選民的媒介使用行為及其政治知識、政黨偏好與投票行為之間的關聯--兼論台灣媒體壟斷對政治認知與行為之影響

全文

(1)iI.m~. m=WI. (83/11) 'pp.1-25. ~~B"J~~fr'f~m1TmR.;!t!EXrEJ~D~. ... jfj(.~~TW1~~1TmZra~B"Jrm~~. -~~~ E1_~~ RII (1fT Wjfj( rEt ~rg~D iT ~ -7 .!i!/ ~~ I mK-1T~~. w. /-*~m* ~7?f .;,. -:I:::". j\L ,. ~*.** ...Io..&...=.. nil 1=1. *~~R~a~~~$~~~~~,-~~amW~.~~~~~~~o~~*~ ~m~lEWi~fj~~. ,. 5j&mJ~::f5'Pf~!fJTOO~.f'F~~JC{r.~~ID-V~~. , jl~m{#~~~. !fJT~.~• • ,~.~~.wa~~ • • ,~~~~~~.~~ • • ,~~.~ea~. am~~'&T~~~-.o~~.~~~~~@~~~.~'.~~~~.B~ffi.. m.. o. ~~~.~~ffiffl'. ••~-.~ •••• '.~*~~~M.".'.~~~~. $~.'~~~~.~~0~$~nWi~~~m~o~~~~'. • •Moo~m~m~~ !&f~m ' w~~~a~.w ' ,1~L~,;f§~ (Berkowitz & Pritchard, 1989; Chaffee & Schleuder, 1986; Chaffee' Zhao & Leshner, 1994; Drew & Weaver, 1991; Lanoue, 1992; Pettey, 1988) 0. ~a~~.~~~ • • • lmff~1lt'.6. 0. , r~.~mJwra~~~J~~~-~~~~~~~ PJAtkin, GallowayWNayman ( 1976) ?lTf'F~li}f~~{§1J ' WE#,&~li}f~.PJ. ~~m~~oo~~*g~,@~r~R~mJwra~~~J~OO~lEWiM.lm~'~. $U7 EPm 0 fJlf'Palmgreen (1979). f'F J. '. 'M~m-tt~Ii~~*W:~B~. r 9}. , ~.~m7t~iWi~?JT~f~~;f§gjfmgt~~D:f;fkttfj]D 'M#'& ' :{:Eli}f~~m~m wam~.~m~OO~lm~~,~~• • ~~~,~~m~~~Wm~'W~0~SS. *. ~. ~li}f~*El*M7F. 0. 4~~ •• ~1. ** ~~~ • • %I 1. /'.

(2) ~WI¥JOOA!a. '. W~m~liiN!I¥J~~~D. '. g~i&.~~fgJJl. '. lUijg~lt~.JU. r ~U-~D. ~J~r~U-~~rr~JzOOI¥J~~o EE~ r~fr~ffl. J (media use)(tE~WNJI¥Ji&~1$flFf~1$*1Ct:ptP.1f:)(Jtfm~ ryJttfr{~ ~J (media dependency)(H-)'& ri&~~D~J (political knowledge) ~m{mm~~* :)(I¥JFf~~,~\ , PJ ""fgt~W'8 {I"{if(~ -~I¥JMIDfB !f.WJI¥JFf~1£tj{UIt r ~fr~ffl J ~ r ~fr{t(~ J ~ , ~*R~tj{UJt~IDJ~I¥J~fr4 • •(media exposure) , ~ggfRi&~Ff~t:p,~\(the Center for Political Studies' fmfmcPS) -ft~ft~I¥JR~~MR~fr4.(.~~~.~.~'~~~~~~~• • •ffiHI¥JW EI~¥&~)fDW~fr[7g~I¥Jti:XijJ(attention )(.m~~~IDJ~liI7t1£ r• • ff~ J fD roo ~.mJ~,w~~~~I¥J~oo~rWNJ[7g'~'i&~' • •~~OOJI¥Jti:.fgJJl)~~liI 7t (Chaffee & Schleuder, 1986) ChaffeefDChoe(1979)I¥JFf~~U~m ' .ff~fD¥&*~~m f.I~II1£Jjtj{U-ftJ\O~~WNJI¥J~~il.WJrdl3l~Jj~ r{t*.AJ ,& r {t*3IAtE~~lii 0. 0. N!~l¥Jft~Jmmf.li&~~~l¥Jm.~I¥J~1fm~~o~~~m'~~i&~~~~-.. , 1I1U~:;jf;7t.W~~~~I¥J~fr~ffl1fM~g~ , ~U~fr!;U'i:ltI¥Jtj{U:It~~ffl~ ¥&m~m ' ffiHi~jJl¥Jtj{U:ll:~U~~ffl~.ff~~m McLeodfDMcDonald(1985)1£Ff~~ ~~.W• • ~OOI¥J~~~~m'w.~~OOI¥Jti:XifgJJl.~.~.W0~$HI¥J~. ~. ; ffif¥~I¥J.ffI4.A:~U~1!W~. ' g~=~Zrdl§!~fElIm f?9I1t ' ChaffeefD Schleuder(1986)sjR ' tj{U:l.:3I~I¥J~fr{t(~ (~ffl ) fgJJl ' &\~:lJD~;jf; r W~fr[7gt¥1¥J ti:x~niJJlJ (attention)I¥Jtj{UIt 1-$*1CI¥J~fr• •:!I:ffiU.I¥JFf~ , m~iJ!¥&*~lIImJj~i&~~D~I¥J!i:IJD1fIEiIDl¥J~. ' ffif.~I¥J • • • Wii&~~D~Zra~~1!WfElIJM(Quarles,1979) , ~g~§!~fElID1(Becker & Whitney, 1980; Patterson & McClure, 1976) {EI~ , 1f.®~ra~Ff~U(longitudinal)I¥JFf~ , {~m~. 0. 0. 0. 0. J{UJfm.ijl~.~-:ff. '. ~.!i:IJD~.I¥Jii&~~D~. (Chaffee, Ward & Tipton, 1970)7L ;jf;Chaffee,&;ttFf~/J\*JlJ!~5jR.ffl~mW~~.i&~~D~I¥J~.jJ (Chaffee & Schleuder, 1986; Chaffee, Zhao & Leshner, 1994) t:E~~I¥J:)(JtMIDfBt:p , fJt{l"IUPJ~m ' tE r ~fr~ffl J (~ r ~fr{t(~ J )1¥Jtj{UJt~ , 0. 0. ~7~~iilU.~WJ1lf~frl¥J• • •z71-' ~~lm;jf;fiJt~OO~~l¥Jitgj]fiN~UA~.. 0. ;tt~,.~~.~mm~~ml¥J~ffl.m,~.~~m~.~7t~~Jt,tP.~-@tE~. .~{mr14l~ml¥Jr~'N!. 0. 1f1mi&~~D.l¥JffiUJt1.iW. '. :)(Jtt:p~Ff~l¥Jf~~tP.~/t-3&. ChaffeefDSchleuder (1986)ffl*tj{U.i&~~D~l¥Jm~1gt15 : i&.~~~~(party symbol knowledge) , {t*.A i&.~D.(candidate party knowledge) , {~~AfElIII~D~(unique candidate knowledge)~ 0.

