社區能力與社區生活品質之研究:對社區治理與社區發展的意涵
全文
(2) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. ଯࡋ҅ޑӛᜢᖄ܄ǶќѦǴޗᓉᄊޑȨ୍ΚȩϷᄊޑȨᜢ߯ ΚȩǴჹޗғࢲࠔ፦ԖᡉޑှញΚǶӧ٩่ࣴ݀زՉϩکፕ ࡕǴҁࣴزගрϖࡌٮ҂ٰѠӧݯޗᆶޗวୖޑ ԵǶ [ᜢᗖຒ]ǺૈޗΚǵޗғࢲࠔ፦ǵݯޗǵޗวǵޗวڐ . ൧ȃࠊّ ⁛䴙ᶲ炻㓧⹄䘬℔ℙ㚵⊁廠復㗗䓙㓧⹄䥹ⰌἮ㍸ὃ炻䣦⋨⍫冯㈽ℍ⛘㕡㚵⊁ 廠復䘬㱣䎮忶䦳㗗䦨⮹炻䓂军ᶵ⬀⛐䘬炻Ữ㗗晐叿㓧⹄⛐䚜㍍㚵⊁ὃ䴎奺刚䘬㤝⮷ ⊾炻ẍ⍲⮯㍸ὃ㚵⊁䘬屔ả廱䦣军㮹攻悐攨朆䆇⇑䳬䷼㗪炻⌛↢䎦ᶨ䧖普橼埴≽ 䘬㕘⼊⺷炻忁䧖廱嬲塓䧙ᷳ䁢ˬ䫔ᶱ嶗䶂˭炷The Third Way炸炻℞䚖㧁㗗天⮯ⶪ ⟜䣦⋨䲵ℍ㱣䎮䘬忶䦳炷O’Toole, Dennis, Kilpatrick, & Farmer, 2010: 430炸ˤ䔞 忁䧖ˬ德忶䣦⋨Ἦ䭉䎮˭炷governing through community炸ㆾˬ廱⎹䣦⋨˭炷turn to community炸ᷳ㱣䎮㧉⺷ㆸ䁢℔ℙ㱣䎮䘬㕘怠枭ᷳ晃炻⬫ᶵ塓夾䁢㗗䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬 慵天㕡⺷ᷳᶨ炷Pill & Bailey, 2012炸炻Ṏ塓娵䁢㗗㓡┬䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬ˬ┬㱣˭ 炷good governance炸炷Bowles & Gintis, 2002烊㰇㖶ᾖ炻2009烉10炸ˤ ˬ䣦⋨䘤⯽˭炷community development炸㚱℞忶䦳䚖㧁炻ḇ㚱℞ả⊁䚖㧁炻⯙ 忶䦳侴妨炻䣦⋨䘤⯽㫚德忶ˬ䣦⋨➡≃˭炷community empowerment炸ẍ㍸㖯ˬ䣦 ⋨傥≃˭炷community capacity炸烊⯙ả⊁侴妨炻䣦⋨䘤⯽㫚德忶䣦㚫℔⸛㬋佑 䑘⠫䘬䆇忈炻ẍ㍸㖯ˬ䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒˭炷community life quality炸ˤ⃀䭉䣦⋨傥≃ 冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ㆾ㚱斄倗ㆾ⼙枧炻Ữ℞斄Ὢ㗗⏎⽭䃞㗗㬋⎹䘬ṵ㚱⼭㕇惴ˤἳ⤪炻 劍⮯䣦⋨䴻㾇夾䁢㗗䣦⋨傥≃䘬ᶨ䑘炻⬫᷎ᶵ⽭䃞⮵䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒㗗㚱≑䙲䘬ˤ Green 冯 Haines 炷 2008 炸 ⌛ ㊯ ↢ 炻 䴻 㾇 ⎗ 傥 㚫 ˣ ḇ ⎗ 傥 ᶵ 㚫 ⮶ 农 ˬ 䘤 ⯽ ˭ 炷development炸炻ᶨᾳ䣦⋨䘬屉⡆≈Ḯ炻Ữ劍㗗䓙⮹㔠⭞⹕㊩㚱炻忁䧖㓡嬲 ⮯塓夾䁢㗗ᶨ䧖ˬㆸ攟˭炷growth炸侴朆ˬ䘤⯽˭ˤ⛐䣦⋨䘬傰䴉墉炻ㆸ攟⎗傥 㗗䘤⯽䘬㨇㚫炻⬫ᶵ⽭䃞ⷞἮ嵛ẍ嬻ṢᾹ奢⼿䓇㳣⑩岒䌚⼿㓡┬䘬䘤⯽ˤ. Ʉ2Ʉ.
(3) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬䚠斄嬘柴⺽䘤⺋㲃䘬妶婾炷ἳ⤪烉Chaskin, Brown, Venkatesh, & Vidal, 2001; Craig, 2007; Das, O’Neill, & Pinkerton, 2015; Fleeger & Becker, 2008; Nye & Glickman, 2000; Toomey, 2011炸炻ᶼ㚱ṃ⚳⭞䘬䣦⋨㕡㟰⌛㍉ ⍾䣦⋨傥≃⺢㥳䘬徼⼹炷Collier & Mitchell, 2015; Muljono, 2011; NRU, 2004; Pill & Bailey, 2012炸炻䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䚠斄嬘柴㚜㗗㖑⍿⇘斄㲐炷Marans, 2003; Raphael et al., 2001; Zautra, Beier, & Cappel, 1977炸炻Ṏᶵ᷷㚱⮵䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒 ᷳ攻䘬䚠斄嬘柴忚埴㍊妶炻McPhee 冯 Bare炷2001炸⌛娵䁢炻䣦⋨朆䆇⇑䳬䷼䘬傥 ≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒㗗㚱⼙枧䘬炻Collier 冯 Mitchell炷2015炸⻟婧炻ˬ䣦⋨䴻㾇䤷 䣱˭炷economic well-being炸⮵䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬慵天⿏ˤ䃞侴炻䔞䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨ 䓇㳣⑩岒䚠斄嬘柴ᶵ㕟塓㍸↢㗪炻ㆹᾹ⌣䘤䎦ẍ⼨䘬䞼䨞庫ῷ⎹⮯䣦⋨傥≃夾䁢╖ ᶨ䘬㤪⾝炻ㆾ⎒婾⍲⮹姙䘬朊⎹炷ἳ⤪炻䣦⋨⍫冯ˣ䣦⋨屉⊁ˣ䣦⋨➢䢶⺢姕 䫱炸炻㘖念仢᷷ẍ⣂朊⎹䘬徼⼹Ḱẍ㍊妶炻䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䚠斄䞼䨞Ṏ㚱栆Ụ䘬䉨 㱩ˤ ⎘䀋冒 1965 ⸜炻埴㓧昊㮹䓇ᷣ佑䎦昶㭝䣦㚫㓧䫾℔ⶫ⼴炻ˬ䣦⋨䘤⯽˭㬋⺷ 塓↿䁢℞ᶫ⣏⮎㕥天枭ᷳᶨ炻晐⼴炻㓧⹄映临㍐↢⎬䧖䣦⋨䘤⯽䚠斄䘬妰䔓ㆾ㕡 㟰ˤ㬟䴻⋲ᶾ䲨䘬䘤⯽炻ㆹᾹᶵ䤩⤥⣯⛘゛天䞍忻烉冢䀋䣦⋨䘬䣦⋨傥≃䉨㱩⤪ ỽ烎䣦⋨⯭㮹⮵㕤䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬デ⍿⤪ỽ烎䣦⋨傥≃㗗⏎㚫⼙枧䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒烎 ⎎⢾炻䔞⇵䘬䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬忋䳸炻⮵㕤䔞Ṳ䘬枿⍿慵夾䘬ˬ䣦⋨㱣 䎮˭炷community governance炸㚱ỽ慵天シ㵝烎㛔䞼䨞昌㫚㍊妶ˬ䣦⋨傥≃˭冯 ˬ䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒˭ℑ侭䘬㤪㱩冯斄Ὢ⢾炻Ṏ㛇⼭傥ὅ㒂⮎嫱䞼䨞䘬䳸㝄炻㍸↢㚱≑ 㕤ℐ䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽ᷳ㓧䫾⇞妪ㆾ⮎⊁忳ἄᶲ䘬䚠斄⺢嬘ˤ䵄⎰侴妨炻㛔䞼 䨞ᷳ䞼䨞䚖䘬㬠䲵⤪ᶳ烉 ᶨˣ㍊妶冢䀋䣦⋨ᷳ䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬㤪㱩⍲℞斄倗⿏ˤ Ḵˣ↮㜸䣦⋨䈡⿏冯䣦⋨傥≃⮵䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬⼙枧⍲℞斄Ὢ㧉⺷ˤ ᶱˣὅ㒂䞼䨞䘤䎦㍸↢⎗ὃ⎘䀋䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽㓧䫾ㆾ⮎⊁夷∫䘬䚠斄⺢ 嬘ˤ. Ʉ3Ʉ.
(4) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. ະȃНᝧᔯᎨ Κȃަୣޠཏోᇅጓᛠ 䣦⋨炷community炸ᶨ娆㗗䣦㚫䥹⬠ⷠ䓐䘬㤪⾝ᷳᶨ炻Ữ⬫⌣仢᷷㖶䡢䘬⭂ 佑ˤ䣦⋨⎗傥㗗䓙役惘ㆾ埴㓧廬⋨䳬ㆸ炻ㆾ侭㗗℟㚱ℙ⎴㔯⊾ㆾ䚠⎴䈡岒ˣ⇑䙲 ㆾ⓷柴䘬ᶨ佌Ṣ䳬ㆸ炷Hardina, 2013: 26炸ˤGreen 冯 Haines 娵䁢炷2008: 2炸炻 䣦⋨⊭㊔ᶱ枭天䳈烉炷1炸⋨➇ㆾ⛘㕡烊炷2炸㍸ὃ⯭㮹ᷳ攻夷⼳⿏Ḻ≽䘬䣦㚫䳬䷼ ㆾ⛀橼烊ẍ⍲炷3炸➢㕤ℙ⎴⇑䙲ḳẞ䘬䣦㚫Ḻ≽ˤMattessich 冯 Monsey炷1997: 6炸Ṏ㊩栆Ụ䘬䚳㱽炻娵䁢䣦⋨㗗㊯ṢᾹỷ⛐ᶨᾳ⛘䎮ᶲ塓䭬⭂䘬⋨➇ℏ炻ᶼ⼤㬌 ⍲䣦⋨ᷕ䘬Ṣ℟⁁䣦㚫朊冯⽫䎮朊䘬倗专ˤ忁ṃ⭂佑⼘栗↢䣦⋨䘬シ㵝炻昌⁛䴙ᷳ ⽫䎮シ嬀⍲⛘䎮䨢攻䘬天䳈⢾炷⛘䶋炸炻⮵斄⽫ℙ⎴ḳ⊁ㆾ嬘柴侭侴䳬ㆸ䘬ᶨ佌Ṣ ḇ䌚⼿娵⎗炷ḳ䶋炸ˤ ⁛䴙ᶲ炻⎘䀋⮵㕤䣦⋨䘬⭂佑㗗ẍˬ⛘䶋˭䁢ᷣ炻㘂役⥳㒜⯽军ˬḳ䶋˭ˤ⯙ ⛘䶋侴妨炻⚈⁛䴙ᷳᶨ㛹慴ᶨ䣦⋨䘬夷䭬炻ἧ⼿䣦⋨⛘䎮䭬⚵⼨⼨冯㛹慴䚠ầ炻㓭 ⛐䎮⾝ᶲ庫ᶵ⍿㬉彶炻ㆾ娵䁢℞⭂佑忶㕤䊡晀ˤ⯙ḳ䶋侴妨炻⬫崭崲⁛䴙䣦⋨ㆾ 㛹慴ᷳ䊡晀䘬䨢攻炻᷎⮯斄㲐䘬䃎溆廱䦣军ˬ䈡⭂℔ℙ嬘柴˭炻Ṏ⌛炻ὅ㒂℞斄 ⽫䘬嬘柴炷ἳ⤪烉㔯⊾ˣ䓇ンˣ䑘⠫ㆾ㔁做䫱炸炻㔠ᾳ䣦⋨ℙ⎴㍉⍾嶐䣦⋨䘬⎰ἄ 㧉⺷炻ᶨ崟㍐≽䨢攻炷䈑岒炸ㆾ㔯⊾炷Ṣ㔯炸㕡朊䘬⺢姕ˤ ⃀䭉䣦⋨䘬⭂佑グἮグ㚱⻰⿏炻Ữ⛐䣦⋨嬘柴䘬䞼䨞炻姙⣂㍉⍾ᾳ㟰⺷䘬䞼䨞 怬㗗ẍ⛘䎮⋨➇䭬⭂䘬䣦⋨䁢ᷣ炷ἳ⤪炻悕䐆✌ˣ䌳㗍⊅ˣ昛楁⇑炻2006烊㠩䁛 䏐ˣ⻝攟佑炻2005炸ˤ⛐⮎姤䞼䨞ᶲ炻Coulton炷2005: 75炸⌛㊯↢炻⭂佑䣦⋨䘬䓴 旸㗗䣦⋨䞼䨞冯䣦㚫ⶍἄ⮎⊁怕忯⇘䘬椾天㊹㇘炻䓙㕤℞㧉䱲ᶵ㶭䘬䈡⿏炻⮯⼙ 枧䞼䨞䘬⎗月⹎冯䴙妰侫槿≃炻Ṏ旵ỶḮ⮵䣦⋨㓰㝄䘬Ộ妰ˤ䃞侴炻➢㕤䞼䨞⎗埴 ⿏䘬䎦⮎侫慷炻姙⣂䞼䨞侭怬㗗⽭枰⚆㬠⇘⛘䎮⋨➇䘬∫↮➢㸾炻ẍ 䁢䞼䨞㉥㧋 䘬ὅ㒂炷ἳ⤪炻Obst, Smith, & Zinkiewicz, 2002; Prezza & Constantini, 1998烊㜿ᾉ ⺟ˣ 匲ὸ 㖽 ˣ∱ 䳈䍵 ˣ 湫㸸 ⋼炻2012 烊湫㸸 ⋼ ˣ∱ 䳈䍵 ˣ 匲ὸ 㖽ˣ 㜿 ᾉ⺟炻 2010炸ˤ⃀䭉⬫⎗傥⚈⛘䎮⋨䘬侫慷侴塓岒䔹暋ẍ䛇㬋ẋ堐䣦⋨⯭㮹䘬普橼シ嬀炻 Ữ忁⌣㗗忚埴䞼䨞⽭枰朊⮵䘬㈱㑯ˤ䁢㬌炻⛐㑵ἄᶲ炻㛔䞼䨞Ṏ⮯䣦⋨䭬䔯䭬⭂ 㕤ˬ⛘䶋˭奨溆ᷳˬ䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼㚫˭ᷳ柀⮶侭䭬⭂䘬䣦⋨ˤ. Ʉ4Ʉ.
