樣本範圍

行政審查實務中，可能存在著檢驗方法的偏好，故本文欲從量化方法著手，

分析專利訴願暨爭議委員會以及專利審判暨上訴委員會裁決中所利用之方法專 利適格檢測方法，以觀察出專利行政審查實務的分布與趨勢。

本研究於 WestLaw Patents 資料庫中點選 Patent Trial and Appeal Board¹⁹³，以 進行專利訴願暨爭議委員會以及專利審判暨上訴委員會做成裁決之搜索。將案件 搜索時間起點設定於美國專利商標局公告「2009 年美國專利法第 101 條專利適 格標的評估暫時審查基準」之當天，2009 年 8 月 24 日，並以資料檢索當天，2014 年 2 月 12 日作為檢索時間終點。其中，再依「2010 年就 Bilski 案所訂之美國專 利法第 101 條專利適格標的評估暫時審查基準」公告日—2010 年 7 月 27 日，以 及「2012 年涉及自然法則之方法其專利適格標的評估暫時審查基準」公告日 2012 年 7 月 3 日，區分成三個時間區塊，即 2009 年 8 月 24 日至 2010 年 7 月 26 日、

2010 年 7 月 27 日至 2012 年 7 月 2 日、2012 年 7 月 3 日至 2014 年 2 月 12 日。

又 ， 關 鍵 字 設 定 為 ：「 101 & ELIGIBLE INELIGIBLE ELIGIBILITY INELIGIBILITY」。意即，內文中出現「101」以及「ELIGIBLE」或「INELIGIBLE」、

或「ELIGIBILITY」、或「INELIGIBILITY」之裁決，均會透過系統篩選後出現。

共計有 1054 件。後經人工篩選，去除掉與本研究主題與方向無關之案件共 659 件¹⁹⁴，列表如下。

※表三：從檢索結果中剔除之案件列表

編號 案號 專利申請人 做成時間

1. 2014 WL 573543 EX PARTE YUEN LING WAN AND KWONG HUNG YU 12-Feb-14 2. 2014 WL 573543 EX PARTE YUEN LING WAN AND KWONG HUNG YU 12-Feb-14 3. 2014 WL 573545 EX PARTE JUAN MANUEL CRUZ-HERNANDEZ AND MICHAEL D. LEVIN 12-Feb-14

4. 2014 WL 572237

EX PARTE PAUL C. HUFFMAN, KATHY A. MCKNIGHT, DAVID C. SHARPE, AND DANIEL C. ZILIO

11-Feb-14

5. 2014 WL 572249 EX PARTE PATRICK JOSEPH O'SULLIVAN, LIAM HARPUR, FRED RAGUILLAT, 11-Feb-14

193

點選該資料庫專利審判暨上訴委員會 (Patent Trial and Appeal Board)，亦會出現改制前專利訴

願暨爭議委員會(Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences)所審查之案件。

194

如，案件爭點在於程序問題、並非討論方法專利適格之案件者。

66

CAROL SUE ZIMMET, AND DANIEL TERLIZZI

6. 2014 WL 547476

EX PARTE CURTIS M. GEARHART, CHRISTOPHER MEYER, LINWOOD H. OVERBY JR., AND DAVID J. WIERBOWSKI

10-Feb-14

7. 2014 WL 572247 EX PARTE CRISTINA BARBOSA CANNON AND STEFAN HUNSCHE 10-Feb-14

8. 2014 WL 457859 EX PARTE YUN-QING SHI AND GUORONG XUAN 31-Jan-14

9. 2014 WL 343743

EX PARTE GABRIEL AARON COHEN, RONALD EUGENE CRAIG, AND GERALD LAVERTE MITCHELL, JR..

29-Jan-14

10. 2014 WL 343748

EX PARTE STEVEN W. LUNDBERG, THOMAS F. BRENNAN, JANAL M. KALIS, SHAL JAIN, AND PRADEEP SINHA

29-Jan-14

11. 2014 WL 343798 EX PARTE KOUICHI KAWAMOTO AND TOSHIAKI SUZUKI 29-Jan-14

12. 2014 WL 332737

EX PARTE ERIK J. BURCKART, JEFFREY E. CARE, DAVID J. SCHELL, AND RYAN L.