(3) ~~®~ft~fflffm&~~~~~'~.~~W~~ffmz~®~~ i13C.-~1I!~~(party-issue. mUJtm~B'gi&rtl~D~. :. knowledge). 0. BerkowitzWPritchard(1989)JlrjP).~.:::.tl1~;fI*. 1~~~1~mA(naming. m~~{~mA1:E=1'f8J~1I!-.tB'g}'[~(comparing. &. Leshner,. candidate) . . positions). 1994)JlrjP)'i&.-Jt1l!~D~(party-issue. (candidate-issue knowledge) , '='1iI1I1f;fl*mUJti&rtl~~. 0. 1~WJ~.~e(naming. Chaffee~.:::.A. knowledge) ,. fDW{,*mA{IAB'g~D~(candidate. issues)fD. (Chaffee, Zhao. {~mA-jie~D~. personal. knowledge)~. 0. ~~~~~~i&ffl~~B'g*~'~*.~*~~M*~,~a • • A~,~~mB'g i&.i&rtlfiZ~~,-ft~.W~§i&.B'g},[~~*B~-~WJ~°1:Em.B'gi&rtl~{~. ~m~MW*B'g.Im;fl~~~.m~am§~~B'gm.*~,.=1'.~~o (~EM. Mn.~m.E~~**~~i&rtl~~.JtB'g~.). 0. ~~.~~~B'gi&rtl~~~~,~*-.t®~*.~mm~~B'gi&rtl~m,~~~m ~W~B'g.~'.~~~~1:E • • ~.B'g • • • ~.ZOOB'gm.tt~m.~(m~. Chaffee. &. Schleuder, 1986; McLeod. ~1:EW~9~.pJT~t!llB'gJ}]~g lID9~S~D~~*-[£. , .tt; ,. ,. &. Kosiciki, 1985; McLeod. 1\f!Hf;RI&~5EB'g~/Jt. 0. &. McDonald, 1985) '=1'. .eP~~~~W~.ff~~m. ~Jtl1g~mr~~~W (~1§-~[J). J}]l1g ,. '. ~I&m~B'g~/Jt. ~§~~ZfS. '. m~~. *-.t ' .ff~~~mJ}]~gZ=1'f3 ' -tft~MtB-~.iiiJP.• • B'g!f.f~tt.Il~.ff~~B'g{~gr~A~ (low involvement) ,pJTP)'MI!AWJ.J:~mlltlB'gq&J&fi/Jt, jj=1'~D~{1!!~m (Gunter, 1987). 0. m~~.IlB'g • • ~~~,-tft~~-m_~,.~@mB'g~~~~'H~ • • ~~. .B'gll'li. ({9U~DConnel,. 1979; Herman and Chomsky, 1988). **sff4W~.m}'[.B'g~.. 0. {1!!fr'JWJa '. m*;fI~.~. ' ~'&1fjU7 B.~rl'l~ ~~{~~~B'gllJfm11: 0 tIt*U~~W6m ' *. • • • ~~m&~W.~Ma'~§.~~.~3(Mrtl~ • • *.)~B'g°M~~ • • ~*.~.,.~ • •~~B'gmm.M~.*~.~~.B'g~~'Rm~B'gm • •~ WC=1'0B'gm~-&J:!IH~ 0 ~Ilt ,~m* • •IMF{f!)f'~gt~.~±*. ' :mfJ(i&rtl~~ , ti ~i&rtlm~'&WW~m~B'g~~~mm.o~Ilt,* • •mR~.m7-tlt~N5A 0~$¥!JB'gm~' 1jlG~-~,~-g-Z.' W~i&rtl~~{~~fi%.1EiIDR~. 0. ~~r~~.J.rtlt~.J~B'g~Qm,am.~,~ • •mB'g~~§nB'gm.. flf71~.JE~!!B'g~13. '. m~X:~~~~*llJl1~~'&1fjU • • ~5C{~B'g~M. '. mM ' ~:aQJ. ~~m.=.tI~.B'g*~.@'M~afr'j.M• • •i&~~~'~.fimZOOB'g~~?. i1{lmfR• •@ ,. ~5tf;l5E• • • m~~~0~~Ji~B'gij!ff4.MfjjG. ,. ~w.~m~B'g. ~~~~,m~mR~-1iI~aB'g®~'1:Er • • J~1iI*m~~,.a.~aZOOff 1£~QJ~B'gm~. ,. ~lItiJ 1~7*~fF;g~D~B'gJ~:'!J:tJ[ti]. : 3.

(4) (l)~.JJi~I¥JAAtm~m'~~. ; ¥tUttI¥JM~$;gT ~m~ , ffi]1l!fflJlAAtml¥Jf~m'~~iiP~~IJT (Patterson, 1980) '~~-{lf~1~~ ~~.I¥J~.o • • ~~I¥J*~m~itti~~~.W;gffi• • ?~~~m~~.1¥J r AAtfl'{~m J (E!X; r AAtfl'fRlfJ J )ti~~~~~~I¥J~.~ , ~~/fJJ!m¥a*J£ffij~m ff~ ? tt1.1ZSJ1It ' ~fr'~mUA: r AAtfl'~m J ~ , ~7 .*1C1¥J4• • (media exposure)l¥JmU ,. -EJ.f~3f~~~ Af§1Jlfd:itl¥J~&Jl1. .~~'.JJ!g~A.wm.AAtfl'~ml¥Jr~.hJI¥J~.omtt1.~~~~.mAAt fl'~m~~~'M • •~qm~m~.I¥J~.~IZSJ,ffij~.m~I¥J~~.~tt1.~fi ~fr~. ~*. ,. ••. ~fll¥J~:m~IUtl¥J'~15t~i?lf!l¥J( ~.Mm.fl'jI¥JMrnIi). 0. '~7AAtfl'• •A:~AAtfl'~.hfi~mmm~~~'~~AAtml¥Jg~fi~m. .Mm'lZSJlIt~.~B~m.-~~~~.I¥JAAtm'~3ftt1.~~-EJ • • •ft~m~ ~~~~'~ • • WW~.fi.l¥Jm~~~~~~I¥J~.'IZSJ~*m~~~~AAtfl' ~m~. , t!2.:1JOA 7 ~ • •fl'{~m1JrEJ'~. ~~J{){rEJl¥J¥a*J£) l¥J~it. (~[]~¥frtv.s.~F~¥frt¥lUJ£. '. E!X;~f*~v.s. §. EE. 0. , .m~.I¥J§:~ttJEtJft:;fi~~JJ~~.~~.~~AI¥J~~O ' m~ , m fl~§:~tt.g~W~~?~~.I¥J.m~ • • ~~~~~~• •~M.~~.? ~;lt ~ I¥J ImlfM!'I1:JJ!g~[]{PJM~ ?. (3)t£[]5IH~. MMM®ffi.~l¥Jm~m~,*.w@~m~~m~T:. (1)tJ~i!V\+=~-EJ.tI!rlill¥Jl\Vfm:R~$.{9U. '. =+~tJJ::I¥J~~. , ~*.AAtft1J®. l¥J~mm~~~~?WA+-~I¥J~~~.m~~~;g~~~.? (2)~~I¥J* • •fit~m~15tW~~~o~' ~ • •~ff[]~.fj.~roljl¥JlDI~'~~~[]{PJ? (3)~~it/f~IZSJ.3iflj/f~~.I¥J • • (~¥frt .fj.J::~p1TliI)jU. '. ~F~¥frt)ffij~iI&~~o~. , ~ • • W~~. ?. ~~-EJ.§MI¥J • •~m(M~qm'8 • • ~M).~*8,~~;gm.g~l¥J~. • '. ~IHjjUT-EJ.AAtm~rnIi~rolj~lC{~I¥JPJ~gtt? ~1i]~ml; , -EJ.~AAtm~m'lfj~. ,. ~~i?l7~lCrnIi.,~~m~•• l¥Jml;~?. *m~I¥JJfmjU4*§~~*~~$m~r:p{J\~~\ilIJ82~p1T¥Afj!¥J r~$fj.W-EJ .tfum:I¥J~~~~{~J if~g)ijJ1l 4. 0. mJ'Cflm• • • :ttB~~l\Wim20~tJJ::~i?lf.lt~~ , Ml.