(5) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. Ρȃަୣݾ౪ޠཏోᇅ ⛐℔ℙ㚵⊁䘬廠復ᶲ炻䔞䥹Ⰼ㍏⇞冯ⶪ⟜ὃ䴎㧉⺷䚠两⣙曰ᷳ⼴炻ˬ䵚䴉㱣 䎮˭炷network governance炸晐ᷳㆸ䁢℔䥩悐攨Ḻ≽䘬㕘怠㑯炻䃞侴炻⚈䵚䴉⊭ ⏓䘬䭬⚵忶㕤⺋㲃炻昌㴱⍲⎬埴≽侭ᷳ攻䘬Ḻ≽炻ḇ⊭㊔ᾳ⇍埴≽侭䘬冒ㆹ㱣䎮ˤ 冒ㆹ㱣䎮䈡⇍⻟婧ᾳ⇍䣦⋨ℏ悐䘬娵⎴ˣℙ嬀⺢䩳ẍ⍲冒ᷣ忳ἄ炻℟㚱䚠⮵庫⻟䘬 ᷣ橼⿏冯屔ả佑⊁炻⚈侴⬫⽆䵚䴉䘬㤪⾝埵䓇↢ˬ䣦⋨㱣䎮㧉⺷˭炷community governance model炸炷Thompson, Frances, Levaþiü, & Mitchell, 1991炸ˤ忁䧖䘤⯽嵐 ⊊昌䨩栗䥹Ⰼ冯ⶪ⟜㱣䎮䘬⺷⽖⢾炻Ṏ⼘栗↢ˬ䣦佌ᷣ佑˭炷communitarianism炸 ⻟婧ᷳ⛘㕡㮹ᷣ炷local democracy炸冯℔㮹䣦㚫炷civic society炸䘬䎮⾝⍿⇘曺 䜆ˤ 㛔岒ᶲ炻䣦⋨㱣䎮⌛㗗ᶨ䧖䣦⋨䘬冒ㆹ㱣䎮ㆾ℔㮹㱣䎮炷Kooiman, 1993: 79炸炻⬫㗗ᶨ䧖⛐⛘⯭㮹䁢Ḯ䣦⋨普橼⇑䙲䘬埴≽炻℞⍫冯侭⎗傥⊭㊔℔ˣ䥩⽿ 栀 悐 攨 䘬 㚱 埴 ≽ 侭 炷 O’Toole & Burdess, 2004: 434 炸 ˤ Woods ˣ Edwards ˣ Anderson 冯 Fahmy ㊯↢炻䣦⋨㱣䎮Ὢ㊯ˬᶨ䧖崭崲⛘㕡埴㓧⋨ᷳ⍫冯䘬㳣≽炻᷎ 㴱⍲䣦⋨ℏᷳ℔ℙ㚵⊁䘬㍸ὃㆾ⢾悐㨇㥳ᷳ䣦⋨⇑䙲ẋ堐䘬㚱㳣≽˭炷O’Toole & Burdess, 2004: 434炸ˤBox炷1998: 19炸⛐䣦⋨㱣䎮⍇⇯ᷕṎ㍸⍲烉ˬ℔㮹ˣ㮹シ ẋ堐冯➢Ⰼ⭀⒉⽭枰ᶨ崟Ἦ㱣䎮䣦⋨炻德忶ᾳṢㆾ普橼⛘冒䓙怠㑯冒㰢䦳⹎炻ᷣ⮶ 冒䣦⋨䔞⛘䘬℔ℙ䓇㳣˭炷㰇㖶ᾖ炻2009烉7炸ˤ栗夳炻䣦⋨㱣䎮⯙⛐㕤堐⽝⛘ 㕡ᷣ⮶冯℔㮹䘬冒ㆹ㱣䎮炻℔㮹⮵冒䓇㳣ᷳ䣦⋨䘬ḳ⊁ᶵ天傥㑩㚱㚜⣂䘬㰢 䫾㪲炻ḇ栀シ㑼屈崟⮎嶸℔ℙ㓧䫾䘬ᷣ⮶㪲屔ˤ 䣦⋨㱣䎮䘬徼⼹⍿⇘ṢᾹ䣦⋨䘬慵夾炻ᶨ㕡朊⬫㍸ὃḮᶨ䧖Ṣ㮹⎗ẍ⍫冯 ⍲䘤倚䘬䭉忻炷Das et al., 2015炸炻⎎ᶨ㕡朊Ṏ⼘栗↢℔㮹⍫冯䁢⮎嶸䣦⋨㱣䎮ᶵ ⎗ㆾ仢䘬天䳈ˤ⽆⍫冯⍲冒ᷣ⿏䘬奺⹎侴妨炻䣦⋨㱣䎮㚱ℑ䧖奨溆烉炷1炸⛘㕡⛀ 橼塓㔜⎰忚⛘㕡㓧⹄㛔幓䳸㥳䘬⬴ℐ㔜⎰奨溆炷a fully integrated approach炸烊 炷2炸叿慵㕤⛘㕡䳬䷼⭋䧙ẋ堐⛘㕡⯭㮹䘬⇑䙲炻᷎䌐䩳㕤⛘㕡㓧⹄䳸㥳䘬⬴ℐ冒 ᷣ奨溆炷a fully independent approach炸炷O’Toole & Burdess, 2004: 435炸ˤLowndes 冯 Sullivan炷2008炸⇯ὅ℞⍇䎮䚖䘬炻⮯䣦⋨㱣䎮⋨↮䁢⚃䧖栆✳烉炷1炸ὅ℔㮹 ⍇ 䎮 炷 civic rationale 炸 ᷳ 忚 埴 ℔ 㮹 䣦 ⋨ ➡ ≃ 烊 炷 2 炸 ὅ 䣦 㚫 ⍇ 䎮 炷 social rationale 炸 ᷳ ⮵ ᶨ ᾳ ⛘ ⋨ ㍉ ⍾ ℐ 奨 䘬 ề Ờ 斄 Ὢ 烊 炷 3 炸 ὅ 㓧 㱣 ⍇ 䎮 炷 political rationale炸ᷳ德忶㕘⺷ẋ堐⍫冯Ἦ忚埴䴙㱣烊ẍ⍲炷4炸ὅ䴻㾇⍇䎮炷economic. Ʉ5Ʉ.
(6) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. rationale炸ᷳ㚜㚱㓰傥䘬䭉䎮⛘㕡㚵⊁廠復ˤ䁢Ὣ忚䣦⋨䘤⯽ᷳ㍸⋯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒 ᷳ䚖㧁䘬忼ㆸ炻℔㮹䣦㚫䘬ㆸ⒉枰夾䣦⋨䘬ね⠫炻⯌℞㗗䣦⋨傥≃䘬䳬⎰䉨㱩炻䳸 ⎰ㆾ⻰⿏忳䓐⎬䧖ᶵ⎴䘬㱣䎮栆✳ˤ. ήȃަୣΩޠཏోᇅ࡛ᄻ ȞΚȟަୣΩޠཏోġ 䣦⋨傥≃ᶨ娆⛐大㕡⚳⭞塓⺋㲃ἧ䓐炻Chaskin 䫱Ṣ炷2001: 7炸娵䁢烉ˬ䣦 ⋨傥≃Ὢ㊯⬀⛐ᶨᾳ䈡⭂䣦⋨ℏ䘬Ṣ≃屯㛔ˣ䳬䷼屯㸸⍲䣦㚫屯㛔䘬Ḻ≽炻⬫⎗䓐 㕤 䁢妋㰢普橼⓷柴炻ẍ⍲㓡┬ㆾ䵕专䣦⋨䤷䣱䘬ㇳ㭝˭ˤLaverack炷2006: 267炸 娵䁢烉ˬ䣦⋨傥≃Ὢ㊯ᶨ䧖忶䦳炻⬫⎗⡆忚ᶨᾳ䣦⋨傥⣈⺽↢㓡┬℞䓇㳣䘬屯䓊 Ⱄ⿏˭ˤRubin 冯 Rubin炷2008: 97炸⇯娵䁢烉ˬ䣦⋨傥≃Ὢ㊯⛐ᶨᾳ䣦⋨ℏᷳ姙⣂ ᾳṢ䘬普橼䞍嬀炻ẍ⍲⎗䓐㕤妋㰢⓷柴䘬䴻㾇ˣ䈑岒ˣ䣦㚫䳬䷼䘬屯㸸˭ˤ䵄⎰ ⇵徘⬠侭Ᾱ䘬婒㱽炻ㆾ姙⎗䚳↢䣦⋨傥≃䘬忳ἄ炻℞䚖䘬⌛⛐㕤妋㰢䣦⋨普橼⓷柴 ㆾ㍸㖯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒炻䁢忼⇘㬌ᶨ䚖䘬炻⎗ẍ䓙ℑᾳ朊⎹Ἦ↮㜸䣦⋨傥≃䘬シ㵝ʇ 忶䦳冯ℏ⭡ˤ ⯙忶䦳侴妨炻䣦⋨傥≃⌛㗗ᶨ䧖䣦⋨妋㰢普橼⓷柴ㆾὫ忚䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬埴≽ 㬟䦳炻德忶䣦⋨ᷕ䘬ᾳṢ冯ᾳṢˣᾳṢ冯䳬䷼ˣẍ⍲䳬䷼冯䳬䷼ᷳ攻䘬Ḻ≽炻䓂军 㗗冯䣦⋨⢾䘬屯㸸䓊䓇忋䳸炻ẍ䳗䧵㚜⣂䘬䣦⋨屯䓊ㆾ≃慷炻ẍ㛇㚱≑㕤埴≽䚖䘬 䘬忼ㆸˤChaskin 䫱Ṣ炷2001炸⌛娵䁢炻䣦⋨傥≃䘬䳗䧵枰德忶⣂Ⰼ㫉⨺ṳ≇㓰䘬 䳬⎰ʇᾳṢˣ䳬䷼冯䵚䴉炻忁䧖䣦⋨傥≃䘬≽ン忶䦳ḇ⌛㗗 RaeburnˣAkermanˣ ChuengsatiansupˣMejia 冯 Oladepo炷2007炸㍸ᷳ傥≃⺢㥳䘬ˬ䘤⯽傥≃ᷳ忶䦳˭ 炷process of developing competence炸ˤ ⯙ℏ⭡侴妨炻䣦⋨傥≃⌛㗗ᶨᾳ䣦⋨䘬屯䓊ㆾ≃慷䘬䷥炻Green 冯 Haines 炷2008炸㍸ᷳˬ䣦⋨屯䓊˭䘬ᶫ⣏栆✳炻怑嵛ẍẋ堐ᶨᾳ䣦⋨ᷳ傥≃䘬䷥⎰炻⊭ ㊔烉䈑岒䘬ˣṢ≃䘬ˣ䣦㚫䘬ˣ屉⊁䘬ˣ䑘⠫䘬ˣ㓧㱣䘬ẍ⍲㔯⊾䘬屯䓊ˤ⛐伶 ⚳炻䁢Ḯ姽Ộˬ䣦⋨䘤⯽ềỜ˭炷Community Development Partnership, CDP炸⮵ ˬ䣦⋨䘤⯽㱽Ṣ˭炷Community Development Corporation, CDC炸䘬⼙枧炻⮯䣦⋨傥 ≃↮ㆸḼ䧖ㆸ↮烉屯㸸ˣ䳬䷼ˣ䵚䴉ˣ㕡㟰⍲㓧㱣傥≃炷Lowe, 2008炸ˤ㬌⢾炻劙 ⚳䘬ˬ惘慴㚜㕘彎℔⭌˭炷Neighbourhood Renewal Unit, NRU炸炷2006炸㍸↢⻟≃ 䣦⋨䘬⚾⁷㗗䓙Ḽ枭㊯㧁䳬ㆸ烉⛘㕡⍫冯㱣䎮ˣ䣦⋨ↅ倂圵⎰ˣ⽿栀埴䁢ˣ⛘ 㕡䣦⋨悐攨ˣẍ⍲慵天℔ℙ㚵⊁䓙⽿栀䣦⋨悐攨廠復炻劍ᶨᾳ䣦⋨⛐忁Ḽ枭㊯ Ʉ6Ʉ.
(7) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 㧁䘬慷グ⣂⌛ẋ堐℞䣦⋨≃慷炷community strength炸グ⻟ˤ⚈㬌炻⯙ℏ⭡侴妨炻䣦 ⋨傥≃ḇ⌛㗗ᶨᾳ䣦⋨ℏᷳˬ䣦⋨屯䓊˭冯ˬ䣦⋨≃慷˭䘬䷥ˤ 䃉婾⽆忶䦳ㆾℏ⭡奨ᷳ炻婈⤪ Jackson 妨炻ˬ䣦⋨傥≃˭᷎㰺㚱⣒⣂䘬䎮婾 側㘗炷湫㘾㘜ˣ傉㵹屆炻2006炸炻ᶼ⛐シ佑ᶲḇ⬀⛐叿㧉䱲⿏炻劍天ᶳᾳ㖶䡢䘬⭂ 佑婈Ⱄᶵ㖻ˤ㛔䞼䨞⛐㑵ἄᶲ㍉䓐⏓㚱忶䦳冯ℏ⭡ᷳ庫䁢⺋佑䘬奨溆炻⮯䣦⋨傥≃ ⋨↮䁢朄ン冯≽ンℑᾳ朊⎹炻朄ン傥≃ῷ⎹ℏ⭡⍾⎹炻Ṏ⌛⬀⛐㕤ᶨᾳ䣦⋨ᷳ屯䓊 ㆾ≃慷炻ἳ⤪炻㚱⼊䘬䈑岒屯䓊炷⤪⺢䈑ˣ姕㕥姕⁁炸ˣṢ≃屯㸸炷⤪䣦⋨⯭㮹䞍 嬀ˣ㈨傥炸ˣ䣦㚫屯㛔炷ᾉảˣ䵚䴉ˣ夷䭬炸烊≽ン傥≃ῷ⎹忶䦳⍾⎹炻Ṏ⌛䁢徥 㯪䣦⋨䘤⯽侴㍉⍾䘬埴≽炻ἳ⤪炻䣦⋨⍫冯ˣ䣦⋨䳬䷼ˣ䣦⋨柀⮶ㆾ䳬䷼攻䘬忋䳸 䫱ˤ. ȞΡȟަୣΩ࡛ᄻġ ˬ䣦⋨傥≃⺢㥳˭炷community capacity building炸䁢䔞ẋ℔ℙ㓧䫾ᶲ枿⍿慵夾 䘬嬘柴炻⃀䭉⛐⮎⊁ᶲ⬫⼰暋冯ˬ䣦⋨䘤⯽˭ ⋨彐炻ᶼⷞ㚱ˬ㕘䒞墅冲惺˭䘬シ 㵝炻Ữ㝸䧖䦳⹎ᶲ⬫冯 Kretzmann 冯 McKnight炷1993炸㍸↢䘬ˬ䣦⋨屯䓊˭奨溆 㗗䚠ầ䘬炻娚奨溆ᷣ⻝ㅱ⮯䃎溆伖㕤䣦⋨䘬⃒⊊炷屯䓊炸炻ẍ㚱⇍㕤⁛䴙䘬⓷柴 炷暨㯪炸⮶⎹㧉⺷炻忁䧖ἄ㱽⌛ẋ堐㘂役䣦⋨䘤⯽⮎⊁ⶍἄ侭⛐㕡㱽ᶲ䘬ᷣ天廱 嬲ˤBerkes 冯 Ross炷2013: 5炸⌛⻟婧炻天傥⣈䡢娵䘤⯽䣦⋨⃒⊊炻᷎德忶㨇㥳 冒ㆹ䳬䷼Ἦ⺢䩳⽑⍇≃炻䈡⇍㗗天斄㲐⇘Ṣʇ⛘㕡䘬忋䳸ˣ₡ῤ冯ᾉ⾝ˣ䞍嬀 ⬠佺ˣ䣦㚫䵚䴉ˣ⋼≃㱣䎮ˣ䴻㾇⣂㧋⊾ˣ➢䢶䳸㥳⍲柀⮶䫱ˤ䁢㬌炻䣦⋨傥≃⍾ ⎹⌛シ␛叿䣦⋨ṳℍ䘬䃎溆炻⮯⽆䣦⋨䘬⓷柴炾暨㯪廱䦣军䣦⋨䘬屯䓊炾⃒⊊炻忁 ἧ⼿傥≃⺢㥳䘬㤪⾝攳⥳䌚⼿慵夾冯⻟婧ˤCnann 冯 Rothman炷2008炸⌛夾傥≃⺢ 㥳䁢ᶨ䧖䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬㕡㱽炻䓐㕤溻⊝惘慴冒≑ˣ屈屔ả䘬柀⮶ˣẍ⍲ᶨ䧖⮵℔㮹⍫ 冯䘬㈧媦ˤ⛐⮎⊁㑵ἄᶲ炻䣦⋨⎗ὅ℞冒幓䘬䈡⿏㍉⍾ᶵ⎴䘬䫾䔍炻⊭㊔ 炷Chaskin et al., 2001; Nye & Glickman, 2000; Rubin & Rubin, 2008; Pierson, 2008炸烉 1. 柀 ⮶ 䘤 ⯽ 烉 叿 慵 㕤 䣦 ⋨ ⺢ 㥳 忶 䦳 ᷕ ᾳ Ṣ 䘬 ㈨ 埻 ˣ ㈧ 媦 ˣ 借 ⊁ 㓰 傥 ˤ Wescott炷2002炸⌛娵䁢炻傥≃⺢㥳⽭枰䚉⎗傥┬䓐⛘㕡䘬⮰⭞炻Toomey 炷2011炸⇯娵䁢炻䣦⋨柀⮶侭天傥⣈德忶⁔⊾ˣ㽨⊝ˣ⨺⎰Έ⮶䘬奺刚Ἦ ➡≃䣦⋨ˤ 2. 䳬䷼䘤⯽烉⊭㊔∝䩳㕘䘬䳬䷼ㆾ⻟⊾䎦㚱䳬䷼䘬≇傥炻ẍὧṾᾹ傥⣈⛐㖊㚱 䘬ⶍἄᶲ㚱庫Ἓ䘬堐䎦炻ㆾ屈崟㕘䘬借屔ˤMcPhee 冯 Bare炷2001炸⌛⻟ Ʉ7Ʉ.