URQUHART

27-Jan-14

13. 2014 WL 343758 EX PARTE TARIQ RAHMAN, THOMAS H. SHAFFER, AND J. RICHARD BOWEN 27-Jan-14

14. 2014 WL 317037

EX PARTE EDWARD K.Y. JUNG, ERIC C. LEUTHARDT, ROYCE A. LEVIEN, ROBERT W. LORD, AND MARK A. MALAMUD

24-Jan-14

15. 2014 WL 262093

EX PARTE BRYCE ALLEN CURTIS, STEWART EARLE NICKOLAS, AND WAYNE ELMO VICKNAIR

22-Jan-14

16. 2014 WL 262094 EX PARTE STEPHEN J. HARRINGTON AND LEE C. MOORE 22-Jan-14

17. 2014 WL 262203

EX PARTE UWE KINDSVOGEL, TATJANA JANSSEN, KLAUS IRLE, AND SIMEON LUDWIG

22-Jan-14

18. 2014 WL 296395

EX PARTE JAY RODNEY WALTON, MARK S. WALLACE, JACK M. HOLTZMAN, AND FRANKLIN PETER ANTONIO

22-Jan-14

19. 2014 WL 296399 EX PARTE LI CHEN, JOHN R. HIND, YONGCHENG LI, AND LUN XIAO 22-Jan-14

20. 2014 WL 572237

EX PARTE PAUL C. HUFFMAN, KATHY A. MCKNIGHT, DAVID C. SHARPE, AND DANIEL C. ZILIO

11-Feb-14

21. 2014 WL 117870 EX PARTE LARRY L. LU 9-Jan-14

22. 2014 WL 47360

EX PARTE ERIC LAWRENCE BARSNESS, AMANDA PETERS, AND JOHN MATTHEW SANTOSUOSSO

3-Jan-14

23. 2013 WL 6907613 EX PARTE WILLIAM JOSEPH BLOEMEKE AND REID ANTHONY CASHION 31-Dec-13

24. 2013 WL 6907819

EX PARTE BRYCE ALLEN CURTIS, STEWART EARLE NICKOLAS, AND WAYNE ELMO VICKNAIR

30-Dec-13

25. 2013 WL 6858195

EX PARTE KEITH S. KLEMBA, MATTHIAS U. KAISER, SHUYAN CHEN AND FRANCES H. JAMES

27-Dec-20

26. 2013 WL 6858198 EX PARTE NICHOLAS HO 27-Dec-13

27. 2013 WL 6776265

EX PARTE SCOTT S. BUMP, RICHARD L. LINSCOTT, NESTONR J. CAMINO, JR., VLADIMIR KOSTADINOV, CHARLES W. PIPER, AND JOHAN I. TEGNELL

20-Dec-13

67

28. 2013 WL 6776272 EX PARTE STEVEN MCCANNE AND ANDREW SWAN 20-Dec-13 29. 2013 WL 6827975 EX PARTE SANJAY KAMATH, MICHAEL A. KONGELF, AND LEIF WOODAHL 19-Dec-13 30. 2013 WL 6698804 EX PARTE EUNJIN JUNG AND AMAL AHMED SHAHEEN 18-Dec-13

31. 2013 WL 6700319 EX PARTE GERT F. RUSCH 18-Dec-13

32. 2013 WL 6681540

EX PARTE RICHARD WAYNE CHESTON, MARK CHARLES DAVIS, HOWARD JEFFREY LOCKER, AND ROD DAVID WALTERMANN

17-Dec-13

33. 2013 WL 6681536

EX PARTE LINDSAY BRADFORD, STEPHEN MILLINER, AND JULIEN J.P.

VAYSSIERE

13-Dec-13

34. 2013 WL 6681572 EX PARTE XIN PENG LIU AND YU CHEN ZHOU 13-Dec-13 35. 2013 WL 6571663 EX PARTE RAJ RAHEJA, HOMAYOUN TORAB, AND MOUNIRE EL HOUMAIDI 12-Dec-13

36. 2013 WL 6571664 EX PARTE RONALD STEVEN KARPF 12-Dec-13

37. 2013 WL 6698805 EX PARTE ROBERT A. COCHRAN AND JAY J. SCHULTZ 12-Dec-13

38. 2013 WL 6907669 EX PARTE ADAM D. DIRSTINE 12-Dec-13

39. 2013 WL 6630871 EX PARTE SVETLANA CHEMIAKINA, PREBEN MOGENSEN, AND ESA MALKAMAKI 11-Dec-13 40. 2013 WL 6355716 EX PARTE SANDY KAO AND RODRIGO L. PASTRANA 5-Dec-13 41. 2013 WL 6355717 EX PARTE PETER WEINSTEIN, THOMAS PHELPS AND H. VAN DYKE PARUNAK 5-Dec-13

42. 2013 WL 6576694

VOLUSION, INC. PETITIONER v.VERSATA SOFTWARE, INC. AND VERSATA DEVELOPMENT GROUP, INC. PATENT OWNER

5-Dec-13

43. 2013 WL 6217721 EX PARTE HEMAL SHAH 27-Nov-13

44. 2013 WL 6212633 EX PARTE BENJAMIN RODEFER 26-Nov-13

45. 2013 WL 6212682

EX PARTE TAHANY IBRAHIM EL-WARDANY, CHANGSHENG GUO, DANIEL V.

