ti:!l1liIJlt~~z

7t

tfT

9

-"1

0

1'~~DNorth ( 1990) PJTf~t/j B"J

'

*IJJi8"J¥A1TMz~F-&rIt!l~

,

~fi1Ji&JffflM~tEjd~i~

ftM.~~mi&.'~~~-+A~~, tE~

••

~~fi~?ti~mU~~~~*~

_,!\~~@rel'~ 0 t)Tti1r'~.tE*1trEllB8[1]pqi&mliil

'

~~if~rElIl!jt&*IJ~f§{t<'ltW

-

n

~~*~~M 'W~~-+A~~~~~fi~.mi&. '=~2~~*~~~ o

(

-) , it)~iB

lIIP9~~lim75im

~~i&JfftE*~~M,~±tE~i&.pq$fi~*~~1J , ~m.mi&.m*m~~o ~~i&Rit1r&~*il'~&

'

i&fiWj:ili±8~~ro{*Mz~~tJJ (1lIJ~1J!

'

~~81~ , ~ 73 Jf)

'n

o

t::::)\~~r&

'

il'iWpqgBWJJrI~3i: 0 18~l1Jt

'

i&Jff~~!i?mMHI~' ~f~1'tJJ'!''&~

,

~c*~i8~t~!m~~)11 '~B&~±j:ili*iJMJ ( mi:jjfm, ~~73~ , ~162Jfi) , 19

ffii==

~,~m~±~~*~n~ ,~~~~&mfiS~$~~~~.~&~1J.*~

••

~1Y-J¥MT(~tl~

,

~~83~ , m291:fO 0 20

C) .. 1II~~)~I,Nm]Jim

m=~tt~*~~~ ,~~~~.tE~~~±~m.,~ur±~¥~J

'

r~~~

±~J

'

r±~.fi~~J ~D~ ' ~~.*.~~~M,~m.MB~~*;~~~

~~±~9"J~~

,

~i1EJ1El£ r~~J lWilll't-J~*~Dt1t~

, ~DB*"

#1$~ ,~~, i¥j

..

m~mil'.5 ,~t/jr±~&¥JI't-J~m' Um~±~¥~9"J~B~ '~ffii@~~.

~

,

*,fH~

~~

B~

~Bl~~IJ~

0

~~OI'~~~~if~M~2

~}f/ml

fj

Fel9

~~*

..

~1&

B

*mJmC~

i

,w;t~Fel9~ttlEJJt

( Wolf Ladejinsky)

pJT~$

~

B~

:

±t

ili&:$~

t1E

JJr~~

~~±~Dfflfl1j3t

l:

rt.Jft1iF1H:t:

(fJX

t~

~

,

F:~

83

1:f:

' m291J[) 0

~ll:

t

'

~~

f

~

19491:f:S,Fj

~

,

OO~f:i~~

~m~~.r~~

.MmOO.~~

••

J

'.M

~

~i&M

~

fi.~&¥(W~.'~

~ , ~21SJf) 0

..\

'ffjU1.fHtH~/11

lI

JLt~fi

~tltE

' tE

;!t

ftMft

~O"J

*

I

JJl£

liJ!

..t

m1

T

*JTB"J*

IJ

li

'

!tPJT~J5X*&"

iil

,Q

1~

0

S

±~

&¥~

~

fi~*'~

.~~

ffi.~~o~~i&Jff~~

~

=+-~~

'£

~M~

~

I

I

l

f*

±t

ili~

*¥G~

tili

ii~

f-'

(Jl!H~

,

F:~

69

4 •

~

82

:&

~

~

88

~

)

0

tR±j:ili

~*

¥~

~

t

~~1:fi

lft;

tili1:.

~

*

{tIl

F

±tJ

1Jo

EB

iItz~

*~lE

ilt~nr.:J1lt

4451:~1

:!1t

·

t

)j~~trgi(UH~j:ili

~fi

10 f.l'JtiEJJ!mf4fJi*~~¥~

m=+

M

J[) 0 ffij#.:(fB11Ja~Meiij7'C~l¥J:ttl1*~~ffit

'

£U~~~+~~~:tiE§w~rJ

'

~~=:t/ ~JtfT.:z.~19UJ3.!Innc~~

-

+

-1f:~~7'CfJXft;]j:tl1*rHli}fffi

PfT

§c

ittt

a'.]:tlli

§

W

~IJ

'

~ZPJE~~~~I.

J;)Jf;~~:fJ3.1&~~Iij:t!1fJ3.l¥Jf~~ (~t~

,

~~51~ , m28J[ ) 0

**ir

~.:z.

'

~~=

+

J\.1f:!f1T~fJ3.a~

,

;?~~ri:Jamlllj7qjf~mllJl&~ft!!*rJJta"J~c~11i[

'~~m.mM.~~~~*~*~~Ma~ ,ffij~ml¥JmM , ~~m.~~¥M.~,

*3i-ti7~~1g 0 ~~~~P.X*~1~

,

PfTJ;J#~ft;].mi&m.fT1~t1ff&~ 0

ft~t~s'.]:±~T

'

#lfl~i&R1~~=+i\'1f:01'!1z rltilt~f~lnJt:ttl1fJ3.ffl~~J ,

_-

~_ i1JEl~~-+4~t~:(f~~tPfT1!DtliJ'f,] rmJ~t~.fJ3..ntli~r*J (~tID!t, ~~ 40~, ~{f

~~

5

][

)

,m~f9~

-

-tn~m1f~ff&~~A1T

'

~ge.~miM~t~~fJ3.~iT~~a"Jm~ ,

r

i'l~f~lHJfj:llifJ3.ffl~Mr*

J

~

r

iM~t~~fJ3..151li~.bi~* J {lJ~~71~ , ='i£Mr!:±~(f.J~~~

1~-~s'.]~T~IJ=JYi

:

1. ~~~fI

:Ji

S'.]

