~m
*:lot-it
k
iiJ:E
,~,;ff.
?t.*'
if-
11t-:lot-it
k
f{:
M
f*
if;
/p~
f§-
Jj.'
*m~§~rr~M*~~m~~~~ffr~$~~we.J~~~M~~
~A"J~¥lnt~')( 0 *1iFf~tt*!'¥lrJl~1Ji&mljBf']HfJ!r~tt1iJfn~!,t:&-Lz1iFf3'tnt~
,
~l1xtf§ 0r
$'I~IDh~~~~J ~*fEfBJJ'¥:~ 63)" *1iffrt*/j*i}~UJl!.: (1)gI5:&1:fr&
13"]~':~MrWLz
ZPj:';;J~IIff;:1.48-3.2951 '
:fC
}\:lliil
r
~$'I*!IlfJ~~e~J ~*:fEfigz ,
1&¥Wj;Z.z1\j:~W'zflff;:3.24-4.1051'
fi1~.i~~Jftij!] ,zi&mIFI\j::'.:::J~t1*1.i~HiHWJ0
JF:t~~ 0 (2) ~rmpfrfi--.-1·J~,!Hi ':f315~ff~l{~t:l:All£~ (P<O.05) (3)
!A
'1'1:. W
i;(il'1:
~ ~ i~5}
ffij
igz
~51
flT
.tt!l!~'tt
flJ
'1'1: t"r
~ ~Jt(If,]
tl~t~1~
,
fr*08~"
~N"
fr~~1N*akJ&~,
rm§.};fiff~~1iJT~~±1lTiakJg~&r*J ~,~&~m±1lTi~M~~We.°fr**~r±$~~we.J ,~ *MJJ!ii'&g*f~M1~~Zfii@i~~af'J51*fT'
j;)M1'F~**im.8~r~rVf~*~~§5i:[Hil~lEAkJ1fJ=
Biflr
ff~ffEW~ ~lJi!.~~EEl.
~~IJ~{ e~)t!J 8kJfiff~1 ~8kJi5tJ *f3~H!"J~$
$&
rf
A'
13-,¥;m~tJ,
*il1t51~ ~~o-'>Z
1£~Irm*tt.iH~
,
**±::1<f*f«LR~¥Mi1:E~f~*~fffiE'
~wmiLi~1J ±y~*~¥fffI''J~1JF~~fm'
~f~~**~IfFLa''J#f-rBVfDt'PtL '
1fEf~*~t$=1~*lftfU{/11L
a
if1R8"J~f~~,
IZIffiJ~'VGt±~XB)H~a"Jtfj:£J!' 1JIJtzU{}&t:IfE "
~1~:IfE"
*~t$'§ ~m~±~~*m,,~wM~"OOw~~"~~~"~L~~T.~"U&.~±tn
'
~s/'JiV:HHjfj{} 0 ~!H,;q;a"J~±tt1~1:Eg~ftIfF
LPJTOO~s"J~DJE: m>~,s"J±9EF~'fm'
1:E~f~8"J&t'L\M*~;LT'
tzUfiiJij~~,7Jmi(rg,~,U~? tzu1iiJij~m:¥T-~W ~~~.~? tn~~JE:NbA~~;q;~.~~~?E8~*&t WJ5(~~W:£li!i1~:t~
,
*t@tJ!i@~irf]±tn~rf;L~*t~,
*~~1J~~~rf!' ~~IJ~f~*~~L0:E$Jft'
idffi~r
±tn~~1'iFf~gffi:l:ti~JII- *7(f~~!D}]1J 1mE!t*~lII**f!JfJ'
*~~f~B"J{}~ '1J~JE:¥~:tJ~1JO 'J.l:t;J\:1iH~~~]jIJ~-~~ B"J1iJf~~,
~IL\~[Wfs"J~,1~HlJimr~,
~1JrLt1mij~*:?J~,
*~~Ei
&ts"J&t " IL' "
.~~M;L~,~.~~ 2~±tn1J~~~~'fu1:Em~~±tn~rfbA~
~f4Bf;J~*t~+'
'
~~tzD1iiJ~~§t:1:$~~ ;L~~ ~ffiJii2;JF~ ffiIL\~)(~1i;f2~ 0,
~JE:~~§+
T r
:1:tn'l~m}]~1J1m~J s"J~J,M~,
~~llJJ~±mm1±tn1JfU:1:mi@1~tjc~Q ~la:;fm~ Qt8JJ'rn~~~:£li!;1t~s"J~~H~"
"
fU~.;L[9*~~gr 1:!!§ 0T~
¥&gffisfJIlij'f~l~fwf~J;U~~fUtzij~ffiJE
' fuB!ittJ!
a'm
±m~t~~~~,
!lifE
~±tn~~B!1j£iMi~
"
~/J\"
~+'"
f~41irf]Ptl'
lBJE:**:1:thJE:~J~w~± tn~w~.molZlft'~7~*~±±mi@~~~~'A±~~W~.'~~IJLJmt!i1l8"J,~\:?J
'
¥ff!J;fJTW{131H-'S"J*~,
ij~BJlfflJE:;JFlf~,
~Wf~100:*lj[Wf8"Jij~ 1J'~JE:~~7ft~.~W.~w±tn~WffiHatt~r±tn~~~1m~J' Mft~¥.m~.mm~:?J,~&~~*~±~~±tn~~~1m~.~~.~ ~~o
---~..- -...
~$~~~m~~m~~~~A+~$ti.~~~~w~~m~.~,~ fffii~Jl$1j£~h~~00J
'
~JJ\'
~J-t!'4"'
&*~~~l$T~~i:1mt~~$~~A~8*t~ (~~~r~, 2003) 0 EE1J~~~/\_j-;'\$tL=--*J:ili~;L1& ' ~~TIITW1;*Ji!R:9ELfl~9~f1Hrr$.