VIENS, ERIC FROMERTH, AND LIENJING CHEN

26-Nov-13

46. 2013 WL 6212690 EX PARTE DEREK J. WEBB 26-Nov-13

47. 2013 WL 6217738 EX PARTE MALLIKARJUNA SAMAYAMANTRY 26-Nov-13

48. 2013 WL 6190727 EX PARTE JANANI JANAKIRAMAN 25-Nov-13

49. 2013 WL 6141636 EX PARTE MARCUS L. KORNEGAY, NGAN N. PHAM, AND BRIAN T. VANDERPOOL 20-Nov-13

50. 2013 WL 6116835

EX PARTE CHRISTIAN L. HUNT, CHARLES LE VAY, ETHAN K. MERRILL, AND JAKE PALMER

19-Nov-13

51. 2013 WL 6141639

EX PARTE NITHYA RAJAMANI, JAMES RUBAS, NORBERT G. VOGL, AND WLODEK WLODZIMIERZ ZADROZNY

19-Nov-13

52. 2013 WL 6217799

EX PARTE DAVID H. BURDETT, DAVID S. FRANKEL, GUNTHER STUHEC, JEAN-JACQUES DUBRAY, AND MARTIN RAEPPLE

18-Nov-13

53. 2013 WL 6073069 EX PARTE NANCY L. BROEN AND JYANPING RUNG 14-Nov-13

54. 2013 WL 6073079

EX PARTE KATHRYN H. BRITTON, DIETER BUEHLER, WILLIAM P. HIGGINS, YI-HSIU H. WEI, AND CHUNHUI YANG

13-Nov-13

55. 2013 WL 6040908 EX PARTE ANUPAM GUPTA, LAURIE BRITTING, KAREN FLEURANT, REMO 12-Nov-13

68

POLITANO, AND JUDY DOYLE

56. 2013 WL 6054410 EX PARTE WILSON CHAN 12-Nov-13

57. 2013 WL 6141618 EX PARTE YULI YOU 6-Nov-13

58. 2013 WL 5937920

EX PARTE HARLEEN K. GILL, ARULMOZHI KASI ANANTHANARAYANAN, ASHU RAZDAN, AND ERIC C. ROSEN

31-Oct-13

59. 2013 WL 5937935 EX PARTE GAO CONG, WENFEI FAN, AND ANASTASIOS KEMENTSIETSIDIS 31-Oct-13

60. 2013 WL 5863320 EX PARTE QING YANG AND JIAN LI 30-Oct-13

EX PARTE BRAD T. RESSER, RUSSELL A. PATENAUDE, SHPETIM S. VELIU, AND ANTHONY J. SUMCAD

23-Oct-13

67. 2013 WL 5758137 EX PARTE ADRIAN ALVAREZ DIEZ AND FRANK LEO MIELKE 22-Oct-13

68. 2013 WL 5758139

EX PARTE ERIC LAWRENCE BARSNESS, DAVID L. DARRINGTON, AMANDA PETERS, AND JOHN MATHEW SANTOSUOSSO

22-Oct-13

69. 2013 WL 5758149 EX PARTE SHIRLEE ANN WEBER AND ANDREW MARK LONG 22-Oct-13

70. 2013 WL 5740860

EX PARTE JESSE PAUL ARROYO, JOSEP CORS, DAVID LEE DOSCH, MARK HARRISON GOFF, JONATHAN LOUIS KAUS, KYLE ALAN LUCKE, MICHAEL ANTHONY MIGLIACIO, AND RANDALL SCOTT NELSON

21-Oct-13

71. 2013 WL 5866631

EX PARTE ANTHONY SATYADAS, BIRENDRO ROY, AMAR P. PATEL, AND ROY W.

BOWEN

21-Oct-13

72. 2013 WL 5758138 EX PARTE VINCENT D. PARK, M. SCOTT CORSON, AND GEORGE TSIRTSIS 18-Oct-13 73. 2013 WL 5979927 EX PARTE ROBERTO BATTAGLINI AND BRIAN PATRICK SINGER 18-Oct-13

74. 2013 WL 5740831 EX PARTE JUHA HENRIK ARRASVUORI 16-Oct-13

75. 2013 WL 5953025 EX PARTE IVAN M. HENINGER AND JOHN DAMON KARI 16-Oct-13

76. 2013 WL 5979918

EX PARTE STEFANO VEGNADUZZO, YUE RONA YANG, ANTON V. JOULINE, AND OLEG S. KISLYUK

16-Oct-13

77. 2013 WL 5864865 EX PARTE KEITH HOWARTH GREAVES 15-Oct-13

78. 2013 WL 5655531 EX PARTE JOHAN RUNE AND LARS WESTBERG 11-Oct-13

79. 2013 WL 5460446

EX PARTE COLLEEN S. CONNEARNEY, MICHAEL W. CROSS, JOHN R. MCGARVEY, CHRISTOPHER R. SEEKAMP, AND AJAMU WESLEY

27-Sep-13

80. 2013 WL 5460493 EX PARTE RAYMOND C. KURZWEIL 27-Sep-13

81. 2013 WL 5487143 EX PARTE FENQIN ZHU, YAJUAN WU, AND YINGXIN HUANG 27-Sep-13 82. 2013 WL 5460470 EX PARTE MARK JOHN ANDERSON, DAVID STANLEY CHARRON, JAMES 26-Sep-13