1~11

:

~~~fjtliakJ11Xfl1'£iM~

t

~~fJ3..

ntli

iM$

Ji:l

{if,

1*

j:lli

:±

{m~

tf

~~.~~

I5rt '

~!ID~4fJ41Rjig~5lfi:fla$

(fltIDiX '

~~40~ , ~noJ[) 0 f:j~~Z~fil

'

~

r

if4~f~iij*jt:tllifiij'fHJJ¥7*J Z~J!55::

'

tJ;~$~~ffUlakJl5rtH1l

'

~!IDEI3~W.Hf1;ttHT

r

=:-t

il

J~m~A

• •

~iij~.~~~~~~

• •

m~'.JE.~

• •

~.$' .~.~ ' ~

~fi.~~.M~EI3

• •

~fi.~a.~~fi.' ~~~~~.ge..m*~MM '~~~

t~Y~fJ3.tffij*

'

~;ij!fimD~~J~5lffU.~i1:

'

~~*~ffiili±

'

~{g:ffijJj]* ( ~~~

, ~

~43~

, ~22J[ ) 0

2. t~r~tj:zJ(?*,kJmJJT3i:~~ (offsetting contractual rearrangement) Z~Jt

:

PfTmf~ml±z

~*kJ1t~~~

,

~Cheung ( 1969, p. 89) ZJE~ES

:

1£~~px*

'

~~::fff1£t~7)t"f '

f.%

ff

~~~

*'H

~

W

~*1

1Mr'n

~i1J~

c

~

WP

!T1Jjf?1~c~*HJ~Z~*,

kJ11~

~1T~ U~

0

llt

JE

~ffl

f£

llNfB

l

,

~~~!IDfflj:lli±a~.p~fJ3.zt~~

,

~*JT~1jFfJ3.1fH~*,~ 0 J:t~

r

iM~t~~fiiWDffi~J)m;J

W

r

1t1lJ

~

f

LW

f:#

j:ilifJ3.

Jl

UJJ¥

i

*

J

=

fi~ffi~

~Jjjt~

m'

1

1~*

kJ

:m*JT~~

F

akJ~

lt

Zt

J!J;E

,

PJ

iI

R

~~glt~~filM1'~9Jf:Xj:llifJ3.~fF!fo/.J~~ONtllifJ3.

'

mJ::jt!@~~£i¥Mr*f*SjJ)OJVE'

r

t:l~~~Lfl

m~mfflW~J ~~.~m~~ , n#~~UiijM~fJ3.fflW$~mm~z~~.~i~

ttlt

' t

J!}Eff}{J;,{~~M~~

,

19!J~OmJ~t~z~m¥Jfii~

,

.R~J!JEj:lli:±1'~~[EJ~fJ3.ffijtiitffH

'

(§

*

11.N*IJ:tlli:±

1f1'm~ffifJ3.*,kJ1

1~H

5t

T

'

~@]g~1~

HJtj:lli

'

f:j~~Z~f

J3.

~JJ¥r*

'

~ll

tlJERffE

1~

i

:

M

I

@]*Jtj:lli '

B!ID

~{~7

*~

1!

@]

~Jt

j:lli

'

~

~

~

[illlii

fii:!!.~~H*

l

l

0

:!fj91- '

#lUJ~Z~fil

1M?iB

JJ

)

O!

~

,

~mMEEj:lli:±~~~]F±.tlliHtApx*

'

~fil1~1'f~Cj:EI3{mM~tJt

'

iM~t!@Z~ID1Mi*U'J *iij~bLl:takJHl}E 0

H~

~

~~tIDit

pfT:±

~B

'.]MIl::jt

~W

tli!V

~~fJ3.

'

PJj;)

J~

JJ

!*

IJ

LtSkJc~

~

•

~~I~

f

~A

&

'

~fT~B"J&~

,

ffij~ff~1J~~*IJLt24~@A~MU~

, Y..

f{~~@A&~tEl*~fTm!¥J&ti

'

~

iMm:1Joj;j{l~n

'

j;J~ig~~§~~PJTtmft;]*IJLtfJX* (~~p'x*) 0 -370­ =--tnt~m~

1M

'

~IJ/frnU!~ 38if~i$J~)~~ ~ 1 Jj § 13 fi~JN ~gt:!i2f 13

fi.:i:

!f1

A

0~11jf[~2f

tt :

13fi:±~ ~1j[ ,

I

~~4*i~

:

~ f.t~7~fJ3.FfT

1

b~1&1mfi ' ~

1i

.Riij1£j:lli:±

~ mJfHM?'~J

1'1­

, ~Cheung

ZJ

J

m

lli '

.t~

fJJ

B~~

~(f']~{~ , PJ~

•

1H=eW[inJIJZ

f!!H

...

fi!t1''@z~ +-n-;:n~ I ' / ~ ~AP,C.\&;-;:].vA....

r-

*IJm:~m~~¥-J~t~-~~~!fi!f~j:i!1*ljgO!i!Z?HJT 11 IB§~~IJ

'

~~.:::.-tl

~~IJ

'

~ZPJE~~~~I:! ~;!tftEmIJJtB"J~~Jii~:

~

t

#

.m!

:t

it

c

jz!J

pfifffi

/li,J

III

~~ 0

~HJt:ttM.El.ffHh¥$J

'

li

~

,

~~

40

1f: ' ~45\

~-t1ij~mwm!H~

,

f.f.fF~~ftl¥-J~.

'

PJft£~l~1±I • ;g=t)J~~29-321f.ZflJ5]~~

1M '

~IJ/f~t~1IL;:~~0tJi~.

'

~m1& (~~39-411f:Zflj:~~ ) j:~~~f.El.M (~&g

36-38~ZPj:~~)~ ~

•

21 !1t~~mtf.El.I¥J*6*B"Jlii1.lE31Ul~l¥J~iI 0 26

~ 1 -

-t1i

JJ

M

il.M"

i&

13 fi1:~JH'Ft~~jJfAlt§~ztt~

l'flf

ft

:

% ~iiWT~'Ma"Jmm,

r

=fm$Mr*±~~!:~m _{Jj § ~~ 29-321f:~Y=:J ~~ 36-381f:~¥-;J ~~39-411p:~~} (g±frn~lI [QJ~fl~l!!l 13 lm1:~&E{'F~~ 100 94.8 124.0 ~tfI~z~f.EI.

'

~

r

l

E~!\ilmftHT

r

=

tE

_{~~:l:ZP:~f§~} i!§~ ;l;U~-ld;- !l m !...F ' :r[)C-l=I1~J;E.' ('l 13 fi:±~mHF~~4:ij 100 81.9 98.9 ~m:*:l!ia~M

'

:tt!rf:

.f'1

0GJ[~:I!:

zP:

Y=:Jm

i&

~ O~~~, ~~43~

z

g

lt :

pfT~rlmm'tt£ ~/f'1¥1£1~mT

'

~ff

)

#~

!l

t

fi::

~fIH£!JLH1Lt ~~t~~f.El..fjffi~}fii1J ~~.LtZ~JI~

,

rlJ~Jl

C~JIJE'

r

~iIltifl-fi

~'l1z~*,"Jm:fJf3ttM';

H~~f.El.ffiH~fm

'

(

ti

t

~

, ~IJ~

JIJE.RffEft($U~

,

Z

i19tf.El.¥JJ¥$rm::~JJUE ml~t~z~f.El.~~1r:U'J

.

:r1'

~

~l

te@LA.

'&

m

tJH~f

T

~I¥-J2.9:~

,

~

U :

13fl±~1If'F1o/]m~*

"

/J \~

"

~?E~

"

*.§.~~

"

tt

im "

m?7t~1L

"

:*:

li

"

~~

"liw

'

~m

"

oo~.&mm

'

~t~HI~tRITfifl1JOfiZflj:5] 0

:i~4*~mi

:

~~~

,

~iflz±tite&!J ' ~~434

'

m

3

6

J{

0

f.t~rJ9tf.El.pJTJ;)~~f'@~~ils"JDj([2g

,

~~{r~mt±:l/f[PJEn~?fo~ 0 Cheung (1969 ) ~~i%ffH I~~l&frnfl

'

iJH§t~A:j~±tln~~

,

[2g ffiH~±tlnl¥J1§~il:fiiit1Jo 0 *X&~~ Cheung

Z

!I~R~l£:tln±QJ~~@J±tln

'

§ El3~1~fmm~1JpxlI 0

QJ

~

,

~DMpfT~' I ~ifiI~~~lHjf

m

m

WJ¥r* J

1'ff

B$wmtit±.R~~f

t<

7

*~5(@J~#tln

'

.El

N

n

~

f

t<~

~~@J

En*1ft

ih

'

;!t

ITfifJlm~~

RmIJ

'~Cheung Zl!~/f'JEJ;)M~1rnllZ~~±j;1n~*~Aiit1JOEn~~ o 27:=§fflMJ lj (~~

6

04)

ml±l

'

j:~lreja~I

~

$

"

~IJ

$?t

~iJ

~

~

fffi

M

pfT

1i1

~

8<J

#Ih3§~~

{

~

~~*~~j£

1

&i

'

?t

~

~

.~

~~'QJ

.

gfffi

.$

-

~

Z±~

~

~

ffl~~z

*.

W

.*,~at±:l.

~

~~

~

*~

'{fl=EWIMJIJ

zf

l

~

m

g

~17}j;~

~f!)!~

,

~

?t*

fT

1J

rt1*i*

r:!J~

!¥WH

"J

'&f

fi

m?t

lfi

~

,

llt

~

i1J

lt

:!l

l

Ut1'

fiz~ 0 28

I

12 i%aB!m~3j.f~*~~¥~

m

:=.