'
~¥~~£!l!&/L\JEt!fl~'3ZgIJ'
~fI~~g~~;f~!jiJjt_'f:tW±~~~/\_j OO~~~ r~$~~m~~~~J,~~~tL+$M~~$~~~ AA~~~~m~$~r~$~~$J,~~~m~wmm~m~~$~~o$~~~~~~§M~~~~$mm~~m~~mn~;L-,ili~mW~~~
IrA"]-JJ1.ffilJQf=fJ# (
'2001;iJ:& '
2001 ; ~ , 2001) 0r
~$~~J ' r
~:9E~~J '
r)iEL~~J
,~_ {!?!I:g~Wr~~{£rjff:::f{~ 0r)iEL~Wf
J
13~'t%'1~3iE'
1ZI~~FkJttWl*W~ilj~J
-~n]~N~~~, ~~Att~:::f~.m&'*~~fflrr~~W~~or~:9E~ffJ
~IJ{t~ 1J~~b:#rtJif)[Jf;f~ff,$JPfTt~iJJA~g:)iE~ff8*{~~~Btt1U~JJ
'
[J;Jfffif~~ffW
&~1J~jW~~:%fplTH1~ffl 0 ~fffi
r
J -5n]~Iji~~~~AplTt~!'J':Jb
,
[J;J~1j£t±@!JJi!,**~' ~~, 1393t '
~§l:A'
rUI~i'
iJ~~,
,
~Dm~i:1~~~~#,m~-MliWl*W~~132~~A~r~$J ,~~g:$
~ff8*tj8':J~~.HEiJJ~fLtt,E\~'I'1f1~~'I'fj (~, 2002) "
~$~ff A~t=UI~t:i</L\
,
~lIrrm~*
§ f~& (~,
2004) , Jj\E!~~-fm1§tJE~$~R;f[j{~{WiA~~ff
(
'1999) $8/:J)~~{Etl~5}IJA8':Jg:$f;iX.ffl-1m
(:f1' '
2002) 0 ~$~ff )J1:{±~J.ljJ)i1-1g:~H.?j;IJ¥IJ$~nJ.'.
$'Um
,~mg:$,~&~~eM~~ ~$(~ , 2001; , 2001 ; {~ , 2001) , JE±_$Fl~f~
1[1[,
~fffi:f¥mnlJ)"'
~m1'~t±~;fD{lliA(
'2001; ~ , 1999) ',~,~AM~l~
,
:1tJr~$8~pg~~(tmf'
2000) ,g)lI*,*,~,:~~1~jqlP{:k:rQ~Jm8~1?~jJ(
2001 ;
iI '
2001)' ~3LJE ii1f1'l~ A~'il&! ' ~~A~~~~1~:j:JZ:r7j,
§fJH§"
~fD13.fX.JJi!, (.ti~ , 2001 ;
rH+! '
2001 ; ft~t'
2001) ,t)j~¥ljf~W~?~ft:Ati '
pgft:{~fU1i6'
l::J&mi'!j;o'I'~~ffem,
2001 ;"* '
2001) 0$~1fBr,J:j:iih;fm~Jr~{E/j~1JE{~~±_A~~~~~1~~~~~1mM:E1J
r
J f1~~$
,
J$I:~~Wf~rmAr,J,IgI,1#!ffii)L\1'~~ft~1'
J$I:~ID::@2)L\'
~I~z'L\ '
~~~1;L)L\&!~}t~t;L)L\,
~~~J~~~$A~ihtJtlJ1?~tJ'
~~~~~~¥t&i&~~~~~~~'~~~~$J-t!~.fX~Wf' .fX~m, ~~~'13 t),&
, tl
A''.JIIDi'
~lIlh '
3:
fnH~tB¥A"J*I£
Arcus fl)J C 2001 ) [Js]tJ~rJ A~Ag ~, 2ftJ
f;f::
'If/-tJ
~ ~,tR"];(
r~®rIM
0(;H¥H'
105 - - - _....__
...._ -
- - - - 'li~' ,~~~,~~~~~aM~~~~~h*~~~~~~~~
HJ,JffiJ~"1~i3H~fjj!U
'
~~~~Ej;a:fZtJlljAHfJlt.®~l'i!.4-l'
[j®2
, ffij
I2f
!lIM]*
i1Jj(/f
*@H1 rfn
h '
~t~ ~, JfiX: ;~'\~).1 mIl ' !CiX: Il.;:J'.r:t'::f ~e;f ' cfDnljAH{J~®
'
.iiffijtt~®H/;]::A:
fJE
1~g
H1
~ lJ~Jltj
},jl/;]r
m
J0* '
2002 ; ,f* '
[I!f! '2003) 0
:±.rfn
~~Q]'t)J!£
'W: ' ill!:
~1ft
1J fD
HE
A
,tt
Wi
X 1 r: ' lJ'iJ::*:
S
~1i
!lIn '
~rfn~w::t.-~tt~~~:±.J~~A±~lEHzHm* '~DlpJ~T~TlJ1J§J ;f§I~' ~DlpJ{~mUili~i2i '~D{pJ~,t~
cH1m1lt,
~D1PJM~l[i1if~{I}lffi1:H1-':f-ft'
~DF'Hml1fD~t'f H1~;~~~£13 '~DlpJ~*c (tJ¥f1'1lt
(Powell & Cassidy , 2002 ; Thomas &Arcus' 1992) 'lJE1~*~1j?6:Mflj~¥3:7l:-rm,F?~~I~1J~rltft:-rm~~ 0
!ElJlttB,
DJJ
~ .jfj~H!
!~ ,~#f
,~11lj
W
~¥.:L
~~1lt (
2001) , RnXR~f81~¥5~'I'1¥,fW~~~~J![
,
~,~lJ1J~~ij(rb9~H'~1l~1J'
~~~fmr~tJT4-lf~15)(HJ
*'.'