69

MICHAEL FLANAGAN, AND SCOTT L. FORSTIE

83. 2013 WL 5460518 EX PARTE BENJAMIN C. GRABOSKE 26-Sep-13

84. 2013 WL 5499698

EX PARTE MICHAEL L. GAILEY, ERICA A. PORTMAN, MICHAEL J. BURGISS, CHAD S. HOLMES AND ANGELA KING SMITH

26-Sep-13

85. 2013 WL 5499706

EX PARTE RAINER ULRICH, STEPHEN J. BARLOW, AND PETER FRANCIS CHEVALLY DE RIVAZ

26-Sep-13

86. 2013 WL 5423559 EX PARTE JAY W. BENAYON, PABLO DANIEL IRASSAR, AND HUMIE LEUNG 25-Sep-13 87. 2013 WL 5423560 EX PARTE RAVOSH SAMARI AND PAYMAAN BEHROUZI 25-Sep-13

88. 2013 WL 5460440

EX PARTE KEVIN THOMAS JONES, MELISSA DORIS BEEBE, JEFFREY ALAN MARRS, AND MICHAEL SHANE CASTLE

25-Sep-13

89. 2013 WL 5460499 EX PARTE WILLIAM R. WADLEIGH 25-Sep-13

90. 2013 WL 5409884 EX PARTE DAVID LOUIS KAMINSKY AND DAVID M. OGLE 24-Sep-13 91. 2013 WL 5409895 EX PARTE DUN ALEX LI, VERNON THOMAS JENSEN, AND CRISTIAN ATRIA 24-Sep-13 92. 2013 WL 5460444 EX PARTE KRUTARTH SHAH AND PHILIP R. GRAHAM 24-Sep-13

93. 2013 WL 5496995 EX PARTE ATSUSHI MATSUTANI 24-Sep-13

94. 2013 WL 5499731 EX PARTE HENRIK PRZYBILLA 24-Sep-13

95. 2013 WL 5409190

EX PARTE EDWARD K. Y. JUNG, ROYCE A. LEVIEN, ROBERT W. LORD, MARK A.

MALAMUD, JOHN D. RINALDO JR., AND LOWELL L. WOOD JR.

23-Sep-13

96. 2013 WL 5467089 EX PARTE BORIS HYLE PARK AND JOHANNES F. DE BOER 23-Sep-13

97. 2013 WL 5487077

EX PARTE DANIEL THERO, MATTHEW D. HAINES, WILLIAM G. MCCOLLOM, PHILIP M. WALKER, AND GREGORY J. LIPINSKI

23-Sep-13

98. 2013 WL 5499719

EX PARTE MICHAEL C. SCROGGIE, MICHAEL E. KACABA, DAVID A. ROCHON, AND DAVID M. DIAMOND

23-Sep-13

99. 2013 WL 5499736 EX PARTE SRIKANTH SANKARAN AND DOUGLAS T. CHORNA 23-Sep-13

100. 2013 WL 5603510 EX PARTE JOHN SPERTUS 23-Sep-13

101. 2013 WL 5409016 EX PARTE WOLFGANG E. WALTER AND AMAR KUMAR 20-Sep-13 102. 2013 WL 5409033 EX PARTE GARY W. BEHM, MALEK BEN SALEM, AND YUE LI 20-Sep-13

103. 2013 WL 5655528

EX PARTE BRENT A. ANDERSON, ANDRES BRYANT, EDWARD J. NOWAK AND RICHARD Q. WILLIAMS

20-Sep-13

104. 2013 WL 5487100 EX PARTE CHIAHONG CHEN AND RADHA K. RAMACHANDRAN 19-Sep-13

105. 2013 WL 5406731 EX PARTE SCOTT SHEPPARD 18-Sep-13

106. 2013 WL 5487186 EX PARTE YIN L. CHEUNG, MICHAEL J. ZEITLIN, AND MARK ACOSTA 18-Sep-13 107. 2013 WL 5406450 EX PARTE STEFAN VAILLANT AND STEPHEN SEILER 17-Sep-13

108. 2013 WL 5406700

EX PARTE JEAN-MARIE HULLOT, BERTRAND GUIHENEUF, LAURENT CERVEAU, AND ERIC NOYAU

17-Sep-13

109. 2013 WL 5406705 EX PARTE JOHN MARK LUCAS, RACHEL ANN CAPUTO, JAMES C. LANG, NORMA 16-Sep-13

70

A. LANG, AND THOMAS JOHN KNOBLOCH

110. 2013 WL 5402269 EX PARTE MIKA LAHTEENMAKI AND TIMO HEIKKINEN 13-Sep-13

111. 2013 WL 5409903

EX PARTE JASON ROBERT MCGEE, MICHAEL JOHN MORTON, AND BRENT A.

PETERS

12-Sep-13

112. 2013 WL 5409856

EX PARTE STEVEN J. BARON, PATRICK J. MALLOY, ALAIN J. COHEN, MARC I.