+

M

BkJ{

*~

,

f

~

1

#{

IIl

M~A

{

ffi

*ifBkJ~~

fJX

*~~

1~

, ~

ffiif

~~A

{IIl

*#BkJ~Ib

~

~*ttftJO

•

29!tJffii

~.*~~~JJD 0

r~

~

~

&~M

~m

m

.$

J

~~~

-+A~

0~.

~

.,

~

~.

~

w~~m~

,

W

~

.2

I%

%

fFm '

m~m~fffiflzi*~IBdl,&.f

lL

z1

M

~

, ~

IHJJ¥

{im±Jm

¥

t;;:&:Jtffu~

~~rt;;fl

0

~

1t

~

U

I

W

1itli1&

'

r

y~tfu±J:J5ttH§;flj~~~~

,

~5[@JtiHElf.Mmz11i~B1Hnl~

,

ffiif1l1m*.4~~·

~t@"tJD~~J (~~~, ~~431f

'

~17J{) 0 ) 0 ~Jlt

'

i&f(;fn1B~~[9+~mi1n;fjffi1T

r

*iftt!!

-

-tli

~ffHl*19UJ

'M

~Hl~f.Ela"J$

%

11RiJJ

rn~

Jtta"J

1Tjf

~

lfnfl~ft

~t:j:I

*

i&JttBkJffi~i

ll

r~

,

1:E~5[@] EHjj:z~f{1iliJ

..

fflHfU

1

x

11

( compensating payments ) BkJ~lt

..

3l'&~f.ElZ1M~

~lnm

'

:iJD5$~flIlfmS"J1*~ 0

_,.~m~~~ffi~~~I\+~~OO

~D[p)~mi&m-fl

'

*#~~:JtEEit~iE~m-.a"J.Jt!!.i&~ 0 JX~+1t1f0H1Ja"J±t1!!i~

,

E1H~ftli§fjj:~8"J-aJi (~l.Bfi

'

~~431f

'

~57Jf ) ' ~~=+li1ff~nB"J±tful:t1!

~

~.

§

*if.

~~~em

~'

~ffii~

~-+~~

-

~

-

B

0

~~

.$,m

~

r

~*~

1t±

JtM"J7}@

cgp~

~

J!

'

ff!J:JiH

riElma&

§1T{

~

m±JiliAff.%D¥(

~

IJ

'

illz~

i~;!:t

@I%

*~~iIDffl

0 J

(lUt;;~-s[9+-=-jI*) 3IJ~iI*~mz- 0 m~ ' f*flL1§~jf.zm1nli1£~~-+)\4tJ

M '

.R1f*I@$151~151a"J$H5~tt!!.l~nE~B"J!.',* (7~~1i

'

~~43~

,

~60J{) 0 m1t*#~

fi;!tEEif~m*1i~1B*I@.IJ!

'

J:J~1B*1J~~lt.~iI;i;{6f~*1@ (~$:m ' ~~73~) , [S

ll:tiE~R11B~~

-

+

/\~~Wi;fIJW1il!1--t1i~mZ1&

'

¥f1B~~I!9+~J:J~~Ii0Jtt!1J:rt1*f@§

*jf~, ~~-=--tli~HI '0tlh~~.w~~IJrla"J~mtt ' ~~~I!9+=$0:ffiJj1JifT r~1iffi*~f

~1tEEi,*19IJJ 0

iJP'

~r~~M*W;!trn.~J Z~~@~,~~affl :M*~~EEZ~m&¥ ,~~f

_-1ffl

1JD1ffil!s"J~@;J5X*zlfi(~IJT

'

fl:liB"Jrl~f~j&JffpfTrniImBkJ~~fJX*

'

PJ*i&

w

e"J

f!Ji:

0

fi

X.

f

r*3i

m1JOfffi~E"J~~fJX*1JOO

'

f*~!ll[btrfTmt±ls~

r

[9~1bJ 1'F~

,

fJE!ff{1ffiMt!D~jJ~jp

,

!if

_~

_'

m-5

*f

fl±tilit!D~j~

~fUt!!.

'

~~

ffii

~iJi~JmiMl,*~

f.El

JH!

'

71c

~Ji~F*~~OOm

:f

~'j

fl

(~

~

-.

_f£~~

~.w±tt!!.l1D~rnb~fll±tili

'

*71c~Jiflj±j:m{JJ{~=-t1i~fli1,*{9IJiirt71cffl )

)

0 311±~1~3(:~m

tt.~

*

1J

@

,

~

it

~m1JO

i&

JffSJ;J

Mi&~1Ji&~

1:

$j!{

~

~3

~

ft

'

f.ttili±:Zfm

i1i~1*

J

J!~fftHI

'

niH:

₁

_2Y+­

,

-t

J5XW~o/.J±J

ili{

Jt~

:&

-

J5X

0~*~Im:~j~~

c

z

0

ll:t

fl*l

j

~

O"J

~tf

'

&H!~*ljrl8"J

~if

t

1t

ro

ZJ1g

0

Jf~{R~fi1i

~

tJ

~~

~

*1~

t~Jjl~Z1rmA~UJU~

,

~~~

1~:Jt*grx~fJX*ffii

~~

l

lmljll~

₂₃

_%:tr:1::

o

. ) ~~~

~

~.1i

1Ji

~.ff~

~:ffit

EEI1'F

1B~~[9

+=4

%PX

'

*jj:Jili

f&

1

j~

~5[B"JJm±F

~

;tt

l06,04

9P

'

~

I

ili~

*~fj

Ufu

z~

~F

~

~

194,823

F

'

~

~5[

jj5[~rtz

Mtt!!.

jjjnI~+

143,568

EtJ

'1JD

J:

JXI~][[9

+:

i~

~Pff~

r

­

*IJJ3t ~f'W~*,"J~m-~~l:lYJaj;ilimIJJ3t!filZ:7HfT 13

~~~it1JD

'

19

lZ9

iffi

$im

~

il1t~[Q]tti!±

ftMA

m

jti!OO

fi

1

5,646

1¥ '

{

~1~

El

*

JtjlliJ:

t$

El3

6

1.