~~,
;ffj~ , fD~ (J~ , 2001) , J;)JszJt'i~r5·'fJ~;W H1A~tm 'ill!:~rLAlJ'iJC'
filiA '
§
~,
t:J.&
tJWlJ1JX1r:rnmf~UI'
2001 ;, 2001) 0
= "
:¢::~ff3i;trsJfaf~WAEirr
:
* tin
~fi&
'X
IlK
'-I
rrtf
fEE
ill
R!;]
r
~rlt
~'tff11
HE!iJn
fD
m
1fH!;)
~ ~fEfD
pN
ml]
0
'l'tJ
/f
J~ rlt¥t(n~R 'rig,,'fDJ.ffiGlffltt:Ii!;JWfiJf'
ffij:Xt::flH~:±.frl1~~fJ.ffi~lffl~ffiJ& EH~rJT~;t8H:fj8fJ 1ffr~ff
fj'
AJ!M][ ,
:Mz1ftJr~~~~H1.1t1fi1J~*f~*~ *m~0~~~r~~~W~~~W.~J~r5~m~~~ ~~,* m~~w~*~m~~~~wmn~~r~rfn~~we~J~~m.:LM~~~
ffl3~H1nX~~ 0
*{in3't8f'J~**7f13~mT
: (--)
8*r][~;tPii.;f;LYc~ffD3.!§lffl~f1t}~~,
~~frl1fx:pf!.ffi
~lffllJ'iJ•
.f~*6 -is-
SZ
J
liJf
~ (-~) ~i'0ttt::*:
,!}": ~f9f1
'I"
S/,)rfn
~WA'0liJf
JE
0 ( _)~.mM~~M.~ttm~~~o (~)~Am~~~~~~~.~~~D (li)~~*~~~~**i~~~~~m~~~n~o~~,**~M~ 81H/;J~.rSUti*7lfJT &~!fl!l'lnx:~ 'iIl~;I~nX~**
lfn¥tfrf
~ Af~:~05z.w~fft~Wr
~frl1
f~!lIJJlJ'iJ
~!WJG*r][
~Q: ~t-I'l/,)
MfLE
1:1R
t~,
t:)JtJl{£ "t
lfh:r~ff
HI;] {iJf ~ ~HJE.Xff
NT
ft
0
-1
-
"
{jff~~1~:
*~~~.m~m~¥-MM~*~-~M· '~¥M~
*i#JJfDf4
~ S"J*~,
~[Q] ~~11~jffi~iJUfzfftW~fU~Jt*p1Cg~r
tfl1'I~iJJ ~1Jm .J~~~'~$M*~.~~+-*~Nm-*Mr tfl1~~we.J~~ ~'.~+A~~~~~~'~~~~~W~tfl1~ffWffiU~tl,~~~~*£JF 7i:
~~ ~Fi"J
11*
1C!=
0="
{jff~~e:~t
:
*£JF~142M
• •
ti£JF~~~cit (Pre-experimental design) , ~¥rH51*n~j~~ i=t142If;t±~~11~jffi~~~fftW~r~Jt*piCm~r
±tfl1'I'*!I!JJ~1J~~J d*f~.'
~m-~ ~*f~M1r1~,
~~r&*~~fTMmIWp''ff1itlimIJ'
,:L1&j~*lt~st+ J\~ri=ttfl1l*glJJ
W~~J~~~-±$~ffftA'~A~-~~~~*~'~¥M~±~~ft ~~~'ff~~o~7i:~~~~~~-: (-)~ *~~f~~ **~rJT~)t~ (18:10-19:55 l~m63A'
• ! ) ~,
8~f~~~ (=)~ :4~~*f~J Ef:J~61J 't)J
ijI
;J}~.6ili'I{J
l'
hS':[!IJm
;fDe~, I!Jl
A8"J1ll?:h
( - ) ~*
o 6.~ ~~~}[~~'±r Jt)(;~8f • #~"u~fl i'fiI 1;1IJ ) "
./ ... /J " ([9)B!
*8*f~1 0_ .
_ _
. _ - ,
~Dr:i'I'~~b~e~e'9~~f~
( - )
~f~F~1'I*~5~H~jj!5iffln';:iffi~~¥)Cff ,LIW!fl¥~:BH*f~
,
~~tfit~t'(ffff;ff1~~~!f!t1'
$r19~ *~~ffi~~,.~~oom~+-~$&m-~M,~~-m+wwm+-w( 18: 10-19:55)
s.~*'
f~tl
:fl~.\il.~t$'I~!WJ~l~tm~ '~~JLZ\{Ml7t{I~f4 '3*f~ )1¥T}~p.fq~71 (2 /j\mj) ,t)i:~*~gnjtT-==.1i1:
[PJ~~~~*f~~t)i:,
*~~~Aiit~~ 63
A '
t$l~*t~PfT¥~~~*'
,lJ[t~.& 9}~~FJ3'8/T~fjF' t)i:~*1TA~~~~,
ill,
,e~'.~'li~'~ 'U.&.e~h'~~~M'&~~~tT~~, ,~,~~~.&affM~o
( = ) ~f1Em;ilit
*5*f~J:r::r*8it "'W:~rfJt£!Mijf.'';t 2.H/;]~trn, '~~'f~M~:zJjIJA
8"J ffI1'
~:t&{JE{lieb12.8/')~$~~JjIJAH"Jtfitf:jXm~-e 0 .lliF83*f~8"J!1!bh.e*I+-t'''f-'/·'j, fDf~~
, 01
.l)j~iD~ll'1i';:n
1:"_ I~ 1"--r As"JFI~h 0(
)
~f~EH~*3!f!fE£!.rl'-J
[3 f~;~tfi-t
5.t]¥~ f~ 0 6}j~~~
1:£
£
4-q~ft
Ji:~~"'
l:J
ft
fj(1~,
[J
ft
i:!)?: ~ "' ~),.&B
ft
i¥
tfi
0 7,*~'I!.'lf£~®jJ1J';:/~JfjiJt~[If~1i';:[J
A. '
1xfi~,
~~;f3Z'film; ,
,
~~'("'
fD~J* 0
8,
ffI1IDipff~~sl,]:'tui1 jJ*iJE1~FI~~J~~~tT~j:8J.)1ID~tMtttr58"Jl!1lj~ 0 9.*~fJt£*Eoj~3zmJj[JA8~)4.fit~f~4~
,
~Flttt~,
~5!rt£®sf.]
,~,#f! "'
::~>§Z±
ffI1 s"J
~ttl '
Tffi
~5fill))7®
¥LIj{ ~,,*@
81 fit h
0 1 0 /1Fi1'~T t\.L~'5t '
~!1!)),
~~~t
"'
~ill: '
2.
f
0Jj I
JA
HI,) ~fit '
3m
Tffi1:£
1.=.