SCHNEIDER, AND CHERYL D. STOCKS

10-Sep-13

113. 2013 WL 4831924 EX PARTE MARIO BRENES AND JAMES ERIC O'HEARN 9-Sep-13 114. 2013 WL 4831933 EX PARTE IUE-SHUENN CHEN AND KEVIN PATARIU 9-Sep-13

115. 2013 WL 4831945

EX PARTE CHRISTIAN LEE HUNT, VINCENT MITCHEL PADUA, ROBIN RADEZ, WILLIAM ALEXANDER REICHERT III, GREGORY COVERT SMITH, AND ORIANA JEANNETTE WILLIAMS

9-Sep-13

116. 2013 WL 4782199 EX PARTE PAUL VILLASENOR, JOSEPH PICCERILLO JR., AND JANE E. MARLATT 5-Sep-13 117. 2013 WL 4831706 EX PARTE BOON HO, SRIKANTH NATARAJAN, AND DIPANKAR GUPTA 5-Sep-13 118. 2013 WL 4692242 EX PARTE JAMES P. GALVIN, AMY D. TRAVIS, AND SARA WEBER 30-Aug-13

119. 2013 WL 4692625 EX PARTE BO-ER WEI 30-Aug-13

120. 2013 WL 4782184

EX PARTE LARRY J. THAYER, ANDREW C. WALTON, MIKE H. COGDILL, AND GEORGE KREJCI

30-Aug-13

121. 2013 WL 4636920 EX PARTE MIKKO HAMALAINEN AND TIMO HELANDER 29-Aug-13 122. 2013 WL 4636966 EX PARTE MICHAEL A. GILFIX AND RHYS D. ULERICH 29-Aug-13 123. 2013 WL 4636967 EX PARTE FONDA J. DANIELS AND RUTHIE D. LYLE 29-Aug-13

124. 2013 WL 4636331

EX PARTE RUPIN T. MOHAN, TRAVIS PASCOE, GEORGE SHIN, AITHAL BASRUR GIRISH, KASTHURIRENGAN KARTHIGEYAN, P. K. UNNIKRISHNAN, JULIO VALLADARES, KULKARNI B. SHRINIVAS, AND Y. P. RAVINDRA

28-Aug-13

125. 2013 WL 4636410 EX PARTE EDMUND G. LOU AND RAJKUMAR PREMKUMAR 28-Aug-13 126. 2013 WL 4636910 EX PARTE STEVEN A. BADE, RENATO J. RECIO, AND MADELINE VEGA 28-Aug-13

127. 2013 WL 4831677 EX PARTE GARY L. SWOBODA 28-Aug-13

128. 2013 WL 4636328 EX PARTE JAMES T. BEZANSON, JEFFREY B. JENNINGS, AND KOFI KEKESSIE 27-Aug-13

129. 2013 WL 4692328

EX PARTE CHARLES J. ARCHER, MICHAEL A. BLOCKSOME, JOSEPH D.

RATTERMAN, ALBERT SIDELNIK, AND BRIAN E. SMITH

27-Aug-13

130. 2013 WL 4636927 EX PARTE PAUL J. BROYLES AND JEFFREY P. KENLINE 27-Aug-13

131. 2013 WL 4831723

EX PARTE DWIP N. BANERJEE, KAVITHA RAMALINGAM, PRITHVI SRIHARI, AND VENKAT VENKATSUBRA

27-Aug-13

132. 2013 WL 5348159 EX PARTE RICHARD TAYLOR AND CHRIS TOFTS 27-Aug-13 133. 2013 WL 4496309 EX PARTE E. MICHAEL STYLES AND MARINS COSMA 21-Aug-13 134. 2013 WL 4478727 EX PARTE MARCUS L. KORNEGAY, NGAN N. PHAM, AND BRIAN T. VANDERPOOL 20-Aug-13

135. 2013 WL 4478703 EX PARTE ERIC A. ANDERSON 19-Aug-13

71

136. 2013 WL 4496292 Appeal 2011-001025 19-Aug-13

137. 2013 WL 4397172 EX PARTE KRISTOPHER C. KASPRZAK, DANIEL STAPLES, AND VADIRAJ MYSORE 15-Aug-13 138. 2013 WL 4456042 EX PARTE JONATHAN HOWARD CORR, LIMIN HU, AND TSU-WANG CHEN 14-Aug-13

139. 2013 WL 4096388

EX PARTE IN-SUN LEE, KYUNG-HUN JANG, MIN-SO SHIN, WILLIAM A. ARBAUGH, AND ARUNESH MISHRA

12-Aug-13

140. 2013 WL 4084112

EX PARTE MARK CHARLES OEHLERKING, GREG ALAN UNRUH, GREG WILLIAM HOOVER, AND TIMOTHY WAYNE BOEHLE

9-Aug-13

141. 2013 WL 4037634 EX PARTE RICHARD IAN KNOX AND DAVID WILLIAM MORTON 7-Aug-13

142. 2013 WL 4009811

EX PARTE QUINN A. JACOBSON, SURESH SRINIVAS, ANNE C. BRACY, AND HONG WANG

5-Aug-13

143. 2013 WL 4028107

EX PARTE ELIEZER DEKEL, JOHN J. DUIGENAN, GIDON GERSHINSKY, ALEXANDER KRITS, NIR NAAMAN, FOLUSO O. OKUNSEINDE, HILARY A. PIKE, AND CORNELL G. WRIGHT JR.