4%

tt

~

84.8%

(

~J!~

,~~

43

4 '

~

8

0

J[W~ 90 Ji) 0 ~~:eraffiMfflntEEM1&ti"i9l~~19:Ailtf:},:Z~1t mt{~m~l¥Jm~

,

~§ ~~2 pJTjJ\ 0

i~~~m1t~ 0 ~1t~

W,

2

~ ~

39

4

~

51

4

:I:

iff

~

*

~

A

JI.

te

t~ f(

.~

,

ffi1nHffi *,~~ifJi~ _{(~ ~}

₄₁

₄

₌

100)

~

[ZB +

1f

Jjji

{fiD1H

'f

r

$

9<:

l&

rff

s

"J H

~t$lli~

4

~ (~ ~

)

*I!

t~

A

~~ lli

~.Lt

..

~)YJJ~t§.Zj1illt

39

1f

92

9

1

401f

95

95

41

1f

100 100

424

102 112

43

1f

1

05

112

4

4

4

106

111 ~

+

Jt

4

0

f1il

e"J

±t

1l!

h:­

45

1f

1

08

121

46

4

112

128

+

Ii

1f{\~nB"J±tllirt;~

4

7

4

116 136

"

;t

,

{i~~

r

~~~1Jd

_481f

11 5 136 ,...,1t:~~!t,m)!!;!;i'lii:t4l 0

4

9

4

113 137

}.E _" ~tlE 11a! § I.BJ"'~

50

4

118

155

m1ilf(f~~~

+

)\4t~

_511f

_{11 9}

₁₅₇

=

,

m60J{

)

0 ~1tM~

$

ffi '

~~731f) , ~

.

t)~~j0tti!1Jt\~ffi8

1f0:ffinllif

r

r

'1

Mfi

*

#

~

.

, EE

2

J

t!

rm&~

,

:t

f

f

,

t

J;f<l&ma

"J

l

§:JE

0

1f

'J

l~

®:

f

ffi

~

fl

D

~

7J.

~

P

,

rr

~OO~JFf~~

J¥j!

(

m~

:

,

~tJl )

)

0 32:(f~~{g;~~fJ

HlH1rf~1Jbtif

m

i'

i

'

ffli

l

,

&

ff!~mllrla

"J~~

tl

_•

~fJX*ffi1

~

~1 J

1M

~

f

..

,(t)

tti!±.F

lt

t

t: 106,

0

4

9

,568

Et3 '

1JDI

lX

~

[9

f

~

.M*~ : .*m, r~.±~&¥~~~J ' lliK~~ w~~,m+~'~~~+Alf, mG'~~ o

~pqg~f51)(~~~IiEl*jHfflj~$f;:1ie"J*5g~

,

tE~lfflw' 21.t*4~' 1111t~tJj

r

~~[ZB

+

-

4

$!J~~1i

+-4Fa' ,

M*1:iI

~~tta

1J

DT1i

-t

%

J

'

pfT

tJ*5~~"

:fj1li~Jtff1'fEEi&~

~

r*~'t

~~

Bm~El

*Jt

M

'

1:iI~W

,,

~B£tr'i'D~

,

~*

1:

~:tJ*¢Mf.

IBt

J

(~

t

8J3

'

~~4

3

...

. ;g 54

ffiD

0

33

;!t

f{

,

f#%ffi;!tEEzJiMiC)(~:(£~~[ZB+=47tm

'

83m1mitlj,w~EHjti!5Ij

,1f~~[g+=1f~~

,

rffiMzJFf~Hi~1:~~~[g+=4~1i

+-4Fa' ,

~Jtttllific9:!J::5

~!!l

*1:iI:tJ*¢

M

m

3t

'

~ljH!

wr~

1:

:(£

~~[g+=4M

1&~

1f

'

1EH:tW,2

$m~tJj

,

~

1lR9

+-4~[g+::::lfFa'

,

~mfB

~*

Z

*~

~t

±:

L~ja~~A

'

t§tt

;!tf

~4~Z

~

1~Mz~

:

*JMtta

]

Z

~ ;!t~f6J~Dllt? Jl:tifJ\PJ£~~~fJX

0

*

B"J}!mfB1JDl-)~~~

0

m

~1'f;!tEEif!x:~

*

fi

lj*{N2:

n%

&

~~M~83--tlim~m~

.

~~

M~

,

tE

i&~r[ZB

~

~

J

ff

~T'~

.

~MOOtt

·~

~px*

Mz

~~*e"J~Jh

'

~~I±l

I3!

~

*

1'f~

*e"JpJT

~mb

0

~

$

~

~

[g

+-4~1i

+­

.£1

tf:l~1JD

57

%

z

mtlEJ'

*x

~:e

~m

wgf~

6Mi

c9:f{' ~E:*4

'

il

iU

'

(P;]~~m~1:iI~llfLj

'

14 iWiab'!},fWj.&*~j,Y~¥~ m~+M

[g , m-~.ttgc&~fi3§~f:j.R!tfHfiUmla9l!i.I

~~m

-~

~

.

~a¥~m

fflMI'tJ§

.~*.

,

#

~~

~zW

g"PJ~

~~.'.

1Jrtz~~'J3rRJ gH#*Ij~rnU{lJ 0 1f:g*IJ~f~$

,

@A:~Hfi~:t~ff!Wd:~~!l:&*IJJ!U'i!ffii~

*.*~.~ft. ,~m~.§.~ffij~.~ '~~

• •

Mi&.§. '3Z.nn~~K~ 0

~IJ

'

J;jfmft~l&f~JJ~)I~*JiilE~JEz~ J;j-"f*x~"t~tth~~V*IJ

'

lElffBVJ.!~=)]iii

'

7;

~~-*M~a¥~~~~~.~~~z~~ o

(-)

'=!ti!~.5tgfmU

±tthr*~~+1~JJfJ!5E : rf~~mHthpJTfHjz~", ~7~~AJ;j*~~&fJ~gHjf%f~~

J

,1ItlJUJ!fEEl3~R*J!~ r 7~~A*~~&t1ggH#J IlPPJ*~Ilt{h, ~~7~~M~=a~1

' *~~~~.~~M' ~$~*n~ffin~V~m~,~lIt~~~~*~* o~&D 7~ r*~A*~~~~MJ Z~~~M~~' ~~~li+-~mfEEl3

• •

~.~~1 I±l~ rfk~~(1fB)*#~tth~~1*~~

J

'1*~IV~~A*~~&wg~1f*#1t, 3683~rgi&~mjJfz~

m~.~~~~~m.I±l~~m.~ '~~~A*~ffm1tffl'I±l~~m.~ma~u

if

'

lElllt.iJ~*~f1m*

'

1fA11Htl'tJ~~(

personali

z

ed

relationship rransact

ion

t1"'

jl-'¥~~*&,~s"JtH~fk~§ (1m ) *#.~tthf$~{*~1f1! (H~~

, Ilt*~

,

~101f) ' l~