$81,JIW
*
iff
Hl~g
~~JjIJA "nX~~''Hj1f' 0
(II!}) ~f~~~~
-
---~---~--~-~~~~--~~~~~-ti5*ifl!r ' *M ' f4 Ed
:gf~,
fJf~&'
,
~;;x'
El
Wl ' i'i1J;;x ' nmlfl '
J!fH~lf1
ft'~~~~'~~hrt'~&~il'
::tJ1Hi'<t
i)n (
):
f~t
' tJ1
~!f£~~!
(li)
~~~~5}~T ;iif1i~*~!fH~
,
*±.&'{fi7C~~TS
f0tt1!i '
1tQ. ~±.pt:9rJ~fDt:Jc~L~,:LfiIJ
fFS"J~ZPfHLl:j
20% '
~~M~*13~>L\1~¥&afr'120%'
~*;f~~~'i1s"J~tlU~fl:-~20% '
---~---...- ...- ... - - - -
iin~~£~~I'lJ;;~~~{6 10% ' j;j&:'=l=.iin£w~~~C~J',~Wt*~~B{6 30%
( /\)
~f~~mi~a}j~**~*fjHMfj):¥J~'~~:'=l=.frn'l'*!IljJfD~~I'lZJ~ll!nt:x')7:
,
iW
~~-.+M1F~9M1J',~4:il'fl'i*lbfD~~~*f~ffi:JAElmmt±:
'
~~*f'lMftR~)lgff*~H1JmIJI'lZJ~Zf£Ei
'
'fit '
j;J.1~~1l*·'±}~~M1&I'lJ;;J;a5~
"
~~J!f
'
fD1i~8JJ25(~' iin'I*lbflilim~d*f~
110 . *'If
r
[Q "
ti7f~I¥t
:
*~~~-ffi~~r~$~~We~~~~.~J,~m~~~~~~m
~jt§tpfr g1-TftfJEaf'Jr~9~ , r~9'ffr*J
: ~lb
"
ttJ1IJ " ifefi " *1#11 "
" if
a".~"~~,, "tthl"~&M~~=+aa o~~'ffm.~~~,
.m_~w*~~~~~eZ~ffltt(r*J )"ffiUtt,,~~~~~
rm~tl::H:t~i 0 **iS~1JW*a"l~5!J¥xr~9'ffztf~7J'fiWfltc!(
,
t)JJtilr*J!g:1§~~J!t'
~®*~n~r*J!g:-~tt~N7J'moma~~ml§7J'ttZ~7J'$*~~7mA"J;f~J.!t, 100%~
r57J'J "
80%~r47J'J
"60%~r37J'J
"40%~r27J'J "
20% ~
rl 7J' J
0Ii. "
ji~71~fT
:
*~fF~W*4~51:1~H&
'
f5RsPSSfPC*1t§tf~A~1-T7J'ffT 0 ~pfrfJeffl a"l~JJitSj*~:fi1t~J.!:H ' 1:t<~fF~ §
R"lfJeffl *1t§t7J';ffT1JH~~m§
7J'lt, (Percentage) "ZPtSj1rnI
(Mean) "
(S.D)
&7J'J1Ij.l:t~~.~~J1tJIH&mIJ~~a"l@C~tw!JE(PairT
Test) ~ 0
-
"
tiE:!$71Hfj~~~ji*~
:
*~fF~z**~*,~11~I~m63A '
J3;'-\-l~tEW11 A (17.46%)
,~tt~52A (82.54%)
0 *~ifefifr$20-25~W30A (47.63%) , 26-30~W26A (41.27%) ,
31-35~~5A (7.94%) '36-401 A (1.59%)
,t:I,&
41-45 ~~
1 A (1.59%)
01:t<?.s*1#IJ*
'~ifi#IJ*j::WA (39.68%) ,
-
3A (4.76%) ,fO[9if1#lj
35A (55.56%)
0 R1:t<f4i{d~ft'
I~~ 11A (11.11%)
'*JJ1:~~W24A (38.10%) ,~~¥tl ~2A(3.17%)
'1:*:m
1 A (1.59%)
,l~I~~10 A (15.88%) 'fml:f.!:H*fi
19A (30.16%)
0 t:I,if~&I&J1IJ '-if~&~j::fi13A (20.63%)
'=if~&*j:: ~37A(58.73%) '-if~&*j::~7A(11.1l%) , [9ift&*j::fi5A(7.94%) ,tJ&~frt*~~
1 A (1.59%)
0 1:t<~~iilt;]#fi:i5tl&5t'
*~g*~~56A(88.89%)
fDE~
(34.9~
$&1Yl
~*=t
T
1tt .
111fO
E
pg~ ~ 7)\. (1 1 . I I %) 0 i&t:H~*
1illi7:lIJ 'fflli
I
1'f:
eft
22A
(34.92%)' 5A (7.94%)' 1 A (1.59%)' ~6A (9.52%) ,
:¥&~ 12A (19.05%) '~i:t~9A (14.29%) 'I~I"E 2)\. (3.18%)
,Ali
m*~
5
A
(7.94%),tJ.&JiJfj'Cl1J]f[tf]
I)\. (1.59%) (~-) 0 [1751J lljl"t 11 (! .4Hlf) 52.A. (47.63"0 ( 41. i . 50'?c) ( 11. II J (j4.')2ik) I :; j.,M¥l:!lj;Lzpt':;J~flm
1.48-3.29fr '
I wn'I*~JJW'~~~J-
"
, {&¥l:!IJ;L
ZPt':;J~frm3.24-4.1OJ},
,~i&¥/~IF1~t':;JW!Z
%*D~M~ZP~.(~~) o~~~~~~m~~~m~~1 ®W~WM~J~W T1N*A"Jc~~
,
~1JOID:tJt"±.$B'J~~&1~1tH ,t.h111H:;=H*~Af'1~"±.¥5'
EJ
&fii!.A
0~ ~lJ
ill
~a{PI
f!