(5) ~~~~ft~fflfim~~~~m~'~.~~W~~fimz~~H~. tl~H~U~1*fJ7tJl:::'~~M*MltlJjJ~U SkJ~~~m~Ml;fJ£. '. '. m-~~;tMl~.mWi. m:::.~~~ut£~~SkJ;fJ£MlI±\{~A. *1iJfJi:pfftimSkJJl*'t~PJffijIDJSkJ1J~1~~. 0. '. m=~~~ut£~~. (tt=). ' ~PEE1iJfJi:HJIj± fif A~WHtIDJ~~9mIDJFI:!'$~ ITll IDJIJ# Fa' EE 1f.J 17 B~2 f.J 16 Bfit-It' ¥AfJIDJFI:!, A~PJ* ~1:;fOtiJfJi:1:~± ' i3~~IDJj§UJII*,* ' ffiLEiPff:ffIDJFI:!'~mSkJFI:!'~W~i&!fl~SkJ-=¥. ' ~ .~~IDJFI:!'fiffrer~SkJFI:!'~~U~ , pff:fffl~I{'F1i~'3f.J20B:fG~ :tt-H~J}].*1394A ' ~tE~IDJ~{ti~.*~50.4% ' :9:"tE~IDJ~~49.6% ' tLUJpgi&g~19921f:-ErIil:ftglilAD~ ~H ' *1iJfJi:~*'tW.£HI11:53U.f::tfjU (~JI1:52.0% ' :9:11:48.0%) SkJ~~.Mz1i:ff~~t ...tSkJ. ~11: (tt==) ~~1iJfJi:~SkJ~m~0.~: r.ft~mJ~ri&~~~JSkJ • • 1J$&~ffl.~ 5<5l::~SkJ~k~O~ : 0. :(£~IDJ~*MlI±\~1&. 0. 0. 0. - ... ~lft{lm1t&lr-Jm~•. •. ft~m7t~~(. • • •~MSkJ.~+ • • •~MSkJ~.~.+~~g~SkJ.~+. ~~~.~.)~IDJ~ti~~m~.§~m~~~~o~~*ti~oo.ft~m~~~fJ ~~~5E. ' YJlU~i:§:~{~~~~:a%~-m[Q]Jftt~SkJ.~ , ~Ufi.IZ§*~fJi\m:*M{J;l.$ -Maximum Likelihood)SkJ~* ' ~m~:rj~1.!ti (load) :(£[Q]-IZ§~ , ~1Z§*1.!ti{rnr (factor loadings)1t<rr;~ • •ffl~MSkJ.~ (.79) , • •ffl~MSkJ~~~.(.85) , M.~~ *J£SkJ.::X(.51) , ~Jf~UJ£SkJ~g~. (.62) '3tfi{~ (Eigenvalue)m2.07428 ' M'-'t! ~1i~51.9% ~~~UK;fOmffl7tOO* ' 1~¥USkJ*s*&1¥IJ::ff:m~ , .~1iJf~~PJ~~*.Lt;fO .~SkJ • • • ~~.~~.mD.~*SkJ.ft~.~~~':ff~1iJfJi:...tSkJ5<5l::.o 0. =.. iI1l5# ~n ~ Ir-J JAY. ~~i&~~~SkJ~m~~:~I±\~.~ffSkJ.±8~~,~m~ff.~~~'&~ .~ff±8~~'~~.~fJi&~.~g~~~-MH[Q].~~ff.,~-mM~:ff.. , ±Ji~~ • • SkJ~• •~'~.~~'~W~~I±\-oo~m~~m~.SkJ~.~i&~~~~ • • ' ~iltHiH~*SkJ#5~ (tt~ ) M~.$~.limFI:!U!. 0. ~.SkJYJlIj.~~m~~'HJf~~i&~~~SkJYJlIj.::f[Q]. 0. *tiJfJi:~SkJri&~~~J~~~...t~li.~~i&~~m~.SkJ~Mm~,.~ti. .-~'~~li.~mm:~~~--li~,m:~~~7t'~~li.~rer~~:fG~::f~~o ~{§.t~5E. (reliability test). Alpha{~~.7980. SkJ~*mi7fr. ' YJlUlI. ri&~~D~J SkJlimFI:!'.~Cronbach. 0. 5.

(6) #rmil&:lt~Hf¥JmU:lU1i. '. ~il&*~~H}fYi:cp,~\ § ~m. ~tJ*' JIf:?x~.1iJfYi:f¥J~. ~B'~~.~~.~'*1iJfYi:~~~mZo. ~. ,. iH~(j{J*~~1t1£m~)~. (~~811F~~~821F~*~ZJt~ ) ~~f¥J*~~-lfr~mM15L. fTMW §. '. !&ff~'~ID = ~~{51*MIDfij. -aJtJ5t(1)¥~*~oom*(2)=iJ!&ff~'~ID(3)=iJtJ7I-Z~ff~. :. ~.lMffl'~~~ftEOO~~OO,~.cpm~ft'~~ft~.~,m*ft~~* f¥JOO.*~~~~~~~,m*ftf¥JOO~*fuffi~.~'~~~~ffif¥J~~#~~~Wo ~m~.f¥J~~*M.~nft~Mf¥J§~~ft,~mm-~~OO~*~~7=OO§5tE (tE5.1%¥U7.3%). f¥J~~. ,. 0. ffij~{i!11®J~'11: (ffij~F~m'l1:) {~#*~8"J¥~*~. ,. -aJfj~~~flBt~ft!!1®. ~~m81~W~m82~Zra9#~*~j~I¥J~1fJ (~DiJmft!!m:8"J cp~ E3 ¥~W~.. :L1!!1®l¥JiJ.~¥~) '{§'~.~OO~*I¥J~{~~~*. 0. ~2~.ffl7=iJ.OO~MI¥J!&~ffiIDo=iJ.OOfTM!&.ffiID'ill~iJ~fTM8"J !&~*.~,~~~~~,cp~fTM:?XZ'~#=~~~'~~• • '~#-~=~~ f¥J!&ff~*. 0. W~m81~f¥Jjl;jSHEl~. ~. J ~~ r ~{i!1J. ,. ~m82~f¥J~1tjl;jS!.fl. '. #~~f¥J~~~~7. rim. 0. iJ.~~~~~*.*.~.m~~I¥J~§EK.~'~~iJ.~.I¥J.~• • • £mff~iJ (TVBS) ~1992~IE~~fltJiJfllfi~~::t:f¥JfTMW§. ~flte. '. ,. ~#• • ~I¥J.m. Wf~ft!!1Jf¥J*~~if~ ({iH~m~iJ) iPJ9ltv1~!lfTM$r~~flfTM. '. ~~=. iJ~7I-I¥J.~fTMW§!&~ffiID'fu~H~g~I¥J.Eo~.3W~4M~,~~m~~ IWHn*~.Mra9.~:lz:~11H~:u.;:I¥J • • m~iJ r ~~~ff~iJ J W§~#8.6%. (tin) ,. ~~ r • • • £miJ J l¥J.ra9fTMW§~#4.7% ,.~~::t:iJ.&.ft!!~fTW§~~U5tIJU# 6.5%.&.2.7%. 0. ~~I!(• •ffl. '. ~~mB~~~,@tJW~#fI~jl~f¥J=iJfTMfElmOO. {§'~~1Nmf¥J~ra9~1N~~:mM.*f¥Jl\l~M. '. B11"f¥J~WjJill~~~;mff~. 0. *f!t8"J*~. ' ,. .~~# • •m*~~~M.~f¥J~~,~~n5tZ-'**~~• •~*'ill~~m lJ!~o. 6.

(7) ~~~~~mff~&~~m~~'~.~~W~~ff~z~~H~ ~l. R;~81!rfWR;~82!rfil.tt!!lii~R;¥!Uj£OO~$zJt~7tm ~~81ifzOO~$. *5JU 9~!W* ~i:l* 9~B*. ifzOOlll$. 82. 21.9% 21.8% l. 2% .3% .5% 3.2% 3.5% .5% .1% 3.0% 5.1% 1.3% .9% .6% .1% .1% 2.0% .1% .7% .9% .1% .1% .1% .1% 32.4%. §:lL!f.* Iim!W* K~B*. ~1:*. ~~B*. 11fifS* ~.!W*. §E8ffif* ~~i:l~*. 9!W~* §:lL~*. *nIG*. *H1:*. 9~Bm ~.!Wm. ~.*IYl* 9~~m ~.S*. ~.*~*. mlffiS*. :;t:zp.~B* /f~,Jtfjg. kl;fO. 1523 ~2. ~m. A. 100.0%. 20.6% 20.8% l.5% .4% .2% 3.3% 2.4% .2%. 0%. 2.6%. 7.3%. 1.6%. 1. 0% .4% .2% .2% .8% 2.6% .5% .1% .1% 0% .1% 0% 35.4% 1394. A. 100.0%. R;~81!rfWR;m82!rf~.MrdJ'='ilIl5M,,~~~1&ff~ltM~. ~mw.~. 81182~*. 811828 5:fJt. ~if!W.. Jtfjg,t13/f~. 647/ 321/ 197/ 1751 183/. 619 302 176 74 223. 42.5%/ 44.4% 21. 1%/ 2l. 7% 12.9%/ 12.6% 11.5%/5.3% 12.0%/ 16.0%. kl;fO. 1523. A /1394 A. 100.0%. 9iil $mw. ==~t13~. 7.