~~~JJi{;*~~~rJ1t~Jfjrt

'

ffij1m1t'i~UJ!f[ixHl! 0 ~lI:t

'

1TiF~p1C~R~t\+1f

- J=l

aA41Jl

ll:

fi:

~~~*~~m.tH~fk~~(1fB)f#~tth~"1*g1f~z*J!fE 0

38

~1~a*~~)]rt~rRJ~~#*IJ

'

J;jf{1f!UJt~;~r~t83iE3I:~ 0 pqiF3I:f§~3Z.~~~t\+ =~-J=l*l~~~~*jt~g1JmaA~ff~*J~

,

39~iR:j~£im~0pJT~~m.~~~~{1l ' ~~H: a.:~~

••

~.~1JM~Z.~ '

• •

*~

••

•

~~.~.~&~*.~~.M~ ~ 0 f!f~fTi&~;tWpqi&f§~3Z.7'r:~&~~~t\+=~fLJ=l

' +

J=l~fu1i r~N*IJ~tthtJMJi1J~J r

:&

r~R*IJ~tthfJ~¥J\1T~)fi$J 41 , m~~*#w~1J~~8A~z~~

,

J;j$~~A§Mlii'Cl{t£~

1J

m

{'F~E.S~N

'

fU

k~

fj

ttthp

JT~

ffi

~

~"

'

~

t1

W

'

r

t~1C*IJ¥R:

&1B

.

Wf

~"

'

~

*~

A

I!!'"

.

~

~

ttM'

fflM

±~

:&.~~m

~z

.

~'m~

•

•

~

.a.z&

.:&.~&MWm

'.~M~

m~~

~

~

'rRJ

~V

• •

ffi

~0

M$~

~a'

83~

.

ffi

~0

M

.~~.

~B

f

m

M

m • •

~, ~~a~~ '

••

~••ff, ~~m~~m.~~Q~~~.~A.~

?IlIJ

0

~@e

~

lI:tJ

j[*Jl~

,

~

iE3I:

f§~~

~~

t\+

=~+-

J=l

H~

~1f:

-

J=l

~fu1i8"J

fP<a~

M1fg

tJ

~~n

~ff~.:r~1JDtUI~lE 0 42

~

M~

~~t\

+=

1fg~

~~JJifti&$~

'.

~

~~

A~§MW

.~

1J

M~,

~~

t

1~

E!

*jf

w~1J

~If

I3A

if1

JRJ.!

~

tthPJT~

fj~'~

1f

~c

'

1§±Jthrt~IJ

m

~

iJ<

~

A~~.w

g

§

fJH

~QJ

K(

-3 74­

~Jl

tt!!

'

%~1TiF

~fr

&~

r

fkff

~tthpf

**~

l.~~N

*IJ

I

,y. , ~

-1]

00

-t!1

"5J

~ o WiX~D5tHi'ffi'

(

~~$~zJI1JD 0 ~lf:!

:g

*i!{gl'tJ~~

~

C)

,milE~m §~;£

r

1:1~~t

••

Qffi~&

'

~$8 Jfnrta"J~~

,

1:

. iiI

~~iMJj't

fY!

;Z

~

~1J[9+~1{;~}

,

lI~±.Zf!~ ~9H'fJl:tJHfjhffij~

,

1.~Mth~lij~1 .:<

3

~~1Ffflt -YIf-m-ff1~ (~~ ) 41 173.6 42 170.4 43 171.7 44 172.7 4S 176.3 46 179.4 47 179.6

=--­

1fatttl~i~~

I

tI~"*8im

!

1ffIJtt~f~H~~*~~m-~1ttf£iIt.j:t!!$IJtt~~Z7HJT 15

1

2

~~J5Q]"

mil'

fllf83i'J

IW=

1

r

oo

,

~A

~~~

~~~

M

'~

~~r

~~~

~iij

M~

m

m

.~

J

rM~-

tli.

fll.mJ

r

.~M~iij~ffi.m

J

0

tth .

~~~~rrL~:aml?

••

Dm

t&

•

i5-

i

*8"J~**

~~

1J~7Ul~IJ--tlifl1f83ffiIJW~

f#

ffi

I

J

=~

lI:t

flt

j~1

$T

m~~

~~~

~

.1'*o

~

~

~g

n~~~~

·~~~~+

~K

#~

~

~

• • •

fim

'

.~

~~i¥J

~.~*ffi

~~

~~

~~JVEEl3

m~

m

~

9X

H£

~

.

ar

j!