11 81,
tt
n§4J
Sl~Y!
tiT
:fJJlJlli~DiilJ¥:t~t3
ft~lliffi~~I~ttmnrt*~mt32ft
T
M~Dipl*'IIWit3
2fO~iJArn{}flli[!]jf ~~ T~~~DinJ.fl)n3 11\ 1'..1:. fttll~~JifiJ&1t3
fU~~~fftifRS
iftl
tt
15
ft~m{\~@ft~lJJ1!knfilJ~IUfl ~hf~!;z*
TI1lli El2
ft~DJ1!kDfi1}~ffi *Q~ *li1!~tt
$
nl:
i~;.2f
t:;;~1 3.27 2.92 3.08 3.14 3.03 129 2.75 2,92 3.02 3.14 2.71 2,71 2.75 2.76 1.48 3.29 2.57 238 1.22 0.92 0,96 0.91 0.97 0.94 0.86 0.81 0,91 0.80 0.85 0,83 0.74 0,98 0.88 1.01 0,95 1.21 3.87 3.84 4,00 4,08 3.94 187 3.48 3.67 3.70 3.67 3.56 3.70 3.98 3.76 4,10 3.78 3.60 104 0.72 0.70 0.81 0.82 0.87 0,93 0,84 0,82 0.82 0.78 0.78 0.85 0.89 1.10 0.82 0,79 1.09 (P<O. .!4!11! a;f>- ' fJ!J.l~2~~, 1
ft
fttli1~~2.49 1.79 1.00 0,79 -,~®.~w.a~.~2.~tt§~~~: 3.81 324 0,86 0,96 ~~~~~~wmMM~~~g~tl~~ftm~~'~~~~Mfl~~
'EI1=3 :
~M5®cS\W'f0lZ,
{}~jt ' -rjq¥~rf\18JT~~,
Tjqit~®slf~flH'
Tf~¥~tfn
fz1fs1
ill:
~tt:'
11ltl~f,!OiriJ;i@
FJ
'M
±
t~4-1
A~Ji~~--7C'
)(0 iN f,!O
1i:TJ
7]'
~-3=:$
~fi"J*
'IJt
')(Ui1i1f,!n1riJjqit~>ti±::$y18~rrfi' j:rHf1f,!ll1ri
JH!{1 [1
'Mttj~y-1S~rJtrr' )(lH1;!tJn1
rJ
J
cs~tf;f*~ , ~[HHJflf+~f*S~}'t.Y3 hA*"fl~:fJH3
jqitf,!OiIJJ:#JJIWf
CfU
JiIJ)"
Sl
{yEll!
l1:Sl
ti '
T
jqitf,!1]
{pI
~.Et)]f[J
Jill
A '
Y
~itf,!Dii:iHz£
A
±
A',]
~ug: AE:
InJ)'[:
Sfl ' tll\c}IzOi
rTnfHJ
cli{)±®fU~~~~H'f*fi '~M;i@trfi~fsf'J'
~F.H}:i@[Jc8"J~ttMfU1ilJ ,j:njn!Jn1IiJili!ffEIJbf{~}~2*l~:f~
,
j:rHg!JD1r1Jili!ffL*n.Lj*~!W4.$ ,
T
Wr!Jn1nH#J~7(f~;[_,~m'l'~ ~ h~FVri'TRJ;) A '
tJ&.)(nmf,!L1iilJ
fjlH'f!VWj::,
®fS
~~ Sl~)
ti
¥-x
JjIJ.A
rm
PiT
n
~::.+
Wi]
Jft
L1 '
ti~ ~]n'\'It
s!;)
~~(P<0.05) 0
ffiU.:J.JifrfTJFH=·J
,;Li~mIW~flIit~lFP:t';;]~};{f)-1J;-
0,52-2.29 5j' ,::JtJ=l;{t
r
fX
m~:i@llf1
S"JWt
tf.rflTJ
.Zl~¥WW~flfjtWFI'£~JW:kz~M(i:k7i)
0!lCJJ.ttN:}
~'~4~~r±®~~weMJ~~2~'~fT~~~~.~*o~~~~
~1@j§IHINH1'iR1
•
ill
~921Jn.ft'l'fI c~)~f{I'1fj-'{I!'ilnr)ft,,
t~J&.
8
1 ,)3=. ti[1 0 L~t1IR
p (tN~ti, '''~, ~---.---.---~--u~r;f.~'J. 11H l~~g 0,60 1.43 -3,344 < 0,001fX
0,92 1.14 ·6.409 < 0,001U
0,92 1.08 -6,753 < 0,001U
r
~'? g>L>.~:to: ~J,IF ,._un f ] ' 0,94 1.09 -6,816 <0,0011I{fQWHnjuJi® 0
0,90 0,98 ·7.335 < 0,001PTl4
0.59 1.13 .4,123 < 0,001tHo
~~ofil}
L!!
f1 B
'ffi:15
4'
If]
~tfr
tHnjg~nfil}1jtfiEl cS1tflr~ ftm~m~~~S1:15h~*~~Elcft
Tm~OlPJ*ljWrEl
C*O~ljAS1{Jl!!I!HIfi
Tm~IJ{iiJ.MEl
C*IJ~ljAfi
Tm~IJ{iiHj£A:1S1~Hj'fJtrQ]7tB~fitlHHO{iiJgIEl
cS1:11fn*01'f$in6~ ft~~fH~81i i'-ft~ ~1:15
fim~{\j~El cB~~m*01ffi3 ftm~~W~m~I!~*W~Elc fi*om~Ofil}~mjcp~*~~:1ifn fi7m~PJmM~~~I.i~MfiS1A fHn~~nfiiIgIH~!M:11fnf§mmS1~M~iJ$~ljA 0.75 0.68 0.52 0.81 0.84 0.95 1.22 2.29 0.81 1.21 1.22 1.32 1.44 1.03 -5.742 1.06 -5.111 0.88 -4.739 1.08 -5.974 1.07 -6.266 0.91 -8.346 1.17 -8.291 1.37 13.215 1.09 -5.893 0.99 -9.708 1.40 -6.947 1.22 -8.601 1.13 10.121 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 <0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 : ~grS8"J P {ffiit::JW~Ji~ «0_001 )1m "
~11'1!)it~II'1a~1~5.1 (1~~~U~~;~~) 2~W5.1~ff
:
9"H:1W:9:'I:1~JHH~7} (132mIH,~MmIJ) ;L~~7};fJT l:t.~~, '1':1:fO:9:'I''f.B~
(P>0.05) a ~'1'1~~1~7} (132mIH~fjIJY~IJ) S"JZ:Ft~J5zflfj~ 0.55-2.18
7} ;
fffi.t..