5-Aug-13

144. 2013 WL 4037627 EX PARTE ROBERT E. BOU AND DANIEL LEE THOMPSON 2-Aug-13

145. 2013 WL 3972226

EX PARTE PATRICK J. O'SULLIVAN, AL CHAKRA, SEAN CALLANAN, AND MICHAEL MULLER

31-Jul-13

146. 2013 WL 3972306 EX PARTE THOMAS RÖ LLEKE 31-Jul-13

147. 2013 WL 3972330 EX PARTE DEBORA MARGARET HEJZA LITWILLER 31-Jul-13 148. 2013 WL 4028106 EX PARTE PETER C. JOHNSON II AND BRIAN DEHAMER 31-Jul-13 149. 2013 WL 3961397 EX PARTE FRANCINE R. CHEN, AYMAN O. FARAHAT AND THORSTEN H. BRANTS 30-Jul-13 150. 2013 WL 3971649 EX PARTE YUI-WAH LEE AND SCOTT C. MILLER 30-Jul-13

151. 2013 WL 3971654

EX PARTE MARK JOZEF WILLEM MERTENS, DANIEL WILLEM ELISABETH SCHOBBEN, AND RONALDUS MARIA AARTS

30-Jul-13

152. 2013 WL 3971667 EX PARTE MARTIN LUND 30-Jul-13

153. 2013 WL 4028102

EX PARTE JUSTIN MOORE, PARTHASARATHY RANGANATHAN, AND RATNESH SHARMA

30-Jul-13

154. 2013 WL 4456032 EX PARTE NANCY KIRKCONNELL-EWING, KYLE NEAL, AND LYNN SAUDER 30-Jul-13

155. 2013 WL 3961419

EX PARTE JOSEPH CELI, CHARLES W. CROSS, BRETT J. GAVAGNI, PETER J.

GUASTI, AND PEEYUSH JAISWAL

29-Jul-13

156. 2013 WL 3971687

EX PARTE AKSHAY ADHIKARI, SACHIN GARG, ANJUR S. KISHNAKUMAR, AND NAVJOT SINGH

26-Jul-13

157. 2013 WL 4028114 EX PARTE MARK C. VADON, DARRELL S. CAVENS, AND SCOTT DECKER 25-Jul-13

158. 2013 WL 4037609 EX PARTE KEVIN T. ROWNEY 23-Jul-13

159. 2013 WL 3873992 EX PARTE SAUL R. DOOLEY AND ANDREW T. YULE 22-Jul-13

160. 2013 WL 3807435

EX PARTE YEN-FU CHEN, JONH HANS HANDY-BOSMA, MEI YANG SELVAGE, AND KEITH RAYMOND WALKER

17-Jul-13

72

161. 2013 WL 3788537 EX PARTE VIJAY V. SARASHETTI 9-Jul-13

162. 2013 WL 3807907 EX PARTE DANIEL S. SIMPKINS 3-Jul-13

163. 2013 WL 3807904

EX PARTE PAUL T. BUCHHEIT, BAY-WEI W. CHANG, PETER D. MATTIS, BRIAN D.

RAKOWSKI, AND TERRY A. WINOGRAD

2-Jul-13

164. 2013 WL 3790552 EX PARTE NICHOLAS P. LYONS AND NINA T. B 28-Jun-13 165. 2013 WL 3804610 EX PARTE RONALD P. DOYLE AND DAVID L. KAMINSKY 28-Jun-13

166. 2013 WL 3804716

EX PARTE ALLEN M. GILBERT, DAVID LOUIS KAMINSKY, AND BALACHANDAR RAJARAMAN

28-Jun-13

167. 2013 WL 3805723

EX PARTE RAVI GAUBA, KLAUS HOFRICHTER, ANNIE WANG, RICHTER A. RAFEY, AND CLEMENT LAU

28-Jun-13

168. 2013 WL 3788523 EX PARTE KEVIN DAVID FOX AND DARICK M. TONG 27-Jun-13 169. 2013 WL 3804618, EX PARTE MIN CHUIN HOO AND RAJENDRA TUSHAR MOORTI 27-Jun-13 170. 2013 WL 3804908 EX PARTE RAND B. NICKERSON, MARK A. TRESCHL AND SEBASTIEN J. ARNAUD 27-Jun-13

171. 2013 WL 3790572 EX PARTE RENE DEHN AND MARTIN KAISER 26-Jun-13

172. 2013 WL 3804688 EX PARTE WOLFGANG BROSS, NORBERT HEUMUELLER, AND FRITZ OESTERLE 26-Jun-13

173. 2013 WL 3804789 EX PARTE JOHN SHERMAN HINDS 26-Jun-13

174. 2013 WL 3804871 EX PARTE THOMAS M. CRONIN 26-Jun-13

175. 2013 WL 3788522

EX PARTE JONATHN MICHAEL COOK, RANDY ALLAN RENDAHL, DAVID G.