~

ffiiJ

Jl{~)t~px*~l1

g1J

A

'

~

ffii{

~

&!

H

thfIJffl

f~

Jl~1J

o

0

IElll

t

'

!fll!1mttMI~t~fMz

3ff

*

JHt '

J6El3~

~iEJ<:~~t; :d

1!9+~f-t~JIl±t

tfti¥Jm~(~

Ji~

3

)

0

m

~

•

~

~

li

+~

{

i:tj

~&

'

~

~

Iim~~~

,

tfj~{-*~

~~

%f

{~j~

{

iiJI

J

_{i '}

1~

1:

~

z

.wr~

*

~*~~

~

~ffiitt

1JDa~

,

i&~

T

ffl~~U~~1JAZ~~

,

{

~{~~rmt

0

:

lationship

transaction

t

f

~~

tfJi!JH

f

mt.J

ffii~

~

s"J~*~1JD

(?JJi

t!n

)t

~px*

~

1JD )

'&ffii1'

~

IJ

~~*a'J~

~ ~1I:t

~

,

~t

~

J

'

'

m lOJ{) " ,

'1

.*

MihfJ:fif~

~

:(f~~li +${i:t)1

&!

gJ

l

tfjT~

~l¥Jm

~(

ffi

R

~3)

0

~~I\+~- ,FJaAfi~lL

3

.~m:~~tihrolm~

~,m~

fia$~m~~

~~

ffl.

o

~~a~~~~~+~~~~~±~

~M=+

.

~ rfk~.etthpJT1Hjz~", ~jf(~Atj1fE§*#tf~~

'

...

J 0

~~~~~~

~~J::~~RffiIJ

.

t

th~"1t4J2~iI

·

r:lJ

~

t

±

H~4J

fI~W1~A~*

,§

~lHT

~

;f

§1i

1'Fffi

s

'Jlm

m

wrr.

WI~!Jt&

ilil

l

ll

Qiffi

~-1JOOlliQ]"

~

tl1

·

~t

a

tth~

"~~R

ffill

'

{~

f

kiij

~

t

ihTIft1'jE~Jl~fk~M~mz-~

o ~~D~~li~

(

Cheung,

1974

)

pJT1~tl1

:

r~l$i¥Jmililllf!!~

,

*H111T~lliit~~

, ~~

wHH~

•

)(n3L~ft-JIEJ\'

d

;zJ~1JO

0

[E)

!tt

'

~!ih~"~R*l

l

z1t~M!*If!!~

•

J:iT

tj~t~

~

fJXft

~.e~

~

~;f

§

tt~

g*~{gS"JJjjt[E)Z- 0

:l

'

'fHffi

~I1

~jf)zg~x~~~t\+=4- "YT-f}"l"f~

I§

3f

lifI-fi~-"1f.~-lI ~ f~

ti

¥

N

1<1

~1nI

H.m

~ff.S~~¥111

'

f~

~;

~

~

)

(

~

~

)

(~ ~

)

(~ ~

)

:me~:&~:fr\W

~~~Uj:

~

1

73.6

48

18l.1

55

188.2

----­

62

­

-

-i7

4.9

7ffl

r

~R#JIJ~tthjl~:n~j 42

1

70.4

49

184.1

S6

188.0

63

179.3

,

t)$~3i)d~MliiJrf~~ ~Fl ,. 43 44

1

172.7

71.7

51

50

185.6

185.0

57

58

183.5

188.0

64

65

180.9

174.6

1tr

.

~

~"

'~

*~

A

E!'

45

1

76.3

52

185.0

59

183

.0

66

169.7

{Fmz~I{:&~:;I:&*iH'F~; 46

179.4

53

189.7

60

179.4

67

168.7

~.9n1lm

~

pJT

lff

[p]

~~

tt!!

t

47

1

79

.

6

54

188.8

61

176.4

68

163.3

t

th

~

"

~$IJBJllirr

ffij!1!

lit

f.

;:;-1IIii;;;;;;:;;;-=

===========:======::;;;;.;=~~=

,FJ~7ffl8"J~~~*1Hl~1Jm ~;f4*~

:

lf~tgi&JffMa

'

.~~¥IH~~)]t)

§M~

.*~m

~,

~

f

~.~

.rmt~

ffimt.J1J

OO

'~

~M~=

-tli.fll.m~m

~

,.m

~

~~~~~l¥J$ffi

1

16 ~~tJJ!ffWj.&*~*¥~

m

=+M

Mg~

M

~n~=tEm~o~ft'M~.

~~

m

~8~

~~$W

m

R~

MW

m8_

,

~

~

*ltJthP

JTff

ffj~

8

"

1fM~

M

Jth~ffa

kJt!f1

~~jfiiff

I

~

3C

~J5X

*~Zm

1:lD

'

I2';lffiHI~i@~

ffm~8Q~a~.~~~~m~@~ o

1fm@~~~~&

.

~

8~~

~~

~

~

ffl

mT

'

~~~M~.~~Umm~

T_

ffl~

,~~-@~mtt.~~.m$*mOO~ilimoMm$*m@~m~~~-tE.mw

m~zm@nrt,~~~.oo

~

n~~

.