(8) ~~~~:~~.~~(_~m~~). 119 A. (rVBS). 65 A 90 A 37 A 5A 4A 1A. _~~£.~. ~±11~~ :f1g:1:Jm~~ j\:I~ cp ~ 11i:1. B:t$: NHK ~~CP)[~. ~4. ~~~~M~~.~(&~~~. mi&i~f.i~:. mi&i-=f.i~: ~~i&i. Kmffi. •• ). A~. s7tJt. 287A 19A 14A 1075A. 20.6% 1.3% 1. 0% 77.1%. 1394 A. 100.0%. ~~m~~~~lr'iEl mi&i-f.i~:. 8.6% 4.7% 6.5% 2.7% .3% .3% .1%. ffi'm~~*~.aoom~~,a~~~. , a.1i~t!Qti=~TaZID1~. ••a~mM~,a~~~.a.~w~~m.ffi~~~Z~fio~~. &~.R~m~.mr~m.~~.~+~~.~~~.m~+ •••~M~.~+. ~5m*. m~~M~~~m~JZ~~o.R~m~.~~~,~~~m.R~~.~~~'~ .fj,~ttL1l1l~. 0. ra~~f1~J J1Um1im~~a~~u~~rr=l~m, fi~Jj-m-7t,. tlOIlt:m. ' ~~m1i~ , ~~1im~Jj , ~{~m~~ , ~~1im~rer (WG~%~::f1it~) ra.~~f J ~JjJ1Um~.~~~, ~:sz:~&~., ~.~{~~, ~:sz:~~&.. ft~c7t. 0. 0. ;f.N~~JIH*;f§~{*.~fi~~. ,. ~Jttfr{~m~ • • a~~O~g\G~~IE;f§~ (r=.56, p<. 001) ,m~~Jj.R.~.~.~,a~~~~~ttL~~oa.~~*~ M~ 8. ,. .1m~mWa~~O~ZF~~IEOOIm{*. '. -rf=iJ'MM:9immJE. 0. ••m~.. tJ&~81~~=mtrr~.

(9) ~~®~ft~mtr~&~~~~~'~.~~W~~tr~zOO®~~. m• •ffi~%.:.k~m~.,a~~D,a • • W~~tt~~~ (~1@82:q::~* ). ~5. ~ft~mftlf(. JJ;Z~~~. JJ;Z.~frT. ~ft~m:5t1f(. ~~~iift. .56 *** -.11 ***. ~.im~. -.08 **. * ftlf(~r\WJ~~3Z::fi'j ~~. p<'OOl. ** p>.Ol. ***. f**~ 1523A.. ~*~'Wll. '. AAtk~m7t.Wam~DmlH~7tJj\~mI~lE1Hi~{*' (r=.58, p<.OOl). .k~m~If(Wa._~rglGj'!t1HiIlJl{*' (r=-.l1, p<.OOl). ,~{{;~~~m. 0. (±:1Jii). J1t1i- ' .Il~. m~.~~~,~a.~~~~~.W&~.'W~~&~.~~~,~am~.~~ ~ :1J1Hi{J;( :P~{~ (r=-.08, p<.O 1). (tl7\). 0. ~'~~~m~~~~~~~'~~fi.~~~ ~D~lW~. , tt.1t!!liIl¥J~~~*~~~ft~mM7\¥£:1J1Hi ' *~~~i15J;Jm*¥~ (~-g-¥~ , ~1@~.)W=* • • • ~tt(tt,~,.~).±:o*~• • ~~~ttm,~~a~ m.fi.~~~.~.wom-mm~~~.ft.m*D~.~ft{~,~~ • • m$a ~~~m.~~~.~~~~,~a~~~~ • •~m~~~.~~~o~J1t-*,~ *AAtft~~~~rMfiJ~@.~~~~A,[email protected]~fi~¥~. ffi8:!J ' ~U~~~~{~~A7J~~.~B~~?7J~[] , ~.&~a~$ll.W mi!§~. -t;). , {gk§AAtft~g~ttmW5!il~ • • '. 0. ~~!¥~WjrJl. BP.$:~~:f;t!!:JJ[]J;JC5<:*. '. '. !ijE~{~~. ~~m=~~ (ti. 0. k§J1t'fi• •~r.k~m~If(Jm.*W'B~~~MWa • • W~OO~~%' ~~JHi~~3X1"r~~N1 ~D~6~~~.7t~~~~~;fft)£j5JT~ , ~ft!3Ul~.~.W:1f ' ;!t .k~m~If(ML.mI~~J5U ' &W~@]~~M r ~:lz:J W r tE~ , ~~D J ~~~ , {t!!1"r~ 0. ~AAtft~m7tIf(Wm@~ft!3Ula._W~~~~AAt.~m~lf(tt~*'~ffi~m¥*, W'§'1~7t.{i£. 0. , ~~fJl~~{j\~~W~*~~~ , JJJijgm~~fJl~rJ& ' l2SIJ1tm!/i5(1i~a~mI~a • • w~~~~~ , ~W~1@81:q:::lz:~. ~{J;(:p'S-m3X1"r~. 115CW~'I1fifl3l1J1l¥J~~ftjlm. 9.

(10) ' :;g:~~rrJ. ~~1i}f~l¥Jft:fJ!. 0. 1£i&m{.ffiCPI¥J::f~D::fjf;:lf (chronic know-nothings). ,. ill~1£.m*~~.~~ffi.l¥Jtt~'~~i&m.Wffi.~~o ~~,a~&ftm'1£~~.i&~~ffl¥J.~CP'U~~~I¥J.~.ft~ffl~.~. ( 12.1498) '~~~.:lf~l=: (11.4392) B ~=:lfl¥Jm ••• ~.~~N~m*::f~,m~m••• ~l¥Jm.~~ill~~~7~ • ••mms~*I¥J-®i&m •• ~~'~~~-*I¥JB.(ttA) 1£.ft~ffl~.Wi&~~~ff~I¥J~ •• ~fi~@'~~6m~, r::f~::f~:lfJ ~{OO:lli~. ( 12.4179). '~~~.:lf~z.. 0. 0. W~~~~/~~~,m~.I¥J.~'1£~ft~ffl~.~OO'~M~l¥Jm~o~~~~. .1¥J.~'1£~ft~ffl*.~@'&W~~~.I¥J.~'~~~I¥J::f~o*~OO§'~ f,¥~.WG~.~:lfI¥J~.{~ffl~.~f.b (12.6622) 'OOf1.'~~::fIlMI~\1¥J. *. ${. *Jl rJl *Jl pq ~. m. ElEBf.!t. zP:1JfD. t!J:1J. 4. 4462.7080. 1115.6770. 1389. 29943.5489. 21. 5576. 1393. 34406.2570 p. im. ~zp. H. im. im. fflt!J. JJU. 7}{rnI. ~ ~. ~ ~. 10. im~~.. 12.1498. im~~_. im*_. 51. 7532. Jl&lftimHJ.m. ~. fr. 19:. F{rnI. <.001. . JI&. r ::f~D::f1t:lf J. --. .* im. $. ~. --L... ~. J.L. ,. :J'§ ~. *. *. 11. 4392. *. *. ·12.4179. *. *. cpft. 9.5339. ~~,t§~. 6.2637. *.

(11) ~~!¥J~fI~Jf.jf=r~N:Jtil&rEl~~. ~7. , iI&.imHW~:~H=r~~FEll!¥JID1~. ~m82:tf.~m~~!Jt~~~::f~iI&:W:~~1£~frf~m7tILt8{J~~7tm. *. ElEl3gr. ${. ~1JfD. i$]1J. Ffit. ~Jl. FEll. 4. 1882.4449. 470.6112. ~Jl. pg. 1389. 32523.8121. 23.4153. ~. l1t. 1393. 34406.2570 <.001. p - -. 20.0985. - -. _ ... -. -. --. -. -. ~1f!~5E. ~. ~~~. ~. ~r--.. fI. ~fW. ~~. 73'. •. .. If(. '-'. ~~.. 11. 6016. ~jl.. 10.4645. iifi./• •. 12.6622. 15i~~~. 9.0215. :tg~. .. if. Jf.ji$] 73'fit. :~. ill. ~. ~. jl. &. :fg. ~. ~. *. *. *. *. /. • •• *. 9.3286. - -. --. ~.1le:m7tl9:{,iiHl£. -_ .. _ - - -. . . '------------. (9.0215W9.3286). *' ....~. 'ffiLEiWm7t~::g~jg~*. ;rb .... A lr:n ~ /-EI ..a.. t;!i;l. ~ iBi '--. Q. ....,.. 0. GlliI Bti. .u;;.x. ic ~H iiU fv n ~ 1X m 'f"J J,;;fJ '<"IWJ '1~fI. iI&~~~~7tWil&~&~fi.Z~~,*.~w.fr~m~.~&~fi.Z~~g. ~o~~8M~'~~~~~M~ • • ~~~'1£iI&~~~8{J~~~.~'W~$X~ t~~.8{J~~iI&~~D~1~~ZP::!$]fWIm:~. (2.5). 1ID~~~. 5~mm:~~). 'm~.~~::vzz. - (2.3045) f§~@]~~~I&[Q]~~~ , 1£pJT1'f8{J~~$ , ~ (1.5429.) I ::f~D::ffl~ J W~m~:M=:lt.8{J~~1:EiI&~f=r.:n. ,~jlt.~~m. iI&~~D~1~~1lifl£8{J. (ZfS:!$]fWI=3.1'. , fI}-::VZ1~¥UE[J~. 0. 0. 0. 11.