ROBINSON, SHAW-BEN SHI, AND BRYON EUGENE TODD, III

25-Jun-13

176. 2013 WL 3790508 EX PARTE TIMOTHY E. GRIB AND MICHAEL A. BROWN 25-Jun-13 177. 2013 WL 3790536 EX PARTE GERMAN SCIPIONI, AVERY KADISON, AND NASEEM HAKIM 25-Jun-13

178. 2013 WL 3804795

EX PARTE PAUL A. BELOW, DEBRA L. MASCHINO, SANJAY KUMAR, LYNNE L.

PALMER, AND DOROTHY J. EASTERDAY

25-Jun-13

179. 2013 WL 3807355 EX PARTE YUI-WAH LEE AND SCOTT C. MILLER 25-Jun-13

180. 2013 WL 3807376 EX PARTE SANJAY M. KRISHNAMURTHY 25-Jun-13

181. 2013 WL 3790539

EX PARTE HEATHER MARIA HINTON, BRIAN JAMES TURNER, ANTHONY SCOTT MORAN, SHANE WEEDEN, IAN MICHAEL GLAZER, GAVIS GEORGE BRAY, AND VENKAT RAGHAVAN

EX PARTE DIRK BECKER, MARKO DEGENKOLB, FRANK SCHEERER, AND CHRISTIAN SCHLOEGEL

20-Jun-13

186. 2013 WL 3807312

EX PARTE RHONDA L. CHILDRESS, CATHERINE HELEN CRAWFORD, DAVID BRUCE KUMHYR, NEIL R. PENNELL, AND CHRISTOPHER DANIEL REECH

20-Jun-13

187. 2013 WL 3362954 EX PARTE ERIC LAWRENCE BARSNESS, JOHN MATTHEW SANTOSUOSSO, AND 19-Jun-13

73

JOHN JOSEPH STECHER

188. 2013 WL 3362805 EX PARTE HON FAI CHU 18-Jun-13

189. 2013 WL 3362810 EX PARTE RAYMOND B. JENNINGS III AND JASON D. LAVOIE 18-Jun-13 190. 2013 WL 3363110 EX PARTE HUGH SVENDSEN AND WAYMEN J. ASKEY 17-Jun-13

191. 2013 WL 3363098

EX PARTE GORDON KENT WALKER, GEORGE ALAN WILEY, RICARDO JORGE LOPEZ, RICHARD DOIL LANE, AND RAJIV VIJAYAN

14-Jun-13

192. 2013 WL 3362880 EX PARTE GIORDANO B. BERETTA 13-Jun-13

193. 2013 WL 3362888 EX PARTE ROBERT R. CUTLIP 13-Jun-13

194. 2013 WL 3807363

EX PARTE GOPALAKRISHNAN JANAKIRAMAN, DINESH KUMAR SUBHRAVETI, JOSE RENATO SANTOS, AND YOSHIO FRANK TURNER

12-Jun-13

195. 2013 WL 3356850

EX PARTE WILLIAM A. BROWN, RICHARD W. MUIRHEAD AND FRANCIS X.

REDDINGTON

11-Jun-13

196. 2013 WL 3361987

EX PARTE WILLIAM A. BROWN, RICHARD W. MUIRHEAD AND FRANCIS X.

REDDINGTON

11-Jun-13

197. 2013 WL 2605292

EX PARTE LARISA SHWARTZ, MAHESWARAN SURENDRA, NAGA A.

AYACHITULA, GENADY GRABAMIK, AND JAMES S. LIPSCOMB

7-Jun-13

198. 2013 WL 2605312

EX PARTE TIMOTHY R. CHAVEZ, CHRISTINA K. LAURIDSEN, SUSHMA B. PATEL, ROBERT R. PETERSON, LOULWA F. SALEM, AND LISA A. SEACAT

7-Jun-13

199. 2013 WL 3362956 EX PARTE ROBERT LAWRENCE GALLICK AND TOBY R. AMBROSE 6-Jun-13

200. 2013 WL 3362226

EX PARTE URI ELZUR, FRANKIE FAN, STEVEN B. LINDSAY, AND SCOTT S.

MCDANIEL

5-Jun-13

201. 2013 WL 5273992 EX PARTE ANDY SHIPMAN, JAMIE HARRISON, AND PATRICK HARRIS 3-Jun-13 202. 2013 WL 2608050 EX PARTE STEPHEN W. LINN AND LAURA LEE OLSON 31-May-13

203. 2013 WL 3338089

EX PARTE YEN-FU CHEN, RICK A. HAMILTON, II, JAMES W. SEAMAN, AND TIMOTHY M. WATERS

31-May-13

204. 2013 WL 3338112 EX PARTE RICHARD M. THEIS 31-May-13

205. 2013 WL 3338095 EX PARTE AMIT RAIKAR, JOHN DIAMANT AND TODD SPENCER 30-May-13 206. 2013 WL 2605229 EX PARTE TARL S. GORDON AND MACK W. RILEY, 29-May-13 207. 2013 WL 4858402 EX PARTE RUTHIE D. LYLE AND CORINNE M. RYAN 28-May-13 208. 2013 WL 3327084 EX PARTE CHRISTOPHER BETTS AND TONY ROGERS 28-May-13