~M~~~moonrt

'1f~~M~m~~ftt

·

1ltm{~1l~31~ljPa

reto~*a

kJ=Ff

~Z

-

,

{B1fmfHl

1f

jfiiff~ljm§t1.td-r

m

43

0

~~~~:tthfIJmfjflskJT~~

,

1EI1lt~~~+1l4fl~lEl¥J!Bl~~~fl~f9iJ~?i%lEi\tu, Z~*,,~ , ~fl~{9ljm-{I~m~ff,xtJf~ r~H:*~:tf

:

f~~M:tthTIDm~/j\~#tJ1'.fEz~~

.e

J~

,

M~~

.

J~

z

g:~f7t~

~g~f

'F*

'

~tt

:J5-*M

.

~~

!!H~mH~

1!H

~'!f

0 J

~::r:i

ITii

~

,~.~z~*$ffi~tt

~

@

.~

'W0~m

~.

I~

.

~,~

.

~z~*

~M~

~~

f

.~'W~gm.~,m~mm=tE.ffl~mZm~, ~~mm=~.*~x.~r~

m~~Z~~~.,~~m@~OJ ~* ,~~mm=+~ilim~r.&~~ffA~ 'i

tJ~mJfH~~~1if'F

'

~~;~U.~.~~?f

'

m

EHlt

0 !t~H:{t!tAtJ.AtJ

'

1if

tJ

'

.JfH~lfri1-t Om~fi~

• • •

~.~~S~~~. ,~~~:tf?f '~U~M~ OJ1lt.~$M~'

~~~+4~zr~ffMWU.IMWm~~W'~M~~~M$ffi*' Ullim.J

(

~MWff~rn~mm~.) ~~~*~~~o

m~'1ffi~~~~~t+-4+-~Mmlli~m=*.~~~n.$ '~~~mft

~~ ' ~~,~w~.wmm~.~~m,m~.~Mm~E*m~Z-( ~.m '~1

3

4 '

m152]{~~158J{) 0 Mz1f~~t+=4j\~fl~na"J.*~~11*WIj$

, M~~~tl

m~~.m:*~.~~~~ffM~z$ffi~~$'~~~@*M.~ ·~~~.WI·

itfr!l!~~~.mH~.?f~~~

(m

-fl*mtff

,x

_

0 Mz5S9~5E~~~t1~*Jtz~~m

:

Elfj

.~*~.~'~~~~~~.~~~$ffi~~$W. '~~@A~~~~.(m~l~

~ff,x) ~~10 1~{9IJ~~~tJt*#z~~

,

~WfiI*lj~F~~JH~

,

1.§.~~11~19IJ~~1.Bn~JiJ;E

r...

.

nlB~~tf~*ltW

'

J;J~flt~

J '

~

~11

*Wlj~~~t

~.

Z~

~

' ~WHl1Hlmlj~F

1It~1~'

+1m

~~~mE~~~sm~rffi

*~~.~z

~~

~

.,

~~

mM

~

=tli

.m~~

~l

i

J

0 ~§z ' ~Jft~tJ:~ r !'~flt.~~rnll*{9IjJ

&

r*lttfu-tEr~fiH.i9IjJ

zJf?t

1

j'

/­

~IJ~~t{iJ:#

'

~~t*~.=-@:.g~~

,

J;)J1~1~JmI*~~

.

fiHHl~~. 0

~~~M

'

~~~.llim

~,~~

•

•

~

.

nrt

zm~'

~

~

~~

mm~1f~M

~·

JilIfliiJ

(~H

:

1~flt)

'f~

1Hl

*lj

(

~

~

t*~.) ~ EI3~m

z1

~7f~

,

~tth

~~mEwh11J1i!~J::

lli

!

,~J;JmimJ{~

,

fEi~$'C1J:Mz~~ 0 ttH~~lSB~~ (~~764

' m

26 .. 27:&

) J;J

488

fllJ

Ht

f~

*s"J[I!)~~ffJt$mlli

'

t*m~~t*

~.?f~

141

A

' 6f

t

*Z

29

% '

~${

~JJ!.~JiU

~

{f.

ztJ:5EnlI

~

TID!k*kJ?f

R ff

42

A El3lltPJ

0

Y! '

~

~

1J~.~1fJE

ij

t

~

:tti!.

~

rw,Zmtmh1i~

*

tfl

'i1H~ 0

-376­

~

{iiJ.*

~Jji~

,'-II"

J

ilT

ffl

A

rthur

(

~

.!31~~

&;.I=

--t

iiU~1fjfiljSkJ~~~

,

l!II.

a1~f:¥1itli

~f.!fM

...{t(

it

n:rr

if

TID

~

..

~gt*~.

'

{­

ffli1t~M:{-t~

iE3m~akJ

a*~

mn~kJ!l15fti:

El

E p~~11~19Ijm=

­

=~z~Ji~

r;

;,tfW:~ 0 *)(~:g1 ~.z1W7Jt 0 ~tJiil~

tili

m

l

J.

I ~Jff~t~~1~

-il

$(i;]&1t£

'

f~ ~llt~f4"F

'

lI

JX

m~, x91~ ~It

1ff>i

ill

~!2~lft

1~~jH~l~j~

9f.Jil1111i~f~WA

f:£*)(~tJlfJ ~q'f~rf~

tJ

itHi'

E

I

ltPfiW

5EskJ

MiI

J!~~BkJtJ9tf~iE)

~

~~~*#

m!i8

tm

l.*~iB~M

t~

t.JJ1

JifIJs"Ji1H

r

f.t~tJ~a~" 0