(12) ~. *. *,fi. ElEBIJt. ZfI1Jffi. ~1J. F{[li. 2l. 9672. rJ3~. 4. 259.5245. 64.8811. j7g. 1389. 4102.4812. 2.9536. km IT. 1393. 4362.0057. *,fi. p. ~. <.001. ~~~. i5l:. m. ~,,-.... *il"ID'J. ~ZfI. ~. ~~ 5t{[li ~. 5t ~. . ~. ~ ~. ~. . .. ~. jft. &. :f§. ~. ~. /. ~. .... ~~.. 2.5000. *. ~jft.. 2.3045. •. ~./mtl:. 3.1000. &$:~~. 2.9055. te~//f:m. 1.5429. *. *. *. •• -ft*~ftM'.-~)Wffi~~fflfi.~ ~~~OO'~~ •• A.~~.~Em~~*~•• OO~••IDo¥§OO.~'*.~ ~.ft~mm~~ftfi'.~~.ft~m •••~.r~NJ~~.~m.ow~~. ft~~mr~~J ' •• ~W~~~.~~~,~•• ~~.o~~~~.~~OO.ID ~~-&~~*~.BOO~IDn(. nW~$&~~*.~m.g~.ID'~~~~Aftfi~~.o gUltff~if~~gllTtl*m. '. -=*~ff~-Er~!&ff~.KmfD~78.7% (~2) '~llir,;t~m'. ~1!tU!.ff~ -ErifliflfJj § ~!&ff~m.f.l. ' -=- -Er1JJ~~~~JJ{§~~~{:v:. 0. ~~{~tzDOOpJTiI!t. '. §M~~m~~~~~~~Iifl~§W-=--Er~~,m~ft~~m~~ft~~~Wm~-Er~ 12.

(13) ~~8"J.fH1t!m1Tm&;t!;j1ilaEl~~ , iJ&.~HW~~1TmZrJj8"JIifiI~~ ~&~J:. '. ff~~Iifl~mMz::fq;~{jIfi¥-f5jUB"J~~ (tift). tE¥~*aoo~~}joo. 0. {[l[1~1It{m'i~B"J~~t~W¥~*a*s-2IB"Jf].~. '. , t)&M~¥Jff¥~~m. .~ff~B"J~.o~.9ffi~'~.~~B"J~MOO~m.'~Uffl~~M~ffi.B"J~*. *{'FiU?t. 0. t)cpm~¥~. ,. cp~Il$M&. '. :~Uwf~t*{m~mOO¥~AD~U~32.3%. .9. I~~¥&m:i:B"Jcp~¥&*OO~~*WfD~20.4% (~D. '. .10) ,t)~-2I¥&" ~-21~¥~. " ~~ B¥~ " ~~. ~m82if:~.~Wi¥~*l£OO~~?tftH~ID (~m~oom¥~*l£~) ~[I] 53U /. ¥IUlU. ' cj:11l$tl , Iiiti ~~.g-~*/~~.g- , ~~Il$tl , ~~ cj:lfRf~*/r:pfRf. %. ~fJ{%. 285 353. 20.4 25.3. 20.4 45.8. 116. 8.3. 54.1. 84 44. 6.0 3.2. 60.1 63.3. 512. 36.7. 100.0. Aft(. ~1::.. En±!~*/§83fRf~' *~~ §:lz:!f!.'Il$tl~ ;t!;ftlvJ\~/ ~~. , -afRf. ~~/cj:15R:'cj:1$'*1::.~. -aifl*j}fl~ ~~" f§~ .g-~t. 1394. _*ft( 1394A. .10 ~m82if:.=:.*¥~~mt~glT'twID (fm~-a-OO¥~AD ) ~[I]53U/~53U. cj:1fRf~*/cj:1fRf'cj:1Il$tl'Iiiti ~~.g-~*/~.g- '~~Il$tl ,~~. Aft(. %. ~fJf%. 285 353. 32.3 40.0. 32.3 72.3. 116. 13.2. 85.5. 84 44. 9.5 5.0. 95.0 100.0. ~1::.. §EI3~*/§EI3fRf~'*~~ §:lr!f!.'Il$tl~ ;t!;ftf!/J\~/ ~~. , -afRf. .~/cj:15R:,cj:1$'*1::.~. 882. i'1H ~_*If(. 100%. 1394A 13. /".

(14) ¥lsH~:1:I¥J~-g-~*OO~$~~~25.3% (1J!1g~OO¥~AO~40%). 'lli1f:*~~~i¥J S EI3. ~*,~sEl3~~'*~~~~lli.~l¥Jsft~*(sft.~.sft~~)a:1:'~OO. (tt+) cp~ , ~-g-.S EI3¥~*I¥JOO~ $ , *'!tjJD~*~54.1% ' ~D*fl*x1g~OO~AO ' J{U~*¥~*1¥J~1~H~~flOO¥~~iTf~ 1¥J85.5% ! a.¥~lIIl¥Jglf'I1:~~{§'~M ' ffijiiill~glf!f,!j:tt ' ~~§IDfH~FJjI¥J~W~ a7*~ ffij~*¥~m.:5tZ1&i¥J/J\¥~ (~D~J5AB¥~.a.~¥~) iTf~ , ~OO~$~fD~~ ~$*'!tfD~8.3% (f1ii1g~OO¥~AO~13.2%). 0. 0. ~U+:5tZ-. 0. .~*,a~~~~~~~m. ••. r.~Ji¥JM~,.afflfia~~~tt:5tmo. ~,~~rB~J~~~mm~~~~~~~~9. ,. iE1r:i;fi~t. '. ~~={jm;ZrB~~/HJ~. 1£:1:mt/;}F:1:mt¥~*~I¥JOOgft#j\15LJnm. ' afm~¥~*~OOm~l~mm~~[Q]I¥J1J$jJDtJ. ~:5t'~ii~m~~~:5tm*~~[Q]I¥J~:5t1J$,~~~~~[Q]I¥J~~~*?m-~1J $~~¥~*~OOMf~~tJ¥&lIIf!F~:5t (~CP~¥~*~. , 9t~-g-¥~*~ ...... ~). ,m=~1J. $~~~.OOgft~~~:1:./#:1:mt~.E:5to~~~r~.I¥JR~~J~a~:5tl¥Jm. .,.~~r§IDfHRN.~~J~a~:5ti¥Jm.,:5tm~*~~:. ' ~D*tJ¥~*J\:I¥JR~~ , fu~~tJ~[Q]i¥J¥~lIIjJDtJWi:5t ' J{Uft;frraJtJ~ ~'~~~OO~~.I¥J~~'1£affl~~.:5tI¥J~~M~~~OO~~.~*•• ~~~ ~D~l1?1T7f:. (m~~ffi~~) offijOO~~[Q]~~/~~I¥J~~'1£affl~~.:5t1J®~.M~i¥J~. •• ft(~CP*B~'CP.B~)i¥J.~,~affl~~.:5t~~ {~~~ (3.3182) 'S EI3/ S J'r.¥~IIII¥J~~::XZ (2.9848) ,~-g-¥~* (2.8159) .CP m ~¥~ (2.7754) i¥J~~1{}:5t~{~ (ti+-) ~D*tJ¥&*~i¥J § IDfB RN.pg ~~:5t~~ , J!u~~~:5tml¥J~*.~®I¥J~~~.* EUo~.I¥J~OO~m~. 0. *1¥J~[Q]o~~um7f:,~~w~.~~1£affl~~I¥J.:5t~~B~~~,~~~[Q]~ .1¥J~~'1£affl~~I¥J.:5t~~~.~~~I¥JB~~~,ffij~~I¥J.:5tm~,.~. .~*[Q]~~omM7f:m.IDfB~~r~~R~~J~~ft~l¥Jr§IDfHRNJ*~:5t~~ I¥Jr.~J~r.~J. 'W~~~~W~~l¥Jaffl~~.:5to. 1£.~~~I¥J~~#j\15L1J®'W.~[Q].~a~~I¥J.J5A'1£affl~~.:5t1J®' ~.lt~B~l¥Jm~ (~13). 0. fi:m~.aff~~~.I¥J.ff~.J5A. ' 1£affl~D~1{}:5t1J® ' ~. •• ~~MI¥J.J5A~~-@,.~*~~m.m~m~~M.l¥Jo~~,&~~~ ~ff~~. (.=. am.~~~~.) I¥J~IDJ~ , .jG~~.llff~~~~ , 1£am~D~1{}:5t 1: CP~. 14.