209. 2013 WL 3327107 EX PARTE SHIGEKI NAKAMURA 22-May-13

210. 2013 WL 3327142 EX PARTE CHRISTOPHER BETTS AND TONY ROGERS 22-May-13

211. 2013 WL 3327164 EX PARTE SHIGEKI NAKAMURA 22-May-13

212. 2013 WL 4858390 EX PARTE J. MITCH LOWE 22-May-13

213. 2013 WL 3323605 EX PARTE UWE E. FISCHER, PARESH DESHPANDE, AND BIJU JATHEENDRAN 20-May-13 214. 2013 WL 3326044 EX PARTE BRIAN PATTERSON, CHARLES FUQUA, AND GUILLERMO NAVARRO 16-May-13

74

215. 2013 WL 3324252

EX PARTE CHRISTOPHER L. CONWAY, DENNIS R. DAMS, AND KEDAR S.

NAMJOSHI

15-May-13

216. 2013 WL 3324253 EX PARTE ELIEZER ALONI, URI EL ZUR, RAFI SHALOM, AND CAITLIN BESTLER 15-May-13

217. 2013 WL 3356848 EX PARTE ROBERT P. MORRIS 14-May-13

218. 2013 WL 3361988 EX PARTE ROBERT P. MORRIS 14-May-13

219. 2013 WL 5273973 EX PARTE EINO JACOBS AND MICHAEL ANG 14-May-13

220. 2013 WL 5273966 EX PARTE JACK CASSIDY AND WILLIAM CASSIDY 13-May-13

221. 2013 WL 3291360

EX PARTE DUNCAN L. MEWHERTER, AMY D. TRAVIS, KOAH-HSING WANG, AND ROBERT C. WEIR

8-May-13

222. 2013 WL 4477509

EX PARTE DUNCAN L. MEWHERTER, AMY D. TRAVIS, KOAH-HSING WANG, AND ROBERT C. WEIR

8-May-13

223. 2013 WL 3294664 EX PARTE JONATHAN H. CONNELL 7-May-13

224. 2013 WL 3294499 EX PARTE EDWARD CARTER, MANOJ THAWANI, AND MANAS DEB 6-May-13

225. 2013 WL 2139758

EX PARTE RHONDA L. CHILDRESS, DAVID BRUCE KUMHYR, AND NEIL RAYMOND PENNELL

30-Apr-13

226. 2013 WL 3323942 EX PARTE WILLIAM C. HEIN, III AND TYLER J. MCKINLEY 30-Apr-13

227. 2013 WL 3323944

EX PARTE KEI-LEUNG ALBERT LUN, TINNY MEI CHI NG, LINH DINH NGUYEN, AND CHRISTOPHER PAUL PARSONS

30-Apr-13

228. 2013 WL 3294752

EX PARTE OLIVER MAIER, SASCHA SCHAEFER, THOMAS WEISPFENNING, PETER WILLIMOWSKI AND ROLF ISERMANN

30-Apr-13

229. 2013 WL 1870777

EX PARTE MANOJ THAWANI, DAVID MILNE, HENRY PTASINSKI, AND RAYMOND HAYES

29-Apr-13

230. 2013 WL 1870809 EX PARTE CHRISTOPHER BETTS AND TONY ROGERS 29-Apr-13

231. 2013 WL 3323970

EX PARTE AKSHAY ADHIKARI, SACHIN GARG, ANJUR S. KISHNAKUMAR, AND NAVJOT SINGH

29-Apr-13

232. 2013 WL 5273962 EX PARTE JAMES HUGHES AND HENRY HANEK 26-Apr-13

233. 2013 WL 1870792

EX PARTE MICHAEL D. FACEMIRE, MOHAMAD R. SALAHSHOOR, JOHN F.

SCHUMACHER, AND MICHAEL WANDERSKI

25-Apr-13

234. 2013 WL 3293200 EX PARTE JEAN-MICHEL ROUET, MAXIM FRADKIN, AND SHERIF MAKRAM-EBEID 23-Apr-13

235. 2013 WL 1751412

EX PARTE JOERG STEINMANN, KARTHIKEYAN A., HIMANSHU KACKER, MOHAN MARAR, JAYANTA M. BORUAH, AND WOLFGANG GENTES

23-Apr-13

236. 2013 WL 1817534 EX PARTE ALAN JASON MCCABE 17-Apr-13

237. 2013 WL 3293231 EX PARTE PETROS BELIMPASAKIS AND CATALIN IONESCU 16-Apr-13

238. 2013 WL 1751415

EX PARTE JONATHAN GRIFFIN, ANDREW PATRICK NORMAN, AND MATTHEW MURRAY WILLIAMSON

15-Apr-13

239. 2013 WL 3294416 EX PARTE MICHAEL RALEY, DANIEL CHEN, HSI-CHENG WU, AND THANH TA 15-Apr-13

在文檔中 美國方法專利適格－實證與研究 (頁 75-101)