(8) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. 婧炻德忶䘤⯽䳬䷼Ἦ⺢䩳䵕专℔㮹⍫冯炻㗗䔞ẋ⻟≃䣦⋨䘬慵天䈡刚ᷳ ᶨˤ 3. 䣦⋨䳬䷼烉℞㧁䘬⛐㕤䣦⋨忳ἄ䘬䳸⎰ˣẍ⍲䁢䈡⭂普橼䘬䚖䘬侴≽⒉ᾳ⇍ 䘬⇑⭛斄ὪṢˤNye 冯 Glickman炷2000炸⌛⻟婧炻⛘㕡⣍Ờ㚫㍸ὃ屯慹ˣ ㈨埻㎜≑ˣ⍲℞⬫㚱≑㕤ㆸ攟㚵⊁℞惘慴䘬天䳈ˤ 4. 䳬䷼⎰ἄ烉Ὢ㊯德忶䳬䷼Ⰼ㫉ᷳ斄Ὢ䘬䘤⯽⎰ἄ䘬ềỜ斄Ὢ炻ẍ⺢㥳䣦⋨ ᷳ䳬䷼䘬⸽Ⰼ䳸㥳烊Ṏ⌛炻⻟⊾䵚䴉ㆸ⒉ㆾ䳬䷼䘬忋䳸ˤFleeger 冯 Becker 炷2008炸⌛⻟婧┬䓐⛘㕡㓧⹄ẍ⻟⊾㨇㥳攻䘬⎰ἄ炻⮵攳∝䵕专䣦⋨傥≃ 㚱℞慵天⿏ˤ 5. ㆸ≇埴≽烉啱䓙ㆸ≇埴≽䘬䴻槿Ἦ∝忈䣦⋨䘬傥≃ˤMattessich 冯 Monsey 炷1997炸⌛㊯↢炻㚦䴻㚱忶ㆸ≇䴻槿䘬䣦⋨炻℞䣦⋨䆇忈天㭼㰺㚱ㆸ≇䴻槿 䘬䣦⋨㨇㚫天⣂ˤ. ήȃަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ޠཏోȃข໕ᇅኈӱષ ȞΚȟަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ޠཏోġ ˬᶾ䓴堃䓇䳬䷼˭炷World Health Organization, WHO炸⮯䓇㳣⑩岒⭂佑䁢ˬ⛐ 㔯⊾冯₡ῤ䲣䴙䘬䣦㚫傰䴉ᷕ炻ᾳṢ⮵℞䓇㳣嗽䉨㱩ᷳデ奢˭炷WHO, 1999炸ˤ Seik炷2000炸⮯䓇㳣⑩岒䓴⭂䁢ˬᾳṢ⮵㔜橼䓇㳣䘬㺧シ⹎˭烊Costanza 䫱Ṣ 炷2007炸娵䁢炻䓇㳣⑩岒ⷠ塓䓐㕤ẋ堐ṢᾹ䘬暨㯪⤪ỽ塓㺧嵛炻ẍ⍲ᾳṢㆾ⛀橼⛐ 䓇㳣⎬柀➇デ⍿⇘㺧シㆾᶵ㺧シ䘬䦳⹎ˤAki 䫱Ṣ炷2008炸娵䁢炻䓇㳣⑩岒⊭㊔䓇 㳣㺧シ⹎ˣ䣦㚫≇傥ˣ㖍ⷠ䓇㳣㳣≽ẍ⍲幓橼䘬ˤ㛶㯠⯽ˣ⏛⬇剛炷2005炸娵 䁢炻䓇㳣⑩岒Ὢ㊯ᶨ⚳Ṣ㮹⮵℞䓇㳣ᷕᶵ⎴䭬䔯ᷳ㺧シ䦳⹎炻Ṏ⌛Ṣ㮹⮵℞嗽䓇 㳣䑘⠫䘬㺧シ⹎ˤ 栗䃞炻⮵㕤䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䓴⭂㘖念ṵ㍉⍾㤪㊔⿏ㆾᷣ奨⿏䘬婒㱽炻ℵ≈ᶲ䓇㳣⑩ 岒ⷠ晐叿䞼䨞柀➇⍲㗪䨢䑘⠫傰䴉䘬ᶵᶨ炻ἧ℞䚠斄䞼䨞彬Ṳṵ仢᷷ᶨ⣿ᶨ农⿏䘬 ⺢㥳㕡㱽ㆾ㧁㸾炷Murphy, Cooney, Shea, & Casey, 2009炸ˤᶨ凔侴妨炻䞼䨞侭⮵䓇 㳣⑩岒䘬妶婾⼨⼨暋ẍ嶛僓↢ˬ⭊奨˭炷objective炸冯ˬᷣ奨˭炷subjective炸䘬䭬 䔯ˤˬ⭊奨˭䓇㳣⑩岒㗗⽆慷⊾䘬䣦㚫ˣ䴻㾇䑘⠫㊯㧁炻Ἦ⍵㗈ṢᾹ暨㯪㺧嵛䘬 䦳⹎烊ˬᷣ奨˭䓇㳣⑩岒⇯“慵㕤ᾳṢᷣ奨䘬䤷䣱炻Ṏ⌛炻ᾳṢ冒奢⮵⎬柀➇䘬䓇 㳣䤷䣱ㆾ㔜橼䓇㳣䤷䣱䘬⸠䤷デˣケ〭デㆾ㺧嵛デˤ䃞侴炻忁᷎朆䞼䨞侭⮵䓇㳣⑩ 岒䘬㍊妶㚱ˬᷣ奨˭ㆾˬ⭊奨˭ᷳ䇕炻ḳ⮎ᶲ炻䞼䨞ᶲᶵ᷷⽆ᶵ⎴䘬天䳈䳬⎰Ἦ㍊ Ʉ8Ʉ.
(9) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 䨞䓇㳣⑩岒䘬朊尴炻Ṏ⌛炻䓇㳣⑩岒㗗ᶨ䧖墯⎰䘬奨⾝炻⬫㗗姙⣂ᶵ⎴Ⰼ朊䘬䳬⎰ 橼ˤ ⛐䣦⋨䘬傰䴉墉炻Zautra 䫱Ṣ炷1977: 85炸㊯↢炻䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬㤪⾝㝞㥳⊭ ㊔ᶱ枭⚈䳈烉⸠䤷デˣ䣦⋨⍫冯✳ン⍲ῷ⤥ˤ℞ᷕ炻⸠䤷デ㗗㚨嵛ẍ婒㖶䣦⋨䓇㳣 ⑩岒䘬妲〗炻ᷣ天ㆸ↮⊭㊔烉⭞⹕䓇㳣✳ンˣᾳṢ䓇㳣✳ンˣ䴻㾇䤷䣱ẍ⍲䓇␥桐 晒ˤ䣦⋨⍫冯✳ン㗗ᶨ䧖㚜㶙⹎䝕妋ṢᾹ⍫冯䣦⋨㍸ὃᷳ㳣≽䘬㕡⺷炻ᷣ天䘬⚈ 䳈䁢烉ⶍἄ屔ảˣ⭞⹕屔ảˣ⬿㔁ㆸ⒉幓ấẍ⍲冒ㆹ㳣⊾ἄ䓐ˤῷ⤥⛐䓇㳣⑩岒䘬 堉慷ᶲ㗗㚨䁢栗叿䘬ʇ㬠屔⍾⎹ˣ屯㸸ῷ⤥ẍ⍲冒幓屔ảˤ. 䣦⋨ (㬉㦪䘬). ⎗⯭ġġ ỷ⿏ġ. 䑘⠫ (傥䓇⬀䘬). 䓇㳣ġġ ℔⸛䘬ġġ. ⑩岒ġġ. ĩ⎗役⿏Īġ. 䑘⠫ġġ 㯠临ġ. 䴻㾇ġġ ĩ嬲≽⿏Īġ. ⚾ᶨ 䓇ン奨溆ᷳ㚱䙲䣦⋨䣦㚫⑩岒ᷳ天䳈䘬㤪⾝㧉⺷ 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉ġ“A tale of three greenway trails: user perceptions related to quality of life”, by Shafer, C. S., B. K. Lee, & S. Turner, 2000, Landscape and Urban Planning, 49(3), 163178.ġ. ShaferˣLee 冯 Turner炷2000炸⽆ˬṢ㔯䓇ン⬠˭炷human ecology炸䘬奨溆娵 䁢炻ᶨᾳ㯠临䘬䣦⋨天傥⣈䁢℞⯭㮹㍸ὃ᷎䵕专ᶨ䧖⃒岒䘬䓇㳣ˤ娚㧉⺷娵䁢䣦⋨ 䓇㳣⑩岒㗗䓙䣦⋨炷䣦㚫炸ˣ䴻㾇冯炷䈑䎮炸䑘⠫䫱ᶱ柀➇䘬⑩岒ᷳ㊩临⿏䘬Ḻ≽ ∝忈↢炻ᶼ⎗⯭ỷ⿏ˣ㯠临⿏ˣ℔⸛⿏⍲䓇㳣⑩岒㗗䣦⋨ˣ䴻㾇冯䑘⠫ᶱ侭ᷳṌ Ḻἄ䓐䘬䳸㝄烊℞ᷕ炻⎗⯭ỷ⿏㗗䑘⠫冯䣦⋨炻㯠临⿏㗗䑘⠫冯䴻㾇炻℔⸛⿏⇯㗗. Ʉ9Ʉ.
(10) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. 䣦⋨冯䴻㾇䫱ṌḺἄ䓐䘬䳸㝄炻ᶱ枭柀➇ᷳ攻ṌḺἄ䓐䘬䳸㝄⌛㗗䓇㳣⑩岒炷⤪⚾ ᶨ炸ˤ ➢㕤⇵徘䘬↮㜸炻ㆹᾹㆾ⎗⮯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒⭂佑䁢烉ᶨᾳ⛘㕡䣦⋨䘬⯭㮹炻⮵ 㕤℞⯭ỷ䣦⋨ᷳ䴻㾇ˣ䣦㚫ˣ䑘⠫ˣ䓇ンˣ㔯⊾ˣˣ⬱ℐ⍲炷䓂军㗗炸㓧㱣 ⎬Ⰼ朊䘬デ⍿炻℞⼊ㆸ䘬デ⍿⮯⼙枧⇘ᾳṢ䘬㺧シ⹎ˣ⸠䤷デ冯䤷䣱ˤ䃞侴炻⎬ Ⰼ朊⏰䎦䘬䉨㱩炻⎗傥㚫㚱℟橼䘬㔠慷炻Ṏ⎗傥晐叿⯭㮹ᾳṢ䘬⽫䎮デ⍿侴ᶵ ⎴ˤGollagher 冯 Hartz-Karp炷2013炸⌛㊯↢炻㯠临䘬嬘柴㴱⍲⇘䣦㚫ˣ䴻㾇䑘⠫ ⚈䳈ᷳ攻䘬墯暄Ḻ≽炻ᶼᶵ⎴䘬⇑⭛斄ὪṢ䘬䚳㱽⼨⼨ḇ㚱⼰⣏䘬ⶖ䔘ˤ. ȞΡȟҢࣁࠣ፵ޠᒌ໕ġ 䓇㳣⑩岒䘬堉慷ⷠ塓⋨↮䁢ˬ⭊奨˭冯ˬᷣ奨˭ℑ䧖㷔慷㕡㱽ˤˬ⭊奨˭朊⎹ 㗗ᶨ䧖忳䓐慷⊾䘬䣦㚫ˣ䴻㾇䫱㊯㧁炻ẍ⍵㗈ṢᾹ暨㯪㺧嵛䘬䦳⹎炻℞ἧ䓐 䘬㊯㧁⤪嬀⫿䌯ˣⶍἄˣỷ⬭ˣ⼿ˣˣ慓䗪Ṣḳˣ䵈⛘ˣ䉗伒䌯ẍ⍲ᶨṃ䃉 枰䴻䓙ᾳṢᷣ奨姽慷䘬㊯㧁炷Ackerman & Paolucci, 1983; Costanza et al., 2007; Schneider, 1975炸ˤẍˬ⭊奨˭㊯㧁堉慷䘬`姕⌛㗗烉⤪㝄⭊奨㡅ẞ嬲⤥炻ṢᾹ䘬 ⽫䎮デ奢㚫嬲⤥ˤὅ㬌炻⭊奨䘬䓇㳣㡅ẞ⮯冯ᷣ奨䘬䓇㳣㺧シ㛅⎹⎴ᶨ㕡⎹嬲≽炻 Ṏ⌛ℑ侭ᷳ攻⬀㚱㝸䧖䦳⹎䘬斄倗⿏ˤ ⃀䭉姙⣂䞼䨞䘤䎦⭊奨冯ᷣ奨㷔慷㗗㚱斄倗⿏䘬炷Wasserman & Chua, 1980; Walter-Busch, 1983; Marans, 2003炸炻Ữ᷎朆㚱䞼䨞䘮㓗㊩忁䧖婾徘ˤSchneider 炷1975炸䘬䞼䨞⌛䘤䎦炻⭊奨㊯㧁㷔↢ᷳ㚨㚱䘬❶ⶪ炻᷎ᶵ⽭䃞㗗恋ṃᷣ奨ᶲ ⮵℞䓇㳣ね⠫㚨デ㺧シ䘬❶ⶪ烊⍵ᷳ炻⭊奨ᶲ㚨ⶖ䘬❶ⶪ炻ḇ᷎ᶵ⽭䃞㗗恋ṃᷣ奨 䓇㳣㺧シ⹎㚨ⶖ䘬❶ⶪˤ䃞侴炻Wasserman 冯 Chua炷1980炸⌣⮵ Schneider ᷳˬ㰺 㚱ᶨ农䘬斄倗⿏˭㍸↢岒䔹炻ṾᾹ娵䁢炻Schneider 㛒傥⮯❶ⶪ夷㧉 怑䔞䘬侫 慷炻娚䞼䨞⺢嬘炻⚈⎬⛘䘬⭊奨㡅ẞ᷎ᶵᶨ农炻㛒Ἦ䘬䞼䨞⭄ẍ庫⮷䘬⛘䎮⋨炷䣦 ⋨炸ἄ䁢䞼䨞⟜➇ˤ忁枭姽徘⣂⮹㍸愺䞼䨞侭⛐ˬ⭊奨˭冯ˬᷣ奨˭䘬䇕彗ᶲ炻⽭ 枰天傥侫慷⇘⛘㕡䘬䈡⿏ˤ ⚈⭊奨㊯㧁塓岒䔹䁢䃉㱽⍵㗈↢ṢᾹ䓇㳣䘬䛇㬋ン⹎炻㓭㚱⬠侭娵䁢⑩岒䘬堉 慷⽭枰㗗ᷣ奨䘬炻⌛㚨㬋䡢䘬 㱽㗗䚜㍍娊⓷㮹䛦ᾳṢ䘬䓇㳣ᷣ奨デ⍿ 炷Schneider, 1975; Zhu, 2001烊⬓㖶䁢炻1997炸ˤᷣ奨朊⎹䘬䓇㳣⑩岒㗗㊯ᾳṢ⮵ 㕤⸠䤷ˣケ〭ˣㆸ⯙⍲╄㬉䘬冒ㆹ姽慷炻ㆾ侭㗗⮵㺧シ⹎ˣ䤷䣱⍲⽫䎮䘬デ 奢炻忁䧖姽慷デ奢⍿⇘娵䞍冯ねデ天䳈䘬⼙枧炻㷔慷ⶍ℟叿慵㕤ᾳṢ⮵䣦㚫ˣ䴻. Ʉ10Ʉ.
(11) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 㾇㊯㧁ᷳ䓇㳣䴻槿䘬⟙⏲炻ἳ⤪炻冒奢暨㯪塓㺧嵛䘬䦳⹎ˣẍ⍲⮵㔜橼䓇㳣 ⑩岒ᷳデ奢⿏暨㯪䘬慵天⿏炷Costanza et al., 2007; Walter-Busch, 1983炸ˤ ᷣ奨冯⭊奨朊⎹䘬㷔慷⎬冒㚱℞⃒⊊冯旸⇞炻劍䳽⮵ẍˬ⭊奨˭ㆾˬᷣ奨˭㊯ 㧁Ἦ娖慳䓇㳣⑩岒炻℞怑䓐⿏⌛⎗傥⺽䘤䇕嬘炻Pacione炷1982炸⌛㊯↢炻⭊奨䓇 㳣⑩岒㊯㧁⛐姽慷Ṣ栆䤷䣱㗪炻忂ⷠ塓娵䁢℟㚱庫檀䘬⎗ᾉ⹎炻Ữ㓰⹎⌣ῷỶ炻侴 ᷣ奨㊯㧁忂ⷠ㗗℟㚱庫Ỷ䘬ᾉ⹎炻⌣㚱庫檀䘬㓰⹎炷㛶㯠⯽ˣ⏛⬇剛炻2005烉 391炸ˤ⛐⭊奨冯ᷣ奨䘬㷔慷㕡㱽䘮㚱℞旸⇞䘬䉨㱩ᶳ炻⤪ỽ䳸⎰⭊奨冯ᷣ奨䘬㷔 慷㕡㱽ὧㆸ䁢⎎栆䘬⎗傥徼⼹ˤ➢㕤⎘䀋ˬ䣦⋨˭䘬⭊奨⑩岒ᷳ慷⊾㔠㒂䘬吸普㚱 ⮎岒ᶲ䘬⚘暋炻㛔䞼䨞㍉䓐ˬ䣦⋨Ⰼ㫉˭冯ˬᾳṢⰌ㫉˭䘬䓇㳣⑩岒䘬徼⼹忚埴↮ 㜸炻℞㑵ἄ⿏⭂佑婒㖶㕤䞼䨞姕妰冯屯㕁吸普䭨㫉ᷕˤ. ȞήȟަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ޠኈӱષġ 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒Ὢ⍿⇘䓇㳣⣂Ⰼ朊⚈䳈䘬⼙枧炻⎬䓇㳣Ⰼ朊䘬䵄⎰ℵ⼊ㆸᾳṢ⮵ 㔜橼䓇㳣⑩岒䘬デ奢ˤ䞼䨞侭⮵忁ṃⰌ朊䘬奨⮇ᷣ天Ὢ⽆Ṣ⎋炷䣦⋨炸嬲枭冯䑘⠫ 炷䣦 㚫ˣ 䴻 㾇 䑘⠫ 䓇 ン炸 嬲枭 叿 ㇳˤ ⛐Ṣ ⎋ 炷䣦 ⋨炸 嬲 枭ᶲ 炻Zautra 䫱Ṣ 炷1977炸䘬䞼䨞栗䣢炻⿏⇍ˣ㔁做䦳⹎ˣ㓞ℍˣ⸜漉⍲⨂⦣䉨㱩䘬ᶵ⎴炻℞䓇㳣⑩ 岒ḇᶵᶨ炻䈡⇍㗗⨂⦣䉨㱩⸜漉䚠䔞栗叿⛘⼙枧ᾳṢ䓇㳣⑩岒ˤXiaˣLiˣHauˣ Liu 冯 Lu炷2012炸䘬䞼䨞䘤䎦炻⿏⇍ˣ⸜漉ˣ䣦䴻⛘ỵ炷⯌℞㗗㔁做䦳⹎炸⍲⯙㤕 ⮵䓇㳣⑩岒㚱栗叿⼙枧ˤ⎎⢾炻ᾳṢ䘬䣦㚫㍍妠䣦⋨倗专炷Grinde, 2009; Murphy et al., 2009炸⍲ᾳṢ䉨㱩炷Zautra et al., 1977; Musschenga, 1997; Xia et al., 2012炸ḇ㗗⼙枧ᾳṢ䓇㳣⑩岒䘬慵天嬲枭ˤ ⛐䑘⠫傰䴉Ⰼ朊ᶲ炻℞㴱⍲䘬朊⎹⎗傥⊭㊔䣦㚫ˣ䴻㾇冯䓇ン䑘⠫䫱ˤ⯙䣦㚫 Ⰼ朊侴妨炻䄲䐆㠭炷1995炸䘬䞼䨞嫱⮎炻䣦⋨⯭㮹⮵䵕专䓇㳣⑩岒䘬℔ℙ姕㕥庫㺧 シ炻ᶼ庫ⷠ⍫≈㚜㕘⺢姕ᷣ⮶ᷳ䣦⋨㳣≽炻㚱≑㕤惘慴⼤㬌㓗㊩⿏䘬⼨Ἦ炻ẍ农䣦 ⋨シ嬀⡆⻟炻㬌冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䵕专⼊ㆸ列⿏⽒䑘ˤ⯙䴻㾇Ⰼ朊侴妨炻䞼䨞嫱 ⮎炻䴻㾇㨇㚫冯⮎岒㓞ℍ冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒㗗㚱斄倗䘬炷Ackerman & Paolucci, 1983; Raphael et al., 2001; Zautra et al., 1977炸ˤ⯙䓇ン䑘⠫侴妨炻Marans炷2003炸䘬䞼䨞 ㊯↢炻䑘⠫冯悥ⶪ䘬冺怑⹎斄Ὢ⇘䣦⋨⑩岒ᾳṢ㳣≽ˣ㺧シ⹎⍲幓橼ˤἳ ⤪炻KimˣUysal 冯 Sirgy炷2013炸娵䁢炻㕭忲㤕⮵䣦⋨䘬䴻㾇ˣ䣦㚫ˣ㔯⊾䑘⠫ 䘬堅㑲炻Ṏ㚫⼙枧⇘䣦⋨䘬䓇㳣⑩岒ˤ. Ʉ11Ʉ.