(15) ~~~~fr~fflff~&~~~m~'~~~~W~~ff~z~~~~. ~11. ~mr82fF~m*~~OODY::f[P]¥~~¥&*1£~~1£i6l:tEi~DimH~7tl:1¥J~JH-}m. *. §E8~. ~. ~1J;fO. l$j1J. Filii 100.0830. *Jl rJJ *Jl ~. 5. 1155.8969. 231.1794. 1388. 3206.1088. 2.3099. ~. 1393. 4362.0057. gt. p. <. 001. -. ~jf~)E. M-----. 1&. ~ j;). ~~. ~ m~ ~¥.D t~f~. l.lU :5t. :5t. ~~. *£till ......,. I. M~fliH~£Uyt~U. r:p. ~. §. ~ ~. L>. EE. ~. /. / IJ\. *. §. ~~. -L.. '*. *. ~. il~ ~ftP.. J.L. ~. ~. ~. /. ~. m ~. r:p~~*. 2.7754. ~~J§"~*. 2.8159. *. §E8/§::V:. 2.9828. *. il~/~,* ~ftP./J\~. 2.8214. .~. 3.3182. *. .9727. *. *. /f~/lB~. m~1f[J!!]~J&ff~~~{~. 0. ffiJjG~::f~~I¥J7t1$l:. , ~::fliZ.Y5i1f~~!&ff~~'tI~I¥J=7t2.-. 0. .~~l:7tm'~~.~'~*.~i6l:~~mW~m.*E.::f[p] • • I¥J~¥~.. tt'~~ffi.::f~o~~i6l:tEi~mR~• •~*I¥J-$a'M~~~~~-~~D • •. •. ~m~gWi6l:.~~&m=fi~2.00I¥J~.o. ~.MI¥J~X7tmM~'OO~::f[p]r.~J.~I¥J~~'1£i6l:.~~~~'1fB.. 1¥J::f[p] tJOOm.:tYm¥UI£ 0. ~:;;~1f1O.3%. '. (r:p~W.~¥&~¥UI£) ~~{jIJ ' ~~~.~1f39.8%. ~if.~1f7.1%. ' -Gf:M'r:p:V:~1f37.9%. 0. OO~~F.:tt"it¥&*J£. '. ~~. ( El:V: ' El 83 ' 15.

(16) 31(. ~. *,ll. r~. ZJS1JfD. ElE8$:. f$)1J. F1fil 125.3554. 4. 1156.9928. 289.2482. *.§. pg-. 1389. 3205.0129. 2.3074. ~. 1393. 4362.0057. ~. p. <.001. OOllI¥~UI£~5JU. jJ&. 00---. 1lI J;J. rEi. ¥f1mE. ~zp:. ±. ~~ ~liI. ~f$). mE. ~F. 1~1fil. /. 5JU :fr. :fr. .:t: Vti. q:r~. . ~. 11\. =1'. ~. ~. IR1I!fd. '-". .:t:Vti/q:r1R1 ~~ir. *. 2.7978. ~F.:t:mt/. Elffi¥'.1%~. ElE8'El:lr. 2.9333. *. jtft!JJ1\~. 3.3182. *. .~. 2.2000. =1'~/1§~. .9727. affi'fW~~~JZ:!3/J\¥R) I¥J~~. , {~'jUl(J~.~ft!J27.2% ' ~.±:mt¥HIH'~:P12.6% ' ~~~ .~ft!J25.6% ' ~.±:mt¥&*J£.~~tB 15.3% ' i\jH~T.~ft!J2.6% ' ~.±:mt¥&~JU.~:P4.5% ' CP}'[~40.5% ' ~.±:mt¥&~~~~~2.6% mf~.3fmf7F ' ~7~fiivJ\¥RW~~ • • ¥RI¥J~ ~~j} , OO~.±:mt¥R*J£I¥J~~ , ~1m.;fF.±:mt¥R*J£ (~JZ:!3/J\¥R) 1¥J~~3Z:t~~~.W$JT .owoom#.±:mtfttil¥J~~'*~CP},[.~&3Z:~~ • • ~~~oWN~OOft~.~ ~~ , 1£iI&.~~f:1Jrnf*~CPJLI¥Jl:t:~J-ti1;fFm~ (48.2%) jZgltt ' Im~JFfl8J~~¥U~ 0. 0. ~~~'1£iI&.~~~~DWI¥J~l8Jo. ~15.PJTmf7F1¥J 16. '. ~IlVg=-a$JTIY1WiI&.fJii~~xX7ttJT. '. -+:1J{!5E*~*mf7F' r ~.

(17) ~.B!;I¥J~fr~ffl f=fm :&.Jtii&tEl~~. ~ 13. , ii&:W:~H cW:5t;m:f=rm zrEflI¥JIOIl~~. ~~82-4l11*rfH~:~!f!~.:::: 'Ei'~$mrmZ~~:(£i&m~D~1~7t l:1¥J~~7tffT. *. ~. *Jl. ra~. 4. *Jl. pg. IT. ~. i$j:1J. F1ffi[. 662.8369. 165.7092. 62.2221. 1389. 3699.1689. 2.6632. 1393. 4362.0057. §EEJ3£. ZP::1JfD. p ---. -. <.001. -. ~W~JE lfiliTiW.if~5JU. ii& tEl. If ~. ..L>. Cl. ~. ~zP: ~J:$J ~1ffi[. 5JU. 5t. iiiW.. iTiW. if. c:p. ¥. ~ ~. /f'. / /f'. iiiJ!. iiiW.. -. ~. JE. •. 2.2682. •. *. 2.2727. •. *. ffrYI.. 2.6704. c:p. iiiJ!. ¥. iiiW.. ~~//f'-JE. ~. .... -. .. .. .7085 '--. -. ... •. 1.5676. If. /f' --. •. ..L>. Cl. ._'Ei'Jwr • • -.JzOO~D~l¥Jg~o.~mrml¥Jfi~.~~.l¥Jtt~.~( 45.5%) ,t:pmmrml¥Jfi~~z (40.7·%) ''Ei';jiJimlifjl¥Jfi~!ilf£ft,~1&' fE!.~tf1.~32.6 % 'Ei'ff~mlifjl¥Jfi~{Aj;~j! • .ttfYUiIi5E~ ( 17.3%) '':::: 'Ei'm~4'!~z ( 13.5%) , ¥mm lifjfi~.p (3.4%) ~.rEf;;I{r.ma)r:r.ff~mMI¥JJ&ff~~tI ' WilDc• • H,@",~,;f§mI ffiJ !ilf£ft,fi.'Ei'~W • •{Aj;H~g'fE!.~-ft*~,.mmMl¥Jfi~~~~~.~,m~* ~l{ro~~~.~~'W • •ffi.z~'.::::'Ei'l¥Jg~ttM~fE!. • • ~m'~~.R~& 0. 0. 0. ~~~~o~~~~J&~~tll¥Jrm~Jwrm~~J~,:(£~~w~j!m.I¥J.H~. 00 '. ~Jl§&ffiJli/J\. 0. ~16.00m~rq]~~~fl*~Wt~~1'J,$I¥J~JZ.7tm. *~fl~,K) ~,$fYU. '. 1~~~.f~~.A.~~38.9%. '. 0. J;JOO~±:im~fl~,K. ~~~.:1f~14.6%. ( $~W~-2r~fl '~m.:1f~8.2% ' 17.