cl'1cg.}HH~7} (HH~IJ~fjfH~lj) Sf'JZ:P:t~~1f-fj~0.50-2.317}
0 ~'I'j:J'~~±-:(£Mt~,@j
[2r't]Il'fll&:fO{)!f;;lt,
7fql~±-JfnA"J~~,
7~*±'JfnA"Jf~{[H'
tiH~f,zDl6J,@j0
'rtf;
, j(Dillf,zOl6J
7}
~±.ifrJl-P8"J
:ftt51t '
j(llill
f,zDfnJfqlf~ft±-Jfnti-JF!"JfI¥i=@i ,
[2A"J'I'flj)il '
j(DillfflitJ~H~S~]g:j51J:r:\3K~J5t!§
C ' TWr.f,zOffiJf'IJ
iff
[2:fOJ.ilLAs"JIL<f-'l~H:I' T~*f,zDfPJ1jtA±-8"Jm81ifJ1::rP]:7'CrlA'
'tit1~f,z[JfPJr,JlB[2
'~fJ{)i&1
[2s''J¥:1ffi:fO@ffi=' *m-g!lOfrtJ;;mfflihfj1fiit*tr
*P~*~~±-Jfn
'
7~*f,zOfPJ:tlE~7Cl~{)~fJ't~t§tHlrJTt=f8f,)A '
J;J&*Dill!lDfQl,BIH'FW±-Jfn;f§~roB"J?J&t~?J&~JjIJAW'
~W+;\1[jl!JJfj §?:tN1.H-~7}
(132rRIJ~MrJllJ) ~~:9:tt~4(~~) o~~,~~~tt&:9:tt Itl] ~~~'~Wffi~~.~~~~*'MU~IHl
fi~~i&l ftn~'±fi
(W~1 fin~1fttMi1tijD
fi~Dill~J fi~nillPO fi~om~o ft~OjgijDfitllJm!tl
ft
T~~PCft
r~~ijD ftrWt~oT
;~~~~~~o1B~~tt*~m~r~®~~ooa~J~w~w&,~~~~ 8'j~m}] " ~,!Z
"
~f,~t"
~m'
"
ft'I'g "
~~>'Z&aJMtt'~fr'I"t~~tt*1~~tfi7.U'
tt~4~~~~~~m~®~~*ttfrtl*4*ffl~~-~o
;fz /", :
15
·ti~*·ti~lt!11-~( 1it
iR'j i~W
iR'j )Z
>J'-;ff[-15 ,ti
11 A
*,ti
52 A
El
y;tt~l!:]~~ filli~~;J;. •Tf@!
pjtH
... --~.---li1!~iH@0
c(f;JUT~!HDJLjj~ 1.09 2,02 0,50 1.28 1.249 0.216-Ii
118 1.40 0.87 1.09 0.834 0.407ft
r
M1:UIl8IJ{~j[Q 1.18 1.08 0.87 1.09 0.879 0.383-Ii
T~t.1:UIlf{ffH1m:'£tt 0.55 1.04 102 109 1.317 0.193 -li'i1R1~HnfiiJ
J@lf1 M
1.00 1.10 0.88 0.96 0.353 0.726-li~nm
izo
jilJ7t
~:1:ffn
yl
Sl;J~t}l 1.00 U8 0,50 1.11 1.341 0.1850.82 1.60 0.71 1.09 0.270 0.788
-Ii
~Oi.ri
911
jfjJB!H B M
Ij:{5
,II
A'JfftfT
0.55 0.93 0.79 1.05 0.707 0.482-li~om9fjfriJ¥t)E§ c3~J'I'~*~ 1.00 1.34 0.62 0.99 1.095 0.278
-li~iHHm frr~~t(l~:±¥5jjA*£HJ\i!
El
c
0.64 0.92 0.50 0.87 0.465 0.643l1<
T~rizDliil*lj~~El
Cfll~IJA(f.J{\JlRlJZltf 0.9\ 0.70 0.79 1.14 0.336 0.738-Ii
T
~~9DfriJl¥{1J}JEl
cfDl}ljA
0.73 1.35 0,87 1.01 0.388 0,699-Ii
1.09 0.83 0,92 0,93 0.555 0.581fX'lij#izQfriJ§!El c~1l:t6tfJtr~{H5iS'
1.36 0,92 1.19 1.22 0.438 0.663fxl~j@I!%i+W'J 2,18 1.25 2.31 1.41 0,274 0.785
-li~~'LA0lEl c~]¥~fDftll! 1.27 1.19 0.71 1.05 1,569 0.122
fHni11izOfll!~m ~.M!s~*E'J!