(12) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. ήȃަୣݾ౪ȃަୣΩᇅަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ 䣦⋨㱣䎮㗗ᶨ䧖ˬ┬㱣˭䘬➢Ⰼ㮹ᷣ忶䦳炻℞䚖㧁⛐㕤妋㰢䣦⋨⓷柴炻᷎㓡┬ 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒炷㰇㖶ᾖ炻2009烉10炸炻⛘㕡㮹ᷣ冯℔㮹⍫冯⌛䁢┬㱣忶䦳䘬䱦橻炻 ⛐䣦⋨㱣䎮䘬⚃䧖栆✳䔞ᷕ炻䃉婾㗗䣦⋨➡≃ˣ䣦⋨ềỜˣ䣦⋨䴙㱣ㆾ䣦⋨䭉䎮炻 ℞㴱⍲䘬朊⎹䘮䣦⋨傥≃〗〗䚠斄ˤO’Toole 冯 Burdess炷2004: 443炸⌛㊯↢炻 䣦⋨傥≃⺢㥳㓧䫾娎⚾天⛐㚜⺋㲃䘬➢䢶ᶲἮὫἧ⍫冯炻䈡⇍㗗⛘㕡䘤⯽⋼㚫炻啱 㬌炻嬻㯠临䘤⯽䘬屔ả⽆ᷕ⣖⛘㕡㓧⹄Ⰼ䳂炻廱䦣军䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂烊Ṏ⌛炻啱䓙ᶨ䧖 䣦⋨⋼㚫䘬ℵ忈炻嬻ṾᾹㆸ䁢⛘㕡㱣䎮䘬徼⼹ˤMuljono炷2011炸⛐⌘⯤䘬䞼䨞Ṏ 嫱⮎炻䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬⍫冯㧉⺷⮵䣦㚫ᷳ䈑岒朆䈑岒䘮ⷞἮ㬋⎹䘬㓡嬲ˤ䁢㬌炻劍傥 䝕妋䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ攻䘬斄Ὢ炻⮵㫚德忶䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳˬ┬㱣˭Ἦ㓡┬䣦 ⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䚖㧁炻⮯㚱℞慵天ᶼ⮎岒䘬シ㵝ˤ 䣦⋨䘤⯽㗗ᶨ䧖㚱妰䔓䘬ⶍἄ炻℞䚖䘬⛐㕤㫚⺢䩳屯䓊ẍ⡆忚⯭㮹㓡┬℞䓇㳣 ⑩岒䘬傥≃炷Green & Haines, 2008炸ˤἳ⤪炻Collier 冯 Mitchell炷2015: 48炸⌛娵 䁢炻劍傥⛐ῷ怈䣦⋨䘤⯽屉䈑➢䢶䳸㥳䘬傥≃炻ᶵ㚱≑㕤攳∝ⶍἄ㨇㚫炻Ṏ㚱 ≑㕤㓡┬䓇㳣⑩岒ˤ⯙㬌侴妨炻䣦⋨屯䓊冯䣦⋨傥≃㗗怩⎹䓇㳣⑩岒㍸㖯慵天䘬ⶍ ℟炻忁䧖ⶍ℟傥⏎䛇㬋㚱䙲㕤䣦⋨⯭㮹炻䪗夾⯭㮹⮵㬌ⶍ℟䘬忳䓐⍲℞忳䓐⼴䘬デ ⍿炻⚈侴炻ㆹᾹㆾ⎗⮯䣦⋨ᷕ㚱⼊ㆾ䃉⼊䘬屯䓊炻夾䁢㗗ᶨ䧖⎗Ὣ忚䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒 ㍸㖯䘬ˬ㨇㚫˭炻忁䧖ˬ㨇㚫˭傥⏎䛇㬋䘤㎖㍸㖯䣦⋨⯭㮹䓇㳣⑩岒䘬≇傥炻᷎㰺 㚱䳽⮵䘬ˬ㗗˭ㆾˬ⏎˭炻侴枰䪗夾⇑⭛斄ὪṢ⮵忁ṃ㨇㚫䓊䓇ᷳ㓰㝄䘬デ⍿ˤ. ȃःف೪ॏᇅၦਠᇕ Κȃःف೪ॏ ȞΚȟःفϏڏġ ὅ㒂⇵徘䘬䞼䨞䚖䘬⍲㔯䌣㩊教炻㛔䞼䨞ᷳ㝞㥳⤪⚾Ḵ䣢炻ᷣ天䞼䨞ⶍ℟䁢 ˬ䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒慷堐˭炻娚慷堐䘬⺢伖ᷣ天Ὢ䓙䞼䨞侭㬟䴻⚃ᾳ昶㭝ⶍ ἄ⥳⬴ㆸ炻⊭㊔烉炷1炸ὅ㒂䚠斄㔯䌣⍲⮵ 20 ỵ䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼㚫柀⮶侭ᷳᾳ⇍㶙⹎姒 婯屯㕁炻㒔妪↢ˬ䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒慷堐˭勱䧧烊炷2炸怨普 5 ỵ䣦⋨ⶍἄ 䘬⮰⭞⬠侭炻忚埴 3 ⚆⎰䘬ˬᾖ㬋⺷⽟厚㱽˭炻᷎䴻 13 ỵ䣦⋨Ṣ⢓忚埴⓷⌟ᷳ婆. Ʉ12Ʉ.
(13) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. シ㕥㷔炻侴⼊ㆸ枸娎慷堐烊炷3炸ὅ PPS ⍇䎮㉥⍾ 40 䳬悱捖ᷳ 600 ᾳ䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼ 㚫䁢㧋㛔炻忚埴朊⮵朊姒婯㕥㷔炻妰⚆㓞 339 ấ㚱㓰⓷⌟烊ẍ⍲炷4炸⮵⚆㓞ᷳ⓷ ⌟忚埴枭䚖↮㜸⍲ᾉˣ㓰⹎侫槿炻忚侴ᾖ㬋慷堐柴枭⼴侴⼊ㆸ㬋⺷ᷳˬ䣦⋨傥≃冯 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒慷堐˭ˤ 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃ġ x x x x x. 䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂ġ 䓇㳣⑩岒ġ. 斄Ὢ≃ġ Ṣ屯≃ġ 屉䈑≃ġ 䑘⠫≃ġ 㔯⊾≃ġ. x Ṣ㔯㔁做ġ x 䴻㾇䤷䣱ġ x ℔ℙ姕㕥ġ. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃ġ x x x x. ᾳṢⰌ䳂ġ 䓇㳣⑩岒ġ. ⍫冯≃ġ 忋䳸≃ġ 柀⮶≃ġ 䳬䷼≃. x 䣦⋨⍫冯ġ x 䣦⋨シ嬀ġ x ⯭ỷ䑘⠫ġ. ⚾Ḵ 䞼䨞㝞㥳⚾ 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉䞼䨞侭冒埴丒墥. ȞΡȟः࢝فᄻᇅ೪ġ ὅ⇵徘㔯䌣ᷳ↮㜸炻ℵ侫慷冢䀋䣦⋨䘬⿏岒炻㛔䞼䨞⮯䣦⋨傥≃䓴⭂䁢⬀⛐㕤 䣦⋨ᷳ⎬枭㚱⼊ㆾ䃉⼊䘬屯䓊炷䧙ᷳ䁢朄ン傥≃炸炻ẍ⍲傥嬻屯䓊䓊䓇₡ῤ䘬≽ン 㳣≽炷䧙ᷳ䁢≽ン傥≃炸ˤ朄ン傥≃䘬㑵ἄ⿏⭂佑Ὢ㊯⍿姒侭⮵䣦⋨㚱⼊冯䃉⼊屯 䓊䘬ᷣ奨姽₡炻ὅ⓷枭⍲℞ℏ⭡䘬⿏岒炻忚ᶨ㬍↮ㆸḼᾳ㫉朊⎹炻⊭㊔烉炷1炸斄 Ὢ≃烉妰 26 柴炻ℏ⭡叿慵㕤䣦⋨⯭㮹䘬䣦㚫屯㛔炻⊭⏓⯭㮹⮵䣦⋨ℏ⢾䘬Ṣ䳬 ䷼ᷳᾉảˣ䵚䴉冯夷䭬䘬堐䎦䉨㱩烊炷2炸Ṣ屯≃烉妰 4 柴炻ℏ⭡叿慵㕤㍐≽䣦⋨ ⶍἄ䚠斄Ṣ≃炷⏓⽿ⶍ炸⍲℞℟⁁䚠斄䞍嬀冯㈨傥䘬䉨㱩烊炷3炸屉䈑≃烉妰 9 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦⋨➢䢶⺢姕䘬慷冯岒ᷳ䉨㱩烊炷4炸䑘⠫≃烉妰 8 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵. Ʉ13Ʉ.
(14) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. 㕤䣦⋨䘬冒䃞㘗奨⍲⯭⭞䑘⠫䘬䉨㱩烊ẍ⍲炷5炸㔯⊾≃烉妰 5 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦 ⋨ᷳ㬟⎚㔯䈑冯⁛䴙㔯⊾䘬ᾅ⬀䉨㱩ˤ ≽ン傥≃䘬㑵ἄ⿏⭂佑Ὢ㊯⍿姒侭⮵䣦⋨⯭㮹⍫冯䣦⋨ḳ⊁䘬ᷣ奨姽₡炻ὅ⓷ 枭⍲℞ℏ⭡䘬⿏岒炻忚ᶨ㬍↮ㆸ⚃ᾳ㫉朊⎹炻⊭㊔烉炷1炸⍫冯≃烉妰 9 柴炻ᷣ天 叿慵㕤䣦⋨⯭㮹⮵䣦⋨℔ℙḳ⊁䘬斄⽫冯㈽ℍ䉨㱩烊炷2炸忋䳸≃烉妰 9 柴炻ᷣ天 叿慵㕤䣦⋨冯℞⬫䣦⋨ˣ㮹攻㨇㥳⍲㓧⹄╖ỵᷳ䵚䴉Ḻ≽䉨㱩烊炷3炸柀⮶≃烉妰 14 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦⋨柀⮶侭ᷳ䴻䆇冯妋㰢䣦⋨⓷柴䘬嗽䎮傥≃炻⍲℞塓娵⎴冯 ⁛㈧䘬䉨㱩烊ẍ⍲炷5炸䳬䷼≃烉妰 8 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦⋨䳬䷼䘬䘤⯽冯㑵ἄ䉨 㱩ˤ 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒Ὢ㊯䣦⋨⯭㮹⮵℞嗽䣦⋨ᷳ庇ˣ䠔橼⺢姕䘬䚳㱽炷䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇 㳣⑩岒炸ˣ⍲℞⮵䣦⋨⍫冯ㆾ䓇㳣䘬デ⍿炷ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒炸ˤ䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩ 岒䘬㑵ἄ⿏⭂佑炻Ὢ㊯⍿姒侭娵䁢⣂㔠䣦⋨⯭㮹⮵䣦⋨㔜橼⍲⎬朊⎹⺢姕䘬姽₡ 炷シ夳炸炻ὅ℞⓷枭⍲ℏ⭡⿏岒炻ℵ忚ᶨ㬍↮ㆸᶱᾳ㫉朊⎹炻⊭㊔烉炷1炸Ṣ㔯㔁 做烉妰 7 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦⋨ᷳ㔁做ˣ喅㔯㳣≽⍲⁛䴙㔯⊾㍐⺋䘬䉨㱩烊炷2炸䴻 㾇䤷䣱烉妰 12 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦⋨⯭㮹ᷳ䴻㾇ˣ⯙㤕ˣ慓䗪⍲䤷⇑㚵⊁䘬䉨 㱩烊ẍ⍲炷3炸℔ℙ姕㕥烉妰 16 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤䣦⋨ᷳ℔ℙ⺢姕䑘⠫䵕嬟䘬䉨 㱩ˤ ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬㑵ἄ⿏⭂佑炻Ὢ㊯⍿姒侭⮵℞冒幓䴻㬟ㆾᷣ奨デ⍿ᷳ䣦 ⋨⎬朊⎹䘬姽₡炻ὅ℞⓷枭⍲ℏ⭡⿏岒炻ℵ忚ᶨ㬍↮ㆸᶱᾳ㫉朊⎹炻⊭㊔烉炷1炸 䣦⋨⍫冯烉妰 8 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤⍿姒侭ᾳṢ㈽ℍ䣦⋨䚠斄㳣≽䘬䉨㱩烊炷2炸䣦⋨ シ嬀烉妰 7 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤⍿姒侭ᾳṢ⮵䣦⋨䓇㳣冯䣦⋨㛔幓䘬娵⎴冯㍍䲵䉨㱩烊 ẍ⍲炷3炸⯭ỷ䑘⠫烉妰 12 柴炻ᷣ天叿慵㕤⍿姒侭䣦⋨䘬㱣⬱ˣ䓇ンˣ䑘⠫⍲䓇㳣 㨇傥䘬㺧シ䉨㱩ˤ ⇵徘⎬慷堐䘬䷥慷堐ᾉ⹎ᷳ Cronbach’V Į ῤ䘮⛐ 0.90 ẍᶲ炻㔜橼䷥妋慳嬲䔘 慷䁢䘮⛐ 63.0%炻↮慷堐䘬ᾉ⹎ Cronbach’V Į ῤ䳽⣏⣂㔠⛐ 0.90 ⶎ⎛炻䷥妋慳嬲 䔘慷Ṏ䘮⛐ 60% ẍᶲˤὅ㒂㔯䌣㩊教⍲䞼䨞䚖䘬炻㛔䞼䨞㍸↢ᷳ䞼䨞`姕⊭㊔烉 炷1炸䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒㚱䚠斄炻ẍ⍲炷2炸ᶵ⎴朊⎹䘬䣦⋨傥≃⮵䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂 冯ᾳṢⰌ䳂䘬䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒㚱ᶵ⎴䘬⼙枧ˤ. Ρȃၦਠᇕϸݚ 㛔䞼䨞㬋⺷㕥㷔昶㭝ṵẍ⎘䀋㛔Ⲟ䩳㟰ᷳ 6,220 ᾳ䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼㚫䁢䞼䨞㭵佌. Ʉ14Ʉ.
(15) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 橼炻ὅ PPS ⍇䎮忚埴䌐䩳㉥㧋炻ℙ妰㉥↢ 600 ᾳ䞼䨞㧋㛔炻ℵ憅⮵䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼㚫 ᷳ䎮ḳ攟ㆾ䷥⸡ḳ㍉朊⮵朊㕡⺷忚埴⓷⌟姒婯炻⮎晃⬴ㆸᷳ㚱㓰⓷⌟䁢 301 ấˤ⚈ 㬋⺷㕥㷔ᷳ⓷⌟⇒昌䓐㕤枸娎䘬⮹㔠柴枭炻㓭⛐㌺昌⇒昌柴枭⼴炻Ṏ⮯枸娎⬴ㆸ 䘬 339 ấ⓷⌟䲵ℍ↮㜸炻㚨⼴⮎晃䓐㕤↮㜸䘬⓷⌟ℙ妰 640 ấˤ䃉婾㗗枸娎ㆾ㬋⺷ 婧㞍炻㧋㛔ᷳ⬴姒䌯䘮䲬䔍檀㕤Ḽㆸ炻℞检㛒⬴ㆸ姒⓷侭ᷣ天Ὢ⚈㉺姒ˣ䨢㇞ˣẍ ⍲ 2-3 㫉姒⓷㛒忯ˤ㛔䞼䨞㍉⍾䘬䴙妰↮㜸㕡㱽⊭㊔烉㍷徘⿏䴙妰ˣ䧵ⶖ䚠斄↮㜸 ẍ⍲⣂⃫徜㬠炷⏓昶Ⰼ徜㬠炸↮㜸䫱ˤ. နȃःف๗ݏ ΚȃަୣΩᇅަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ϟ྆ݸϸݚ ⯙ˬ䣦⋨傥≃˭柴枭䘬⎴シ䦳⹎奨ᷳ炻⤪堐ᶨ䣢炻ˬ㔜橼䣦⋨傥≃˭ᷳ⸛⛯ 㔠䁢 3.67炻ˬ≽ン傥≃˭ᷳ⸛⛯㔠䁢 3.73炻䔍檀㕤ˬ朄ン傥≃˭ᷳ 3.62ˤˬ朄ン傥 ≃˭㫉朊⎹ᷳ⎴シ䦳⹎ὅ⸷䁢斄Ὢ≃ˣṢ屯≃ˣ䑘⠫≃ˣ屉䈑≃⍲㔯⊾≃ˤˬ≽ン 傥≃˭㫉朊⎹ᷳ⎴シ䦳⹎ὅ⸷䁢柀⮶≃ˣ䳬䷼≃ˣ忋䳸≃⍲⍫冯≃ˤ 堐ᶨ 䣦⋨傥≃⎬朊⎹⎴シ䦳⹎ᷳ⸛⛯㔠冯㧁㸾ⶖ ⸛⛯㔠/㧁㸾ⶖ. ⸛⛯㔠/㧁㸾ⶖ. 朄ン傥≃ Mean=3.62 SD=0.37 䣦⋨傥≃ Mean=3.67 SD=0.38 ≽ン傥≃ Mean=3.73 SD=0.47. 朊⎹. ⸛⛯㔠/㧁㸾ⶖ. 斄Ὢ≃. Mean=3.86. SD=0.41. Ṣ屯≃. Mean=3.62. SD=0.67. 屉䈑≃. Mean=3.30. SD=0.60. 䑘⠫≃. Mean=3.51. SD=0.49. 㔯⊾≃. Mean=3.20. SD=0.69. ⍫冯≃. Mean=3.56. SD=0.49. 忋䳸≃. Mean=3.58. SD=0.59. 柀⮶≃. Mean=3.91. SD=0.52. 䳬䷼≃. Mean=3.78. SD=0.59. 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. ⯙ˬ䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒˭柴枭䘬⎴シ䦳⹎奨ᷳ炻⤪堐Ḵ䣢炻ˬ㔜橼䓇㳣⑩岒˭ᷳ. Ʉ15Ʉ.