(18) i61:.im~/1J!I1I. 5JU. 5JU. ±:?1rE~~. ~F±:?1rE~~. .~. ;K:ft!!JJ\~. (n=638). (n=195). (n=44). (n=5). /f'~. (n=512). ~~~.. 39.8 %. 27.2 %. 68.2 % 40.0 %. 21.5 %. im~~.. 10.3 %. 25.6 %. 4.5 % 20.0 %. 11.1 %. ~fT.. 7.1 %. 2.6 %. im/f'im/cj:JJ'z:. 39.7 %. 40.5 %. t8~. 4.9 %. 4.1 %. X 2 =179.07587. 4.5 %. 0. %. 22.7 % 40.0 % 0. %. D.F.=16. 0. %. 1.4% 48.2 % 17.8 %. P<.OOI. tJ~. cj:Jji. tm/f'~. (n=302). ¥ ji (n=176). tm~. (n=619). (n=74). (n=223). im~~.. 32.6 %. 40.7 %. 45.5 %. 17.6 %. 13.9 %. im~~.. 17.3 %. 9.9 %. 6.3 %. 13.5 %. 8.1 %. imfT.. 5.2 %. 5.0 %. 3.4 %. %. 2.7 %. tm/f'im/cj:JJ'z:. 38.4 %. 39.1 %. 40.9 %. 54.1 %. 50.2 %. t8~. 6.5 %. 5.3 %. 4.0 %. 14.9 %. 25.1 %. i61:. im~f /. ~I!Y~ .L>.. 5JU. I=l. x 2 =159.47776. D.F.=16. ( 13:lr ' 13 EE '. P<.OOI. ~*~~1!HH1.8%. 0. m~.~{521.0%. ~~mt:¥Ul£.~Y17.9% '~~3it.~{530.8% '~~mt:¥Ul£~~~. te 16.6% '. '. M.~F~mt:~*l£. 0. ~ff:f;~{54.6%. ~~xYJO.5%. 0. '. ~~mt:¥&*1£~~Y3.6%. Ei'1f,fYt!~~~[g/J\¥&) ~~~. '. ~*~~~lHO.3%. '. ,. ~. ~~mt:¥&*l£. ~lItz9i-. ~.~l:t:fjIJt!?f§'i'iWi. ' fJt{l'H!?J}f~ , ~J~mt:¥&*l£~~~z9i- ' .¥&~.~N:m (52.3%) '~F~mt:&~f!j1JJ\¥&~~~~~it.~~~J{U~~' ff:f;. ~~:m~J{U*mHt~±mt:¥&*l£~.~. 0. .n~~.=Ei'ff~.~.fi~~~X~mo~~.~M.a~, r.~_Ei'JYt!. r N:I!Y~-:i; J 18. ZFMHfa~~IRI~. 0. rpfflYiffM~&~~m$';:W;~l:t:fjIJAf,1b. (41.1%) '¥fflYi. r.

(19) ~~~~ft~mfi~&~a~~~,a.~~w~~~z~~H.. ~ 16. ~1!II~/lillll~M. --.. 53U. OO~¥IU.EUp~~~lHT~~3(J(.?t:fJT. .:Emr:~~. ?F.:Emr:~~. .~. (n=638). (n=195). (n=44). ~fili/J\~. 1'~. (n=5). (n=512). ~~~.. 38.8 %. 2l.0 %. 52.3 % 20.0 %. 28.3 %. ~~~-.. 14.6 %. 30.8 %. 11.4 % 40.0 %. 18.2 %. ~if.. 8.2 %. 4.6 %. &~~~. 1l.8 %. 10.3 %. 1'~/t§~. 26.6 %. 33.3%. x2= 81.34205. ~17 ~[!B~-./~[!B~ ,L... t=I. 4.5 %. %. 3.1 %. 2.3 % 40.0 %. 13.1 %. 29.5 %. D.F.=16. 0. 0. 37.3 %. %. P<.OOl. J&~.ff~iTIVJW:l)tI!Y~-.~3(J(.?t:fJT -tJ~. cp~. (n=619). (n=302). =m~. =m1'~. (n=176). (n=74). (n=223). ~. ~. ~~~.. 34.4 %. 4l.1 %. 37.5 %. 20.3 %. 17.9 %. ~~~.. 21.0 %. 15.2 %. 13.1 %. 20.3 %. 17.5 %. ~if.. 5.2 %. 7.6 %. 9.7 %. 4.1 %. l.8 %. ~9.$:~~. 1l.3 %. 8.6 %. 12.5 %. 8.1 %. 18.4 %. ffi~. 28.1 %. 27.5 %. 27.3 %. 47.3 %. 44.4 %. X. 2= 8 1 . 1 5 0 4 6. ~M~B~~Z(TI5%) ~.~.tt{JIJfi{~. ( 17.9%). ;g~ J ~~ (20.3%). D.F.=16. P<.OOl. '~~~M~B~~.(~A%) 'W-~.~.~,:l)tM~ 0. ~ff~iTM~B~~M~~.~.ttWJjfi~ (21%) , r -=~.. '~ff~ifM~B~~M~~.~~p (13.1%). 0. ~,*S~ *~~~±~~m~~?tm~$?t*~~:. 19.

(20) , fl(;fFraJtJ~J~ , ~fllil1l'~ml¥J~jj]'fj:?F1¥H~ ,. f:t~~~~814:lr~~~W~~824~rfH~:~~~~I¥J~~1I'~JfHt~. ~~j:~f~ml¥Jlilft. '. 1JJtx~:*:¥~W-=-~mff!ftfffifjmj:. 0. ~-I¥JR~~-=-4*~~.~ • • W~~I¥J~~~.'~*h~.~T'-4~~~~ TM~§~~I¥JM~$'WH.~~~l¥Jm~oW-=-~m~fffifj~~~$~~m~,~. mM~~j\:ai1faJPJW~lffi~~m!Z!3~1!W~m~~I¥J'tt~~T. '. J!~liif*TBI¥J~W~~. 0. ~m~.~E~ • • ~~.~W1!W~.~lila~MT*$~~Mmm.'ffi~B~~~ g~~m~'fu~~~~W*~~m'f:t~§~~OOW~~~m~~I¥J~.'~~~~ ~To. , ~~m~~~~ r ~~D~jt=%f J (chronic know things) ,~~ :1J1ID~1~~m~{JiiH~I¥J{tj~ {9IJ~O ' ~1I'~m~~W~m~DID1M4~fi{~ tf' ML::f~~~¥-i~.~~JtM'tf ' w~m~J.t~m~~~{J'I¥JA ~U~O ' ¥~~30% 1¥J~~::f;g,~*1l£' ~lO%tJ~~~~::f;g.ff~' fu~m~w:~~~~~*~~, ~~ r::f ~~.~E~JOOI¥J~m~~r:p. 0. 0. ~~.=%fJW-H~~~M.~.K*,~~fl(;~~-~~~o. _ ' ~fBlj:i1'~ r ti~ J ~IGr-.H~~. , 1fiEi5fl~~~af';} J:M!.lmli~5J1j , {8. ~1fiEi~~B_~=fi.J:~~lmli~~: M~::f~r~~J.~~~tf'Wft;g::f~.~~fffifj~ftw:,~~m~~I¥J~~. ML1!WBlf~.. 0. 1!WIDfIj~tJ r'&lWIm~tf J ~~.*1l£1¥J ra~R~J *lii~,~~J£1¥J rYfrt:~J. (j:Yfrt:v.s.?Pj:Yfrt:) ~ r ~~ J ('~lWIv.S.lJ\'~) '-W::f¥~~W~tf~~m~O~1~~ ::f~ , j:Yfrt:~ft~*'~~Mmw: ' ~~.fJiii~TW~~f.fm:1J1ID~{tj~JtM'm~.Wff. ' 0. ?pj:tlt~~flt&-,J\,&I¥JMmw:, ~~.fJiiiHwt~~1=rm:1J1ID~{tj~JtM'~~.~f*M'r:p:lr ~fi~i16*W~~814:lr~~~l¥Jif~~fJ!~jm~{J;( (~*~~. , ~m824). 0. 0. ~'~G~fflffl~~~~*~.~~~a'M!g~.~~~~iEi~~N~ iEi~~~/~~f. :. i;:£tJ~~.mif~i16**;g. , fl(;fFnr~11UI~~JGv.s.m*u=JG~~ra~ , 1*mz-{~~. f:t~~.~~~&~o~~fl(;~~~~~~~~K1ID~~,m~fl(;~1!W~NE,~m~. ftlii.f:t~~~~m~~~~_~ffi@~,~m~~JOO~~~if~r:p,~ft~mW~~. ~~I¥JK1ID~~'::fmf*M'T.~~~Blftt'MLH~~~OOI¥J~~W~.I¥J::f~~ff 20. r.