c
1.45 0.69LIS
1.04 0.917 0,363 ft~DlliizD1ii]Jim *n~*I~j:.®
1.64 1.43 1.13 1.39 1,084 0.283-Ii
TMf,m1riJ
f1l~.kf92{\~rot!t!itj!P!TffRI;] A
1.91 0.94 1.19 1.24 1,809 0,075-limm~W~WW¢UIlffil~IUli~A 1.73 L19 1.38 LI2 0,910 0.366
J5JT~\i4jrn8W<~W~x~ i~~
J
~ itW3~~J
~f
O
i;m'l'w~J-'J ~j§~~gllJ'
~~~.~ftm~~'®~~E
• •
~~~~~~~i~A~WJ~~ i~A~~Jo~~~~~W~R~~W~~~~,a~ft~~$,~ft~W~~~
~ i~J
W i11\J
B"J~~¥t~~8liB"J~f*~m1Jf'
®:~JgfiAB\J~~tt'
5ge~AB"J~'I"±
'
~;g~DfO'I1f~B"Jm6-@;-,
[7qat#1iW7i-tt~nM"JfJ~,
t)J5~7i-tt~m1~mIHmB"J~-@;-
,
~!mEl~B"JmfJ~~~~fJ~,
.m:t~~'L}ilZPttjB"J~rR~ft 0 ~A~~~*~El3~~B"J~li!.*~~
EI
~B"J~Jl: ~ ~~ ~ {}g ~'l'wt®
~ rl!f~:1J ~ ;§lj~:1J ~ t±~tt'
~ fD~mtfi~~,
1JEf~~~~px~AB"J~~§
B"J '
1i!1!!l~1I~1fl ~ t1W5ge~BJ\[ ~&
'11ft®~-@;-W~1J[ijB"J{}l~~m:'
~®~¥lj~D ~'l'N
~ ~ ~fiB"J
§
f~ 0~i~~A~fti!~~!:J-,r~B"J~ft
'
1~f~~~~&B"J$ 'f8~~~~xtl~~~~L-'
R~J=FH~}~:1JB"J}lf~~~B"J*1i&[7q?6
'
;f§1§m1:.'M~~1'W~tl~B"J'
~Jt)fJEfFE~~{}~zp.ttJ~~B"J 0 ~Jlt
'
~ifrJ~ft~~~~~ft'
gti~±~~~DfiiJmJ~EI
~,
•
.m:~ifrJ~Bm~ifrJ,~m~ifrJ~~~w•
•
,~m~m~~~'~B~~m~*~w~~oAAU,i~ifrJ~~W~~JB"J~~,m
• •
~w~~~~A~ftB"J~~~~ott*.~~M~m.px~B"J~m' ~~~*~~~~ifrJB"J
~~fD~~
,
~~lfli~9(D~ ~ JLe;~ ~ fi~,
fit'jfW1N*B"J$'~ 0El3*6*51tfT1~9(D
'
*~~~r
~ifrJ'I*~W~~J 8*t¥~~B"Jpx~51tfT' J5JT
W1?t~*&B"J*~~~8*t¥~ZP£~B"J®l-JJ4~
§ Z
1&mlJZP:t~I!z.l§'*~Mmljzp.t~1!z'
~7]\~~~~8*t¥1&
'
~~ T1N*B"JCJ:~,
~1JD.m:t~~ifrJB"J~~&flf@, m
tm
m~~B"J~~m'~®~~E12&~AoM~~mM~oo~.px~zU~tt~
~7ttfT~§i
'
*~~~J5fTW=+f!BlJj[~§,
'M~~WM~t±B"J~~(p<o.os)
,
® E!.J5fTWJj[ § Z
1&mlj~M7WjZP::l:~I!z:l:~fI~o.S2-2.297t'
:7t~fti ~~!~iH~!l'tiTB"J •
•
~mJ~§z~OO~MOOzp.~.~ft~,~~m~~~m~~~z~ ,:l:~Wl3jJUB"JJllJ.~*
'
~?6~~tr¥lj~IU~B"J.m:~t±'
m~~1JDB1'~E12~~B"J~~I$7t'~~~~~*E12'U&~mEl2~~$ ° ft~ttWfttt~Gm
f1
(f&mlj~Mmlj) Z~~7ttfT.tU!~,
~'I1:fOftt±.I§'~U~~~~(p
>o
.
os)
,
~
ffiJ
~'11:
~(
~&mrl¥r~U1J; ~r
~ifrJ1* ~ 0 f8~~ ~, ~~,J1JJ
1iir.
0 ~91
*~~o~~a": ~~c:!Z~F? f~~~,
1¥;
IK&jJje,~ iJ1~~E*~1=J *±'B"Jm~ ~~ oRkJ
0 ~~*fliI
'
~'J~
~11'~ 1.48.fi
4Ij:-JJ4Jm
7QN
jeB"J2)(
E!
2&fti!.A
f~JJj § ,'Mr.
0.52
-2.
2951
)tf',3ijIiIJlt
t
:E '
in
"if~ 0~t
.
117~fffi JEjt=!:15-~J.H~5t ({&i~rnmt~lnftIJ)
St)z:p:t,';:JWJfr1.i:SO.SS-2.18
5t ;
fffi3:z:'I'1:<!H~7J\. (f&mlJrT~nfnftIJ) I'l~JzFt~)i5.rfl1.i):0.SO-2.31yJ"
0 ~Jll:t'
~'I'i&~:cl'':E~~/-t_fl'iH~t~r4~~~We~J~~~'
ffi
~~~~.~*·M~~~~~~~o
.fffi~~,~~*~r ~~~we~J~~~'~.~W.~~~.& Ilj)i,it ~9H;'U}~48kJ::&'n!f" {~~
"
trilrM "
tJ "
fllJ5fitJ "
'1'~!'iL~I'l(Jrf~"
*1:l;fD~,1t8t)t!1i#1J
"
,~3Z~~gB"
tJ&
Ed
fllJIljJ}dlk]t.f§::tr¥f~Jfl*5r~ 'i1Jfl!Jt~~tiJ t~I~~~~~ , 'MWAffi/~lfJtfE.f~j~,
~lJxBI~R{ifA~Rfft7f '~1J '~Tt=lr~l~wlf't**
r!~
*-'
g:jt,)rr'iJ1#/FtJc~ , I fFT'liffi,CAms ' tJ& [gj~tITltJH~:fffikA~A"J;f~* '~W~~~~ ~, T~~~ffr~~~~W
• •
J~~~~~tl'iliM~*~W~~~~~ff& ~~~IW~m~&~~~M
~o~~*m~M~W~~~'*-*~~~~~~ffr~~~~W.~J~~
t~
,
YlJJ},j.
!'If;]JJX
~'!z ~15J nil:
?
*
iiJf
'J-t
lik)*5
~Ri ~: (1)?"r:q~~;& st)'~!tmnft1j
/P
J:5jW:5.rfr-1.i-):
1.46-3.293.24-4.10
7t '
o
Z1&mIVrt~JW:5.r~'r*-n:SHiap'rJZ:P:J:~W)c,
~ii:(1.4*&H};J,~ytfj~ci*1&~~ 1N*-SkJc~~,
J!:1JrliRt5i4~8~JZ!~~&1~flIT 'W:I"if#tj(~s")it&g:.¥~,
~fffi.fijJld
EdillA
0 (2) ¥~!£JN~i\*fjWp{[~;2.f1T~lJJ'1 Hij{~j~lj.tt~s(~}ffT'Fm--j
f~Jl1 ':Mr)~tHfJl~ttfl~)i!t~
(p<o,OS)
'rJTnJf! 0;2.