(16) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. ⸛⛯㔠䁢 3.61烊ˬᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒˭ᷳ⸛⛯㔠䁢 3.84炻檀㕤ˬ䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩ 岒˭䘬 3.43ˤˬᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒˭䘬ᶱᾳ朊⎹ᷕᷳ⎴シ䦳⹎ὅ⸷䁢䣦⋨⍫冯ˣ䣦 ⋨シ嬀⍲⯭ỷ䑘⠫ˤˬ䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒˭䘬ᶱᾳ朊⎹ᷕᷳ⎴シ䦳⹎ὅ⸷䁢Ṣ㔯㔁 做ˣ℔ℙ姕㕥⍲䴻㾇䤷䣱ˤ 堐Ḵ 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒⎬朊⎹⎴シ䦳⹎ᷳ⸛⛯㔠冯㧁㸾ⶖ堐 ⸛⛯㔠/㧁㸾ⶖ. 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒 Mean=3.61 SD=0.43. ⸛⛯㔠/㧁㸾ⶖ 䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒 Mean=3.43 SD=0.45 ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒 Mean=3.84 SD=0.46. ⸛⛯㔠/㧁㸾ⶖ Ṣ㔯㔁做 Mean=3.57. SD=0.59. 䴻㾇䤷䣱 Mean=3.23. SD=0.61. ℔ℙ姕㕥 Mean=3.50. SD=0.47. 䣦⋨⍫冯 Mean=4.07. SD=0.51. 䣦⋨シ嬀 Mean=3.96. SD=0.53. ⯭ỷ䑘⠫ Mean=3.62. SD=0.54. 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. ΡȃަୣΩᇅަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ө८Ӫϟࣻᜱϸݚ ⯙ަୣᓘᄙΩᇅঐቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵䘬斄倗⿏侴妨炷夳堐ᶱ炸炻朄ン傥≃䘬⎬ ⚈䳈冯ঐቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵䘬䷥橼⍲℞⎬朊⎹䘮忼栗叿㬋䚠斄炷P < 0.001炸ˤ℞ᷕ炻 ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭冯ˬ䣦⋨シ嬀˭炷r = 0.402炻P < 0.001炸䘬䚠斄⹎䚠⮵庫檀烊ˬ屉䈑 ≃˭冯ˬ䣦⋨⍫冯˭炷r = 0.177炻P < 0.001炸炻ẍ⍲ˬ㔯⊾≃˭冯ˬ䣦⋨⍫冯˭炷r = 0.134炻P < 0.01炸ˣˬ䣦⋨シ嬀˭炷r = 0.156炻P < 0.001炸ˣˬ℔ℙ姕㕥˭炷r = 0.179炻P < 0.001炸䘬䚠斄䦳⹎䚠⮵庫Ỷˤ ⯙ަୣᓘᄙΩᇅަୣቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵䘬斄倗⿏侴妨炷夳堐ᶱ炸炻昌ˬ䑘⠫≃˭ 冯ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭㛒忼栗叿䚠斄⢾炻℞Ṿ⎬⚈䳈冯䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䷥橼⍲℞⎬朊 ⎹䘮忼栗叿㬋䚠斄炷P < .001炸ˤ℞ᷕ炻ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭冯ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭炷r = 0.192炻P < 0.001炸ˣˬṢ屯≃˭冯ˬṢ㔯㔁做˭炷r = 0.199炻P < 0.001炸ˣˬ䑘⠫≃˭冯 ˬṢ㔯㔁做˭炷r = 0.168炻P < 0.001炸ˣˬ㔯⊾≃˭冯ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭炷r = 0.162炻P < 0.001炸䫱嬲枭攻䘬䚠斄⹎䚠⮵庫Ỷˤ ⯙ަୣᄙΩᇅঐቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵䘬斄倗⿏侴妨炷夳堐ᶱ炸炻≽ン傥≃䘬⎬ ⚈䳈冯ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䷥橼⍲℞⎬朊⎹䘮忼栗叿㬋䚠斄炷P < 0.001炸ˤ℞ᷕ炻. Ʉ16Ʉ.
(17) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. ˬ⍫冯≃˭冯ˬ䣦⋨シ嬀˭炷r = 0.404炻P < 0.001炸䘬䚠斄⹎䚠⮵庫檀ˤ⯙ަୣ ᄙΩᇅަୣቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵䘬斄倗⿏侴妨炷夳堐ᶱ炸炻≽ン傥≃䘬⎬⚈䳈冯ᾳṢⰌ 䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䷥橼⍲℞⎬朊⎹䘮忼栗叿㬋䚠斄炷P < 0.001炸ˤ℞ᷕ炻ˬ⍫冯≃˭冯 ˬ⯭ỷ䑘⠫˭炷r = 0.306炻P < 0.001炸䘬䚠斄⹎䚠⮵庫檀ˤ. Ʉ17Ʉ.
(18) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. 堐ᶱ 䣦⋨傥≃⎬⚈䳈冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒⎬朊⎹ᷳ䚠斄↮㜸堐 朊⎹. 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒 ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒. 䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒. 䣦⋨傥≃. ䷥↮. 䣦⋨ ⍫冯. 䣦⋨ シ嬀. ℔ℙ 姕㕥. ䷥↮. Ṣ㔯 㔁做. 䴻㾇 䤷䣱. ⯭ỷ 䑘⠫. ䷥↮. ䷥↮. --. --. --. --. 0.449***. --. --. --. 0.414***. 斄Ὢ≃. 0.404*** 0.353*** 0.402*** 0.339*** 0.409*** 0.231*** 0.192*** 0.318*** 0.307***. Ṣ屯≃. 0.337*** 0.228*** 0.295*** 0.292*** 0.315*** 0.199*** 0.252*** 0.220*** 0.277***. 朄ン 屉䈑≃ 傥≃ 䑘⠫≃. 0.354*** 0.177*** 0.249*** 0.299*** 0.283*** 0.245*** 0.256*** 0.317*** 0.334***. 㔯⊾≃ ䷥↮. 0.277*** 0.232*** 0.269*** 0.261*** 0.291*** 0.168***. 0.049. 0.341*** 0.216***. 0.232*** 0.134** 0.156*** 0.179*** 0.183*** 0.253*** 0.162*** 0.213*** 0.248*** --. --. --. --. 0.430***. --. --. --. 0.393***. ⍫冯≃. 0.421*** 0.343*** 0.404*** 0.332*** 0.399*** 0.280*** 0.251*** 0.306*** 0.332***. 忋䳸≃. 0.377*** 0.289*** 0.320*** 0.267*** 0.333*** 0.289*** 0.287*** 0.237*** 0.326***. ≽ン 柀⮶≃ 傥≃ 䳬䷼≃. 0.370*** 0.344*** 0.335*** 0.279*** 0.358*** 0.203*** 0.217*** 0.272*** 0.292***. ䷥↮. 0.399*** 0.293*** 0.338*** 0.285*** 0.347*** 0.271*** 0.272*** 0.289*** 0.343*** --. --. --. --. 0.408***. --. --. --. 0.355***. 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. ήȃަୣΩᄈަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ϟኈ ȞΚȟަୣΩөӱષᄈᐍᡞަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ϟӼϰଠᘫϸݚġ ẍ䣦⋨䘬朄ン冯≽ン傥≃䫱 9 枭⚈䳈冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒忚埴⣂⃫徜㬠ᷳ䴙妰㩊槿 䘤䎦炻㬌㧉✳䘬妋慳≃忼⇘栗叿㯜㸾炷F = 17.529炻P < 0.001炸炻℞ R2 = 0.243炻婧 㔜⼴䘬 R2 䁢 0.229炻栗䣢㬌㧉✳⎗ẍ㚱㓰⛘妋慳ὅ嬲枭 22.9% 䘬嬲䔘ˤ⛐ℙ䶂⿏ 姢㕟ᷕ炻℞ VIF ῤṳ㕤 1.436~3.403炻CI ῤṳ㕤 16.979~52.999炻堐䣢㰺㚱♜慵䘬ℙ 䶂⿏⓷柴炷ńŊ ῤỶ㕤 IJıı炸ˤ忚ᶨ㬍㩊夾⎬嬲枭ᷳᾳ⇍妋慳≃栗䣢炻㚱Ḵ枭⚈䳈℟ 㚱栗叿䘬妋慳≃炻℞慵天⿏ὅ⸷䁢ˬ屉䈑≃˭炷t = 4.208炻P < 0.001炸⍲ˬ⍫冯 ≃˭炷t = 2.532炻P < 0.05炸烊Ṏ⌛炻ˬ屉䈑≃˭⍲ˬ⍫冯≃˭堐䎦グἛ侭炻℞䣦⋨ 䓇㳣⑩岒グἛˤ℞⣂⃫徜㬠㕡䦳⺷⤪ᶳ炷夳堐⚃炸烉 炷䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒炸 = 1.021X1炷⍫冯≃炸 +0.972X2炷屉䈑≃炸 + 107.329 Y炷. Ʉ18Ʉ.
(19) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 堐⚃ 䣦⋨傥≃⎬⚈䳈冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ⣂⃫徜㬠↮㜸堐 䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒. B. Se. 107.329. 10.636. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-斄Ὢ≃. 0.184. 0.146. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-Ṣ屯≃. 0.473. ަୣᓘᄙΩ.ଓޑΩ!. Beta. T. P. 10.091. 0.000. 0.075. 1.256. 0.210. 0.541. 0.048. 0.875. 0.382. 0.972. 0.231. 0.203. 4.208. 0.000. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-䑘⠫≃. 0.243. 0.320. 0.036. 0.759. 0.448. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-㔯⊾≃. -0.143. 0.375. -0.018. -0.381. 0.703. ަୣᄙΩ.ᇅΩ!. 1.021. 0.403. 0.164. 2.532. 0.012. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-忋䳸≃. -0.120. 0.321. -0.025. -0.373. 0.710. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-柀⮶≃. 0.273. 0.242. 0.076. 1.129. 0.259. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-䳬䷼≃. 0.421. 0.398. 0.076. 1.056. 0.292. ⷠ㔠. 2. 2. R = 0.243ġ adj R = 0.229 F = 17.529ġ P = 0.000. 㔜橼㧉✳ 姣烉* P < 0.05 ** P < 0.01 *** P < 0.001ˤ. 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. ȞΡȟަୣΩөӱષᄈঐቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵ϟӼϰଠᘫϸݚġ ẍ䣦⋨朄ン冯≽ン傥≃䫱 9 枭⚈䳈冯ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒忚埴⣂⃫徜㬠ᷳ䴙妰㩊 槿䘤䎦炻㬌㧉✳䘬妋慳≃忼⇘栗叿㯜㸾炷F = 16.780炻P < 0.001炸炻℞ R2 = 0.219炻 婧㔜⼴䘬 R2 䁢 0.206炻栗䣢㬌㧉✳⎗ẍ㚱㓰⛘妋慳ὅ嬲枭 20.6% 䘬嬲䔘烊⛐ℙ䶂 ⿏姢㕟ᷕ炻℞ VIF ῤṳ㕤 1.418~3.251炻CI ῤṳ㕤 16.930~53.193烊堐䣢㰺㚱♜慵䘬 ℙ䶂⿏⓷柴炷CI ῤỶ㕤 100炸ˤ忚ᶨ㬍㩊夾⎬嬲枭ᷳᾳ⇍妋慳≃栗䣢炻㚱⚃枭⚈䳈 ℟㚱栗叿䘬妋慳≃炻℞慵天⿏ὅ⸷䁢ˬ⍫冯≃˭炷t = 2.703炻P < 0.01炸ˣˬ屉䈑 ≃˭炷t = 2.433炻P < 0.05炸ˣˬ斄Ὢ≃˭炷t =2.323炻P < 0.05炸⍲ˬ柀⮶≃˭炷t =2.250炻P < 0.05炸烊Ṏ⌛忁⚃枭傥≃堐䎦グἛ侭炻℞ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒グἛˤ℞ ⣂⃫徜㬠㕡䦳⺷⤪ᶳ炷夳堐Ḽ炸烉 炷 ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒炸 = 0.488X1 炷⍫冯≃炸 + 0.251 X2 炷屉䈑≃炸 + Y炷 0.247X3炷柀⮶≃炸 + 0.154X4炷斄Ὢ≃炸 + 48.157. Ʉ19Ʉ.
(20) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. 堐Ḽ 䣦⋨傥≃⎬⚈䳈冯ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ⣂⃫徜㬠↮㜸堐 ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒. B. Se. ⷠ㔠. 48.157. 4.852. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-斄Ὢ≃. 0.154. 0.066. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-Ṣ屯≃. 0.257. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-屉䈑≃. Beta. t. P. 9.924. 0.000. 0.132. 2.323. 0.021. 0.243. 0.055. 1.057. 0.291. 0.251. 0.103. 0.114. 2.433. 0.015. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-䑘⠫≃. 0.201. 0.143. 0.064. 1.405. 0.161. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-㔯⊾≃. -0.166. 0.164. -0.046. -1.012. 0.312. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-⍫冯≃. 0.488. 0.181. 0.169. 2.703. 0.007. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-忋䳸≃. -0.103. 0.146. -0.045. -0.708. 0.479. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-柀⮶≃. 0.247. 0.110. 0.145. 2.250. 0.025. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-䳬䷼≃. -0.015. 0.177. -0.006. -0.083. 0.934. 2. 2. R = 0.219ġ adj R = 0.206 F = 16.780ġ P = 0.000. 㔜橼㧉✳ 姣烉* P < 0.05 ** P < 0.01 *** P < 0.001ˤ. 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. ȞήȟަୣΩөӱષᄈަୣቺ઼Ңࣁࠣ፵ϟӼϰଠᘫϸݚġ ẍ䣦⋨朄ン冯≽ン傥≃䫱 9 枭⚈䳈冯䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒忚埴⣂⃫徜㬠ᷳ䴙妰㩊 槿䘤䎦炻㬌㧉✳䘬妋慳≃忼⇘栗叿㯜㸾炷F = 13.777炻P < 0.001炸炻℞ R2 = 0.199炻 婧㔜⼴䘬 R2 䁢 0.185炻栗䣢㬌㧉✳⎗ẍ㚱㓰⛘妋慳ὅ嬲枭 18.5% 䘬嬲䔘烊⛐ℙ䶂 ⿏姢㕟ᷕ炻℞ VIF ῤṳ㕤 1.435~3.394炻CI ῤṳ㕤 16.956~53.100烊堐䣢㰺㚱♜慵䘬 ℙ䶂⿏⓷柴炷CI ῤỶ㕤 100炸ˤ忚ᶨ㬍㩊夾⎬嬲枭ᷳᾳ⇍妋慳≃栗䣢炻㚱ˬ屉䈑 ≃˭炷t = 4.328炻P < 0.001炸⍲ˬ⍫冯≃˭炷t = 2.156炻P < 0.05炸ℑ枭⚈䳈忼栗叿 㯜㸾烊Ṏ⌛ˬ屉䈑≃˭⍲ˬ⍫冯≃˭堐䎦グἛ侭炻℞䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒グἛˤ℞⣂ ⃫徜㬠㕡䦳⺷⤪ᶳ炷夳堐ℕ炸烉 Y炷 炷䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒炸 = 0.617X1炷屉䈑≃炸 + 0.535X2炷⍫冯≃炸 + 62.364. Ʉ20Ʉ.