(21) .... o~.~. w.~.g~$'~~~a~w.g~~~~.~M•• ••• @~@§. ~~~.mfu'~W~ • •M• • ~**~.omw.$,g.~.~. ~~*IM. '. ~iJj1l~-i:.ntllf~~md~. ,. ~ijf{f r OOJI J ~ • • L.~~H!!:~. 0. +¥X~+¥?. ••~0~~m'~~. .. .... ID*m'~~.~~~E'.*.*~~~~@@§mo~.~ .~~. •• ~W-~~~~~~'~~~~~~#W-~~.~•• ~~@'~~OOJI. .E~B~~ID'~~~. ••~.~~~~.~@~. '~. ~~~OO~~. o. :a ' ~:If~,.E ' ~nJU-i:~n:UtlEl*~ r -i:~M ,. W~MllD~ • •. ~g'~~~. 0. J. ~• •~. ,. WfffEJng&li~~JWw.. +.. nif![(~:rlz0~~~~L~I/;~~. :a ' ~s£.~~O¥?d~lf1~1¥.. :¥DmOO~Ylf~~~f?~%fM[gj?d~• •. ••~••~~'W~~D~ • •~@'~~~.XW~'~IDo.~M.

(22) tt -: ~OJ. McLeod~S. Chaffee tt =: :(£~:fJ:g£'~!f-f53U~!Y3B"J~~-~~B"J~.rfn~~AD!f-f~~Ir!~~~:r~~~ 0. 7tnX:11.f~}j~. a* '. ,. JjJWJ::f~f~Jj~zP'JB"J~jfttlil*. Jj~~Jj*&ZrdjB"J~~'~. ~DlIt-*gtllJf;RmtfmJ&*~¥{lL*/J\nX:.tt{§lJ (Probabilities Proportional. to Sizes' PPS) B"Jjj~~ff:fiEf*. tt. '. 0. .~:fiEJ&f*~~~3986A. 0. ~:~~.g~~,~~~~ti~E.!Y3.~B"J~.tt~&ffi~z.~.~M.o W:Ji-~~O~~'I'ff1!fllJ~OOil&m*~~$~~$J[}~~~831:f:tf:Ht&B"J. ~~alftJ~ -w! B"JiI&1i:J ~:i: {l: J ~f-lt1t~~~~~tJlJnX:.¥~~. r ~~f'T. 0. tt 1m: ~11.@E13~rm~B"Jm~IiI&m~o~B"J~ § ~iI&*~~$J[J,pff~J.itB*B"J tt 11.: r ~~mff~a J 1it~~~821:f:rfm~~$Mrf;l9:(£~13!J'JHgH~~iI&mrnai:l~B"JfIJ 0. EI '. ij 1€~~~§'i'&.J!tB"JY.:I:g. 0. ~~~J;).~~mYBl~~. , {tJtf~.:=. a-53Ummf. B"J~mo~~~.a:(£.~ • • ~~~~.~rm~o. tt. t\: :(£ElJIU!H§~{*~7tfJTB"JffB7t ' ~~~OO r iI&.~H J ~J][~ r :l;53U J ~ r ~ H&'~ J "{l:nX:I{l:~J][. 0. 7t~~Ji.J~~a~7t,. , .~~~~ ~~:w;. r~~Ji:W;J~*~7t,. 0. {§IJ~D. '. @]~. r+. r+7t~~~.J~a~. r~~~.J~*~7t,~lIt~mo. 7t,. tt. 7t~~~~. ~:~~~~*~~.mB"J.m• • ~~37tfJT,~~'~~mM~B"J.m~9'. ~.~m.~~oo.m:(£• • • •~OOjjOOtf~m~0B"Jfi~'~*1:f:M~M. ~B"J.m~9~~'B~~~~.~~.B"Jm~~~zT,.:=.a.~~OO~. ~R~.~~B"J7treJ::~tf~Ji,m~~mB"J.mill~~~Ji.~~.rrm®. *(. @.ll£f.¥~. ,. 1993.11.25). 0. tt A:m••~J::B"J.~'fi~.$~~~~~.~B"JiI&m~.*~.~~iI&.B"J~ ~~~om~E13~~B"J~~~m*.'~~~.~ • • • B"J.~:(£iI&m~~B"J ~7t.~'IlJ~~~tBiI&m~~B"J • •R~,~~mM~~.~~~o~lIt* *B"J~~:(£iI&m~~~~J::B"JR~'~~.~~~r!mo. tt fL:. J;)..~mmB"J!liJH!~~~-~~0~-&~pff.!¥J=m=m.~mff~a TVBS. ~~U. '. ~~IJfJ~~~~W § B"JR~t~~gt~t). a.B"Jfi~~±. 0. ~~m831:f:J=iff~. 1MJ8'9fJit~~~Jj~WEI r2100~~~~J 'flH.E:(£JJH~-J::J=iffa, ~l&ff~*~. • • ~M~~~~7%'~~~W-aB"J~OOW§ffim~o 22. r f.

(23) &Z. o ~~Y-1tlqmhJ}~irbi1} ~ i1!f~t:lJ. ,. n:k!t~~~~~¥$.fj-di-'tf}*.~~tl~~)fl!. ,. ~~~l¥l}~~4*~}~§J~ , .fM.OmmM'~if~W r~1llW~~)fl! J ~~ W~tl~~)fl!if;ij;~. 0. B~t:lJ~Jfl~* ~Y9VE[gJtl~. o ftl?f]tlq~rrJ~~~~~¥$'r/~. ~:If~.t:5. '. ,. : -+E. ~}~. Jb~.~~ (~~4U¥M~~&E$ S&~) *:m-~~r:r!fM*~~7;LS:Ft. '~W~~DEM~~nM'~~~.~ ••Ma.~~B:Ft*M7;LS~m'~. ~~*~~MMID:Fto~B*~~.~~*M~S'~W~Y~~~~W*:Ft:+. E.

(24) ~~~. 1993. r ~~W-EJ.i¥Jil&¥i:t~.:t1t-1.fE~=JOOJL$~jl~~:I*~ J ~~~~3fmif~rr"JnlG*¥fH~-. , -EJ~t : il&*iit~if~cplc..,. '1=ril&~~*f-t. 0. Atkin, C.K., Galloway and O.B. Nayman 1976. "News media exposure, political knowledge and campaign interest", Journalism Quarterly, 53, pp.231-237.. Becker, L. and D.C. Whitney 1980. "Effects of media dependencies: Audience assessment of government", Com munication Research, 7: 95-120.. Berkowitz, Dan and David Pritchard 1989. "Political knowledge and communication resources", Journalism Quarterly, 66 (3): 697-701.. Chaffee, S.H., S. Ward and L. Tipton 1970. "Mass communication and political socialization", Journalism Quarterly, 47: 64 7-659,666.. Chaffee, S.H. and S.Y. Choe 1979. Communication measurement in the March, 1979 NES pilot study. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, DC.. Chaffee, S.H. and Schleuder 1986. "Measurement and effects of attention to media news", Human Communication Research, 13,I,pp.76-107.. Chaffee, Steven, Xinshu Zhao and Glenn Leshner 1994. "Political knowledge and the campaign media of 1992", Communication Re search, Vo1.21(3): 305-324.. Connel, I 1979. Television, news and social contract in screen. ij I § Curran, et.al (1984). The Study and the Media: Theoretical Approaches. In M. Gurevitch, et al.(eds.). Cul ture, Society and the Media. New York: Methuen.. 24. r.

(25) f-t. n. ~~~~~fflfim~~~~~~'~.~~w~mfimz~~~~. Drew, Dan and David Weaver 1991. "Voting learning in the 1988 presidential election: Did the debates and the media matter?", Journalism Quarterly, Vo1.68(1/2): 27-37.. Gunter, B. 1987. Poor Perception: Misunderstanding and Forgetting Broadcast News. NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.. Herman, E.S. and N. Chomsky 1988. Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. New York: Pantheon Books.. Lanoue, David J. 1992. "One that made a difference -- Cognitive consistency, political knowledge, and the 1980 presidential debate", Public Opinion Quarterly, Vo1.56: 168-184.. McLeod, J.M. and G.M. Kosicki 1986. Paying attention to the concept of attention in mass media Research, paper presented at MAPOR, Chicago, IL ... McLeod, J.M. and D. McDonald 1985. "Beyond simple exposure: Media orientations and their impact on political processes", Communication Research, 12: 3-34.. Palmgreen, P. 1979. "Mass Media Use and Political Knowledge", Journalism Monograph Vo1.61.. Patterson, T.E. 1980. The Mass Media Election, New York: Praeger.. Patterson, T. and R. McClure 1976. The Unseeing Eye: The Myth of Television Power in National Elections. New York: Putnam's.. Pettey, Gary R. 1988 "The interaction of the individual's social environment, attention and interest, and public affairs media use on political knowledge holding", Communication Research, Vo1.15(3): 265- 281. Quarles, R. 1979. "Mass media use and voting behavior: The accuracy of political perceptions among first-time and experienced voters", Communication Research, 6: 407 436. 25.

(26)