f&tWJv~Wn~IJZj"~J~)c/r-;lj~0.52-2.2951 '
JtJttE
r:tk:~~}MJlftrfRt)l}tl~'+jfTJJf'H]
z{&mljif~fIfj1ftlj4'-~J~~p
a~J±$ 0
(3)
~tE&JjJ9:ti:g.~1~5t (1*dWJ~MmlJ)5tfJT.ttlii5t,
tifD
9:'ti.l§'~D~akJ:£~
(P>0.05)
0 ~ti:g.~11)f5t (1&mlJ~~MtftlJ) AkJZPt~lift1B:0.55-2.185t ;
fffi9:ti:g.~11)f5t (1&r~IJ~MmIJ) AkJZPt~lift1B:0.50-2.315t
0 ~ff~tt&9:tt*±~.m~r±$~~W
• •
J~~m·~~ffi~~D~~.~* '
PJTtJ~%f 0 ~fffi~'I'i*±~--t-~1[!liJJft:S-Jm1~5t (1&mlj~M~)~ZP~
•
.l§'~1B:9:tt*~,~~~tt*~m~~m~mN'~~±$~IJJ '
~~,
,
~m'
"
~'I'!'
~'§Z&• •
~5t9:'I'i*~*11)f5tE?U' n&W>t
~*.tt9:JI'i*~*1~~~~=f-ltt: 0
**~~~.~T:~**~r±$~~W.MJ ~~g.'~1B:9:
Jti*±mrfl41JD5tE~~;\Jl!:g,~i~ §
c±$fDJ.lIJA±an
r,~~--.J AkJ~-W:'
~~±$~~IJJ'~~'~M' ,g~, '~'§Z&.M,~~~m*
I3kJ'j.~*&WJ~ 1£**¥Aff&mmJ:l3kJ1J~ 0
,
H!t~HiakJ¥}f:':n~'f*±•
~l~!± ~mJ:1M!~8kJ § ftftW~&r'fift'
JJXm~*~W1?~:tJMWJ'
tttJlli:*JW:~1?~:tJWJJ.lljA
0 ~fffig.~*~,
tlH& '
f3t~lf!H±l!lli$,
UH~lE~AkJ±~§.N3t'
±tnw~~BkJ~t!!fMJIfi
'
~[QJa~J:E'~WEH~,
>"=.I·J,•• .J...• $~1fI3~J~&f1J8kJf5l'!:A 0
(200I)
0 ±$akJ~Mlli!1~m~ Q *~~ift~76
WJ '
p32-36
0(2001)
0 ¥fY:1f.W~Yt rlf]~J ,1§~Frf]r9E*tu
.
~1f1*m~,
p22-29
0~~iij
(200t)
0 g.~ift~fI}~}g~~Il~±$~1f. *~~m~76
'plOO
111 0 Ir~~9JX
(2001)
0 ~.B<:/J\*~gffi~$~1ft§~~~2~Dli!1J1!~NztiJfY"C 0 gffiffm**~1f*fift±;fRi)( 0f*N.l$
(2002)
0 tzDfm.Dffi~$~1f 0 *f3t~$~1fW*gffi1i~)fI*'*li!1J~Pc~giE -
**f}E§}II*~~' pI 16 0f*N.l$
(2003)
0 § ~~~JjrtlakJ:E-'8Rfif~ill!li!1Jt5ZJ7J-
;1F~{Cf:!lhf~~§jffj ~~p64-70
QtiMf
7:V, --'-, 1*';(~*1t
11~J Ztf~2
I~I92
0 ~.~. 0 ~~40
0 ~. pp ~B57
0:t5Z*fift
~; http://21~j,t ~jj
?i:!
I
1'p:l:jJ,
1-4 0Ji!fHs{fJ
(2001) 0 t~lH!IpqlzUfPf.;fjffi-'t_p64-70 0
~flB.[tiTJ (1999) 0 ±$ft<:W8":JJJE.~OO 0 )(ft<:' 12 ' p17-21 c
miSfffl
(2001) 0 ~~37EL~~9ELft<:W 0 t±ft<:1i~4~git ' 276 ' p4-7 0o '=:-jo'~;o;", 35
WJ '
p4-30 0~*m{~ (2001) 0 f;t"::t$s"J~~9~1~1!H~OO±utft<:W 0 if!Hl{-~§it' Ax~
{lit!
;Z:g~ 28M '
P 161- 1 70 0 ~*K~ (2001) 0 t~~ql ,ffl*~~ 0 ~:f~~J±38AA ' p83 92 0 iJ:lHr,Q~ (2001) "r
ft<:W _ 0 :':t37Eft<:W ' p3-6 0 1M'f~ (2001) J 0 if!m~:im~n66~Jj , p38 40 0¥lili~¥n (2001) 0 ±utt';zWM!lLA~IJJE.~*;f~ft<:~H"Jft<:**{~i~7}¥ 0 J'-?±if!m ~76
PA '
p64-71 0 r~*fTff (2001) 0 if!m~)(t[;ilj 76 AA ' p96-99 0 ~~JlJ*(
2004) 0 ~ , ppl-5 0 ~~B}j § (2002) 0 l:t~t ;z~§i_
ft<:w~Jf'iC1i~ft' 10 (3) ' p 1-14 0 [5'g:g: _Life University *~J~*~\wlzU '>
t*EW;
'> (2003) 0 :':t$~W-±rfrd*!itb~'i~~~~*;f~§~§t;Z.ffl*~~ 0 ~~t7CJj\. (2001) 0 57 0 if:f~Ai (2000) 0 ~~*±:':t$ft<:W8~W!!J7;g:g;Z7}tfT, tX*~~±gffflX 0 ~~:g~ (2003) ft<:~:g[s:fijj]'}:t$ft<:~l-f-:i;f~~tli ( http://210.60.194.100/life2000/edutearn/projeccmid.htm.
- - - _.._ _..._ _..._._
Powell, L.H., & Cassidy, D. (2002) . Family life education: an introduction. Family Relations, 51 (3) ,285-286.
Thomas, J., & Arcus, M. (1992) . Family life education: an analysis of the concept. Family Relations, 41, 3-8.
-" c: 8}'J~1f! !II~1~ir1 ~~8*1~F Ijlf;..t:=; lJrii. ,',,,1=:1 15<:1 T-,@oj rJq1~:%j