(21) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 堐ℕ 䣦⋨傥≃⎬⚈䳈冯䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ⣂⃫徜㬠↮㜸堐 䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒. B. Se. ⷠ㔠. 62.364. 6.540. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-斄Ὢ≃. 0.023. 0.090. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-Ṣ屯≃. 0.220. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-屉䈑≃. Beta. t. P. 9.536. 0.000. 0.015. 0.254. 0.799. 0.332. 0.037. 0.662. 0.508. 0.617. 0.143. 0.214. 4.328. 0.000. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-䑘⠫≃. -0.022. 0.197. -0.005. -0.112. 0.910. 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃-㔯⊾≃. 0.222. 0.230. 0.047. 0.967. 0.334. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-⍫冯≃. 0.535. 0.248. 0.143. 2.156. 0.032. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-忋䳸≃. -0.013. 0.197. -0.005. -0.068. 0.946. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-柀⮶≃. 0.037. 0.148. 0.017. 0.248. 0.804. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃-䳬䷼≃. 0.376. 0.245. 0.113. 1.531. 0.126. 2. 20. R = 0.199ġ adj R = 0.185 F = 13.777ġ P = 0.000. 㔜橼㧉✳ 姣烉* P < 0.05 ** P < 0.01 *** P < 0.001ˤ. 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. ȞѳȟަୣᡑȃަୣΩөӱષᄈަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ϟቺଠᘫϸݚġ 㛔昶Ⰼ徜㬠↮㜸ẍ⚃ᾳ⋨䳬Ἦ忚埴炻 1 ↮⇍㗗䫔ᶨᾳ⋨䳬䘬䣦⋨嬲枭炷䣦⋨⛘ 䎮⋨ỵ炸炻䫔Ḵᾳ⋨䳬䘬柀⮶侭嬲枭炷柀⮶侭㓞ℍ⍲借㤕⇍炸炻䫔ᶱᾳ⋨䳬䘬㔜橼 䣦⋨傥≃炻ẍ⍲䫔⚃ᾳ⋨䳬䘬䣦⋨傥≃嬲枭炷䣦⋨≽ン傥≃⍲䣦⋨朄ン傥≃炸ˤẍ ⚃ᾳ⋨䳬忚埴↮㜸炻㧉⺷ᶨὪ㈽ℍ䫔ᶨ⋨䳬䘬䣦⋨嬲枭炻㬌㧉✳䘬妋慳≃忼⇘栗叿 㯜㸾炷F = 3.140炻P < 0.05炸炻℞ R2 = 0.019炻婧㔜⼴䘬 R2 䁢 0.013炻栗䣢㬌㧉✳⎗ ẍ㚱㓰⛘妋慳ὅ嬲枭 1.3% 䘬嬲䔘烊侴忚ᶨ㬍奨⮇嬲枭ᾳ⇍䘬妋慳≃᷎㰺㚱栗叿ˤ 㧉⺷Ḵ㗗⮯䫔Ḵ⋨䳬䘬柀⮶侭嬲枭㈽ℍ炻℞⮵㕤㓞ℍ䘬妋慳≃䁢 R2 烌 0.041炷F ῤ 1. 㛔䞼䨞㫚ẍ䣦⋨➢㛔屯㕁⍲䣦⋨傥≃⎬⚈䳈Ἦ枸㷔䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒炻⛐䣦⋨➢㛔屯㕁ᷕẍ 嬲䔘㔠↮㜸炷one-way ANOVA炸忼栗叿ᷳ冒嬲枭䁢ᷳ炻㒔妶婾䘬嬲枭⍇㛔⊭⏓䣦⋨⛘䎮 ⋨ỵˣ䣦⋨Ṣ㔠夷㧉ˣ䣦⋨⯭㮹借㤕⇍ˣ柀⮶侭⸜漉ˣ柀⮶侭㔁做䦳⹎ˣ柀⮶侭㓞ℍ⍲ 柀⮶侭借㤕⇍炻ょ⮯⇵徘嬲枭廱䁢嘃㒔嬲枭炻↮⇍忚埴⣂⃫徜㬠⼴炻䣦⋨⛘䎮⋨➇ˣ 柀⮶侭㓞ℍ⍲柀⮶侭借㤕⇍䫱ᶱ嬲枭℟㚱栗叿⿏炻㓭昶Ⰼ徜㬠⇯ẍ⇵ᶱ嬲枭䁢ᷣ天䣦⋨ ➢㛔屯㕁ᷳ嬲枭Ἦ忚埴↮㜸炻᷎⮯⋨昼䁢䣦⋨嬲枭⍲柀⮶侭嬲枭䫱ℑᾳ⋨䳬ˤ Ʉ21Ʉ.
(22) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. = 1.743炻P > 0.05炸炻㬌㧉✳㛒忼栗叿ˤ㧉⺷ᶱ㗗⮯䫔ᶨ⋨䳬䘬䣦⋨嬲枭ˣ䫔Ḵ⋨ 䳬䘬柀⮶侭嬲枭嶇䫔ᶱ⋨䳬䘬㔜橼䣦⋨傥≃嬲枭㈽ℍ㧉⺷ᷕ炻⮵㕤䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬 妋慳≃忼⇘ R2 烌 0.268炷F ῤ= 13.729炻P < 0.001炸炻⛐㍏⇞䣦⋨嬲枭⍲柀⮶侭嬲 枭䘬⼙枧ᶳ炻䣦⋨傥≃䘬㈽ℍ傥⣈柵⢾ˬ届䌣˭23.1% 䘬妋慳≃烊ᶼ⛐䌐嬲枭ᷕẍ ˬ㔜橼䣦⋨傥≃˭䘬届䌣⹎㚨⣏炷t ῤ烌 12.294炻P 0.001炸炻栗䣢⛐䫔ᶱ⋨䳬 ᷕ炻ᷣ天䘬届䌣㗗䓙ˬ䣦⋨傥≃˭∝忈ˤ㧉⺷⚃㗗⮯䫔ᶨ⋨䳬䘬䣦⋨嬲枭ˣ䫔Ḵ ⋨䳬䘬柀⮶侭嬲枭嶇䫔⚃⋨䳬䘬䣦⋨傥≃嬲枭㈽ℍ㧉⺷ᷕ炻⮵㕤䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬妋 慳≃忼⇘ R2 烌 0.269炷F ῤ= 13.974炻P < 0.001炸炻⛐㍏⇞䣦⋨嬲枭⍲柀⮶侭嬲枭 䘬⼙枧ᶳ炻䣦⋨傥≃䘬㈽ℍ傥⣈柵⢾ˬ届䌣˭25.1% 䘬妋慳≃烊ᶼ⛐䌐嬲枭ᷕẍ ˬ䣦⋨≽ン傥≃˭炷t ῤ烌 5.455炻P 0.001炸⍲ˬ䣦⋨≽ン傥≃˭炷t ῤ烌 3.853炻P 0.001炸䘬届䌣⹎㚨⣏炻栗䣢⛐䫔⚃⋨䳬ᷕ炻ᷣ天䘬届䌣Ṏ䓙ˬ䣦⋨傥 ≃˭∝忈ˤ䴻䓙昶Ⰼ徜㬠↮㜸炻㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦晾䃞䣦⋨嬲枭⍲柀⮶侭嬲枭⮵㕤䣦⋨ 䓇㳣⑩岒忼⇘栗叿㯜㸾炻Ữᷣ天⮵㕤䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒妋慳≃䘬届䌣Ἦ冒㕤䣦⋨傥≃ 炷夳堐ᶫ炸ˤ 堐ᶫ. 䣦⋨➢㛔屯㕁ˣ䣦⋨傥≃⎬⚈䳈⮵䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ昶Ⰼ徜㬠↮㜸堐. ⷠ㔠. 㧉⺷ᶨ. 㧉⺷Ḵ. 㧉⺷ᶱ. 㧉⺷⚃. 87.501 P = 0.000. 57.216 P = 0.000. 11.092 P = 0.000. 10.893 P = 0.000. -1.596 P = 0.111 -0.922 P = 0.357 0.895 P = 0.371. -0.721 P = 0.472 -0.503 P = 0.615 0.803 P = 0.422. -1.508 P = 0.132 -0.394 P = 0.693 1.105 P = 0.270. -1.568 P = 0.117 -0.422 P = 0.673 0.866 P = 0.387. -1.474 P = 0.141 -1.083 P = 0.279 -1.093 P = 0.275 -1.196 P = 0.232. -2.021 P = 0.044 -1.739 P = 0.083 -1.605 P = 0.109 -1.718 P = 0.086. -2.191 P = 0.029 -1.852 P = 0.065 -1.828 P = 0.068 -1.784 P = 0.075. 䣦⋨嬲枭炷⛘䎮⋨ỵ a炸 悱㛹✳嘃㒔 Ⱉ⛘✳嘃㒔 悥ⶪ✳嘃㒔 柀⮶侭嬲枭炷㓞ℍ b炸 㛒㺧 2 叔⃫嘃㒔 㺧 2 叔军㛒㺧 4 叔⃫嘃㒔 㺧 4 叔军㛒㺧 6 叔⃫嘃㒔 㺧 6 叔军㛒㺧 8 叔⃫嘃㒔. Ʉ22Ʉ.
(23) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 堐ᶫ炷临炸 㧉⺷ᶨ. 㧉⺷Ḵ. 㧉⺷ᶱ. 㧉⺷⚃. -2.239 P = 0.026 -0.445 P = 0.657 0.235 P = 0.814 -0.408 P = 0.683 -1.366 P = 0.173. -1.889 P = 0.059 -1.076 P = 0.282 -0.501 P = 0.616 -0.933 P = 0.351 -0.949 P = 0.343 12.294 P = 0.000. -2.069 P = 0.039 -1.207 P = 0.228 -0.607 P = 0.544 -0.765 P = 0.444 -1.245 P = 0.214. 柀⮶侭嬲枭炷借㤕⇍ c炸 彚㜿㺩䈏㤕侭嘃㒔 ⶍ㤕侭嘃㒔 ⓮㤕侭嘃㒔 㚵⊁㤕侭嘃㒔 徨ẹㆾ䃉㤕侭嘃㒔 䣦⋨傥≃ 䣦⋨傥≃ 5.455 P = 0.000 3.853 P = 0.000. 䣦⋨≽ン傥≃ 䣦⋨朄ン傥≃ R2. 0.019. 0.041. 0.268. 0.290. 婧㔜⼴䘬 R2. 0.013. 0.018. 0.249. 0.269. Fῤ. 3.140 P = 0.25. 1.743 P = 0.55. 13.729 P = 0.000. 13.974 P = 0.000. 姣烉a 䣦⋨⛘䎮⋨ỵẍⶪ悱㶟⎰✳䁢⍫䄏䳬ˤb 柀⮶侭㓞ℍẍ㭷㚰㓞ℍ崭忶 8 叔⃫䁢⍫䄏䳬ˤ c 柀⮶侭借㤕⇍ẍ幵℔㔁侭䁢⍫䄏䳬ˤ 姣烉* P < 0.05 ** P < 0.01 *** P < 0.001ˤ 屯㕁Ἦ㸸烉㛔䞼䨞. Ӄȃଇ፤ᇅ๗፤ Κȃःึف౫ᇅଇ፤ 炷ᶨ炸ġ㔜 橼侴妨炻䣦⋨䘬≽ン傥≃檀㕤朄ン傥≃烊朄ン傥≃ẍˬ斄Ὢ≃˭堐䎦㚨 Ἓ炻ˬ屉䈑≃˭冯ˬ㔯⊾≃˭䚠⮵庫⻙烊≽ン傥≃ẍˬ柀⮶≃˭冯ˬ䳬䷼ ≃˭堐䎦庫Ἓ炻ˬ忋䳸≃˭⍲ˬ⍫冯≃˭䚠⮵庫⻙ˤ. Ʉ23Ʉ.
(24) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. ⯙䣦⋨朄ン傥≃侴妨炻寸䘬ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭⼘栗↢䣦⋨ṵ⬀㚱晬⍂䘬䣦㚫屯㛔炻 䣦⋨劍傥┬䓐忁枭⮞屜䘬䣦⋨屯䓊炻⮯㚱≑㕤䣦⋨㱣䎮忼ㆸ℞慵夾ᷳ䣦㚫ↅ倂䘬 䚖㧁炷Bowles & Gintis, 2002; Pill & Bailey, 2012炸ˤˬ屉䈑≃˭ˬ㔯⊾≃˭堐䎦 䚠⮵庫⻙炻⍵㗈↢ᶨ凔⮵⎘䀋䣦⋨䘤⯽ᷳˬ慵䈑岒ˣ庽㔯⊾˭䘬姽徘炷哉⎱㸸炻 1995烊湫㸸⋼炻2004烊湫㸸⋼ˣ∱䳈䍵ˣ唕㔯檀炻2011炸炻ㆾ姙枰ᾖ㬋䁢ˬ㖊庽䈑 岒ˣḇ庽㔯⊾˭ˤ ⯙䣦⋨≽ン傥≃侴妨炻ˬ柀⮶≃˭堐䎦䚠⮵庫Ἓ⎗傥㗗⚈⍿姒侭⣂䁢䣦⋨柀 堾炻侴㖻㕤星ℍ冒ㆹ姽₡ㆾ冒ㆹ昞愱䘬ね⠫炻䃞侴炻劍⽆䣦⋨⃒⊊䘬奨溆Ἦ䚳炻柀 ⮶侭⮵冒℟⁁柀⮶≃䘬ᾉ⽫炻ㆾ姙⎗䁢䣦⋨傥≃䘬⺢㥳⤈⭂⎗屜䘬ᶨ朊ˤˬ忋䳸 ≃˭䘬䚠⮵唬⻙炻ㆾ姙シ␛叿䳬䷼ᷳ攻䘬⋼≃斄Ὢ䘬ᶵ嵛炻忁⮯ᶵ⇑㕤⬴ℐ冒ᷣ奨 溆ᷳ䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳ慵夾䈡⭂ềỜ斄Ὢ䘬⼊ㆸ炷O’Toole & Burdess, 2004炸ˤˬ⍫冯 ≃˭䘬䚠⮵唬⻙炻昌シ␛叿䣦⋨寸䘬朄ンˬ斄Ὢ≃˭炷䣦㚫屯㛔炸炻㛒傥⃭↮⛘ ⍵㗈⛐⮎晃䘬⍫冯ᶲ炻Ṏ冯䣦⋨㱣䎮⻟婧䘬℔㮹⍫冯䚠忽炷Das et al., 2015炸ˤ ⎎⢾炻䣦㚫屯㛔冯℞Ṿ㚱⼊屯䓊ᷳ攻℟㚱忋≽斄Ὢ炷⤪烉Bourdieu, 1997; Putnam, 1993; Kay, 2006; Green & Haines, 2008炸炻劍仢᷷⮯朄ン䘬斄Ὢ廱⊾ㆸ≽ン䘬⍫ 冯炻⮯暋ẍ⮵䣦⋨㱣䎮ㆾ䣦⋨䘤⯽㚱⮎岒䘬≑䙲炻劍䛇⤪㬌炻⌛ὧ㗗ℵ寸斄Ὢ 炷䣦㚫屯㛔炸炻ḇ⮯⎒㗗ᶨ䧖ˬ㨇㚫˭炻⮵䣦⋨⮎岒䘬ㆸ攟≑䙲㚱旸ˤ 炷Ḵ炸ġ㔜橼侴妨炻ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒檀㕤䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒烊䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒⎬ 朊⎹㘖念Ỷ㕤ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒炻堐䎦䚠⮵庫Ἓ侭䁢ˬṢ㔯㔁做˭炻ˬ䴻㾇 䤷䣱˭㚨⻙ˤᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒⎬朊⎹ᷕẍˬ䣦⋨⍫冯˭堐䎦㚨Ἓ炻ˬ⯭ỷ 䑘⠫˭⇯䚠⮵庫⻙ˤ ˬ䣦⋨⍫冯˭堐䎦庫Ἓ炻⎗傥冯䣦⋨柀堾炷⍿姒侭炸ᷳ檀⹎㈽ℍ䣦⋨ḳ⊁㚱 斄ˤ䃉婾㗗䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䘬ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭ㆾᾳṢⰌ䳂䘬ˬ⯭ỷ䑘⠫˭炻䘮冯⯭㮹䘬㖍ⷠ 䓇㳣〗〗䚠斄䘬炻⯌℞㗗ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭㗗⼙枧⸠䤷デ䘬ᷣ天ㆸ↮ᷳᶨ炷Zautra et al., 1977炸炻℞堐䎦䚠⮵庫⻙⎗傥冯役ṃ⸜䴻㾇ね⊊ᶵἛ㚱斄ˤ䴻㾇冯䑘⠫庫暋ẍ䫎⎰ ⯭㮹㛇⼭䘬䎦尉炻㝸䧖䦳⹎ᶲ冯⇵徘ᷳˬ庇ˣ䠔橼˭暋ẍ䫎⎰⯭㮹䘬㛇⼭䚠⏣⎰炻 ⯌℞㗗⮵䚜㍍䚳⼿⇘䘬ˬ䑘⠫˭冯ˬ䴻㾇˭ᷳデ⍿⎗傥㚜㶙ˤ 炷ᶱ炸ġ㔜橼侴妨炻⃀䭉䣦⋨䈡⿏⮵䓇㳣⑩岒䔍㚱⼙枧炻⯌℞㗗䣦⋨⛘䎮⋨ỵ炻Ữ䛇 㬋⮵䓇㳣⑩岒℟⼙枧≃䘬⮎䁢ˬ䣦⋨傥≃˭ˤ⎎⢾炻昌朄ン䣦⋨傥≃ᷕ䘬 ˬ䑘⠫≃˭冯䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷕ䘬ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭㛒忼栗叿䚠斄⢾炻䣦. Ʉ24Ʉ.
(25) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. ⋨傥≃䘬⎬ᾳ朊⎹冯䓇㳣⑩岒䘬⎬ᾳ朊⎹䘮忼栗叿䚠斄ˤ ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭㗗姙⣂䣦⋨䆇忈䘬ᷣ天≽≃ᷳᶨ炻䈡⇍㗗⤪ỽ┬䓐冒䃞䑘⠫ㆾ䓇 ンẍ䁢䣦⋨∝忈䴻㾇₡ῤ炻㚜㗗姙⣂䣦⋨䘬慵天ⶍἄ䚖㧁ˤ冢䀋䴻忶⣂⸜䘬䣦⋨䆇 忈炻㚱ṃ䣦⋨ẍ℞冒䃞䓇ン䑘⠫炷ἳ⤪烉❼慴㟫䰛䣦⋨䘬䓇ン㛹ˣ旧慴ⰙⰙ伶䣦 ⋨䘬忼⧄Ẳ察冒䃞䓇ン℔⚺炸∝忈↢⁚Ṣ䘬䣦⋨䓊㤕炻忚侴ⷞ≽䣦⋨䘬䴻㾇䤷䣱ˤ ⃀䭉⤪㬌炻ˬ䑘⠫≃˭冯ˬ䴻㾇䤷䣱˭攻㛒忼栗叿䚠斄炻ᶨ㕡朊⎗傥シ␛叿᷎朆⣂ 㔠䘬䣦⋨䘮傥┬䓐℞冒䃞䑘⠫䘬⃒⊊ẍ䁢℞ⷞἮ䴻㾇ᶲ䘬䤷䣱炻⯙㬌侴妨炻䣦⋨屯 䓊㗗ᶨ䧖ˬ㨇㚫˭炻⬫ᶵ⽭䃞傥⡆忚䣦⋨䘬䓇㳣⑩岒烊⎎ᶨ㕡朊炻Ṏ⎗傥シ␛叿 冒䃞䑘⠫ⷞἮ䘬䴻㾇⇑䙲炻㗗䣦⋨⮹㔠Ṣṓ㚱䘬炻侴↢䎦湫㸸⋼炷2004炸䧙ᷳ ˬ⮹㔠Ṣ⇑䙲˭䘬䣦⋨䆇忈ˤ 炷⚃炸ġ䣦⋨傥≃ᷳ≽ン䘬ˬ⍫冯≃˭冯朄ン䘬ˬ屉䈑≃˭炻䘮䁢妋慳㔜橼ˣᾳṢⰌ 䳂冯䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿⚈⫸炻⎎⢾炻≽ン䘬ˬ柀⮶≃˭冯朄ン䘬ˬ斄 Ὢ≃˭炻Ṏ㗗妋慳ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒栗叿⚈⫸ˤ ⯙⼙枧䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䣦⋨傥≃⚈䳈奨ᷳ炻≽ン䘬ˬ⍫冯≃˭㚨䁢栗叿䘬⚈ 䳈ˤ䣦⋨⍫冯㗗ẍ德忶⯭㮹䘬㈽ℍ炻ẍὫ忚䣦⋨䤷䣱ᷳ㍸㖯䁢㖐嵋炷㜿ᾉ⺟䫱炻 2012炸炻䣦⋨⯭㮹䘬⍫冯䣦⋨ḳ⊁㗗ᶨ䧖䣦⋨㳣≃䘬⯽䎦炻⛐䣦⋨忳ἄ忶䦳ᷕ㈽ℍ ゛㱽ˣ埴≽ㆾ屯㸸炻᷎德忶⮵䣦⋨ḳ⊁䘬斄⽫ˣ埴≽䘬夷∫屯㸸䘬普䳸炻ᶵ㚱 ≑㕤䣦⋨忶䦳䚖㧁炷➡≃炸䘬忼ㆸ炻㚜㗗忼ㆸ䣦⋨ᷳả⊁䚖㧁炷䣦⋨䤷䣱炸ᶵ⎗ㆾ 仢䘬天䳈ˤ忁ṃ䎦尉㬋㝸䧖䦳⹎⍵㗈↢䣦⋨㱣䎮䘬堐⽝ʇ⛘㕡ᷣ⮶冯℔㮹冒ㆹ㱣䎮 炷Box, 1998炸炻Ṏ⎗⻟⊾℔㮹⍫冯ᷳ㚱≑㕤橼䎦䣦⋨㱣䎮㍸⋯䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ䚖㧁䘬 ᾉ⾝炷O’Toole & Burdess, 2004烊㰇㖶ᾖ炻2009炸ˤ⯙㬌侴妨炻檀⹎䘬ˬ⍫冯≃˭ ᶵ㗗䣦⋨㱣䎮䎮⾝䘬⯽䎦炻Ṏ㗗Ὣ忚䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬⚈⫸ˤ婈⤪ Paul炷1987: 2炸 ㊯炻䣦⋨⍫冯傥⣈⛐ᾳṢ⼿ˣㆸ攟ˣ冒䩳ㆾ℞Ṿ㫚徥㯪䘬₡ῤⰌ朊䓊䓇≑ 䙲炻᷎⡆忚䤷䣱ˤ⎎⢾炻ˬ屉䈑≃˭㗗䣦⋨䓇㳣㨇傥䘬➢䢶炻ˬ屉䈑≃˭⮵䣦⋨䓇 㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿⼙枧炻⍵㗈↢䣦⋨䘬➢䢶⺢姕⮵䓇㳣⑩岒䘬⼙枧ˤ ˬ柀⮶≃˭冯ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭㗗妋慳䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿⚈⫸ˤ䣦⋨䘬柀堾ㆾ ⸡悐㗗䣦⋨䘬ᷕ➭ấ⫸炻℞妨埴䘮⎗傥⮵䣦⋨⯭㮹℟㚱卓⣏䘬⼙枧ἄ䓐炻⯌℞㗗⛐ 㼃䦣満⊾䔞ᷕ⼙枧⯭㮹䘬ン⹎炻忚侴⼙枧⇘⮵䣦⋨䘬娵䞍ˣ⍫冯斄Ὢ炷湫㸸⋼ 䫱炻2011炸ˤ䃞侴炻ˬ⛘㕡奺柕⊊≃䘬Ṍ丷˭ㆾˬ䎮ḳ攟冯㛹慴攟䚠Ḻ㈿堉˭㗗⎘ 䀋䣦⋨䘤⯽ᶲᶵ㕟塓娔䕭ㆾ㊹㇘䘬⓷柴炷㜿䴻䓓炻2002烊湫㸸⋼炻2004炸炻忁ṃ䎦. Ʉ25Ʉ.
(26) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. 尉⮵䣦⋨䘬媏ˣↅ倂ẍ⍲ḳ⊁䘬㍐≽冯䘤⯽炻⽭㚱䚠䔞屈朊䘬⼙枧ˤ⚈侴炻㛔䞼 䨞䘤䎦ᷳˬ柀⮶≃˭冯ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭⮵䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬⼙枧炻ㆾ姙㝸䧖䦳⹎⛘⍵ 㗈↢䣦⋨柀⮶侭㛔幓䘬天ẞˣ傥≃⍲℞冯⯭㮹ᷳ攻䘬斄Ὢ炻⬫⮯斄Ὢ⇘䣦⋨ℏ悐䘬 媏冯䣦⋨⢾悐斄Ὢ䘬⺢䩳炻᷎⼙枧⇘䣦⋨⯭㮹⮵䣦⋨㔜橼䘬娵䞍デ⍿ˤ䣦⋨ề Ờᷳ䣦⋨㱣䎮栆✳㗗⺢䩳⛐⇑⭛斄ὪṢ⼤㬌ᷳ攻䘬ᾉả冯ℙ嬀炷Pill & Bailey, 2012炸炻劍柀⮶≃傥⣈怑↯䘬䘤㎖炻᷎ⷞ≽䣦⋨䘬媏冯ↅ倂ᷳ斄Ὢ炻⇯⬫⮵䣦⋨ ềỜᷳ䣦⋨㱣䎮䚖㧁䘬忼ㆸ炻⮯℟㚱㶙怈䘬シ佑ˤ. Ρȃ๗፤˕ᄈަୣݾ౪ᇅަୣึޠཏో 䔞䣦⋨㱣䎮ㆸ䁢℔ℙ㱣䎮䘬慵天怠枭炻᷎䳸⎰䣦⋨䘤⯽徼⼹ἄ䁢徥㯪䓇㳣⑩岒 䘬䫾䔍㗪炻⇵徘䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒⏰䎦䘬斄Ὢ炻ㆾ⎗⮵㛒Ἦ⎘䀋⛐䣦⋨㱣 䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽℟㚱䚠䔞䦳⹎䘬シ㵝炻勚⮯⎗傥䘬シ㵝冯⺢嬘㬠䲵⤪ᶳˤ 炷ᶨ炸ġ㈦↢䣦⋨䘬斄挝⃒⊊冯≋⊊炻ἄ䁢䣦⋨㱣䎮䘬↯ℍ溆炻ẍ┇≽䣦⋨㯠临䘤⯽ 䘬年忻炻᷎嬻䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳˬ㓡┬↮惵䘬㓰䌯˭䘬䚖㧁⼿ẍ⮎䎦ˤ 㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦炻⍿姒侭⮵䣦⋨傥≃ㆾ䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒㘖念⬀⛐叿㬋⎹䘬䚳㱽炻ᶼ㚱 ṃ朊⎹堐䎦䚠⮵庫Ἓ炻ἳ⤪炻ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭ˣˬ柀⮶≃˭⍲ˬ䣦⋨⍫冯˭䫱炻忁ṃ朊 ⎹䘮冯䣦⋨㱣䎮⻟婧ㆾ徥㯪ᷳˬ䣦⋨冒ㆹ䭉䎮˭ˣˬ⛘㕡ᷣ⮶˭ˣˬ℔㮹⍫冯˭ 冯ˬ䣦⋨➡≃˭䫱䎮⾝䚠䫎ˤ㛔䞼䨞Ṏ䘤䎦炻䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬⎬ᾳ朊⎹ 㘖念⏰䎦栗叿㬋䚠斄炻Ṏ⌛炻䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒⎗傥⬀⛐列⿏䘬⽒䑘ἄ䓐烊 ⎎⢾炻屉䈑≃冯⍫冯≃㗗⼙枧㔜橼ˣ䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂⍲ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿⚈⫸炻䃞 侴炻ㆹᾹṎ䘤䎦䎦⬀ᷳˬ庽䈑岒ˣḇ庽㔯⊾˭䘬≋⊊䎦尉ˤ䁢㬌炻劍ㆹᾹ傥ẍ䣦⋨ 㖊㚱䘬⃒⊊ㆾ㼃⛐⃒⊊炻⍲㈦↢䣦⋨䘬⓷柴炻ℵ↿↢⼭妋㰢ᷳ⓷柴䘬⃒⃰㫉⸷炻᷎ 䚉⎗傥ẍ䣦⋨䘬⃒⊊Ἦ⚆ㅱㆾ妋㰢⓷柴炻劍傥⤪㬌炻⌛⎗⮯䣦⋨㱣䎮⮶ℍ㍸⋯䣦⋨ 傥≃冯Ὣ忚䓇㳣⑩岒䘬列⿏⽒䑘傰䴉烊Ṏ⎗嬻䣦⋨䘬⃒⊊冯⓷柴 怑↯䘬忋䳸炻᷎ ⮎䎦䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳˬ㓡┬↮惵䘬㓰䌯˭炻忚侴⮎䎦℞徥㯪ᷳ㚜℟㓰䌯冯㓰傥䘬㚵⊁ 廠復䚖㧁ˤ 炷Ḵ炸ġ⻟⊾䣦⋨忋䳸≃炻᷎徸㬍䲵ℍ䣦⋨ᷳ⎬䧖⛀橼炾䳬䷼ㆸ䁢䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳ䣦⋨ề Ờ炻ẍἄ䁢䣦⋨怩⎹㯠临䘤⯽䘬⼴䚦ˤ 㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦炻䣦⋨⛐≽ン傥≃ᷕ䘬ˬ忋䳸≃˭堐䎦䚠⮵庫⻙ˤ䵚䴉㗗䣦㚫屯㛔 䘬㥳ㆸ天䳈ᷳᶨ炻䣦㚫屯㛔⇯䁢忼ㆸ䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳˬ䣦㚫ↅ倂˭䚖㧁䘬➢䢶ˤPutnam. Ʉ26Ʉ.
(27) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. 炷1993炸㊯↢炻⯭㮹㖍ⷠ䓇㳣ᷕ⍫≈⎬栆䣦⛀ㆾ䳬䷼⼊ㆸ䘬䵚䴉倗专炻⌛㗗∝忈 䣦㚫屯㛔䘬⸛⎘炻㬌栆✳䘬䵚䴉グ⭮普炻䣦⋨⯭㮹ὧグ㚱⎗傥䁢普橼䤷䣱ℙ⎴⎰ ἄˤ⯙㬌侴妨炻⛐䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤䘬傰䴉墉炻忋䳸≃䘬唬⻙⮯ᶵ⇑㕤䣦⋨ềỜ斄 Ὢ䘬⼊ㆸˤ䁢⺢䩳䣦⋨ềỜẍἄ䁢䣦⋨㯠临䘤⯽䘬⼴䚦炻啱䓙⻟⊾忋䳸≃ẍ⺢䩳ᶵ ⎴悐攨ᷳ攻䘬忋䳸炻䈡⇍㗗⏠⺽ˬ⼰⮹俛倆˭ˬᶵ㖻㍍妠˭ᷳ⛀橼≈ℍ㱣䎮䘬埴 ↿炻㗗䨩䟜⼊ㆸ䣦⋨ềỜ斄Ὢᷳ旣≃䘬慵天徼⼹炻⏎⇯炻䣦⋨㱣䎮䳪⮯䃉㱽⚆ㅱ℞ 㫚德忶䣦⋨冒ㆹ䭉䎮Ἦ⍾ẋ䥹Ⰼ冯ⶪ⟜⣙曰䘬姜㯪炷O’Toole & Burdess, 2004炸炻 䓂军↢䎦⚈ềỜ⋼≃䘬ᶵ嵛炻侴星ℍ䣦⋨Ṏ⣙曰䘬䩀⠫ 炷ᶱ炸ġ⻟⊾䣦⋨柀⮶Ṣ≃ᷳ⁔⊾ˣ㽨⊝ˣ䳸䚇冯Έ⮶ᷳ㈨ⶏ炻ẍ㊃⊇㚜⣂䧵㤝℔㮹 ⍲⇑⭛斄ὪṢ㈽ℍ䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬埴↿ˤ 㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦炻ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭冯ˬ柀⮶≃˭䘮䁢䣦⋨䚠⮵庫⻟䘬傥≃炻ᶼˬ柀⮶ ≃˭Ṏ㗗妋慳ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿嬲枭ˤ⤪⇵徘炻⍿姒䘬䣦⋨柀⮶侭Ụ᷶⮵ 冒䘬柀⮶≃⃭㺧䘬ᾉ⽫炻劍ㆹᾹ傥⣈┬䓐㖊㚱䣦⋨柀⮶侭ᷳ℟䅙婈冯ᾉ⽫䘬⃒ ⊊炻᷎㕥ẍ媠⤪⁔⊾ˣ㽨⊝ˣ䳸䚇冯Έ⮶䫱䣦⋨➡≃冯䣦⋨ềỜ暨䘬䚠斄㈨ⶏ炻 ⮯⎗㽨䘤㚜⣂栀シ㈽ℍ䣦⋨㱣䎮埴↿䘬䧵㤝℔㮹炻忁ᶵỮ傥ⷞ≽䣦⋨ᷳ℞⬫傥≃䘬 䘤㎖炻Ṏ⎗Ὣ忚䣦⋨䘤⯽徥㯪ᷳ㍸⋯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ䚖㧁䘬⮎䎦ˤToomey 炷2011: 193炸⌛娵䁢炻⛐䣦⋨䘤⯽➡≃䘬忶䦳ᷕ炻䣦⋨劍天傥⣈㚱㬋⎹ᶼ㯠临䘬㓡 嬲炻柀⮶侭ㅱ⽆⁛䴙䘬㓹≑ˣ㍸ὃˣ≽⒉ㆾ妋㓦䘬奺刚炻廱⎹⁔⊾ˣ㽨⊝ˣ䳸䚇冯 Έ⮶䘬奺刚ˤ䁢㬌炻䣦⋨柀⮶侭䚠斄㈨ⶏ䘬➡妻䘤⯽炻ᶵ⎗䳗䧵㚜寸䘬䣦⋨ 㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽ᷳ傥慷炻Ṏ㗗㍸㖯䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬慵天徼⼹ˤ 炷⚃炸ġẍ⻟⊾䣦⋨シ嬀⍲䆇忈⍳┬ˣ℔⸛冯⸛䫱⍫冯䑘⠫炻䁢䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽ 䘬∝忈㚱⇑䘬㡅ẞˤ 㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦炻ˬ斄Ὢ≃˭ˣˬ⍫冯≃˭冯ˬ䣦⋨シ嬀˭㚱䚠⮵庫檀䘬䚠斄⿏炻 ⍰ˬ⍫冯≃˭㗗枸㷔㔜橼ˣᾳṢⰌ䳂⍲䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿嬲枭ˤ斄Ὢ≃ˣ⍫ 冯≃冯䣦⋨シ嬀䘮䁢㥳ㆸ䣦⋨䣦㚫屯㛔䘬天䳈炻䣦㚫屯㛔䁢䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳˬ┬㱣˭枰 ℟⁁䘬天ẞ炷Bowles & Gintis, 2002炸炻᷎攻㍍⼙枧䣦⋨䘬䓇㳣⑩岒ˤ䌳㗍⊅ 炷2008炸⌛㊯↢炻䣦⋨⍫冯䘬ㆸ≇䴻槿⮯㶙⊾䣦⋨ㆸ⒉攻䘬ᾉả斄Ὢ炻忚侴Ὣ忚䣦 㚫屯㛔炷斄Ὢ≃炸䘬䳗䧵冯㚜㕘ˤ㜿ᾉ⺟䫱炷2012炸䘬䞼䨞Ṏ䘤䎦炻䣦⋨⍫冯䘬忶 䦳㚱≑㕤䣦㚫屯㛔⬀慷䘬䳗䧵炻䣦㚫屯㛔⮵䣦⋨⍫冯Ṏ㚱㬋⎹䘬妋慳≃ˤ䞼䨞Ṏ嫱 ⮎炻庫檀Ⰼ㫉ᷳ䣦㚫屯㛔䘬䣦⋨天㭼庫ỶⰌ㫉侭㚱㚜Ἓ䘬䓇㳣⑩岒炷Kavanaugh,. Ʉ27Ʉ.
(28) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. Reese, Carroll, & Rosson, 2005炸ˤ栗夳炻德忶䣦⋨⍫冯䣦⋨シ嬀⮵䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦 ⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬㍸⋯㚱℞慵天⼙枧≃ˤ 㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦ᾳṢⰌ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬䣦⋨⍫冯䣦⋨シ嬀䚠⮵堐䎦庫Ἓ炻Ữ⛐䣦⋨ ≽ン傥≃䘬⍫冯≃⌣㗗䚠⮵ῷỶ䘬ˤ忁ṃ䎦尉晾⍵㗈↢䣦⋨柀⮶侭⮵䣦⋨⍫冯䘬㈽ ℍ⹎庫Ἓ炻⌣ḇ⍵㗈↢柀⮶侭Ᾱ娵䁢䣦⋨⯭㮹⍫冯䣦⋨ḳ⊁䘬ᶵ嵛ˤḳ⮎ᶲ炻䣦⋨ ⍫冯ᶵ嵛ᶨ䚜㗗⎘䀋䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽⼭䨩䟜䘬䎦尉炷㜿ᾉ⺟䫱炻2012炸ˤ䁢 㬌炻䣦⋨㱣䎮䘬忶䦳⽭枰天傥㈦↢᷎㌺昌旣䣁ㆾᶵ⇑㕤䣦⋨⍫冯䘬⚈⫸ˤCollier 冯 Mitchell炷2015炸㊯↢炻䣦⋨䘬ềỜ劍傥⣈ᶨ崟⋼≑䣦⋨⺢䩳傥≃炻⮯㚱㚜⣂嬻䣦 ⋨嵐㕤䷩㥖䘬㨇㚫炻⯭㮹ḇ庫傥⣈㚱冺怑䘬䓇㳣⑩岒ˤ⚈侴炻䁢⻟⊾䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦 ⋨䘤⯽䘬傥慷炻㚜䁢㍸㖯䣦⋨ᷳ䓇㳣⑩岒炻䃉婾㗗㓧⹄䘬㓧䫾ㆾ䣦⋨䘬⮎⊁炻䘮ㅱ 农≃㕤䆇忈㚱≑㕤⍳┬ˣ℔⸛冯⸛䫱䘬⍫冯䑘⠫炻ẍ忚ᶨ㬍Ὣ忚䣦⋨シ嬀⍲䣦⋨⍫ 冯䘬シ栀炻忚侴䁢䣦⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬㍸㖯∝忈㚱⇑䘬㡅ẞˤ 炷Ḽ炸ġẍ⻟⊾➢䢶ⶍ䦳冯䴻㾇⺢姕炻 䁢⻟⊾䣦⋨傥≃䘬ᶨ䑘炻᷎ㆸ䁢䣦⋨㱣䎮 䣦⋨㯠临䘤⯽䘬㓗㞙 㛔䞼䨞䘤䎦炻ˬ屉䈑≃˭ˬ⍫冯≃˭䘮䁢⼙枧䣦⋨㔜橼ˣᾳṢ⍲䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇 㳣⑩岒䘬栗叿⚈䳈ˤ㛔䞼䨞㊯↢炻⎘䀋䘬䣦⋨䘤⯽ᶵˬ庽䈑岒炻ḇ庽㔯⊾˭ˤ䈑 岒㗗㚱⼊䘬炻⃀䭉䚠斄䘬䞼䨞ᶨℵ⻟婧ˬ䣦⋨シ嬀˭ˣˬ䣦⋨⍫冯˭⮵䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬 慵天⿏炻Ữ忁᷎ᶵシ␛叿䣦⋨䘬➢䢶冯䴻㾇⺢姕㗗ᶵ慵天䘬炻⍵Ὰ⎗傥㗗傥⏎┇≽ 䣦⋨㱣䎮冯䣦⋨䘤⯽䘬➢㛔朊ˤCollier 冯 Mitchell炷2015炸⌛娵䁢炻➢䢶⺢姕䘬㈽ 屯⮯䁢䣦⋨攳∝᷎ᾅ㚱ⶍἄ㨇㚫炻䣦⋨㚱㫋㫋⎹㥖䘬ẩ㤕⎗㍸ὃ䴎⍿ₙ侭⍲℞⭞Ṣ 㚜⣂⍾⼿屯㸸䘬㨇㚫炻忚侴㓡┬ㆾ㍸⋯℞䓇㳣⑩岒ˤ劙⚳䣦⋨㱣䎮㓧䫾ᷣ天䚖㧁ᷳ ᶨ⌛䁢惘慴㚜㕘炷Pill & Bailey, 2012炸ˤ忁ṃ⮵➢䢶䳸㥳䴻㾇⺢姕䘬斄㲐炻塓 ⬠侭夾䁢䘤⯽ㆾ《⽑䣦⋨傥≃䘬慵天朊⎹炷Berks & Ross, 2013炸炻Ṏ㗗㍸⋯䓇㳣⑩ 岒䘬慵天⚈䳈炷Collier & Mitchell, 2015炸ˤ ℐ朊⿏䘬䣦⋨䘤⯽㴱⍲⇘姙⣂朊⎹炻劍⎬朊⎹䘮㫚朊朊ᾙ⇘炻⍵侴⎗傥ᶨ攳⥳ ὧ↮㔋䣦⋨䘬傥慷炻⚈侴炻㍉⍾徸㬍䓙溆侴䶂侴朊䘬䴻䆇䫾䔍炻㗗嬻䣦⋨㛅⎹ℐ朊 ⿏䘤⯽䘬慵天徼⼹炻䁢㬌炻⮵㝸ṃ嗽㕤Ỷ⹎䘤⯽䘬䣦⋨炻劍傥⣈⽆庫䁢栗叿䘬ᶼ䚳 ⼿⇘䘬ˬ屉䈑≃˭炷ᷣ天䁢䣦⋨䘬➢䢶冯䴻㾇⺢姕炸叿ㇳ炻⌛⎗傥忚ᶨ㬍妠≽⯭㮹 䘬䣦⋨シ嬀ㆾ䣦⋨⍫冯炻忚侴䁢䣦⋨䘬㱣䎮冯䘤⯽ℍ庫䁢䨑⚢䘬㓗㞙ˤ. Ʉ28Ʉ.
(29) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. ήȃःف४ښᇅଔᝧ ⃀䭉䣦⋨䘬⭂佑嵐㕤⣂⃫炻ⓗ⚈➢㕤䞼䨞⎗埴⿏䘬䎦⮎侫慷炻㛔䞼䨞怠㑯ẍ ⛘䎮⋨➇䁢➢㸾䘬䞼䨞䭬䔯炻暋ẍℤ栏⇘ὅḳ䶋⼊ㆸ䘬䣦⋨ˤ⛐䞼䨞⮵尉䘬怠㑯 ᶲ炻䁢栏⍲⍿姒侭⮵䣦⋨䚠斄ḳ⊁枰㚱ᶨ⭂䦳⹎䘬䝕妋炻ᶼ天傥⣈℟㚱ẋ堐⿏炻㓭 怠⍾ẍ䣦⋨柀⮶侭䁢⍿姒⮵尉炻农ἧ㛔䞼䨞⎗傥暋ẍ⭋䧙㗗㘖念䣦⋨⯭㮹䘬奨溆ˤ ⛐䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒䘬㑵ἄᶲ炻⚈䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼㚫䭬⭂䘬䣦⋨炻⣏⣂㔠⛘䎮⋨➇䭬 䔯ㆾ傥慷㚱旸炻䣦⋨ᷳ⭊奨屯妲⺢䩳ᶵ⬴⁁ㆾ吸普ᶵ㖻炻⸦䴻妶婾⿅侫炻⎒⤥㍉ ⍾㪲⭄䘬⥍⋼㕡⺷炻㓡ẍ婳⍿姒侭↮⇍⽆ẋ堐㔜橼䣦⋨⯭㮹䘬奺⹎炷䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂炸炻 ẍ⍲ᾳṢ冒幓䴻槿炷ᾳṢⰌ䳂炸䘬奺⹎炻Ἦ⮵䣦⋨㔜橼⍲ᾳṢ䘬䓇㳣⑩岒 奨⮇炻 忁䧖Ὗ旸⎗傥旸⇞Ḯ䣦⋨Ⰼ䳂䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ屯妲䘬娖慳ㆾ㍐婾ˤ ⃀䭉㚱⇵徘䘬Ὗ旸炻㛔䞼䨞ḇ忼ㆸᶨṃ慵天䘬㓰䙲ˤ椾⃰炻㛔䞼䨞Ὢᶨấ憅⮵ ℐ⎘ 6,220 ⣂ᾳ䩳㟰䘬䣦⋨䘤⯽⋼㚫ὅ PPS ⍇䎮㉥㧋炻ẍ朊姒婧㞍䘬㕡⺷忚埴炻ᶼ ⬴姒䌯忼ᶨ⭂䦳⹎炻㓭䞼䨞䳸㝄㚱℞ẋ堐⿏ˤ℞㫉炻㛔䞼䨞嫱⮎䣦⋨傥≃Ὢ⼙枧䣦 ⋨䓇㳣⑩岒䘬ᷣ天嬲枭炻忁⮵䔞ẋ⻟婧䣦⋨㱣䎮ᷳ℔㮹⍫冯℟㚱慵天䘬シ㵝炻ḇ⏲ 姜ㆹᾹ䣦⋨➢䢶⺢姕䘬⽭天⿏ˤ㚨⼴炻㛔䞼䨞㍉⮎嫱䞼䨞㍊妶䣦⋨傥≃冯䣦⋨䓇㳣 ⑩岒ᷳ斄Ὢ炻⎗墄䚖⇵憅⮵忁ℑᾳ㤪⾝忚埴斄倗⿏䞼䨞ᷳᶵ嵛䘬仢ㅦˤ. ՄНᝧ 䌳㗍⊅炷2008炸ˤ۩Җަୣᇅ࣐ϟኈዂԓःفˤ⚳䩳ᷕⰙ⣏⬠℔ℙḳ⊁䭉䎮 䞼䨞⌂⢓婾㔯炻㛒↢䇰炻檀晬ˤ 㰇㖶ᾖ炷2009炸ˤަୣݾ౪ϟ౪፤ᜍᇅᄃଡ଼ݚȈпަשୣᕋആ࢈๋࣐پ ȞJȟȞ䱦䯉䇰ȟˤ埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫䞼䨞妰䔓ㆸ㝄⟙⏲炷NSC 972410-H004-096炸炻㛒↢䇰ˤ 㛶㯠⯽ˣ⏛⬇剛炷2005炸ˤ⎘⊿ⶪᷣ奨䓇㳣⑩岒ᷳ堉慷ˤഎҀᇅॏฬ炻32炷4炸炻 387-420ˤ 㜿ᾉ⺟ˣ匲ὸ㖽ˣ∱䳈䍵ˣ湫㸸⋼炷2012炸ˤMaking Community Work烉䣦⋨屯㛔 冯䣦⋨⍫冯斄倗⿏ᷳ䞼䨞ˤѯᢋަཽᆌւᏱё炻10炷2炸炻161-210ˤ 㜿䴻䓓炷2002炸ˤ䣦⋨䆇忈冯ⶪ㮹⍫冯烉䣦⋨䷥橼䆇忈䘬䎦㱩冯䎮゛ˤུзखහ৳ ፤Ꮼ炻19炻30-38ˤ Ʉ29Ʉ.
(30) ǸϦӅՉࡹᏢൔǸ ಃѤΜΐය ҇104ԃ9Д. ⬓㖶䁢炷1997炸ˤпϵӔ೪ࢋᅗཏ࡚ᇅަཽᆪ࡚ຠզަୣҢࣁࠣ፵ϟःفˤ⚳ 䩳ㆸ≇⣏⬠悥ⶪ妰∫⬠䲣䡑⢓婾㔯炻㛒↢䇰炻⎘⋿ˤ 㠩䁛䏐ˣ⻝攟佑炷2005炸ˤ⍇ỷ㮹㕷悐句奨䘬㔯⊾䴻㾇冯䣦㚫屯㛔烉ẍⰙ伶䣦⋨ 䁢ἳˤӵ౪Ᏹൣ炻39炻31-51ˤ 悕䐆✌ˣ䌳㗍⊅ˣ昛楁⇑炷2007炸ˤ⯭㮹䣦⋨➡≃冯䣦㚫屯㛔ˣ䣦⋨シ嬀斄倗⿏ᷳ 䞼䨞烉ẍ檀晬ⶪ㷗⎋䣦⋨䁢ἳˤϵӔٲଡ଼ຠ፤炻8炷2炸炻97-129ˤ 湫㘾㘜ˣ傉㵹屆炷嬗炸炷2006炸ˤ䣦⋨傥≃ᷳ㷔慷炷Dr. Suzanne Jackson 㺼嫃炸ˤ ୋஷ࠳ҀᏱё炻188-194ˤ 湫㸸⋼炷2004炸ˤ䣦⋨ⶍἄỽ⍣ỽ⽆烉䣦⋨䘤⯽烎䣦⋨䆇忈烎ަୣึ۠ё炻 107炻78-87ˤ 湫㸸⋼ˣ∱䳈䍵ˣ匲ὸ㖽ˣ㜿ᾉ⺟炷2010炸ˤ䣦⋨䣦㚫屯㛔冯䣦⋨䘤⯽斄倗⿏ᷳ䞼 䨞ˤϵӔ࢈Ᏹൣ炻34炻29-75ˤ 湫㸸⋼ˣ∱䳈䍵ˣ唕㔯檀炷2011炸ˤ劙⚳䣦⋨㕘㓧⮵⎘䀋䣦⋨ⶍἄ䘬┇䣢冯ῇ掉烉 䣦⋨㱣䎮奨溆䘬↮㜸ˤѯτަཽϏձᏱё炻23炻1-46ˤ 䄲䐆㠭炷1995炸ˤ䣦㚫䵚䴉䘬屯㕁吸普ˣ㷔慷冯↮㜸炻庱㕤䪈劙厗ˣẘ㬊ˣ䝧㴟 㸸炷䶐炸炻ަཽ።ࢦᇅϸݚȈަཽऌᏱःفРݳᔯଇᇅࠊᙂϟΚ炷313356 枩炸ˤ⎘⊿烉ᷕ⣖䞼䨞昊㮹㕷⬠䞼䨞⮰↲ˤ 哉⎱㸸炷1995炸ˤ婾⎘䀋⛘⋨䣦㚫屯㛔ˣ䣦⋨シ嬀冯䣦⋨䣦㚫ᷳ慵⺢ˤѯᢋစᔽ炻 228炻1-12ˤ Ackerman, N., & B. Paolucci (1983). Objective and subjective income adequacy: Their relationship to perceived life quality measures. Social Indicators Research, 12(1), 25-48. Aki, H., M. Tomotake, Y. Kaneda, J. Iga, S. Kinouchi, S. Shibuya-Tayoshi, … T. Ohmori (2008). Subjective and objective quality of life, levels of life skills, and their clinical determinants in outpatients with schizophrenia. Psychiatry Research, 158(1), 19-25. Berkes, F. & H. Ross (2013). Community resilience: Toward an integrated approach. Society and Natural Resources, 26(1), 5-20. Bourdieu, P. (1997). The forms of capital. In A. H. Halsey, H. Launder, P. Brown, & A. S. Wells (Eds.), Education: Culture, Economy, and society. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Bowles, S. & H. Gintis (2002). Social capital and community governance. The Economic Journal, 112(483), 419-436. Ʉ30Ʉ.
(31) ૈޗΚᆶޗғࢲࠔ፦ϐࣴزǺჹݯޗᆶޗวޑཀ఼. Box, R. C. (1998). Citizen Governance: Learning American Communities into the 21st Century. London: SAGE. Chaskin, R. J., P. Brown, S. Venkatesh, & A. Vidal (2001). Building Community Capacity. New York: Aldine de Gruyter. Cnann, R., & J. Rothman (2008). Capacity development and the building of community. planning and policy practice. In J. Rothman, J. L. Erlich & J. E. Tropman (Eds.), Strategies of Community Intervention (7th Ed.) (pp. 243-262). Peosta, IA: Eddie Bowers. Collier, O., & P. Mitchell, (2015). Building capacity to improve economic health. North Carolina Medical Journal, 76(1), 46-49. Costanza, R., B. Fisher, S. Ali, C. Beer, L. Bond, R. Boumans, …R. Snapp (2007). Quality of life: An approach integrating opportunities, human needs, and subjective well-being. Ecological Economics, 61(2), 267-276. Coulton, C. (2005). The place of community in social work practice research: Conceptual and methodological developments. Social Work Research, 29(2), 73-86. Craig, G. (2007). Community capacity-building: Something old, something new….? Critical Social Policy, 27(3), 335-359. Das, C., M. O’Neill, & J. Pinkerton, (2015). Re-engaging with community work as a method of practice in social work: A view from Northern Ireland. Journal of Social Work, 1468017315569644. Fleeger, W. E., & M. L. Becker (2008). Creating and sustaining community capacity for ecosystem-based management: Is local government the key? Journal of Environment, 88(4), 1396-1405. Gollagher, M., & J. Hartz-Karp (2013). The role of deliberative collaborative governance in achieving sustainable cities. Sustainability, 5(6), 2343-2366. Green, G. P., & A. Haines (2008). Asset building and community development(2ndEd.). Los Angeles: SAGE Publications. Grinde, B. (2009). An evolutionary perspective on the importance of community relations for quality of life. The Scientific World Journal, 9, 588-605. Hardina, D. (2013). Interpersonal social work skills for community practice. New York烉Springer Publishing Company. Kavanaugh, A. L., D. D. Reese, J. M. Carroll, & M. B. Rosson (2005). Weak ties in networked communities. The Information Society, 21(2), 19-113. Kay, A. (2006). Social capital, the social economy and community development. Community Development Journal, 41(2), 160-173.. Ʉ31Ʉ.
相關文件
資源和支援 學與教資源 社區資源 學校設施 和支援 研究與 發展計劃 學校領導與
Professional Learning Community – Music
年齡階段 N(2-3歲班) K1(3-4歲班) K2 (4-5歲班) K3 (5-6歲班) 生活經驗 家庭與學校 家庭與學校 學校與社區 家庭、學校與社區. 重點培養 孝 禮
H., Liu, S.J., and Chang, P.L., “Knowledge Value Adding Model for Quantitative Performance Evaluation of the Community of Practice in a Consulting Firm,” Proceedings of
結合 NPO 或 NGO 團體基於組織使命及發展推動文化與教育、觀光與
They are: Booklet (6) – Healthy Community, exploring the communicable and non- communicable diseases and how they affect community health so that students are able to
Examples of relevant concepts: equality, discrimination, cultural differences, community resources, self-concept, vulnerable groups, community work, community support
Apart from actively taking forward the "Walk in HK" programme announced by the Transport and Housing Bureau in January this year to encourage people to walk more, we